ML20005C007
| ML20005C007 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Perry, River Bend, Clinton, 05000447  |
| Issue date: | 09/10/1981 |
| From: | Faulkner H Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| To: | Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8111170216 | |
| Download: ML20005C007 (12) | |
Text
b s
SEP 101981 MEETING
SUMMARY
DISTRIBUTION l
l STANDARDIZATION & SPECIAL PROJECTS BRANCH DIVISION OF LICENSING
- ', i -
1
[D'cketMia SERVICE LISTS FOR: - Cli'nton l
"* ^
o ont PDR Perry. m local ~PDR
'~ ~ ~ '
~' ~
River Bend '
TERA..
GESSAR,IIJ 2.
NSIC SSPB Reading LRG II Address List R, Denton
~
~~
~..
E. Case W. Brooks-
\\ U l /(b x l
8, Purple J. Kudrick.
'/N R. Tedesco J. Read - -
8[
'.E N. Fioravante 8I G.- Lainas
'G,~ Ze c h'
~~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
M. Lamastra pl y,ggP A
~ 4 B, Youngblood J. Knight U
Jg/S
'%,,f4g,g]A A. Schwencer S. Rhow
~
- N 7-F.:Miraglia C. P. Tan-c E Adensam R. Bosnak-4
'A
'/4, / T
\\/
OELD D. Ziemann d
ai
()t I&E (3)
K. Kniel ACRS (16)
T. Collins PPAS V. Moore B. Grimes
' C. McCracken J. Kramer R. Boyd, KMC D. Ziemann N. Hughes R. Bosnak H. Bramaer P. Check W. Kreger L. Rubenstein J. P. Knight W. Jchnston D. Muiler F. Schroeder M. Ernst H. Faulkner H. Williams D. Houston R. Perch J. Miller L. Tremper/M. Service 8111170216 810910'
{DRADOCK 05000440 PDR m
y s' ** tio o
UNITED si AT Es E
'k NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION E.
WASHINGTON. D. C. 20555 SEP 101981 v.
e.
e.
DOCKET NOS.: 50-440/441 STN 50-447 50-458/459 50-461/.462
SUBJECT:
LRG II -
SUMMARY
OF MEETINGS AUGUST 26 and 27,1981 Meetings between the LRG II working group and NRC were held on August 26 and 27, 1981 in Bethesda, Maryland.
The purpose of these meetings was to finalize a list of issues amenable to common resolution by the participating parties and to clarify the specific needs of NRC for each issue. The meetings were attended by representatives of Illinois Power Co., Cleveland Electric Illumin-ating Co., Gulf States Utilities Co., General Electric Co., and KMC, Inc.
An attendance list is attached in Enclosure 1.
7
'.he document providing tie bases for discussion at the meetings was the l
list of issues developed by NRC (Memorandum for NRR D1 vision D.irectors from L. Ribb and H. Faulkner of August 3,1981) and previously providedlto LRG II.
These discussions resulted in the addition and deletion of some issues.
A final list containing 51 issues was compiled and agreed upon by all parties.
A copy of this list of issues is attached as Enclosure 2.
This list will r ovide the basis for joint resolution of licensing issues common to the Clinton, Perry, River Bend and GESSAR II projects.
A meeting of the LRG II executive comnittee with Harold Denton and s'enior NRR management has been scheduled for Tuesday, September 8,1981.
At that time, the LRG II committee will discuss their approach to the common re-solution of these issues.
.h H. d. r ulkner, Proj,ect Manager Stan i:ation and Special Projects Branch Division of Licensing Attachments:
1.
Attendance List 2.
Compilation of Issues f
Ammar onumm cenar,,,,,,, Q g j G C
=-
u-8 e
m
Attendance List LRG II Meetings of August 26 & 27, 1981 Illinois Power Company-NRC D. L. Holtzscher R. Tedesco H. Faulkner Cleveland Electric Illuminating Co.
T. Collins L. Beck W. Brooks'
~
~
~
- E. Buzzelli J. Kudrick
~'
J.' Read Gulf States Utilities J. Wermeil W. Reed J. Knight
~-
L. England
~
S. Rhow E. Grant-C. P. Tan:
P. Matthews r
General Electric Company.
R. Bosnak 2
M. Anciaux K. Kniel O. Ziemann J. Fox V. Moore KMC C. McCracken
.R. Boyd'_
}
.1 C. Anderson
~
3 i
~
E. Rossi M. Tukar S. Sun
~
L'.
Yang D. Tarao i
9 r
ym --&
wp-,.-e,-.+
~
w~e me,,-, -
~ s ww-
-.c
,~ -
SEPTEMBER 1; 1981 1e 1.! o n.
L
,,c.,
- .1,.1.
t i
5, I
j',
):
I LRG-II COMPILATION OF' ISSUES CLINTON i'
PERRY RIV5R BEND
(
I' 1ti.
t '. i.
.>ti..
+
i NOTE:
THIS COMPOSITE LIST (51 ISSUES) WAS DEVELOPED AS A CONSEQUENCE OF THE AUGUST 26-27, 1981
~
><=
LRG-II WORKING GROUP MEETING WITH REPRESENTATIVES OF THE NRR REVIEW BRANCHES.
,4
.p.
f e
LRG-II COMPILATION OF ISSUES L
i e:tui t due i.n.3 ?
l
't n i
.ut n
'l.
1-RSB Requirement for Autorestart of' HPCS Af ter Manual ~ Termination (II.K.3.21) 2.
2-RSD Design Adequacy of RCIC (II.K.3.13, 15 and 24)l
~
i 3.
3-RSB Commitment to Participate in Saf'ety-Relief Valve; Surveillance Program 4.
4-RSB Operator Actions Required 10-20 Minu'tes'Follo" win'g a-LOCA 5-RSB Control of Post-LOCA Leakage to Pro'te'ct ECCS'alid Preserve Suppression Pool Leve'l f 5.
l 6.
6-RSB Applicability of Liquid-Flow-Throuih-SRV Test (Part of II.D.1) 7.
7-RSB Provisions to Preclude Vortex 'ormatidn'(Ad'equa'te NPSH)-
F Operability to ADS Vis-a-vis Long' Term nir' Silhhl'y '(II.K.'3'.28) l 8.
8-RSB
- 9.
9-RSB Long Term Operability of ECCS Pumps'(Post-LOCA)
~ ~ ' ~
~~
i10.
10-RSD Single Failure LOCA Analysis With Sub' sequent'Ffow' Control' Valve Closure ill.
ll-RSB Use of Non-Safety Grade Equipment in Shaft Seisure Event 12.
12-RSB Classification ~ of Transients: Turbine Trip'w/o Bypass &' Generator Ioad Pejection w/o' Bypass 4
il3.
1-CPB Fuel Rod. Cladding Ballooning'and Rupture,
3-CPB Channel Box Deflection (Need for Friction Flow Test Program)
!16.
4-CPB High Burnup Fission Gas Release
~
17.
5-CPB Cladding Water-Side Corrosion (Cu 'Eoncentraticnin Feedwater) l
,4 e
Y
_2_
~
4 18.
6-CPB In-Core Thermocouples to Measure Inadequate, Core Cooling (II. F. 2) s 19.
7-CPB Rod Withdrawal Transient Analysis-(Tech' Specs :onqRod Withdrawal' Limiter) 20, 8-CPB Fuel. Analyses for Mislocated or Misoriented' Bundles l
21.
9-CPB Discrepancy in Void Coefficient Calculation
.i 22.
10-CPB Rod Worth: Bounding Accident Analysis 23.
ll-CPB llydrodynamic Stability Analysis (For'Operati'on Beyond First Cycle) 24.
1-CSB Containment Issue:
Pool Dynamic Loads ~( swell velocities, etc.)
25.
2-CSB Containment Issue:
!!ydrogen Management
____________________________________________________________________________________________________q 26.
1-AEB Reassessment of Accident Assumptions Tied to MSLIV Bypass Leakage Rate BWR Scram Discharge Volume (Response to 12/1/80 Generic Letter on BF3 Incident [
27.
1-ASB 28.
2-ASB Safe Shutdown for Pines (Sec. 3.G and 3.L of Appendix R) 29.
3-ASB Protection of Equipment in Main Steam Pipe Tunnel (BTP ASB 3-1 revised.7/1/81) 30.
1-RAB Exposure Resulting From Actuation of SRV's 31.
2-RAB Routine Exposures Inside. Containment 32.
3-RAB Controlling ledioactivity During Steam Dryer and Steam Seoarator refuelina Transfer
e.
,n-
.?
co.
v < e.,.,. 1 33.
4-RAB Shielding of Spent Fuel Transfe'rt Tube 'ahd, Canal duridg N, ef ublincjl R.T.'-
7, C
g..
s-34.
1-ICSD Failure in Vessel Level Sensing Lines Common to. Control & Protection' Systems 35, 2-ICSB Lack of Diversity of Interlocks Isolating High and Low Pressure Systems 36.
3-ICSB Potentia 1 for Both Low-Low Se.tpoint Valve,s to Open Owing to. Single Failure 37.
4-ICSB Loss of Safety Function Af ter Reset (Bul. 80-06)
,o,,
38.
5-ICSB Control Systems Failure (I.N. 79-2'2)
~
39.
6-ICSB Procedures Following Bus Failure,(,Bul. 7,9_27) i 1'.
40.
7-ICSB liarsli Environnent for Electric Equipnent FollQ _High Energy Line Breaks (I.N. 79-22) t'
_______________.______.___________________.__________________.'._______________________e._____.
i l
41.
1-PSB Reliability of Diesel Generators (May be ASB involvement also) y 42.
1-GIB Interim Licens'ing Bases Pendingl Resolution o.f~ Unresolved
- Safety Issues
.j l
________________________________________________.m.____________..____________.
t e.,
1 1
.e.
j 1.,..
43.
1-IIFS Special Low Power Testing Program :(I.G.1) j l
~
44.
2-IIFS ATWG EOP and GE Reactivity Contro'l'. Guidelines, (I.C.1).
45.
3-ilFS Common Reference for Reactor Vessel Le',v,el-Measur.ement (II. K. 3. 2 7)
____e._______
__________f l'______
---_____-_-__4
-_---_-__e
- l 46.
1-CllEB Reactor Coolant and Suppression,iPool Sampling (II.,B. 3) j 47, 2-CllEB Estimation of Fuel Damage From Co lant and Pool Samples p
e.
W. e. e.
- e. 8.
- e. e.
- m. e. e. e. eu.
al. _ e. e. emD e.
mi.
- a. m. em. e. _ e.
em.
m.
_ eu. u. a. _
emo e..* me
- a. -
- e..m _ _
_ _ e.
een _ am. es. a e.
- m. es.
_ em..us
- e..us e.
eu L...
x, 48.
1-MEB Input, Criteria for Use of SRSS for Mechanical Equipment (NUREG-0484, Rev. 1) 4.
RPV Internals Vibration Assessment Program for BWR/6.
49.
2-MES 50.
3-MEB OBE Stress Cycles Used for NSSS Mechanical Equipment Design Inspectability of Welded, Flued Heads on'MSL. Containment Penetrations 51.
1-MTEB m e.
..e. ee mm e.es..sm er - e. - am es es se a-.. am - en -. -.= -. - ee -
e - am me.. -
.e am e. - ee se em en.-- een - me.. am m az em - se m. -.a 3
8 l
r e
I a
9 5i d
i
^9
+
g eq e e t
i
- 4
+
e e
+
9 I
111knoisPowerCcmpany cc,b/ enclosure (s):
S v. -.
J!r'.[ L. d. Koch, Vice President Mr. Hugh K. Clark, Esq. Chairman
- Illinois Power Company P. O. Box 127A 300~ South 27th Street Kennedyv111e, Maryland 21645 Decatur, Illinois 62525 r"~
Dr. Oscar H. Paris Mr. Julius Geier Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Illinois Power Cpmpany U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 500 South 2/th Street Washington, D. C.
20555 Decatur, Illinois 62525 Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Mr. Peter -V.
Fazio, Jr.
Appeal Board Panel Schiff, Hardin & Wai.te U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 7200 Sears Tower
~~
Washington, D. C.
20555 233 S'outh Wacker Drive Chicago, Illinois 60606" Dr. George A. Ferguson School of Engineering Mr. H..H.1Livermore, Resident-Inspector Howard University U. S.. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 2300 Sixth Street, N.W.
RR 3,'. Box 229A.
.~
j?
Washington, D. C.
20059 Clinton, Illinois 61727 Mr. Richard J. Goddard, Esq.
Mr. D.1.. Foreman, Project Manager Office of the Executive Legal Director General Electric Company 2i:-s U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 175 Curtner Avenue, M/C 682 Washington, D. C.
20555 San Jose, California ~ 95125 '
~
Mr. R.- C. Heider, Project Manager Sargent & Lundy Engineers 55 East Monroe Street Chicago, Illinois 60603 e
k
GF,: r '
Mr. Dalwyn R. Davidson Vice President Engineering c.The. Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company
'cPr.9 :0. Box 5000 Cleveland', Ohio 44101
- _ c '.. r
.L5 L :.
?cc:
Gerald Charnoff, Esq.
Shaw, Pittman, Potts & Trewbridge 1800 M Street, N. U.
Washington, D. C.
20036 i.a;
~ Donald.H. Hauser, Esq;
' Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company
--P. O. Box 5000 Cleveland, Ohio 44101 U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Resident Inspector's Office
'Parmly at Center Road.
Perry, Ohio 44081
- i!
Donald T. Ezzone, Esq.
Assistant Prosecuting Attorney.
- 105: Main St'reet:-
. ' " ~ "
- Lake ~ County A~dministiat'ioM Cente,
Painesville, Ohio 44077'^'
~'
n Tod J. Kenney -
228 South College Apt. A Bowling Green, Ohio 43402 Daniel D. Wilt Wegman, Hesiler & Vanderberg 7301 Chippewa Road, Suite 102 Brecksville, Ohio 44141 Jeff Alexander 920 Wilimington Ave.
Layton, Ohio 45420 Terry
- Lodge, Esq.
915 Spitzer Building Toledo, Ohio 43604 e
0 e
Dr. E. Linn ' Draper, Jr.
Vice President - Nuclear Technology Gulf States Utilities Company P. O. Bo'x 2951 Beaumont, Texas 77704 Troy B. ' Conner, Jr., Attorney
- cc:
Conner andWetterhahn Suite 1050 1747 Pennsylvania Avenue, N. W.
~~
Washington, D. C.
20006 Mr. J. E. Booker
. Manager - Technical Program:
Gulf States Utilities Company P. O. Box 2951 Beaumont, Texas 77704
~
Stanley.Plettman, Attorney *
' Orgain, Bell & Tucker Beaumont Savings Building Beaumont, Texas 77701 Karin P. Sheldon, Esq.
Sheldon, Harmon & Weiss 1725 I Street, N. W.
Washington, D. C. 20006 William J. Guste, Jr., Esq.
Attorney General State of Louisiana Post Office Box 44005
" State Capitol Baton Rouge, Louisiana 70804 Richard M. Troy, Jr., Esq.
Assistant Attorney General in Charge State of Louisiana Department of Justice 234 Loyola Avenue fiew Orleans, Louisiana 70112 O
e 9
GESSAR II General Electric Company ATTH:
Glenn G. Sherwood, Manager Safety & Licensing Operation nuclear Power Systems Division 175 Curtner Avenue, Mail Code 682 San Jose, California 95125 m.
cc: Mr. Joseph F. Quirk, Manager BWR Standardization General Electric. Company 175 Curtner Avenue San Jose, CA 95114 Mr. L. Gifford, Manager Regulatory Operations Unit General Electric Company 4720 Montgomery Lane Bethesda, Maryland 20014 Director, Criteria & Standards Division Office of Radiation Programs U.S. Environmental Protection Agency 401 M Street, S.W.
Washington, D.C.
20460 s
e e
i I
-e
,-