ML20041F963
| ML20041F963 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Palisades  |
| Issue date: | 03/12/1982 |
| From: | Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| To: | |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20041F958 | List: |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8203170595 | |
| Download: ML20041F963 (3) | |
Text
.._ -,
.e,6+
- m.<
f
. C, 4.!f.'!TED 5T ATES
,(
3.
tiUCLEAR REGULATORY COMM10SION e
i.
."d i e
- . 4 %"",,f E
M.SHINGT ON. D. C. 20555
- c. 4 %. *.s !, !
. ~. d
.-......e SAFETY EVALUATION BY THE OFFICE OF NUCLEAR REACTOR T<EGULATION o
SUPPORTING. AMENDMENT NO. 6o TO PROVISIONAL OPERATING LICENSE NO. 20 CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY PALISADES PLANT r
. s r
n0r.Lr. 4 f 0. :. n..S e e s
1 I
e r
.(
Ey E iE!:Er dEteC Sep; Ester 2,19El, Consumers ;ovEr Co pany (the licensee)
.... a..
-....<,3,.
e., 3, <. < 2.
.. e.., e t..,s 7..,,,'. tc PreviSicnii OperatinC LiCer,se No. DPP-20 for the FElisaces FiEn!.
Tne prC;Cr ed ChEnces invcive revision of the inservice Surveili' Ente
.E;UirE'*Ents.,Cr Ir,ULg.ers.
.ne licenSte,E recue51. 5 in cirECT re5;Cn$e r.
C Ine NRC stEf f's letter dated March 23,19El.
- c. n.
- , C h e r.,,e,,.,. n -
r v :.
t.
To reflect eCCumulEteC experience obtlinec from operatinC plants in the pest severEl yeErs, NRC issued Revision 1 of the Standard I
Ie t '.n i C E ' 5?tCiSiCatiCni C*n thE EurveillEnCE reCUi"e e"l11 for EEfEty-2 s.,
._e,....,
.,..E
..c.
cc.,
.6,
...,..c...
e
.. E. c.. e,.
wg..
.w.
10 CCETE!*,nc LIER.tE E Y.C..;C i r. ; t h0i e U S C e t SE~ LICn* Witn E reCuelt i
n ;. g.,, g,
e.n..
c.e e
- 2. 7.,..,.. g. 5 a,..
z c
, p
- 4..., j.
....C.
9 L..
..e r C.t
+
. so.
E e,..e
}.
t.
.. g s.,.
.g.
.e
...r.
...L.
s:.
-:.c..
71g
,. g e.. a. e g - g.
- r.
g e
.g g
{
a f._,.a gg'# {
w a : ' : ' '., =.
a
- t. s o.. e.
....i. t. e.
e.
.. a...,=.
. c.
- t.....cee.
i
-e.p
....-e
....y. it n. g
. h..
- g. g
$p
_. ph' pp E3 g :
-a..
.bg. g C.. b I g.p.*
.p..e.
a 9
pk..w.O*Cv I p-8 $
O
{
<a v
5 ?e r.i fi C E
- i C ';5 fCT cCert. tint reECIOr piEnts, HowEver, 5everal CefiCiencies ve t " E 'Te"*d#iE" 8; f
- e r t* e Cri ci nEl r e C ui"E E"it! WE"e in fCTCe f r C
r.
..c
.. ~, t g.
..c:
- 'ge**gr
- r1 A. r :o. c-r.. i v.c
,, z
.,.. ~ c.
- c..
~g
$.z..
.e...c.
..e..,
e e.
n..
c.
- c.
eE..: e g - g e..
f
.C.
1 b.
,kb El[rC VE i WEE rieCE5 Eery fCr **De ECT Ct f SEEI mEtEriEls.
r-4 l'
C.
391ervice test recuirenents werE n0t s
.Er
' ned, f
k 4
[ l : =.,
In-; ECE inte*Vice IEitint v. E ! PCI
- E r~'i !!E d.
E.
g 0203170595 020312 PDR ADOCK 05000255 P
1 s
s c
3.0 EVALW, TION Since mechanical snubbers were not subj.ect to any surveillance require-ments, some licensees and permit holders relievec that mechanical snubbers were preferreo by W.C.
Many plants used mechanical snubbers as cricinal ecuipment and many others-recuested to replace their-hycraulic snubbers
.with mechanical enes c simplify er avoic ar, inservice surveillance
- .. c....... ' e.. :.
..,.a...-
- -. we.
e..C...
s.,s.
.a.
w a...
an unsurveVed i*tenanical snucDer, :ne s: likely fail Fe if D e **~d".e n'.
.<*...g e.
C a E...~.. ). e.
..:. e :..e '. e. - s..:.
~~s)
.n.y.
,:s.e
~
C..
. +.
..g...<..g..
-r.
..e, e r. g e.
J.c /
- s. c /.:, b. ie u o.a. e.1.s.
m>.s a y! :
e g
a
.n 4..
- n.. : - -
C
.e....+ g,
o
.w.
u..ar s
c...
g.
..,3.,.e re.-
,...,..<. n h.
.,.e - w. 3,. 31 c p e. c. 3ca.3e.e w..e c.g 4.e,
. i w.........
a cc..p
..s,.
wa.e.
a.e.,. n..;....e..a..e.:nc c:..e, +,..e
. o.~-.., e w:...
.o
.o hit i.e k
E"s a. +m' -he r a.c. e c a'.s.. i..v c. n a.. ~.c.
- ar. 50,000 1."s.
e s
.e.
......:,.,...,n..,,...
C.. g :. 3 C. L, z.,, m....:.
..e
.,e.
e..:-.,.n.
.n(.n.g
.e r..
.a
..r
. c
.c.....
m J
seme parameters at :ne sn=ber ratec icac.
Since. hen, c.reater ec.cie-
. men capacity anc te::er uncerstandinc cf parame ric ccrrelation botn cevestpec.
a c mm,ntain :r.is arbitrary -D,000 lb.1.1mit coulc mean ari unnecessary compromise en plant safe v.
l The cricinal nycraulic snubber nroblem started from leakinc seals.
n.-
{ S.J) (
f1.. Wi *.f.e *.* 3.d
- h c.
- e. C. * ) *. 3
- A. *. E. g ).e ' [ #.
- ., g ).C 7. *n E
- A y. e
- C *y.
M. **. e *
. C 4
..,M. y i.,t
...., y., n. gi.
w..
g, e. i. (..
.g e... g
..JJ..
4.. C,.. C...,.
g..
..; g
. g, ;,. s.... g C..
> b s. z. e.r V. s.
.c e e.\\,1' e
1, :i. e :. C.
.. e.g.c.Ii 1. e.. C. p p,. I b.
, 2. :. g y C
g ec.
. e c.
4 4...
. 1 6 ia u.
3 a.
.. e e.. :. ~.... ; g e.....,. g. : g '1
- a. e g e e. C ).z..
7.
n
.' e....
e :. S e n.. C
.-g
.g y *~* 3 *.........c.
...r. g e.J..:
. c.
- a.
. t a..a
- 4..
- k c.
..e..e:
t it
.v
....,,j.e
.g
..g
.a
.b
.Y C'..
C.
C--
.y.
- R
..,p....t.
-.~.h O.[.*O 7
C.80 F.
Q
[9..
6.C-
..t O.
r...
g...
....O
- .e
4.t.
0...
1
.a.:
. ;..
- O O
l t.......
.O
.t
....g, C;.
.O
'O.
.... *.,g.
.,T
-C.O...-...
...e
..e
. i...
- 4..e..., 3. g.,.
.c g 5
- . g. J..
- c.
. e.
....4
....(.r..g
., C..c C
..,.y i.f C.
l B m. _ c e.. a. ; e,. C - e. o....
.o.. e. < C
.rc. c C. 'l '. C.. v e..e #. rs c. '.
<r 46.
. t -
i i
l
.4 c
g.-:.......,q
.c...-g.i,e rg...:,g g..c.
ge.g..........e..-.,....,-c
.,.g
.e.
(
- .-g 2.
.m*... ;.
.t
...... ?
r :..C
.O.
~
(*
- 4
.--.,s.g
....e..'.1
[*
i e' r_. g e. e...*r J..
- r
. e. 4. g.. I.1
, ;.c
- e.. g :..e
...*(.
, [.
- [(*[O
'D*
- O. O
- O P. *(
.F' (P. EPh.
. C.( [..(
( P. *
- g P
- O[( ()
.*.**P*
.PO. -...
[
F.
F V
C.f.*,...O...L f f...t.
- e..
+
(
f **
W f.
Y{..%*.V
= t,
( " '. *. *
- c. #..c
- r*..
.-- -.. i.e..e
- e ". *,i '. e-.~.'.' *.*:
~
...iy.
-. t.e. e... -. e..e...-:<c
..c
.c.
.a...
..g g.
C. $ t. s. e e
- e. i e v e.
... g.' e.
s.e.r :'):.e
- e. r c :6. :
e, g
~..~... :. e
.iy syg g.~ r. 6 g.. e6.
4. ; y t.g
... 6
...f
.t.
..3
..g egg e g... i. e. e.
.e. g.
- e..o y..
- 7.,c. a. r.,.., **4.;
- c.=.
- k. g ym* v. 's4. f.
- 2 e.
3 a.
- e...J e. g
- e...c..n 'I,'f C.a. - e.i s
.. 4 4.*.
4.:
- z...
g,. e
- ,g e.
.eg
.g.
- f...e.
v.
.i
. e y
C. E * *, - c. '6 4***e l
- t*t
- -*ts
.. c. e. t.
~ ~ ' e.
.'c. '= C : * :... ~
- e s.
i
..
- p.g
.gg.q
.e,.... g r.e,
....:..... :,..g.
.c. g.
- c. b..g *; r.g.
e.
l y.,
- c..
.[.
e e d
.. i. p..s pg p.
eE
.p p
- g. g (..
8 g.,...C..g..g..
e.
e. Le. *....C g G =
- r. g ( g.
'. C.**i.'*...
t.
- u. n c. C c*
~.
. l*t*:
...r..."
e.r. - *.
.. ~ c..* t..
g.
.e
- e. x
.p...
.4
..g
...c.
.........s e g ;s..r e. g.(
t I
l
_m
.i m
4 3'-
i d
i From these short-comings it was concluded that the. snubber surveillance requirements-for the Technical' Specifications should be revised.
The -revised surveillance' requirements correct these deficier.cies in the following manner:
I 1.
Mechanical snubbers are now included in the surveillence Oregram.
2.
No Erbitrary snutber capacity is used as E linit to the inservice test recuirenents.
t
- 1.,.. c,
es.,
<<c.,.
, * :~ c.. -.. c,.
r:-
. c.. c.
- c.,
...st
.y
.m
.c... c... C r, c. - e-c...
4.-
.. : -, 4,.
, :' i c.
.ue I_t.. c..c C.. g C...,g
.. c..
- 6
-b I. b 6 s
4.a i s e.
+. -
ineir service life.
I
.b.
- f..
C.*y F C. E. Nt, e" P.
5.v.,
t.. A * ?.
- L..e. f e#..pE. f y *
- w. *..g w
-p tys *W impienented.
.. ~.
.m
.ce.g (w*
L
...c i r e. c. r v '. " e
'.c. e wi n - ( h. c-l i ' c. c e.. '. '.. e w'.
j
--l c-e. c..
j u
s w.
.o o
Ine cr posed license amenCment submittec' by Ccr.surers Fower Con:Eny fer Provisionai Operatinc License No. DFR-20 for the FElissces Plant has i
.the necessary recu rements -in r.evision r c the 5Endarc.
incorpora teo.
Technical Specifications for the surveiliEnce of s-afety-related snubbers i
3 and is therefore, BCCeptable.
-.,,..r...,...
er..r....,--n..
- 6. - '
.c2.r,.
1 ne;
- e k c-e c q s. e. s c..e s. c. e-f. n c. &....k.:... r.. g t,.' a.
y.c n g
.~...~c.
c c-g e.
. c..
- e. e. c. e. n. e.
g c
o s
s s
3.,,c.:.tc.
-,.e., -. :1 t r. e.
c.e
.. c...
.c. e..t
..e..
r,,,
4
, e
- e. '-...-:...: * :-.:..
,..-;:a,,
...+
y 2,
a c.,..
. +
.e
- .... e.
i.e:.
w....,
.w, c.
s.
J e.,.:.... e... *: ; :- : l. '.., ',
- c....- e
- <..<.,-ca...-
+-
c.
.<c o
.c.
-s
.~w, envirtn entEi 1CDaCt s*Eterer.I, or necctive CeCIETEliC5 End envirCnnenta,l
.e-c. -,. c. e E t
- n.. G e t n e - k e.
n_e E. c e.c. s.
- r..
- e.,.. e. c e. +. t e.,,.w
.v...e 1e.zuar.ee
- e. n. c. e..... <
i ns s
.e
.. c.
- -c.~--,..
b
.~.
1
" " '. t. # ". c. r - *. i s* '. t.
w" i.c.*. ( < c. ".
- s. ' *. '. e. * "1 "s ". e ". * ",. '.' '. C e "., ~ c* * '. '.
". ".. ."mc
- . c, 5
vv c
r.
t--c.,.-:...
. e. c..e... i,... n.... e.
.:..<::,,,-,,,; eg tn l
i
! 1 1,
+:.,
....s
...c...
.." C i " e ". ~ c
- r e \\i s".'. ' v "
- n. t.. " c. r. e w" L"," ".c e.t..' e.e y
.ng. r.. g
- e. i e.. " '.> r r.. w.-
.y v
, CCes CCI involve a s1Cnl,iiCar.1 Cecrease in c sE,.c;v CErcin, the anC 4
~
~
. ~
rny a'enCOert does not involve. a significant hE Erds COnsiCerEtion, u, there is reascneble EssurEnce thEt the heEitn End sE fety cf Ine publit Will 90t be endEntereC by CDe"c
- ion in The Or0;Cs ed ~. Erne", EFC (2) such sw..
'.#.E*~"e
'.~."~
~."c.
P " ~ ~. 4. ( c. '. " ' '.'
c -. '. V ' *w i E ' W '. l l.
h e e" "w"~d" '.
w* i "~
^^~~
- w w.
w V**
>9 P%
f*
%.9. - Q C..,f
- W, [
- k. { Q.. y 6
[*
w w..
$. % ; V.*(9*
'b
-f
- &*(
w.
.c 9
bc.
A f.[..
- 0 the con 50n de#en5e Er.d security tr tc ite recit-Enc sEfety Of the
... s $ :t h.
1 l hk h.*4
- y* - h 4
.c wo it, l
-w
..---,,.r-.n---n-m-,--
.-,. -,.