ML20040A276
| ML20040A276 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 12/21/1981 |
| From: | NRC |
| To: | |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20040A275 | List: |
| References | |
| REF-10CFR9.7 NUDOCS 8201200680 | |
| Download: ML20040A276 (19) | |
Text
. ___._ _ __
~
c vum No D
wiu t
oo 2
N u
1 T3 aS x
flRC'S REACTOR OPERATI0tlAL EXPERIEtlCE PROGRAM Conmission Briefing December 21, 1981 6
D N N fa 1 MY
.-...-......-.__.,.m
.m.,-
~ -,, - _... _ _ _., -
._-_v~,.,_.__
.-.m.
- __c,
NRC'S REACTOR OPERATIONAL EXPERIENCE PROGRAM December 21, 1981 Page (1)
INTRODUCTION AND PROGRAM OVERVIEW C. MICHELSON 10 minutes 1-5 Sources of data Allocation of staff resources Coordination activities gg g
(2) 0FFICE OF INSPECTION AND ENFORCEMENT R: DeV00M6-10 minutes 6-7
- Review responsibilities
- Review products (3) 0FFICE OF NUCLEAR REACTOR REGULATION H. DENTON 10 minutes 8
Review responsibilities Review products (4) 0FFICE OF NUCLEAR REGULATORY RESEARCH R. MINOGUE 10 minutes 9-10 Review responsibilities Review products (5) 0FFICE OF NUCLEAR MATERIAL SAFETY AND SAFEGUARDS J. DAVIS 5 minutes 11-13 Review responsibilities
- Review products (6) 0FFICE FOR ANALYSIS AND, EVALUATION OF OPERATIONAL DATA C. MICHELSON 15 minutes 14-18 Review responsibilities Analysis program
- Distribution of resources Review products s
1 s
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION Tile AlcuC JAf fiY A10MIC I Af fiY ADVi10 RY Couu:litt
- A Ntk VC t h',1N G O N R f Ar' '
- AND LIC(N$tNC '
,{
80 Mc tAhtL Arrt #L PAkt L 1AftCY I
i l
I 1
I of flCE OF of flCt 01 of f!CI Cf Auoi 04 IV L Ail 0N
^ ^
Aff 1
r tultulevt DIAECID A TOR OrtRAlt0N1 i
1 I
I I
N Of FICE Of suALL' AND offtCE Of flCI Of of fitt of gg, gi Of THE M AN AGiutNT AND OISADVANTAC10 ADMIN 114A110N CDs.i AOLLE A PROGRAW ANALYtt$
SU$4Nt11UilLIIA140N
\\ Of f sCE Of
\\
\\0f flCE FOR ANALY5:5 Of flCE 07 Of flCE OF Tait in f CUIIV8 touAL EMPLOYMENI N I E flN 4160 N A L
\\ AND (VALWAis0N 07 g tiCAL 014ECio A DrrontuNtIY
\\
FA0GRAh!
P{R AQ0NAL D A A I
I I
I
' f $7CE 0t N'uClt AK
\\\\0 7 f >C r'O f' \\
g\\\\ Af fiCh O'T \\ \\
,\\\\ ChThi of
\\
O Malini4L1AffiY\\
NUCLEAR At AC104 NUCLEAR RioutA AV
\\ aae'can5\\,
\\ T"e'n \\
\\ \\ \\a' W cis N IN5FICI10N AN
\\'mies N.\\ \\
\\
\\ \\ \\~\\
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ \\
\\\\\\ \\\\ \\
N
\\\\\\\\\\
\\
Y*s x"N k N\\\\NS\\
\\Ns$
_\\ Y \\\\
NNT\\Ns
" I 9
.a g\\ W Offices involved in the review of operational experience 2
SOURCES OF REACTOR EXPERIENCE (1)
PROMPT NOTIFICATIONS (APPR0XIMATELY 2000/ YEAR) e 10 CFR 50.72 e
PLANT TECHNICAL SPECIFICATIONS (2)
LICENSEE EVENT REPORTS (APPR0XIMATE'.Y 4000/ YEAR) e PLANT TECHNICAL SPECIFICATIONS (3)
CONSTRUCTION DEFlCIENCY REPORTS (APPR0X1MATELY 2000/ YEAR) e 10 CFR 50.55E (4)
DEFECTS AND NONCOMPLlANCE (hPPR0XIMATELY 300/ YEAR) e 10 CFR 21 (5)
OTHER SOURCES (APPROX 1MATELY 300/ YEAR) e INSPECTION ACTIVITIES e
DOE REACTOR EXPERIENCE e
LICENSEE REPORTS AND REQUESTS i
e FOREIGN EVENT INFORMATION 3
L r
REVIEW Af!D At!ALYSIS OF REACTOR EXPERIENCE ALLOCATI0tl 0F STAFF RESOURCES LICEllSEE C0tlSTRUCTION PROMPT EVEt!T DEFICIENCY 10 CFR 21 OTHER TOTAL OFFICE NOTIFICATI0t!S REPORTS REPORTS REPORTS INPul RESOURCES hh k
0.2M m g ss w HIGH.
IIRR f1ED PSY
- 19 LoH
?//////////////////////////[/[////)7//////////
0 9M
~
~
HIGH.
AE0D MED
.PSY
- 14 0.5M d
agww LOW sugg%
HIGH.
PSY 1
RES MED N mms /m///fflllllYb WH7MZU//
LoH
/
4
4 COORDINATION OF REACTOR OPERATIONAL EVENTS e
WITHIN THE STAFF DAILY AND WEEKLY CONFERENCE CALLS WEEKLY MEElINSS ON OPERATING EVENTS NRR/IE/AE0D/RES FORMAL lifTERFACE AGREEMENTS PEER REVIEW PROCESS ESTABLISHED OUTSIDE CONTRACTS REVIEWED DISTRIBUTION OF SCREENING RESULTS REQUIREMENT-SETTING DOCUMENTS REVIEWED WITH THE CRGR COORDINATION PROCEDURES ESTABLISHED IN MANUAL CHAPTER 0515 e
WITH OUTSIDE ORGANIZATIONS MEMORANDUM 0F AGREEMENT ESTABLISHED WITH INP0/NSAC SELECTED IE BULLETINS, CIRCULARS, AND INFORMATION NOTICES AND SELECTED NRR GENERIC LETTERS REVIEWED WITH AIF, VEND 0RS AND OWNERS GROUP PERIODIC BRIEFINGS TO ACRS 5
REGIONAL 0FFICES AND IE iiEADQUARTERS RESPONSIBILITIES e
REGIONAL 0FFICES - ADHERENCE TO REGULATORY REQUIREMENYS e
SEND RESPONSE TEAM TO SITE FOR MAJOR EVENTS e
RESIDENT INSPECTOR PROMPT REVIEW ON SITE e
REVIEW ADEQUACY OF PROMPT LICENSEE ACTIONS FOR EVENTS WITHIN REGION e
COMMUNICATE INFORMATION TO OTHER OFFICES e
REVIEW WRITTEN REPORTS OF EVENTS WITHIN REGION e
CONDUCT FOLLOWUP INSPECTIONS AND INVESTIGATIONS o
IDENTIFY POTENTIAL GENERIC ISSUES AND DRAFT PROPOSED ACTION o
REVIEW LICENSEE ACTIONS IN RESPONSE TO GENERIC ISSUES o
IE/ HEADQUARTERS - GENERIC ISSUES e
INITIATE INCIDENT RESPONSE ACTIONS e
OVERVIEW REGIONAL EVENTS EVALUATION e
REVIEW EVENTS BY NSSS, PROMPT AND WRITTEN e
PROVIDE EXPERT ENGINEERING SUPPORT e
IDENTIFY POTENTIAL GENERIC ISSUES AND DEVELOP i
APPROPRIATE GENERIC COMMUNICATION o
COORDINATE WITH OTHER OFFICES i
(
o OVERVIEW RESPONSE TO GENERIC ISSUES i
w
REVIEW PRODUCTS REGIONAL OFFICE e
DIRECT FEEDBACK TO INDIVIDUAL LICENSEES VIA REGIONAL MEETINGS AND INSPECTION REPORTS e
COMMITMENTS FOR LICENSEE ACTION VIA LICENSEE LETTER, REGIONAL CONFIRMATION OF ACTION LETTER, MEETING SUMMARIES e
SPECIAL INSPECTION REPORTS IE HEADOUARTERS o
SPECIAL TECHNICAL REPORTS e
GENERIC CORRESPONDENCE TO LICENSEES r.
INFORMATION NOTICE CIRCULAR BULLETIN o
ABNORMAL OCCURRENCE REPORTS TO CONGRESS e
OTHER FEEDBACK MECHANISMS INSPECTION PROCEDURES TECHNICAL SPECIFICATION / LICENSE CHANGES RULE CHANGES STANDARD REVIEW PLAN CHANGES
_-,v.
0FFICE OF fl0 CLEAR REACTOR REGULATION l
REY! Elf AND EVALUATION OF OPERATING REACTOR EVEilTS l
l RESPONSIBILITIES RESOURCES e
ASSESS IMMEDIACY OF SAFETY CONCERN ON OPERATING REACTORS 9 PSY e
ASSESS SHORT TERM GENERIC IMPACTS 4 PSY e
DAILY COORDINATION WITH IE/OTHER ORGANIZATIONS 2 PSY e
LER/Pfl - DAILY llIGHLIGHT REVIEW - COORDINATION IE 3ULLETINS, ETC.
2 PSY e
WEEKLY OPERATING REACTOR EVENTS BRIEFINGS AND FOLLOWUP (NRR, IE, AE0D)/ SUPPORT OPERATIONS CENTER 2 PSY TOTAL 19 PSY l
PRODUCTS NO. cF PRODUCTS l
e EMERGENCY T.S./SHORT TERM SAFETY EVALUATION REPORTS 75/YR e
GENERIC ISSUE SAFETY EVALUATION REPORTS / GENERIC LETTERS 25/YR e
TASK INTERFACE AGREEMENTS /0PERATING REACTOR EVENT IlEMORANDUMS 50/YR e
REVIEW 0F AE0D RECOMMENDATIONS 5/YR e
llEEKLY OPERATING REACTOR EVENTS BRIEFINGS S
DAILY HIGHLIGHTS 200/YR O
8
0FFICE OF RESEARCH PROJECTS ON OPERATING EXPERIENCE COMPONENT DATA PURPOSE:
EXTRACT COMPONENT RELIABILITY DATA TO IMPROVE DATA BASE FOR RELIABILITY AND RISK ASSESSMENTS PRODUCTS:
8 COMPONENT DATA REPORTS AND 3 REVISIONS IN 1980-1982 DRAWN FROM LER ANALYSIS AND IN-PLANT LOG REVIEWS 4
9
~-
4 OFFICE OF RESEARCH PROJECTS ON OPERATING EXPERIENCE EVENT ANALYSIS PURPOSE:
DEVELOP AND TRY METHODS TO ANALYZE LER EVENT SEQUENCES FOR SEVERE ACCIDENT PRECURSORS AND EXPERIENCE BASED VALIDATION OF SYSTEM FAILURE AND CORE MELT PROBABILITIES PRODUCT':
REPORT ON 1969-1979.LER'S IN MARCH 1982 S
REPORTS ON LATER LER'S AND EXTENDED ANALYSES IN FY 1983 10 o
REACTOR AND FUEL CYCLE SAFEGUARDS DATA RESPONSIBILITIES e
SCREEN, EVALUATE, AND MAINTAIN DATA BASE FOR LER'S AND OTHER OPERATIONAL DATA e
REVIEW ABNORMAL OCCURRENCE REPORTS e
REVIEW DOMESTIC AND FOREIGN INTELLIGENCE DATA e
THREAT CREDIBILITY ASSESSMENT e
SUPPORT OPERATIONS CENTER f
PRODUCTS a
ORDERS, LETTERS, AND LICENSING ACTIONS s
RULE REVISIONS e
THREAT ANALYSES GENERIC ADVERSARY CHARACTERISTIC (NUREG-0459) i INSIDER STUDY (NUREG-0703)
SAFEGUARDS
SUMMARY
EVENT LIST (NUREG-0525) e e
CASE STUDIES AND EVALUATIONS fil
FUEL CYCLE SAFETY AND ENVIRONMENTAL DATA 8ESPONSIBILITIES I
e SCREEN AND EVALUATE LER'S AND OTHER OPERATIONAL DATA e
REVIEW ABNORMAL OCCURRENCE REPORTS e
SUPPORT OPERATIONS CENTER I
t PRODUCTS e
ORDERS, LETTERS, AND LICENSING ACTIONS e
RULE REVISIONS l
e CASE STUDY REPORTS l
e ENGINEERING EVALUATIONS i
l 12
4 NMSS REVIEW AND ANALYSIS OF OPERATIONAL DATA OFFICE RESPONSIBILITIES e
FUEL CYCLE SAFETY AND ENVIRONMENTAL DATA INTEGRATED WITH AE0D COORDINATED WITH IE AND REGIONAL OFFICES e
REACTOR AND FUEL CYCLE SAFEGUARD DATA i
COORDINATED BUT RQL INTEGRATED WITH AEOD i
PARALLELS ACTIONS BY AE0D PLUS LICENSING'0FFICE ACTIONS COORDINATED WITH NRR, IE, AND REGIONAL OFFICES' 4
9 13
L AE0D PURPOSE AND G0ALS (DECEMBER 1981) e ASSURE lHAT SAFETY CONCERNS INHERENT IN THE EXPERIENCE ARE IDENTIFIED TO THE APPROPRIATE NRC 0FFICE, INDUSTRY, LICENSEES, AND THE PUBLIC, AND ARE SATISFACTORILY RESOLVED AND IMPLEMENTED.
e COLLECT, STORE, RETRIEVE, ASSESS AND FEED BACK OPERATING EXPERIENCE.
e IDENTIFY NEEDED OPERATIONAL DATA, AND PROPOSE AND MAINTAIN DATA REPORTING METHODS AND SYSTEMS.
e IDENTIFY POTENTIALLY SIGNIFICANT EVENTS FOR FURTHER STUDY.
e SEEK TRENDS OR PATTERNS, OR OTHERWISE IDENTIFY POTENTIAL SAFETY PROBLEMS OR PRECURSORS OF MORE SERIOUS EVENTS.
e DEVELOP RECOMMENDATIONS FOR ACTION BY OTHER NRC 0FFICES FOR RESOLUTION OF SAFETY ISSUES REVEALED BY ANALYSIS AND EVALUATION.
e PREPARE SPECIAL REPORTS ASSOCIATED WITH OPERATIONAL EXPERIENCE (E.G., POWER REACTOR EVENTS, ABNORMAL OCCURRENCE REPORTS).
o PROVIDE GUIDANCE AND A FOCAL POINT FOR C0 ORDINATION OF SUCH ACTIVITIES WITHIN THE NRC AND WITH THE ACRS, INDUSTRY, AND OTHER GROUPS (E.G., INP0, NSAC, AND FOREIGN).
1 14
i.-,ll11 1
I ll 1
l e
(.
. /
I 5
Y E D SA U T
C S S
A E
k I
T D
A I U L
D CT m7 A
I S T
f GT l NSY I
.' { '
i I:.
N SI IL IL T
E I R M
V I
E SI E
5 E AB L
TN P
! l BAI P
SQOL U
NNRE OEPR S
= * +
I GN NO I I 1lgIJ RT a
TG
=
2 EA E U N
SN C_
l L I d
=
m Q A LR N V HO a
E jk g
TNI
=
E C T r
j o
A O P
mF WM r
L n
fll o
ita lua T
v E
d H
n 5
'L a
T 1
P s
P i
A l
lM r+
i A
sy lan 1
Y D
D G O
E E
E G
NI A T
GN A
E NI MR C I T T
Y 3
ARO EN e
AN TH N I COP TI u
I N I PE U H E
r C
g ME I ER P C D
F R
R EA E
NR M
iF ILR G 0E O
PS A
A RE EC l
CS e
E RS
$#N e
- e P
m-m7
,S D
F NC SI
.O PT T EN E P S
L A OF LI F
R A
E E
C CE AE N
S D
OT NN U A A ER I E E
I f
EI P DM NU VU TN
\\'
U D T
R V QO MAR I
6 I Q AE F l S D E
EC OEO EAV N E
E CRF DFS l S P
S e
e O
l l
ll i!
OFFICE FOR ANALYSIS AND EVALUATION OF OPERATIONAL DATA REVIEW AND ANALYSIS OF REACTOR OPERATIONAL EVENTS REVIEW PRODUCl3 e
CASE STUDY REPORTS e
ENGINEERING EVALUATION REPORTS AND MEMORANDUMS e
POWER REACTOR EVENT REPORTS e
ABNORMAL OCCURRENCE REPORTS TO CONGRESS e
IDENTIFICATION OF EVENTS FOR REPORTING TO NEA e
DOCUMENTATION OF LER SCREENING RESULTS e
LER MONTHLY AND SPECIAL REPORTS 16
0FFICE FOR ANALYSIS AND EVALUATION OF OPERATIONAL DATA FY 1982 BUDGET 33 POSITIONS DIRECTOR SECRETARIAL STAFF DEPUTY DIRECTOR Director's Secretary Secretaries (3)*
l l
PRCGRAM TECHNOLOGY BRANCH REACTOR OPERATIONS ANALYSIS BRANCH
(
Branch Chief Branch Chief
- NON-REACTOR ASSESSMENT
?ROGRAM DEVELOPMENT DATA MANAGEMENT REACTOR SYSTEMS 1 REACTOR SYSTEMS 2 sTArr
~~--
SECTION Chief SECTION Lead Engineer Lead Engineer Support Engrs (2)'
Jection Leader Section Leader Support Engr Support Engrs (2)
'rogram Analyst Reactor Engr aisk Assessment Engr Technical Editor REACTCR SYSTEMS 3l p
REACTOR SYSTEMS 4 Opr Exp Analyst Reports Analyst *
(DARE)
Lead Engineer Lead Enginecr Support Engrs (2,)*
Support Engrs (2) l l
ENGINEERING SYSTEMS PLANT SYSTEMS.
l Support Engr Support Engr 1
l l* Change from FY 1981i hy addition i** To be filled in FY 1983 17 i
)
.n AE0D PROGRAM OBJECTIVES FOR FY 1982 e
IMPROVED COLLECTION OF OPERATIllG EXPERIENCC e
REVISE LER REPORTING REQUIREMENTS e
IMPROVE FOREIGN DATA ACQUISITION CAPABILITY e
IMPROVED STORAGE AllD RETRIEVAL 0F OPERATING EXPERIENCE e
ESTABLISH ROUTINE OPERATION OF SCSS e
SELECTIVELY BACKFlT SCSS DATA BASE e
DEVELOP STATISTICAL PROFILE OF DATA BASE e
COMPUTER ASSISTED SCREENING FOR P0TENTIALLY SIGNIFICANT EVENTS e
COMPUTER ASSISTED SEARCHES FOR TRENDS AND PATTERNS e
ADVAilCEMENT OF ANALYSIS METHODOLOGY e
PROBABILISTIC RISK ASSESSMENT TECHNIQUES e
STATISTICAL TECHNIQUES e
IMPROVED REPORTING AND FEEDBACK OF OPERATING EXPERIENCE e
STRENGTHENED RELATIONSHIPS WITH INP0 AND NSAC 18
--