ML20043C385

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Final Response to FOIA Request.App a Documents Encl & Available in Pdr.Documents Listed in App B Withheld in Entirety (Ref FOIA Exemption 5)
ML20043C385
Person / Time
Issue date: 03/30/1990
From: Philips J
NRC OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATION (ADM)
To: Frownfelter D
TEXAS, STATE OF
Shared Package
ML20043C386 List:
References
FOIA-89-513 NUDOCS 9006050131
Download: ML20043C385 (4)


Text

I' U.S. NUCtLA[CLGULA10PY COMMi&&lONW eo.Lu o n swu n6 FOIA - fa.o, ray f

, -1

/

-@4

,u,m

,\\

(

1 RESPONSE TO FREEDOM OF lJu"u

. '*u INFORMATION ACT (FOIA) REQUEST

...../

._ta.o wsu, u,, n...,

MR30 W aeou uta k.

k ~ A/Rti.-Aci G.$ [M' '&

RtcogR Lt Asto oR Not tocAtto <se, enecica ee.e.,

u..',.nc,.u......t.,.o i. E,..

i h... t..a im.i.e

w...o ie.i.e.x,.......t,.n i, i,... n... t..n ix.i.e l

n..

.i.e,uie.......a.u.ih,.,#.neh. peu.can,4.vi.n

....m s.. comer,.s.ci.on A..nc,..c o.u. o,.o ie, ib.... not...

.ni.t.o e A rt. o

>.o _

....i... s.... c.u. i., su.c

.n.,.. o..n.ne...,, m Nae e u.. Docom.ni aoo,n tiro i sv..i. N W W uhrsion x 20$55 Ap

.C nt '8 0 n A De r. we., one.. ~. e oi A n me'. I.e g m.6....d.bl. for put lic e.p.tten.66 geg ya g in t ki.^d I '.. I n

n uac.nf. 8.t 0 6..uty.t t to th.

  • ..w..t l'.

1 er.cou< Ox m.ni Rc. airo t si.. N w. W..he..

g o

.n,.... n., n.m.

1h.n...,.................,,.........,.u.........r..............m*~.,m..,.,,..n,.,t.n,m............

ee.p.Cten ed C &r.eg.t th. 6,RC PvW4 DDf wm.nt Room P1lo t $t.nt, N W. WHhengton DC, en. 8160 u d.14 80ia numt4e ed ecoweite, t e*4 0

n Ap.nt, t t..C..st s.El 10 th e Qv.t 19 1... op.htet.d on A +.nO s '..i _

--.m.y t ee.g (it$ end t op..c.t t,. NRC t ot.',wtdat DOC omentApom sd. nt d t

en th. Comm.' t. $.Chon Ence.$.e6 e. m'o.m. tion on how vow arev ett.m.tc... le.no tt, ch. pe. for e oreng en o.c. pl.ces in the hhC Pvt 64 Doc waint m om. 2170 4 5t..et NW, o

W.Mglon DC

{

Ae.nc,eno.e. t.,.o ioib

....ni... non.e F nu..e. sty.o i. i.....,ni h... ter..'e..a i. nch., r e e...i.eene vi...i v,, r...no e.o ennr. i.,..

yow will t4 tbh.g by the NRC f os f... tot l ng 8.,

,n...... N. c......,.,m...... n...... u,...

m.... n....,,,......

4.

PART k A-IN80RMAtlON WitHHttD f ROM PUBttC DISCtOSURE

c.,...ei.. m.i. n.n is..... c... :.. n.. w.n.

. e. ee o r su<., i~. ~...n o. ~... mci.r..n c. +..m.ne... i... nr. u.i......o.

f l'. O N v".mi. 8 a h< h Onl, $..I Of the..C O.d '. t.*g m @* 00... ti.ing m.Se.* F.t>4 to p,td< r.pu t on eg Xg..Clion.$Ce6DAA.

v 4 H.d 901@^. O 0

.ppng en th. NRC Pyldet Document Repm 2120 t $1...t. N W. W..hangton, DC in.10100 once. tN f Qi A n mtO e6...unto e.m.

u covutwts y-g g'

"l g

~

//

4 l

l 4bb sicNAtQtfRICtoR. BMsioN or FR4ooM oglNFORMATION AND PUBUCAT60N$ SERVtCES

~

l 1

9006050131 900330 PDR FOIA l

FROWNFEB9-513 PDR l

FOIA - P9. sy3 DATiMAR 3 0 1990 FREEDOM OF INFORMAT60N ACT RESPONSE r oia NuMar n:sl PART U B-APPLICASLE EX(MPTIONS Records subsect to the reovest that are descrit,ed on the enclosed Appendistes) _

_are bemo withheld in their entirety or in part under the taemptions and for the reasons iet forth below pursuant to 6 U $.C 552(b) and 10 Cf R 9.17(a) of NRC Regulations.

1. Yte withhold information is property classified pur6uent to (secutive Ordec ([X(MPTION Il
2. The withreid enformaten relates soiety to os intemet personnet rules and procedures of NRC. 4(XEMPTION 21
3. The withtold anformation is specificetty exempted from public disclosure by statute indicated if XtMPTION 31 sections 141146 of the Atomic Erergy Act which proNbits the d'sclosure of Restncied Data or Fcumerly Restncted Data f42 U $ C 210121666 Section 147 of the Atomac Energy Act which prohibits the desciosure of Unclassified Sa4 guards information 142 U S C tion
4. The withheld information e a trade secret or commercial oe fmancial enformation that is bomp withheid for the reason (s) indicated. ftXLMPTION 41 The information as considered to b6 tonfidential business (propretary) mformation The information 6e considered to be propnetary mie,rmation pursuant la 10 Cf A 2.790ddHit The information was submitted and received in confidence pursuani

.U CFR 2 790(dH2p 0

[

6. The withheid mformation consists of enteragency or miraegency records that are not available through oiscovery dunng litigsten IthtMPTION 61 Apphcabie Privilege Dehberative Process. Disclosure of predecisionalinformation would tend to inhibit the open and frank eschange of ideas essential to the dehberative process Where records are withheld m their entuely, the f acts are mestncably entertwmed with the piedecisional mformation There also are no reator ably so,pregabie factual X

portions twause the release of the f acts would permit en mdirect enouiry mto the predecisionet process of the agency Attorney woe product privilege (Documente prepaied by an ettorney in contemplation of htigaten 6 Attorney - chent pnvinege tConhdential communicatmns between an aHoenew innd his her chent t

6. The withheid mformation is enempted from public disclosure because its disclosure would result in a clearly unmanented evasen of personal povecy. ItXEMPTION 61
7. The withheid informaten consiste of records compileu toe low enforcement purposes and is being withheld for the reasontsi 6ndicated <txtMPTION h Doctosure could reasonabty be espected to mterfere with an enforcement proceedmg because it could reveat the scope. direction. and focus of on-forcement efforts. and thus could possibly allow them to ta6 e action to sheid potential wrongrlomg or a velation of NRC reowrements from investigators IkiMPttON 7 (AH Disclosure would constitute en unwarranted invasion of personal pnvecy 1[1[MPTION 7lCil The informahto consists of names of mdividue,Is and other mic,rmaten the d4 closure of mNt.h could reasonabst be espected to revealidentities of confidential sources it At MPTION 7 (Du 01hlR PART N. C-DENYING OFFICIALS Pursuant to 10 CFR 9 26tbl and'or 9 25 tc) of the U $ Nuclear Regulatory Commissen reguistions it has been determmed that the information withheld is enempt from production or disclosure. and that its production or doctosure is contrary to the public inteselit The persons responsible for the peniel are those of ficials identified belon es denying of ficials and the Duettor. Division 01 f reedom of information and Pubucations Services Of fice of Administraten and Resources Management. for any demets that may be appepled to the (secutive Deector toe Operations (t 001 DENYING OFFICIAL TITLLIOf flC(

RECOROS OtNIED APP (LLATE OFFICIAL SECRETARY 1D0 A

6a PART N. D-APPEAL RfGHTS The deniel by each denying officialidentifed m Part il C may be oppea6ed to the Appellate Official 4dentifed m that secten. Any such appeal must be m wettog and muet to med, withm 30 days of receipt of tNs response Apposts must be eddressed as appropnate to the Esecutive Director for Operatens of to the $6Cretary of the Commission, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission. Washington, DC 20666, and should cleerty state on the enveiope and en the letter that et is an " Appeat from en initial FOIA Decision."

2 RC rORM 464 (Pert U U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION tt t sel FOIA RESPONSE CONTINUATION

I i

Ret POIA-89-513 L

I APPENDII A RECORDS MAINTAINED IN THE PDR UNDER THE.ABOVE REQUEST NUMBER l

NUMBER DATE DESCRIPTION 1.

1/29/88 Letter to Commissioner Kenneth M. Carr from Lawrence R. Jacobi regarding meeting,

)

(1 pg.).

2.

8/25/88 Letter to State Liaison Officers from Carlton Kammerer regarding Low-Level Radioactive Waste Policy Amendment Act, (1 pg.) with enclosures, (4 pgs. ),

3.

2/21/89 Letter to All Agreement and Non-Agreement States regarding Governor's Certification, (1 pg.) with enclosures, (15 pgs.).

4.

8/9/89 Letter to State Liaison Officers from Robert Bernero regarding Governor's certification (2 pgs.), with enclosures, (11 pgs.).

5.

12/12/89 Letter to Honorable Kenneth M.

Carr from William P. Clements regarding Governor's Certification, (2 pgs. ) with attachment, (8 pgs.).

Ret FOIA-89-513 i

APPENDIE B DOCUMENTS BEING WITHHELD IN THEIR ENTIRETY NUMBER DATE DESCRIPTION

)

1.

12/20/87 Note to George Felgate from Gary Sanborn, regarding Commissioner Carr's January 28, 1988, meeting with Texas officials, (2 pgs.).

EXEMPTION 5.

1 2,

2/4/88 Trip Report by George Felgate regarding Texas official's trip to Comanche Peak, January 26-29, 1988, (3 pgs.). - EXEMPTION 5.