ML20028G210

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Forwards Info on Seismic Qualification of Equipment Supplementing Util 830121 Submittal.Info Addresses Specific Items 6,7 & 8 Re Resistor Input Card,Indicator 1151 & Control Element Drive Mechanism Reed Switch Position
ML20028G210
Person / Time
Site: Palo Verde, Waterford, 05000000
Issue date: 02/01/1983
From: Maurin L
LOUISIANA POWER & LIGHT CO.
To: Novak T
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
Shared Package
ML20028G211 List:
References
W3P83-0367, W3P83-367, NUDOCS 8302070523
Download: ML20028G210 (11)


Text

I OUISIANA f 342 OuAnONCE s1nar POWE R & L1GH T/ P O BOX 6008 . NEW OnLEANS LOUISIANA 70174 . (504) 366 2345

'$E0$!;Er"sY[O u

L. V MAURIN Vrce Presnient Nuclear Operatrons February 1, 1983 W3P83-0367 3-A20.18 3-A1.01.04 L.09.02 Mr. Thomas M. Novak Assistant Director far Licensing U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555

SUBJECT:

Waterford 3 SES Docket No. 50-382 Supplemental Information on Seismic Qualification

Dear Mr. Novak:

The purpose of this letter is to provide information on the seismic qualification of equipment which supplements that provided by W3P83-0251 of January 21, 1983.

Addressed in the attachments to this letter are specific items number 6, 7, and 8, Resister Input Card, 1151 Indicator, and CEDM Reed Switch Position, respectively. i 1

If you have any questions or comments on this matter or this memo, please advise.

Sincerely, t

L.7V.(??g, Maurin,,,;,

LVM/SFU/pco cc: Jim Wilson, Jerry Jackson, Jag Singh (EGEG), E. Blake, W. M. Stevenson l

Ap\

8302070523 830201 PDR ADOCK 05000392 PDR A

bec (w/o attachments): F. J. Drummond, R. W. Prados, M. I. Meyer, K. R. Iyengar, John Tompeck (Ebasco), John liart (Ebasco), Terry MacNair (CE), Kanti Gala, Centrai

! Records, Nuclear Records (4), Licensing Library, R. F. Burski, C. J. Decareaux f

Before the UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY C01241SSION Docket No. 50-382 In the Matter of LOUISIANA POWER & LIGliT COMPANY SEISMIC QUALIFICATION Louisiana Power & Light Company, Applicant in the above captioned proceeding, hereby files additional information on the Seismic Qualification of Equipment.

Respectfully submitted, LOUISIANA POWER & LIGilT COMPANY By: )

L. V. Ma6r'in ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' '

] fi, , , , __ .

Vice President Nuclear Operations DATE: 2M h3 1

l l

STATE OF LOUISIANA)

) SS PARISH OF ORLEANS )

L. V. Maurin, being duly sworn, states that he is Vice President - Nuclear Operations of Louisiana Power & Light Company and that he is authorized on the part of said company to sign and file with the Nuclear Regulatory Comnission this report.

Y /n , , , L L. V. Hau~rin SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN to bffo .e me, a Nopary/Public, in and for the Parish and State above named, this t.5 . day of ('/ /up; <pm , 1983.

/

7 Ly > [

  • 56ffr P b 'ic MY COMMISSION EXPIRES:

, m m, s . - . . _ ,

,,.r jf&J,.<J J Westinghouse Industrial Control * * * *50*58 Electric Corporation Divisions 2co rie a onn September 10, 1982 o ra a te nsn:e Pes:upPennspansa 15238

.412i782 1730 Combustion Engineering, Inc.

Nuclear Division 1000 Prospect Hill Rd.

Windsor, CT. 06095 Attention: Mr. T. MacNair

Subject:

Louisiana Power & Light Waterford SES Unit No. 3 C.E. P.O. 9403341-9270 (W) IED W8000 Seismic Qualification Review Team Audit Item NSSS 6 NCI SORT No. NSSS ICE-5A Resistor Card Reviewer: R. W. Macek Audit Date: Sept. 1, 1982

Reference:

Westinghouse Electric Corp. Seismic Test Report - WCAP 8828 Seismic Operability Demonstration Testing of the Westinghouse IED 7300 Series Process Instrumentation Bistables Gentlemen:

The subject audit concluded with one action for Westinghouse Industry Electronics Division (WIED) as follows:

" Verify by means of test data that operability of resistor input card was demonstrated during the test".

Mr. Macek noted that WCAP 8828 included the NCI card in its equipment listing, Table 2-1, demonstrating the cards inclusion in the test. He also noted there was no direct mention of, or data to show, the cards operability during the test.

Westinghouse stated that the evidence of NCI operability could be provided but it would be in the nature of raw data, i.e. block diagram sketches, schematic sketches, copies of strip chart recordings and explanations showing linkage bet-ween WCAP 8828, the NCI card, signal names, sketches and recordings.

h__

Combustion Engineering Page September 10, 1982 The followinng is a list of attachments to this letter which will serve to demonstrate operability of the NCI card:

Attachment A. Block diagram of circuitry in Card Frame #1 Attachment B. Schematic of Card Frame #1 Wiring Attachment C. Strip Chart recording of NCI outputs Attachment A defines, in block diagram form, the circuitry of card frame #1.

Attachment B defines the hardware and wiring which implements the block diagram.

Attachment C shows strip chart recordings of signals described in Attachments A

& B.

The relationship of NCI card output, signal name and recorder / pen number are as follows:

NCI Output Signal Recorder No. Pen No.

TD/411 A A TLL 2 3 TD/411E TC 2 4 TD/412A TAVG 2 5*

TD/411B OPSP 2 6 TD/411C OTSP 2 7 In Attachment C, the signal on Pen #2 was purposely changed in order to vary the input to bistables to demonstrate that they change state. The signals on recorder pens 3,4,5 & 6 are not functionally affected by the signal on Pen #2, and therefore, remain at a steady state value. The signal on Pen #7 is func-tionally affected and, therefore, moves as expected. The Attachment C recording was run during the seismic test and showed no anomalies.

Therefore, the operability of the NCI card is demonstrated.

If I can be of any further service, please advise.

Very truly yours,

//W" ! /

Pvt 44%M?

W. J. Ri tter Projects Director WJR:msb cc: Mr. J. W. Veirs - Combustion Engineering Mr. L. Karl - (W) IED l

l I

_____., 'l : 0o !!

, i mw S

?

s f i. f s. 1 . >

i 7 li 1 *.i I,

?, 7

'Ih p> e e 6 s

y'2 2

g O. du 1, " Yg$ $n $p. )

- i

= s 5.I T 4 2 3 a Lii ri IIy;.

Q' g;:ym dlri.i i s; d?

i.H g -

C, o rt i

?. <t , .r. ..r-p u w .

s' c

). .

t w E C E R H  : >

W , .; I . . . . *.g!.j ,n .,

a j j\ -

! I jq  ! . .. pa ,d[ h U { f(i Iis 22 t g l; i .) e L g-

- e,0i ,p  ;*

~

E-- cn N

... i m n;&ng;,-- - Jp. -! -a c.

ij 2~AI  :-[;'T " } gj uv_ @-  ;.

. .. .. e -

i,. d $!!, d@---i!! .

1---.

EI; . - G !.- n .

Oi'!,n '

d  !  !.I U E @ d -!ji. e i* 5m ..

2 ', n
j.  ; g jh }!12 f--

d :

h

!  ! I

  • g(

I !.E3+:; t o . .

II ,.f.:: IiN

.<.::  !,  !,l ;a @ N ~.

p

. a- ..

i'i a- ..............  : .fd. @ -- -a,

km n /p l((
i. f-. M 0,. as::
?  !'l..$ rJ
N-3 0.5; P
  • ijj! J1.I ; ! %; ,- .- -

b

- -l -E- h!. .-  %!

l ,

)g!!. [!n, , in

,; '; .a :, . . . - . i'....!.!1,r f. ,

(rpi--s.v.;

-  ! . .87 .

4./..i .- l

$gI S I fi[Nr nys h.!, ...,..... ., 5

! ... : s ,., r ,@ <o b ke f

o o! b' '

SS*e a lls * **. . el

--s i _

pg@, . L _ _ __

--- q}) . ~g* .

i '! ,#3'qy '.- --y;{ ;. :. i. , . .~. s 4.

  1. g. - '.

e o Qd

! . . . W. . .I.......si t ,,, ; tu

  • t..l I

.3

'M h3 < s dmA. ,

i e r,t gf.!SMIII.:....l..}lg

. Q . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . n . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . /ff ,,

s: 'l [; _ hi Ep h mg .

g

!:i!,s;!' M,e '"&i

0,,, i T $c ds7 ' s i :n , $.
i.  :- w { .i&', Q ,!j  : .

l 7_ _ *:,

if5.

! 15 Q,Q-...( . c E ,.! h,

$ $ f:-@- - h_ ----- !'::i b Ij

/:

1 I 'u g ..l...........  ?

i Pl 6  :

r

!! d .li l l s

l St &  :

1 l 6 .s " . . ... *

% y%

o v=.=*,

  • \

la

's e
, $e$$$

l l

n. .i

'?h*e. Q*

f '

?i' ~ 5 i

, {I oG' j i v$' T.- ,'Q, -

I' -- gm  :.

I 1 *

  • k I;'" .*,

-- ; . , e .

.,zl ,,);-

,i i , ....

II 0.i a

D fi-i, j

Ii 23 l

.7.

  • '- 3.tjh 4 -' , e--*

I8 t r in14

' ' * ' 5 '- I' y 'i Q  : . y :1.. i g )I,lnn: I g .

yll +

3 r;; -1 E: .

1 1

?- y, , s_.,,,_ , u ziu  !  !

'M

{ j, (i_. , . ..N. . '. ! .-

" I  !  ! ),',i_.

  • u/ 7"A.4, l,! n. yp -{ ' lg/

. . e I,.i _..fij.M. -

m._ -2 g

p  %. < ,:.

_v. I h !l*d e [ ; s f { _=. .c gg N'. ~M I - - -

.u j.! *, 11 I a,s ,

,, 4 h *HLi Y A I I E ri t

y en'm.r 1,; 9e1.2c i i i

S p, wwa.ng,4.

3 e bs .f .;

, Lo.,2 -

p gi!. g; 37

-.%p. n ;.

g. o o 1 l.o
h. m. -

I. i,-a.

.i ..

. . c-y 1.s n uuu m

p? 7i Mip6:-F 3

m it. .

?

  • gw!\

d2

.! -s . :g - - . . f

!g  ;

' ~

i i-T'"*

h, lih h  !.ll_

i l!. %g h I h -  !.N a wl$ #,,,...$  ! N.- _

. o. . %o ,r n1 d L ,<i I g N !!!b _ !i t! ! @ ' R j!!. di ij Lt.'- jR- - ,i. -

' - _ .,._U

)iI.7 lie 9

== 2. ,g -

f .

, p _ o- -

' l 4 --+ + Q3 C b

!8

' D) l

.'.r p ,I l

    • '" ===

f a [,, --*,j

$4(

!(If -+ !ff! M"-

.};

!ar- .o't-  !,, , .

. v ,._ lJ e

.I  !=== .. .)

-u 3.j al

- Ye -

3 ;. 5"I "I .

f.=-i ,1 t . i ly;

i . i +f c])!!! '

Q

.' ' ' 1e

  • '7;-)

., 48 l' .s h - il

' r.e., i p ,l u --rL ur y$ n !=

rea: -

rj_ .d7 ,s,t,1 .,

!y' g g< nJ , ,

E!6-

'- j'hj}['! ""

i

- i: b 4-' I  ! g' Y. k'  ! M! l I_4 g G _t n$g. 1519

?

d . . .i .

_ _ __w I

! ~-y _.G"3-. ;L!!!

i.

I

, %e%.~. _._ - _

i t

~

,! -'! .?'F*'I

' , p g' .

S*_., im "'f '- ' m'l

~

-ij_

ii:i n .I t 1

  • 3 g

. - : se s- 14:I - I

r _ H MIb!!!yI! !t i

I !b

! -)

i) f:

lea!r

(

.c M M hdN ' Y -

dCk di  ! -

N

, r -u . < ,

! I

. b.a .

~

j h a 4;d. ' I- @ 3 - - _ ,

3 j

2 44j5 t iiI 5 i 8

  1. )

i i t E h,

b{b s 3-

, n.

Y l,ip pu G/WQj,F.tj'hs t .U .:c:

h""- j;hs

. .ns: WWW$31 u 41 0 l.i:. O g T Q

. ~. % MM M i; %. ; M u. 4 o .al,s mug"-

i_d! I ie m a

~

I.4.. ,

s, y <

I s -

h Q -4 p  ; -

i q-.

g-

[e a

1- %e,,ee, t- a e .

l l

ih, dl ;' :;

I .

9 t' vMA ihe :j I r,T:.r.%

,n.: - ,

, iu um :,, *.cs. ;- -. 9T

  • .-s,.,

s m, vv Tr e -

-.6 =-

{" 8, kO0D ,

t, *8 kf ,

c l s 4.t r

,. -v r ' l ~ Q *,* ' v 'N 1 lj ~ ',

,!ja 1ih!!- hj!.'!!-  : <@k,

. 1

. ..d' j},i;n ta d __  ! v.. g .w.

I .- .

.; ;. 7. ;. ; .a--
: 0 'T. P_'~::.. .Ql. h'd~

',-'.E.~_ _~~ :.i' g C Td # ' " "

  • 7,y*==.

r ,, '-

. soWw4 w - _. ,

. ~

i :)!u. .!.f.

m ,,rl d; [O el eN g:.! :,,,

a li., I ,. ., II-N:!l

.v  !..

S_

o: i .:

sd u >

i.i r i:.

5i' li! "4 i j .:-l p- 4- ~

? ]l i

!tosy/llji

'b'i T' 4. sr.[

I { l'i ,l$p k'- -J.!;ii!:l[i: g h'r i < i9 u. .: 8 m'j:.!,,d' .

. '1;-. --

...L en a -k E 'I:t it : i:

i. en * *<.  :.d sk;e i. a ia s 'l l- I 8 --

'8 g

E M.. .i ; Tit *'

.ijs-I t [3f's.-.- y, v G ll,r,] / >.' .

=

--[e

  • .6 ==

39, i

1 l..i 4- e P ;o,b j . -

JJ i t : l i 1/

j p.g rv.b>+

d!J I

D 4 @it dLt ;;Jj l.

l ._

! Q315!!

. j d' d'i '

l It '

_ l!. ft

-1 st 1--

7 e

,1 [

s L. . )l h 4,i .l J . ;, ;1.g ! ls r, s.'U r :t.;.

I, 't

g. . } i .i w, o pi

-+"

u Ii l'l lii!

i ' .i i;yj

.i ,i

[,jy. !_ .*! I j ;Ti n I

! 'l? .

~~

e..

='

-lt ,T,.t**ent,pJunn, id-----;- e

!!i M, ,

) - k_ [d,!

.f.: e.ug;;.t:;;;;p

- f a i, s

i E h %$853!!h Eh jj

$d3lik~

iij't j s . . ." .i I t I h : ,iIei I

d..

8 e (9 , .

'l' f I.I 5 i +-- 'I!ir  !

j j "ii i

-  !=[r: t

,  : im

' '@'!-- m .iin

[ ' n) T.i i _

hlu -

g!.

ir g

. $u, s.  ! t G.

E7 t 1 ~'

l .Qi "* Iii

_ .- . . _ . - -;  ; .2 4 k !!I e.m ss kk s ll u

, n v .ss ss

.I I

ut Q

1 -- I  !

  • 5 f.

l -ll -+t ' air I i tj mR

=m a, l . a ,s Dq

%~

W --

w f l.

0 CA fdddINikst~fSi%~

t. e h -w3ewT [iiuePdIINiINI[U[2ffSI Ik
i. ' Ilqit 4
p w, ,

Qy9 onk..Te.wk I

h l.n ni nn n.yl l t,;. .

nse t.i. ll it.e,,i.;.

9 N. ,

t.

l lI!i.!. d. d.

i' Ils im h@tE e q .-

U '

,8- I 6 88

!!  !.i 1

' :' ' " ti!!
  1. ' I s

l# p'

, a "ww' b !.]kA-r- r j} ( ,!j!

i I 4 7 Ifi , (2"t_,

t-

  • g 9 Jj%. ;m g;.JI . .m t, "

I

' .$e 5,p im g ', g j

y 10 LI.h,s.i!!! 4,!:

.: e .:j t ' e *: 1 ,-

E 04 8 e i

--** C S'. ,,3 LM iis t

d. l ~;* D' ' . ',

% .% g: 3 ,p 3 ,

,8 4 .%. .%  % .)

,7 T ,,,-

~

11 *

=- liit:

t- lii;g:

E-G ;

!r=- ~io&W tha

.:- p,,

}'

wy.ui, d=im sie ./-'t? r n.~.1 q, '". } ., I- ,

- + _ - .

a - z:'-J.h.y

,f-{sr--

j ,:is "

as -,ti d_._-jl PT I .-: ;.dii i, .', J C.

c J-g._

..h.y

y S, g2.A A,.

_ m

E l: - _ . - _ _

F- . . , - . - . . ~. .

.,.,,.n----- -- ,

~'

- m --

,b .__s.*-

9e n

_.'.y, - ,

--- M _ _ _ .

- - = - -

%- - --*-3M-m - 1.2 E ~"". . *

, ,Je

,. ac. 2,I.,".r,_N

. .' 2

'r' g , _ _ ,

g. -'^' -_-x.

f- 4 r.

_ . .:. _ M} [

t_

.-, . , e -

.~w - -, -

mi4-%~ r .~.F. g+. .a

e .

l.; - - . ,'.1 3 _ -'R-. .

- } :~ s i - - . .-

o g\ , a

~

-- .r-* A .aec

..e.

d' 4 1  % ' &T-Wre '* * -- n . r s --_1,. d-g :se . .f-a.&.Q' & --

. g ~r~%'-:- - y%

, w*L*-"'--

f{ .-

m. -

,-M*-* ., 4 s . ,. . , m- '

w.

s ,..ss

-s- - -

-.79w.

r w'.p':

2Ss- es:

r5h.%-w.:

~ :

_ aeg _

_ E[d- ..

-* .. - . r-

-r._,.,

e 'rn qgy.  :.- g. ..s.y.,,

ggp , , , .. .. j,64p ,

s f _..7-- -.p.~h.4 o m 4 1 r _ . _

u,,,,

- -f .- - 1

[.,,_-

m^W;y' I

y

  • 9" b f , :-N"" ! : " T% i

$ eQe-,

- - % ~.;.pN S

- - d.,.N

& S ""$'9"rYi'N+1m a n T-;.er_,' - .m:- n -

h ~M-- n~1 b ," p'L=..e e -- - =gd +- .

jQ W f ._ - v^'-r =ior= y_,7; E36-7  ;.n %:.. -

  1. , s _ _ MY ~ ;-- -">' ' ' P. O r

f,.J.': ; 3 -

a -i a.c i. p , "..-+:a ' - ~~ ~ W

=* . . r.r 4 . -sawr i n *J A. _- M . _ r_ . _4 :c.g;;;i -i-b ma

=TrN's" n--w.==,. - "' -'a -

2a..u. mN. dr a . 3 .-.3.uw.

.e i -e -- --

v- . h,Z MT.

s  :- . -

-- - . . .i . c , N .:-+W' a- g .-

,uar:4 g- 1 ,

_ : -$S -- -.- -m

- i N T,'k-k_ N.M2* .

'-' +- -- -4';~1 @ . M -4

    • " * * ' - p c.ig.:yz afWrs?. _ _- .%-  ; -E. % 'a v A -

M -' i ei

- -- . p ii I '

' _'  ! 8 $

i.T I

~  ! 1- n'j ?. . - * ;

W

  • *
  • a. ne. - . .. F-4E- n 4' .-4 M S-e - _

^A=[.-*

-w--

  • h.+t-,..--'  ?

= . ~ . ~ - .4 -

"I

,, =.'.a@MW"a'n"p.ame-S anc+iN -e+-

    • == -w

.h3- -F~.C* .M"*5-- O * 'l ' ? . . 2 -'.qi

  • t

- i t_

WTA--NMd - f

- P-

." 7

  • W - Am M - in,$ '4 v t .* g n Em r - q-i

. . p--A.- f "p==

-- [. , e .& t

~'_ - @ m sii

-m<...~.

i.

man n .o =, a=+G L &m . . A= p ww' =wa 5 # id

.J.s'4 i _ ii 'l.

i -n 1

! 3 -5 2 -- - 1-

%- , ,r~=-'.

.-+

+ - . -w I

+=-=mtsx-.W2

--3 m -x =riz 5

---c-*

. . _ _P - :_' _2 ; .-si h -e- a =n %- & -i n.-w

_~~_~"~' _

.. n . -n.=

=- + . a = a.- m x T-fa%%--c.S f =d.-w.=-= mw = :Tw +a - a- - 6

4,q,,,

.I e7 '

5 ,

.h

. "e -, $

i I _g pm 4 18 ] ,, t r:3

_a.. -t c .m '. , va g'4g e

4K, Am.

4 g ').

__ 6 ,i e J -a ,8 8 1

, ,.= x.-3 % . . , _r . _m r _ ,

V=31.~LW 3 -TM "! ' s' * . -W Y4ci--R 5^W -p ;:x=p =

- --m,r I -- - s r - ab s 9 -T: + u-- .- ,

- O-MG ".m;=:&M

~

-- wg r-i e,.,. - --

, r. 0

'. \

(g 3*hd 4

  • f

_ mi c e ,. -

4 e'l t-  : M s=,g[M[

~ ~ ~ ~ , sa , , i i  ! 4 e-wN w a.=.m _;t'i

, , , . , t ..

. i . ,

w g

~_ . - m% --

' ' - ' ' i ' + , h :i' -~1%"5 d_Y% .ne

-n:.-~.M 4.g Q .1.; _ _ :k = - _% a : t 2 u a ce, +ga , a ;.

n_1s.-tzu $ ; 4 n: -

. . . . -, 4 ; , y; ,

V _-a-die N t-s 1- . N ; . )+ .t.# -

ea eg-

{ ) e a ..,._).t g

. -, a 1. u T9 . -- n_ ,.

-TWp7 -._r9 - . . _

_w .- j; . < . m j- =_

  • ~ ~

g.

. .. m

, rest. u. -. .

- =

, - . #v--d;A y a... .

- m:+#%..

w',- . :.W . . m_

,m -h. _ .a.

3

- _em E e=.r t:s. m .-4 -- _-.@' ;. ,-,:~-a s

r. _v. , --

.. - -w . a+. ..

a -cW ,;'- ,.-

m,gi#: :M.m.

-. , m. . 4 m

- o..._4. -. ' 9 Y, :" ge'd * "W'*-3-- F-I'*'- *T 8+-

NE.~ A ;; t -> . I~ 2E

. - se .n.,z=.r: : .rew

_:n- , .- .

v.

. - .+0. - *-M-- - -;

9 " a

-; 5- :

r' 4 .

2 E- 3

.; r-. - q. ,r,1,=,, g g q _.g_:K s3.;r.

. # d.:.6.-._.'ar_*8 a: A -.1 -%=.x $; 1 .:= g y%: J k 1_ :-9 a.;_a-25 3 9p:-- ~

-J z y q .. : - :

s -v.c , . . d_--%f'-- -b? d -=: - r y. a.. er m_.-ys -

s  !

.-Mg-C -D 5. -_%.r s77 3 e  ;._.rj i
-

* -- - r + .-- men . n_-,==== _ -=

= gr =W E,J:8,5 +4 4s 3-%44- .. .F .ir-s.nq . u ,, .. aM.:n  :--  :.n_316 %_;~,_.z._ . . p C-s'PNW b,rsr,--.",-M w - w

  • 1 - =+-.*---

p c ., t ,.in-e- . r -% :.w--7 w ..

v/

w

3. y . ;

,=

G- - ay -- 3 u._ r

}-tv y --crr -- Jj W- g. m -

ww---Eres-A=- s.+& .3m:.h_ . = _Vd _ ..v. .- -- ,t-7.c-w.M- M_4P.F;TX,,..;IT".r'!"*,,D

,' F*

90 -~ v; m -- :-

,.( w i_ _ _ P.4.

..c ~

. UG WiWWnw-M:21:P +2c ws-ws -Sm=-N -% =~n v - a - V -s v ' m-C'") -L=4=ai s

. . W y- -3? vJ w KW;m. !T-N"g}r .c=wV=&. : '-.:+m rm.w ;g; m. a+w=--s_n = : Wr c=1 dM;Ti %" 19_W.'Y m+N

-, ,-4*rC#am. :

w m==n==+m n: --M Jg-an qp_.7- s =-w u wwg gs ud ,4 e4w-=-w-E.w- rP -- srw +== 3- --r m= ? nr=.r=a r

.p- . - , sh'--4-- >Js::e=i= e- f . ~ze - ~ s . _

.- "4-.-.. . Q. .3 . -s ~-c rn.i - am i e.'or +ar-mA ar =.WF8- ..p. --

+r._u,- t--. r-u  ; ~J .t ;. T e-

'lr -. i c- A1- 3 : % :r%_

-~--'---'+':=12E

, -.:w, 2.' ^ 4d s=,

-==

er; ~ vr es wd2 4u 1 rr- s- -ac n: : ~= l 7 T q= id h w :a.m t 1 v 4- D- a  :- w. 4~w,-  :.-.. h'.==.r.

. 'l- ' W- r wirw +na.-smr-h f_  :-- --7*S--i3--

c.r m rfM-= F. ' d'~ ~:'_- i=="?9:'.d .h (I

b-br imevl-~ } ' _ .  !* --

2 ^5 ' ' d - 3 ';eL1- - ~* n 4 - -r - ..'# ~4 d ? P' Ji -in-+

n ii!. y'!;su--

"z

,r - %.c n--r l . ,. 2 4_.d'.iM T-4' Fir i.L.disti- 1= 4 d W b '%'*

15 -

z - p - F-U-i ' f

.y. gy . _ _ _ _ , _

-. I

^qosen.g.py

,,_ 7 ,_ , , , , , ,g

_ _ py.,-. ;_ ' '* : ^ 3-s * ~ ~ . ~ ~ ~.i M ;-4::c

~w uM^ ((-.u t -2W*

s-sm2z h g h--T  :..--rw w-Try-rra m-= "%-~ r- -

,,~ -;e-_-k L -:- : ~ 4a-+ -4 = +- nse:--es. 1 ~. &h-'s =Csm -

[4[N"'_y N' ' : [ ' ' la u_m '

h-- { nri. *"-MN .: .,. f'i,p f f$9'E-= 2- .d.=  : ..c

-;. r_q--

-.-,s j,..

- -Q - - ~y}- - N:--fM--m- L Me: 1._k7_

5

  • g- .-
:i-4

[',= 'd. k.--A- -

7',w'

, ...-'Jm; N.$-~hmd"m e, s -r-- --~s=-  ? e . - k. .n --

I'+3 T. 9 _y m .M2_

. :=..- ^ j Q.'

_%,q _ a,:-.r,=.E.

-- :i 4,p' %r+ tw + -f d, M - a. AM. -- E .z,i -.-.- g _ + _-

",._e.+J-.- +-4 A M---M. am __ -3 _ J '. gq - -m-. -- 71 du- - -v. . - -# c.

. ._<_+ N

c. i=5 m . -

v.j_ W 2 :2

.m--,.4. .p-,., ,.-:.i f.- . 3..- y n n , =.- . i &&.,q O t . ._ .

..~ g a

- _ =q -m g x- - ~E a%_ ~ N f* ,_-s 7

'UN n. n. ; .2 y[z,.- , .

*7A'_, W ,- kke. -.. _,,

w . =-.=
:

uah3-..Q

~ . 4 - m, w w _.e,--'s._-,-n,.s.  : .j as~+-,-.- , p,.,3 4,.L.g r,,. .%n .a, 3

n
4._L _.%..:. ,,-,~_ .n -f . -- ]f;_ _- _. > . ,. . . f .y _.,-*~ - r. -g.[+=gg y ,__, _g :_
f _

4 3 A..} 7-

%. g , . , - 2 s  ; :. t,- 3

_ '.-.-+-% p.-

.t-.

p:res--r is,.t a:c:1 -r- 'p g

+-4'- 9T*E-D51-Et I

! .,.I.,.M N ; ~'.,' : _a m __4 I'5 NNdM' .i.g. y." * ' -.--l--.'~. ' u s a shs j

.,i.. v i .,

-a- s

' - J su -

-..s  ;- _:= = 7 6_ . i

.m u .m ei-s.----wQ= e_g 4,

6 _g w w,

.ne m, c*

4- .e-. --e

~4 4 - m Wh_ . , _ , ' ~ . za * - W =~

  • 0 *b "' i.$,r ^*T-.Q.G.-[ k$P" ' .

.,: - c, : k: _

o,'_., ,,--.-.,._J_g._*

'- 5 w -- -

- Lj}. D.. - - $ &-.L_: -. ---w-_ - n -- , ,

._.y-

. 3 r- m R- a g -. e-+_.4. ,-

~i *-',t-rgA 'd.-r ~- -?f.a.-:,_..,.,A, -

-r.

z_. _,,_ 4 3 .-t -

-4 -. --bl  ; ,,a g

-- f ar-,%

.m-f.. - _--w-

- t  ;

-.d -43.3 w 4w' * ~ T' '"e*1.;f. M e_.,;_ ,, ; -'**:

. . . - .Ild-.

6 - . M mg-

- m .p t r, f A[g. .;.J_

- +m_

-~****'_-"**W1*a a+**-

4-,~

W -^- r:=ay:es: ,._x .,#hJ r- - _ . .. , 4 ;- t~ - -t* .- . - . N - '7-

  • v5-r e--,Q4 CWp Ls.-,i,;-4 NJ-.L. _.,O , p

.4

+

} N , y 1 _ m sta

, as.u w4g ..a,w ;2g%p a ar . .,r. . -,ac '- .

r 4 s e-

.] . o. m d -g'{ -- c +

-- &4 ta 4,,- -

^

.w.---v ,.n - - - ]

-- . 7., 3 '

'w _ . .

r.. + . , %. g' _4~ 1. .Jah ar'.r Q L e - +.S. . s :i.- . m._ (i.6 is,ws 'g Q . a ._ u a

_'_ ~ - .

-1 . ' '~u

- . _ , ~ , .

ng ; s . ' af. s.r. 1 r .'L - . - -

,qya . ..o,. N * ,

I.

7- _

. . m - , - - . Am., ; ; .  ; b.~-% . p , ye*"@. n. ,.c. ' , ' .. ..

' ,g a '. ~- . ".f:U L%. . ..e' . %. .. ..a.., .:..s .~eU.,'f#,.*CAYa i .a . .*.* . ., a*.4 + ,. . ,, ,* '.i. . g,4. N. ,, ,.,i.n*,%. . g j. ,- ,,, ;

>%, (*- 2. .

n

%. m. g 3. ..w m a,,,c,73 #y~< hg i.;3.gg3.s.,

- ~- . * . . . - ~ . - - , f. .  : m - -;. .,.

-'s

~

r n. .. %.s ,,, , . 5. e

. .. v y y;_g, ~

s gv s- -- .

  • q * .  ;.!, . .a 3 , _
  • * $s.\ weM -- % .seon
  • s. % o '-s*La*w
.e !. c d v . ' + =Y-~ I * * - - -am h '-s..a.. , - -

ATTACilMENT 2

~

The instrument u'ncertainty analysis has been completed. Included in this analysis is the 5%

indication uncertai.ity (due to seismic) associated with the SIGMA Indicator Model No.1151. The results show that the plant design is sufficiently .

conservative to accommodate the combined effects of the instrument channel uncertainties, including the 5% uncertainty due to seismic, and insure safe operation of the plant.

e e

l

\

n

- ,