ML20057A511
| ML20057A511 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Vogtle  |
| Issue date: | 09/01/1993 |
| From: | Merschoff E NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION II) |
| To: | Mccoy C GEORGIA POWER CO. |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 9309140324 | |
| Download: ML20057A511 (12) | |
Text
SEP 011993 Docket Nos. 50-424, 50-425 License Nos. NPF-68, NPF-81 Georgia Power Company ATTN: Mr. C. K. McCoy Vice President Vogtle Electric Generating Plant P. O. Box 1295 Birmingham, AL 35201 Gentlemen:
SUBJECT:
MEETING
SUMMARY
- V0GTLE UNITS I and 2 This refers to the management meeting conducted in the Region II office on August 27, 1993. This meeting was held at your request to discuss recent char.ges to Vogtle management.
It is cur opinion that the meeting was mutually beneficial. A list of attendees and a copy of your handouts are enclosed.
t In accordance with 10 CFR 2.790 of the NRC's " Rule of Practice," a copy of this letter and its enclosures will be placed in the NRC Public Document Room.
Should you have any questions concerning this letter, please contact us.
Sincerely,
$$bEc) W D
v Ellis W. Merschoff, Director Division of Reactor Projects
Enclosures:
1.
Management Meeting i
Presentation Material 2.
List of Attendees cc w/encls:
J. D. Woodard Senior Vice President-Nuclear Georgia Power Company P. O. Box 1295 Birmingham, AL 35201 cc w/encls: Continued page 2 1311o6 n
\\\\
9309140324 930901 a
\\
PDR ADOCK 05000424 p;
FDR o
p
1 1
\\
SEP 011993 Georgia Power Company 2
cc w/encls:
Continued J. B. Beasley General Manager, Plant Vogtle Georgia Power Company P. O. Box 1600 Waynesboro, GA 30830 J. A. Bailey Manager-Licensing Georgia Power Company P. O. Box 1295 Birmingham, AL 35201 Nancy G. Cowles, Counsel Office of the Consumer's l
Utility Council l
84 Peachtree Street, NW, Suite 201 l
Atlanta, GA 30303-2318 l
l Office of Planning and Budget l
Room 615B 270 Washington Street, SW Atlanta, GA 30334 i
Office of the County Commissioner Burke County Commission Waynesboro, GA 30830 Harold Reheis, Director l
Department of Natural Resources 205 Butler Street, SE, Suite 1252 Atlanta, GA 30334 Thomas Hill, Manager Radioactive Materials Program Department of Natural Resources l
4244 International Parkway Suite 114 l
Atlanta, GA 30354 Attorney General Law Department 132 Judicial Building Atlanta, GA 30334 cc w/encls:
Continued page 3 1
l l
i
SEP 011993 Georgia Power Company 3
cc w/encls: Continued Dan H. Smith Vice President Power Supply Operations Oglethorpe Power Corporation 2100 E. Exchange Place Tucker, GA 30085-1349 Charles A. Patrizia, Esq.
l Paul, Hastings, Janofsky & Walker 2
12th Floor 1050 Connecticut Avenue, NW j
Washington, D. C.
20036 I
bcc w/encls:
r D. Seymour, RII D. Hood, NRR P. Skinner, RII l
A. Herdt, RII Document Control Desk NRC Senior Resident Inspector U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission P. O. Box 572 Waynesboro, GA 30830 FILE: G:\\DRP\\VGMTSUM.DAS i
1 l
RII RII RII DA f 31'q W
DSeymour P5kinner AHerdt F#1/93 F/3/ /9',
g/31/93 l
t l
ENCLOSURE 1 MANAGEMENT MEETING PRESENTATION MATERIAL l
l a
f I
i i
i
.~.
e I
=_
A
.M M
(.
m j
m e
e M
Y m
g g
'% W m'
,As l
4 2
5 I rn-lll i
5
{
.V.
l
)
b
[
h:
$MMA_ii:
s t
I v
v IC w
0
~
2
'R
).Y l
IT i
.Il
^
m g
s, 4
i o_
/
s'
(
2-
~
w
.I a
~
w 1
/
^
()
m W
li l
I
's
~
i n u.,..... a,u.,.a.,. w.
.c,. v, a.a u,,,,...a.,..s.a,,....,.,,
{
4 f
^
r s
s t
Y
m_..m_
...m
._m..
m,.
__m__
m l
1 l
I I
i I
k 1
y m
a a
a O
G m
m
=
l v
f y
O Co e
O,m m
~;
i a
^
O I
.m A
h iJ I
9
,/
J
~
q, i
g F.-
f, i
I 3
- 94. "
O
- f3
\\
'l i i
/
n 1l v
Q i
(' m i
\\' m)
kJ
~
I' f"
l l
g e
f
(
'u j
,i m
i l
tb) e
(
{
7 f
=
r
)
i
,m
.m 4
t j w
N
/
~ m' i
{
__ w N
I.
bj 3
m j
L_
I i
i
-~
i
=
2 l
r A
/-
I) t s
i e
V i
4 s
1 w
a
/N.
l l
E l
h'
(
3 I - i. i
-G j
i
}
s
)
C ~
o' :-
[,9 g
f 1
)
~
w
~
4
(.
}
e l
T h,g sz 4
.E ;
I g
as -
1 t.
.1 s.
4 4
I I
I.
4 I
1 I
i d
I
- i. -
1 1
I s 2
1 i
i i
I I,
.=
l g.
- l. a i. I i.
~E-E it.
t *.
t.
.?
I.
i 1.
I
==
4
- =
a.
=
-2:
t-i t
e s
1-
..:.::=1
- t. " I -
l t
I I.
I I-i
.i
- e..;
3 t
-.=
1
-I,
..t 2.t A
-t
=
s ;.
g.-.: -
.t-..
.s-a..
,o
- i.
d;.
- i e
-g...---
)
s - :-:- w.
5
- ! O i
t
=
- g.
1 i
- -:-s,
.i a
a
- m zi:
i i
z::::: : :
r-r re i e 5;.
- i ti
.i:
i i
- sti-5 :
I W
m m
==t,
=tm i.
a, a:.sge
$ ;=E:im W:;; ::
is:
4 e.
(d 2 2. e ;:
- a C") 2 s
-i ri i
r
=. = j
-in i
i 4
.i : a. -
,ei..=
255.
a tu--
m i,,is.-..
.e_m_,..n
_.ee
.,_. _ m =_.-_.
__=_._:_:-
,,=-
e un
.,3 _m _ e., :
ai,
< w :i ~,m
~.-.i e.
. i
.a
- -=,.
,_i.
m m ::
.,=:.e:-
- x.. : s..: :
- 1
- =
.= i
-:s.
_s a
m a.i. : : t m r-r ol i
- n:E ; ;r ; 5 i
gy c E
e.s;o.el (12 i s!
t e
- i:
iu y.
..._z__,
.e.-.
- i m_x m..
~i i s ?,i E ej
-=
5 i
m e t E
5 EE Zm Fi!
zE i i
- i.
" :i i
.i!
1 *E s - ! !
m 4,
r#
.a..
ri
~
==
i m
_..i 4
g s.O n e w,
p:
55: 5 t
i 3
i
- !E 2
a cm u.,
.s i
i
.ie. : a t.
z a
=
r-
+
.,. - )
g :l 1
1**
]
3
=
g 3.
i E-g*
.i I
=
,m
.i g
3-.322 g-p g
-t l
I i..i 2.
6 I
al-E 3
tap
- -R
-I en E
i
.g
- t t
9' i
-.t j 3 - e t.-
- tll3
-i:
3__
- n.
_m.
w s
,i
- i
>=>
i
- ::s a--
-t l
.c.u_,
I t
t.
-E.
.=
.. a.
h-
}$..I i
3 IE"g
- ~ ~., 5
?""
Jll
~
l j E.! ;-
.e.T : :
O a
i l
, =..
??
e-
,. c2 *
- et "33 w
_ tg m
t=l i
_g_.....
?. i l
e s..,.
W e
g -
e-a t
l
~-
- *J I
l
~.
a d.::
j i
! a 3
g-ie l-q) n e
\\
I I
}
t i
1 1
l I
I J
t Non-Outage Corrective MWOs No. of MWOs i
1,200 1,000
[-
i 800 600 400
)
'i 200Jan 92 Mar 92 May 92 Jul 92 Sep 92 Nov 92 Jan 93 Mar 93 May 93 Jul 93 Feb 92 Apr 92 Jun 92 Aug 92 Oct 92 Dec 92 Feb 93 Apr 93 Jun 93 Month
t
_~.
h T
W S
g 2s 3,
g p
a o
d hm o
3 i
g R
'<;"" b 5
deff a 3 u
n
' p, M _
2' F -
y ro p s v
e a ulp l
iSI5 Y
k cnsh a eP g
e' l
r t
n d""E l
n e
n o.
- o a
t i
).b F M A.
- h c
u r
t t
i 8
n e
s o
l i
i M"8 n
s ot e eD
- D h*h r
S S
t e
eo n L*r y
' R.
c gpr l
P, " G e
n u
E@S T,
C.
A iE O' K H.
,8 r.
T L
g M
r 8
g r
S g
W M'
OO M
M j
L
%t t
f d
6 m
i. -
- r. t s N
gr n r-Mope c
g y
.ph p
'i r
nu c s
~~
3' d D a r t
e t
D Y
y' 0
eS G
/
- Od ek G
I r
.t
/
c le 1
c e F.
r n$u eW l
5 g
t l
2 S
slsP W A
/
s 2
M o W.
r A
a 4K F p i
/
CJ nG e
S g e*n e
n n oi e' e
-k gi r i" m n
rac rt p y
ea e=u s
n P
e i*r int t=
H e
o a"
n R
- D.
c r.
u r.
S i
N 'i G.
r g
ra"E e
s M
R.
y d
e cp
%l M "" R e
e ee n nei e
d C
s ey p Y
s s
o e
- o. l o
pH i
1 B
r. -
la on.
"tn t
e B.
pE D.
a 8'
n b >n g l
nJ i
J y
c e
a G
V sj t
n n
MG a
r p
se-a 0
m s-n A
h e
- s
~
~
A
)5 n
b /.
2 ahm t
-Q 7
3 yT~ 4 t
p
- M pK f
l f,
c V
- r. s
- J' y ~ p t
go r
n y
0 Mi t
~
. at r n
~
ne e
/
ep c GO e c
V
.td
~
s e
sl AP g
h r
e gk t
d s
ec e
n l
g o
a 0 #
= e ci a*w r
l 0 0 P
.a m ne P.
t*
0 al
,ed u
z o "' t
- r. a o
- r. n e H
/
g 1
r n
/
g=
H ga r r.
w a
Md F u" S 4
M '=r R.
i d
2
~,.
r l
g g
r 0
oR M
oK e
1 M
E n
e G
nmeWt ebs n
J e
l e
o G
u tow t
r c
c p
t o
o olu A
o i
cod M
r d
/d o
S. C. A. D' A. A' T 0
J Emi o
e C
D l
t n _
r C R e1 o R
WM G
4
(
S n
ieh gnt 5
}
l o u u VJA i
I'
- i
~
li 1iii' j'
~
_ =.
1 2R3 OUTAGE OVERVIEW l
l DURATION :
36 Days 6 Hours MAJOR SCOPE :
1 1276 MWOs-430 CM,714 PM,132 FOR 38 DCPs I
i S/G EDDY CURRENT TESTING - 50% OF 2 S/Gs SLUDGE LANCE - 4 S/Gs RCP MOTOR INSPECTIONS
- #2 ( 10 YEAR )
d1, #3 & #4 ( l8 MONTH )
l RCP SEAL WORK - REFURB #1 & #4 l
l
. RX VESSEL NOZZLE ISI
. RHR SPLIT COUPLING MODIFICATION FLUX THIMBLE EDDY CURRENT LP TURBINE B, HP TURBINE & TURBINE STOP VALVE INSPECTIONS MAIN GENERATOR HYDROGEN SEAL INSPECTION MOISTURE SEPARATOR REHEATER INSPECTIONS MAJOR CHALLENGES:
RHR SPLIT COUPLING MODIFICATION
- DEFUELED WINDOW i
j 2R3 VS 1R4 START WITH THE 45 DAY OUTAGE OF 1R4 AND ADJUST FOR THE SCOPE REDUCTIONS AND PROBLEMS WE WILL HOPEFL1.LY AVOID:
NO ILRT NO 5 YEAR RCP ROTOR PULL AND INSPECTION NO SIGMA DELAY NO TRANSFER TUBE GATE VALVE PROBLEM NO SEQUENCER DELAYS NO LOW POWER PHYSICS TEST DELAY APPROXIMATELY ^2 LESS MOV TESTS NO CCP REPLACENENT NO STUCK STUD DETENSIOhTRS LESS D/G WORK LESS RCP SEAL WORK LESSONS LEARNED FROM 1R4 ON RAILROAD, CCW HX COATINGS, NSCW MOD, VOTE TEST EQUIPMENT
ENCLOSURE 2 LIST OF ATTENDEES U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION L. A. Reyes, Deputy Regional Administrator, RII J. R. Johnson, Deputy Director, Division of Reactor Projects (DRP), RII A. F. Gibson, Director, Division of Reactor Safety, RII A. R. Herdt, Chief, Reactor Projects Branch 3, DRP, RII B. S. Hallett, Deputy Director, Division of Radiation Safety and Safeguards (DRSS), RII P. H. Skinner, Chief, Projects Section 3B, DRP, RII W. H. Rankin, Chief, Facilities Radiological Protection Section, DRSS, RII B. R. Bonser, Senior Resident Inspector, Vogtle, DRP, RII D. S. Hood, Senior Project Manager, Project Directorate 11-3, Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation D. A. Seymour, Project Engineer, Section 3B, DRP, RII i
GEORGIA POWER COMPANY J. B. Beasley, General Manager, Plant Vogtle J. A. Bailey, Manager, Licensing S. H. Chestnut, Manager, Technical Support G. R. Frederick, Manager, Maintenance j
F
- -