ML19324B042

Final Response to FOIA Request for Documents.App a Documents Available in Pdr.App B Documents Withheld (Ref FOIA Exemption 5)

ML19324B042
Person / Time
Issue date:	10/25/1989
From:	Grimsley D NRC OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATION (ADM)
To:	Darke J AFFILIATION NOT ASSIGNED
Shared Package
ML19324B043	List: ML19324B042 ML19324B045
References
FOIA-89-355 NUDOCS 8910310037
Download: ML19324B042 (7)

Text

1

(

s

.s. wucted

" rony comunsaion e f o.s aiove.i v c==

FOIA 355

)

if II I

j amo ym RESPONSE TD E

M 1

'=

I l'aa m i

l[

)

INFORMATION ACT (FOIA) REQUEST f.

OCT 2 51988 l

e.ees ooern esu man:n.,e.eem I

j moureveR j

Mr. John Darke PART 1.- AG'INCY RECORDS RELEASED OR NOT LOCATED (See checaed isones)

No egesipy records subfect to the request heve toen located.

No addiq6enal eponey recorde subsect to the request have t.een located.

Respeeied records see eveneth through another pubhc d.stribut6on program. Sw Comments Section.

Agency records subpet to the reevnt that are 6dentifed on Appendialest e<e already evellatae for public anopection end copying m the edRC Pubhc Document Room PtP0 L St+eet. N W., Wash #ngton. DC 20666.

A e,e i.e.no,nede evenous for puu.c inspeewin and copy.no in the Agency reconts subsect to the request that are identefed on Append mini XX NRC ruu.c poewneni Room, PtPO L Situt N W., Wnhington, DC, in a foider under ih.s eDiA numter and reauesier name.

The nonproprietery version of the proposellst that you agreed to accept m a telephone converseten with a memter of my eteff is now being mese ovelletdo for pubhc inspection end copying et the NRC Pubhc Document Room PtPO L Street, N W., Washmgton, DC,6n a fonder undes this FOIA numter and requester name i

Agency records subject to the request that are identifed on Append,alest may to mopected and cogued at the NRC Local Pubhc Document Room edenhfied l

in the Comments Sechon.

Enclooed le eformation on how you may obtean access to and the cherges for copyme records pieced m the NRC Pubhc Document Room, PtPO L Stent. N W.,

Weehgton, DC.

p gg Agency records subsect to the request are enclosed.

Records subject to the teouest have toen referred to another federal egencytest for revew and dvect response to you.

t h

You wiu be teed by the NRC for fpH totehng 4 in ylew of NRC's suponse to thes request, no furtter acten to bemg taken on appHIletter dated No.

PART R. A-INFORMATION WITHHELD FROM PUBLIC DISCLOSURE Cortem 6nformation in the requested records is tems withheld from pubi.c disclosure pursuant to the esemptions descrited in and for the reasons stated in Port a, i

XX sectens B, C, and D. Any reiened portens of the oocuments for which only part of the record es teing withheld are teing made available for public enspecten and copying en the NRC Pubhc Document Room, Pt 70 L Street. N W., Washangton. DC. m e folder under this FOIA number and requester name.

COMMENTS f

t h

l 1

, DIRECTOR. I ION EDOM OF INFOftMATION AND PUBUCATiONS SERVICES d4@4dse p wm 'f.jff ]%&&&$fil&hfGW,@W&&$$h@WhY&

p %:w w,wvic.&,s..o j ',, y qp@c,wn

,z,

- o.n w.

m..

3 y rugWg y

ggq u

j. cg.

H 3.

7,. " s '

4.M F.T'm o, M c:4

.; 8910310037 091025 2+

aggy y pi g J'

1;, ' 29

. lM '

PDR FOIA

,,A,A W

+; w., %y;:g 'f '&; r QW>,

b r,'

,o mu,

%py My _,_ ;ll. lW DARKEB9-355 PDR v.qye%,ym.m:ywgwggw my y v

NRC FORM 464 IPert h eti es.

jf-~ "

i MWEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT RESPONSE tosa ruwet ms>:

FOIA 355 oA4M,,e_

~'

PART 3.8-APPLICAelt LXEMPiimi I

B er> being withheld in their entirety or u part under the

' Aposede subpoet to the esoveet that are described on the enclosed Appendiates)

Esemptione end for tp seasons set forth below pursuant to 6 U.S.C. b62(b) 6nd 10 CFR 9.17(el of NRC Regulations.

t tl

1. N withbeid 6 formet6en is propeely cleoWfed pursuent to teocutwe Order (txtMPTION ti L

. N w.tte.w.nf-euen raio.

, io ihe iniem.i per.onnoi ruies.nd prxed,es of NRC. nxturfioN ei

t

3. N wethhe6d intoemeuon to opcificeny esempted fearn public disclosure by stetute indicated; ftxtwPTION al

~

(P' 4'

141145 of the Atomic Energy Act which prohibits the d+ciosuis of fiestricted Date or formerly Restricted Deta 142 U $ C.

16121661 sections 1

l I

Sect 6an 147 of the Atomic Energy Act which swohibits the dieciosure of unciennited Sefeguards informeuen (42 u 5 C. 2167).

l 4 i The wnht.w mf.menon,s e i,.d..ec,ei or comm.,ciai o, f,noncienntn.non ihai is t.mg wnhhow ior it. reasonisundiceied. itxt MPTION el i

• b N informauon is considered to te confidentist busmess lproprietery)intormation.

N information es considered to be peoprietary intorniation pursuant to 10 CFR 2.790tdHt).

+4 N 6nformaten was submnted and received in confidence pursuant to 10 CFR 2 790tdH2).

p X

6. The wahheid information consists of eteragency or entreepency recoeds that are not e=eitable ttwoogh d+covery deing litigsten it AliWIPTION 6). Applicabie Priv6eee:

Ocu.eouve e,0 cess D.cieu,o of p,edecisionai ofmmai.n wooid iond to inhee,i th. open.nd fr.ns each.no. of ideos essenisei io ine d.iiber.iive,,ocess.

Where records are wethheld m theer entsety, tte f acts are enestric abtv intertw6ned with the peedecisional mformation. There sino are no eessonably segregeble f actuoi X

portions tocause the,eiease of ihe facts wouid p.amn en ind ect movery enio the predecisionai process of the ag.ncy.

Attomey wortproduct priviiego. (Documents prepaied by an at*orney m contempletion of htigsten i Attorney-client privilege iconfidential communicatens between an ettomer and hm'her cl.ent i p

I S. The withheld information le enempted from public d sclosure tecouse 6ts d.sclosure would result m a clearly u marvented invasion of personal pnvecy. ([xlMPfl0N 8) n

7. The withhow information consists tf records compiled for law enforcement purposes and is bemg wethheld for the reason (s) mdicated. (Ex[MPfl0N 7)

Disclosure could reasonably be espected to mtertees with en enforcement proceedeg because n could revee the scope, directen, and focu of on-r e

forcement offotts, and thus could possibly ellow them to take action to shield potential wrongdoing cp a ve; sten of NRC requirements from er vest:0stors L'

LEEMPTION 7 (An Disclosure would constnuto en unmanented invasion of personel privecy (EXEMPTION 7tC))

Q The 6nformation cor sists of names of individuals and other information the disclosure of whech could reasonably be espected to eeveal edentities of jr confidentel sources t(KEMPTION 7 (01)

OTMLR PART B. C-DENYING OFFICIALS Pursuant to 10 CFR 9 25tb1 and/or 9 26 sc) of the U S Nuclear Regulatory Comm4sen reputatens. n has been determined that the information withheld is enempt from spoducten or d,sclosure, and that ets production or disclosure is contra y to the public interest. The persons responsible for the deniel are tuose officiais identifed betore es denyng offacia!s and the Dire. tor. Division of Freedom of information and c bi ce' ions Serveces. Office of Admmsveten and Resources Maeogement. fos any u

done's the. may be oppealed to the Isecutive Directoe for Operations itDOL DCNYING OFFICIAL TITLE / OFFICE RECORD $ DENIED APPfLLATE OFFictAL Se cm'*

'Do Regional Administrator Mr. Robert D. Martin B B-17 X

ggy Director, Office of Nuclear Mr. Robert M. Bernero B-18 X

Material Safety _and_ Safe, guards i

i PART R. D-APPEAL RIGHTS N denief by each denying officialidentifed in Part R C may te oppealed to the Appeftste Official identifed in that section. Any such appeal rnuet be in writ 6ng and must be mede within 30 days of esCeipe of this response. Appeals must be addressed es approprote to the isecutive Duector for Operations or to the Secretary of the Cornmissen.

U.S. Nucteer Regulatory Commission. Washington. DC 20$b6. and shouw cieerty state on tte envelope end in the letter that it 6e en "Arosal from en Initial FOIA Decesion."

. t Rc postsA 464 (Part 2)

U.b. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMIS840N (t boel FOIA RESPONSE CONTINUATION i

r Ib v

f Re: F0!A-89-355 i

1 L

~

APPENDIX A RELEASED RECORD t

l 1.

5/1/86 MeetingAttendanceList(1page) 2.

7/30/86 NRC/ Atlas Meeting of 7/30/86 - Attendance List (1 page) i 3.

3/18/87 Note from Dick Bangart to Bob Martin (1 page) 4 Undated List Attendees Representing Atlas Corporation at Meeting with NRC on May 1, 1986 (1 page) i i

r e

i a

1 t

l

T[

Re: TOIA-89-355 i

APPENDIX B RECORDS WITHHELD IN ENTIRETY - EXEMPTION 5 i

1, 11/5/86 Draftnote'fromDaletoDickBangart(1page)withattached draf t Order to Show Cause Why License Should Not be Modified (Effective immediately) (4 pages) i 2.

3/18/89 Facsimile Transmittal from William L. Brown to Dale Smith (1 I

page)enclosingdraftmemorandumfromRobertD.Martinto i

HughL. Thompson (4pages)(1page) draft letter to Richard R. Weaver

]

(1 page), and draf t Order

]

3.

6/26 Handwritten notes from Dale to Bill regarding Atlas (5 pages) 4 Undated TwodraftlettersfromR.DaleSmithtoR.E.Blubaugh(4pages) 5.

Undated Draft letter from Robert D. Martin to Richard R. Weaver (3 l

pages) with attached draf t Order (3 pages) 6.

Undated DraftletterfromRobertD.MartintoRichardR. Weaver (4 pages) with attached draf t Order (3 pages) 7.

Undated Draf t memorandum from Robert D. Martin to Hugh L. Thompson, Jr.

(3 pages) 8.

Undated Draft - Appendix A - Order of 1987(8pages)withattached draf t letter from Robert D. MarTTn to Richard R. Weaver (3 pages) enclosing draft Order (4 pages) 9.

Undated Two draft memorandums from William L. Brown to Robert D. Martin and others (2 pages) with attached draf t Order to Modify License (5pages)

10. Undated Draf t Order to Modify License (6 pages) 11.

Undated Draf t Order to Show Cause Why License Should Not Be Modified (Effective immediately) (2 pages)

12. Undated Draf t memorandum f rom Robert D. Martin to Hugh L. Thompson, Jr.

(3 pages) with attached draft letter from Robert D. Martin to Richard R. Weaver (4 pages) enclosing draft Order (3 pages) e

,....---,-.----,-,--,.,,,a w

,,, - + -,,, - -

e i

Re: F0!A-09-355

[

APPENDIX 8 RECORDS WITHHELD IN ENTIRETY - EXEMPTION 5 i'

(Continued)

13. Undated DraftletterfromRobertD.MartintoRichardR. Weaver (4 i

pages) with attached draft Materials License SUA-917 (11 pages) i 14 Undated Draft Materials License SUA-917 (11.pages)

15. Undated Handwritten notes - Key Events in Chronology (8 pages) l

16. Undated HandwrittennotesconcerningAtlas(2pages)

17. Undated Draft Appendix A - Order of 1987 (7 pages) with attached draft letter from Robert D. Rariin to Richard R. Weaver (3 pages) j enclosing draft Order (4 pages) 18.

Undated Draf t Comission paper (8 pages)

I j

i l

)

l l

l i.

l j

3 1t resl pas.emyfpi,t;y.}a$.2.;

~

< + p:gr x, C....

g:7;.;;

gp4

.s

,s::.&,h;p 4@

kg

_ st :-.

\\

~

w&g 6.fk5i

^

M

. 'i Tl0 A '

>: a..,

. e. 8..,.5g. cc: +iv.

m..

, y pu' anac.

BancM uGe hh 6 /t(n, tim,'

Wr% jh'M S 5 huNc.. leceby 1

//fr. L. /firsw M u7 ffsoom Cown l*,

6 th) & k VANEy

.ane,At ATI.

l'P.4~tuAine

%wd f yh on ATL

.s Gur w, v twih2 58k

-21ces s.

OwwceA 4 l

%.s n r o s Adsn L L a (2. E m

.Ams Rc,w v_ a

s. c ne., c.-g v'

M g

T' N

f u

g%

A c.*, m e.x, N

u% c._uf 5 h4 y C.cwwe $. Mi.CAviH,/

4o [h,44 g l

uai:/t4(y a/J D.s

./a(G,pbm A,, e. haJ.,.

T w s. 6,u n-a o e is r c micumie, asu c.

.P. ~d hb r.nl %s U S s.h2-C..

'~% n hl' h b lA G

t i

Jh4 N' % en (UMMC.

P<gek/%p+,"

f l

O y-I q

, ?"t Mtyd ?

,.;.pl:D,

'...s b

~ :: ' '.

st 4;-

[ j '7,

' '^

~ 4.

g[,r I

ifE; /kfLkt Nccr.iac of 7/so/sc

,t

~ '

t. +.-

A Trc,J b A n'cc L1er

~

l i

kame

• h r?t OKGMt2Arnd i

& 6/

Al A hl9f $ /f Y

f Ih 91 o

%d L k af Diu4,.D,v. ru.nf/y/.cg!,-+

g lafe.

4. h ers e;, Anensnt off e.r T W e. C m n-H

% uc.ron,oR90 m a/ nIE~

//422}'

PETTE 9iU chef /LS*2lHKfO

'dfC/'ff 7)ksi G. Wl4krtoi Se' d<% len/< -

NAs sslwnt.u jfG. x.,5/ww,s

/ % cwsi G us.c n Ac,/A'a; P s'. c//ec/c 7; 9, 4 /. e a w we -ag i G

/2, /TEXBy' ft%ua ei ras /ficew s.

ObMt! 10.d fl/Aub '

kT14 f

}f-NM M"E j

i C2 A.1 R.w

/

afs e-a.a m a,o,..

g.e. u k

, p M-eg. ct-q w Wa

% sky 9ts QWyhi u

1 Band 2/a4yA Pepe/<4 y #stis //pt.

.44.s /k<ds A

i C, ~ ys i

1

.