ML19329A923

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Forwards Request for Addl Info Re Protection Against Tornado Missiles.Response Required by 751205
ML19329A923
Person / Time
Site: Davis Besse 
Issue date: 11/14/1975
From: Schwencer A
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
To: Roe L
TOLEDO EDISON CO.
References
NUDOCS 8001150819
Download: ML19329A923 (3)


Text

I 4=

mp:q Wa;tyMT?Q Yhhh$TlDRU: -

~

R.h -

i.y L%%% ':%b'.Wh T *9;;';;;~df~ % ' ~%.i.',;=

y; 7::

4w e

w.

s;;q7 s 72. _. _) mrv ~.s.u.i.e %pyr.w ;lg J:Ijil N BITG ON,., a.gu._ g.3 y@ ex;' ~ ?

~-

p:

'n Docket File TR BC's

  • NRC PDR LhR BC's Docket to..:

20-340 h0v. I a o

w L PDR ACRS (16)

LIG 2-3 Rdg g' g gthy, DTIE d

PF Toledo Edison Cannany ATRi:

.'tr. Lcwell'E.' Roc FHeineman

.Ice President JPanzarella Facilities v,evelopment JBuchanan' ORN'L E son Plaza RKlecker 300 Madison Avenue W' illiams ELD Toledo, Ohio 4365:

IE (3)

Gentlemen:

LEngle EGoulbourne

'Ihe additional infomation requested in the enciesure to this letter will be required for our crpletion of the Davis-Eesse, I! nit I review.

Ifr. L. Engle (Licensing Project.'imager) discussed these matters with Mr. E. !;ovak (General Superintendent of Power and Constr':ction) en September 13, 1973.

In order to naintain our licensing schedule, we will need ycur respenses to the enclosura by Decacher 5, 1975.

If you cannct meet the respense date, please inforn us within seven days after receipt of this letter so that we may revise cur scheduling.

Picase contact us if you have a17 questi ns regarding the enclosure to this letter.

Sincerely, i

., rpet N A. Schwencer, Chief Litt h'ater Reactors Branch 2-3 Division of &acter Licensing

Enclosure:

1 Request for Additional D

[0 Informaticn t

cv ces: See next page

~I

~

D g

v

_J y

x x7886/L

'-3 C-Liv

_3:RL o rr,e a,.

LEng #

AS e.cer 11/ j.j. /. 75

/....(..."._)._7 5....

11 Da719 Foran AIC.)l3 (Rev. 9 33) AECM 0240

%" u. s. ooveaa s=7 Pan =Tias orrir i

  • 2 * ' '*

o

, ~..

+.

l Toledo Edison Compa:r/ i ces: Donald H. IIauser, Esq.

The Cleveland Electric Illininating Ccapany P. O. Box 5000, Ree:a 610 Cleveland, Ohio 44101 Gerald Charnoff, Esq.

Shaw, Potts, Pittrian 5 'Ihrcwbridge 910 17th Street, N.W.

Washington, D.C.

20006 Leslie !!enry, Esq.

Fuller, Seney, Henry 6 Hodge 300 thdison Avenue Toledo, Ohio 43604 l

I l

OrrtCE D summaaes

  • oars >

. ~ - - - -

Forum AEC 313 (Rev. 9-53) AECM 0240 W u. s. sovannutar pen =vige orrects s era.sae-s ee

~

e e

ACCIDENT ANALYSIS BRANCH In order'to assess the degree of cocparability of protection against tornado missiles provided by the Davis-Besse 1 design accepted at the CP stage of revieu with that provided by designs currently under review, submit.the follouing inforna-tion for all Category I structures and appurtenances with walls or roofs less than 2 fcet thick, considering the spec-trum of missiles listed belou.

1.

For each significantly different vertical or horizontal surface thickness, identify the approxinate velocity below which penetration cnd the generatich cf secondary nissiles is not calcu]ated to occur, for at least Missile F below 30 feet clc zation and Missile C for all elevations.

2.

If you have relied on separation of redundant components for nissile protectica, please proeide ir a tabular fora all instances uh2re systins vital to safe shutdcun c.re not protected by barriers.

Describe the physical separatica with respect to cissiles frc: both horizontal and vertical directions.

Provide tha inherent capabilit'; of each un-1 protected vital systa= in the carne,r indicated in Itnt above.

Missile Socctrun i

A.

Wood plank, 4 in. x 12 in. x 12 f t., weight 200 1c.

Steel pipe, 3" diereter, schedule 40, 10' long, 78 lb.

B.

C.

Steel rod,1" diancter x 3' long, ucight 8 lb.

D.

Steel pipe, 6" diareter, schedule 40, 15' long, 285 lbs.

E.

Steel pipe, 12" diameter, schedule 40, 15' long, 743 lbs.

F.

Utility pole,13-1/2" dicceter, 35' long, weight 1490 lbs.

G.

Automob ile, frontal area 20 ft2, weight 4000 lbd.

O r^m' D

D eu cv J1 i

c,

~\\

e A

ol

_S_i

.......-...y

.--.--..7

.1-._..._

l i

-