ML20052B175
| ML20052B175 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Grand Gulf  |
| Issue date: | 04/20/1982 |
| From: | Luria N, Schmid C, Sherbin W GENERAL ELECTRIC CO. |
| To: | |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20052B163 | List:
|
| References | |
| E22-S001, E22-S002, E22-S003, E22-S004, E22-S1, E22-S2, E22-S3, E22-S4, NUDOCS 8204300121 | |
| Download: ML20052B175 (40) | |
Text
{{#Wiki_filter:- .. +. +.- n., 5 I K wi i-i..d. . iL . k Jahr> l $M =A Ufi Aqw v t.1 G J ' GRAND GULF NUCLEAR 4 4 . w 1 n x Rm.f STATION N 3 /r ~ ,J 9 UNITS 1 & 2 s .E. p 1 r. t e J L..... ln SEISMIC QUALIFICATION EVALUATION i i. lp m-e
- b. ws.
l [ u.
- g
$e CLASS 1E EQUIPMENT
- M
\\ c -i J , ::J5, g,- i 4 W. ~J . c a u.g . ;4 COMPONENT NAME: HIGH PRESSURE CORE SPRAY DIESEL GENERATOR Q EM NN [ MPL OR EDL ITEM NO.- Attached id r
- (
- q MPL
REFERENCE:
E22-S001, S002, S003, S004 1 4 a. J p 1 M >{ s u !.Lg; 1] ~h ..M r m M
- .?
DQ{ g, y r T. ) .k 'J.* i m t s ~n [Q N ' '. 1 r ~ ~ G '; 1N ao
- J ' Y.;
Sg -j; -i M..2/ ',h ).} l i' *, ij
- j!O I
- M j
,h.:UlbdUd"A"' 3M ~ M 41o[?2 W.C. Sherbin, Sr. Engineer o47g f l Url! 5.5 {.. i PREPARED BY: , ;M.:, W Qi GE - Qualification Enaineerino -- Valley Force, PA H b @Awg$ i
- g,yi ORGANIZATION i
.yg &)dA b JN.fg? Carl Schmid, Sr. Engineer dw. % M2 P;W Q -] REVIEWED BY: DATE 5$d M %pq'
- n 1
( $l d ~.m i . n.. %"S-f;,y 8 2 0 4 30 0Gl ; M '17, ' i ' -c_*:
- . s' M'
' ' *p a j N* Luria' Manager - DATE 4 6 d ' >[F APPROVED BY: ,gg. l 238.b Qualification Engineering s:i r l ?1 n
- 9f G E fj E R A L (;p E LE CT R I C
=; . I' W:_k s ?i.' :L ~: _. _.. ~ ~ -* - L..1._ ; ' - T ' .- ^ H __] Y ~ ~ ~.1.5 ' ' ' " % %.~ ~ ' 'T~~ ~. s'.,,,- 3,.-.;. '- -. - g..
- c. ?,'. d g s_ --,..
,, j g e
- ,. y
.3 1 'l. J,. l _.w
e i CONTENTS SECTION PAGE 1.0 GRAND GULF HPCS SEISMIC QUALIFICATION........................ l j TABLE 1. G ra nd Gul f HPCS Sys tem.............................. I 1.1 E22-S001,.HPCS Diesel Engine-Generator.................. I 1 1.2 E22-5002, Motor Control Center.......................... l 4 1.3 E22-S003, HPCS. Transformer............................. 3 1.4 E22-S004, HPCS Switchgear.............................. 3 4 i TABLE 2. HPCS Diesel Genera to r................................... 2 REFERENCES........................................................ 4 APPENDIX 1........................................................ 5 i l E22-5002, Motor Control Center AP P E N D I X 2........................................................ 12 l E22-S003, HPCS Transformer AP P E N D I X 3......................................................... [ q E22-5004, HPCS Switchgear 1 L e i o
~ e 1.0 GRAND GULF HPCS SEISMIC QUALIFICATION Table 1 below lists the items and qualification methods used on the Grand Gulf HPCS System. Each one is discussed separately in this report. 4 TABLE 1. Grand Gulf HPCS System MPL NUMBER ITEM SUALIFICATION METHODS E22-5001 HPCS Diesel Engine - Analysis and Test Generator E22-S002 Motor Control Center Test E22-5003 HPCS Transformer Test E22-S004 HPCS Switchgear Test 1.1 E22-S001, HPCS Diesel Engine - Generator The Diesel Engine - Generator qualification is based on stress analyses and seismic testing performed by the vendor. Table 2 shows a summary of the critical items that are fastened or el-ectrically connected to the engine - generator. Items 1 through 17 are qualified by. stress analysis with positive' margins of safety and-resonant frequencies greater than 33 hertz. The ana-lyses are contained in References 1,2,3 & 7. Item'18, the Mechanical Overspeed Trip, is seismically qualified by an opera-bility verification. The analysis is contained in Reference 4. The Battery and Rack, item 19, was tested to 1.5g biaxial at resonance. Reference 5 contains the test report. Item 20, the Engine - Generator Starting and Control System is qualified by similarity to a tested Cofrentes unit. The vendor still needs to certify the seismic capability of a modified reactor bracket. The test report of the Cofrentes unit is contained in reference 6. 1.2 E22-S002, Motor control Center The Motor Control Center is qualified to SQRT criteria. The forms are in the attached Appendix 1. 1
TABLE 2 HPCS DIESEL GENERATOR FTL No. E22-S001 Calc. Allow. Wt. Loading Max. Tensile Tensile Margin Of Critical Locations (1bs) Combination Stress Stress Safety, % o Stress Evaluations
- 1. Air intake filter 250 3gH + 2gv 2,168 40,000
> 500
- 2. Accessory rack 4,500 3gH + 2gV 8,978 40,000 345
- 3. Engine lube oil filter 1,000 3gH + 2gV _
8,107 40,000 393 , 4. Water expansion tank 925 3gH + 2gV 11,250 40,000 ! > 500
- 5. Governor 100 3gH + 2gV 1,341 40,000
> 500
- 6. Primary oil pump 197 3gH + 2gV 2,062 40,000
> 500 .7. Scavenging oil filter 203 3gH + 2gV 3,298 40,000 >500
- 8. Scavenging oil pump 230
.JgH + 2gV 3,446 40,000 > 500
- 9. Engine lube oil cooler 1,230 3gH + 2gV 4,223 22,000 420
- 10. Engine at base 28,150 2.12gH + 1'.'5gv 10,989 40,000 243
- 11. Generator at-base 41,500 2.12gH + 1.5gV 10,653 40,000 209
- 12. Engine at foundation 43,000 2.12gH + 1.5gV 12,158 40,000 199
- 13. Generator at foundation 43,604 2.12gH + 1.5gV 8,069 40,000 383
- 14. Heat Exchanger 2,095 2.12gH + 1.5gV 9.333 40,000 329
- 15. Air turning box 500 2.12gH + 1.5gV 5,'539 40,000
> 500
- 16. Air receiver assembly 7,156 3gH + 2gV 281 MIN.
l
- 17. Compressor air tanks 983 1.5gH + 1.5gV 13,980 38,000 POSITIVE i
yield i o Operability Consideration
- 18. Mechanical overspeed 3gH + 2gV Operates Satisfac-65 crip torily o Seismic Tests i
- 19. Battery and Rack 1,200 1.5gH + 1.5gV Operates Satisfac-biaxial at reson-torily l
ances I l
- 20. Engine Generator 9,200 TRS envelopes RRS Operates Satisfac-l Starting and Control (IEEE 344-1975) torily (Vendor to System certify bracket change) i l
NOTE: Allow tensiles reduced per Section 1.6.3 of the AISC Steel Handbook ~ ALLOWABLE STRESS l Margin of Safety = _1 100 CALCULATED STRESS ')
[ 1 i, 1.3 - E22-S003, HPCS Transformer .The HPCS Transformer is qualified to SQRT criteria. The forms are in the attached Appendix 2. 1.4 E22-5004, HPCS Swit_chgear 1 'l The HPCS Switchgear is qualified to SQRT criteria. The forms-are in the attached Appendix 3. i 4 k I i i r I S
s_. ( m 3 _ __ .1 i ---
- - c !?--- F - l ti &
i I, !. i. l. 2 _' _ ~ . ~.... f_j. j i, t,
- 1. ~ 9. t
.,} ,y_ 8 f,. .l __ ..t. I f l..... .t 4 .... I...T.,;6.. i_l- ) l_ i_ ._t q - t .__._]_ p i 3 4._.. 3, .l: '; t -i.-.i_. e t .l _. q -. 4 g i- .-__u_. .___._.u._.. ~ e } s i i-9-- i
- -i.
__i_. i. _.-.... -. -.. _. - _ _. -.. _...... i - c
- -- - i t-
~ n. . E l,1 ! '~ i i eo I .i_._... l. i v .__.__y 1 z , l -i - l O 4 s s ...i g . : c l. r
- , - p '. ' 1,
'O w i 4..,.. t a, l 8 - g. Q 1-. 4 6. U i 9 i '. j ': i i;,- s r ..._.RRS FOR. D.EESEI'GESERATOR BI.Dd ^ 136' El. 4 l i l*: 1 . _.. _. 0,138_g ZPA O ( FREQUENCY (l!z) 2 v
9 ? \\ f s n 4 e 't i e. t .__~..__.~_..__.,..__.I.-_'__5_'*' 'I l: 1 ' _.-, _....._r_. a i f ' [. f* 1 }:i:l ,}[ s w. i f.. '... - .._ 4 .. _ _.. _ _ _. _. _.. p. g..._.. 4 . s.-. - l.,.. . j..__.. [. .._+..J_, 9 ,, j. _j._&.L i w-._.' i ... ~ -... - - _..... .. _ _. _..._._.__....._ _. - ~ .g-i t. s - _ - _. ~.. 3.-. i . p... L. i i ! ... - g ; t... .[ ,.._C ~~2' 4'. i."~j. # i i j _. l. . i .l. ,-.,. }.. ,~ ."^ 7.,.. J. 1 i l _.L. .. _ _. -.: L f 4 i i et l t - i I,_ .r; i i i n vi i I 8 i l i .l J i l._.. ti i i i v i r + -_...__.,..m._ 'P ~ 't '1 z S i e ii g g, . ~ _. _ _ _ 8 i' I.. l t-i i i. i i..t - ; i tg g 6 i-l l' y I M I I i." ' l 6 _ __ I 1 i I 1 p 4 8 i F ' '...!. 1 j 1. t, i. u .. _.. _.. _ t. i-i i 4 l. l l !.L.i l.1 l
- 11..
,0.219 8 ZPA . _ _ _. _ ~ _ _... _ _ _ _. _ _ .!._'._L_ J _ L i.1.4a [.. - ;-j - IIORIZONTA.L...S..SE, 27., DAM. PIN. G _.... _ c_ I I -...,..__m.. t e 'RRS FOR DIESEL. GENERATOR _ BLDG,., ..l.. t t 136, El. t t t i : ,, s .I O i FREOUENCY (liz) s O
REFERENCES 1. Seismic Analysis of Diesel Emergency Generator, GE VPF #3636-67-2, September 4, 1975. 2. Seismic Analysis of Diesel Emergency Generator.GE VPF #3737-62-3, April 28,1975. 3. Seismic Analysis of the Horizontal Cylinder Compressor Air Tanks, GE VPF #3737-82-1, March 12, 1975. 4. Seismic Calculations, Part Number 5-046-12-102-004; GE VPF #3636-81-2, November 11, 1974. 5. Seismic Test of an Emergency Generator Starting and Control System, Wyle Report #42749-1, June 24, 1974. 6. Seismic Test Report, Engine Generator Control Panel Switchgear Assembly, Wyle Report #43026-1, October 22, 1975. 7. Dynamic Behavior of the Mechanical Overspeed Trip on the General Motors Diesel Engine, 654 Series, When Subjected To Seismic Ex-citations, GE VPF #3737-93-1, July 5, 1974. 1 A
O O 4 + APPENDIX 1 a O i K
Qualification Summary of Equipment Mpt: E22-S002 I. Plant Name:* Grand Gulf Nuclear Station Type: 1. Utility:Missippi Power & Licht PWR 2. NSSS: GE 3. A/E: Bechtel BWR-6-fik III II. Component Name Low Voltage Motor Control Center 1. Scope: [X)NSSS [ ] BOP 1 2. Model Number: Series P-32000 Quantity: 3. Vendor: Powell Electrical Manufacturing Company 4. If the component is a cabinet or panel, na.me and model No. of the devices included: Panel was tested as a unit. 5. Physical Description a. Appearance 6-Bay Cabinet b. Dimensions 120 in. Wide X 90 in. High X 30 in. Deep c. Weight 4200 lbs. 6. Location: Building: Control Building Elevation: 111 feet 7. Field Mounting Conditions [X] Bolt (No. 12, Size 5/8" ) [X] Weld (Length 31", every 15") [] 8. a. System in which located: High Pressure Core Spray (HPCS) b. Functional
Description:
Inject High Pressure Water c. Is the equipment required for [] Hot Standby [] Cold Shutdown [X ] Both [] Neither 9. Pertinent Reference Design Specifications: GE Purchasing Spec. No. 21A9301 and Powell Drawing No. B57746-6 12/80 e 6
E22-S002 Mpt: 1 III. Is Equipment Available for Inspection in the Plant: [X 3 Yes [] No IV. Equipment Qualification Method: - [X3 Test [ ] Analysis [ ] Cortination of Test and Analysis Qualification Report *: Seismic Test Report Number 43549-1 (No., Title and Date) _ Low V,o,1tage M_CC_Seigic Test Comany that Prepared Report: Wyle Labs, May 6, 1977 Co pany that Reviewed Report: GE V. Vibration Input: 1. Loads considered:
- a. [X] Seismic only
- b. [ ] Hydrodynamic only
! M'Ph
- c. [ ] Cortination of (a) and (b) 2.
Method of Cortining RRS: [ ] Absolute Sum [ ] SRSS [] N/A ~(5!fieM spRiif]~ l 3. Required Response Spectra (attach the graphs): Attached t 4. Daging Corresponding to RRS: OBE N/A SSE 2% 5. Required Acceleration in Each Direction: [X] ZPA [ ] Other(specityl OBE S/S = N/.A F/B = N/A V" N/A V =~ SSE S/S ='- TT. <o F/B = 0.26 - 0.21 6. Were f atig;e effects or other vibration loads considered? [ ] Yes [X] No l l If yes, describe loads considered and how they were treated in overall qualification program:
- NOTE:
If rore than one report coglete ite::s IV thru VII for each report. 12/80 e 7
E22-S002 -3 Mpt. VI. _I_f__O_JalifiC_at_i on by T_e_s_t_, t_ hen Compl ete* : X] random __ _______----~~ 1. [ ] Single Frequency [X] Multi-Frequency: [X sine beat 2. [ ] Single Axis [X] Multi-Axis (with sine 3. No. of Qualification Tests: OBE 0 SSE 77 beat) Other 2 Sine Sweep UpHUJ) 4. Frequency Range: 1-250 Hz 5. Natural Frequencies in Each Direction (5,ide/ Side, Front /Back, Vertical): S/S = 18 Hz F/B = 15 Hz Y= 16 Hz 6. Method of Determining Natural Frequencies [X] Lab Test [ ] In-Situ Test [ ] Analysis 7. TRS enveloping RRS using Multi-Frequency Test [X] Yes (Attach TRS & RRS graphs [ ] No 8. Input g-level Test: OBE S/S = F/B = Y =_ _ 2 SSE S/S = 1.8 F/B = 1.8 Y= 1.7 9. Laboratory Mounting:
- Size,
) [X] Weld (Length ) [] 1. [ ] Bolt (No. 10. Functional operability verified: [X] Yes [ ] No [ ] Not Applicable See Note 1
- 11. Test Results including redifications trade:
Specimen operated satisfactorily in side-side / vertical orientation. Contact cnatter is noted in front-back/ vertical tests. After modifications were made, the specimen passed the Other test perforced (such as aging or fragility test, including resultsf:ts fronUback/vT tTcal tests. These modifications were necessary after 29 te f 12. i None If qualification by a co-bination of test and ar$1ysis also corplete
- Not e:
Item VII. NOTE 1: The unit at Grand Gulf has all the seismic bracing as required after seismic testing. However, per paragraph 6.3.1 of refer-enced seismic report, tray SA required adding a screw through the side af ter test 57 to prevent contact chatter. The manu-facturer claims that there is no other docementation to sup-port the addition of this screw. It is his opinion that the technical reviewers of the test aecided that it was not neces-sary. The test ZPA's in this case was 2.8g horizontal and 4.0g vertical.
E22-5002 ,4,
- gpt, VII. If Qualification by Analysis, then complete:
N/A 1. Method of Analysis: [ ] Static Analysis [ ] Equivalent Static Analysis [ ] Dynamic Analysis: [ ] Time-History [ ] Response Spectrum 2. Natural frequencies in Each Direction (Side / Side, Front /Back, Vertical): S/S = F/B = V- ~ 3. Model Type: [ ] 3D [ ] 2D [ ] ID [ ] finite Element [ ] Beam [ ] Closed Form Scluttor. 4. [ ] Computer Coddsi frequency Range and No. of modes considered: [ ] Hand Calculations 5. Method of Corbining Dynamic Responses: [ ] Absolute Sum [ ] SRSS [ ] Other: i hiiif)-~~~~---~~~~~~~~~~ 6. Derping: OBE SSE_,,,,, Basis for the damping used: 7. Support Considerations in the rodel: l l ( 8. Critical Structural Elements: l l Governing Lcad or Respo te Seismic Total Stress A. Identification Location Combination St ress Stress' Allowable l l Maxina= Allowable Deflection B. Max. Critical to Assure Functional Opera-Deflection Location bility l l l i 12/s0 9 -w
10 4.,.,,. _. a 4._ .+ -o_ J + 4++..,+.t tTTi +-+ +- - - t '1 6 t- -t-4 *t ' "tt ~~ Tt*t vt t'
- r -t-YY hi @
~ 1 --"4t iO4 TM4 ti ta Et4i - - * - h! t -i- ? -fY d-- dit-t t -* -d-* 7 --l+ itii iH+ iii: +444 -..vtil: + i E +f-. +_, +.1ti. _,.r.,.:. _____. =.. :.:. =_ _:- r 2 :_-,=. =__q. a: tiir + MT, -i H Hii + + i 4 ! i: nit iiii iiF ttii tiii ilt + f i-
- .. =a... = _ =.r.g c.
=.. _ =_ :;_n.=._z 6 .i. w.,._._. a . L..: = 1_.... 3:r.g
- ;-1
- -
C;I Or 11. 1 : ~~ C;2 ;;" 81 nu h.2:7 _7:: . - ~ TM- = In* ' I- ::21 C4' OU -f 2 U _.4. - ~.1TII*
- =_P:.+.'
___. n = r r : ..,_.2-nn :n-u y , 1 - 2: g: ini at I.m = ar 1 1 :
- ,_._+,_- nr.
a_; a. _+ 4 __:L_
- n..g
.,~ r t. .r, ., p + 1.. g.,. -t. p.L.,, + y y + .4 7c4 g+, 4 g,,.._- + 2_14.g.. a%_, u .t.. .}_._r,.$- tt 4., t t. ___4. g, 4 1 1 c 7 4_ 4 2 a u .r. 3 ._u._.=__.==
., _ =._..
- n.: =
y .:.=.:.=, _ :--.... .=. _:. u j... _u.__ 4 _ -.~_.-._~. z=._.:.:. : :: =.
- -- =
= :.... _n_=.__=:22
- ir a,
n_.+,:; 55==.;;: :;. :
- i
---4 _.+ nr = T = ,.t_: nz: g:;:; r;y n.,2 1g: ung=- =.=:. r, _,.,,4,..,,. 7 p.r. _ _._._ 4 .p
==. m: =:
- =1:
-+- _,_ tr
- m r
.+.. o a.. _ m . y. 9.
- a.,.
. 3._ .a c 2. _ j'y y pt,, 3i 4 m. ,_._4 _-3+ .,a.r p . 4 p.__. _4 .., + _w .. 4. _1 e . g__ 2 __.,.,. + + . n, __y 1 k b I T' I' --- I'# AL ^ m um T.1 2 . I' III' L' ** I' l' U'p E' ' '_ - . [ __,,,,fl-j!'f1
- 'J'1'..m j.uJ _. _]
94 L 4 .t_ j _ ___. a4 I--* 'ur 4 tw t 2 41. _d. U' !"!__a. -I i -7 TI_i E N iFi $i E + t 2.' tN! lin I!II - 4. . _ -uu .up m _Iy _4 ei - I'w[lyh t ~ ~ - @. N9 Tli T .i $ + ii __q t._ s. -*/t-ttt* ' *---h-~ +---""' - * - ' t- * ----I+*- -
- Tit M-
~rr*-t tTH ' 4 11 -t- + t -t- -4th'~-**tt --tti
- 4t i-Mi- "- +
t- + f-t-+ \\- 44 + -,+ r '. - tm tit-Mf+ ++H & + + & - tm+ - *r-in4 % 4M4 -di -+r - + + t + r'.- a Mtfiti i+ii -+i ti- + + +- i 6H+i\\_4 ++i +++-F+ S pii hi- + + tiH titi tiit Hii lii- +++ - w H-tHi .i. / --- - %,;=====::. = l =. / _a_._= } 6 _=_.N =
== = = = = . :- - -- 2 = = = = -- = = =.- - u :: = = =,
- u : i
=r = =
- =
- - = =. : :-
.;-==
- =
r= _._._fzu: ~~ -l.___%
= =
i-
- =; ::: = x :
/: ' ;
- =
c m:. =
- ;2 =
= 2 n p.= =
- = : : :-
mnd =21:L =: 1;r =1 ,,._,.m.._
- :. _ _, =
x nn
:
-+--r r 44 """'++'t' 1 '. - t++ .+4-E<+++.'e,-+"E'--'++- $~ 77,, _.4_ ' - - ***-*'L'OW VOLTAGE MOTOR CONTROL CENTER r I7' % 2i! ' --~, ..-e- .T T "1'*- ~ - - 'il "/ i ? -t i-l2 T ~I Di r 3, ", ___=e. _T _i__ R
- i. i.
T,iE _ _=i -
- -\\1_~:5._ -E_ =_
HORIZONTAL TRS.. _
- i. 5-
_". _24 6_55.
- 2
= .__2 ?._- _ = = _ = L zK _f _;. = = 1 : 2% DAMPING r = = p+_
- n =, - - -
f_:
=
- m~.
- n:pw
- .:::=ur up a. z-1
- =n
= =
- =
- = = :=
.,, k. d. .,2.. __ t_. ._7 4_ ..y a. .m. w _p II!i - - ~ ~ C' I ~ ? - 'th,1,+21 W2_- W II I:T. i iL -ll ~T' Iff,.I~ ++ iTd i$f i i J 4-- r Ni G i7,. a ti Mfi +- + i j 14 t [- M... 4 T- ,,i 4 - i" ft -- Tri-ij _Ti_rI -t. f., ipi
- 4 ag "{-
. Lf_. --j "P_a W
- n.,1,pr; T t-r
--i .j7--g__r .l, .._.r.i.tr..i__. r._.,-j. r._. .Y _r_.T i ca. .r-1 T i,, 7: hI!! h hiki Y T 'i i f -h i-d riT2-i =.. t I -} l,!li ik - - '. , l.! l ki b. Ti
- iii i#.i h Y T
~_.4 7.g_ r. _._4._. a )7( - +i-tt ---ir Tt* - - - ~+ + t ii - ttti l-m4 i 1 --r-
- 4
-t' + a+ % --f i tii -t- + 4- -r +t+2 .rAi4 1"-i4 \\4 H i- -; "fr i A4-f+ i++t f i--* ", n- --- + + + i ll f tt4i 'ii-iWi H-- % +4 .ll i-/tifi ilii ffH Wii; Y[f i +N4 +iii tiiif ".: D riii '& + + f i -te +H iiii liii i4if tH! iii t + i
- , --ra
__u = .2;
== y ,= u m
:
= m .c 1 u_ . :m u.a== = =.==n =.==. e.. 2.__; 3
- T-2 n.
11=
t
== _;.i nn m==: r A =
- 12. 2. :
- nf( =
= = = 1 :-.
- 6 1
=
- 1d2 r
.it: = r : I @E
- tn hw =
r.: = = =
=
an-1btr-mz x x x : _F.-iail,ril
- t = Inr n==n -
- m. T 1 1 7
- I 1=
n p t : E.- u: ,r _r p.p pt j ~ A$. ; -Il t r ^ : *~-' ; i-rTlii fin Hii M 1111 iF6 T T T ~..y{T: i--} ;P: $ +-t l :::':" 2 firr 2_ ~ H..r.d.. "b T T
- =,
,-+. c-T" T, i
- t. t.
t-L... I. " T i -~ ~ ,i p t r. ni rr HORIZONTAL SSE, 2% DA_MP1NG-' n =;; = ~ =: = = = c i _.-+J - - - - - - - - - - - ~ ~ ~ - --.g S FOR CONTROL-BUILDING =}__. 9__
- n
= .= rq =::
== ==; _I'EfEIEEIEIIIN 'RR l11' El*
=
== a = =_r = EnI C ; un = E E ~: EI;'== - ' ~
- t' L
E"i~ E i +1 :n
- - Trn =
- i
=.t,r : -+-t+t,lp =--0.26 g ZPA
- 11 r=
1-f ..I'.e; .4. } A__. .,.u 2a .2 1 ' 4._ _ya ., 4 m r 4 _.4 -4 4 - +j 44 .h.i m.A .m . t4.; },_.,.,, -t- .4_ 2.;7.. J"- i b- --Il 4 f i + + M ITit rn +-4 il. i thi + -t a,a n ,j _4_- -i.
- 4_
g 1 T .ib. T I .4 7 L a__ t. -+ ya 4 94 r-; % f 14 .t _1-v. -4 ru M 4 fi } fh} -)~ ~-- i~flI h-EY}i ~T-Ni I l - ' -f '- -i yh"}- '.' - T-m --- Y h j- - h' 1-ji f-],iti ',i r,' n Ti % j { a O b l TT i in f"' TT ~ ii7 T d
- n. ii rit iE T1'i I~ I
~i ~ ~I ~i 7
- li de.n:
'T T
- '. T-T T Ti--
7 j i r i r ~f +r o b'r.4 r r rte r rift Ibi 1 c t"i-4 l T m m: v on T T i T r, ii. - r i.. i w i
- ,1 7
3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 2 3 4 6 6 7 8 910e 2 3 4 6 6 7 8 9 l FREQUENCY (Hz) l a.9 6 l 10 L
'o ., u,_4._ ,.4 + 4 .,u..,, * *,4.,u 4.,._. _ _ , ; ; i. _.r... -+ y1, 4,. + + E H+ - ++++-..e +n1 - 3,F ,++- + 4 + 3ty + r+++ 144 r., + -- +
- ie+ mr i
- ;i +m m-i 7 -i-1+f-ifft hit Hit itH -n iiii-+- + + 1 IIil iii tHi-fili Yt+1 fiH iiii +- + i -i i l ll;!- tHi iiii -Hi+ 14ti Hii ---+
6 -4:====x=== = =
- =:===
= = 1
- === =u: m:
.. r
== m, = = x = 2 =: n= = x :.. s = a.:
==~=; a -.== a r-ua
== c= = = = c
== -+-
.;::L e.: :::= pt ~ - n;r un pun: e =- or = = T t an :..
- .- -n:,,: 2
=r ag uv a .a_ + a nu nt w u.nur zz .urz = at c r r : c 4 m :_ :: 2: r,. 4 4 + , p:q*,++- _a. 4,. .. L.__+= g _W_p _ .3 4 -n+ ;;- . _= _ung ___..} ll - N. g. +__4
- 1. "1
.. F
- f-4 t1
- t I! ! +~ ---+ -4+- +4 ri --I,*- a ,,., E. _u --4 bq. -f _ _... t- _tf s =-
== = _ _= = =.
==.T.==. --.1._ 11;=_= = ..n.=.=
- x. = :..
m. =:1 =a:n.2 - -, + r + _- -,. w= =., un x==r x~ 2n ::==== -3 ;;.. +tt;
- = ::
m n=- r -~ -~
- iiut
- m n: :::
. nn p: zz 1 < 2 : .im + 1a m,t-i _4 .i nr .,_ __ g. ,4,, 4 p ___, .f: e . u.a.. ___a pmg m..I l l 39 -.,, +t -. g..-7+t- + g, m,,,, -4 ..F -1 + + tt, p + r -- 44 r a U i+ C- '+ + t+t iit- +42i. - -ij iit- -j-4 I' i, d' jf 12- " -i' ~ ~ b;' j ~ I 5' "- r & -d, 'I' ili 1 ~~h~ 7 ~~T 7 ~ i 1, tg eu o 'r i - T1 iii-I N u1 'T; ~7-ecrr [l rm T' r iTT ifi ----T ii ~ ~~i "Tfc-~ i im ~7, 't n ii., e - -g -T T T h / TTIiTiT1 i i i ~~ T .61 i i to -Z.e ,i liiT to. io iei " + - +++- -+-- -+- + + +t ~ -t-tf + m++ -\\ i ~++ + a + _- O - g ,a
- r, + - +
4,e erm + -+-/ ; tm +++ im g y+- --r; i- --w ::i: --4 m: + + + + +1l
- +4rV.
l il L +Hi Wh ! Ii n" Hr + ++ ---+ --r -g - w it :!:i-ifH tiii 1ii; -ti iiF + + + 4 -t/rl+ "tH iiiifNittt titi iii++++ i i l ll!l ittt itti i,ll Mli lii--+ + t 3_g3 g===;.5 g._. ____.=_==_=.=._=__- =_=3= 5 ag Igp =r
_ = _
- g = =-- g: o ~+ = x x : A .== 21 nu m ~, nnnn- =_: uu
== Erix r - ~ ~ n2 f i+- Mr_._. g :r : LOW VOLTAGE MOTOR CONTROL CENTER.-,. 1 E 4 __ 7:- .;n; g; e g g tp t,% c g: pfQ 7.x .- th -i.- 4. +. t.r VERTICAL TRS, - - r .i* + 1,,@: -2E-k. tr+f,-,..o, s --T 2% DAMPING 9 7- ++ t r- / i i i .m 3 o c r-- c i. \\:= = z =. w
p
__ t =- = = = s + = .m-._.-,.. _._ / -:-. - + - -
=
= a= = 1 = ar=== = u.m - nu =s -r z1
==,/;- m.,_; :::: r: . _..= c - une rn _., - 2= 22 2 nn ttt +,- -e +%,.--*f. - - Tr + h. ++t-tr- .,y- _4- + i jT**t T,E.'~.*j*,R. ^- ~ ....,. -:i _ :- E j 1.p n..n"~T.$'r i ~~7 f* T ..i '---H T r,i, i,
- n..
t6,..~Mt.. +* a ii i.
- m..Ib
_:1 .u.t. g.
- 1 1
i, u o ~ o=pr. u. 1 um i> u= 1x 1 1
- u. rt.-- u.i.n r m. a u
,it mm ~ u aH mv o.- .x . x
- u..i Ip 2 +_1 m
x. _-a mr :rg,i.- _.a.. 2 1 1 2 .1. 2. u e o 2 i ~J_1 .,,e si e i i T eT ni. i.. l til T iir' TI,' TI i i ul i Hi i M' i! it, L_A_._6f 1T, o p r' 4 i t 11 R.i i ITTi. on i i .'T. T i i.e. 6 si i m_ 1 1 1 e i 4 e i i: Ti d 6 ii g ,-y r -.-r-,-rt,4 +- +- f-f- t r.w n 4 - - +, r ifHirt* l ;, l-ti+t 14ti r4 lll ,lj' tE ll: 4th +T--- -t-t * +M itt+ t-f tr te i;,; ---i Pi- + tD 1 i, % : lL+m mi e m: -w e + + 1 4
- H+-otme-mi ne mi + ++ + +i-e eta ++F mt 4m +++
f+ HM iHHiiH! M tie + + -t t --t+ +M t W i+ +Hf tm Wi-++4 i !l NN tHt Wi t-H ttH Hii + ++ 1=u5.}==
.=-=
n= -el== -= ; ::=..-- t--h=y=- } =.=
- g
. =t = - = =
===.v
== =. 1
==: -* -re - :== =
==
- i.===
a-+=
= = =
- - =
u .u; ;.--=1; 2t~~'n. t;n IE @ 41 :=' r r= m v z r \\ r-r -ni. @ -@:-=r . 1 = x dE = 7"-- c r 2 14 _._Li- -t+: ttr 2-,a Lit.j._n ",:: na :a
- 2 T= u n =4 Mi 5 ===
J 4: h =:p :: + .1. ::r - 4:- t- -4 tt ig x : + i: 1T; l.g_.pg4,1 ,trr +m z r y gk:= I pr d W
- ep cia # #ti a fit *
- 4
=t v : w = = z un a, =;- ;- wz = = . =r=1+==t-\\~'Tk- =- ~ . h._;
==
- =.==
=; = = = =Iin V =r
:
=
un . = = - = r g 4Dg PING 2 -2 a-- 14 n -t 1 y VERTICA LS,SE 0 t1 2 -+N'Et -==
2t tr :
== x r 22';C M. ^=p @ r. r. r . RRS FOR CONTROL BUILDING.., 7. } :. M,-d__. m __v._.__m 9 -d 'i ~ . 2_ 24 lh, yhc$. _Y.~4 - + TF Thi H-Antw-;w-rrt- +-- _4+m.:t: _+ ., -3 0.214 g ZPA : 12::. 111 '.. El..., , m nii + - + --i+ -T i +-il it b t'~ ~ 1 - d-.. ) 2w + 2 ~~~~ T'i . Llif .. Illa! 1** Llai un L C $111 n Ll: g' ' e . ' I.1 !'] 0' T 1 iirQ'[_yR'.jjjjpu - 1 }1st 3% 1.{11
- .{.
l'M L'r 1 m u'. a.. I;E 2 11 4 I t L. - d o ." 1 a til 9 m'thi Ihi Mi +_-_ h Titi A R HB T - i ! I?1in' -+ l4 nii r i T i r
- ,1 2
3 4 6 6 7 8 9 to 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91m3 2 3 4 6 6 7 8 9 FREQUENCY (Hz) -- a,. f i 11
aa,ema, -,.s.sme-.mammaam+,awd-a m a m 4.s a-m-mmam*M-A SM-M---Am.m--mM1
- LASms #
9As-h -u- ---m6 + b-4,-a L wn. - -.A naAs.A.A A-_ _ _hua aA,_,- A-a_Au_-- m 9 6 a b
- e b
APPENDIX 2 1 I b F l' h l i e 19 .. ~..
Qualification Summary of Equipment MPL: E22-5003 I. Plant Name: Grand Gulf Nuclear Station Type: l. Utility: llississippi Power & Light pwn 2. NSSS: GE 3. A/E: Bechtel BWR Mk III II. Component Name Transformer 1. Scope: [X)NSSS [ 3' BOP 2. Model Number: Elma Engineerinq #376 Quantity: 1 ea. 3. Vendor: Elma Engineering 4. If the component is a cabinet or panel, name and model No. of the devices included: Transformer was testad as a unit. --ai.2=i. 5. Physical Description a. Appearance Sheet steel enclosure b.- Dimensions 50"11 X 54"H X 30"Dp. c. Weight 3550 lbs. 6. Location: Building: Control Building Elevation: 111 feet l 7. Field Mounting Conditions [X] Bolt (No. 6 . Size 1 in.) Weld (Length ) 8. a. System in which located: High Presst.re Core Spray (HPCS) b. Functional
Description:
Inject High Pressure Water c. Is the equipment required for [] Hot Standby [] Cold Shutdown [X] Both [] Neither 9. Pertinent Reference Design Specifications: GE Purchase Spec. #'21A3598 and Drawing # 163C1398 12/80 O 17
MPL: E22-5003 i ' i III. Is Equipment Available for Inspection in the Plant: [X ] Yes [] No IV. E_quipment,Quayfgation,Megg: - [X] Test [ ] Analysis [ ] Corbination of Test and Analysis Qualification Report *: Seismic Testina of 750 Kva Transformer for Elma Engineering (No., Title and Date) Report # 58338, September 18, 19_7_8_ Comany that Prepared Report: Wyle Laboratories Comany that Reviewed Report:_Gge ra l_E l_e c_t r_i_c _C_omo_a_n_y___ V. Vibration Input: 1. Loads considered:
- a. [X] Seismic only
- b. [ ] Hydro (vnamic only
..' E
- c. [ ] Corbination of (a) and (b) 2.
Method of Corbining RRS: [ ] Absolute Sum [ ] SRSS [] N/A 15?.fGr-iJi:cifi]- 3. Required Response Spectra (attach the graphs): Attached _ /A SSE 2% 4. Daging Corresponding to RRS: OBE N 5. Required Acceleration in Each Direction: [X] ZPA [ ] Other(s pecity] OBE S/S = N/A F/B = N/A V= N/A Y =~ 0.21 =_ - F/B - 0.26 SSE S/S =---- u. < b 6. Were fatigue effects or other vibration loads considered? [ ] Yes [X] No If yes, describe loads censidered and how they were treated in overall qualification program: _______________ _
- HOTE:
If nare than one report coglete iters IV thrv VII for each report. 12/80 O e I
l MPL: E22-5003 i VI. .I.f Qualifica_ tion by Te_st_, then Comple_t_e_*: [X) random 1. [ ] Single Frequency [X3 Multi-Frequengy: X sine beat 2. [ ] Single Axis [X3 Multi-Axis ---~~~ 3. No. of Qualification Tests: OBE O SSE 11 Other ~ TipecTTi] ~~ ~~~ 4. Frequency Range: 1.25 to 100 Hz 5. Natural Frequencies in Each Direction (5,ide/ Side, Front /Back, Vertical): S/S = none detected F/B = none detected Y = none detected 6. Method of Determining Natural Frequencies [X3 Lab Test [ 3 In-Situ Test [ ] Analysis 7. TRS enveloping RRS using Multi-Frequency Test [X] Yes (Attach TRS & RRS graphs [ ] Ko l 8. Input g-level Test: OBE S/S = N/A F /B =_- N / A Y= N/A f SSE S/S = 1.8 F/B =_, 1.8 Y= 2.7 ~ ~ ~... l 9. Laboratory Mounting: 1. [X] Bolt (No. 6 Size _1 in.) [ ] Weld (Length _ ) [3 10. Functional operability verified: [X]Yes [ ] No [ ] N;t Applicable
- 11. Test P.esults including modifications made: At SHz sine beat (X-Y) three 3/8 inc bolts _ sheared.,_,This had no effect on function. - Bolts chanaed to 1/2 inch and retested.
The Grand Gulf installation has 1/2" bolts.
- 12. Other test perforred (such as aging or fragility test, including results):
1 If qualification by a corbination of test and an$1ysis also gorplete
- Note:
Item VII. 12/80 l l 15
_ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ MPL: E22-5003 VII. If Qualification by Analysis, then complete: N/A 1. Method of Analysis: [ ] Static Analysis [ ] Equivalent Static Analysis [ ] Dynamic Analysis: [ ] Time-History [ ] Response Spectrum 2. Natural Frequencies in Each Direction (Side / Side, Front /Back, Vertical): S/S = F/B = V- ~ 3. Model Type: [ ] 3D [ ] 2D [ ] 1D [ ] Finite Elenent [ ] Beam [ ] Closed Form Solution 4. [ ] Co.puter Codes: Frequency Range and No. of redes considered: [ ] Hand Calculations 5. Method of Corbining Dynamic Responses: [ ] Absolute Sum [ ] SRSS [ ] Other: i i i Tf)~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~- - ~ ~ ~ ~~~~ ~~ 6. Damping: OBE SSE_,,,,, Basis for the darping used: 7. Support Considerations in the rodel: 8. Critical Structural Elements: Governing Lcad or Respo :e Seismic Total Stress i A. Identification Location Combination Stress Stress' Allowable 1 Maximum Allevable Deflection B. Max. Critical to Assure Functional Opera-Deflection Location bility
- M 12/B0
~16
.',O ~
- 4...
- --e -.p.. .. +
- r
.p4.&..,4 M. n .q
- a. -t-7
.l tm % 4-M r--- -t r-4-+ +- 1 u., 3,..r i Th
- ~
- it, f -i i i Hti R Ml iTi it: Y i n
- iff tri
- n.'J
, _...._ : { =_= j n...;=__._:-_.;. 1 Y +M ' _i i ! i - =___ -., -. i 1 lll iYh thi iilf l. ll' iiii'.fih,.. H_. _ __ ' *.. _ _. =_ _ ___,- - t.. -s m -. =. = _ _ = _.. =_ .__.m._:==.j,. n_
- =..== _:-= = :
_r_=:::: __-. n;. u =pm .:.. r =rr. =;
- -= = ; r
+ rt
- mr::
^
- -tTt -: ::-
n =pt I i 1 _,_,_t m2 im -- : tr r :-r: . _It! ;fn . : := - - + -+-+ .c
- 1
- ::- _4_.2_n 4
g,4 y g . g- +. _,. _ ,ii 1 1, TTt it t' 4 - -E. W *l-r-+- + t ,,.1 __7 p .i r.,_ .7,'t 1 -t-+-- --44 ti?* ~*YtT- ..c t... rt" -t, -+ i - -r t i r ig p t J. -_i__=r_
- u_n i
T ~ a _ _.,,. +_ _rF.. .__= =_ _ _ _ _., = _. =..2_ :_..: x___.--. _. _. _.m==_..=.._. .=. :_.:._._ =_=__ _=- r ,i ~ fi -t- _g ri r r+t - t r .3.._.. n.;;-a.... =__ y_ : 2_:. _,
- __ _ _. _ -~=.
- ::r. = _..
_._T._T.,_1__ _=,.2 _, _ +. _.,._T...=___=_._=_.1 : ....;_::=::- _ _" e-*~.: ~
- =}:t.
4 t+i+- i CL:::. _ T 3* ..4 _3y-4 .._...-7.,, . 4..... 7,, + y + +y.,. 77 r,7,-,4 , -y l 114 y-4.- 4 l $. I@ $$"i.1 _gi Z { --"-%~t'$I IJR IT.C j l :- a++; r;p h. 74 j I ;, : ~~ TZ g-xj7 tg; ; ;-77 7 7 c gjj g ___. g
- j gI g
g ._4_ 4 y j 4jp. 7 g pa
- yj
] 7 E.i_ T'TTT1' ' . 1}J ta _._4. 1._._ . E j. iii. tei nr _L 1 1 e ie _ [II }T t T'i n11 " y" 1.+,i I"b; L .q '.i ' ' 11f1 '.id,. I ie i i Ti -'1' . m!)4. i t M O.t L' _L T' T Ti I iei oo e,o 4_.,,'. . a T. i oi u i 1o _,}.. e... .,._+.,, -/. -T_f + 7 . _+-3 { c - '++f in-t& -i -+-- -*- t+ _ _ _, -..v.e v_-. --t+ r- -f- + t+r4 -++- tr -+ / -+ ', A 2- + + + t-- M e r+- -iii -- ++ ilti titt L ll l Ttr-tit --t- ++ + +- [, ='i. 9i _t/rn -}tihW' M i ! 'A l ~ 'Hf iii-li,i Hii 12i- + + + i i ;;; iti titi iiti fi+i tiii H12+ +++
- _=.=_-
= =_ f======l _====. f ~ e -i = =
=='- h=f_=.-, ___ =.==== f l=== ====. =w==.
=
==
- .= =- = z
3
f = = = =
..==
=
= z --Am
- E=. _. -==
= = = :xy = = = r nr =,---/h=:=====_==1y
- n;.;
= = =
- t.:
R2: : x = ': _2-: r: r : ~~ u: t22 :: r 2 4 N_. __._ 4 . t ,--__._b___. f_ ._.4 _a. 7 ..nn.. w j 4-4-M y. ,r ..q,_r i _+ ~iI.t. -+, + + +. %-r a \\_. + r, -i _u. +. r r +1 t -r g _ _. ," _c _ 2_ _. gi = g_ r_==: *== _=_ %=.<-4_=- TRANSFORMER VERTICAL TRS
== .1
- n
=_; =__lu . +..
+
r * -~t- -r~ n;= = n.
u.==
= = = =
sq===
=:
- -- =
= : : .== 2
- a_ _p -
=:}=:: = = =
- r
~~ - - = --r = = 2% DAMPING _= : =: . __L__ _ _.,_. __r_._ _.a_ I. . __7 r ,,.r_ _._ g _r. u _Q, + __7 ,7,7. .4 7
- f.c 2,
. g. : : - -l-Z v i.o -_],- r -i, .l t n + + -i- } a, i
- -H -g -i,%, -H-e- f. + t ;
7.r rii-j77t g,: rTr 2 ii oo T-i '.in-Tr r i. TT m ,3 m-{- T t.7 i i - igt g T t.. - if,, ~r --- v i je TT; :r-T tm n,1 n r. nr 7.- .e.c- -T ,Tr e r -- T n 1,,, t o. _ w _. , r ___7__ ___,__r z
- ,-+
~- t - - + -, Wr --- H -t r e. t t- -+"-t+w t++i *+r- +i-t- "rv +' t- + + ' S W - H+- r--- f,i - + \\ -tkrw l 1.. ++i 4 t llll ttit iiH +t++ fiYi tHi +--+ + + D
- s _.. : ::::;-
rt itg. m#i:ih + + \\.i +ti+ Hi+-- l::.- ii4i tH-t + t i +i-i+ tttt +tli fii"++tHtH ht; + + + + g __._.jn:-l =}:p. = { =_,l-., =_;h r:-:_; _} _._ _{. _ __ l=___ =__l=_; ,:}__. _. =s - r :.
- 2-- =
= m g..htu. :- d_.__ p_ =. r r = n . =. - , =_., =- = A _ _ - _ -. }=__ n.
- r. t T_.. WI
- rkt....
"-+- 4:l. =_._+:u. c.. _. _: =L 6.r:.t._ .t.T W
- _t.i
- =
pr
- 4 a.
u t an o .ta_. u 4 1_, _ _..,u un .... a i 7 ,_t__. _ JL,. }. ' ' l' 'f i d'fiIf h' 'II ". "i-. + U, ~ - ' ~ 'f' __r*-- ^ 1 Mil Cli A liii ~ Ni -i- $
- -$, t 1 Y+u.
a y I$$$!I? f+tr-:iW M ; T i 4 . Ibi d i@ Z :. I 1 _= = _ = =. - - - = = l--.2. u_,=r --s m- + - - -. 1:. , -:- :\\; L.=_= =!=
== = = - p - 22'
==
- = =pr
=
=
- -[ bb-N b mu -Eint TEI:' EE. b__i b__ k.h _,u::_it im _ _n. t ^ M:: k 55
- ~~~~ : C
.__,_=_-_---_.-1_ R,R,S FO_R CONT. ROL. _.B_U_IL_ DING hg, --, + m,- g t-t. w 4 _m m 0.214 y1 ZPA i-111' El. ti I u. .i;+.h t, HiJ % He h -h . 1.t -i @7Ai d r,, e r dc r_- pt 1 I m:.s the!r r l -i HH r-mr w T-- midi + I n W - e -v tr + r 1 4_j4_ L ILj g'p g 3.__ 4j;
- t. y 4 3
_ _L ' pg. g' T' g~~~94g g -~ ~2.~ ~ '4 } .w.y J _j ' W Epa'Shu *o u' pLjj g q _. t p# 'i i _L.TT ' L' i '. ' L _~f - 1' ~- ~ t "p 2 m x _t. T 1 1 _ q' '- ^..~1 e. ~ .o~~, ' ~ r Y a.. i i i T q b i i' ~ ~ i -'f if I -~ ~ 7 ~' T i i i 8 2 3 4 h 6 7 8 9 to 2 3 4 S 6 7 8 9 100 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 FREQUENCY (Hz) $N
ic ____4__.._ ___. g ...p.. __ g _ __4 _. +. _ _ p__. .__.4. .... -,_.+-+. a _a _, _.. _ p_ _.o_ m 3 % g + +
- a_.
._.7 -+:---3.__- .. _ -:it: + + r i .: Tui Tiii-fiii +Hi Mi iiii -i-f f -M+ -HYi inihir YM -it + i i i i +Hi i:ri + w - = _ _ - _ =. =.__....... . _ _y_,__. =_ .,., _,.. :-._.....=.. -. __ - - -_ _ -.__~.._+- . _ -._;_-_--- _, -__ :_M ;-_ _--=_ - = r_n =.__. _==_ _ =..n.. _..,.,. w.
==
- = _. - =. : : :
._nn: n_- - =.. = r: 22., ~. a.u _. u.- 4 _.- - a .a. *_-*- ,..-'f.. +. c .,m b_-._ j i. i t, r " i ,_r, . e_ .t.-_*t Y . ' w
- d. '
H--t u:,r + +- y . i i, __q . -*_-t t._ ? P~~. T*._++ +. 4' T-- -. ' _...;4 p . _ _. :=_ =_ ; =_== _ _ __= =_. : u _ r:; c__: :== _ _._ _ __ =__._= _= =_ :_- r_---_.__ '_._ .i 4. m w r _, -.+ + 4 r% t+ .- Hi 44.v.-+
- p==
__. --_- +_,. =___::...
- _r.-_=.
3 =.._=:_=_i_____
- = : _ l=n r_: -
n_._._._: ...... _==;_. _. 2 m-
- ,.. ^,,,_ - _ _ -
= ^ j .r._ . 4_u ,4 -t O: ,- I -{ I 7 ._7,.. _.y.. a_. 4 ._._...+,_ j . @, ;~.77 j.i PtT, tn , _,,.,._y- . +, 4 L, a.. .+ 4_ 7 Ti~TT a,, J m. 4.--- +,M-tm -rr,t- ,Hr , p ,1 -T, - t + + 4 -- i, i, i.i ; i m __'Lt - -.-4 + r-r r 1r i i c o 1 i d,,i,.. - ! d' fYit H4iu iiQ -ii-I'- i : 'il' --H i l. T T "-i @ + + t- 'i itri-rii-iiti -R @ fir - "i .o. r-- np ,,i m i m' g rti- -f
- in 6
iTr I - I yi. 3 ,,i, iti 7 T,,m T i T 1 ~] i i ~ ~TT m. i7~. L. 6 : i. .i. i on i n ie m, it i Trt 6 i u.'iTil 7-1 TTT* in. 7ii n. .o T i .c i _+_._,,4 . _.4... _ _ _. _. _. _ . ___4.__ y 10 .;1 __q.__
- 4
%u t* _y_f.4.,- H p.. +..._ _u.. t. 4- .A. ,. q j4y. _j_ ,,p _g_ a l ll;, l[ jl;; M _p. l 7 _ -. _ _ y [<_=_ r - i-H th,::: -- W yq li; .iiH-il-
HY Yd ill li!L tiii iiii iffFii Hi2 ++ t f-
= =.=- - :..y _._=- =2.
- 2. 2 :
. = = = = --= __ l _.-
== .=; =-
= -.==- ;= = - = ===;===
== - = = =. =. =- m== == _=.__=,. /.. =_._.__m_ . =,_: _ __j. .__ _.m- -,n__n_=_ _=xx.T.. __._,m_. .__.-h.._,= n_ - n r __4 . +. _. .. _, _ _. _.+., 2. 9p ., g a._ f t a_ _._ g
- ii;
- 4 i,_;.
,y
- 1..y t
___7 1-..-_, __ _ _ _- t=._ _.=_..._=. =
_
. =_ _. _ _=. --, a . _ _ _ _. = _ =_. =_:- ---V.._. _==_= :_ - - - = _ = _. = =_. rl g =_-=:- =__ _ t u== m: =.j== =_ _ =..===E >== ; = -, = = :
==m;== =_ =y:_ =- - ..r--- =j =. = = = 11 _ = = -m L _,,,__p._ a.__ TRANSFORMER HORI.ZON_ TAL._T_RS._rT_ _._.7,.___. _ _. + . __,t 2% DAMPING p._...__ r ^ 7 r t M, ~,T--- T, E i
- I
,+ i i c . 'rtt2 i- - -rn Y _. _. _ a,. --d 7"t T-f___rm. _ - _--.m_ _. _. -. m_ -r. _r _T ; _3, - ,_.ii.. __. _L. a.. + __t, l 3 m r T i,, ,ii. .n i iii r--i T y i i iT. . ii ,i,, ..it ,o, i i m 7 . _., f % _r __y__ g ____ __7 y *g ___y __ ._ j. g _ _ _ _ _ __ g A %_r+, _.g.% e .,. + e g_ z y _ 4 ay q__ g_.. ,.+ 3
- i tt"Ym H-M
- iil
"~ M + + r f . }.2. s 9 .7
- Pi fi" i-Hl+
"i --\\+ hr + M +Hi Ft-~ ,r; =- +- +~t i-1lll lH+ i++i ti24 -lllt Mf % +++ 1 g w _: = = ; - - ==== =y. . _= .--_. =,== = . _=.-. + = = = ---1=- t==:-
2
-=
==]== _=.=..=..- =. =-
= :==__.=t
=
==
w=
=un-
== ::-
,= .= = :
u ___r_ + =_ an1. 2_1: =, r, - - 11- =_ _= =,.r 2 . 2 =_: _=_ _= 2,_ 1_ u-u " ~g __l _- _,. g 7' o .c - g, ,_M! n,... :r 7'i n_: C T 2 : n. v y, d-_4t-1 1 -1 i 1 H r,;t Tm mt M. tTt o.. tt t i q I; r :--
- / +- h r+H E' J-M i-0
+ + 4II g I ^ .=. = =._v = ;_u
==. HORIZ0NTAL SSE,, 2% DARIPI,NG -r
- g==
.: ; =: .= .. _m- := =
- . mr__:-
= {.__- ; __ 4 RRS FOR CONTROL BUILDING _= :=
==
- _ xx t~-d G,
.E E. -2 _-~1_1__: %._.5!. ~~ :5_. _2_i-i_ _ i_= ~ ; 1.5.3 i=__ R_ 0.26 g ZPAI'~l II": M -~l'11' ~51. P__S-a + + _._______.____1__,____'.m --_m, _..,.,i. ..g 7 2- - r- - --y ..4 1 y_4 2 4 1 1-4-- q- _11 p p. _q _. J 9 q_. .L ..J 4 _ 1q 5 _, 1 j.__, .y. . i: Yrhr'r
- b. -!;Ib t
t ._- N_.iY l'I--- it5 -b i. _-! ' ,-tq -i-I-'i q. ? 2-T il fi-' T _i --FIMi...T i-i. _3_. l L' 1 j Al1 !ji. _L 111 -l_ .b.'. _I'. 4 4 d _ l_1 4 {' ' 8 L Q 1 IJ .l_ .L
- j..
J 8 8 6 8 i 1 1 _L,___ J;1 typ ;;,. iie i ti a Q: 46 41 e i ia 3 'h" hl $hf k Nh4 m 1 1 T- : .-- h -h-Y i i i i [ h -$- i I I--- 'h 7} Tiil b-k i' i Tin un Tm , tri I' "' a TT 1 in er T }i u ir r r t r iT T n-im
- ,1 2
3 4 h 6 7 8 9 10 2 3 4 6 f> 7 8 9 100 2 3 4 6 6 7 8 y 1C FREOUENCY (Hz) 18
.A, n 9 I f ? APPENDIX 3 1 1 1 l l 9 19
Qualification Summary of Equipment MPL: E22-5004 I. Plant Nare: ~ Grand Gulf Nuclear Statio. Type: 1. Utility:Missippi Power & Liaht PWR 2. NSSS: GE 3. A/E: Bechtel BWR-6-Mk III II. Component Name HPCS Metalclad Switchgear, 4.16KV - 1200A - 150 MVA 1. Scope: [ ] NSSS [ ]' BOP 2. Model Numbcr: .GE Tyoe M26H Quantity: 1 (8 bavl 3. Vendor: General Electric 4. If the component is a cabinet or panel, name and model No. of the devices included: Device list attached 5. Physical Description a. Appearance 8-bay rack 7, b. Dimensions 17'4" Wide X 6'7" Deep X 7'6" High c. Weight 26,250 lbs 6. Location: Building: Control Building Elevation: 111 feet 4 in front & 2 in re r of each bay 7. Field Mounting Conditions [X] Bolt (No. , Size 1/2" ~ Weld (Length ) l B. a. System in which located: High Pressure Core Spray (HPCS) b. Functional
Description:
Inject High Pressure Water c. Is the equipment required for [] Hot Standby [] cold Shutde<n [X) B o.th [] Neither 9. Pertinent Reference Design Specifications: GE Purchase Spec 21A9300AL and GE Swgr. Dwg. 0126D9539 12/80 O
MPL : E22-5004 3 1 III. Is Equipment Available for Inspection in the Plant: [X 3 Yes [ 3 No IV. Equiprent OJalification Method: - [x] Test [ ] Analysis [ ] Corbination of Test and Analysis . Qualification Report *: Seismic Simulation Test Program on (No., Title and Date) 4.16KV,-1,200A-30MVA_Metalclad Swi_tchaear l Comany that Prepared Report: Wyle Labs #43581-1 Comany that Reviewed Report:, _ _ GE_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ i V. Vibration Input: 1. Loads considered:
- a. [X] Seismic only
- b. [ ] Hydrodynamic only
- c. [ ] Codination of (a) and (b) j l
2. Method of Co61ning RRS: [ ] Absolute Sum [ ] SRSS [] N/A 7BT. nim spiUYi)- 3. Required Response Spectra (attach the graphs): Attached l 4. Daging Corresponding to RRS: OBE _N/A SSE 2% l 5. Required Acceleration in Each Direction: [X] ZP A [ ] Other(specity] OBE S/S = N/A F/B = N/A Y" N/A Y =- 0.21 F/B = 0.26 SSE S/S =_ _u_.<o _ _ 6. Vere fatigue effects or other Yibration loads Considered? [ ] Yes [X] No ) If yes, describe loads considered and how they were treated in overall qualification program:
- HOTE: If sure than one report coglete itens IV thru VII for each report.
12/B0 i .~. 21 ~ i
- MPL: E22-5004 VI. .I_f Qua_lif ica_t_i on by Tes_t_, the_n Co_mpl e_t_e_* : 1. [ ] Sirgle Frequency [X] Multi-Frequency: X sine beat ~~~~~~ 2. [ ] Single Axis [X3 Multi-Axis (with sine 3. No. of Qualification Tests: OBE O SSE 61 beat $ther 3 sine sweeps ~ 1specTTj) ~-- 4. Frequency Range: 0-250 Hz l 5. Natural Frequencies in Each Direction (Sid / Side, Front /Eack, Vertical): f._ 5/5 = 7 Hz F/B.= 8 Hz. 18 Hz Y= 23_Hz 6. Method of Determining Natural Frequencies [ ] Lab Test [ ] In-Situ Test [ ] Analysis 7. TRS enveloping RR5 using Multi-Frequency Test [X] Yes (Attach TRS & RR5 graphs- [ ] No 8. Input g-level Test: OBE 5/5 = F /B = Y= ZPA SSE 5/5 = 2.0 F/B =__ 1.8 Y= 2.25 9. Laboratory Mounting: 1. [ X] Bolt (No. Size ) [ 3 Weld (Length _ ) [] 10. Functional operability verified: [X) Yes [ ] No [ ] Not Applicable
- 11. Test Results including rodifications made:
[
- 12. Other test perforred (such as aging or fragility test, including results):
See attached device list. If qualification by a corbination of test and analysis also corplete
- Not e:
Item YII. ( l i l 12/B0 22
. MPL: E22-5004 VII. If Qualification by Analysis, then complete: N/A 1. Method of Analysis: [ ] Static Analysis [ ] Equivalent Static Analysis [ ] Dynamic Analysis: [ ] Time-History [ ] Response Spectrum j 2. Natural Frequencies in.Each Direction (Side / Side, Front /Back, Vertical): l 5/S = F/B = V= ~ 1 3. Model Type: [ ] 3D [ ] 2D [ ] 1D [ ] finite Elecent [ ] Beam [ ] Closed Form Soluttos 1 4. [ ] Computer Codes: l Frequency Range and No. of modes considered: [ ] Hand Calculations 5. Method of Combining Dynamic Responses: [ ] Absolute Sum [ ] SRSS [ ] Other: l 6. Dacping: OBE SSE,,_,,, Basis for the darping used: 7. Support Considerations in the rodel:__,___________ ____ 8. Critical Structural Elements: Governing Lcad or Respo :e Seisrd e Total Stress A. Identification Location Combination Stress Stress-Allowable Maximam Allowable Deflection B. Max. Critical to Assure Functional Opera-Deflection Location bility t l 1 - - -- f 23
I l SEISMIC QUALIFICATION EVALUATION Panel MPL Ref: E22-S004 Panel Dimensions: 17'4" W X 6'7" DP X 7'6" H Sys tem.: ' HPCS Metalclad Switchgear Incation, Elevation: Control Building, 111 ft. i. CUARDif 5f tSMIC CATABILITT/ M4ll4JM [IPECTE3 ggp,g i . PURCHAst PAaT Cut. MALFuncT101 Lin!T PtAt ACCELERATIC.'s AT LOCATIGI CC5CalPTIDsi gg gg f-b s-s y f-b s-s y \\ = Freq. Relay 121JF51A1A 3.5 3.5 3.5 1.20 1.20 0.9 See Below l I .t l [ l 4 i This relay is qualified by comparing the current seismic capability with the maximum expected acceleration. The seismic capability is from GE PSMBD Engineering Section Memo 08609. The maximum expected acceleration is obtained by multiplying the trans-missibility at the mounting location times the ZPA for t'his elevation. All other essential devices in the Grand Gulf Switchgear are simila'r to those on tlie tested unit.
i 10_._._._._ __4_ __ w..._ u. . w.. . _._.a e
- u. j.,
_4 u. 8 -4++--ttr+
- t. -
+,- im-++ i t++v +4,4 w +-- 4 +--t, r+ - n- +: er - 44 -- + a 7 t Y i t lil! liti-hi4 illi lili -iii :iH + t i itf-ill. iiii-itif ii t ifH iii- - i +i+i-iW hH ii". _.fiff _r_ -=__- ; _ _ _ _.. --* * : _= =... 2___-f __.: ~-_-- - h_= =_. -..0. . _,.=.. 7_::'__ m.__.~_:.... .~ i.:*; =_r_
- .....__.. '
- 1.::crI::
a_ =_ :.:...- _T_ _i _i,.. ..dr.,.n..
4,=_=_
.,_ -z_:. m m
- n :=
._.: 2-r_ r a. ,. _.i _- =.: ._,.,c _.v. un#. .o + n + ._m_. 4 -tt-i ,,,.i. 4 -~"
- -tt*
~ 3 tf + 1 *+ - @" fE4' t. -r F'--+*4'. "a..- I. _f.. t I +u,-... i. t. g ~r -~..t. T*- - - + - - -~ +4+ ,,.i _- n-t".i.- f . i I..rr rfr,.- "r*n. c rY' 1' l.1 m.r e ~ i
- r i i>
i i;, t r -- rr- ---n tr r i i -7 i,, iii. ,F b".-_t 4 n r-t 1, Tt44 t
- Tv t +
,i.- i.. c -- 3 =____:=_1=..__., =:._ _ _. = _ __: =.=_.- = = = _. _ _---- x .=_=.i.=_._... =
_=_=._ =-- _
_=_z... =.==-= _..= :. -..,____..-._a,. ,.__y_ _._..__4__ _-__g__ .2 ___4._. 4_ . _~ u m. 3 7u~_+_.,,,; m + ,;--j ii r,, r, re-p.. :ttt;,;,., ___. +-p- *t r,--+>- rr+ - ;.,o-1 ,,,,. _ _._a,. T. +,, _. +4- ++. Tti n r+ .i.- r+ . --d, f If.fr, r*r- _. -.,r. r-- tt-n+r .i..- St-tv- ,i t I."-ji. - l!.i 121i -i--
- i!
liii TT r -.i i
- @'y Ti H14 Y + tt
,ll-iiii iii'
- i
- titt -iii i
m 1-tl rli M W + t i T --. n ,m T T iii n .iii n.1.s 1 e.c. i
- T-7i r
iTT % T.i, Ti nr T I- [- nI hi; i.I im ou e i n., ,n! iTil GT 11-fT Ti o i T T t i eii. i TTr .i,.. ^ ii.! Tm Til i i,4 oo is ,,i.- oo TT T i' ii6 ieii Tii; 7J TTir Tit iTr. T T .- 1 .i,i NTT illi i 10 -Z,, ~ ~ ~ - -- W ^~~~ - ~ ~" ~ G. o -,_ _. fy :,,.. _ _ _m.:: c __e. +.,. _+ + .,m y _%_ _m. -H;7 ,,m -_~ e' -fr-F..:. Hi--+- W r+ &it +t+ + l;; ,':i ;;;; ,l
- l, "+ i-+
l i i+ ++r g; wit il HHt-+ ;,;F r iitcY- ++ i- /rf \\}l;;l iiti-ii itti nH iii: + + i i jjl llll llll lli, l l l l-iin._ili l s. x __}=.,..l.-_l=_ { =. -/=,_._.. __. .w- --.jn,.=1- -=--- =. =...=:_. -.a. - =}._-- -_: ' - - -=. -.-== = = ..: o. u n_._ - --t- = = :-r_r -m = 7_ : -~ <_.1_ r.- _t r _4 _.m m 4.- 2. _ nr_
- l, up m.
_.h i,, ; :.._1 _.___.j z . a. + a m+4v _. ___+ ,, m -%T-nr* 4,~ M{. ir " - - c
- 1. %, rrr Mt ni
--f-- r err-o m m i 1 -T -r
==s= EE-g=g- =:M ~ ~. - jgEji$M 5 2-BAY METALCLAD SWITCHGEAR
~==~i==-- jigjg r=
r: = HORIZONTAL TRS,;u. % DAMPING-3 2
{
.r r n : ,m= /- 2n =
- n t-gn
- q
- 7
[7-.__ ,,a._ __, _y-. 'rr-- m.- s .TF. -r __t y - r- ), _.r, ret- ,t r t it.. -r-r T T ii, --1--- ,u r- - g r r: w , r2.3 r.. --/ r-- _g -h 1 m .sy ..'i 122. .,x-nt, n T =4 ii ,L .=. a ta_., u _l,,,' l_.. .y. n' j. 1 ..L, t -t _saa = t ' I '__. r'1'l1 . 11 i i ~, 3, L. Tr 38 _2 ._.L M,-f1 t'l. l.i. i l' 2 i m u' !. ,.1,1, 'I 1,3 ~ i 4 11 i, L. il . _u . i , y i 1 t. ll NP Nht- 'l -- i f i } l l, $f $ $ hti --ii rh -I-i- _ lll llll yil! 3 l,ll tttR H 1 2 g -,+ _,,.4 +w d- -.--w * + - y ; g, - re, w m1 +v -w er + r r 2
- +itm-
'-t--.m- [', *+t +49 f-i -- -l'.: % H2- -/- i W .l'F tita tir tW 2i et'" 4 Y-i llll ,l'; fti HH +t4f tiff W + i-r H+ t+F iii2=- -Hii i--Niii +f i- -t-N+iffi-tiii-2iii iffi-Nii ii= + + ti lii! llll iiti iffi lidt tiit :iii-- f-
- 5%d5 MIE 55lEE-5M/I5 5 5 ~5-'M;is. Ell 5 i $ ~-}iE 5l5 5-di.
IR 55}5Zl55}57-5 5 .__ __h_t;, =h_- : _. = _. =_ x_ -. ; I ,l,,I j y;[_r _..t.- -7 r_ _. m:n:.;;;;. t. 'i-- . -._.u.__ - - _ - -r
- ....n_
._- - := _r - _r m
- c e
'i.t.. d.
- .n. 'a T HORIZONTAL SSE, 2% DAMPING--,
t a.g u.2T a. t x p 1_4 Lim 2-7 o E --I-5 :.._ - un t T w i 7 w t HL +. I i ? i H NN +rt - --ti 7-RRS FOR CONTROL BUILDING e -I-T +_r : 4 ++ Ini e 4 ffi -2
- 3
_E.. E 2._E.=_ 3 "__ii i_E_j _E=_NIE EtE $=}ij - -~- 111' El. .. _l_ E_ _i ._Z_ _ _-} Z_ _ 5....E_ Iig = E n ur ___d]g-___.2}#':= r:e;rt ir
- :r;
= r :: : r,.q ,2n4= k g,- ___ = : .r.:n nr
- g: =r n ;-
r r;: x = : s _.__.: ;:n 2-*n.ru te.- nr xx x r r r r :r ::n t t-nr - :+ 0.26 g Hz 2 1_.1 L.2 U. - 4 .h... ,j jJg ,26 -t-p~ _ __.4 j - 4 J L.L. l ' }- -I---tY 112-} .. 3.g _ - _ __.11. _A. 7 L.L p4.. _4.} {m _ L p._ 3 T T- ~ l' - 1 4 u. !jp 4J"J. .L 1__. T F~ IJ 7 ? L, ' H --i tH- + i -t-++f - b.Lh rit 4 Hu' fv4 4' +1.' wi f rli' l-i2-2 34 H '4i4 r t,- F 2 tr -4H + v i +4 +'-t-i Hii-tii: -Mi T + t i I 21-i-in.2 fii M J ii-liii tiii + + f-it +fTi tiit 9 HH -i" it'i i- - "- 2 '22 'y .iTT ii.2 g ThT T i, tir 'T TT 1* tni rti: - T tii; . i,:
- n...i Ti~g' pr n 3,~Tri ip =-
riea ~7i {i TTT" fi . ai: T T T III Ili. T iTii ~ ~ ' t' T ~l t t j i 1 f i]Ti
- iii,
.e t, i isti si, "lTi i e,,a 6]II [I I ~ T T ~ 3- ' ,in ii I i TT ii'i i i; i~.i T T i iTTT .iii iii. . T TT TT. T T T ~ ~
- 1 1
2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 100 2 3 4 6 6 7 8 9-FREQUENCY (Hz) 25
- 8' 10
,4 - __4 -._ p. +. j
- u+.
t + m.. ..,.y. y +. u e>. _m. + e + r +
- 1. + 4+
,d e+ + + + t
- r. m + + -i
- ini m. +er. 11 .,r
- : m r--
+ + t-f -f 1 l ;- illF iiii iii; -titi-iiii tii- -i-t i L +H+ iii+ iiii iiii iiii iiii-tir + + + t tr4+ iiii iiiftii fi+F i ri-r- _.. e =._=_ ..t.... .=q=..= =::7. _.2_=._.. _::- =_ = _.:_ _a . =. = =._::...._
_
.= :-= =- =
== = = = r -14._. z
- n r= r:
a =r ::
== r2:
===:. az==._= r :a_,_ - :m.w_e n:: ___m
- n2:
. = =
= r :. _
_c 4
- t'
~ ~' +,,",' '-~ f- - - ' ~ r i ;,- 1, ,1 '. l Ai - ' ' -i+, . i+*' -E-h ,.-g'IA+. Me 3 im + r-f~l'. -TT t ri+n JI. I- [r. ,T -'. +I, g. ' 't ~ i n - m + 1, -H,,-++ -f. - r-- r ~ i + r-r - HT---r r- +y , 1 __S _,_
== =__ =,_ =_ :_ :_.
-u
r --- r- - - - - =_a :--::--: = _ =..
=..
.=.-1 =.n.. _ _...=.=_. -=- n. + - -: =..=_ -
- ==
. = =:::
- .::,=n:::
r==
- r 1
.1
- x=
== r : . - - -r w
- 1. =
.== = r r :
- ,r:2p
- =x
- r
-+r ::. :n- .i,- en =
- -1 1
8
y-4,.v.+_7.- 'r 7
7 +,. +. o-te, ',$-- . + ..4-A +.. _ J.1_ _ 14. D 1 ,!j y,, . 94- .-6 h,,.74} -t, --- 4, 4,.1{ 3-y ,..c r- ~4T--+ -r, t-r- r~ @.- r 1 -~ r-- m + r 1 - -r+ >-r..- , c,,,-- m.. h + h+r g4+ y +g-97 __5 4 T T T T. i6i ' TTTi.ir 7;'i T- . irt 4 i i - g~ qNi j gg gj. t 4 g;
- s 44rN; 3-
. g. g-.... t p+ e nt r + f i. - gr .o. rm rS. -A T M. T .. TT r-il.I~1, i i ar Im =,,,, - - T T 1 T1 tit ~ rn ,, n T T m. iiT TTi' !To 1 i T1- ~~ ~ ie TH TTei 1 - TTTT TITT iiii iii On m _q g _.m.,. .~. e,.+4 + _-+ + M : e.o.____ 9.-v_-,_ wt rte r.,- + + _+ _/ : m e_. +_,, -+ .+ er @;; +'a ++ + + H+i rih mi i;:! ". 9-*+++ -f. V +2 m ++++ "F itra 'i++ - ^ 2-- + r+ Miii2 i:i: r:iH ++ + i- /t..- %%2fii -llll iiii i+ + + + llll ::!l-tiii ffii +iff iiii liitY Y' + + t-llll
== == = = .=u=
=-=-;
5 =:
- la
. =h==-l= =__== m=__,= ^ =
=
=
== . -. =1=- --==
Dj ___ ' n
- x--
r : :: -l>
- t:
= r ; =:t u. ~
t
= =
=
t-m =
== _= r : .xun '+r -+~.. ___~ r r
- w -
u=1= _,__= = =x >---== = ~ MU -- ' 5_. b. -w' u-td . _.a_ ,,,+,,,..-,-,,. ++ u+_. ~. . u +v _r... .i d-t
- - ~
--i --..., ' r + +-) .t, l. ii D... -+*4% tii.j -r- ". 2-BAY METALCLAD SWITCHGEAR 2r"- t . = = --=:. -h = . = - =h- - VERTICAL TRS,-2% DAMPING T~ 4 = = =
l_= t=
..= _ _. _ = _=._. = =-)
== --T =N _j 5 m = WE .Ei y .__z= ss =E = = 3 =5N = _ _ _. =. _ _ _ = _ _. .i.._..j_,--
== = V r--1 ._..._.+_ -_.2. - _ -, 4 _# ".w + n__. w. i_th _tr_H.t.i k,....+ _.g rri .t,1 H, - ,os .~ -4, .m 4, g,44 j a L -. ._.u..:.. ~Z. - T i .t
- i L s 4_
+;i. 14_t.dut TTTi e.2 E- ~
- a. "-.i.'. 0 11 x
x .. =. 4 in
- _1 2
_p..
- IIII,
_._ 2 L a. 1
- I' m
u 4
- u _-
i i i 7
- q. EF n ia un u-i
'1 lpipi.'Tii 2 i i.:. I._ 1 i,l.n t!:1 _L 1-. r, } 1 e.- i*it >i'i u.. 1 p Li.12, 1,1,R, r .L.] iis' ..ti s2 41 in .s _n: Ti
- 4 ee
,oi ii e i c m i e i i:it i .i i i. s
- ._ -_ -, j. _w g -.-
.a ~, ~.,. ; c. m ge e ,,i-r- -r .. __ p m. % 77_ p. _ p . ;.g
- m. _n... _c
+. + __m. r-t-W +i+i Hri -+' l!.. T --. + t ( i il -H-ti tij++iff +++t- -tii Hi++ + f ,;l;
- li; iffi ith +rfT Hti ilTi t + i-t lll+ itil Hfi ii' tim
- i 2
-i-- i ! ll:l fiii tiii-l!ti +fff fifi HfP f-i llll lYfi ttfi ffti fiff-tilf-iiii + f i =: r: = 1
- N:
-j= = c
==: -== .= =
_=_=._ _=_= _ = - _ - ~ = = = .-- ~l = = : s=
..
.= .= =_== _. =
==1: =- = = =
- =_
= =.- a=. g. 5 ._ ? r___
== : .g: r r _ 1' +r : nr :;.- ' r; _. -:4_ 1 17 S.u=.=. y-. r- .. l._ r_ n r: 2 m _.a .a. u.a w w. +--.a. _.x x +
- 4
-- t+r} r. Q T++tt p.- h,: t,,i, e-t +-+ + r + . +, i q . +.. t j T 4 .. -,t y_ q y, 4tr 7 4 7, p. vSt -j + +. -+- ++ gt .g + 2, -fi $ Y l T.yr- ,r - - -I-/_j~~g ud-,y..fR bri nr 77 ___ii.= =. =._4_;E_=E_ M_ --VERTICA.,SSE, 2% DAMPING ~I T J zf44 Mri @ i444 b i+ 2 LT "T i
- 3 _r = :
=;5~-- E_E._}E _iE__ =__E_ ~=~ E_ _: _=_ _y :~~= _ = ~. ~. RRS FOR_C_ON_ _T.ROL... BUILDING = E --=:=== r r : 111, El. --- -{w. _-...__ - _i et = rr = = r .putypunaunuwq: r : : r: =
== = x m ; a .g yg 7_v g _. k,_. r --- r. I 'i- - - -. p4.r -t. vt .4-- .t . T _ gt._ 1_., 2_ s r ,7 __Fm ,m m a 1,. 0.214 g ZPA h ..a +.+ r m2 4- +- +- I, i.ji..-i W ,. i b --sr' e -%- - - jJ, r - M, r -,4,, .p4 ,,t rt ...e q4 -' TT~ '~r ~~ I f , --.. f. .m '7-' i 2F' - Ie F !.' t.. f j~ 2 .s<. + +M.... r 'j .je. E.1.T ii I TT.: ,e.i i. T .,.i. 1 : c-- i;il ,e . T i' 4ti 'i i T~
- n. T.~TT. l T'i e ii!
'i~ Tili i;* g T T I T ; i
- m..i:
- il f rii i
~ " ' - Ti i i e T T T-i 'I TT eT iTI t j] iTi' TITT' 1771 iT'~ i i j r e4 hi Ti_1,j ' T ]T iT t i .a.-. j
- TT Tii'.
J.,' a'" e. i;e ae, p. ,i e i i i nit l' ti im sisi i eTlT iTil tir" TTU ~11 ~~ T T T i s. ,esT in o ~.. iii i e + i.
- I 1 2
3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9100 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 FREQUENCY (Hz) 26
ATTACIDfENT NO. ~ 4 -Electroswitch Series 20K Switches on Panel H13-P601 C41A-S01, E12A-S03,-E12A-S57, E21A-S07, E22A-S03, E21A-S06, E22B-S02/S07/S09/S10/S15/S16, E51A-S15 AE2Z4
GRAND GULF i NUCLEAR STATION UNIT 1 l 1 l SEISMIC AND HYORODYNAMIC LOADS REQUALIFICATION CERTIFICATION JOB NO. MPL-02 EQUIPMEtiT NAME: ECCS Switches, Panel H13-P601 SPEC. ti0: EQUIPMENT NO: See Attached List LOCATI0ti: Control Room l EQUIPMEt4T CLASSIFICATI0ti: @ ACTIVE PASSIVE SEISMIC QUALIFICATION REPORT REFERE!1CE: Electroswitch Corp. Engineering Test Report No. 1981-2 Electroswitch Corp. Engineering Test Report No. 2392-10 l THE AB0VE SEISMIC QUALIFICATI0ti REPORT (S) HAVE BEEN REEVALUATED At.0 REQUALIFIED WHERE tiECESSARY TO SHOW THAT THE ABOVE-MErlTI0rlED C IS CAPASLE OF PERFORMIrlG ITS INTENDED SAFETY FUtiCTION UNDER ALL THE APPLICABLE LOADING COMBINATIONS INCLUDING THE POOL DYMANIC LOADS. PREPARED: G.P Chew APPROVED pr.h/dr/n&n- \\ V.J. Brocato l DATE: [/re/f2-l l
t-GRAND GULF NUCLEAR STATION UNIT 1 QUALIFICATION
SUMMARY
1. Equipment Name ECCS Switches. Panel H13-P601 2. Equipment'.No. 'See Attach'ed List 3. Qualification Documentation (Enclosed with this report.) A. Qualification Summary of Equipment (SQRT form), including required response spectra with TRS plotted on RRS graph as appropriate. l i l l B. Reference Documents Reference Document Revision or Title / Subject-Number Identification Date l 1 1981-2 11/20/75, Engineering Test Report 2 2392-10 11/29/78 Engineering Test Report I l i l C. Additional Supporting Documents Document Revision or Title / Subject l Identification Date SQRT Forms 3/27/81 Panel H13-P601 Qualification l e_
QUALIFICATIO!!
SUMMARY
(COMTI!1UED) EQUIPME!1T NO. See Attached 4. Functional Requirements Switches..'are active and are r'equired to remain operable during and after a seismic event. .~ I 5. Demonstration Capability Specimens were subjected to seismic load's greater than required for Grand Gulf installation. Specimens functioned properly throughout testing and showed no signs of damage or deterioration. ~ 6. Rationale for Qualification certification I (Includ'e Decision analysis with comparison to acceptance criteria, l approach for demonstrating operability, and consideration of l high-frequency response.) The switches are located in panel H13-P601 which was tested l seismically to envelop the Grand Gulf RRS. The TRS enveloped the RRS by a large margin resulting in measured accelerations at the panel device locations being excessive. The panel TRS and responses were ratioed down such that the adjusted TRS enveloped the RRS by a factor of two. The resulting adjusted device accelerations are enveloped by the switch test data, indicating the switches satisfactorily meet the Grand Gulf requirements with margin. l i
'l Qualification Surmary of Equipment I{P1antName: Grand Gulf Nuclear Station Unit I Type 1. Utility: Mississioni Power and Light co. PWR 2. NSSS: c.r. 3.' A/E: Bechtel Power Corp. BWR 6, Mark III l II. Component Name _ECCS Switches, Panel H13-P601 (See Attached) 1. Scope: [x] NSSS [ ] BOP 2. Model Number: Series 20K Quantity: 14 3. Vendor: Electroswitch Corp. 4. If the component is a cabinet or panel, name and model No. of the devices included: N/A 5. Physical Description a. Appearance 6 deck switch b. Dimensions 44" L x 2" x 2" c. Weight 14 lbs. 6. Location: Building: Control Room Elevation: 166' 7. Field Mounting Conditions [ ] Bolt (No. , Size } [] Weld (Length ) [X) Panel Mounted 8. a. System in which located: RHR b. Functional
Description:
Manual Start of RHR Pump c. Is the equipment required for [x] Hot Standby [] Cold Shutdod [] Both [] Neither 9. Pertinent Reference Design Specifications: I Prepared by: ef 'l /:'0/81. 12/S0
- ' / 2#/8A Verified by:
2 V III. Is Equipment Available for Inspection in the Plant: [x] Yet [ 3 No IV.EquipmeStQualificationMethod: [x] Test- [ } Analysis [ ] Combination of Test ~ and Analysis Qualification Report *:1 9.8, h L. A q e g n t,_ g f _ A q i g_m.i.c. cLu_a l : _ T e s t s (No., Title and Date) Spri,,qs 10 and Series 20 Switches 11/20/75 l j Corpany that Prepared Report: Electroswitch Corp. Corpany that Reviewed Report:,_N,UTE,CH_ _ _ _ _ __ __ _ Report referenced for resonance search results only. Switch contained 10 decks, whereas Grand Gulf has 6 decks. V. Vibration Input: 1. Loads considered:
- a. [x] Seismic only
- b. [ ] Hydro @namic only
\\ ~ l
- c. [ ] Combination of (a) and (b) 2.
Method of Combir.ing RRS: [ ] Absolute Sum []SRSS []~15tfiiM ipiciTy)~ 3. Required Response Spectra (attach the graphs): 4. Darping Corresponding to RRS: OBE SSE 5. Required Acceleration in Each Direction: [x] ZPA [ ] Other(ipiciTy }-- OBE S/S = F/B = V= SSE S /S =" " " - " - - - F /B - " - "- -- -- " " " V =--- " --~ ~ ~ 6. Were fatigue effects or other vibration loads considered? [ ] Yes [x] No If yes, describe loads considered and how they were treated in overall l qualification program: l
- NOTE:
If more than one report corplete items IV thru VII for each report. 12/B0 t i
'3 VI. .I.f.Q_u_al.i f.i c_at.i.o.n by Te.st.., t.he.n Compl e.t.e= : 3 random 1. [ ] Single frequency [x] Multi-Frequency: [ ]* sine beat [3~~~~~~'-~~~~~~~~~~~~ - 2 [ ] St-ngle Axis ' [x] Multi-Axis 3. No. of Qualification Tests: OBE____.____ SSE_-- ... Other liliiTJ)~~~~~~~ 4. Frequency Range:,,g,g35 nz 5. Natural Frequencies in Each Direction (Side / Side, Front /Back, Vertical): S/S = >35 nz F/B = >35 Hz Y* > }},1DL 6. Method of Determining Natural frequencies [X3 Lab Test . [ ] In-Situ Test [ ] Analysis 7. TRS enveloping RRS using Multi-Frequency Test [ ] Yes (Attach TRS & RRS graphs [ ] No 8. Input g-level Test: OBE S/S = F/B = V= SSE S/S = F/B = V= 9. Laboratory Mounting: 1. [ ] Bolt (No. Size ) [ ] Weld (Length,,,,,,,) [3,,,,,,, 10. Functional operability verified: []Yes [ ] No [ ] Not Applicable
- 11. Test Results including modifications r.ade:,_ _,_ _ _,__ _ _ _,_ _ _ _
- 12. Other test performed (such as aging or fragility test, including results):
- Note:
If qualification by a corbination of test and analysis also co plete item VII. 12/ 80 l t
4 III. Is Equipment Available for Inspection in the Plant: [X] Yet [] No IV.'$quipmeniQualificationMethod: [X] Test [ ] Analysis [ ] Combination of Test and Analysis Qualification Report *:2392..LQa.2M1 IDERaat19A.9f. SeEles 20K (No., Title and Date) Instrument and control Switch,,,,1,l/29/78 Cocpany that Prepared Report:, E,1,e c t ro,sM t c,h,,co r o,.___,_ Cocpany that Reviewed Report:...N.UT.E.C.H.....-................. Specimens had 12 decks, whereas Grand Gulf has 6 decks. V. Vibration Input: 1. Loads considered:
- a. [X] Seismic only
- b. [ ] Hydrodynamic only
- c. [ ] Combination of (a) and (b) 2.
Metho.1 of Cortining RRS: [ ] Absolute Sum [ ] SRSS [X] panel test data '16f.fiiM'spicify]~ 3. Required Response Spectra (attach the graphs):..e.e adjusted panel data S 4. Darping Corresponding to RRS: O B E____. 4.%....... SSE___....4.g.--......._- 5. Required Acceleration in Each Direction: [X] ZPA [ ] Other l (spiciij]-- l OBE S/5 = j g,33,,,,,,,,, F/B = S /S =,,,,j,,4,g, _ _ _,, F /B =,,_ _qq,3g, _ _ _ _ _ V =,_gg, yg_ _ _ SSE , _,gg, g_, _, _ _, _V =,_g4,g_,__ 6. Were fatigae effects or other vibration loads considered? []Yes [X]No If yes, describe loads considered and how they were treated in a,erall qualification program:
- NOTE:
If more than one repert conplete iten:s IV thru VII for each report. 12/50
5 VI. .I.f QJa_lif..ic.at.i.on by Te.s.t, the.n Comple.t.e'.: [ ]*randem 1. [ ] Single Frequency [X3 Multi-Frequency: (3 3sinebeat L ~ ~ " ' " - ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ " ' 2. [ 3 Si'ngle Axis ' [X] Multi-Axis 3. No. of Qualification Tests: OBE... 5..._._SSE___3.....Other 4. Frequency Range: 1 - 100 nz 5. Natural Frequencies in Each Direction (Side / Side, Front /Back, Vertical): S/S = F/B = V= 6. Method of Determining Natural Frequencies Test Report #1981-2 [ ] Lab Test . [ ] In-Situ Test [ 3 Analysis 7. TRS enveloping RRS using Multi-Frequency Test [ ] Yes (Attach TRS & RRS graphs [ ] No 8. Input g-level Test: OBE S/S = 2.5 F/B = 2.5 V= 2.5 SSE S/S = 5.0 F/B = 5.0 V= 5.0 9. Laboratory Mounting: 1. [ ] Bolt (No. Size ) [ ] Weld (Length ) [ 3____ 10. Functional operability verified: [x]Yes [ ] No [ ] Not Applicable
- 11. Test Results including modifications made: soecimens did not chance state due to seismic loads.
No evidence of damace or deterioratior
- 12. Other test performed (such as aging or fragility test. including results):
Er,ior to seismig..... _ Environmental testing y r IEEE 323-1974 r test. Performed satisfactorily.
- Note:
If qualification by a cortination of test and analysis also co plete Item V11. 12/B0
6 l VII. -If C;alification by Analysis then ec plete: NA 1.. Method'of Analysis: [ ] Static Analysis [ ] Equivalent Static Analysis [ ] Dyna.ic Analysis: [ ] Tire-History [ ] Response Spectrum 2. Natural Frbquencies in Each Direction (Sice/ Side Front /Back Vertical): 5/5 - F/B - V.................. 3. Podel Type: [ ] 3D [ ] 2D [ ] 10 [ ] finite Ele ent [ 3 Beam [ ] Closed Fcrm Soluticn 4. [ ] Cc puter Coces: Frequency Range and No. of rodes considered: [ 3 Hand Calculations 5. Method of Conbining Dynamic Responses: [ ] Absolute Sum [ ] SRSS [ ] Other: g 3777;)............. 6. Darp ing: OEE 55E...... Basis for the damping used: 7. Support Ccnsiderations in the rodel: 8. Critical Structural Ele ents: Governing Lead or Respcnse Seismic Tctal Stress A. Ider.tific at i en Location Cc.bination Stress Stress Alloaa:1e 1 Maximum Allo. sable Deflection B. Max. Critical to Assure Functional Opera. ..eflection Location D ...lity bi l l l 12/53}}