ML20054B872

Summary of 820324 Meeting W/Util & Franklin Research Ctr Re Implementation of Radiological ETS for Facilities

ML20054B872
Person / Time
Site:	Calvert Cliffs
Issue date:	04/06/1982
From:	Jaffe D Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
To:	Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
NUDOCS 8204190270
Download: ML20054B872 (14)

Text

'

j

~

w 4

44 p&

w y1 90s/rls-o/6 7'

N APR 6 1982

//

WEIVED 3

LICEtl5EE: Baltimore Gas and Electric Company (BGLE)

APRg C

m 1982n FACILITY: Calvert Cliffs Units 1 and 2 6

/

SUBJECT:

SU2fARY OF A MEETIfiG WITH BG&E TO DISCUSS Tile RADIOLOGICr q, 3

EFFLUENT TECHi!ICAL SPECIFICATI0ftS (RETS) y cp On March 24, 1982, we met with representatives of BGLE to discuss the implementation of RETS for Calvert Cliffs Units 1 and 2.

A list of attendees is enclosed.

We started the meeting by reviewing the background of RETS implenentation for Calvert Cliffs. He indicated that BG&E had provided comitments for implementation of RETS for Calvert Cliffs Units 1 and 2.

These commit-ments had been withdrawn by BGLE after considerable expenditure of review time by the NRC staff and its consultant, Franklin Research Center.

The purpose of the meeting was stated to be an opportunity for BGLE to present an alternative to RETS.

BC&E stated that its major objection to RETS was the excessive nan-power requirements for impleacntation which was estimated to be 4 to 5 man years per year for chemistry personnel. In addition, DG&E stated that they considered RETS to be inconsistent with recent reculatery tronds including the trend toward simplification of. Technical.:Specificationst.

The BGLE presentation, summarized in the enclosed charts, provides the basis for the proposed BC&E alternative to RETS. The BG&E program is characterized by::

G) Baseline requirements that are augmented upon detection of a signi-ficant release,'or potential release, and (2) Significant portions of the program to be iriplenented via plant procedures, including a dose assessment manual, rather than Tech-nical Specifications.

At the conclusion of the meeting, BG&E comitted to submit the proposed program within 30 days of the meeting.

(Wml*W F David H. Jaffe, Project Manager Operating Reactors Branch #3 Division of Licensing

Enclosures:

As stated cc: See next pace sao419027o e20406 fDRADOCK 05000317 PDR g

ORB (3:DLy/

ORB #3 g. ICN(3p,............. N... m' =........... ".

ORB MrNU2nE '.N5 FEE /.V..n "

rk so-o

..t...............

...../.82 4/c4 4/. 6 /82 4/ 6..../82 ouo OFFICIAL RECORD COPY usa m m m Nae ronu m ooencu caa

d MEETING

SUMMARY

DISTRIBUTION Licensee ~:

Baltimore Gas and Electric Company

• Copies also sent to those pecple on service (cc) list for subject plant (s).

Occket File NRC POR L PDP NSIC TERA ORB #3 Rdg JHeltemes 3 Grimes RAClark Project.51anager PMKreutzer OELD I&E ACRS-10 ORB #3 Summary File NRC Participants

. Baltimore Gas and Electric Company cc:

James A. Biddison, Jr.

Ms. Mary Harrison, President General Counsel Calvert County Board of County Commissioners Baltimore Gas and Electric Company Prince Frederick, MD 20768 P. O. Box 1475 Baltimore, MD 21203 U. S. Environmental Protection Agency Region III Office George F. Trowbridge, Esquire Attn:

Regional Radiation Representative Shaw, Pittman, Potts and Trowbridge Curtis Building (Sixth Floor) 1800 M Street, N. W.

Sixth and Walnut Streets Washington, D. C.

20036 Philadelphia, PA 19106 Mr. R. C. L. Olson, Principal Engineer Mr. Ralph E. Architzel Nuclear Licensing Analysis Unit Resident Reactor Inspector Baltiu.cre Gas and Electric Company NRC Inspection and Enforcement Room 922 - G&E Bullding P. O. Bos 437 P. O. Box 1475 Lusby, MD 20657 Baltimore, MD 21203 Mr. Charles B. Brinkman Mr. Leon B. Russell Manager - Washington Nuclear Operations Plant Superintendent Combustion Engineering, Inc.

Calvert Cliffs Nuclear Power Plant 4853 Cordell Avenue, Suite A-1 Maryland Routes 2 & 4 Bethesda, MD 20014 Lusby, MD 20657 Mr. J. A. Tiermlan, Manager -

Bechtel Power Corporation Nuclear Power Department Attn: Mr. J. C. Judd Calvert Cliffs Nuclear Power Plant

^

Chief Nuclear Engineer Maryland Routes 2 & 4 15740 Shady Grove Road Lusby, MD 20657 Gaithersburg, MD 20760 Mr. W. J. Lippold, Supervisor Combustion Engineering, Inc.

Nuclear Fuel Management Attn:

Mr. P. W. Kruse, Manager Baltimore Gas and Electric Company Engineering Services Calvert Cliffs Nuclear Power Plant.

P. O. Box 500 P. O. Box 1475 Windsor, CT 06095 Bal timore, Maryland 21203 Public Document Room i

Calvert County Library Mr. R. E. Denton, General Supervisor Training & Technical Services Prince Frederick, MD 20678 Calvert Cliffs Nuclear Pcwer Plant Maryland Routes 2 & 4 Director, Department of State Planning Lusby, MD 20657 301 West Preston Street Baltimore, MD 21201 Mr. R. M. Douglass, Manager Quality Assurance Department Fort Smallwood Road Complex Administrator, Power Plant Siting Program '

P. O. Box 1475 Energy and Coastal Zone Administrati,on Department of Natural Resources Baltimore, MD 21203 Tawes State Office Building Annapolis, MD 21204 Mr. T. L. Syndor, General Supervisor Operations Quality Assurance Calvert Cliffs Nuclear Power Plant Regional Administratcr Maryland Routes 2 g 4 Nuclear Regulatory Ccmmission, Region I.

Lusby, MD 20657 Office of Executive Director for Operations 631 Park Avenue King of Prussia, Pennsylvania 19406 s

s-

ATTENDANCE' LIST MARCH 24, 1982 f tEETIflG WITH BG&E flRC F. Congel D. Jaffe D. Trimtile C. Nichols BG&E G. Brobst R. Crinigan R. Denton D. Latham R. Olson J. Tierman Franklin Research Center S. Chen S. Pandez i

~.

=. ~ :,. 2 a. =r.

.... ~. e.:.

,,Y STFJ,M GDERICOE STER 4 GERATOR I-I31 ACIVITY I-131 ACI#ITY

< 3E-5 u Ci Ir1

> 3E-5 uCi/=1 N

EXTESIVE LCO ECEISIVE LCO l

SR@ LING on i

SRGLING cn PROGPR4 SRELEPS PROGPR4 SMGLEit /

/

EXTUSIVE LCO EXTE::SIVE LCO MCIIITORII;G on MONITORING cn PROGPR4 MO:iITCES PRCGPR4 MONITOIa

/

PROJECTED LC0 PROJECTED LCO l

RELEASE cn DOSE RELEASE on DOSE i

I and DCSE ESTIMATES -

and DOSE ESTIMATES l

l CALCULATION CALCULATION 1

l l

~7C"ITO.

LI:TII FILE.*3ES

';FC APPPCACH Fipre 1A i

i I

RCS and STFJ14 GE:iERATOR INTEGRITY DECISIC::

STFAM GENERATOR STE24 GE:EFATOR I-131 ACTIVITY I-131 AC'"IVITY

< 3E-5 u ci/ml

> 3E-5 u ci /mi EXTENSIVE SRGLING PROGRE4 DECISION I

I INSIGNIFICANT SIGNIFICANT RELEASES RELEASES

< 0.1 IGC

> 0.1 !GC PROJECTED LCO RELEASE on DOSE and DCSE CCM4ITMENT CALCULATION SURVEILLANCE SR4PLING L"C'ONITCEED LICUID RELEASES - 3GLE APPROACH Figure 1B m

RCS and STF.X!

a:. : :.n. w..

...._a...

. v :... _ :. a.- _ ~

z. :....

.:.. : -. a :.. :..~.n.. :.

c. u...

_ _... - _:... :.:r.. v :.

s r,,,._

xL-.-,<--y r, u. a. T..I,7Ir.-v.

,,.I,.-y 1 2;2 AA.

av 21.

<. ' ?? C

.1 4 0 '.? C

> 50 ?GC EETCISIVE LCO EXTE'!SIVE LCO EXTENSIVE LCC SRTLING cn SR4PLING cn SRGLING on

)

l J

PROGRR4 SRGLEFS PROGRR4 SEGLERS PROGER4 SRGL7HS r.,. r.,.S IT,.e Lv0 r.,A. r... ;

r ~c,

-- c. - r I..;v-

.u 7rn

...o

..~._

v MINITORING cn l

MC:!ITORI:!G cn MONITCRING on s

PROGER4 MCNITORS PROGRR!

MCNITCPS PROGPai MONITO j

/

r PROJECED LCO PROJECTED LCO PROJECTED LCC RELEASE cn DCSE RELEASE en DOSE RELEASE cn DOSE and DOSE ESTIMATES and DCSE ESTI'4ATES and DOSE ESTIMATES CALCULATION CALCULATION CALCULATION e

_.e...se._...

.._,___m...

p

. ~..~. u :- : L

e. w

• s-

=

gen e, p

~..~; ~.. L u r : n..

s'sL s

Fig re 2A

i j,

4 l

RCS and STEAL 4 4

GE!ERATOR INTEGRITY l

4 I

i,

~~e.~..~.~r"

't l,

1 STEAM GUTEPATOR STFE4 GEiEPaTOR STEAM GEIERATOR I-131 ACTIVITY I-131 AC"IVITY I-131 ACTIVITY

<.1 MF C

.1 - 50 MFC

> 50 MPC 1

i 1

i i

UNRESTRICTED 3 LC'4DC'4N 3LC'4DCf4H I

BLOWDC'4U to BAY to BAY to PEP 24ISSA3LE ONLY WITH 3AY vith SPECIAL PEPJET APPROVAIS i

t I,

f i

I i

)

LCO LCC i

l RELEASE en DOSE RELEASE on DCGE l

and DOSE C0'CETMEIT and DOSE CCb24I2.iEST CALCULATION CALCULATICU l

G 'r."..' ~_.~'.x' "'u ". n_ 'u~<."u'a..'

~ ~ ~ ~

'u. _ ~x. u_

DD r_

S.* t"v' '.

r

- 222 r

Figure 23

?0EL bbe'D

-~...

Z.J."..

1 ULO l

a, :,.

r.v,..

. -:- n...-.:

nu.a.a.:

in RCS in RCS in RCS

< ^.1 u ci /.1 0.1 - O.R vCi/rl

>0.c uCi/cl s.

MdJ E FJA LCO on MJJ SIUM LCO cn MAXD7JM LCO cn 4ASTE FRCCESSII;3

'JASTE PRCCESSING WASTE PRCCESSING i

?RCCESSING EQUIPMEUT PRCCESSIIiG EQUIPME';T PROCESSING EQUIPMI?:i" l

l s

PRCJECTED LCO PROJECTED LCO PRCJEC"ED LCO RELEASE on DCSE RELEASE en DOSE RELEASE on DOSE and DCSE

~

ESTBIATES and DOSE ESTIM.ATES and DCSE ESTDIATES CALCULATICU CALCULATIO:;

CALCULATICN e-l l

l l

l l

i 1

r I

i Y.R J

.Y-

.~.-:~~-..~

,, 0 G *.2

1... -

O...

~.. -,

...Ss' l

h t=.

Figure 3A l

l l

l

FUEL A'!D RCS INTEGRITI 1

DECISIO:

.1 I-131 ACTIVITI I-131 ACTIVIrl I-131 ACTIVITY i

in RCS in RCS in RCS

<0.1 u Ci /=1 0.1 - 0 5 uci/=1

>0.5 uCi/=1 1

9 1,

SAMPLING of WASTE PROCESSING STREAMS j

MINDIUM WASTE PROCESSING uECISIO4 l

INSIGNIFICANT SIGNIFICANT IEEIS IN LEVEIS IN WASTE WASTE STREA'G STREA!G MAXIIGM WASTE PROCESSING f

l NCEMAL WASTE LCO s

PROCESSING RELEASE on DOSE and DCSE CC10ilTMENT CALCULATIONS i

i WASTE PROCESSI:!3 SYSTE" - S3LE A ??.CAS Figure 33 i

_ _. _,. _,.. _.. _ =. _ _ _ _ _.. _ _

FUEL A!!D

, c..;

.. u -.

c;;L Ac;-c;;y x. - -. r -..

_.c.m..

y..

.x,

. v. n_,

in RCS in RC3 in RCS

< 5 u Ci /nl c-en uct/-,-

> 50 uCi/nl h

ECIENSIVE LCO EXTE;SIVE LCO EXTE;SIVE LCO SR4PLING cn SRGLING cn SRGLING cn

~

PRCGER4 SRm 050GPRI SRGLERS PROGER4 SRGLEFa j EXTE;SIVE LC0 EXTENSIVE LCO EXTE;SIVE LCC MONITCRING cn MONITORING cn l

MONITORING cn PROGRR4 MONITORS PROGRAM MONITORS PROGEDI MONITCR3 PROJECTED LCO PROJECTED LCO PROJECTED LCO l

RELEASE en DCSE RELEASE cn DCSE l

RELEASE J

cn DOSE I

and DCSE ESTD'.ATES and DCSE ESTIMATES and DCSE ESTIMATES CALCULATICNS CALCL : 'TIONS CALCULATICNS I

n....,-

..,,.--n,n..

G w.s. L.6 G G G O UM, _ D L.n?.*J L =..'a

.U) u n

,e.--..,,,,,o n. c.

Figure 4A l

1

FUEL AND RCS INTEGEITY ECISICN 1

TCCAL AC IVITY TOTAL ACTIVI!Y

" r-- ^-, - ;

in RCS in RCS nS e: y et /-i 5

90 u Ci /n1

>50 uCi/nl c

i INVESTIGATION of SUBSYSTEMS STREAMS nECISION SUBSYSTE4 SUBSYSTE4 STREAMS STREA>'S INSIGNIFICANT SIGNIFICANT l

l l

NOF24AL SURVEILLANCE EXTENSIVE UTILIZING SUBSYSTE4 MAIN VEIT MONITORING HEADER EELEASE LCO and DOSE on DOSE CALCUI.ATION CCM4ID:E:!T l

CONTINU0US GAS DISCHARGES - 3G&E APPROACH Figure 43

,.y_

u:

m. _ _ -,.. _ _... _ _

i e...,.-.

,.C........-..--.:

.n

.v.c in ECS in RIS in ECS

< 5 u Ci /-l 5

CO "r'i-

> *n ' rd/~'

~

\\\\

ECIE;SIVE LCO cn EXTE!SIVE LCO cn EXTE!SIVE LCO cn OrfGEi CXYGEi OXYGE'i OrfGEI OXYGEi OXYGE' MO:!ITCEI:!G CCI!TEIT MOiITORI::G CC:!TETT MO:IITORIIiG CCNTE;T /

FE0JECTED LCO PRCJECIED LCO FE0JECTED LCO

'N RELEASE on DCSE RELEASE a.nd DCGE l RELEASE and DCSE and DCSE ESTD'.ATIS and DCSE ESTBIATES and DOSE ESTIMATES CALCULATIC::

CALCUL.".T'C:.

CALCULATICI!

,..,".,.0.@.-

..,,r.,

'.?..'

.. -.... ~ - -, ~

.~.-~~...,r..#.

L2G -

h.c

~~ :=

?${l:6 s..

~.

\\

4, TU:

r3 a

RCS INTEGRITY I

ECISICN i

1 6

d

' 7.AL AZri!~i TOTA ~ ACTr/ITY TOTAL ACTIVITY 1

in EIE in RCS in RCS

<3 acife:

5 - 50 u Ci /ml

> 50 u Ci/~l i

NOE'AL INCREASED EXTENSIVE OXYGEN OXYGEN OXYGEN MCNITCR2T3 MONITORING MONITCRING i

DECISI0h DECISIOL NCF"E WGDT DISCEA2 E

's i

e. n.n - -,..;.

.v

-w

[C ]

[0 )

[0]

[0)

LCO on 2

2 2

2 EELOW h%

ABOVE h5 BELCW h5 ABOVE h5

[0) 2 t

t I

N l

WGDT REDUCE REDUCE

(

DISCEARGE

[0]

[0 }

DISCHARGE LC0 cn 2

with 2

pos3 i

.. w

'..Q

.. g or RELEASE MAXIMUM.

or RELEASE

~

COMMITMENT

-f;; '~~

W3DT DOSE WGDT

{i~- ATICUS ASAP EVALUATIONS ASAP

-.,,.,-,.y

,,...y

n. q.

2.,a~=a n b r A. 2,,nOn. u-u.

e.

3n=

.: =. r..

m....

-..r a -..-

..E e 53

-