ML19317E634

Affidavit of Tk Golden on 730930 Re Production of EPIC Subpoenaed Documents Listed in App A,Item 11 of Util 730516 Statement.Documents Not Yet Received.Certificates of Svc Encl

ML19317E634
Person / Time
Site:	Oconee, Mcguire, McGuire
Issue date:	09/30/1973
From:	Golden T WALD, HARKRADER & ROSS
To:
Shared Package
ML19317E558	List: ML19317E557 ML19317E634
References
NUDOCS 7912180822
Download: ML19317E634 (5)

Text

. .. ,. _ _ _

! . t J e C:) .

L I

l UNITED STATES OF AMERICA ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION i

In the Matter of )

) Docket Nos. 50-269A, 50-270A

DUKE POWER COMPANY ) 50-287A, 50-369A i

(Oconee Units 1, 2 and 3 ) and 50-370A 4

McGuire Units 1 and 2) )

I AFFIDAVIT District of Columbia ) ss.:

Toni K. Golden, being duly sworn, deposes and states:

j I am an attorney with the firm of Wald, Harkrader 4

& Ross, 1320 Nineteenth Street, N. W., Washington, D. C., 20036, i

l and a counsel of record for Duke Power Company, Applicant in the above-captioned proceeding.

i Pursuant to paragraph B. 3 (b) of Prehearing Order Number Six, issued in the above-captioned proceeding, a Statement was filed on behalf of Applicant on May 16, 1973, setting forth those documents subpoenaed from EPIC, Inc., which then had not been provided. The deficient subpoenaed items were

, set forth in Appendix A of that Statement. Item 11 called

-for the production of:

Each document prepared by or for EPIC, or any of its employees, agents or consultants, which re-l lates to, ccmments on, evaluates or discusses i the siting criteria established by the Atomic Energy. Commission or how EPIC.or North Carolina Consumers Power would comply'with such criteria.

In a meeting.with William T. Crisp, counsel for EPIC, i

Inc., held at the offices of Wald, Harkrader & Ross on June 23, '

1973, Mr. Crisp advised me~ that documents-responsive to item 11 l 7912180 %  ;

.. ..- _.. - _.. _ _ . _ . . _ .- _ . . . . _ . ..--_.__._~.a

were being withheld on the ground that information regarding future sites was a " trade secret".

I subsequently advised Mr. Crisp by telephone and by letter (dated August 16, 1973) that Applicant would agree to the deletion from the said documents of specific identi-fication of the future sites involved. I further suggested that this would balance the interests of all concerned.

Having had no response from Mr. Crisp, I telephoned him on September 5, 1973, and was told by him at that time

]

i that he had instructed EPIC's consultant to provide the in-formation requested with the references to identifiable future sites deleted. Mr. Crisp also stated that I probably would receive these documents in a matter of days. To date, I have i not received the said material.

T Toni K. Golden Sworn and subscribed to this day of Septem-

[

ber, 1973.

1 W

i

, ~, _ , . .

.- -. . , . . - ,-4-. . - - - ,---- .

s, o UNITED STATES OF AMER CA ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION In the Matter of )

) Docket Nos. 50-269A, 50-270A DUKE POWER COMPANY ) 50-287A, 50-369A l

(Oconee Units 1, 2& 3 ) and 50-370A

, McGuire Units 1 & 2) )

i CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that copies of APPLICANT'S MOTION TO COMPEL EPIC, INC. TO COMPLY WITH SUBPOENA, dated i September 17, 1973, in the above-captioned matter have been served on the following by deposit in the United States mail, first class or air mail, this 17th day of September, 1973:

, Walter W.K. Bennett, Esquire J.O. Tally, Jr., Esquire i

P. O. Box 185 P.O. Drawer 1660 Pinehurst, North Carolina 28374 Fayetteville, No. Carolina 2830; Joseph F. Tubridy , Esquire Troy B. Connor, Esquire 4100 Cathedral Avenue, N.W. Connor & Knotts Washington, D. C. 20016 1747 Penna. Avenue, N.W.

Washington, D. C. 20006 John B. Farmakides, Esquire Atomic Safety and Joseph Rutberg, Esquire Licensing Board Panel Benjamin H. Vogler, Esquire Atomic Energy Commission Antitrust Counsel for Washington, D. C. 20545 AEC. Regulatory S taf f Atomic Energy Commission Atomic Safety and Washington, D. C. 20545 4 Licensing Board Panel Atomic Energy Commission Mr. Frank W. Karas, Chief Washington, D. C. 20545 Public Proceedings Branch Of fice of the Secretary Abraham Braitman, Esquire of the Commission Special Assistant for Atomic Energy Commission Antitrust Matters Washington, D. C. 20545 Office of Antitrus t and Indemnity 2ph Saunders, Esquire Atomic Energy Commission Anritrust Division Washington, D. C. 20545 Department of Jus tice Washington,.D. C. 20530 i

4 1

Nfs a i

l l

David A. Leckie, Esquire David F. S tover, Esquire Antitrust Public Counsel Section Tally & Tally Department of Justice Suite 307

} P. O. Box 7513 1300 Connecticut Avenue, N.W.

20036 Washington, D. C. 20044 Washington, D. C.

Wallace E. Brand, Esquire J. A. Bo uknight, Jr., Esquire Antitrust Public Counsel Section c/o Tally & Tally j Department of Justice 1300 Connecticut Avenue, N.W.

, P. O. Box 7513 Washington, D. C. 20036 i Washington, D. C. 20044 1

Wald, Harkrader & Ross By:

Attorneys for Duke Power Company l 1320 Nineteenth Street, N.W.

Washington, D. C. 20036

)

J 4

4 f

I 1

N 1

l l

l

, - . - - - - - . . -_- ,. . . . . . , , ,.-,-.,n,-

p r....,

O

• O*8iA *=d 'd D ,'3 %# '* i a'* O m-

'dA

• bu *\ 1 \'* # \

, ,p...>. -...e.

st a v .* L . L s, .i f .pM-,L .

V .O.*.a q e01v p.

. m. 4, v

34 . n . m

• An 4..b. 3u .- -- )

) Docket Nos. 50-269A 50-270.'.

,rv J u . s m=o ,c=Ls Lvet-eww+..o.,u,-.. a.

) ,,, J o, CIn, v

sU

,ia-jus 6 (Ocm,,..on- U .4 .a~ . ' , .' .=..4 3 )

a ,. . '- 50-370A

...i ,vc..

1 4. .. ,. v,4-

...s ..- .

d- b.

r .,. 0_ . t.

,.1 1 n .s ., C r.3.,2 1 , , , , . , -

wa.:

O .r -qrRt'T -*rs L.

I h o .- o ~" ", c o - . i " v,

. - - ~.'a.

. s " a u^^" ~

g -^ .# 71 0 .u-0 ~ ~ C .; "< ' c .%.^s~a' - 7. 0".

^ ^ A

m. O CO.'D ~- a~ FD'

-.C, u' ". . c . T u^ e 0."._0 a .v ". . '. T. .". .O U _ . 7- '. . n' , u=*ed a' e '"; w e"..'m" a ."

.7, 1 9 7 .' , 4.. '-". o- = b e v v,- c ..- *-' -~..a d - . ~.' = ". e v. = s s o- r v o. d ^- . .

N. i .' .' 4. a m. . T. C . .4. a, .c o , r ~ ~, "m .' .- -n

-ae C o , .2u , - e. .o.-

Tv. C,

-. 1. . .

C 4.o., e a..a - n ., , vw.

av- . ,

P. O. Bo:< 7 51 b l e " ; .". , '. ' . C .

.'. '/ 6 0 2 by d n sw.a

, , . .4 ..

a 4

-.m. A.b.. . p g 4-4.np.

. w- .O .. 2,.3. ..a.s6 - .4 a* , 3 .4 v. . m.t.a .i 1 , O ".. CC ".,;'.~ n. .*. w" - o .. .' 7 ,

y

.9  %/a.

.T .c. i , - h. --a - ,a-- -- . ...  ; ..h. 2 + .

4 c. -

-u gc .. k. 4a - g Co - -c- - i - r.

. r g. .qRv -

{.C .D.T. .T. .".' T {.*.P r. .

'.g s *',* a- h a

-- o .e. a g- < ; A- 3 m.

- va . . .

4 3-i7

-==.v.+..

y- ,.

p-a

.au m.

-4 m

v. h. . o. .v. e y-n .sa a> ,v . a

^ . , < -

g .n. iw.41a4o.--

v. p , .,.

-u.4 p a- o r, v..g C u3 4

- .m. 4..k.

s .q.a - .w o,. - :O .j :

, 3,n,~;f u a *- - &n wk n4 4

Q.m-S* 34 lOc b' '

E IT ua . i b c 4 - .-3 ~.%-- , .. 2 4. .awv.a - - m- 2-~

-sa N.**

v . --n 4 ** ". . m l' .'. , *. ..h. .E a a

en C T.i. y . O go -y,.. ,= .. ~x o . ,

1oaIa.

-s 1

'e.' C' t . 1 .y,,., *'e..',,..3.Ac.,,,,.-

c Q m ,. ,,

J . s w .p .,)

/ e lt

/.: -a.***

a\%' .e 3;/: .-F ,7,, 9 /%. \./,

m. C..., .s . r.:, - .,;l.-- , t; n M' ..w.

mv

. .z.;~ 2

.. p , ,-s-3 .' a D. s.

n . * -m . *'"'~~s.3...*

-.6..y .

• ^ * ;

1 J ')- V . . . e 4 ;., a

.- .. h. v.,a4 Ou- .- u, .

.t'*/.

b

. *,-cb..s .z .

n u

..; . a..r m

J t

". Q(J Q~ 3" C f*

)

.