Text

Licensee Motion for Leave to Submit Citation to Supplemental Authority.* Licensee Moves for Leave to Call Recent Supreme Court Authority to Attention of Appeal Board.W/Certificate of Svc.Served on 900803.Granted for Appeal Board on 900803
	ML20056B201
Person / Time
Site:	Turkey Point
Issue date:	08/03/1990
From:	; FLORIDA POWER & LIGHT CO.
To:	; NRC ATOMIC SAFETY & LICENSING APPEAL PANEL (ASLAP)
References
	CON-#390-10695 ALAB-115, OLA-4, NUDOCS 9008150189
	Download: ML20056B201 (3)
	v • d • e

.. -

ghd5 " GRANTED '

For the Appeal Board ;

e

) .s. . t2 D .l. J /-s % if*

Secretary to the Kppeal Board

'90 AUG -3 All :46 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION Of FICf 0F SECRfIARY

00CKt ilHG A SU<VICFL ,

BF. FORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICC'dSING APPEAL BOARD ""

SERWD AUG - 31990 ,

In the Matter J/ ) !

')

$ FLORIDA POWER . LIGHT ) Docket Nos. 50-250 OLA-4 ,

COMPANY ) 50-251 OLA-4

)

(Turkey Point Plant, ) (P/T Limits)

Unite 3 and 4) )

LICENSEE's NOTION FOR LEAVE TO EUBMIT CITATION TO SUPPLEMENTAL AUTHORITY i.

07 April 3, 1990, Licensee submitted its brief in this proceeding. Subsequently, on June 27, 1990, the Supreme Court '

-decided Luian v. National Wildlife Federation, No.89-640, 58 L.W. 5077, June 26, 1990. At slip opinion 14-15, 58 L.W. 5081-i 82, the majority opinion enunciates principles governing rulings on motions for summary judgment under Rule 56 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure in circumstances in which the opposition

! -is supported by affidavits that contain factual ambiguities. The l-discussion bears directly upon the argument made at pages 34-36

-of Licensee's Brief and pages 16-17 of Intervenors' Brief. '

,s.

Consequently, and in accordance with the procedure prescribed in Consumers Power Company (Midland Plant, Units 1 and 2), ALAB-115, !

6 AEC 257 (1973), Licensee moves for leave to call this recent Supreme Court authority to the attention of the Appeal Board and 1

9008150189 900003 PDR ADOCK 0 gO O

Y 4,,

3 e - - . - - - -

g 77_

, 4- '

l Qpp G P- g 7 ,

y ,

i-

, , 4-t-

UNITED STsTES OF AMERICA- :

jhg 2 NUCL E AR: M6U(. ATORY L COMMISSION 1 l$y ; l ;

n jj@ ll'n.the Matter oi= i ,

JJ uf

't :c hi: .. FLORIDA F0 Weit AND LIGH'T COMPANY ' l -- Docket No . 'i a )/50-250 / 2$ 1 -OL A-4 i QM - ;l *

%' .liurkev fotnt= Plant, Unit Nos. 3'6 4) i '

o :.

fM .-;.'

~;

t i

.i i

up CERTIFICATE OFLSERVICE 5 V bl

[ hereby certify that copies of the foregoing AB-GRANTED LIC.. MOTION.. .

8/.3'

% . have been . served 'uDon the f ollowing per sens. by JU.S. . mail gf ir'Lt'_ class, nexcept . i L'

s L as etherwise .noteo and -in accordance with the requirements of 10 CFR Sec. 2.712.

4' u, ; w' t , . .

a glii ' ~

Adannistr ative .Judce Administrattve Judge e Christine.N. foh!. Chatrman Thames'B..Noore Atomic Saf ety and-11consing 4Doeal Atomic Safety and Licenning appeal ( '

4

Boaro ':e c ar d ,

, 1 ULS. Nucle.ir.Reoulatory Commission U.S. Nuclear'heoulatory Lommission- !!

y-: Washinotoni: DC 20535 Washinoten. DC 20555

'*i. * ' '

~ Adetnistrative Judoe l Horward A. W-lber Administrative Judae j , Atomic Saffty anc Licenstna-Appeal B. Faul- ' Cat t er ,' Jr. ,; Chairma.6 ;

i Boerd. , Atoast $afety and Licensing boardi 4 -U.S. Nuclear ReQulatory Commission' U.S.. Nuclear Regulatory Commission-i

' Washington, DC 20555- Washnngton, DC- 20555-i i

Aoministrativs to .Administr'atfve Judge j

'~61enn 06 Bridht J e r r y. : _ Harbour Atomic-Safr y

and Licene ng Board Atomic: Safety.and ltcensino Board- j

- U. S .' ; Nu c l af eaculatr' 'mmission zu.L L lluelear Regul story Commt ssion

Washington. ]

205 Washington,yDC :20555 j e

Janice:E.:

Patricta Jehle,' Esquire;

0Hice of. : n + .,u n s s ! Office of-the General Counsel . !

qu.S.-Nuclear

. - , . ,,y'Comm.sston U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commtusion Washt69 ton, DC 20555 .)

Washington _, OC. 20555 3 Harold F Reis, sowire Joette' Lorton, Director Attorney for FF&L . Center for Nuclear'Responsiblitty

) Newman &;Holtringer. P.C.- 7210 Red Road, #207 B 3

'fg

(

-1615 L Streatt, N.W., Suite 1000 Miami, FL -33143 Washington, DC 20036- ,

n- i 1

\

1 i

~

'E ' b [] '

& U' [

? %w,- 1 4

-l

.. : - , ~ n.

' Wh k &.f?' S" I jp

' -;uc n3' 19 . '. 'y y ' _ , *yk- -.j \.,';

my 5f c'I~'!s m'.j;&f;;4m%.l

-p.. l l 7 h --% ? b.:N n.

_% g 1

) .h)t

,, y p

&a nw ~ ~ .

,..k . ,$k. y

-m, 1-,- r,-,,- ,. + .u,. ,w.,y' w&.. (L; r ,

u, ,) .- m w , ,

w%n) sg ).A + -ne ~nyu .p ;w; o--+ * , .im t-3m u . ,m q3 ,:C:

v, , - ,

e 3y p <

36 f 4 4 d I 7 3

Ii /

_sI-

' ' ^

. q9 I p

'(3 ....., g pIq I1 5

.h t k.h.

',h n{'y. g 3_ _# -9.g - .h.,

Ii ,, , 1 )

1.Am e a',_ pm'/ j I$5

, 4. r w'- ,f imw8 wN.Y 7 ~w=a Y- Y' [A $ f r? - [.-[h.- ,i,, h. Y p m 3

'N N . ri,i.-o.; y,v $5.- f.g- L k N.[ *')^"$ d1O, 'pM, ' yi .* ,'A, sys

-c) U - Iye-i , . _ ,j'Jh ' f.9 7h7 --i yf

',L

-4 f7 M[i/ 7_,m i7 M$[kl @ 2 i AW i n ' * - ' '> 9

@[MSDN@f A6MRANTEDMinMotiONd.MM $ -)3oWetiNoW[el50-230/251-01.A t

@ di

' 4; '

@U J W ' '

[.Y n e mme/h,~w .r s -,,

4 v:p 4 -*

e

%'- "=f wc 4 4

' mix

- w4 t "

t

=

' w'

-1.-

s w?

'T- 1.

WM Ne%

M s- Jwo -.R gi.M,iqtt ef. 4W; 0 M, b 4- s f r n;r.N O,4 a -y -'ufM r o

1 . i,

+

f _-t , .t -s

.- rr u &;

i ;

-' ' , " s

- ' 1' 1

.a;M-4b

^ +;i :a .M, "3s, t:,

..s- H-

& , ter . 3 - - t 4

'W e

e up q, y sv . > 1 mn '1 1 V. +

' v' s. .

a, 1

w'd.' r.. m. r sj p-c. R vg a .a%.s< p y # ci e ,. <

c c;10 - p .

-@ c

p og : Ah.m .., *,

< g, %, c srej - .

t ? --

y~ ,

t

,r ;Wan, W\ :+ \, ,, A,q r ^' c; ., ,,,,

>f

@.,v 6

. . , ,,; p . .+=, , .

y. ,,g ~

, , * ,' n j,.

W' [ 1_ ' 'pq t

n_ - n. R h e s

- .vj - . buh E h, g[ ' b 'f A-F2- I .d n *}[..4..,'g.. -m .m f._,. 3,1 N ..',b hh.n[ L[I' f - m.. -[

a. t T

N k. A '?)

3, p

3 4

m <

p:v h~ o~m~N,~, .astaJNSaporito H c'.4.? M -, P W y pWM ,@ M r-.a ' Y,Y.y r . c a

_m " %, ,.s , - 4t ,o.,

m,n#w:/

m a ,t s- ts Ek. :ec u t i-ve : m Di r, ec.'t . .. or'.m: , " . . ~

1- x. .3 1 e+ , , , a M W % g uc1 M EnergyEAccountability? Project- . b m / . '

T,' '

p

@3 - Y.-PTDWBoM+1290." . s' M

~ i W . .

OM.

n Q M l W dJupiterB W M3464i nena m ,

n a 1 e

,7<Y

. 4 Pr scc t j ~ m, ,

.. u .m% :: s - '3 )

~ '

nim i si n .$ w ),e, . a

J ast: d l,1-~ Q D, ; p,j'ira)-~ - =

@* 9. ' , ,

, ' i.'a ]

QW % --

d : - - . - -

' ,l e MW M" k.1<Ns' ,- ted st 3cct q c3 W hts;- J-mm ,

M 0{W%&jMDa'1': W m C '

%. WU F9 C y ' ' % W daVof ~ dC 4

$ pstBW

-cl M, w ~

WY< L' 1

+

. . -aag -

L A -

.ma..._.....m..............m, _

+

o

, M.

@mm$_,- M , %,. -;<^% # M"A'q ' '

'uffic Jofithe?' Secretary ch theJCommissionL 4 p .;\? r'gr ; \ "@x 7;p - n t,q s t-.

i i - _ ). t , ,

m 3

=

,j/;:s.'4 z.'. 7_-- - gu a y . ,, s gg, 41 g- $ '4 u 7- ? N g .7 .

g .Y '

I tj{4 j-l- ['

.w.,';.~ {- {) . 4 y - 3 ' '

de2 j#- Jj nW , ~f F r '- --$ p!

g

.f g T ';N f' W' ;:&: , F 'T. 5

.t: fi.'Q Q?

' y ;3%hf# .

. _):-' : ?f b- ,. t hb A

r, '

h*

F N t" ': h ' 4:- .i IjJ Ih'E' %--U / [hS -E-' j L' (, 5i %

' .'; 4 >

b

I T - ; f f-3 b .

(_..

,e 'i Jm.-I 'u' 1

'K. -

3

'b.,<,

^'b _

it c .- ~~'F--_.4.-, Y g- 4..

f I f 4 g

+ _\ - JI -

$-i;[A t -[' 'hh 1.hI e.i ,_

e_

j s

-.. h '$,'+~ 1)f.

-,y 5,

9;"

_'.M.'p%u:: -d-.wm, . cg -., p _.

i 1 s '.m{ _J> -

r.u'c y- ';,

g , . ,

[i49 *^3s,' ,

p i 3 1 h ,eg 53 ,Y y $

{aq, j. ~ ' ' 1 a

_1 s,, __, y h, g,_'..

Ia-(j[

II y t t .g.

? -

.e ,!I_ f. ,;

- J " ->

A y

' 4

--fg

,su -h

5 ---

b:' -

= lR k

( ,f.,4 7.k . {. . ,h '

J. ( A 1

,s -

l-[f

'4-e-'19f'

~,Aprir. ,m.e um 3' ,

x ,l ,

g L' Th I- k .

-6 ) .y Ik,7E-Y U kk]'f*^h. )5 :l . ' --) ^

. I: p'". hb A D '

1 hl ^ y ' N

_(- g . ' ' j i *. p F

,,Y.

V' l'-

M 'J';b " ' W' ?*3. ' ['E' f' ,

M

,,i

[mn n , j$w r 1

- b < 8

R ;_ > ' +

3y s W ,. 3 c v[l z

O n i , - ~ "-

w > ,

MMk ' N . t , > > >

q' ,

?Os 't

,.,'J_' [ . W a.,

s ,A.. h,

" s-$ ^. ' if , e d q' NM r::7 -

QG ' ' M if D +N -

g ;,

i

. y 4p f5i: .u,

-=^'.

- i t yp y, s b

-:#( ; ,

gg., '

c s

j 0-* . .: : j(; f , , ! ) ,. .

4 y e ..

R-

[My, .f. u(7,p ;'mm 4 ' cp e

= i m 1 ,n.gb,a. > , ss <

2 e, 4

n .- i , i 1 s ,

w t n -

r e t, >.<

-^[-.

,$ )

7 r 3.n, 7 C '-p.$ - . :j)'yye 3 ;%"

4

'.I-,.; aI ,,3-.:

't','-'

k ih + t 1 5,' 5 1 49

'I 4

k r (Q);.C ;< 4 .f . 'N,. [c,-

s.

, =- sh'G'):, -ih: . + '.. + w ; - ,, ,M sa

, > J_s.

2

) 4 'tY45

<=- . .-Q' ' ' 't g e4 rrs_,q . .= w np 4 s , ,;- 1 v ,

> '.e

' 4i. ., ,

l ,,. fJ p V gj s, i

_- = i

, +

+

} i(

W* W7(m 4 ,,

4:gea- 4: eQt y

)O iO, ,,

ta , y, a.E, 41.f. '

I . ' 3

4 pi, g }I i .,

$*'*','.['gI d t' Y,: ;'%1r4 4i 14 > -

s b ,.

' ,1 i E.

o--

+

U.

A .--:

yt g 1. ; :

t r

, . V yg F, Li.- '..- )[": '

M T7L::. _1 :.-f 1_ ,

t N,

g' I 3W >yf

_@. eL. .-

e s m,._

3 s.

w y s..VI,: ;

! ):e

-, p J- 'f T '3- f- , (

- - _ ' '- ,p-g 4

,1_ 4 t: 3 rt 4 p*, ;.% y i

- -a w' ' '

4 i

,m s

. - ; hb .~

II I 'f k , #

fl-- t -,)'

'if, ....,-F e:

W:,=;

i t # y L

i ? . .i {

W:n , , V' '- "I %I , . - .

N y [fI h. ..k ,'W,.

%[

. . .e 2

^' -- 1 t. ',1

-c f ! '

N I '_.,, , , # , 7. ' ;

, [kh 4 G: 1 j' I g .

i

,1, 3 ff .

j y ,

,f] 3.._,*

^ j %*f' Q

. . .- y g?4 r

,{. }.j 5 3 _

>,I Y i f'(f h,x '.) @w'. { g 1 y 2 o s a -r g

s , i t '.' 4 3 f!-j l 5

f'tk '

. g il

.1 } .h b'>,

" % I rb g b g, L LJ

'.' e 4 :'-

1'A

. . 3'%

=

. . , 4

- j "N sv.

~~

I h i4 17 ccg ._/i,

%M'tNy,n 'W

_ . g

, a J- 1

+

3 % =

m% p n:n:QiW. .x m k

'g' y1 ' ~.a , i n s af.

y-c

+ ,

1 ';

Of >

M* &.h'N .,q M2 M' f - 2 ;

_,

y:.NC M -!i i 1

1

O-f4 y' ~ ]' -

t

-n

. g p

v_r go M- 4 th. <~u f.'B$ e'4"-m, _.

,9e

^

h .s/f[h( $

d cIf $ m : !- t i vayp 3 Ahn,MJ 3p

- /

.q i;

v

'.g ff_LN "'

'l l , l>

A Jt ;4 ;

{

-R; c

l}

h:,

3 4

g t ' '],[ + " '

k # ,

'f 4

'31l- 45

%? Yb l 3 ,

-lj C t

' w -ti

./

1 3A N (

(,t,r_

i>- +

$a-(,^ . 1 i . 1.

+b ',,. ,d, f 3 4n.i st 1'-0:;

_t s

,k e y, k

'h"'

---'M_t

~~-'

E-?-,

5 ..

>5

,,t

)

.7, '. T -

bf$

Apy ap (t.s[g, 'S,, ' Lj- , f

- mtata.p . 3.f y-h (i

, i y

\' ,.t- ?

r. ,-

($ g ; 5^ . y :a , Y

- m f' 4 qtgr c

o $. ' 1 --

L' ,

i

.t p;m a fs, cm -p -

t iE {F ')In fF__b.

S'i. '

d 1 -

d

ML20056B201

Text

Navigation menu

Search