ML19340B022
| ML19340B022 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Millstone, Dresden, Palisades, Oyster Creek, Haddam Neck, Ginna, San Onofre, Yankee Rowe, La Crosse, Big Rock Point  |
| Issue date: | 09/21/1978 |
| From: | Desiree Davis Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| To: | Eisenhut D Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| References | |
| TASK-***, TASK-RR NUDOCS 8010170729 | |
| Download: ML19340B022 (12) | |
Text
.
I
. = _
g2 i
+=we
=.
8["
%,]
- f uMTED STATES 7.
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION e-g wAssmoTon. D. c. 20sss
=
/
~
September 21, 1978 DockeUNos. 50-29, 50-244, M. 9 50-409, 50-219, 50-213,
=5h 50-255, 50-155, 50-245 d?
MEMORANDUM FOR:
D. G. Eisenhut, Assistant Director for Systems
& Projects, DOR FROM:
D. K. Davis, Chief, Syst.ematic Evaluation Program y
Branch, 00R j:
4
- 9. =
SUBJECT:
SYSTEMATIC EVALUATION PROGRAM (SEP) SCHEDULE E s:M MEETINGS WITH INDIVIDUAL LICENSEES i-=r m=
=3=-
On July 18, 19, and 20, 1978, meetings were held between the NRC staff 5
and representatives of the following SEP utilities:
Date Licensee Facility Docket #
7/18 Yankee Atomic Electric Yankee Rowe 50-29
.... =
E 7/19 Rochester Gas & Electric Ginna 50-244 i
~
7/19 Dairyland Power Cooperative La Crosse 50-409 i
7/19 Jersey Central Power & Light Oyster Creek 50-219 7/20 Connecticut Yankee Atomic Haddam Neck 50-213 l
==
7/20 Consumers Power Palisades 50-255 7/20 Consumers Power Big Rock Point 50-155 7/20 Northeast Nuclear Energy Millstone 1 50-245 E....-.
h" 7/25 Commonwealth Eoison Dresden 1 & 2 50-10 &
4 50-237
=
7/27 Southern California Edison San Onofre 1 S0-206 The meetings were called to discuss the scheduling of SEP activities and
=-
to infom the licensees of reviews which are anticipated to be initiated shortly and may require substantial licensee effort. Attendanca lists z...
for each of the meetings are attached.
~
,. s= '
o d
8010170 72 7 b
po p
y
)
- =
v f
D. G. Eisenhut
-2 September 21, 1978 Licensee comments on the draft SEP schedule book were received. Major comments, which will be corrected during the course of future book revisions, are:
l.
book difficult to read, logic hard to follow 2.
difficult to determine when licensee input is required or when licensee will be expected to review documents 3.
schedules for topic reviews should be plant-specific, not generic
!L as shown now 4.
many minor changes to the schedule book will be incorporated as a result of licensee comments.
The NRC response to the SEP Owners Group suggestions for documentaticn procedures was given to the licensees, as was the staff documentation of seven topics considered essentially complete by the staff. The staff requested that the licensees review these documents and provide any comments to the Project Manager.
kI.
The staff also requested that each licensee review the information regarding leak detection systems to assure the information describing each facility was current and correct. Some licensees were also re-F quested to review information regarding seismic and quality group classifications and were asked to provide additional information in certain areas.
=
Each topic discipline manager (reactor systems, electrical /instrumenta-tion and control, mechanical / materials, seismic, structural. plant systems, and site hazards and radiological) presented the schedule fe" review and outlined the effort which would be required from the licensees. Two areas of concern were uniformly noted by each licensee.
Both topics (sei:mic review and pipe break inside containment) may i;
require substantial effort from licensees. Because of the need for L
cooperation in the performance of these reviews and the need for joint discussion of review guidelines and Cata, and because of the probable availability of additional informat' an not presently docketed, the staff suggested that individual 'icensee meetings be scheduled in the near future to discuss the two topics in detail.
- 4
. s..,
(*
h$
~
I-g
(.
c,.
u 30'lO 1 1970 SEPTEW.BER a-D. G. Eisenhut fij l
Each licensee presented to the staff a list of topics which were either not applicable to the particular facility or which, in the licensee's opinion, could be resolved quickly and with minimal effort on the part
=1 of the staff and the licensee. This discussion also covered any ongoing
=
licensing actions which could possibly have an impact on the SEP review and schedule.
The staff requested that licensees be aware that, although credit may eventually be allowed for non-safety-related systems in lieu of
~
safety-related systems or to improve safety margins such sredit could not be unilaterally assumed by the licensee without prior NRC review and approval.
The staff concluded by stressing that licensee input is both valued and necessary.
Original sigwd by h
m K. Davis Don K. Divis, Chief Systematic Evaluation Program Branch p-Division of Operating Reactors gj Attachments:
As stated cc:
See attached f
if
- 1 btb
'/
DORQPb/S&P DOR:0RB #2 g g j3gp o,,,c.,
DKDavis:rj DLZiemann
,,RPSnaider
,y R
0Db O lNY 1l5/bR 7 yf f
e.,.
o c m., n
,,.u, s m, m o 7
I-
.. = -
55 (E
2.:.:"5A
~
l:
- ==
ATTENDANCE LIST YANKEE R0WE
[s 7/18/78
.,..m...
- JsEJ z
N. Anderson, NRC/ DOR /SEPB K. Jabbour, NRC/ DOR /SEPB
-Es.
F. B. Litton, NRC/ DSS
=+::: -
H. Fontecilla NRC/ DOR /SEPB P. A. DiBenedetto NRC/ DOR /SEPB y
R. Snaider, NRC/ DOR /SEPB I'-
H. Levin, NRC/ DOR /EB p
R. Schaffstall, KMC ki"'
J. McEwen, KMC A. Burger, NRC/00R/0RB #2 H. Schierling, NRC/ DOR /SEPB -
C, Bagchi, NRC/RES P. Sobel, NRC/DSE A. Cardone, NRC/DSE D. Mcdonald, NRC/ DOR /SEPB T. Kohli, EES, Inc.
c.
S. Bryan, NRC/ DOR /SEPB
[i R. Rumble LLL i= - -
D. A. Hansen, Yankee Ato.aic D. K. Davis, NRC/ DOR /SEPB
. = =
T. Greene NRC/ DSS /CSB
'E. W. Roberts, EG&G
..g:l J:
5:E9
/
U
,. - u
.=
- ]
7:: -
f:i - '
ATTENDANCE LIST GINNA
=-
- u =.-
7/19/78
- =::.
1+
=555 5e D. K. Davis, NRC/ DOR /SEPB
=
N. Anderson, NRC/ DOR /SEPB
~
B. Saffell, EG&G R. Schaffstall. KMC
=
=
G. Wrobel, RG&E R. E. Smith, RG&E t;
L R. C. @ credy, RG&E
,g J. Shea, NRC/ DOR / ORB #2 G. Bagchi, NRC/RES J. Arthur, RG&E E. Cohen LeBoeuf. Lamb, Leiby & MacRae K. Jabbour, NRC/ DOR /SEPB
;
- 0. Mcdonald, NRC/ DOR /SEPB
=:i E. W. Roberts.. EG&G
==
R. Colmar, NRC/ DOR /PSB 9: --
D. L. Ziemann, NRC/ DOR /0R5 #2 H. Fontecilla, NRC/ DOR /SEPB F[:I em an-
.a
-er
.,.- +
y-
==
- .':^
, ;2f3' o
a.
u:::
e oete d
a
~
- .1
+<
u:
d
... :=:n ATTENDANCE LIST I =4j LA CROSSE
- =j 7/19/78
=f.,7.~..
.:=.5.
R. P. Snaider, NRC/ DOR /SEPB
- t. 35
P. A. DiBenedetto, NRC/ DOR /SEPB
[
W. T. Russell, NRC/00R/0RB #2 h + =+..
J. D. Parkyn, Dairyland Power E
R. Milos NES, Inc.
=
S. Ramos, NRC/ DOR /0RB #4 J. W. Taylor, Dairyland. Power p.
[T' 'E?
R. E. Shimshak, Dairyland Power N. Anderson, NRC/ DOR /SEPB E. Tremmel, Dairyland Power.
"Tf H. Schierling, NRC/ DOR /SEPB fy K. Jabbour, hRC/ DOR /SEPB
~~~
G. Bagchi, NRC/Research S. Bryan, NRC/ DOR /SEPB T. Kohli, EES, Inc.
H. Fontecilla, NRC/ DOR /SEPB W. Roberts, EG&G u.-
R. Rumble, LLL n
- 9. -
.4 e
=
i
,.. ;r
.j
..j i
1 O.*
l ATTENDANCE LIST OYSTER CREEK 7/19/78 g==
.. = =
R. P. Snaider, NRC/ DOR /SEPB D. K. Davis 'iRC/ DOR /SEPB
~...
K. Jabbour,:iRC/ DOR /SEPB H. Schierling, NRC/ DOR /SEPB i
J. Knubel, Jersey Central
. =.._
T. Tipton, Jersey Central se W. R. Schmidt, MPR Associates J. McEwen, KMC P. O'Connor, ORB #2 R. J. Kiessel, DSS /MEB J. R. Rayan, DSS /MEB P. A. DiBenedetto, NRC/ DOR /SEPB
'55:
D. Shum, NRC/ DOR /PSB
=i
=
T. Greene, NRC/ DSS /LSB W. Roberts, EG&G H. Fontecilla, NRC/ DOR /SEPB N. Anderson, NRC/ DOR /SEPB D. Mcdonald,'NRC/ DOR /SEPB S. Bryan, NRC/ DOR /SEPB G. Bagchi, NRC/ DOR /SEPB p
i:
~ if.:
{"
f::.
ff Eli.
.U.'
- =
..N
- ,s b.*:
+e.
h t
l.
1 e
s
$2U1..
c....
- .:e:.
ATTENDANCE LIST g._
BIG ROCK POINT & PALISADES
- ,3,.
7/20/78
- e: -:
S. Bryan, NRC/ DOR /SEPB 4 = +i B. Beckius, Consumers Power I:1-J. Beer, Consumers Power (E
J. Shea, NRC/00R/0RB #2 l5' O. Bixel, Consumers Power F ""
J. McEwen, KMC
[
H. Schierling, NRC/ DOR /SEPB if G. Bagchi NRC/RES D. Mcdonald, NRC/ DOR /SEPB K. Jabbour, NRC/ DOR /SEPB H. Fontecilla, NRC/ DOR /SEPB N. Anderson, NRC/ DOR /SEPB R. Silver, NRC/ DOR / ORB #2 T. Kohli, EES, Inc.
W. Roberts. EG&G R. Rumble, LLL k
3._...
w L
.h um en ll..s" e
ee -
': 4
I l
4
=
a
(.2 -
=
['i:..
ATTENDANCE LIST i++
HADDAM NECK & MILLSTONE 1 gis 7/20/78
~
.=
=:0:
K. Jabbour, NRC/ DOR /SEPB M===
N. Anderson, NRC/ DOR /SEPB R. Rumble. LLL H. Fontecilla, NRC/ DOR /SEPB
...=2 B. I1berman, NUSCO
.. Russell, NRC/ DOR / ORB #2 W
=
R. Schaffstall,101C
"?
B. Saffell, EG&G H. Schierling, NRC/ DOR /SEPB D. Mcdonald, NRC/ DOR /SEPB
==
G. Bagchi, NRC/RES T. Kohli, EES, Inc.
R. L. Guinness, NUSCO j
=bi a
~
e-
.~.L
- 'J'.'.:
d+.nyg 3.i 1
l
.. }
.{ ~ ~
_'"~
UI e
c!
~
7:3;j
- ==
ATTENDAN ' _iST
~1
.+ ;. :
I" DRESDEN UNITS 1 & 2
[E w:==.
7/L5/78
.:.gl:jji:
E+
Il P. O'Connor, NRC/ DOR /0RB #2
, ::~:-
J. Wujciga, Ceco /D-2 p:
R. Jungk, CECO /D-1
!=:= ~
F N. Smith, CECO /SNED J. White, CECO /SNED
==
P. Clark, Ceco /NSC-J. Abel, CECO /SNED M. Turbak, CECO /SNED
"~6 R. Janacek, CECO /SNED J. McEwen, KMC
..,jijf G. Bagchi, NRC/ DOR /SEPB
..s
.. ~
M. Fletcher, NRC/ DOR /SEPB K. Jabbour, NRC/ DOR /SEPS
" I; D. Davis, NRC/ DOR /SEPB D. Mcdonald, NRC/ DOR /SEPB H. Schierling, NRC/ DOR /SEPB
= :-
H. Fentecilla, NRC/ DOR /SEPB
~
E
~
m.7 7...... !
E".:
s if.j +4
==
=
e
>a-
?:b "L
- ~.
L
~
- dM
~
(?
!=.
1 E-
= = =. -
.is-ATTENDANCE LIST i
- i=e P
SAN Of40FRE UNIT 1
- =
- . :=i
= = = =
7/27/78
[.........
. Marsh, NRC p :. ~
.i. Anderson, NRC p[i:.
D. Nunn, SCE l
M. Wilber NRC/IE
~ ss..
W. Moody, SCE
=~
J. Rainsberry, SCE
..?2 P. H. Renseyres SCE l.!....
i L. A. Watson, NRC J. C. Sarenson, SCE
==
C. A. Carossino, SCE F s=
M. P. Short, SCE
~
G. T. McLandrich, SCE
== E R. P. Rumble, LLL
= ===i G. Krellenstein, NRC J. Reeder, SCE p.:
f..~..
~
- ^.
[j e.
!=
. 5l:'.
P j.3:==
r=
f'!c l
J.;
w-t
=u MEETING
SUMMARY
DISTRIBUTION 50-206 g ets 50-29 50-244, 50-409, 50-219, 50-213, 50-255, 50-155, 50-245, 50-10, 50-237 7. ;;
~~"
NRC PDRs SEP Reading NRR Reading
.m.
E. G. Case V. Stello B. Grimes T. Ippolito J. Arthur, RG&E R. Reid E. Cohen, LeBoeuf, Lamb Leiby, MacRae G. Knighton R. Colmar, DOR V. N6anan J. D. Parkyn, Dairyland Power D. Eisenhut R. Milos, NES, Inc.
A. Schwencer S. Ramos, ORS #4 D. Ziemann J. W. Taylor, Dairyland Power D. K. Davis R. E. Shimshak, Dairyland Power G. Lainas E. Tremmel, Dairyland Power m
P. Check J. Knubel, Jersey Central T. J. Carter T. Tipton, Jersey Central L. Scinto, OELD W. R. Schmidt, MPR Associates y
OI&E (3)
R. J. Kiessel, MEB d
H. Smith J. R. Rayan, DSS R. Fraley, ACRS (16)
D. Shum, PSB T. B. Abernathy B. Ilberman, NUSCO J. R. Buchanan R. L. Guinness, NUSCO SEPB Members (10)
T. Marsh, NRC J. McEwen KMC D. Nunn, SCE Licensees M. Wilber, I&E ORB #2 Branch Members W. Moody, SCE F. B. Litton, DSS J. Rainsberry, SCE H. Levin, EB P. H. Renseyres, SCE R. Schaffstall, KMC J. C. Sarenson, SCE J. McEwen, KMC C. A. Carossino, SCE P. Sobel, DSE M. P. Short, SCE A. Cardone DSE G. T. McLandrich, SCE T. Kohli, EES, Inc.
J. Reeder, SCE R. Rumble, LLL J. Wujciga. CECO /D-2 D. A. Hansen, Yankee Atomic R. Jungk, CECO /D-1 T. Greene. DSS N. Smith, CECO /SNED E. W. Roberts, EG&G J. White, CECO /SNED B. Saffell, EG&G P. Clark, CECO /NSC G. Wrobel, RG&E J. Abel, CECO /SNED R. E. Smith, RG&E M. Turbak, CECO /SNED R. C. Mecredy, RG&E R. Janacek, CECO /SNED H. Denton i