ML19325C970
| ML19325C970 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Davis Besse  |
| Issue date: | 10/05/1989 |
| From: | Taylor J NRC OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR FOR OPERATIONS (EDO) |
| To: | Shelton D TOLEDO EDISON CO. |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8910180230 | |
| Download: ML19325C970 (2) | |
Text
w p;, N..
q Q
- r sy a
L
+,
N October 5, 1989 L
Docket No. E0-346 Toledo Edison' Company' -
ATTN: Mr. Donald C. Shelton Vice President, Nuclear l
-5501 North State Route 2 Oak Harbor, OH 43449 7-Gentlemen:
By application dated September 22, 1989, you requested a partial exemption from the FY 1989 annual fees of 10 CFR 171 for the Davis-Besse 1 reactor.
You. -
t requested that a portion of fees already paid be refunded because you had been charged for research which had not been performed.
As you are aure,iPort 171 user fees are assessed on the basis-of budgeted costs, not' actual obligations. Since it is expected that there will be some i
deviations between the funds budgeted for a specific activity and those actually obligated, exemptions will rarely be granted. ~However, in unusual situations where there is a very significant variation between the budgeted obligations and the actual obligations, an exemption may be consiaered.
We have completed our review of the exemption request filed by your att9rneys.
Based on the' fact that very significant budgeted costs for two B&W research-related activities, namely, " Prevent R3 actor Core Damage - Plant Performance -
B&W Testing" and " Reactor Accident Risk Analysis - Assessment of Plant Disks," -
were.not totally obligated for these specific activities in FY 1989, but rather were expended for other activities relating to all power reactors, we have-determined that a partial eNemption is appropriate. Therefore, pursuant to the provisions of 10 CFR 171.11, a partial exemption is hereby-granted for the
-Davis-Besse 1 reactor. The annual-fee is reduced from the FY 1989 rate of 51,592,000 to $1,320,000; accordingly, an appropriate refund will be sent to-you shortly.- Enclosed is a documer.t showing how the refund has been calcu-l a ted.'
If' thet e are questions regcrding this exemption, please contact Mr. Lee Hiller, Deputy Controller, on 301-492-7351.
bri$l'krkd By.
Jarr.as M. Taylor James M. Taylor Acting Executive Director for Operations l
Enclosure:
g Refund Calculation See attached for distribution.
no 14 d ci p h,,s s
/
EO Og
.-.---:-..gqC OC i
OFC :
0 i-----:.-
hgins: JMT 'f or :
-....:--------...-:-.--.h-f[-:
NAME.:CJ oway:jc (
er
- RMS
---:-----(/89 10/f/89 DATEf ::10/// /89' : 10/ f /89 :
1
/89 : 10/
-8910180230 891005 PDR ADOCK 05000346 0FFICIAL RECORD COPY
-- P PDC s,
pf 9)p,,
~
N '.
i-
[!Q.g T-l NN I
u -:
A a)
- p
,,. +
c,-
s l, hA';.
a!'
DISTRIBUTION..
p w
lQ:/
i, J lJMTaylor, Acting ED0' EDO.R/F'
?!
-License' Fee:rdbt Collection 171 Fee File
,.niv Docket ~ 'llet E-OC Part'171: Exemption file CJHolloway,DC(2) e
.Lll iller, OC-r
~
.RMScroggins',0C; OC R/F M.#<
GDJohnson,.0C/DAF
. 'EKBlack, OC/DAF.
l f DBDandois, OC/LFDCB
'~
^~JDWeiss',OC/LFDCB
<'TRothschild, 060-j
.:.;.'~
RSmith, 0GC; P M..
( 5,'
f E
I 1
ll 4
(*
P
';#r I
k ja l.-
r
".[
( )l-1.{'
{
?
/
I
{
J 's ;,,1
{/i' <
1
+
i e:
9 5
h
_l
.t
,1 ['
Itq'
~ * -
+ '
g p,
i-c y 3,9 ;;
- vn N % Mj 7 +
g..
,1%
.e
^
M COMPUTATION OF PROPOSED ADJUSTED ANNUAL..
u FEE TD BE A55E55ED -FOR EIGHT-BABCOCK L!
[li;m AND WILCOX (B&W) REACTOR 5.
2-
,, j; FY 1989 BUDGET.
O g
yp,
'k l ~ Part~ 171 Work by Research PTS FTE 3;;y
' % -Original Budget Base e
'b,S.
Nuclear Steam Supply. System -
-Large Dry Containment (B&L': only) y ls
$ Prevent Reactor _ Core DamageJ-53,500,000 1.8 -
. Plant _ Performance - B&W Testing 1
2.
Ructor Accident Risk Analysis -
475,000
. '7 Assewnent of Plant Risk l
E ly,
Subtota l.
$3,975,000 2.5-I?
.2.5-FTE-x $1CR 900/FTE =
377,000 g
L a-l:
Total Costs
$4,352,000 L
Total B&W Reactors 8
- = $544,000 per reactor b
j, Revised Budget :%se (Sums.0bligated)-
. 1.
Prevent Reactor Core Damaga -
$1,309,000 1.6 ~
' Plant Performance - B&W Testing t
[
- 2.
Reactor Accident Risk Analysis - H-Assessment lof-Plant Risks
?
Subtotal
$1,309,000 1.6 1.6-FTE x.5150,900/FTE:=
241,000 Subtotal Revised Costs
$1,550,000 Recap
'$4,352,000 ' Orig'inal Costs 1,550.000'- Revised. Costs 52,802,000"Losts Applicable to All Plants l
106 Reactors s
$26,400 x 8 B&W Reactors
211,000 o
Total-B&W Revised Costs
$1,761,000 = $220,000 per reactor Total B&W Reactors 8
A f $5'44,000 - $220,000 = $324,000 x.84(M Factor) = $272,000 Amount of Each Refund y w I
ENCLOSURE 1
.