ML19326C562

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Discusses Util 771212 Response to NRC Tech Specs Re Fire Protection Equipment.Resolution of Fire Protection Review Must Include Both Facilities & Be Submitted by 780115
ML19326C562
Person / Time
Site: Arkansas Nuclear  Entergy icon.png
Issue date: 01/12/1978
From: Case E
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
To: Cavanaugh W
ARKANSAS POWER & LIGHT CO.
References
NUDOCS 8004230677
Download: ML19326C562 (2)
v • d • e


Text

_

., &'T. :RX.v.Q;.uQfbWy[.Q.,.8 Vu%v.

Q QQGf.WW.ug@.w.Ky M %. %((

a mA fQ Mf'QWWP

.n 3

.~ ~ 1 n

L,

fWfM,

~ w :; G ; M.

M:,f~ Q $.Q g MrQ Q f k

l kb

'.Nh

"% %d%.M 7 N g. M 4;( W 9 Mi

.fa n an j: 7 9 4<i, % W 7 \\ g h M Q 3 $ Q g DISTRIBUT M A g' @j @u' f

J

..:/y p ' hRMDiggs.f7, Q 3 Do X

Mg j..y Q : ;y ;

'; MQQ fj <f TRPSnaider y.1Stolz' * ] A W NRC:PDR%

y; 4_.-Q ~ f Q); i i

5 % # 50VassalTo *j* ~ ; NOR.8-2.Rea' jf g@' y 3 t 1.

DochetNo[50-31 QQ

[ q,,,g.y&g;y@[JAN6121978

~

Q G ED0hReadingq q g $

z X d::,,lpNRRiRea#ingy 4 $,)%

w RMartin yf r'

', *y G,

% AffdSfM'JRBuchana'n s

> M[y,

. MNf hf.

o Arkansas Poweh & Light C' mp5My ~ %I;S OTBAbernathEWI(jlJS EG o

] JACRS (.16).,., j,KRGol,ler pgy tello3

. ATTN: Mr. William Cavanaugh, III

~ a M ".

,gJ g.

s J Executive Director, Generation f, J % A RSBoyd - gfg 3

and Construction.. M V e

'e -

YAI 'Qff DEisenhut,.qg

-1,

& p. O. Box 551.4 WW JM N u E 1/#g 4 W[igqfhgJScinto.,,0ELDq3T;.

. g%Little Rock,; Arka$a[ [72203%$ 5 Attorney 5en demen k N $[:,N D{ N h s h M h D M h M c p r. %.eg.+. y wrg M W &.f. m ev.l M U:gI&

3,gne $g,,

S mmended technical spe?hUK.9M&s b +g,

, N.: n.,W,9 % % :ded to you r @eco WMM

-g W~& $%?

r:f l 1 A We recently;forwar cificatton f

. ?;7 for. existing fireTprotection(equipment at Arkansai:Nuclaiiione9 Uni

~

MD(ANO-1) andsasked.that yoWrespond~within'20 dayslanhdyise E l

~

j

^

b f

us any specific requirements to which.you objected, citing the;

' MpgO

..i reasons and bases therefore.

Your company's response, dated W

December 12, 1977, signed by Donald A. Reuter for Daniel H. Williaras,,

stated simply that our recomended technical specifications were

" unacceptable

, s..,

. ", c,4 2without giving any-explanation. ig@.f:.h?g%g%. tybeM,

.. _ u..

p

,.n

< fA: complete fire,,,lhaz?, %w;y ~vg; m m;%.W, 7,,w.x.,..w& s.kuge f

.Q*.e

. c

. n n,,

r c

D Q.

.c s

24 ards analysts has ~stf11 not been s tted: for

,.y 9

w ANO-1, and'you are presently the en19 If6ensee that has not done _.%;#x,W MMgQf The fire protection technical. spectffcatiens that'you ?e'fginallffyb;g%

J

,saw r

proposed fel1lfar short of the level of protection we believ o

-pecessary. We consider the attention your organization has beenV a - fC iving.to,this important. issue to be ' unsatisfactory.q.ij g

y. % ?$.R ~ Q 'W.yffb.?,Mity Q Q &

yW},\\

'We ho h

C g%O:your,(pe <t at"this#matterfwill;be rectified 4the matdHa1; t

s.f.

Wil2, heis!.

Mindbi:a,tes :tist.youMyrsubm!fg

,.w6 ianda$lif#1Lf781g;,1-977E ~

c I "siYeady,%esisfaitriKthetit$sF:Mamerher ;p.

- 7@ef7ANSMWn%2 ts.sosiffu$ist@p~ n Wtisfactory?'rsolvt'tenfofKtheWQh e

. ^ fire protection. review.VSucPi resolutfen. is to include' heth Units" 1o eh il -and 2. 'If any event, the 'res' lution with respe o

be achieved very promptly.',.

y

~

.,v-

  • a q.

, J c h;;:W Q, m

. ln..

, Sincerely,' %:..' w,

. s ph e,e %;.-

s v

w

.n.-

s s

. n,n n

, 1,. ~

v..

. wgp a

f,4 (x 33

- THIS DOCUMINT CONTAINSs

'.1

~ g ; a. men p Jg_

.n

.+s s-w+-

? p60R~QUA0T(PAGliS y

C
1. "

' ' OJ.

Edson S. Case, Adtinglirector 'ZPgd

'4

<~

Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulatieel(4*%

,e

..n.. g cc: See next pa6e DOR:PSB-

'OELD e

WButler*!

JS'cinto

  • FOR PRFVTOll9 MNCHRRFNrF9 9FF ATTACHFn YFt I OW 1/9/78 1/

.'78

..,,e.,

DOR:0RB-2 0.._0R:0RB-2 DOR:AD/0Rs DPM:DIR DOR:DIR

,- Nf..iA IDIR -

.ne.i RPSnaider* esp. DKDavis*

.KRGoller*

RS,8cyd

-VStello-E6Chs,e y 1/6/7.8.

,.1/6/78.,..

1../. 6/. 78_.... -

1../... _/. 78 1/ /7.8 1 */78 y

i om j ronx sts (9 76) NRCM 02 4 j u. s. eovenwas sert painw.e orrica. s.7e -ese e c230g9Qx[

.a M@dlMCM e w. D ;h y W T

  • p.7 % @ I[# W@ mv y y @%.n@g 1

S MME@M.(r.p6y;,p 4;r TQ UT6TE#@lMM[

Nf@e,.g,c.g.

W, WMD

.w u y ys., e s an u

w w.m.

w.

2

n hh 4 g'Q.@.ng&w,h d Qby h68MM,$i%[hy@O h

d h

M $v $g v. M k ;C R.. M. g.c Wyh s qw;

/ -u l.P.; Arkansas Power,& Light. Company i x,n ?

n.w m/AN '12 ~197

.s n

.a

.w.p;Ms.

] g'5Q'g.., ;, g j ff:

W T.

.r.3

73 -; %,. n}4.Q},$. Q,,W;@Qy 3

X 2c-9

~n 4..; m 4 -

m-

~. I ' h,' h -,.

. Q p'

,.' y

. 4

.. *, r 5,-

  • ,# J' ?y
, J 'st..

'.a.[. $.. '

O hh I p'.'. c. N ' 1 Y

"T" s

y v'.

1

, - (c.'.*.

  • o.

34

. 's

. y,. ~

p se ; Phi 111p K.;Lfon,' Esquire -*,,.

.., %.n ^,' '.

." n y

.,a. j,.

g Cm. :s w' 5 y

, 1 MGT 4

, T, 4,f'g:i, House, Hol'as & 'Jewell. V ~l3 'l ' Mc$9 MG '*.@%Gp/M;Y.

,. m, ' s. VB W

%g' W 4M

" C ^4WN 0 M?'dWy D'N 91560-Tower Building '

b l~.:Little Rock, Arkansas 72201

,. s,,

M..,

vg *s +: A $ A

.j z.

4. '.' ).am.;,*

i

~4,

,.. Mr." Donald Rueter

.,z, s,

pu'

  1. ,'. ?!.-

f.#

n M,. u r

?, O W.h,

Nenager, Licensing C.

i = ~QF W

>; Arkansaa' Power & Light' Company, ? 6AyCg ?S;;&.,

~

Q 4 M @E M., M.. n. E P A. 5'l, & M @ +~ n.. + @

+ qw.

.Q6 M

/

W s. e *p+f y, w.

a., w w.

~

m p-T g? w?,_ ~'y@:.u. m% f W fcMr.(John W.iAnderson'1Jr.. W;~y *L n.

.~

- Q5"ne ' m

,Q:. c w.

^* R e.x R. s..q, An.

2 MN%;$*:t y., J. ~

h WAwpW J, AM%,,s M

n.

J v

Plant Supeiintendent,.

QsQsgSM:GM

- %,7 3 g *~ Arkansas Nuclear One. g,jf M % q f $ 9 @" 7 ~

w.Lr.M W SA RM i

'" ~Vh L4

?

v WV ' Post Office Box 608

~ 72801

~

4'..

~a mv Russellville, Arkansas'

'.l W '

~~ '

Arkansas Polytechnic College Russellville, Arkansas 72801

,y

. o., -4

  • ) ' J 'n N*
  • br h

,g g

3 d-y.)

7,,,

M '1 h[

$'[,) ['

.D. h' y I1 ;/.,, s,h.h

. /)

("'

i.

i 3..

.q... ~..

%, j. g..

s

.. & >4 n..

,,, o_,:

7yy

.,e f

's u x, e ;.

+.

4,*

u.

-e y.

~-

+g

y. - :

g % %_..,,+,.f e

a c

f h., ;y,$ ?.1., _,,

ase

,e

. ',. w f'

Y., d.

_y d f

wj. pt,

W *. M g g,&, f,. w. c*,

s

- p

's. ; n,-

5, i

^.& ' e 2, f'r., 4

',. ~

^^=s;

^

^*J?. w.Q v

n a n

  • <r

'*(,h.m.., _.

f

., !S

4. !..

p' *Jh [ %-.1 ' b.eQ e ji

,J h;

h 7, Q h,I.=.

e'$. *i

,. g.

2,.. v,,,[2,y a. up,.. -

^f r

~.. t o 7.,.

..g

' j... %,., e.4 E.B,4. ' !.1

/

v.

4.

- - 2W c f

..ge r

m gtf N

,,. v.,',,. :

, f k,.

', *. y,,w{,.n,

. n.. a s -..s. n. 9' +$s - m'.

  • h

^^ '"

-,~ ~.

?

?

~...

u~ M> M,. 5.

. k; e, r se

.y~

~

r..

.," A.

wL 1.,@ 7 b,4.E-%.*[,,"ars,' Q " M %~, g$,

,.w,,

A

, *.g^"e & n ;,=~ ry

-9.. ~r&.

~: 4 e

' [.4 *% d ' [.'f.M y i

pe.f n, t s

l7 4.7l.,

' N.*N
  • 8 [. "-

E

+.,,p $) g,,D g

_ ' A, i'

  • '. ~

. J i

.t s.,

i 'ts -= - 4

?

. 1?

q',

.a y,

-.c t'*

y ~g s a f _ ; 4 '.

v

". ~4 1

..> ;... g;,

.m g

.,..m

  • r *'

,~***T,

't.

n

. e s r

'js s

~-y-Z'g

+

2.,,

' n,$

j

,[

'*. 'a A.

C,

g,

v e,

.4

,[

k ,)

'4

- 3 3

,2 g-3,*

  • y g
w *-

m=

,. t r,. ' [4.,

r r

s a

g

+

^

7 y

4.,l 3

,s

  • - f. e >-

) w.'

sfA a '

  • N-uf.

,,A g g' xgc g -

a

,s -

.?'

_y s

3 t

- s;'

., eq <. f, -

r y~

c,.

,1

.t v:.>

,, =*

7. -

g' 1,.

?,

-s

V 4,

c,

.f:.

' ' > f ;c,

-_.. ".+:

.e

^

c q,

~

's

.S

}.

~. -

,,,y 3

,s.

4, l ^'

. l.

's,,o,.

, ' p.

k.

-3*.-)

n

. _,' m. %f.,,p_

~'t~-

,..o r. :

'2

~-

3- +

.*s

.e r,

. g'.Q,,

"e

-e 3

  • ] C 4-g

~

Q.r

~

r

m.., i..

,s

,a

. y

.t s A

OPPIC s W s

j

,,,.n u.&

' +

y x,"~

j A

1-

- x.

4

,g 1

  • g w

N, g v -

~f

.oave>

...c,...a.....

~

l PORM M3 (9 76(NICM 0240 g.,,,

. ; W u. s. oovann-esur m= vine arries sore.

L

'7

[

4 P'i*?~W L'

B,W W%

n W #3dY,, g4

%vaa%gm%rpq%q%e$m%me rrqfp q M nw,'

77 Q h T; D< w$..x., h_ F'. N ; 4 RMD ddwg t

Q u,+k..f.. %; w Q M". M r

M dQ E9M-OM ^3dB

.s h @_k!%..yA'W Jh8 WIN

.u4

  1. g-9m y

y d

i w. d. #

'4 9 %RPSn' aid.er"q% uD'osketr;4 7 wpm.. p,.

4eL., <

^

' & &g:4 W,w, m,x %v _ O -

M 9 l m e ;, g.

.A.

,; s

. 4,3 N NRC7PO

.. DVas.sallo..>m Jocal.R'!N GA,pPDR ww y.

  1. ; Docket' 40 '..#. ~Q, J. S /. K ~, m.,j r

ma n wn ymA

' + Q,.,JStolt y

R

.A ORB-21Readin. ~p.

...M,~NRR kea_d.i n_g. g: ;

~~ +

58-313 PM $ q*

.A M al(RMartin V

.j;&

,. p. M v L'c J T,a. D @ dJRBdchanan "y" P

.m 2 'A h~4 9@ h M.+ m, 1 W.W -lMc. $pe J 'CRS (16)' ' kE' Case @

MBAtierna thy'.

G MMNdM

' q ' O,n* ' Arkansas Power & Light Compa

~

<DM*

e~

A

VSt' ell o ny

? r KRGoller a " Y M ATTH: Mr.cWilliam Cavanaugh, III

.y

?

D~

', >T ; Executive. Director, Generation y Q ^ $ RSBoyd ~ Y'NN 3

. DEisenhut 3 M S 3..

and Construction.

y q v. iW. 3JScidtb(OELD).

"P. OJ Sex 551 J.g t

m. g..,lCf. A. Q;'Eggi,4 A tTo}nsk@

" " Little Rocks ArkansasE 72203.

P~

? & J y d4& Q3j &,8 mma{NecSentlem&:f&GQQ{lf)hhy%Dr.f &BM.)M 9T 5%&

T-d W

&{

N i ?ti% % % M M M &g d g q g k,2 7 M r & m W y n e

ent. s i d' M r

4DKDWy nA

%WMW

% ggr We meantly. fomarded ;tocyou reconneeded afcal specfffcetionsMMM)&

f

'y P <;for ' existing ~ fyre ; protection ' quipment' t Ark e

0 p/ n.11 (204) and asked that you respond

" of any specific requirements to whjcb you objected, citing the '1 thin 20 day reasons and bases therefore. Yoyr company's response, dated

'$gy December 12, 1977, signed by Donald A. Reuter for Daniel H. Williams, stated simply that our recorriended technical specifications were

" unacceptable".,e thout givipg a.ny explanation.m A wi h

7 i

.,,.. M.,.YJ r t

s +. +

,. m.. 4 m

-.. r..:.;r n

,:3 m

lysis %s.y m w m % v 9 :s sti11'not beenisubmitted c,

V A co.mplete fire haza s

.g vw yn

.y

' M0-1, and you 'are presently the only licensee' that nas not done?.M'&'W ^

~

The fire protect' ion technical specifications -that youferiginally se

( pro.

necessary. - We consider the attention your organ _on posed fell. far ydiert of W level 'ef protecti

~

ization has book..,.,Q giving.to this fapertant. issue.te;beJ

s. p unsatisfactoryM@M QM@P.D

.y

'f fn Fy U;, FQ@WB.WWW WV MW fk c:Jeupa,veap

/,,

a heen advised that;thejlicensin 4 pen the Jet.isfa;gtegy. geashengen, 6(offMe Aung 2M;,' me6~*o

.it Ch ac

,e T.htsmL:,thi44Ms3spisimWoE[7miiffr 6ir eAtimaleeep n y

M yI W G. 7 'i s qbeid i 4

utt C $ b b Wis'EARSrstts h M.. inMii Etelt y %'1974i,WC.. 1MuidT2.Fhik1 r d rga.f n

s.< your @uimar. er a e m>

4 er

~

ttal. ma.s"$)sdica m

.s 19771etter, and.the prompt satisfactory (ese.1stionof'this ~

r w

,7 g'

L ~

7,

, x.m,L.c

. m ;, ~

n

, 4:,. -

.,f s',. p e, jG 3 :. a p.p _ q.

.. en-Q : e,o j y y.,Sincer,ely,

x y ':{2.g&f.cg,K g.

..g

,y -

s-y-s c. ' " r, e.,.,

.m.

,,%g, st.q'

( ~ y. c.p,lw' w ;. w,.

> ;g., _ ?,, y

,, u p ny3.p. y ' y'W1

-s

',;' n,Lw

,. ; 4,,

3.,..-

3

.s.

.y - m m<

,v, 7; m n c.

si,.

n,y.

.c #

..c. v, -

g I'. Edso'n G.' Case, Acting Director',:%,- w.a,...

y, r y e.

-8 J M p_.

..1

~ %n'.a, v.Offic s-w.,..y.y 4 e, e of Nuc, lear Reacter, Regulation s.

'L

, +e,.n..

c

~. - -

3 L.. w-A*,,]y ; JN,.m u:\\

.qM, %,. 4

_ ec:11See next.page' EW?m eM p Y ~4 W M ' Y..

a*J D

~

DOR:PSBf rM)W <.."j~

OELD1

/

WBecler ((

UScinto

- -)

4 :x. ;

, :(

/,

1.4 /78'

- 1//W78, s/

Wl7M<.

mic;

  • RB-2 10i% 0/%.2

[00R:AD0R RGol dg....

.db iS.tglio

}GCase-DP' DI

.00R:DIR NRR:A/DIR

.RPSnaide.rie m DADb I

..u - a.

A m_ AKd

.uwe aA.

m 28 _ ti/ >/78 2 e

NRC FORM 313 p.76) NRCM, 0240

.,,, (ui s.+wammessur ensurine orriced sere-sas esJ

..Of,4

.[.

i

.

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML19326C562&oldid=4760331"