ML19338C204
| ML19338C204 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Midland |
| Issue date: | 03/13/1978 |
| From: | Cherry M, Engelhardt T, Grossman M, Perlman T, Tourtellotte J CHERRY, M.M./CHERRY, FLYNN & KANTER, KOMINERS, FORT, SCHLEFER & BOYER, NRC OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE LEGAL DIRECTOR (OELD), NRC OFFICE OF THE GENERAL COUNSEL (OGC) |
| To: | Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| Shared Package | |
| ML19338C191 | List: |
| References | |
| ISSUANCES-SP, NUDOCS 8008050652 | |
| Download: ML19338C204 (8) | |
Text
.
er y
c:mma u s.uc n:
UNITED STATES OF A'~. ERICA MAR 21 1978.
NUCLEAR REGULATORY Coy 01ISSICS 6
cn-..,i.s. w e c o a,a :.n:
kw Before the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board ETA-y For Special Proceeding Ni[l6 In the Matter of
)
)
Docket Nos. 50-329 CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY
)
50-330
)
(Special Proceeding)'
Midland Plant, Units 1 and 2 )
MOTION AND STIPULATION In view of the letter of January 30, 1978 from.
3./the Chairman of the Nuclear Regulatory Commission to the Chairman of this Special Board, and of this
]
Board's~ orders of February 1 and February 14, 1958, and in consideration of the mutual promises herein contained, the undersigned parties stipulate and acree that this proceeding should be settled upon, the following terms and they hereby note that the Special Board recommcq? to the Commissica the
.ulstion and that the Commission approval of thi-c so approve:
1.
upon approval by the Commission, all motions listed' in Anpendix A hereto and all pleadines, motions, reques and amplications in this soecial. Proceeding 8008050 {t.eQ
,~.-. a..w.2.
- 2. -
shall b'e deemed withdrawn'with oreiudice;
.that all documents' submitted in connection s
2.
~
. ith the-proceeding In The Matter of Consumers Power w
(Midland Plant, Units,1 and'2), Docket-Nos.
Company 50-329, 50-330- and ali parts of.the transcript of the hearing thereon which arerlisted'in' Appendix A
~
hereto shall.be stricken from~the record in that proceeding;'
that all orders-and memoranda in connection 3.
with-the above-mentioned-proceeding listed in Appendix
< ~
B hereto shall be stricken.from the record in-that
~
~~
proceeding,.and that all charges against any party-
. C'
- ~
hereto contained in any-such order or memorandum and referred 1to the Special~ Board, or filed with that s
5 card'shall be dismissed with prejudice and may be N-
- considered to havelno'effect as'if such charges had'.
~
- ot-been brought;t 4... thattheNuclearReculator[ Commission-shall issue noticesfor publication 'in its official-
_recorts to-the:effect-that all orders and memoranda
~
listeduin Appendix 3.heretoLhave been stricken and that charges l contained therein. have\\been dismissed -
"l 9
Swith?prciudicci b
a n
i
.j.
'5
__w-
+-
1 *.'.
that all-documents 1 submitted.by the. parties '
H 5 '.-
sin connection,with(the. proceeding before the'Special g
" Board, all(orders by that:-Board,'all: correspondence
.by thattBoard,:and'allitranscripts of any proceeding thereof--sh'all be.-stricken from the. record and that-the record 'of the Special Proceeding',shall be stricken -
~
in its entirety;-
~
_ that ithe Special Proceeding shall be 6.
terminated; 7.
that the Nuclear Regulatory Commission or apm opriate members of it's staff shall furnish notice a e m
. ~
r*f containing.the-lahquace'. set'forth in Appendix ~'C hereto to all persons to whom.the! Commission or any member
~
-x of'its-staff disseminated any letter, press release, document.or any other information,. describing, concerning.
or relating'to the.Special: Proceeding or any matters at -issue therein, -informirtg allEsuch cersons. of the disuosition of-_the proceeding; 8.
fthatitlie" Nuclear Reculatory Commission-or
~
. appropriate memb'ers of its. staff promptly:shall (providef. counsel?for.Myron.M.: Cherry with copies lof allEwrit' ten-communications by the' Commission or cits /staf f with 3 third persons, other than parties t
4&
'}, _
- s.,
._ z 9..
(
l
[~;,[;.*:.
.to.this proceeding or their counsel,. describing, concern-
~
t
'ing~or relating'to the-Special Proceeding or any matters I
at issue <therein( and p
.e Cherry.. enters into this stipulation 9..
that Myron M.
on the.fu'rther condition that the Nuclear Regulatory Commission
~
i i
shall' pay' actual out-of-pocket expenses not in excess of
$1,000 incurred by or on behalf of Myron M. Cherry in con-nection with the Special Proceeding.
In the event tLe Nuclear Regulatory Commission fails j
to' approve the foregoing motion and stipu1ation in its entirety,
~
the ' stipulation and.all terms hereof shall be void and to no effect.
i SO STIPULATED:
' lh. m: r I b
^^
l Counsel for the Nuclear. Regulatory-Cor.n.ission Staff n,hydn Counsel *for Milton J.-Grossman and-
~
James R.
Tourtellotte 4
I
- {w&fC. D Counsel for Myron M.. Cherry-
,A s.+/k ( 4/k Counsel for Intervenors Other Than
< Do'..- Chemical Co.
$ted: - Ma rch L13,. -197 8.
__.z._
%.j,
\\.
c: Tag- >
1 t.5:.2
.1
,
- G\\
f5AR211578 >
q
, c.......,...o tw,
..-,, 5.3:a A
N.i f
APPENDIX A g
(
N i t Letter of 3/7/77 from James R. Tourtellotte to members:
1.
.of-the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board (Midland Panel).
.Letterlof 3/10/77 from Myron M.' Cherry to members of
~
2.
.the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board (Midland Panel).
3/25/77. Motion for' Censure of Myron M.-Cherry,.sub-3.
mitted.by Milton J. Grossman.
. Letter of 4/5/77. from Myron M. Cherry. to-members of 4.
the. Atomic Safety and Licensing Board (Midland Panel)~.
5.
Letter ~ of 5/6/77 from Myron M. Cherry to Dr. Lawrence R.-Quarles.
2 ? d*.
-Transcript of hearing of May '9,1977 at pages 5220-5224, line 5.
~ ~~
5/13/77; Motion to Strike Certain Pleadings as Sham 7.
Pleadings,~ submitted by Myron M. Cherry.
8., 5/13/77-Further Response in-Opposition to Censure Motions.and. Cost' Motions and Statement in Support of Intervenors' Motion'to Strike Certain Fi]ings of 9
the Regulatory Staff and. Consumers in These. Proceed-ings, submitted by..Myron M. Cherry.
5/13/77 Affidavit of Myron M. Cherry. in Support of c 9 ~.
the Further: Response in Opposition to Censure Motions and.. Cost' Motions and Statement in Support of Inter-venors' Motions to Strike'Certain~ Filings of the Regulatory Staff and. Consumers in These Proceedings,
. submitted by.Myron M. Cherry.
2.713'and 10 10.
5/16/7,7 Motion Pursuant to 10 C.F.R.
. C.F. R. :2.718.to Take ' Appropriate Sanctions and ' Ac-tions Against JamesLTourtellotte.and? Milton Grossman, and!tho Regul'atory Staff, submitted by Myron M. Cherry.
~
-r---
~
..t s.-
- :- r 2-e 11.
5/16/77 Intervenors'= Motion for Investigation of Improprieties Occasioned by the Regulatory Staff-b andL.'in Particular by their La'yers, James Tourtel'lotte and Milton Grossman,.. submitted by Myron'M. Cherry.
.5/20/77.NRC Staff's Response to Intervenors' Motion 12.
to: Strike Certain~ Pleadings, submitted by Milton!J.
Grossman, James R. Tourtellotte, William J. Olmstead;.
~
13.. 6/6/77 NRC Staff's Motion for D rected Certification, i
submitted by Milton J.
Grossman, James R. - Tourtellotte, William.J. Olmstead.
14.,
6/14/7.7 Intervenors' Response to NRC' Motion for Directed i
Certi'fication, submitted by'Myron M. Cherry.
l i
l l
~
l-l l
^
1 l:
l i
t I
f1 e
T k
9 9
' t'.
APPENDIX 3
- 1. _ '4/29/77-Order by Atomic Safety.and' Licensing Appeal
- Board -(Midland Appeal Panel), Separate Stat'ement. of Dr. Quarles-(ALAB-395).
~
6/15/77. Memorandum by Atomic Safety and Licensing.
2.
- Board- (Midland _ Panel).
L3.
6/29/77_ Memorandum and' Order by Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Board (Midland Appeal Panel)
(ALAB-417).
-4.
11/4/77; Order by Atomic Safety ani. Licensing Board (Midland Panel) (Referring Charges to Special Board).
5.
11/7/77 Order re Establishment of an Atomic. Safety and Licensing Board for a Special Proceeding Con-cerning 10'C.F.R. 2.713.by James R.
Yore, Chairman, Atomic S'afety,and' Licensing Board Panel.,
6.
12/7/7.7 --Order re Establishment of Atomic Safety; and-Licensing Board for Special-Proceeding-by James'R.
Yore, Chairman, Atomic. Safety and Licensing Board
-Panel..
7.
12/14/77' Memorandum by Atomic Safety and Licensing
~
AppealTPanel (ALAB-450).
!/
s.ej o
e\\
w
.gy
,~.,[
,a MAR 21~m/.e, A.).
9 pl_.
T*.~. ' y :
. my}
m c,.,3mi g#
/i
\\
ut_ L
~
c APPENDIX C The Nuclear Regulatory Co:rnission has determined that the Special Proceeding to hear charges of profes-t sional misconduct acainst Myron M.. Cherry, an attorney in private practice, and NRC staff attorneys Milton J.
Grossman and James R.
Tourtellotte should be terminated.
All charges aciainst Mr. Cherry, and Mr. Grossman and Mr. Tourtellotte have been withdrawn or dismissed with prejudice.
\\ @l i ~
6
/
5$!
' 'Q n
V w/
U3N.tc
} 'lan).~.t;g AR2 s
W.e v '
%>4. GE L 8. A
' s44 ; 4 i\\
d 9
,e e
e 9