ML20050D056
| ML20050D056 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Brunswick  |
| Issue date: | 03/26/1982 |
| From: | Stello V NRC OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR FOR OPERATIONS (EDO) |
| To: | Dircks W NRC OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR FOR OPERATIONS (EDO) |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8204120016 | |
| Download: ML20050D056 (3) | |
Text
i
-V
\\
YAR 2 61982
?7 h g5C2 W Q.
g p. 0 6 99 7 ~O
~
5 MEMORANDUM FOR: William J. Dircks
[f Executive Director for Operations
(
Committee to Review Generic Requirements ('
Victor Stello, Jr., Chairman
)
FROM:
0)
SUBJECT:
MINUTES OF CRGR MEETING NO.10 l
The Committee to Review Generic Requirements met on Wednesday, March 17, 1982 from 1-5 p.m.
Attendance is shown in the Enclosure. The following matters were considered:
1.
Mr. Baer and Mr. Kiessel of IE presented a proposed Circular on Surveillance of Hydraulic Snubbers. The Circular proposed that licensees alter their plan for random sample testing of hydraulic snubbers by biasing the samples toward snubbers installed on systems i
subject to vibration and sudden piping movement such as water hammer. This recommendation was based on snubber failure exper-1ence at the Brunswick-2 facility. The Committee suggested that an Information Notice containing no requirements for licensee action would be more appropriate than a Circular and that the systems having the highest rate of snubber failures should be explicitly identified in the notice.
2.
Mr. Grimsley of ADM briefed the CRGR on the draft Regulatory Analysis Procedures produced by the Task Group appointed by the EDO to review and recommend improvements in NRC's guidelines for performing value-impact analyses. Committee members made the following suggestions to Mr. Grimsley:
(a) There should be a single set of regulatory analysis procedures tnat
'essses the majority, if not all, of NRC's needs for value-impac+. analysis. The procedures should be consistent with the CRGh Charter ultimately approved by the Commission.
(b) The scope and depth of a regulatory analysis for a proposed regulatory action should be proportional to the judged impact of the action, and there should be guidelines for determining l
when an analysis is not required.
(c) The derivation and sources of benefit / cost information and confidence in such information should be included in the regulatory analysis.
(d) The items listed in Appendix A, Checklist for Identifying Potential Impacts on NRC Programs and Activities, should be N
l 8204120016 820326 l
0" PDR REVGP NRCCRGR sunNia..
PDR om>
- anc ronu sis oog Nacu cao OFFiClAL RECORD COPY usom mi-mm
'N ~ ' E William J. Dircks identified as a guide for the staff to use during the develop-ment of a proposed regulatory action. The checklist should not be required to accompany the proposed action.
(e) Appendix B, Procedure for the Early Identification of Potential Impacts, should not be a requirement.
l (f) Appendix E. Guide for Constructing a Summary Table of Regulatory Consequences, should not be required to accompany the proposed action.
(g) Regulatory analyses for alternatives to a proposed regulatory action should not be required.
(h) The methodology and criteria for performing the regulatory analysis needs to be developed and included in or referenced by the draft procedures.
3.
Mr. Rowsome of RES briefed the CRGR on the research programs under way and planned to develop methodology for value-impact assessments.
The Committee noted that it may from time-to-time request research assistance in this area.
Original Signed by V. Stello...
Victor Stello, Jr., Chairman Committee to Review Generic Requirements
Enclosure:
List of Attendees cc: CRGR Members Office Directors G. Cummingham, ELD Connission (5)
R. Baer, IE D. Grimsley, ADM F. Rowsome, RES Distribution:
VStello TEMurley WSchwink DEDR0GR cf Central File PDR(NRG/CRGR) omer>..D
/D.....QEDR0GR.....
sua-e >
...... u,r,1,,ey,t,9,,,y,s,,te,1,1,g,,,,,,,
b
. 3/..WD.R........
. 3./...../.H.2,,,,,
om>
unc ronu sis oo-so) Nacu oua OFFICIAL RECORD COPY usam i,,wm
CRGR MEETING #10 ATTENDANCE CRGR MEMBERS Don Mausshardt Joe Scinto R.A. Purple (for Darrell Eisenhut)
J. Heltemes Ed Jordan R. Bernero V. Stello, Jr.
Others Walt Schwink, DEDROGR Tom Murley, DEDR0GR Dan Guzy, RES Bob Erikson, NMSS Ed Blackwood, DEDR0GR Mat Taylor', DEDROGR Steve Stern, NRR Tom Cox, DEDR0GR Robert Baer, IE Horace Shaw, NRR Richard J. Kiessel, IE
- W. Minners John Austin, OED0 Joe Felton, DRR John Philips, DRR F.X. Cameron, RES M. Messier, AEAB Daniel R. Muller, NRR F.H. Rowsome, RES A. DiPalo, RES G.K. Tomlin, RES e
4 9
-