Text

Ack Receipt of 890811 Supplemental Response to Violations Noted in Insp Rept 50-382/89-12
	ML19325D083
Person / Time
Site:	Waterford
Issue date:	10/13/1989
From:	Milhoan J; NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION IV)
To:	Dewease J; LOUISIANA POWER & LIGHT CO.
References
	NUDOCS 8910180339
	Download: ML19325D083 (3)
	v • d • e

R $ h( y % % L.;

lF [ ' ' '

'

n

,

nnsllib& m

'

L

-

~

,

.

/ 9J

'0CT T31989

.

' ,

gNyp

y y

a

m,&w

.

,

.

a

.8"

.

,'

-

'

' _ '

.

..

.

.c

.

"

r,

. , .

.,

,

b' ' e '; min 1 Reply. Refer To:'-

.

-

v

'

-

,

j

.

'

l

'

^ -Docket:o50-382/89-12?

'

p

, g,

'

_

p

_n

.

y

,

yp g

'

ar

e

4

e

,- g

,

LodidianaLPower.&OghbCompany

h

j

,

iT

J,T : ATTN:t tJ.EG. Dewease, Senior Vice President

'4

'

'J

Nuclear.. Operations .

'

..

{,]-[

New Orleans ~, Louisian'a . .

.

3171Baronne Street'.

" 1

'

r 70160-

]

_

,-

.

,

-

,,

^ #.

Gentlemen: ,

,

,.

.

11,1989, .for a supplementalf response

d'.i

'

o

,

'

Thank you' for; request of August

.

i

,;

.

'

to ourLietter and Notice'of Violation / dated June 9,1989.

.

, m

.

'

'.

q_

-

We havei

-

4

',

,

a c

q

y['

reviewed your1 reply andLfind:it(responsivecto the concerns raised in our?

/

.m

m

.j

^

"

(Notice of Violation. We w111) review the Limpleinentation of your corrective-

a

,

'

,

'!.

. .

.

,L

~

-

.. .

..

s '.

actions during a future inspection to, determine that full. compliance has

,

m

-

w

.

j[bEen~achievedand'wil'1bemainta'ined.-

.

l

.

q

,

-

y,

Sincerely,

"a,

-

,

a

,

w-

.

<

,

q

..

!

mI

/f '

>

s

s.

,

m-

_

m.

,

.

w

P

James 'L. Milhoand Director,

,

.

W

-

.

Division of Reactor Projects

l

'

e

.

<

'

.

,

~

'

CC:

,

..

'

/

"'"J

' Louisiana 1 Power &' Light Company .

l

ATTN:?R.:P.-Barkhurst,ViceLPresident

^

,

'

,

'

?-

LNuclear Operations'

F'"

P.'0.. Box B-

,

l

lK111ona,l Louisiana 70066

'

.

be

.

.,.

.

4

'

,

4

Louisiana Power &-Light = Company

T

i ATTN::,;J. R. McGaha, Jr. , Plant Manager-

-

M

P.O.: Box B: .

.

s

F

i Killona. , . Louisiana D 70066-

.

-

L&

. .-Louisiana Power & ~ Light' Company

.

'

" ATTN:

'L.: W.1Laughlin, Site-

LL

Licensing Support Supervisor

,j

'

J,

.

[

,

-P.0i Box'B'

.

70066

'

': ~

}1ona,'Louisia

'

>

D:0Rb

Ok

l

h

RIV:RI'

'R

SRI

C: R A

L

~

< TRStak

WFSmith

DDChamberlain

JLMi hoan

'

.

j

?10/g3/89 .m

10/g/85

10//3/89

10/g /89

,

-

l

e91o180339 891013

'

if

di

.

gDR

ADOCK050g2

},',

..

,;

'%-t

.

. . u

.

. .

. . .

.

. .

.

. .

..

a

.

.,,

-

.w 'e

.. .

&

1

x

n, x

..

,

>

.

<

+ s A

'

Mfh;[91% ,:J ,'.,,7g,

~

'

Msm :

y

'

+

.

M

<

'

.

,

-

qv.s.y .y-

yx

.

,

.

,

-

,

j[hh.

4- '[ '

^

'

y

,

tQ;;m

4

. . .

.

. .

" Louisiana Power & Light Company-

-2-:

-

-l

Q ;Ev

,

.

a

,

.

. ,

.,

~

.

v

.;

.,

"I

'

p ' .') "

4

'

r

,

~

\\

i .., u 4

.'

,

'

%;3 : ;~;,

,

/L'ouisiana Power ALLight Company ~ ?-

'"

,

' ATTN:n G. M. Davis 1 Manager.; Events

'

-

'

e

J

'

&4

.

N.

1 Analysis Reporting & Response

"

g

.M

,

'

iP.O. Box B.

Q ' 4~

s

-

i

'

.K111onaWLouisianac.70066L

.

,

'

n

. ,

f tF iMonroe & Lemanu . .

,.

'

+

<

'

' ATTN:o W. Malcolm Stevenson,i Esq..

>

'

7,a 2011St. Charles: Avenue Suite 3300

,

<

_

-.m

O^l

DNew;0rleans, Louisiana ;70170-3300-

'

.

,

_c

1

r

" ,

,

r

'

Shaw, Pittman,Motts & Trowbridge .

b

' <

.

. ATTN:i Mr.!E. Blake

-

'I

,W_

'2300 N Street. NW

.

' "

'

. Washington._D.C. E20037l

y

'

^

,7

,

4

%

"

!

[ATTNi).ResidentInspectorU.SE NucleaP Regulatory Commission.

. '

'

t

,

-

.

x

.,

J

0

'P.O. Box;822-

1

~

'"

'

>

iKillo'na,~Louisi5na-170066

i 1

"

7

,

c.

,

,'

l

SMiddle SoutfServices'. Inc. -

, 1 ATTN:; Ralph T. Lally,, Manager.

.

m

.

.of Quality Assurance

..,1

P.On Box:61000-

'

-

,

'

M

New;0rleans, Louisiana 70161

'

p ':

,;

,

.

Chairman

5

. ..

"

,".

fLouisianaiPublic Service Commission ~

l

'-

'

10ne"American1 Place, Suite.16301

BatonRouge,(Louisiana: 470825-1697:

j

u

- m.

..JLouisiana' Power & Light .. Company

.. .

.

. .

~ . *

'

ATTN: : 1R. F.LBurski', Manager,. Nuclear

~ Safety and Regulatory Affairs

3

.:317 Ba'ronne~Streetu '

'

-

.

E

l New . Orleans,; Louisiana l7 70112

,

w,

~ , U.S. Nuclear! Regulatory Commission-

'

&y

-7'iATTN: iRegional Administrator, Region IV

'

611 Ryan Plaz'ai Drive, Suite 1000-

'>Ar11ngton.1 Texas 1 76011,

.

Oc

5.

,

.=

. . .

Office of Environmental Affairs

-

lh* '! ATTH: William H. . Spell, Administrator

,

.,

,

Nuclear Energy Division

"

'

P.O. Box 14690

-

Baton Rouge,^ Louisiana. 70898

.

,

. ,

, ,

h

/

.k

% )

%

, X.

...;_....

, . . , - . . . .

-_, . .~_____ __ _ __ _____________________ _ _ ___,___

,-

s

..

_

mbpy;gr

J6,9%u

'

.g ;.;

' '

'

1:

'

x

,

.

,

.

,

.yy

n;;c

=g5:

. V ,. , ,

'

,

f (l;l

"

i,,:;

1

~,

g; e@t .g.; ' Am! f, i .

4

'<

'

1-

<

% p',

'

,-

i

t '" 1

'

"'

,

.

,

-

,

-

,

- -

,.

O'

,4 ;

+

5

i

1

,

L;

$h;

,

-

i ('>

i

'

.

,<z

e

'

d, ~Louisia.na Power & L1Mt' Company 1

H3-

i

'

_,.

..

-

.-i.

,

..

,.

p-

+p :

4.p..

,

,,-

i

,. .

.. '

' ' .

,

'

,

a

w

,

.

v.

,

,,

,

4 .. -.

,-

,

President, Police Jury'*

-

l

.

,

.

b'

w St. Charles. Parish

'

-

'

,

fi

.

Hahnville,Louisianai.70057

>

n #..

.

e

c

,

'=>

,5.-

, , ,

.

.,

'

7'

'

,he

P

"

,

E

Ae

J

.'Mr? William 1'A' h' Cross .

-

4

7: f

.

y

P-3,

g

I

p)

-

> >

Eh

-lBethesda, Licensing Office

v

j

'

>

,

n4

13 Metro Center

?

'

a

f

"

'

,

9"^

Suite 610: ; . . . 20814'

i

',

Q ', t iBethesda,!Mariland

..

,

'

"

,

.

,

m

_

..

e

,

..

, o

. . .

, ..

.

,

-[T_

, '

y ;

'

.

p# u.. y

,1becito DMB:(IE01)

'

r

+

.

'

s

. .

,

. ,

a

.

.. . ..

..

.

'

.

+

L

-bec distrib. . by RIV:-

.

'

>

,

'

P

e: OSection. Chief (DRP/A)

DRP

'

" -

-

3

"i

RPB-DRSS.

,

.

.DRS

'

, ,

.ProjectEngineer:(DRP/A)-

T MIS System

'

"'

RIV File'

.

RSTS-

-

<

,

' ~

-M D;iWigginton, NRR Project Manager (MS:

13-D-18);

-

iLisa Shea, RM/ALF;

'

-

.

t

2

N

s

l t}

+

t

'h

I

g

4.

1

.s

>, ~

5 9

'-

h

,

.tv,

,

N l:

'

y

-F

, ' ,_

..

r

i*u,

,

. . .

-

ly

,

,;

2

I

r

i o

x

n

. . -

,'}-

.,

i

l } M.

':i

s

..

1

4

'.;

%

( ..

' .c o

o

-

s

m

li

kO,

$

yv

,

h

I

j j '. 'g (, ?

'i_

.,

,

4

' 4,

r

j.

yp g. ;

+ - - - - - ..

.

..

-

'

-

s

..

V:

]

'

3.: um., .--

o

,

'

jf'.

.t

L,?e p q

.. .

.

l

= .

< -

-: y

.

s

l

-- l

'

., ?.} [

.

_

l

.

4

b

-

.1

'

~

[ ' LOU 181AN AD/ sir sanoNNEStatete.o.soxe0340

..

(504)595 3100.

)

POWER &' LiG HT

NEW ORLEANS, LOUISIANA 70100

[;

,-

,

UdSdivsWU

'W3P89-1561-

' A4.05 '-

,

=r

.QA_

.

September:11,11989-

-

MhM

b

-

..

i

.U.S'.. Nuclear Regulatory Commission

.-E IO N

j

'

)

'

j

~ ATTN

Document Control Desk'

a6

,

'

-

Washington, D.C.,

20555

I

Subject:

Waterford 3 SES

. Docket No. 50-382

License No. NPF-38

i

.NRC Inspection Report 89-12-

' Gentlemen:

i:

Louisiana 1 Power & Light.(LP&L) hereby_ submits in Attachment I ths

<

supplemental information~ requested in your letter of August- 11,/1989.

-If you have any questions concerning this information, please contact

~

y

.L.W.-Laughlin at (504) 464-3499.

H

,

L

Very truly yours :

l'

G&La-

L-

-R.F. Burski

!

l:

Manager- .

.

Nuclear Safety & Regulatory Affairs

'-[

RFB/DMU/pi

,

'

cci- Messrs

R.D. Martin, NRC Region IV /

F.J. Hebdon, NRC-NRR.

D.L. WiggintTIC~NiiC-NRR '

NRC Resident Inspectors Office

E.L. Blake-

.

,

W.M. Stevenson

-

1 '

'

>

\\

e

j

"AN EOUAL OPPORTUNITY EMPLOYER"

-

g-

~

^ Mi&&i58

5

. . - .. -

- - - .

p

'

,

c

+

4 ;* x

, '

]

y4y:.

7-;. ; - 1 e .

L

l

. . .

I

'

' ATTACHMENT 1

,

-

SUPPLEMENTAL RESPONSE TO VIOLATION NO. 8912-02

INCIDENT NO. 2.

)

l

'As. state'd in the original violation response LP&L does acknowledge that a

procedure / drawing discrepancy did exist.at the time the splices for MS-416

1

.

. were made.- The' specifics of this discrepancy'were discussed in detail. It

was.also stated that when the discrepancy was identified, Quality Notice QN

]

,

No.=QA-89-124 was immediately written.

.1

p'

In paragraph 5 of the original. violation response, LP&L stated that

procedure ME-4-809, Low Voltage (600 Volts and Less) Power and Control

.

Cable / Conductor Terminations and Splices Revision 4 would be revised to

3"

eliminate'the noted conflict with drawing LOU-1564-B-288, sheet 40. This-

,s-

p

was the proposed response to the QN as well as the planned corrective

action to' prevent recurrence

j

From the time this discrepancy was discovered and until ME-4-809 could be

r

~

revised, interim measures were implemented for splicing low voltage cables.

- '

Maintenance planners were instructed by LP&L management to discontinue the

use of, or reference.to ME-4-809, Section 8.5 in work instructions for

insulating splices. Work instructions were now to specify that all low

voltage splices were-to be made in accordance'with the B-288 drawings.

>

'An innediate-revision to ME-4-809 was therefore not necessary because it.

would no longer be used to provide instructions for insulating low voltage.

splices.

On August- 16, 1989, Revision 5 to ME-4-809 was issued.

Section 8.5, which

had been the insulating procedure, was deleted in its entirety. No further

possibility now exists for a discrepancy between the instructions of

procedure ME-4-809 and drawing LOU-1564-B-288, sheet 40.

,

All future-low voltage splices will be made solely in accordance with the

B-288 drawings. Work instructions in all future Work Authorizations (WAs)

will direct technicians to use only the current revisions of the B-288

drawings to perform low voltage splices.

In Revision 4 of ME-4-809, Section 8.5.2 contained a note which stated.

" Filler shall not be required if totally impractical, such as with

-small-sized wire splices." At the time the splices for MS-416 were made,

Revision 4 of ME-4-809 was approved for use. Based on this note,

insulating tape (as a filler) was not used on the MS-416 splices. When

Section 8.5 was deleted from ME-4-809 in Revision 5, the above note was

also deleted.

Based on-the above information, the low voltage splicinC Procedure / drawing

discrepancies have been resolved and no further action is required.

s

-

--

---

- - -

- --

-

.

m. .

.

-

ML19325D083

Text

Navigation menu

Search