Text

Deposition of Jl Bacon (CPC) on 730515 in Jackson,Mi.Pp 1, 220-23 & 250-1.JC Pollock Affidavit & Certificate of Svc Encl
	ML19329E683
Person / Time
Site:	Midland
Issue date:	05/15/1973
From:	Aymond A; CONSUMERS ENERGY CO. (FORMERLY CONSUMERS POWER CO.)
To:	;
Shared Package
ML19329E679	List: ML19329E678; ML19329E682; ML19329E683;
References
	NUDOCS 8006160459
	Download: ML19329E683 (10)
	v • d • e

s _

_a-

. 1

,1 _ .__ a j

} I.

i

.* A*tn'*ic vm'r" (*G 3T"G_'O .1

. I . , -..

i ..

') .

1. \. 3, l-}

. .. 4. . .

"I )

i /

l In the I:stter of t ) G; ~#

j .

COM:.A"...'.i;'s L....,.,. 1. os., .,J P ~d C". C0!!PA!N e

) )

i I . L..us. . ) m .. '

AL'C ' ~.1 -. . M 5C. :J.OA and )

' . :.' )

5:30.;3:. ..

)

1, ,

-. . 4 .

f. ..

m 4, h

.: .., 4.6,,. ,. ,., ,o _4 .- . ~ . sa _ . ~ . . . . . .

,4 . ; .

.. . s. . .

I t ' i l .:. , .

l P., Lc.tv...a2Or, i:w.:ry Pub li.c 2.a

' l I . N.C D.2;, :

te,::c., lae;.'cTc 1 :'lt:::

j

w .~e. .~ .t . ...- ,

l t.N , .).<. n * , n.

- *

4. .'w' . . . . , ..'>. 0. . .

y v .. .Jh. , .; , r , ~5 -

s... .A t . v-u ~.. . . . .r,

. .. ,c, ,

c .. -.....-

.. . . p. .,..4.. c .t r. e~ .

i 4 . . ... .,. .,. .; a

,, ..,...,..<..a,.;,..s.._c,,.,

s,: . . . . .

t, 1973, -- .u. :

.. I I

) a.

1' . , . n . . . .,,, ,, ,e . .. u > ~ , .

j jl . . . ...,...m

....,m.

j

~- ! ,; .

t .<....s, u .. u g. . .~ o.e.

,. . c .

.re.a., , v. y.w......

.,._ ... , ..u. . . ,s .. . u .i 4 . .. + . ~ .-w..,..,

j

a. < :. ,, a c .. . ..... 7a.., .. .. , . .

u. ..

e . .., .: .,o. . n s. e . s.s.

. l

. . .. .... .t.

,.s. e . u.. ,>, .: . .4.. .e .

.7,n j 1

rep .rt::ent, oi Juntices ..

~l i

l

.,V:crhin,; ten, D.C. .

t

. :.;; . . . . t .

A.qx: Oriracn behnf of the I)nited Cts ca.

' I

j. ....,....c,

>n -

1 u. .

I ,.,., . l'O n..,r..,, a , J . 3,,, ,,v y e. .A. .the Atenic I:ncrgy Cce.ict.ic.1

)

C I httorncy ic: t l

f' Q,::hington, D.C.

e.

i icn.

{.

i

.J. .v. n. * , Appeari:'.9 on bchal.f of tho /. tonic Encr ;y Cox; t

..i .

--..'.-ev..,.,

.- i !

3

," *. . , , n .n. .1. ." . . uOHice of anti-Tru::t and Ende:nnity of tha Atcr. I

. c

,, Energy Cc:.- icsion l ion.

'.. , " tinchington, D.C. Appearing on bchci

~

--1 J

.t

" " " " ~""

8 W. R. L.suemn & MsocIATes

b. . ""^"'8

8006160h -

.. .i 1

q .

I ' '

2 0.. !;

_ l ~ e .

4

't qdcotican rolatitig to that'aubject :ntter. .. :.

Q (cy Mr. Cabica, continuing) Do yco kuc > uho Dc:.ald f-o.

t Cor&on 107* w. '::'r 1 d % - -

h

. . . . . . . . ' . .. .., . > .,s ..r.

b'~-

Yca.s . - .

. - ~ - .,. . . .t. -

l, ,

h - ,

1 Do v.ou knct him.Idrsonal.ly?: ac :

m" ! - Ni

{

. Q ,

I !

n ye a ; . ' ' :.. c:s:.~,. . yr n ,

I' i i Q I!aa he cint donc rny work far Co.1:U".:7rc rc. cr Co:.:[cny? I tca, u : - ' 9 ::s a : a .: , :.-

l

n' c , c. ,

s t

oI 1 hat'in tho~nscura'of? tha'.:i:nrk?:

- " . *'c4

~ ' '

' Y)":

f, O .

A EJ prcp n c0 a cMcur:nt which t:ca a nynthe ic c.i tho i

? iupach ..f and !.qcrtcnt of Canourern 'c.fcr Ucarna'f g i 5:0 tyc other r?. jo:: utilitics in the ctato to the [

o

j, i

cc0nc 7 c " thu r,tctc and reintcG cut come of t ne . : - .

ikportar.Qf. actors that had n bearic; cn tho'nuconcity ,

fer the various utilitica to have t::c chi!.it./ to i, li t jE i

finance their coactruction progra:u:, tho uc;;nitude !.

i-cf the:c p:00rn:.c cnd'their'icportance ho the ccenczy l ii I:..

of itho etntc~- . - ' it 14 W a 'd V W : a l'J -

' W h*

lh 3 ':

.f 3 jQ !!c 'uda bico ccoictant to Covernor Miliken, van ho not? .F 1

}

,i

'j A I:ct at the time ho prepared the study for un.* ,

i i

When did ha preparo the study?

~

- ;;I

.( jQ 1-

.y A Ec prepared the study after ha 1.cft the stato govern " .i;

. a

s'cnt', ' * ';* ' " M YG: h ? n L+'" :< -

9 ,'

i l i'

W. R. LAUCENER & ASSOCIATFP. l OETROIT. M;CHiG AN 48226 WOOOWARD 3 - I t 18 s

h l .

J

......--w.. _ _ __

~ _.. 2 21_. .

. .~

. .a - < -

0 That uculd be quito recently?

l A

It was in the fcil of 1972, fall or vintor, I'm not ,

-- 4 " l'- -

curo precicoly which month. . . -.'.: : 2 by each of J O

Ic it ccrrect he uno paid $19,755.00 f e

i Consumers ro.for, Dotroit Edison and I;ichigan UcIl Tclephcao Co=pany? :

A Ho. i i

7 Do you knc.1 hou auch he una paid by concumara Ecucr?

O

.i::. thancc.nd and A

I thin!- h3 wan paid apprenir=toly i j

-s l i

cc r2 cdd dollarc.

other O

I.onid ha have been paid an equal nr. cunt by th.1

~

- - .a e- ' :..- . .

, I tuo? ,

)

A Ye c . .

I undcratccd ycur qccation to tch whether or not l i

c !

1 he was paid 19 by cach and. that ucc the ceggregate of

} j

,3 ; , - -

,e: E a'q - -

all thrco, ao I recall it.

5I l i

u

.? I e:T (; la nC30: Ccunocl, before you j t

2 ";-- - .' r- i

! i

,,.., t i

- j continue the line of questioning, I accuce you're t

l going .to connect it in come way to an iccue in thin l llt

' I . g.; ; - -. M:;~ - c.c : . 1.a / - .- . !

proceeding? '

,J

' .:-: :, :- . I S:. .- IL .0ADLON : . I'beLieve the t ca i .i e.t -

, I I

J.va.. <-

i :

uLtnoso hac. x..,.. . .. : : uc.- : 1 :i-l.

cetg,.

.. L, 1'

i i

t, N..; t: IL ROSS: I object to any further ,

y-c.y t:

g en o , W: s r_...,, ,

questions unicos you lay a bacia.: _.

a 3r.33 L

W. R. LWCENErt & ASSOCIATES WOO 3W MD3 111*

dETRC;T. ?EMGt N 48:.O

u .. . v, I

i

> +1 I.

, i u

t. .,

.'s q e l

. p'< n ~..,

u.x :;r ym gggy ~;;; : Tne rea:on- i= : .

f I

f' npp :ently there hco been a-r morb tdich has an j

it.p.ct' on the coactruction prograt:2 undithe financing j .i i

l ,

c2 tt:c of the thrco cr:jor utilition in tho occ::o. i

-s

, I t tihe.t's that got to c:o !

c: 3;.- ic , . .w . .:-' 12. no:: : {

', I

. 0 U - G ' -:u ' I' with' thic t, Octeding?' M 4

f l ~

t l

7 % Onnm: - - Cecatu:o it t. g cen~

1

!' C F. tion ,

I tain inCc nation reicvant t , the ctatur, of cor?.;;;ti i

' i p

POT:rc e.ud their O.

~

D troit Edicon en: F Cons:- :::<0 .

t '.

' i a

. . i : . . e +. .. . ..th tia Chr.tc.-

CO

! ;r'- '.m :.' . ;a; 7c: :: nec :ca LeuOLn'3 CP I i cJ t I

l ., .s. . .n. .. _ . . .. .r.. ,. . 2 to r. e- wza6u 2ic:1 of chu docucwnt,10 ;

I,

.g 1

t

* * ~ - ..

6 tbst yOur laitP :C E0?

n ,

t._ o. ~ .;a, a;n..;;; z u.:.r do ::o.

i -

. .2,

...;- . y,,nogg, :Do yce hava uny pt:: pose l

..u.>,..

, ,, . 2 p. n. , .. x .i : "-3

'in"thic lin'0 of o. cationin; ?:- -

{

) . ..- s..,.a . . , . ...a.

s. ..

.,. .gg gggg;;,.733 g nantionet I do i.

I r de plbh to ncho a notion to ' l have cu ther pertene. l a

i c,g tho' ccart 'ulth =cgn 0 to m;ectiono which have been oq O Ic::citidad cudr thin't thin 4:ould alco bc a predicato

.for that. " I do 'not want to argue a cotion which I n:t.ht , .

'e" ""

'" - * * " " ' :' ' ~

c nnf cuko' at' thic ti. o. '

nc.v:e n : i. ma s s g , nggg ,- If you're not willing -- _ i i

3: cup W. R. LAUCRXine & Associates

_. t 1 i te WOODW ARD 3 DETROtT, MtOUGAN 48226 .

/

.A

. *p- - - . - _ . . . _ _ . . . ,

z I.

c ...

.. to givo ec your reacono I'll instruct tho tritne:;n r. ,1-5 t ! to anc',Jor any more quectionc of thic type uith re-t I

t g

}

1

}

Opect to nr. cordon with respect to this particular i

) ntudy, t

{

i Q (By Mr. Jablen, continuing) Let me ack you thiu 5

t t qucation c.n-2 your coun ci m?.y object, do you thinh l

4 censumerc Pc .tcr co..pany hau enf fered adverec publi-1 i

city becauce of this report? fir ,

f. - ,

.y }

e a e' .- l'a. nC1'C : . I objech..~ - '

i

, Q (ry :::. Ji21ca, continuing) Did ycu learn infor:ratien j from the '/cr=1 (phonetically) plcut which uan hclpiti

)

3 , l to ycu in the pir.nning fo': the !!idland planta?

g.

s A If you me.2n did I personally. - .* . . 1 . .; t ; .

. . Q Uc, I m0an tho company. . t:y; c , . , ,; ,0 . . . , ..

I

15 I think that.tho Fermi.: plant. produced. inforantion 1

j, j that in helpful to concumcro Pcuer company and indeed 1

j to the entiro electric utility inductry,f but uhother d; j it had any cpecific value in the decign.of the aidland i

f l plant, I ara unable to anctecr.

1 Q Did it have any impact at all on your decicions to 4 ,

apply.for a licence. for. the Midland planto or your f

I c

decicions to construct and operate.the ni.dlund planto, ;

3 l ;

I .

j ccouming . licenco . in granted?. .. . .- . + tcary ' . . . . .

q, i

W. R. LArenNun & Associates

'I'

, DETROtT. t/iCHiGAN 4G22G \VOc OW AM -

/

~.-.~ -- .a.sw ,. ,

.-- _ ...;~ <,a m .

E 2GO

.. . I i e

I l

(32cstian. < ..- .

l 1

(, , Q (My 1:::. ,R.bicn, cc:'.tinuing) , D ycu know uho l' red {l i

f., Pnroy ic? . .

i. ... . . ;..,.

, s...c..,..

, 5 i

e n Xcc. . , ... .. .a

. . . . . .. .. ... , , . . . ~ .- , - ,

, ; l

' l l e

O 1:*m in ho?

r j

I

A iM.,1.'c: cv is in charac -- I thith hic titic in Civic

. I ;

ns .,.. .. .u.s.. . .. . u,. ... . . . . ..

. . . s . . ., c n ....,: < .,, . ,. .

t.

1 7p he c regittc:cd it-chyict?,

i i

O .~ .

,..e ...

is } .r$ .

i

,J ! !

O p. ,. 4 .,- ., s.c -+ i. n .2 : .:c, . t :. : . . 7

i, e,

n

.,0.,

. x.~

,~. - t.

w~,.

.m, . ~

1,,,

a. 1.:.c, 1,. " i~- "ut th a u ~~..c . c..*'

.4 r.>.-

s. m . . , . ..c -

,. .. . , r . .

.i l Q tlh?.0 kin *I cn.uoth. cid ycn n .y he did y,cr .tho c=.gany? ,

A C.b,..~....'..'#..'.~.'.'**..

w . . . . . . ,.i ..,. ,.9 .

y..

. .u.....

. t. . . ,

4

. O i:h t U.id Irc oc beforc.for tha ccmptny,1:sfore hia procent ;:Oaition with .them?. ,. ,

A.

Ec tr.a, at one tiro, a registc cd lobby 1ct and r. ap. . . .

I

,recented tha cogeny in c=prcucing . ocr , point. of. vic.u 3

.to the l'.f.chigan L;<ji.clature t O I chou you a copy of documcat 10C02 and thc follcwing .. . . .

l 6

Do you knc.e,vhy.t.his liat uco cor. piled?..

.s pego. . .

.' l A F0~; 5 ; .~. n y h~ -i. t , *bi , h v, .:c j. -, :.w :;1: =.1w::ar

-7 .,

Q I cho.: you 6xutent. 010204..., no y.ou kucu,why the in- . .. . . .

t.

W. R. L*d;cENEu & AssocLt*dra D[THOM. MICHIG AN 4tl22o WOODWARD 3 - 111-J

- = -- - - - - - - - - . - -

- ~ ~ - -

_ .._ .L . .. -... ~- .

.~

9 p ,,, n ..

- . . .. .i L fort.c.ticit en thin ust... v:r. win ::cqueoted? , .

A Ap;;c;.- nbly i;r, Cap:bcll. Oc ,irca to hava .6:'.cr.r..d.irm che..t. C. anc;tix2 of. cw c:stivoc in t-ho nc.:thtent

- - J .. divi ;ic'.. .Ehat he tran plarmin.i to cb with 10, IOWn s

.*.y.

u. . .. .

t .

p g ' s,>. p r. .

. f ..<.

o.

.. 1 u.. *.. .. J A t. .s.*s.. n . . .

8

1... ~T.>. .2i. . i .f 3.,j e 0... g 5..* ,.

. 4,. ..

g. ..g ,.2 .,3 L. % 4 G 4 , L.. - .s

v. j .*,.a . .. 4* .Q.w'- .' . ,. .

,t es p, c.. ... , ,%. J s....

4. .! , . , en C a/. a. . ~ ,r. .. a .F.,.o.

t

% 's ! r. f..1.,....,

. p.. 9 , g ,. .,.

. ,s s .s *s

.e . . fT L ,

) [

C . a , .. . s~c.s . .

>, r. .- .,

7

t. . n ,2 .. . c .. . s....

4 . . -

. . . .: , . r .,.L,.,r..

c, .w .. . ) ; .,.r. . . . ..._.

3 3 1 1

,. s .. .

.p.+...s ..v....

.y c.=.>......tg,.,<,

og . s.

.......'......j

.r..ar . . .. . .

i.

4.,pe #. ,,

.... w. .g. ,, . .. f s -1

e. e..j v . p ......

. i

! g r,, g ,,,., ,.... -w.. s..,3 n..~.,.,..

p. ..

,s. .

t e. gp q,. q.. c... . .. g..,

' ; ( . .,j. e. ..s. , ..u 5, ...m..,. . . . . . .

, n..

(

t , .,

A c,*4... cD G f. - ..., - . . ,,

., .,. C,,.. ,r.,..m.. .$.n'...w:. _.:J.t, A . .s ...".

c.e. b.,...,* ,

1 i <.4 be.sai..e. - ,

9 ,i

'. i ,

.ra .f.e 4*

g t.,. Q. ..s. g.r.*. se u-. y,t , , a...7. .

',6 .

. . eu. 4 g, e3 . (,* .a%. . . u= .4 %..c. .{ .. .,*... i s c, ., .F....

l i

I n

i

. nkin ; colitical.cbjcuticas?

I, y

...A. r. . .C.",S . C. '~' ,t, e- ' .*.w .'1. ,

i I i b '

Q icy *C. Jabl011. 'CCntim12.ng) 50 7C3 UnOW 2 hat..P.r. Land t.

i hrs 2 CV' r C*:53 any political conk *ibutiCn On bChalf j

. Of CGn0un".:r.? 1lC.f0%*/ -

.. . ...' % . :. . ij c;$ . ,

f O q r $ . .: O - e...a., '

t~;. D0;;O: C';j ectica.m. .; m. j

.O (ny =. .Cablen, . centir.uing) . I t.' ant .to nefor.you A i ." A 'cpecifically to it, t.<ir, but do ycu recall a letter !'

I O .

.? to IL 2:cr:nn I.L.zpp, concerning the rural - do ycn :

i W. R. T4 AUCID:R .i ASSOCLiTI.:S

/ DETROIT. V;CH:GAN 482 26 . wooowt.R0 3 - li t t

AFFIDAVIT DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA, SS:

James C. Pollock, being first duly sworn, deposes and says that he is an attorney for Coldwater, Grand Haven, Holland, Traverse City, and Zeeland Michigan, the Michigan Municipal Elec-tric Association, the Northern Michigan Electric Cooperative and the Wolverine Electric Cooperative; and that as such he has signed the foregoing Application for Subpoena and attachments for and on behalf of said party; that he is authorized by Coldwater, Grand Haven, Holland, Traverse City, and Zeeland, Michigan, the Michigan Municipal Electric Association, the Northern Michigan Electric Cooperative and the Wolverine Electric Cooperative so to do; that he has read said Application for Subpoena and attachments and is familiar with the contents thereof; and that the matters and things .

l therein set forth are true and correct to the best of his know- ]

l I

ledge, information or belief.

O e' Pu M

James d7 Pollock i

Subscribed and sworn to before me l this 24th day of January, 1974.

(d.i A e t I h.

Q

. AYXLx_

Nptpryp Public My Commission expires Septembe,r 30, 1974.

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that I have this 24th day of January, I 1974, served the foregoing Application for Subpoena and attachments the by mailing copies first class postage prepaid to counsel at I

1 following addresses:

t.

Mr. Frank W. Karas, Chief Joseph J. Saunders, Esq.

Department of Justice Public Proceedings Branch Office of the Secretary Antitrust Division Atomic Energy Commission Washington, D.C. 20530 l'

Washington, D.C . 20545 Harold P. Graves, Esq.

Wallace E. Brand, Esq.

VP & General Counsel Consumers Power Co. Antitrust Public Counsel 212 West Michigan Ave. Post Office Box 7513 Jackson, Michigan 49201 Washington, D.C. 20044 William Warfield Ross, Esq. Dr. J. Ve in Leeds, Jr.

Wald, Harkrader & Ross P.O. Box 941 1320-19th St., N.W. Houston, Texas 77001 Washington, D.C. 20036 Hugh K. Clark, Esq.

Joseph Rubberg, Esq. P.O. Box 127A 1 Atomic Energy Commission Kennedyville, Md. 21645 7920 Norfolk Avenue Bethesda, Maryland Robert J. Verdisco, Esq.

Counsel for AEC Regulatory

.Jerome Garfinkel, Esq. Staff Chairman, Atomic Safety & U.S. Atomic Energy Commission Licensing Board Washington, D.C. 20545 Atomic Energy-Commission Washington, D.C. 20545 Mr. James B. Falahee, General Attorney i

Abraham Braitman, Chief Consumers Power Company Office of Antitrust & 212 . West Michigan Avenue Indemnity Jcckson, Michigan 49201 Atomic, Energy Commission Washington,.D.C. 20545

.. - ,- , - _ . , . . . % , , ., , . , . 7 -.-__.-m_ , . _ ., , .-v. - -y . - -.

~

Alan S. Rosenthal, Esq. Keith Watson, Esq.

Atomic Safety & Licensing Wald, liarkrador & Ross Board Panel 1320-19th St., M .W .

U.C. Atomic Energy Commission Washington, D .C . 20036 Washington, D.C. 20545 C04-James CT Pollock January 24, 1974 Law Offices Of:

Spiegel & McDiarmid 2600 Virginia Ave., N.W.

Washington, D.C. 20037 i

l l

1 9

/

ML19329E683

Text

Navigation menu

Search