ML20006D676
| ML20006D676 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | McGuire, Mcguire  |
| Issue date: | 02/08/1990 |
| From: | Tucker H DUKE POWER CO. |
| To: | NRC OFFICE OF INFORMATION RESOURCES MANAGEMENT (IRM) |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 9002140222 | |
| Download: ML20006D676 (4) | |
Text
Fag ~A.
az q-
- s 4
b/,.';;.
~
S 4 lC w
~.q,
- f
- L lbuS pany
- 11 1L T& i.
in,+ ;
i iPU 11ar33llIS.
l' ice President :
~
i u'
~~*%,
- Chartone,NC28242;
. Nuclear (*roduction
- (701)37;i 4531:
Li;,
po Id i1 f
p s
-[' h
+
4 lDUKEPCWERl 9* iPebruary 8, 1990 a...
~
w-
~
s
- p
'( $ f E I l V i; y t
L
[.
.U. S.LNuclear Regulatory Commission r
iDocument Control Desk 4 Y
' N, Washington,:D.C. :20555 O
g J
Subjecti~ ' McGuire Nuclear Stat. ion i
- Docket Nos. 50-369,'370 1
LInspection Report.Nos. 369, 370/89 ;
4
. g-
,Replyfto'a Notice of': Violation g>
l4 A o#
-Gentlemeni'
+
u
- 7
~
[~q
~
- Pursuant to 10CFR 2.201,rplease find attached. Duke Power Company's response
- f 1
~ to Violation' 369; 370/89-38-012and 369, 370/89-38-03' forfthe McGuire Nuclea'r1 W.m Station.:
t Sliould:there be any. questions concerning this matter, contact W. T. Byers at
]
(704)$373-6194.
.y
'i A
.Very:truly,yours,.
s p
y
.t i
A 9q;;L m
c m
.o
.m
%;i i.,;
Hal_B.: Tucker a
o, w
v 1
.1 1 l WTB159/1hs :
15
.t O
,i
^.Atta$hment i
- 6
- xc: Mr.J E. D.J Ebneter-4 Regional Administrator, Region 11 f
- U. S., Nuclear:P.egulatory Commission _
y
~101 Marietta'St., NW, Suite 2900-
^
Atlanta, Georgia-~30323:
w l#
Mr..Darl. Hood.
U. S.TNuclear; Regulatory Commission-
.}
<0ffice of Huclear Reactor. Regulation:
Ll
'~
,,.Mjif f
iWashington, D.C.
20555-
- Mr. P.uK. VanDoorn I
- t..
?
NRC_ Resident Inspector
, L McGuire ; Nuclear ~ Station
.4:
3]I flpNh0YAESEW8888ggyy, I
)
=
n m
u gj < /. ~ ~i [jjM R 71g d!
V
'.}
Wh,.
}
L McGUIRE NUCLEAR STATION RESPONSE TO VIOLATION Violation 50-369,370/89-38-01 1
10'CFR 50.54(q) requires that nuclear power reactor licensees follow and maintain in effect Emergency Plans which. meet the requirements of 10 CFR 50.47(b).
Technical Specification 6.8.1.3 requires,-in part,-that written procedures shall be implemented i
and maintained covering the Emergency Plan implementation.
l a
Section H. 10 of the McGuire Emergency Plan states that station-specific procedures define the inspection, inventory, and opera-tional checks required of emergency equipment.
The specific requirements for the periodic test and functional operability of equipment are defined in Periodic Test (PT) Procedures PT/0/A/4600/79 and PT/0/A/4600/ll.
According to PT/0/A/4600/79, on a quarterly' basis (weather permitting)-an operability test is performed on the emergency boat motor and radio communications.
~
Contrary to the above, during Calendar Year 1989, the emergency boat operability tests were not being conducted at the specified
. frequency in Enclosure 13.1 of PT/0/A/4600/79.
At the time of 3
the inspection,'only one test had been conducted during Calendar Year 1989.
1 i
This is a Severity Level V violation (Supplement VIII).
Response to Violation 1.
Admission or denial of the violation:
The violation is admitted as stated.
e L
2.
Reason for the violation if admitted:
The functional check of the emergency boat was inadvertently overlooked by the personnel responsible for the functional check.
3.
Corrective steps which have been taken and the results <
l achieved:
This incident was reviewed with appropriate Compliance personnel.
4.,
The corrective steps which will be taken to avoid further violation:
Functional check of the emergency boat will be added to the PMPT program.
r I '
m..,
2 y'
1 D
E The date when full compliance will be achieved:
5.
The functional check of the emergency boat was added to the PNPT program on 1/10/90.
Violation 50-369,370/89-38-03 10 CFR 50.54(q) requires that nuclear power reactor licensees follow and maintain in effect Emergency Plans which meet the requirements of 10 CFR 50.47(b).
Technical Specification 6.8.1 e requires, in part, that written procedures shall be implemented and maintained covering the Emergency Ple.n impl6 mentation.
Section E of the McGuire Emergency Plan addresses notification and activation of the onsite and offsite emergency response organization.
Section 2.0 of RP/0/A/5700/01 " Notification of Unusual Event" details the activities regarding notification and activation following the classification of an event at the Notification of Unusual Event (NOUE) level.
According to Section 2.1.2, the State and county notification must be made within 15 minutes of declaring the emergency.
Contrary to the above, on August 24,.1989, the licensee declared an unusual event at 5:20 p.m., but failed to notify Station / local agencies until 30 minutes after the event declaration (5:50 j
p.m.).
L l
This is a Severity Level IV violation (Supplement VIII).
(
l~
Response to violation L
i 1.
Admission or denial of the violation:
L The violation is admitted as stated.
2.
Reason for the alleged violation:
1 L
The condition that requires declaration of an Unusual Event was,the initiation of the load reduction to comply with entry into Technical Specification 3.0.3.
This occurred at 1745.
The entry into Technical Specification 3.0.3, because-both trains of.the annulus ventilation system were inopera-p.
L ble, occurred at 1720.
Notification of the states and i
counties occurred at 1750.
The shift Supervisor prematurely I
' declared the Unusual Event at 1720.
RP/0/A/5700/00, Classi-fication of Emergency, enclosure 4.1, page 22 of 24 states the criteria for notification of an Unusual Event is " loss L
of'both trains of any ESF function found inoperable and load reduction'or plant cooldown initiated in accordance with E
Technical Specifications".
The shift crew was preoccupied in complying with Technical Specifications involving,the l,
l:,
(~
c f ?g :;,S 3
o
..p?
\\
inoperability;of the-annulus: ventilation-system'and failed' to make the notification within 15 minutes.
3' Corrective steps which'have been taken and the results:
achieved:
This item was covered.with the supervision involved and with-
.other operations supervision.
4..
The corrective steps which will be-taken to' avoid future.
t
. violations:
No further actions are considered necessary.
5.
The date when ful'; compliance will be achieved:
McGuire has maintained full compliance.
l
(
L p
1 i
l*
l-4
,o Ni\\
Nsc aEn ng MMb[t bMpnn*nqy M,e MDqpm$$MMM MMnnERRwnmu n
a nn 1, yh y k fs %[ n %nd e p w*3h D nY,n m.
pg -
m m
u m u o e
hMyh m4 y
1kM lpO- [ay%wM_Nf N$
p symspum._y g, [@gu%g&c#wNwg; 6 m.9yw@r_impwg#wMpzw~ygnm m%4%
s w
4 ;hmg aigggg y%s 4 w
p m
g m~ q>g&~M m9g~:ws ' p?nyay m, askpMmgAk.g x
n ggwwwnms orq wW w.m m m.. wwx;&:mWwv..kypn w+. : &w Q g4 g Qgwmw m%MMmWek;;g x s&g w %, wf ys e m Gt s
,p W
x 4
mme.
-, %y v
a n we p
i > y.fy mpwu-y 9impa Qw-y Q,q g M pMy, g g g gy *mg Q q> h My m w a
t J
wy m
w
.gw mys.
M V o w ';wy m w M F ge~7 grw9pm p Nq %g n,-.jy g W h gi 4 % g y" wQ y pyy p 3
4.yy qmw34 y ; men w wp y
a a nun $ h;qs_;u; wA 9 -
,k pd h$
.n
[i-i %
j h
.h Q+,a e%r~w M'f-dI,q/s W W ~a - m? f h%.,+&whuM,% %~ % m A. mM Q 'n n
n n
n n:4 % W W n
n.
M,Y 5t W:
%'*xn'f,fv &w munMDSM k?%n W
M' WW,vWM:m w r W W 4, n%g n o.~
na w -.
mk m
- appz,:s um&.:a v~
n ag 9 2.n r9 m ; 9,ik 1
.n wqw.x mmp%
on m>+dQ,p,M p
-rzk m. m. m :s.e n
u es m:er:Wu-W.r, m.
O&dfW.f&- A' %%.M, &' &+y w M q0l%3 W V.d:QNW W y*-S'D lnA?'% w.w
- h. n s
n q i-u
'
- W %;e c
u n
m9 %:n v.
s mc mu q,jk 4w 3 k O L sWha
- p 3 3
- M' ;
- L ' y'rp m
Q MW ':4% '
MjQ,f? fp M w
u 7
i j &&q.9:
"-n1:
Q 7f D m
y MW 1.%$g. &e &v:% '
n i-k &pf h
w;; f OV v m ne; yn. a N'n,A. 'm%Ug4V&:u g" t g sww&g:4.
x&
.. L-gw;wyv.wl%u %=pek a w.
h &+s,1 a
Q m >
g w sq wyw wkpk
% s %g:y m p + A p.n n
a. w m. n y
w nrw w.. V.&.9 g u a m M.'J.w:up;&.y /g U, m 4V. < 1.w mx m+cm. s W
v w;f 4.n m
nx:n pu, n;mL n' L
m w
y w:
v q ue Lm & u c
x-A R'
w
+v-p m sg:N ; ':(_T<
w m&a.'.Q'4 t.4nu w!N h&n -
w% f
%\\
YYik' m'
w-
, kgM J.QM w.pf'Qw,w,uAQ%y@M.g g. 4..w' h. Nyn;-y Q 4.yg:%)id
?O h
' JJgA ;g/ ra'ht 2,o(.f &s :i f Wk N?
y'3 ?
.?DW.L
.k,
' T Mb/
M.
4 o m"r
,g, m;.y:p'?*%Ijag U g %gy,p.4 gg a wm&w.a w d-s n.
m a
w-s
~-
W m:M a_4/p T.
My y,
6 q*
%W %p%
ng; 4
nW, ww, s, s, ;
M y wp;n... n a n mm,
. %aWW wd :v5 9 gm gp
?g t
aen y wc%mmdW3. pmm..qw _ aps/ n::
i magn v w 4
cyy
.g e w w w c sy" eAv w
w. mnu:wwy m.@m www =M.na4g vp 7,a; y
m mpwwm mu 4
Q', &b. a$@M g j;n.M@$'%gw w m%u%bf&%M, y
p4e 4
o x
vs,cs e %+m,m?WQ? Am W 4 v) a ~wVS
.u n!g ow s.w y vngy u a ww' gN&w Y&; @y,b4 QW w&m a: MpuQpW nWe Ir.
m%y4Q?
i
.a An a cW8 o w
, t NW i kh@um. ev
~
- %a n
no
- &g$%vfQ NWW M
!"4'? ' '
MQ% L%% K' +
AW M Cy%M WWwy W
2 bdV J
.k WN w w pa n.Y:s px p. m%a& W!%w%
dQ p%
W aA.
m w*n.a h v
rmy wga z%;my n m: Qy:+,,
44
,@nwym ww g
.yv m (4 q a,w hp;e y
my2 -.
n.
m,
m sp n y, y + phh;mhm%yngy_vl?,jb' m'Yunlh?hgymm.y?&w&an.hh,l?R Y.- nhW 4
n
- s. %nh Mxw w
ce yY;h Q l ty[9 x1 gVSb(
w.
o.
MD %VFF jf 8 s.
Q:; Yv && Y
- .lA f
m v.,
%y % yf3gp;.d MAf.r _. p n&(y lgfy?g y.gmsgw p
mp w;
l n p$wwm - e n= c4yn pwow n?p ;
- lMM ge.
up??&kMN$kW e
Y f
NWYh O
N
?
a wom a u
wwna me~
. w+hh m
v-v.~ &~
w x w w:y ens 1, k k
h f,kh ix h~M'hk4yW_
N N
'_C N_,.i a,
j
[
-mek#
- [ Va W, %.JM Y N P
? 4
+
e p Q%.g%%n %m.%dO:$$klm>_&&M.&m.gr:.yf %yQM+
m~ te-mm d W n
E W.,
me%:- C.
w 4A
,.n t.
y% gwq v an a r~<m+
v v
QQfyp %g.-..
tg M n w YFM w f~ px, m; j :'; p j;. s $y
,[y n;;[y :~-
mame 6 9 %pfi g %g;;a w% w/p &
.+Mr M:.Qg'
- u +: '<
1 f
y
'(j '
Qt gy:;9.:; r S
m, %WppQb@q@;i i Swpyb M iwh g
e%.Mg-v:gh4y y:c;"n"F ' @t
,r s, p
~
s W 4 6
Nwgi R
w Ae g:n mw3
<,b u dM[+ 1 M-ib[' A> $q w
- M hMT3NN1I S:
ND~hjN'. W
.I (f.
h, 4e N $[1:gwef, L2bb mM wf.;fq%+'h:W h dI$j 4k P
a-w w e mw'.+wxso mem
~ As;A c%
m e
w-u m
M n%+w? hY'YW MlY W
76%
dkV A'" : :
u-wn w?m n%
WdG' ux a n,
=~
m
<na 3 - d6 w w n ww' WWW " nWN W-9 w
1.b Y P* WW '
'd' N-~ % ; YkN ? n$ ? Y.
kY Yf
$hk R
\\"
. i,Y?&hy N
- k g w@el$xW Mf4:m 9W,k.WIdPdrgu W~ ~ du h
Y
%.e $:
O D."# E O W' k
" 5% " OiF, nWMj$-s?3)p>9g M~k l M w,f? '
M
+
- m "h s pa %s%a*c&m%GO, d,w;cyWM;gW.m?
4 82 f M.. -WW W WS&m $8h ny W3-w y-
? k g.ww
&wm%g~ ww m m mu m, W.~, w~ g :8, aarm emn www
+
nn wup m
u-mm a mm 1 wNm%m$0MM-N%UdwN
.a w nv.d@wM N M: n,, % m'[ P S IMEWNW p
Mi
NA.
I 3!
M MN F l
- a :w,m m w%w &y m.(t m
%w p 3
t ~ O,~w@ ew swu n
w u
a
- p. y-4 LD;mDMd@m,b,%gw:W.J,d
- n c.w g^
n, my s w
) %M4 MJ n
~,.
+I U ', #
%w, r_g
<n-P v ?M[s4.a p,Q, l
VJ2 e 4 " n.5 i.
W 5 l M?
W Qu y j nD
%aw'r, 6
w w & nus-wy w u^
4,f Mg n Q@A8pnnw %qpMW ym :-
r w ' Q f, %.. p.
- / =
pS
$ W, w~ - @w%:J::wMym -r
- y) w+w p eQQgy w-.ts-wp e' %y ~ mi%
1 s kJereq Wa%
4 y;A r
%s t wq" wy y %~ -4 4
-4 A
am u
o em
+ s r y upQMMp.' w.WMW@t%d*TVA A-yA m :M h M M 9 M/M f ? p :; mu M MMW,cm m;KJfRxydnw v j
-6 r
A4 riene Nl 13 ^ ~ _i:, + 1 QN t
N+ V_#%sjO V% 'Wy3%
4WW.
9 s g
~
b p qa s,a %, m, m%,myg.M @gw, V~W' i
Mf 3
M gs tww@grM.
pV e
e
< u ag
, ~ m. m u
w%ngny s
m&, <c,wh., W 1 nam;4:,7.%, +y h
J
= ' ' '
<; gy A
,e.
6c. u,he, ~"k-M;,
e.n %- 0
- fm qmn.w - s 4
g3 s,- 2 a-% m'w u,,r.,& P ;wm. wMu
~u-
.. ^
p w
n i
..r_,.
- @ G-hx--
wu.:
r
> '.. yy a p
_a..b v4,M 4 - MM e
- a n, e%.
. a@ n.
s Ro sys e
t
-i
-...sww v u
- MZWns L
i@9y. W
-R n
9 yf e A yhpA6y a'1
' w y;& na<*'w:hye%w
,,g-4
. cy 7,nw & m-.
w 3s 4
L app ig 3
%j y k w &.W u$p"k 4.;ih%p p maNv&y@T&:yJgg m
3 %v Wjn ku:0 nW f.
L pes-4Mw
- sd':
Nw
.W.;Q'Q lh: f y;m _ L >
e s r :Q [t 3-f '
f uff Q Q > WJyQ 5f 20Mdm'fhyR w @mk
~pq ~p 3
a.
q ' Myq?W 49 in
@W.ugW:
r s
~ @NW <
- r n %v - w -Vm4 y
- q4%ws eu u
y,,s w y g w -Fi, v g gj m
g 's +
P Q&p@q%w sgM
- m x
Ma
+
p f m pA ml%m p %
- QMQQ&
wwwm 9 P # $m$q%y:
w Og W,, %, W ;p w
p M,.Om.QL
~
> y
_.s gy m w n n@ylQufyr."m?R,&p w X,v a n.m$ am M,9 Wh@% J% &,,$g "g L4 g
9 4MWty
' WJ da ym w:;; n =ummwn#n;TM AMM?
W w
w, 7,
n m
gf c
y
~ %a w kns%q& w#,,n m y;w-c..u- - n
.s mm >+ w> %:mhw r aa av Aw em n., '
f a %y m%wigee wMw m em--
Mm e e &m,vv.-
1 ss m hg p
- n..
.3 W
r._. %;.- 4
- y. y ~ m.
+
m t
w q r1 wm -
5 e
e 3
c-M h M
be' h
-1.
^
- N
- k') k
's 4
Y m
y$
. %gm[(f kq gyng[.
y l
3,Mensg:%. w4;&
hg' r(-
- y $)
1'
- i 3
s'
, ' ~0;w y,n +4 s
u v3 4 w e,y.n,tWnqq:s ah.wt n r
m' ww@m %g; w,,,
z ia
>.4 a
m%a ngwp-9/;&q#,.hs
-L p, gap
~.
opm er a
m
~W x'
p W T a
- n, u no..E
&n &
&M
. m w
e.. % y_%Q a %a
<o w.um a<g- -.+
m mp
.,..rg
.mm-on 3, m, e
e
.gge n,.t x'
&b 3 4 -
J
%,GlQQp g }. s o
_ - cg'mW' '.-
r c% m'
'f, _ _
- \\ ','
f Q.s - 9' d '
g y ~,
Q fi4 im s-
?
\\
Sip w;p %_4_,~f'5_Q.
sY g,.Q
.j Wp Q- - a (Qf -
n+y M&wy :g mcgo
- j> -
i q&sy MWWhfMT xm a nn p 4n
?
~
m
. R 9 %, d g @p #p :
- < Wp :
n y.m qNe g:pe gc;c 3 j, W #gmwgm :-n+j{_ p, %s;.aW+ L ~ M. c M..
s y :n u y
y y%a n
~ a L M g M+) Q 3 y k p2 WOg V,
~~ M M 4(&<
S1
~c
-vge
. w
- y M;'
gfn c
, g# y % %
%m WuRMM, y"hb p
SWEW Y- :>..
.QtWii a
8 a
a9 q
,gn u
< ns a; n :pm a
hlb,,
r1 h.
f hh h
J h+~. e
- WZ I
h
,- h@cww[$
> n_o.
c n; h " m'n~s
+~ '
2 s
d +.sw a m pr
. e~n:mme
. ::s
' ~ a J n
" ".g m
- i., Uwd m% p 4w a p 1
~C 7
pc 4
s A n
%M f uf7.:
+
4 ew-
- d 4
mm s / j r*.r%CS
.t 4 e t %n1 emq
.v v
- 5
=
m
[m", #g^
41 P gr
.*L.
- AI5 a
Yi ^.
I h3,;VV' N aD wh2 -
Iy W' i! /%n $>1 M2'!...
' $ N II' O' "' '
'6 k O '.
y_. Ng!?Fu rt '% [wN,
dL
,.h
/j bnMd in )kgJ,
{
~ W
%'h
V' u?
'1
~c o
~ ; i s -
-+
y nm m p m:
~
h+
h l
-uh
' bY
. 3,*. M;rM:ea n
T fl 5 k,h
., =
- h. hl '?
?
tid i+-
fkV..
n*
m i
&*, Q&NNf i&ow to..s ec.,$ *hs -i df, ',pm:. -
n Af??Y N
W' myedwwnu w:m<n s
em m p n&y+ m**sw s
w
+
l R*'
U-
+
f W A. 9,. y# _
Uf i w[.y: W'1
.. 1 8
--s#.
- 1. T
'C yL 3
.. m~
1 ".
W~-5
(
c'I i
&.D. %6 m
w gg.
- Q.d!
Y5 elyM%;nufq w.%Q $wQiMy:h v.p 'hl f-v V ' % %)@W i '". _ ' >
Ts
- k.. y gi c
't
<s
^m' '
-:L
""g yM
, ;W*%gr Ag%q%@c JM.e ph._ $_vs
,' n
- b M- :? "
M t
b, w
^
~ a C'
'M w<sn,%m-Ql5&owQ
- 3. [n
'$h m-Mt A$f 4
. ' QWjy$ &m&? [f %'N
. v' 4'
v
+
h Q$
,n ww mm:w se
<a; e, n Wm wg&M.%, s m 47s 2. > ~~
?W4 W.
- p. %
g QHg..Mb.r a
m 3 wh c~
AT6M W K MyM%'1 q
3 n+
f
.1 h
i
[
p 1,
%,% ye4n$f@kn o
i
~ n,
^
@b-N db 4DN di:W i - -
<M C
")
-8 i
s ib - %~ f g[ug h] g@ P)j@@ /p'M94 p p' hdaggg;q.. 3;E "
gg}p q
.gp y"
JWp '
Y' 5 jpgg
?
gh m
g
- y M%gy
~
g$
b $
Y Y
Y Y@
$NNIW k N Y No Y g
W