ML20003E864

Response in Opposition to Intervenor 810401 Motion to Reopen Record Based on Misidentification & Portrayal of Lake Norman.Motion Contains Only Allegation,Unsupported by Facts. Affidavit,Maps & Certificate of Svc Encl

ML20003E864
Person / Time
Site:	Perkins
Issue date:	04/15/1981
From:	Barth C NRC OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE LEGAL DIRECTOR (OELD)
To:	NRC ATOMIC SAFETY & LICENSING APPEAL PANEL (ASLAP)
References
NUDOCS 8104170404
Download: ML20003E864 (11)

Text

' day of April, 1981.

.72lry Publ4ckit 4,.&

tY'**'h!Y NO.u

/

//

My Coanission espires 7 -

/

~1/See tranwript pages 3105 ff, 3150 ff, 3242, 3782, and 3285; staff exhibits 10 and 11. and staff testimony following ' transcript page 3249.

l

(..,

. y-f,~?..;S y

js ':

.Y h ~. > ,

8

\\.i r

,~.,r.3

/

(/

. - (.'., \\

'j.

n ' $ ~.; ' ~..

-(

\\

"f'

,j -s j-

\\

(, 7 6

,,. \\.

./

..../,.

4.... 1-

.m-i..

./

. s.t. c?

s.-

~,

......y1

(

a g:.. i., :.. y.

.'),('-

.C,..

..-4

/

\\

-y n'ii

/' ~ lr-U. '.^

f*..

-].s.-

.(u 9

i.r.

.. '\\..:.:,. <\\,.. -

->r N /-

. l. N,g s.

n.

'i

-m t

]

........-Q:...-es,

.c,,....~.

MN65,~.

..:,... T

~<

. - ~

.\\.'

(7:

. }. j '.,

h f ': S f ~

rC' _' '

.~\\.9 f 1,:.L. < '.)y *5 } /~.1..k,V l:..

~

.%J)

, f:.

~

.:' >. C'li /,i -. I;

?.

.., M

. (" (c'

?.p 3.._ R '

~.4,,}g.:[ '+'-

Q.: %

y:.

.1.. w'. '

. s. ~

~

f. o J:)~y

~

.Q<.

(G.i)

~

<?

p p }.

3!

p ~

j

-h 7.j 2.Onf 7

3. - 'N, v' :

/4 4

\\

/

',)/,W(TD h [

h'

I/

ks

Ds','f

_.yt

~

f..l.N'Q_.l-l!, b ' qg.. ' 2 ;; 4 q

~ o L

_ \\]' '

n S

i

(

,,. f' i

fs

~~),

m-s

..y F\\g:.f,.{,,,~;.

3 3, --

t... f y'

iS E

( ' ~ " '..!.~.. :h R,,- f '>',,

-g'

y..'N

',. ss b

f.

L,. \\f' y

2 s

6

\\l,-

i :.!,

.l$ Q

. / ' 4' t,1,l',i Nv.^~ i, J Q (4 '3 l - V y

- (y.

N.

.n.A.,

a x,-

. 3,,..,.

. ~.

=.

-c...

.. ey

~~%.

. Q. 9 e.~

M..r 1 L. '-

.E..

1. y%%D) I 'b.w' 17D6,g. ' 5't h ts l'.

O ' " ' '

j

\\

e/?,,(,O.d(_>

t

i s.-l, N.

3 s

s g

LV 7,pf s

t-i n.

' fj ;

h.

I

_ _, l j ',..

%'s e.

/

L

-5 \\.~[.,r'p,*0:( j\\.

7 4

g r

q,. /

~.

' V

(___ J 5

~

c

% g'1 j

c, c' '

t

-~

\\

r

~.

g. ?:ci

..\\.

, /

....,.)r[ F '

s

'Y NOC

,-l;--

,f

,b

.. ~..

/l-

~

~

Q- ~~~. g' h,

Q I

'% ' ~,,

l,'

s c g 7

'N I

.s g

11ap 1 from Intervenors' 110tian

/.

/

,A., j \\.. ', 3

, \\.

e 3

'q Dated 11 arch 31, 19S1

.Q 1

P00R ORIGitQ:s, // c

'~

1 Exhibit i 8

c

,8 * )6h /

3

.s l

.,. 1

/.

3

. c

.s

.,. i

.j

(.

f.

\\

r' s..f p

r.

.;g

..y. -

}

8

\\

.'- /

's. N t

.......(

%.,. N t

,5.

a.

3:.

.r.. )

. t-t< '.

2.' '

' t...,,..1 st'O

.t.

~

,.. t

.. u..

...,2 v-t I,

r

~

1.

r

's s

,1

/-

a n. -a

• ...J - "N ' ~

i?

N.'Y c, f-..%

.. ~

's tv - I < ' > :. -

sr l

f

,s e

e

. ;e...... I. 8, '1./.- /l;<.ft'*..

I

. ~. '

i

.,.\\,... - m

.-l l -:* 1

.h -

,1 y

.. i-

.-. t a.g n

r i

g l

._j r

'~

glx-

\\

• ) f;

., < K c, s r

I

.- j s

,,i., d.'. t

,. :p> e r-

.t l

7-

,t u

~

ei d_,

M.os,,f f-

/

'N 7,

.p 1

I

}'i 96 h> t

.- 4

't.4 l&.b

%/ ~ ~.flc G

,/

j ;$ 9.n tO-

. l

\\

J,-*N**.c[as't.-R 1

n!

fj y

\\

,a i

ik...,.,/ f,.i j

..,L. 2...

{f

.f

~

/

v

, e.

r g r s.

gr e fm s

7

[., P: ".-

. p

, - %.j.y%.5'U -

r, >..I"'

U

%'/.

l

/

.p.,K.

s..

c \\ e.

c-

~; : 0 A

/

q,s q

\\n

\\.'IeeX r,-

t%

4

/

'/

> W:,

N~~

\\

M.-

r

/

l..'.) Q W s. % \\c* 'f.

4 ;3;

/

. b o s. $ h i- (

3

.,N,

/

e. N '~ s,As..<h,..

'Rx,.7,r

., s s M..

1o g

t

, - (., g T.,C 'J

^ % \\

.c c

sh e-1.

M W. ~ &.e p t

\\

/ C. ?

e r}

'.s

+Qs~~ ~ '.

' ~.,

t -*

c.

g

,t.

. s. s,. s 8,

• \\

sy o w.

ai N

..g#;.. -.. \\.

~

i., ? '

1 9,.

N.

bwk

~9-

.- l sv

..--;;.g

.\\)g.

4' o a

n y ~.~)

.:.-47 n_.

l.d a

m/ c, I,;_N'N.,en..-.,. v-.

-=%

. c.

.bi'..s

.et-1 v

j'I,og

.s s

,s n,

s.

s.

c p

7,., A j[ \\l,

.).,,

)

~I \\

~

^

i 7. / i ~. 2

.) e, \\,.

,% '* i.-....... - - '.i%.

l4 g

,,.g f

\\,,:'\\ Y U, l,>c\\-[

3) t

)

/.

• f f.2 je

/

J.~', &

\\

/

f.J.,,w?,.J' 3

• g./

j8

(

y,,\\

b M....i, '.' i i

ez.d..

r.~d, <,. e. 3>..s {'

s a

.e. @

a

. s \\) ;t s

g-,

'f -

e i

.lr -s *'.'

'3 o

o/

o ll// zp)s' -

/},

?

?

Y

(

'N.

g z-

"h /

/.

, g3

• A='

• f. f O

h 1-f

_q

)

l=*

j,

tf t '

[

. ;,/**. -

.?,-

,6 f *](. t, r

q f

,/" '

0 s

~ * - -

g

.~.a.8. ;s I.,....

r

, \\.i m..,,

s. =.\\*4,.f,o

~

-/.v s

t n

s.

b

[

O O

's i

V

..v.,

3 x

a.f,-

3 9

4 o

s a

(_..$'P,~$ \\

'/'.[ h s, /.

5 kk' f' M t.a \\,..s_.., w]i :.t,.I}.-+q(t

,. m r ~ __

it 9'6

{'

i "V ' ? n ?

I..

... g ;,

l

.'..s,%

~~i,\\..I M g

-~-~~--~..l\\.<','-.-.,,

c:.

........ o

,, ' ;, s.

'co 1

e

\\\\

1,

\\ / T'-

m'.cQ, 1

., y r-N.. ~ ' 'f 5 im a

... y< '

s.

m\\)

\\

n\\,.

.o_ e> \\

i

~

V

.s r

.e

,s s \\ o \\ \\) N,

\\ %,<

• :)

)

i'ap 2 from Intervenors' Motion

.\\

h l

\\

,3

. - (.

Dat ett March 31, 1981 f

(

r,

,e 1

7 fxhibit 2

. ~ -

S

sy..)

./.'.

1 1

i c

.\\

h

i

}

),

\\

i v.,/ c t

s

, -)-

X-

, s N

e g

-)

s

\\.

N

. t > s.,

r

,... ?

'.s s

)

s.

\\.<

[

1 ;,

s s.... \\. x 3.-

. e o

f e.

N s.

s q.v

.a.

1 4,.

v.s '

a: a;. v O

a o

t -

s

, \\;.: \\,

^

~

1

~

,-8 s;

Q

.c 9e

(

p y.

e 3s

. ?,,i a..

n 2;.,...

s.s.

t g

.r.

s-

\\.,j

'> N j-T.,,

og-}s

/ n.-

Q

.:.S s

,e b

e;s +cm,s, s -:o.<~..

\\.y <.. A.)

s W-s i

s.. c c

o

.L,

.e.

v

/<-

~.:a,v -r,w!

s, :-~.

g \\

e

,-c -

5: -

9 f

N

.?,

.r..c e

/[.

s L'

.g i-L,, 0

[-

a

~

c

- y#

.. :. l.

8

}

\\

y

.3 t.1 w

,i.\\

6' g

~,

,c.

~

C')

J

(

.,._ i ;,,

c,.

s wx

=

r;-

/,

.~-

Co s.

-n s

5

.-r. \\

C,; i p

c. i vb w

, 2

,x.

(.. :.Q

'I

./,~%y< 4.... sl x

\\

^

... \\

J

.f eg 1 Lr.-

-< 4-

8. ;..

o l

n..s.

.., p; -. '.., - f).,.id ,.

.g A,

.'y l<,

'. t, ).

R : y q l 5!

t b

m 1

s, q).).:.

. 5

f. >c ;, e a

0 -

o, o

b N.

.g

,.. c. ~. /..

i v

c.

t-d N~m,;,.J sl c.f _....... i,h,..n -], } 'e s\\.n..- a

~

s l

n-s s

(,1{)/>

t.x

/,

i

'r I

a' b!-s.

y d: c' / -

J-l r

&~

Eu

/:m o

y

.^

,: n Ic

s,

/ :. ( O iS-Qr'\\r, r(. f(*' / o ? ;,

r s

e N.

v

/

/

~ c

's., = {-

s.:

jf; S

f N

,.... <,.4, '

.~.

- d. f h

g ! g ;i 5

x ~

LLI g/.,n

. s-

\\,-

)\\ '*,

.,/

' ~.

\\ qf ys r,

\\

r-i r,-

G, 9,, # *f73s.,'b-[.)e&k,3,

'\\g ';' h,,,

g, n

I

.m. >.g 3..-.fQ '* l,' ' ' ~'. l

~.."3 3

i s

e s '_.

g%

b-r

- s >

a c

,. o

.,s.

Y *,,.

• x

/

';~~.,\\.

,f N,

.~

r n

• L l

S.'4 }.

c,,

{/,,':.')n j o

'.,p*,o,

.. ' s, -

J l'.

1 y l-k ' :..

. 1r.,;...

~-

t. - ~

.c.,

r.

i r {,.

'5

\\

c y

f "o

'*,>. l:,ll 'l. l :-

'C. .\\

y/

re. y v y,,V;.. t,'.,j-s,,:.

I, ~

- \\

m 3,.

g q

a

- i q

\\ - " ' ' j-

-y, y

o J', '- ('

5 -

.z

, N o

/.-

s-j

".. g '

. -(, f,. /'

i

\\

g 5

'"'N k \\-4 h. [ ;

,%:.: ).

i:'.

J - 1 ~. \\} >/ e

/,a,r))c,'s.e ' 'h,,,

.~

/

I,.J O,

.i

. ~..

.w

-,/

j

[.-)

c. ',,-

r. ~

y' *

.--,,s

.[r-q,. J *2 c.

o' l

,. J

-.. j c.

' Nf'4.

.+*

./

6'.'

.T

'i !

a

,...,'.l.'.'

sa1c A

(.--

1.,.

v.

7., f.o,,,

J.D t w

.s s.

(

g 3.,..

'e s;.

t

., ' '. wf't

.3 i'N.(3 e

s

.>. s b

.,s i k's',

o.

=q:.

k,v. 9

.,3

[

% j.

'."..;10 ( T

, %~ g y :,

1

'T.

. <.~,~t y

.,,f){.,.' -

sl.j, a

s,s

/, -

.. r. (l

-.'5 l 3

')s i,.,,:.

w O'

NN f-

,A

,'q

, s.

$,.9~

P-

\\

m 3 from Intervenors' :1ot ion

f-3 Dated l' arch 31, 1931

/

,N E> hibit 3

/

)

i

?,

'3, 0

'W

.,7 F

e

\\

o t !,'y.,. (

\\

/ '{, '. ' ;n,,/.

jl'

/

).

11

/

t'

../ ls

(

(

\\lt>:

l;

's y

. 'l/'y.-.., ('Q / '

l :.

/ !..\\

(,s *.i,

~f.\\

\\.M.'.L. ':!.C [ \\ ;- ~

f

)

I s N, it

', /

3

'/

,\\s s

i

)

I

.\\

x

-./. t, %,.

.. ' t 3. t E ( co. g '. n.s

,. l, '

Is

/

/

J t

(

f

's

/

g i:i,

s. p\\.

ia g t-g, a,y.,

'g y7

-)..

y, -.--:

l l \\,

..o.

u

/ [:>l

/

1'.'.

r

• i fi:.-

['

/

l / }, s,'[s a.

\\

($ '.

/

H..41i.!S I,

s, s.x.

)

i

.[.%s,,'e N

s%

/(

.).,

~ -

s

~

t

..~.,.s,.

/

t e,.

(

y s

',,. I I- }? ~Q _ _./,\\()ii,.

l,.,';,,

'(!

y

/

\\

l *fI

(

I 0.

' ' ~

,~.. ;,

)

y

\\.l.. *. i s i :

f

~ ~.

(

• i

( 'i

)1

)

/

i

/bcp y %

\\

' ,Q. ' f

')

/,

,}

},. 'i i

\\

t' r i

1.

3. !

t

).5?b b. ~, *,!

~

i. *';l' j 1y?,.: ':,*. (k; t

, '. l %

/

' 'N -

_..f' l

.. T

~

,... = _ =.]..s

., i,

( j.,

. '. w.,

j I*.

l

/,2.l.;,,/L) l-llt '; '

.,. y

\\

h vi,.~4 N C)

/

- n

, j': }

^

y

/

,/

. O. t\\, (Ja ; <.1,.

p

~

~

.' S o

q

\\.

s t

i s3 m,,

\\ i

}\\

'(-

a s.

1 y

6 j/ --

._(..

./.,

,5 [\\. b /) ;/g'/:~ / CE';(. / _li/O ". _

.8.., N

\\

,s

,s y-s

[., 1 s,

S/UIdf/(k.x...i.. _ff/

s., ) ( h l l I l )$

Nj

- ','.,,[cGLh;,..\\

\\

1

\\

\\

s i

N, I

./.,

s zu

-1/,

(

\\y.

-[

>4

\\

-/

\\

s s

\\

s\\

',/ 'l.. ;.

^

s, ss

.'\\\\

(

\\

l

\\

\\

',/

Q. (.3. d.s :s. o.

,2 s..

s.

,/

s s

.Q d

.N

-.s

)

\\'

b17.ISL'.~'O

'..\\. \\..\\

-(/

s s>

c,.

.[

(

'r

> N

/ i a c si e s yc.;G CO.

f i

'~

S Tt,NL EY C,0. k lde c R/l cry i

t

.....~

.e.3

\\

1 s

/

'N

)

.I

'l'.,'

\\

l 2 C N.. ~Y..[ '..:: /.,?.. 'N' '. ' '

/

.i s

.l l* L'll F. W,.!

'. ' " y '

/

e-

, d' 's...

r...

i -

l li

\\

\\

l y, /

.,. _ f

/,'

f

'k i

~

.',/

/

\\

.,, ~.. -,

(

j

[.

Part of figure 10 from Staff Exhibit 10

.,.- /

i 1

3 s

l I..'

g Y,

in Evidence, Transcript page 3061 N

N Titled Phase 1 Siting Study g

)

)

1 1

\\

.,,j-i f..

'\\

\\

I i

s.,,,

. ~ ~ s. 1 N.. }

J '),

\\,s\\

\\

,... ',K.. t vt., :

.....> 1

?i t

\\

s s

u s

\\1

' toc.i(;.'.//;

N ' -..... /

..\\:'3

\\' i :.~,'.m' j*,y't.. % lE ko/U.:. : I C;. /-CC '. *

~~

r i * * '.j:.-

\\

'i i 1. ; :. i.'..\\,

I. t. r. n Y

.,l. Alsl:.

un t.oes.t. co. 4-,, g-;-

\\

)

~. _

.,/

s

'I

, gc,,.u co,

/

, - _ 't

'" ' 1 1

s s.

I

/,. -

's t 5 U!JI'l:Al.0 S::?Al S/ [j ai b

\\

/....-s.'.

,/ /

8

• , q ,/* i....

...,[../. p'

/

3, s ' '. l,%. '. A CO. t I t,,y/ -

a']

t' '

/

3, g

.(

)

,,(1l'/... : 1... t.. ). ',. Ii: : l.t

,1/ *...

i. 'l. l s t. '/,. ) ;

,,(A,

t.,

,i

\\

/\\

.. ? if

.*'f

'\\

/ //

lI

/l l

/ /

/

j

./

'*j g

\\

\\

/

,s

.,. f' >., li (/ 6 b 5 )

/

I

,,. - i,0!.

T1

~,

I

\\ j').Q'.j,)/

V'

,1),t

\\

/ )../)

(

-j.\\ (N. L'.

, '.' '. f ' /

( )

,/

,[\\~~

4

3 I

)

\\

\\ y :.q

/

i ) \\

q.-+ -

i _..\\. s. x..'

.../

/

s

--, [,.3 g t

/

1

\\g

\\([i;O;.,

)'

-[

"\\

~,, 'd' f

\\

\\

\\

\\

\\

N; i

i g

/

g

\\

1 t

i s

s

//

v(u

.34

\\

\\

-\\ s.

s e WC %' 01\\

si

/,cC.

s, g 3s

/i j

\\

% 'o3 %

\\

\\I l

'?

./

s

'e

) R:\\'.iT'Sl' X'... <...t,k..\\.C,;. -...g f

,.. '![ j "

.-.s.

s.

N N1 x

i I

tr

..~,}\\[0fbil.

),yj jy n

y

\\

,e.

1,., 3,o...,,V N,

', fgf,jf,fy g,; 3

\\

N f

\\l..'

/.AN/f i

s 's \\

I i

/

\\

\\ N i

m:n ca j\\

f

(.

~ w

.. -\\

3 <"

N l

/

/

s.

g

..... P %o

\\ ;

1. ,,.ECKl-'NEURG CO.

' [/f

's

/

M ' J: 1 i j

/

.o

/

c '.., !

s

% l' U 7/<U

/-)

I 3 '.i.,.., s )

i I

\\

,,. ~,.

.. \\

,i

\\

l lt'

...c. / -.. i

\\..li

's

)

)

\\

/

t s,

..s 1

i s\\

\\.

_u. - g s f.

g i,<

\\ s-

\\,,i t s

s

's s.

l l

,/

q.,,...,\\

\\ )f s-

~.

...,1

/

/

,-g h

'. ' g -. -. y\\ -

'. *, '.t' (';.6. Rli' Q' \\ ' t W

./ /,. '

/

/

y

c. 5,' l..,.,.,.,\\.. \\,

,t., /

/ ~,.

s 3 ~.%

i os

.. :1 j [

3 1."D,.. ':l Tl_l.',\\ / ; /./._ /1,/l 7

) z ~,. - ;\\

,/

,i i

s 0

/

/

~.-

/

', p '"

3

/.f

'h - E i

.l. 's

,/

i y'i. ' '

l.K i

s s

/"-

i e

1 i

.)

e

,. r ~. 3 v)

,-"s

/

\\

/,. /

s 6,

.:Q g

g x

.:. y

\\

t-

\\

N N

'N N/

a (..r%2[] \\

'is t.,, l' t...;

i

,e 1

g

's \\

/

I s i :i.I.

S l

• l' O R _ f.

s R' V L.if g.l

/

/

's s

f

. s, g :~

..,:si

./

l' art of Figure 10 from Staff Exhibit 10

., / ) *' ('

in Evidence, Transcript page 3061

..(

August 31, 1978 Letter Dail

'.o Regan

\\

Rt'sponding to Staff Inquiry P00R ORIGIN $"":

~

/

Exhibit 5

\\

UllITED STATES OF AMERICA

!;UCLEAR REGULATORY CO:'XISSION BEFORE THE KIDMIC St.FETY Af!D LICE l SIf!G APPEAL BOARD In the l'atter of

)

Docket flos. STN 50-488 CUKE POWER COMPANY STil 50-489 (Perkins fluclear Station, Units 1, 2 and 3)

)

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that copies of flRC STAFF REJ0ltiDER TO IflTERVEf4ER MOTI0fl TO REOPEfi THIS RECORD in the above-captioned proceeding have been served on the following by deposit in the United States mail, first class or, as indicated by an asterisk, through deposit in the fluclear Regulatory Commission's internal mail system, this 15th day of April, 1981.

Alar. S. Rosenthal, Esq., Chairman

• Dr. Donald P. deSylva Atonic Safety and Licensing Associate Professor of f*arine Appeal Board Science U.S. f:uclear Regulatory Commission Rosenstiel School of l'arine Pashington, D.C.

20555 and Atrospheric Science University of liiami Dr. John H. Buck

• liiami, Florida 33149 Atenic Safety and Licensing Appecl Board Dr. Walter H. Jordan U.S. f:uclear Regulatory Commission 881 W. Outer Drive Washington, D.C.

20555 Oak Ridge, Tennessee 37830 Mr. Thomas S. floore

• J. Michael McGarry, III, Esq.

Atonic Safety and Licensing Debevoise and Liberran Appeal Board 1200 Seventeenth Street,fl.W.

U.S. ?!uclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20036 Uashington, D.C.

20555 Elizabeth S. Bowers, Esq., Chairman

• William A. Raney, Jr., Esq.

Atomic Safety and Licensing Specfal Deputy Attorney General Scard Panel P. O.

Box 629 U.S. !;uclear Regulatory Commission Raleigh,:; orth Carolina 27602 Uashingtcn, D.C.

20555

.illiam L. Porter, Esq.

Atcaic Scicty cnd Licr:nsing

'ssociate Ccneral Counsel 20ard Panel

• r ke Po.ter Company U.S. !!uclear Regulatory Cc:canission o

i.22 South Church Street 1.'as hington, D.C.

20555 ri.arlotte, fiorth Carolina 28242 Atenic Safety and Licensing i'rs. Mary Davis Appeal Board

• Route 4, Box 261 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Cor. mission Mocksville, fiorth Carolina 27028 l'a shington, D.C.

20555

• !illian G. Pfefferkorn, Esq.

Docketing and Service Section*

P. O.

Box 43 Office of the Secretary h'inston-Salem, fiorth Carolina 27102 U.S. I'uclear Regulatory Corr;nission 1.'ashington, D.C.

20555 Quinten Lawson, Esq.

Federal Energy Regulatory Commission Room F611 885 fiorth Capitol, N.E.

h' ashing ton, D.C.

20426 0 mf A

r.harles A. Barth Counsel for flRC Staff

%$S m W.

FDDR DRIGINAL