ML20003B010
| ML20003B010 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Comanche Peak  |
| Issue date: | 01/23/1981 |
| From: | Burwell S Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| To: | Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8102100207 | |
| Download: ML20003B010 (10) | |
Text
wvy 4
[M UUgDo UNITED STATES j'
',j NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION 3
g wAsMNGTON, D. C. 205%
%,+..../
JAN 2 31001 Docket Nos. 50-445/446 APPLICAtlT: Texas Utilities Generating Company FACILITY:
Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station, Units 1 and 2 SUEJECT:
SUMMARY
OF MEETING ON EQUIPMENT ENVIRONMENTAL QUALIFICATION PROGRAM Summary A meeting was held at NRC Headquarters, 7920 Norfolk Avenue, Bethesda, Maryland on Thursday, August 14, 1980. The applicant was represented by staff members of Texas Utilities Services, Inc. and Gibbs and Hill, Inc. The NRC/NRR was represented by members of the Equipment Qualifications Branch and Licensing Branch No. 2.
A list of attendees is enclosed (Enclosure 1).
The purpose of the meeting was to discuss the methodology and documentation to be used in conducting the environmental qualification program of Class 1E equipment for this facility. The meeting discussion was primarily directed to the balance-of-plant equipment.
Meeting Details The applicant described the procedures and documentation used to demonstrate an adequate equipment qualification program for Class 1E equipment. The presentation followed the outline provided for the~ meeting (Enclosure 2).
The program consists of a step-by-step procedure for each equipment item which must be qualified for accident conditions. The principal milestones in the pr ess are shown graphically in Enclosure 3.
The applicant described the procedure to be used to confirm and document the conformance of Class 1E equipment to the requirements of IEEE Standard 323-1974,-
"IEEE Standard for Qualifying Class 1E Equipment for Nuclear Power Generating Stations." During this discussion, the appifcant used a draft document dated April 11, 1980 titled, " Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station, IEEE 323-1974 Equipment Qualification Documentation Review Instruction." Copies were provided to the NRC staff. Because of its length and detail, it will not be attached to the meeting sumary. Copies are available from the Licensing Project Manager upon request.
8102100#07 g
. JAN 2 3 1981 The staff cautioned that the installed plant equipment needs to be connectible to its qualifying documentation. We must be able to establish by audit that the installed equipment is qualified to its accident environmental service conditions and that acceptable documentation of the qualification test or procedure is available.
The applicant noted that the ICSB Question 032.31 sent by NRC letter dated February 28, 1979 requested that it submit a qualification test plan, test setup description, test procedures, acceptance criteria, test results and supporting test data for at least one of each group of equipment listed (17 items).
In view of the change in NRC organization, the applicant inquired whether it should submit this information. At the meeting, the staff coninented that we had not made a decision on this matter.
(Subsequent to the meeting the staff has concluded that the issuance of additional guidance in NUREG-0588 and the staff change in review plan to an audit of the environmental cualification program documentation provides an improved review. Therefore, the applicant is not required to respond to Question 032.31. The applicant is required to respond to t'te request for information on the conformance of the equipment qualification program to NUREG-0588 described in the NRC letter dated February 21,1980.)
After a lunch break the meeting continued with a discussion of the status of NUREG-0588, issued for cornnent by a NRC letter dated February 5,1980.
Mr. Szukiewicz noted that ccmments from about 12 utilities were received, including Texas Utilities Services Inc. (TUSI). The corm:ents were valuable in pointing out those sections needing clarification. We discussed many of the comments offered by TUSI, providing guidance on the staff's meaning or intent for each item discussed.
i /
/.. v<
S. B. Burwell, Project Manager Licensing Branch No. 2 Division of Licensing
Enclosures:
As stated cc w/ enclosures:
See next page
o Mr. R. J. Gary Executive Vice President and General Manager JAN 2 3 gg; Texas Utilities Generating Company 2001 Bryan Tower Dallas, Texas 75201 cc: Nicholas S. Reynolds Esq.
Mr. Richard L. Fouke Debevoise & Liberman Citizens for Fair Utility Regulation 1200 Seventeenth Street 1668-B Carter Drive Washington, D. C.
20036 Arlington, Texas 76010 Spencer C. Relyea, Esq.
Resident Inspector / Comanche Peak Worsham, Forsythe & Sampels Nuclear Power Station 2001 Bryan Tower c/o U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Connission Dallas, Texas 75201 P. O. Box 38 Glen Rosa, Texas 76043 Mr. Homer C. Schmidt Manager - Nuclear Services Texas Utilities Services Inc.
2001 Bryan Tower Dallas, Texas 75201 Mr. H. R. Rock Gibbs and Hill, Inc.
393 Seventh Avenue New York, New York 10001 Mr. A. T. Parker Westinghouse Electric Corporation P. O. Box 355 Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania 15230 David J. Preister Assistant Attorney General Environmental Protection Division P. O. Box 12548, Capitol Station Austin, Texas 78711 Mrs. Juanita Ellis, President Citizens Association for Sound Energy 1426 South Polk Dallas, Texas 75224 Geoffrey M. Gay, Esq.
West Texas Legal Services 406 W. T. Waggoner Building 810 Houston Street Fort Worth Texas 76102
j 1
ENCLOSURE 1 ATTENDANCE LIST FOR AUGUST 14, 1980 PEETING COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION, UNITS 1 AND 2 Texas Utilities Services, Inc.
D. Woodan Gibbs & Hill, Inc.
i K. Mittal J. Isgro NRC Staff 3
Z. Rosztoczy P. DiBenedetto F. Ashe J. Page J. Watt S. Burwell A. Szukiewicz (afternoon only)
.L.
ENCLOSURE 2 PRESENTATION TO EQUIPMENT QUALIFICATION BRANCH ON ENVIRONMENTAL QUALIFICATION REVIEW DATE:
August 14, 1980 PURPOSE:
To present the methodology to be used in conducting a review of the Environmental Qualification program of Class lE equipment at CPSES and the methodology to be used to document that review.
To exchange ideas with the staff reguarding these methodologies prior to full implementation.
PRESENTATION OUTLINE:
I.
Environmental Qualification Program for CPSES II.
Program Review III.
Qualification Tabulation IV.
Qualification Certification V.
Review Package l-l I.
Environmental Qualification Program for CPSES (handout) i A.
Design and Specification Process 1.
HVAC design i
2.
Systems design 3.
Radiation evaluation i
4.
Regulations, standards, guides,.etc.
5.
Equipment specification Sheet 1 of 3
-c
ENCLOSURE 2 B.
Vendor's Plan Submitted, rs'riewed, revised, accepted C.
Vendor's Testing and Report Submitted, reviewed, revised, accepted D.
Acceptance Criteria 1.
Specification 2.
IEEE Standards 3.
State-of-the-art II.
Program Review A.
Required per D. F. Ross letter of February 21, 1980 B.
Purpose - to document review to NUREG-0588 criteria C.
Procedure (handout) 1.
Provides consistant methodology 2.
Provides criteria D.
Review form (handout) 1.
Identifies equipment 2.
List qualification documentation 3.
Checklist of specific documentation i
4.
Justification of alternate methodology l
S.
Summary / location of qualification contingencies E.
General Review - discusses some aspects in a plant generic manner 1.
Phase change identification 2.
Synergistic effects Sheet 2 of 3 b
ENCLOSURE 2 III.
Qualification Tabulation A.
Requirement - per D. F. Ross letter of February 21, 1980 B.
Purpose - to allow audit of required versus demonstrated parameters C.
Format modified from 2/21/80 letter (handout)
D.
Information sources 1.
Specifications (purchase orders) 2.
FSAR 3.
Qualification documentation E.
Table will be completed as review is performed IV.
Certification Process A.
Purpose - final acceptance of qualification for specific equipment B.
Procedure (handout) 1.
Provides methodology 2.
Provides criteria -
C.
Certification Sheet (handout) 1.
1-for -l with review form 9
2.
Basic description of demonstrated qualification V.
Review Package A.
Purpose - to assemble review documentation and qualification tabulation of licensing B.
Content 1.
Index 2.
General Review 3.
Review and Certification Sheets 4.
Qualification Tabulation Sheet 3 of 3
ENCI.0SURE 3 Environmental Qualification Program Procedure CPSES DESIGN If SPECIFICATION PREPARATION VENDOR QUAL, PLAN if COMMENT / ACCEPTANCE iP VENDOR QUAL. TEST / REPORT IP COMMENT / ACCEPTANCE IF CPSES FILES Sheet 1 of 2
i ENCLOSURE 3 Review Package to be Submitted to the NRC i
/ !
TABULATION OF
, e' DATA s'
e
/
/
/
CERTIFICATION AND REVIEW FORMS
,s'
/
/
GENERAL REVIEW
/
[
INDEX
=
/
ENVIRONMENTAL QUALIFICATION REVIEW PACKAGE
/
l FOR CPSES
/
i l
I l
l 1
Sheet 2 of 2
s MEETING
SUMMARY
DISTRIBUTION Occket File D. Muller NRC POR R. Ballard Local PDR W. Regan NSIC D. Ross TIC P. Check g po, TERA R. Satterfield
\\
NRR Reading
- 0. Parr Q ( g.
LB 12 File F. Rosa g
v H. Denton W. Butler D'
h FE3 d ~ 1931 * }--
E. Case W. Kreger Ed s
D. Eisenhut R. Houston 3
O,,.gj$aph R. Purple T. Murphy T
Q)
B. J. Youngblood L. Rubenstein A. Schwencer T. Speis F. Miraglia W. Johnston J. Miller J. Stolz G. Lainas S. Hanauer R. Vollmer W. Gammill J. P. Knight F. Schroeder R. Bosnak D. Skovhcit F. Schauer M. Ernst R. E. Jackson R. Baer Project ManagerSwatti
.C. Berlinger Licensing Assistant MService.
~K. Kniel Attorney, OELD G. Knighton I&E (3)
A. Thadani ACRS (16)
D. Tondi R. Tedesco D. Vassallo G. Lear J. Kramer V. thonan P. Collins S. Pawlicki D. Ziemann V. Benaroya S. Ramos Z. Rosztoczy S. Schwartz W. Haass NRC Particioants:
Others:
- NS
- 4. 61.WI(i gwit,,5 T. A s he, h
~
BCC: Applicant & Service List
//
.L