ML19331B179

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Memorandum & order,ALAB-160,referring Saginaw Intervenors 730518 Motion to Clarify ALAB-123 to Commission for Appropriate Disposition.Motion Appears to Assert Conflict W/ Nine Mile Point 2 Memorandum & Order.Certificate of Svc Encl
ML19331B179
Person / Time
Site: Midland, Nine Mile Point
Issue date: 11/26/1973
From: Duflo M
NRC ATOMIC SAFETY & LICENSING APPEAL PANEL (ASLAP)
To:
Saginaw Intervenor
References
ALAB-123, ALAB-160, NUDOCS 8007280731
Download: ML19331B179 (6)
v • d • e


Text

._

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA co ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION C)

S 89CEEif5 9

ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING APPEAL BOARD E

9-NOV271973* r11 Alan S. Rosenthal, Chairman Dr. John H. Buck, Member T

William C. Farler, Member tus Cu

/

)

In the Matter of

)

)

CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY

)

Docket Nos. 50-329

)

50-330 (Midland Plant, Units 1 and 2)

)

)

MEMORANDUM AND ORDER November 26, 1973 THIS DOCUMENT CONTAINS P00R QUALITY PAGES (ALAS-160)

Saginaw Intervenors have filed what they choose to cha.racterize as a motion "to clarify" ALAB-123, RAI-73-5 331 (May 18, 1973).

The motion is based upon the November 6, 1973 memorandum and order of the Commission in Niagara Mohawk Power Corcoration, (Nine Mile Point, Unit No. 2), Docket No. 50-410, RAI-73-ll In that memorandum and order, the Commission reversed certain pre-hearing conference orders of a licensing board insofar as they precluded the presentation of evidence on energy conservation.

The proceeding was remanded to that board with appropriate directions.

Despite the label appended to it, the Saginaw Inter-venors' motion appears in actuality to assert a conflict so 73/

gon I

. between ALAB-123 and the Nine Mile Point 2 memorandum and order.

In a real sense, the relief which the Saginaw Intervenors seek is a remand of Midland to the Licensing Board "for further proceedings to consider questions of energy conservation" (Motion, p. 22).

ALAB-123 was rendered more than six months ago.

It affirmed, with a limited exception not here relevant, the initial decision of the Licensing Board.b!

In the cir-cumstances, we think it at best doubtful whether we now are empowered to entertain what is essentially a new attack by the Saginaw Intervenors upon the initial decision.

Be that as it may, since the motion is based exclusively upon a recent ruling of the Commission, it seems to us that the Commission itself is the body which should decide whether the sought reopening of the Midland proceeding is warranted.

This is especially so since, in its Nine Mile Point 2 memorandum and order, the Commission made snecific reference to ALAB-123 (as well as to our more recent decision in Long Island Lighting Co. (Shoreham Nuclear Power Station), ALAB-156, RAI-73-10 831 (October 26, 1973)).

1/ The only issues left open by ALAB-123 related to quality assurance matters.

Over six weeks ago, those matters received final disposition on our part.

ALAB-152, RAI-73-10 816 (October 5, 1973).

,.s

. Accordingly, the motion is' referred to - the Cc-dssion for such disposition-as it may deen appropriate.

It is so ORDERED.

FOR THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING APPEAL BOARD

//kisct[ ( /Da

.vArgare: E.

DuFlo Secretary,to the Appeal Board i

-n

-e

.Y

~'*N W q.. -

=

..' b i

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION In the Matter of

)

/

CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY

)

Docket Nos. 50-329L

)

50-330 (Midland Plant, Units 1 and 2)

)

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that copies of Appeal Board's MEMORANDUM AND ORDER (ALAB-160) dated November 26, 1973 in the captioned matter have been served upon those on the attached Service List by deposit in the United States mail, first class or air mail, this 27th day of November 1973.

b GCL C.

httAo f the Secretary of the Comm:,ssion Sffics o a

Attached: Service List ec:

Mr. Murphy Mr. Engelhardt ASLBP l

E. Goulbourne G. Williams l

L Wsg. Files ASLAB j

O m;

e i

)

i

t. - - -,

e

~.. - -

a; n

,s

,,, 9 7,. 5 3,

>, 3

  • ',9
g..,

y.

,.. <p f

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA

~

^

.'.., ATOMIC, ENERGY, COMMISSION

/

s In the Matter of

'^

?

C).

o,p),,,

CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY '

')

Docket Nos. 50-329

~

),

50-330 a-(Midland Plant, Units 1 and 2),),

/

., 3 i

. SERVICE LIST

<3 Arthur W. Murphy, Esq., Chairman Harold P. Graves, Esq.

Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Vice President and General Counsel i -

Columbia Univoraity School of. Law c

435 West 116th Street, Box 38 Consumers Power Company New York, New York 10027 212 West Michigan Avenue Jackson,' Michigan 49201 4

Dr. Clark Goodman

.Mr. R. C. Youngdahl 95 Antigua Court Corenado, California $2118 Senior Vice President

~

A*

Consumers Power Company t

~

~ ',

212 West Michigan Avenue 4

,-f

. Jackson, Michigan 49201 Dr. David B. Hall Los Alamos Scientific Laboratory Honorable Frank Olds, Chairman a'

(

P. O. Box 1663 Midland County Board of, e

Los Alamos, New Mexico 87544 Supervisors

'~

623 St. Charles D reet Midland, Michigan 48640 Dr. Stuart G. Forbes 100 Tennessee Avenue, Apt. 37 -

^

Redlands, California 92373

' Honorable Jerome Maslowski'

. O Assistant Attorney General Thomas F. Engelhardt, Esq.,

'. State of Michigan'

,[

David E. Kartalia, Esq.

Seven Story Office Building Robert Newton, Esq.

,. 525 West Ottawa s 3

+

Regulatory Staff Counsel Lansing,' Michigan 48913 ?

1 4

U. S. Atomic Energy Commission Honorable Curtis G. Beck

~

Washington, D. C.

20545 Assistant Attorney General 4

3

I State'of Michigan Harold F. Reis, Esq.

Jerome E. Sharfman, Esq.'

Seven Story Office Building Neuman, Reis and Axelrad 525 West Octava c

1025 Connecticut Avenue, N7 H.

Lanoing, Michigan ~ 48913 Washington, D. C.

20036:

Myron M. Cherry, Esq.

' Richard G. Smith, Esq.'

.'., j,,.

y; y' 4 1-IBM Plaza c

+i Chicago, Illinois, 60611 Smith & Brooker, P.C. '-

' ',. m-703 Washington Avenue Bay City, Michigan 48706 f

4 s

E r-3

~'

[*

~

v s?

,N r:

4 e

', nr g,.

'k e4 4 g..'

.a %

.r

-h r *[.y h

..i.

  • = -

s_

e f

%,f..

I E.'

.6

I'.

5-

.' * > pYg2 2 ' *

",, '/.'g.,'. '

', :., p"., * %.,-',..

.,.. 50-329 cnd 50-310, c.

.,s

...s'..

.a

.A g..

, : r. g e

ss

.+

a i

n..

' Anthony Z. R:isma2, Esq.,,.

9 2 ** r., 'Mr. W;ndt

3. MIrsh,n11y ?.i.

' z

..r..i RFD No.10, Mapleton * *..

' :. Q ;l).3.d iBerlin, Roismancand Kossier *,' $';. f. ' Midland l Michigan 9

4 p'

1712 N Street,' N.' W.

4

,l J " J 48640-

' ..f l n.;")

f~'

Washington,.D. C.

20036'r,q

~

.f.P '. '= '".s. Irving Like, Esq..

c -

. 'n.

James A. Kendall, Esq.

'J".

4 '

' % Reilly, Like and Schneiddr,

'..$". j ' '-

'. +

j '.

~,

/'

X 200 Uast Main Street G-Currie and Kendall

, 'j

'+

Babylon, l'cw York ' 11702 s..

135 North Saginaw Road

' +

'./

Midland, Michigan. 48640 ' ;....

' ~

., /.

!!onorcble William H. Uad r

i.

Milton R. Uessel, Esq. 4 *,

"I.ssistant Attorney General

h., '-

.' J. Richa rd Sinclair, Esq.. '../ '.', ~ Topeka, Kansas State of Kansas -

66612 f

' Allen Kozabom, Esq.

',6.

f Kaye, Scholer, Fieman, Haya 7 --

., y......,,,

t ?.

.'f<,

  • ' * > l'..Howard J. Vogel, Esq.' '

and Handler

-l 425 Park Avenu. e - e ~

b:

7 Knittle & Vogel i

New York, Nr; 'sork 10022 J'.

v.,.

s 81411our Exchange Building r

~, #1

.,, Q#r* yfj *

~*

.,, Minneapolis, Minnesota J5415',.'

X, WilliamA.Groening,Jr.,[.Esq.

.s i

.s.

.'.27 James N. O'Connor, Esq. *.,

Judd L. Bacon Esq.,,'..

l

. Consumbers Power Compa'ny:

' *. -, "f[sw, The Dou Chemical Company. (M 212 West Michigan Avenue,,, ' - ;. 7.'

7,M',. y.e r g,; q,b 2030 Dow Center

.f

'tIJackson, Michigan s ;., ' 7,,:

49201','.

Midland, Michigan 48640

.e.,,..I ;..

.. i,

.' p,6t.; ;, 'Mr.',' Karl Jerg, Dtreetor i.J

,. Grace Dow Memorial Library',,.,l7 W a, g,.. -,'d. 'eg

,.3 William J. Ginoter, Esq0, 7-48602 s,9... 'j. ,,1710 West St. Andrew Road Merrill Building, Suite 4 N

.l,#

))

r 7, gIM+:

Saginaw, Michigan

, ;' f.1 % Midland, Michigan, 48640.;*

.. s.

4

.r.

(, *. 9 6..-

.~.

6 Ve '"t

..u.

r e

g

~-

a y, f e

y

', ^ ) ".Q*

"Y

. t o!.g

.;,s : ey y rs. p. =9.m,.L

.. ~.i

.(

,., s.

5

. g g. r..

J e

p.

n1C.'

,**.i f.

.$).

' '.. ' (,'s '

,'*..'6

) b,. l*

. r,:

.n e

.- r? D i.

s

- *~

%',,,y'dr*(.

..'#, O,

[ ** f g, 4 *,,,,,,

i

/

A..

., a ;

,~t

.t

,44s M.'

  1. $ a +%e. '..

(.

+e.

. = ' <.

.f..

- a *. S.',M. [-

4

. ~4, %.

.e,

... 42

.,'.,p.-

..y s

7 i

J

's h.

3 j,,

,,,.I

  • ^.d. g 4

.,'e*,

P f',*

g.

,88

('

l *, # ',.. j !,,

h ')'

g

, p 'n. a., *,, 'p; f;z 6m..m.. '.:*,, -

5 8.-

9

..,j,

r,. v.%

,p

  • i u.r.ig e,

[ A y,....,..

4 4l']s

,.g d,,<,

., s q. t, y w,.

9 r,

I I

s

, f h

1 g

,a,..,,

3,

's

..: 3

.'p'.s

.s

.,* Q,<

.,r* r *.

, 4

. '., D...

.y',.'a

,+,,,, J.

    • v,3.;., T.

o~

r

.. o ;\\

. 6 *s.

4-s

.y

,v

+..

+

. %.,..* ?N ',-

t;.'... '

  • ~ ;g..'.' '. ;,i.x'y,'

m,, ';r ~. -

~

.,j

  • s,.,.

., *:s t. <

y ;

't ',

'*Y

.. g e= 8

.,b

  • 4
  • a s,

',I,,~, t.

.((p...,

. e,r.,.w' E )* %a.' * -',a,

,...w

.m

.e,,f a

.e.m<, rf u.

.e

' yh*4

. N ;*.t v -

      • r,*.

s.

1 8's

,, [

,q /,

+

s as s

3

,.. y L, j e/ g..,,.. g'i Q,.' j" }'t,' i,]., *

[ 's g 4

..h, u,.1,,f, o %w..

,y A,,,

4

,, 7.

.,,~...

s.,

,, :4. :. ;7,.,',' '. d .1 v.,j, q f of.A V. ?

3 t

?1.y.;,p y. g.'

s g +, f.gd g -i.,1.-, y ;s 1-

  • w

.7, a

4. o J4

. a

..-se c

..e

,+

,,t.s ;.;:..

.s,..,., 7, ;,,,,,; t

_a i

.r; s

p'.. v, >.,+,..:<;'Q <V,* W,

  • N.* Y ll* ",

1

,. s..l,.. :

,... '}.. J., s,

v... -

., ' +

..'. d,s) j.s_,

a

.?

.e

.'s ',/

,,, g,,. - 4 a

6 w '.-

e '

n. /.

6 T

r,

, *~

.c i

.I.

,.,/* k '

._9,

,g g

5.

3

.I D

' ~. h,02 -

lsh ' * ',

  • Y,
  • k

. r'

?

, J,'. *.,*,g, y. ' * '[,.',.-

4

,,). r" ',

),....[t.

.e

,p,, g 7j, f

p'i p,,-)] #.

, 3 "'

)

. a y,.., m-a,.rA,,,..m.

. m.s...

' A. g..,

+

a t

- g I. I 9*

0.$

.T. $.#d h

  • [

' 8, An, #g* I.gg,

&.,(gI "f,

.9'..

,4 3

u

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML19331B179&oldid=4747739"