ML20045A650

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
PG&E Response to Miscellaneous Requests for Production of Documents Filed by San Luis Obispo Mothers for Peace.* W/Certificate of Svc.Related Correspondence
ML20045A650
Person / Time
Site: Diablo Canyon  Pacific Gas & Electric icon.png
Issue date: 05/26/1993
From: Warner C
PACIFIC GAS & ELECTRIC CO., WINSTON & STRAWN
To:
Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel
References
CON-#293-14003 OLA-2, NUDOCS 9306110158
Download: ML20045A650 (15)
v • d • e


Text

e ,

' / OO RELATED CORRESPONDENCE May 26, 1993 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA ' '

NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of: )

) Docket Nos. 50-275-OLA Pacific Gas and Electric Company ) 50-323-OLA ) (Construction Period (Diablo Canyon Nuclear Power ) Recovery)

Plant, Units 1 and 2) )

)

PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY'S RESPONSE TO MISCELLANEOUS REQUESTS FOR THE PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS FILED BY SAN LUIS OBISPO MOTHERS FOR PEACE Pacific Gas and Electric Company ("PG&E") herein responds to several miscellaneous requests for the production of documents dated May 6, 12 and 17, 1993 ("MFP's Miscellaneous Document Requests"). Copies of these miscellaneous requests are included as Attachment 1. In accordance with the agreement entered into by PG&E and MFP concerning the scope of discovery at the May 12, 1993, prehearing conference, this response includes answers and objections in accordance with 10 C.F.R. SS 2.740(b) and 2.741(d) and addresses MFP's Miscellaneous Document Requests in full.

Because of the volume of documents involved, documents identified in Attachment 2 are being made available to the representatives of the San Luis Obispo Mothers for Peace ("MFP") for review and copying at the Diablo Canyon Power Plant (DCPP).

J]

v

< c, 9306110158 930526 {)

PDR ADOCK 05000275 G PDR J

o

, GENERAL OBJECTION MFP have requested miscellaneous documents such as Nonconformance Reports (NCRs), Action Requests (ARs), operability evaluations (OEs), submittals to the NRC, sections of the DCPP FSAR, NRC information notices, and other similar documents. To the extent various of these documents are unrelate'd to maintenance and surveillance (such as NCRs and ARs which do not actually or potentially involve maintenance or surveillance-related deficiencies as their root or contributory cause, or such as OEs which by definition review plant operability, not maintensrce issues), PG&E objects to the requests as overbroad and not within the scope of Contention I as admitted in this proceeding. Other requested documents are available in the San Luis Obispo Public Document Room, such as PG&E submittals to the NRC and sections of the DCPP FSAR. S_qq 10 C.F.R. S 2.740(b) (1); see also Discovery and Scheduling Order, at 3. PG&E also objects to the request for INPO SOER 26-89 as unrelated to maintenance and for the same reasons cited in Answer to Request 13 in PG&E's Response (dated April 12, 1993) to Second Set of Written Interrogatories and Requests for

///

///

///

///

///

///

1 l

t . . , - -

e the Production of Documents Filed by San Luis Obispo Mothers for

. Peace.

Respectfully submitted, Joseph B. Knotts, Jr.

David A. Repka Kathryn M. Kalowsky WINSTON & STRAWN 1400 L Street, N.W.

Washington, DC 20005-3502 (202) 371-5726

& '( ' 'l O

Christopher / J . Watpfer Richard F. Locke PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY 77 Beale Street San Francisco, CA 94106 Attorneys for Pacific Gas and Electric Company Dated in San Francisco, CA this 26th day of May, 1993

. 1

i ATTACHMENT 1 MISCELLANEOUS DOCUMENT REQUESTS List Provided by Rochelle Becker at May 6, 1993 Plant Visit

1. RCS Cooldown/ A024578
2. CFCUs

--A0283507

--OE 92-20 (rev.1)

--NPAP C-29 (rev.1)  ;

3. Seismic

--A0288854

--AP C-10S1

--AC-12 -

--AC-29

--A0279568

4. CRVS

--A0283432

--FSAR Chap.II & IV

--OE-91-13

--OE-92-02

--OE-92-05

5. MOV Thrust Valves

--A0276504 --A0281232

--A0279073 --A0278268

--A0279161 --A0281550

--A0278260 --A0281645

--A0279186 --A0175420

--A0269028

--NPAP C-12

--QAP 15-A

6. 4 kV

--A0283880

7. Monorail Hoists

--A0286084 --A0283112 '

--A0235119 --A0282333

--A0224865 --A0286084

--A0253845

--Work orders C0098579, R0085966

8. CVCS

--A0281716

--OE-92-02

9. Feedwater & Isolation Valve

--LAR 90-14

--DC2-92-TN-N015

--A0250944

10. Diesel Gen.

--A0276639

11. RMR

--A0267055

--INPO SOER 26-89

--NECS E.3.2

--DCM S-10 (rev.0)

  • 9 w

o

12. Control Board Cracking

--A0272474

13. Brvsker Valve Failure

--DC2-87-EM-N043

14. Operating Resources

--A0277002

--A0243843

15. AK Circuit Breakers

--A0261448

16. Inappropriate Tech Specs

--A0258050

17. Steam /Feedwater

--FSAR

--A0262835

18. Accumulator Nozzle

--A0259794 *

--NRC IN 91-05

19. Containment Airlocks

--A0262487

--A0263075

20. SI Pump

--DC1-87-OP-N071

--OI 89-14

21. All OSRG Open Items Beginning 1987
22. Minutes from EIT 1990-93
23. TRGs 1991-1993
24. JCOs 1991-93
25. PG&E Letters91-293, 91-313,91-314
26. OEs --92-02 RO-CK Valve

--92-01 RO-CFCU

--91-15 R2-CCW

27. LAR 92-01 Accumulators
28. STP M-91
29. AP C-12 Reclassify Equipment Important to Safety
30. Emergency Service & Safety Sury. Dept. Corres. 1991-93
31. Tech. Spec 3.7.9.4 Fire Watch Additional Plant Procedures C-40S2 PD TSi 1993 NCRs Related to Maintenance OSRG Annual and Ouarterly Reports 1990-93 Related to Maintenance Additional 1990-1992 Maintenance NCRs and Related Earlier NCRs

[See attached Mothers for Peace facsimile list dated 5/17/93].

gy 5-!7-13 pay ( fu .g)  ;

, 773-727, cc: RFLocke '

EMGreene

.4JWarner FROM: R o cl elle B a c.f e , '**""'

b +), e n {, r faare A &as. . <

V IA ', Jana 3 wo >a, A1 F F '

FA7 f' dos.)S95-7229 PL,,a f<o 05) s 9 3 ,2 gog ,

R E '. O, , , , ,

0 t

o m.sma m u4 O b Md .L.

L. .

I I

5

, - - , +....n-- , . - . - - . , , .n ,. , ,

~

h 1 *

'I cas ur

- - 1 -

- f,e ref. In NCR ree'd-NCR Dco-89-TN-015 .

1 9 9 0 N C R's DCl-90-TI-007 dr h .

DCl-89-TI-I 12 (ref.DC'0-89-RC-062 .

DC2 90-TN-015

  • DCO-90-MM-032 .

DCO-90-MM-022 .

DCO-90-EN-002 DC2-90-WP-004 .-

DCl-90-TC 008

  • DCO-90-MM-013 .

DC2-90 EM-014 DC2-90 EM-017 DCl-90-TN-018 '

DCO 90-TN-019 DCO-90-MM 022 '

DCl-90-TC 008 ,

DCl-90-0P 011

, DC2-90-T1-010 ,

DCl-90-TN-038 DCO-90-EN-014 .

DCO 90-TN-02I .

. DC0-90-TN-027 .

DC2-90-OP-037 ( ref.DC2-90-OP-039 same event)

DC2-90-TN-015 .

DCl-90-TN-038

  • DC2 90 TI-039 DCO-90-SC-001 DCl-90-NS-003 DCO 90-EN-008 DCO 90 TN N019 . ,

DCO-90-RC-024 '

DCO-90-TC-033 -

DCl-90-OP-036 -

DCl-90-TN-041

  • DC2-90-TI-037 -

~

DC2-90-OP-039 DCl-90-0P-045 DC2-90-EM-043 DCO-90-EM-026 (similar event DC2-86-TI-100) ,

DCl-90 EM 049 DCl-90 MM-051 4

m..

DCl-90 TI-052 DCO-90-EN-001 DCl-90-TI-010 -

DCl-90-NS-003 DC0 90-TN-060 DCO 90 TI-058 &D59 DCO-90 TN-062 -

DCl-90-CE 072

  • DCO-90-EN-022 DCO-90-OP-061 (ref.NCR DCO 88-TN-038 DCO-89-TN 015.DCO-89-RC-074, DCO 89-TN-081 DCl-90-MM 002 AND DCO-90-TN 019 .)

DC2-90-TI-076 DCl-90-TC-075 1 9 9 1 N C R's DCO-90-TN-077 DC0-90-QA-004 DCO-90-T1-091 DC2-90-TN-047 DCl-90-MM-035 DCO-9 l-EM-009(ref. DCO-89 -TN-015, DCO-89 -TN-081 DC0-90-TC-067 .

DCO-90-SS-079 fref.DCO-89-SS-023) .

DC2-90-MM-050 DCO-90-TN-054 S DC2-90-MM-064 DCl-90-MM-086 DCl-90-MM-087 . '

DC0-90-TN-088 .

DCl-91-TN-032 DCl-91-T1-045 .

DCl-91-TI-047 (ref DCl-91-OP-035)

DCl-9 l-TI-046 DC2-91-TI-008 '

DC0-90-TN-084 k DCO-91-TN-020 '

DC2-90-TN-015 ,

DC0-91-EM-005 ~

DC2-91-TI-062 DC2-91-0P-074 -

DCl-91-NR-033 DC0 91-TC 080

  • DCl-91-SS-081 ,

I i

1 en e

~

DC2-91-TN-087 DCl-91-OP-082 DC2-91-OP-089 ,

DCl-91-OP-083

  • DCl-91-TC-098 DCO-91-EM-009 DCl-91-MM-0 ! !

DCl-91-TN-035 .

DCl-91-TN-048 -we have DCO-91-TN-048 DCl-9 l-TN-051 '

DCO-91-TN-065 DCO-9 l-MM-078 -

. 1992 NCR's DCl-9 l-CE-001 DCO-92-EM-014 (rer.DCl-91-TN-032)

DCl-92-TN-005 DC2-92-TN-002

  • DC2-92-TN-102 DC2-91 -TN-075 .

DCO-92-SS 006 DC0-91-EN-030 DC2-92-TI-009 DC0-92 TN-008 DC0-91-DC-104 DC2-92-TN-O l i DCl-92-EM-010 DCO-92 SS 006 DCl-92 OP 019 DCl-91-MM-028 k DCl-91-TN-032 DC2-91-TN-087 DCO-92-SS-006 DCl-92-OP-019 - -

DC2-92-TI-016 i

  • ~

DC2-92-TN-015 . .

DC2-91-EM-095 (ref.DC2-87-EM-043) ,

DC2-92-MM-013 DCO-9l-EN-030 DCO-92-EN-01I .

DC2-9 l-TN-087

.tCO-92 EN-014 DCl-92-0P-030 DCO-92-Til-038 (ref. DCl-87-OP-071)

DCO 91-EN-028

, e a

DCO 92-EM-014 ,

DC2-52-M M-031 DCl-92-TP-044 CO-92-TN-008 .

DC2-92-TN-028 DCl-92-TI-042 - -

DCO-92-MM-034 .

4 e

4 e

e e

e O

e I

i l

e e e 4

e

+ .

a 6

e

ATTACHMENT 2

, MISCELLANEOUS DOCUMENTS TO DE PRODUCED List Provided by Rochelle Becker at May 6, 1993 Plant Visit (Note: This list is solely a list of items in which maintenance activities are mentioned or involved; these items do not necessarily involve events in which maintenance was deficient or was the root cause or contributory cause.]

RCS Cooldown/ A024578_ [ Unable to determine because incomplete reference)

MOV Thrust

--A0276504 --A0281232

--A0279073 --A0278268

--A0279161 --A0281550

--A0278260 --A0281645 l --A0279186 --A0175420

) --A0269028

--NPAP C-12

' --QAP 15-A j i

_..A0283880 Monorail Hoists

--Work orders C0098579, R0085966 Control Board Cracking

--A0272474 MOV 8805B

--A0243843 AK Circuit Breakers f --A0261448 Accumulator Nozzle

--A0259794 Containment Airlocks

--A0262487

--A0263075 STP M-91 Additional Plant Procedures l l

C-40S2 PD TS1

1993 NCRs

, [ Note: This list is solely a list of NCRs in which maintenance activities are mentioned or involved; these NCRs do not necessarily involve events in which maintenance was deficient or was the root cause or contributory :ause to the nonconformance. ]

DC1-93-EM-N019 Unit 1 4kV RHF Hinged Panel DCl-93-EM-N010 CWP 1-1 and CWP 1-2 Cable Failures DC2-93-EM-N014 AFW PP 21 Steam Supply, 2-FCV-37, Failure to Close DCO-93-MM-N002 Control of M&TE DC2-93-MM-N012 Loss of Unit 2 Auxiliary Building Ventilation System DC1-93-OP-N024 [No Title]

DC0-93-QA-N003 DCPP/TES M&TE Interface DCO-93-SS-N007 Water Discovered in CO2 Line K2-4540-3" DCO-93-TN-N006 DCM Surveillance / Maintenance Requirements DCO-93-TN-N011 Potential Missed NRC Commitment DCl-93-TP-N021 STP I-33A Exceeded Time Limit DC2-93-TS-N005 CCW-2-RCV-16 Missed Alert Frequency DC2-93-WP-N025 Corrective Maint, on PI-178 Without PMT Prior to Mode Transition Additional 1990-1992 Maintenance NCRs

[ Note: This list is solely a list of NCRs in which maintenance activities are mentioned or involved; these NCRs do not necessarily involve events in which maintenance was deficient or was the root cause or contributory cause to the nonconformance.]

DC2-90-TI-NO39 DCl-90-OP-N083 DCO-91-EM-N009 DCO-91-EM-N046 DC2-91-TN-N087 DC2-91-EM-N095 DC1-90-TI-N007

-- - w

DC3-90-T1-N010 DCO-90-MM-N013 DC1-91-TI-N045 DCl-91-TI-N047 DC2-91-TI-N062 .

DC2-92-TI-N009 DCl-92-EM-N010 DC2-92-TN-N011 DCO-92-EM-N014 DC2-92-TN-N028 DC2-92-MM-NO31 F

REtisTED CORRESPONDENCE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD

'93 JU" -1 PR :10 In the Matter of: )

) Docket Nos. 50-275-OLA Pacific Gas and Electric Company ) , 50-323-OLA

) (Construction Period (Diablo Canyon Power ) Recapture)

Plant, Units 1 and 2) )

) ,

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that copies of " PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY'S RESPONSE TO MISCELLANEOUS REQUESTS FOR THE PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS FILED BY SAN LUIS OBISPO MOTHERS FOR PEACE" in the above-captioned proceeding have been served on the following by deposit in the United States mail, first class, or as indicated by an asterisk (*), by Federal Express overnight delivery, this 26th day of May, 1993. Copies of documents being provided, as referenced in the discovery response, are being provided only to parties indicated by the (t) symbol.

Charles Bechhoefer, Chairman Frederick J. Shon Administrative Judge Administrative Judge Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Atomic Safety and Licensing Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 Washington, DC 20555 Jerry R. Kline Office of Commission Appellate Administrative Judge Adjudication Atomic Safety and Licensing Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 Washington, DC 20555 Office of the Secretary Ann P. Hodgdon, Esq.(t)

U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Office of the General Counsel Washington, DC 20555 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 1 Attn: Docketing and Service Washington, DC 20555  !

Section l (original + two copies) l 1

Adjudicatory File Peter Arth, Jr. l Atomic Safety and Licensing Edward W. O'Neill l Board Panel Peter G. Fairchild j U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission California Public Utilities Washington, DC 20555 Commission 505 Van Ness Avenue San Francisco, CA 94102 I

Nancy Culver, President Truman Burns Board of Directors California Public Utilities

. San Luis Obispo Mothers for Peace Commission P.O. Box 164 505 Van Ness, Rm. 4103 Pismo Beach, CA 93448 San Francisco, CA 94102 Robert R. Wellington, Esq. Joseph B. Knotts, Jr., Esq.

Diablo Canyon Independent Safety David A. Repka, Esq.

Committee Winston & Strawn 857 Cass Street, Suite D 1400 L Street, N.W.

Monterey, CA 93940 Washington, DC 20005-3502 Robert Kinosian Jill ZamEk*

California Public Utilities 1123 Flora Road Commission Arroyo Grande, CA 93420 505 Van Ness, Rm. 4102 San Francisco, CA 94102 Mr. Gregory Minor *(t)

MHB Technical Associates 1723 Hamilton Ave., Suite K San Jose, CA 95125

/ VvV %

Christoph6r J. (Harner Counsel for Pacific Gas and Electric Company i

I i

~

,

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20045A650&oldid=2557669"