ML19262A437
| ML19262A437 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Crane  |
| Issue date: | 03/09/1977 |
| From: | Arnold R METROPOLITAN EDISON CO. |
| To: | Goller K Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| Shared Package | |
| ML19262A432 | List: |
| References | |
| GQL-0288, GQL-288, NUDOCS 7910290783 | |
| Download: ML19262A437 (18) | |
Text
-
NRC,snu 195 U.S. NUCLEAR HEGULATORY Cs ilSSloN DOCKET NUM6E R 50-289 4 24* ' -
^
NRC DISTRIBUTION FOR PART 50 DOCKET MATERIAL To:
K. R. Coller FROM: Met. Edison Co.
DATE OF DOCUMENT 3~9"77 Reading, Pa.
19603 P..C. Arnold DATE RECEIVE D 3-11-77 3 LETTER O NOTO RIZ E D PROP INPUT FORM NUMBER OF COPIES RECEIVED EOniclNAL S U NC L ASSIFIE D 1 gigned OCOPy oesCRIPTION Ltr furn addl info to Change Request EN CLOSU RE Revised table 3.16-1 entitled " Safety No. 19, Amdt 2 to tech apeCs regarding Related Shock Suppressors"....(ISP) shock suppressors & trans the following:
(2P)
(1 Cy enc 1 rec,d)
I NOT REMOVE CKNOWLEDGED; PLANT NAME:
Three Mile Island Unit 1 1480 299 SAFETY FOR ACTION /INFORMATION vmrTon 4
ASSIGiED AD:
A49TcWn An.
/ BRANCH CHIEF!
Md e i [ 6) unAMeu cuTvv.
/
PROJECT MANAGER:
2r.us.f C (
PROJECT MANAGER:
/ LIC. ASST. :
L 4 4 E as LIC. ASST. :
i A
INTERNAL DISTRIBUTION i
[ REG FILb T SYSTEMS SAFETY i
PLANT SYSTEMS SITE SAFETY G
( HRC l'DR llEINEMAN TEDESCO ENVIRO ANAT_YSIS
/ I & E ( 2. )
SCHROEDER BENAROYA DENTON & MUr T r t i
/ OELD YATNAR
/ GOSSICK & STAFF ENGINEERING IPPOLITO ENVIRO TECH.
I MIPC MACARRY KIRKWOOD ERNST CASE BOSNAK BALLARD HANAUER SIHWEIL OPERATING REACTORS YOUNGBLOOD i
HARLESS PAWLICKI STELLO SITE idCH.
I PROJECT MANAGEMENT REACTOR SAFETY OPERATING TECH.
GAMMILL BOYD ROSS
/
EISENHITT STEPP P. COLLINS NOVAK
/
SHA0 HULMAN HOUSTON ROSZTOCZY
/
BAER PETERSON CHECK
/
BITTLER SITE ANALYSIS i
MELTZ
/
CRIMES VOLLMER HE,LTEMES AT & I BUNCH I
SKOVHOLT SALT 7 MAN
/
J. COLLINS i
RUTEERG KREGER I
EXTERNAL DISTRIBUTION CONTROL NUMBE 9 4LPDR:N,,edt,n./4
_NAT, LAB:
BROJ}31AVEN R\\T. I.AR.
/ TIC:
{ NSIC:
IA_PDR
'7 910 P.,9 07 'l A_SLB_: _ _
. CONSULTANTS:
ggKg y/g
[
/ ACR_S /(o CYS lict9INC/ 3E! TN5 CM /3 NRC FORM 195(2 76)
/
A2M
=,
METHOPOLIIAN EDISON COMPANY POST OFFICE BOX 542 READING, PENNSYLVANIA 19603 TELEPHONE 215 - 929-3601 March 9, 1977
" 288 Regulatory Docket File Director of Nuclear Reactor Regulation 3,,,
Attn: Karl R. Goller, Assistant Director for Operating Reactors Division of Operating Reactors e%(
U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission O
Washington, D. C. 20555
?>ll
Dear Sir:
~ "
Three Mile Island Nuclear Station, Unit 1 (TMI-1)
Docket No. 50-289 Operating License No. DPR-50 By letter dated February 17, 1977, you transmitted to us proposed changes to our Technical Specification Change Request No. 19, Amendment 2, regarding shock suppressors (snubbers), noting that unless we inform you in writing within twenty (20) days of any disagreement, you plan "to initiate steps to issue the enclosed change to the Technical Specifications of TMI-1".
We find all the proposed changes acceptable except those related to Section h.lT.l.
After further review by our safety committees and Engineering Department, we still maintain that conformance to our proposed Section h.lT.1 will provide quite adequate assurance of hydraulic snubber operability for TMI-1.
In support of this positien, we must point out that in 19Th we committed to inspect all safety-related snubbers every 120 days and we have diligently ecmplied with that commitment if plant conditions permit it, or during the first reactor shutdown thereafter.
In one instance, due to highly reliable plant operation, reactor criticality and the attendant radiation levels did not permit the 120 days inspection interval to be met for those inaccessible snubbers. On this occasion, the plant operated for 170 days between snubber inspections.
Following this period of plant operation, one inaccessible snubber was found to be isoperable due to faulty assembly and installation, which resulted in a loss of hydraulic fluid. As stated in the NRC Safety Evaluation supporting an amendment to our request, loss of hydraulic fluid does not prevent hydraulic snubbers frcm supporting associated piping or ecmpenents or from reducing their motion during a seismic event.
In addition, as there were eight other snubbers on this line and two within seven (7) feet of the inoperable snubber, and due to the conservative design of this line, we are confident that no failure would have occurred even if there had been a seismic event.
1480 300
.,u
~ 6. u
- )?cWC Wd
TABLE 3.16.1 Pace 2 of 15 SAFETY RELATFD SHOCK SUPPRESSORS ( SNUBBERS)
--~~
w.
CD O
Snuleber In Snubber Snubbers Snubbers M
High Radiation Especially Inaccessible Accessible Snubber Area During Difficult During Normal Puring Normal MK No.
Location Elevation Shutdown
- To Remove Operation Operation Ex. Bldg. Inside Sec. Shield RC-13 321 No No Yes No H.E.
Quad.
RC-lh Ex. Bldg. Inside Sec. h ld 321 No No Yes No H.E. Quad 11x. Bldg. Inside Sec. Shield MUE-38 318 No No Yes No H.E. Quad.
MUE-39 Ex, Bldg. Inside Sec. Shield 318 No Ho Yes No U.K.
Quad.
Rx.
ldg. Inside Sec. Shield PR-23 3h 0 gO Ho Yes No H.E. Quad. RC-RV-1A Disch. Line PR-2h Rx. Bldg. Inside Sec. Shield 340 No Ho Yes No fl.E. Quad. RC-HV-1A Disch. Line Ex. Bldg. Inside Sec. Shield PR-25 340 No Ho Yes No U.E. Quad. RC-RV-1B Disch. Line PR-26 Ex. Bldg. Inside Sec. Shield 3h0 nO Ho Yes No H.E. Quad. RC-RV-lH Disch. Line Ex. Bldg. Inside Sec. Shield PR-34 345 tIO No Yes No U.E. Quad. RC-RV-1A Disch. Line Ex. Bldg. Inside Sec. Shield PR-36 3h5 NO Ho Yes No H.E. Quad. RC-RV-1A Disch. Line Rx. Bldg. Inside Sec. Shield
"~
No Ho Yes No H.E. Quad. RC-RV-1B Disch. Line Ex. Bldg. Inside Se. Shield PR-37 345 No Ho Yes No H.E. Quad. RC-RV-1B Disch. Line Ex. Bldg. Inside Sec. Shield
]
g pp_h7 355 No Ho yes no H.E. Quad. RC-RV-2 Disch. Line lix. Bldg. Inside Sec. Shield PR-h8 355 NU Ho Yes No U.E. Quad. RC-RV-2 Disch. Line Ex. Bldg. Inside Sec. Shield USE-77 333 No Ho Yes No H.E. Quad.
Itx. Bldg. Inside Sec. Shield USE-78 334 No No Yes No H.E. Quad.
3 Rx. Bldg. Inside Sec. Shield USE-79 331 Ho Ho Yes No U.E. Quad.
Ex. b1dg. Inside Sec. 3hield USE-75 B2 h
h h
h H.E. Quad.
"E" TABLE 3.16.1 SAFETY REIATED SHOCK SUPPRESSORS ( SNUBBERS)
Snubber In Snubber Snubbers Snubbers High Radiation Especially Inaccessible Accessible Snubber Area During Difficult During Normal During Normal
!E No.
Location Elevation Shutdown
- To Remove Operation Operation Ex. Bldg. Inside Sec. Shield W-110 325 Yes Yes No S.E.
Quad.
Ho
- Bldg. Inside Sec. Shield faIE-20 Ho Ys No S.E,. Quad.
No Rx. Bldg. Inside Sec. Shield
' 69 310 Yes Yes No S.E. Quad.
No 1x. Bldg. Inside Sec. Shield NSE-85 332 Yes Yes Ho H.W. Quad.
Ho x.
B1 g.
nside Sec. Shield USE-86 331 Yes Yes No H.W. Que.d.
No Rx. Bldg. Inside Sec. Shield HSE-87 331 Yes Yes No H.W. Quad.
No USE-88 Rx. Bldg. Inside Sec. Shiel.d 33h Yes Yes do H.W. Quad.
No I x. Bldg. Inside Sec. Shield USE-131 33h Ho Yes No N.W. Quad.
No Rx. Bldg. Inside Sec. Shield USE-132 334 Ho Yes No H.W. Quad.
Ho
"** O C'
"*'d* U"
- U"I"Id USE-133 334 Ho Yes No U.W. Quad.
NO Rx. Bldg. Inside Sec. Shield USE-138 331 No Yes Yes No U.W. Quad.
E' USE-lh1 331 nU Ho Yes No U.W. Quad.
Rx.
dg. Inside Sec. Shield USE-lh2 331 nO Ho Yes No U.W. Quad.
Rx. B1 g.
nside e h ld faIE-43 310 gO No Yes No U.W. Quad.
Rx. Bldg. Inside Sec. Shield IRJE l lti 310 Ho Ho Yes No fl.W. Quad.
Ex. Bldg. Inside Sec. Shield 12 310 No No Yes No N.W. Quad.
C' "I*
CF-16 310 Ho No Yes Ho H.W. Quad.
Ex.
g.
nie e hed 316 No No Yes no CF-16A H.W. O.uad.
1480 302
Page 3 or 15 TABLE 3.16 1 SAFETY HEIATED Silo.CK SUPPRESSORS ( StrJBBERS)
Snubber In Snubber Snubbers Snubbers High Radiation Especially Inaccessible Accessible Snubber Area During Difficult During Normal During No. cal MK Ho.
Location Elevation Shutdown
- To Remove Operation Operation NSE-76 Rx. Bldg. Inside Sec. Shield 332 No No Yes No N.E. Quad.
E' NSE-103-334 No No Yes No N.E. Quad.
Rx. Bldg. Inside Sec. Shield 334 No No Yes No USE-104 N.E. Quad.
Ex. Bldg. Inside Sec. Shield NSE-105 334 No No Yes No j
k N.B. Quad.
"** bl U*
d*
- 1 334 No No Yes No NSE-108 U.E. Quad.
Ex. Bldg. Inside Sec. Shield NSE-110 331 No No Yes No N.E. Quad.
Rx. Bldg. Inside Sec. Shield NSE-ll2 332 No No Yes Nc-N.E. Quad.
N** Uldd*
"*'d*
"I'ld NSE-ll3 338 No No Yes No N.E. Quad.
Itx. Bldg. Inside Se. Shield MS-201 338 No Yes Yes No N.E. Quad.
Ex. Bldg. Inside Sec. Shield NSE-80 332 No No Yes No S.E. Quad.
C*
"i* **
h NSE-81 331 No No Yes No S.E. Quad.
Ex. Bldg. Inside Sec. Shield NSE-82 331 No No Yes No S.E. Quad.
d l
Ex. Bldg. Inside Sec. Shield NSE-96 338 No No Yes No 8.E. Quad.
Ex. Bldg. Inside Sec. Shield NSE-96A 338 No No Yes No S.E. Quad.
.c.
Bldg. Inside Sec. Shield HSE-151 334 No No Yes No S.E. Quad.
h**
8 6*
"1 USE-153 331 No No Yes No S.E. Quad.
Ex. Bldg. Inside Sec. SMeld EF-ll6 330 No Yes No S.E. Quad.
No Ex. Bldg. Inside Sec. Shield FW-109 325 NO Yes Yes No S.E. Quad.
.80 303
"r.
K. Boller, URC 2
3/9/77 GQL 0288 Most of the hydraulic snubbers' failures experienced at TMI-1 have resulted in loss of fluid.
These failures are in the conservative direction since loss of fluid does allow free movement of the snubber piston and, therefore, no stress is placed cn the affected piping and/or ecmponents due to piston lock-up during thermal growth (1). Similar isolated failures can be expected to occur over the operating life of the plant. As few as two or three such failures could impose an arbitrary inspection interval on inaccessible snubbers which, during continued reliable plant operation, could only be satisfied by a reactor shutdown solely for this inspection purpose, regardless of the cause of those failures. We feel that this arbitrary inspection interval may not, in all cases, be sole and sufficient justification from a nuclear safety or economic standpoint to warrant reactor shutdown and otherwise, unnecessary reactor plant cycling. Reactor shutdovrs performed with the only purpose to inspect inaccessible snubbers shall be limited to those occasions where snubber failures strongly suggest the possibility of equipment design deficiencies, procedure inadequacies, or poor maintenance practices. As was stated in our Change Request No. 19, Amendment 2, we continue to believe that adherence to an arbitrary periodic inspection interval may be unnecessary frcm a nuclear safety standpoint and may have an unnecessarily harsh effect on plant operation.
TMI-l completed a very extensive snubber seal replacement program in May, 1976, which replaced all seal materials which had been demoi.strated to be incompatible with their operating environment with ethylene propylene seals.
Only one snubber failure has been discovered since, the failure due to improper installation. While this extensive program should greatly improve the operability of hydraulic snutbers, we agree, from cur operating experience and our knowledge of other plant operating experience, with the URC assessment in the Safety Evaluation supporting an amendment to our request that some failures continue to occur and are generally attributable to faulty assembly and installation causes similar to the one cited above. We also concur that snubber operability and surveillance requirements have a place in Technical Specifications, however, we strongly differ in that arbitrary inspection surveillance requirements which may not reflect specific plant problems should not by themselves govern plant operation. As discussed in the ACRS 196th General Meeting (page 2h9, lines 15-21), snubber reliability is strcngly dependent on plant-related factors. We therefore request the retention of the text of Section h.17.1 as submitted in our proposals.
In addition, we are submitting a revised Table 3.16.1 which more clearly specifies the proposed inspection schedule to be followed with hydraulic snubbers classified as "especially difficult to remove".
(1) Only one snubber piston lock-up has been experienced at TMI-1.
The failure (A0 75-08) was due to painting of the piston surface, in violation of the manufacturer's instruction, during plant construction.
Sincerely, r
a?
1480 3N R.
C.'^r" Vice president RCA:JMC:eg
Attachment:
Revised Table 3 16.1 for Technical Specification Change Request Lo, 19, A=enament 2.
TABLE 3.16.1 Pure 1 of 15 SAFifl'Y liEIW1Mi PHOCK SUPI'RESSoltS ( SNUBBERS)
Snubber in Snubber Snubbers Snubbers High Radiation Especially Inaccessible Accessible Snubber Area During Difficult During Formal During Normal MK Ho.
Location Elevation Shutdown" To Remove Operation Operation R.B.
Inside Sec. Shield RC-h 355 Ho Yes Yes No U.E. Quad.
I x.
Bldg. Inside Sec. Shield RC-5 355 No Ho Yes No H.E. Quad. Top of PZR Near RC-V3 Rx. Bldg. Inside Sec. Shield pg_g 355 Ho Yes No N.E. Quad. Top of PZR Near RC-V3 No RC-16 Itx. Bldg. Inside S
. Shield 355 No Yes No U.E. Quad. Top of PZR Hear RC-V3 Ho Rx. Bldg. Inside Sec. Shield RC-17 355 Ho Yes No H.E. Quad. Hear RC-V1 No Rx. Bldg. Inside Sec. Shield 355 No No J
Yes No N.E. Quai. Hear RC-VI Itx. Bldg. Inside Sec. Shield RC-19 355 No No Yes No U.E. Qual. Hear RC-V1
"** "I E'
"" d*
""d RC-23 355 No Ik.
Yes No U.E. Qua.l. Hear RC-V1 I x. Bldg. Inside Sec. Shield RC-20 353 No Yes No H.E. Quad.
yo Ex. Bldg. Inside Sec. Shield RC-21 353 Ho No Yes No H.E. Quad.
6*
353 No no Yes No RC-22 N.E. Quad.
U*
"I RC-9 3h6 No No Yes No d
k H.E. Quad. Hear RC-V31 J
F Itx. Bldg. Inside Sec. Shield ItC-7 353 No No Yes No U.E. Quad. Near RC-V31 Rx-
- g. Inside Sec. Shield RC-8 353 No No Yes No U.E. Quad. Near RC-V31 Ex. BlJg. Inside Sec. Shield RC-6 353 No No Yes No H.E. Quad.
lu. Bldg. Inside S. Shield RC-10 3h6 No Yes No no U.E. Quad.
Itx. Bldg. In ide Se. Shield RC-ll 328 no No Yes No H.E. Quad.
"*1"*
"I RC-12 328 no No Yes No H.E. Quad.
1480 305
Page 5 of 15 TAP'_.E 3.16.1 SAFETY liELATED S110CK SUPIItESSOll3 ( GNUBBERS)
Snubber In Snubber Snubbers Snubbers Iligh Radiation Especia]1v Inaccessible Accessihlm Snubber Area During Difficult During Normal Durinc; Normal MK No.
Location Elevation Shutdown
- To Remove Operation Operation USE-69 Ex. Bldg. Inside Sec. Shield 33h No Yes No S.W.
Quad.
No Ex. Bldg. Incide Sec. Shield USE-90 334 No Yes No S.W. Quad.
No Rx. Bldg. Inside Sec. Shield HSE-91 334 S.W. Quad.
nO No Yes No
<x.
Bldg. Inside Sec. Shield U
2 33h no Yes No F-.W.
Quad.
No Ilx. Bldg. Inside Sec. Shield USE-122 342 No Yes No S.W. Quad.
No Ex. Bldg. Inside Se. Shield NSE-129 334 Ho Yes No S.W. Quad.
no
'4 *
- Bldg. Inside Sec. Shield USE-130 33h Ho Yes No S. b,. Quad.
No py g g Ex. Bldg. Inside Sec. Shield 325 No No Yes No J.W. Quad.
Rx. Bldg. Inside Sec. Shield pgq) 5 325 no No Yes No S.W. Quad.
C'
"" d" EF-ll3 320 No Yes Yes No S.W. Quad.
Dif-b Rx. E dg. Inside Sec. Shield 302 no Yes Yes No S.W. Quad.
lix. Bldg. Inside Sec. Shield DH-5 302 no Yes Yes No S.W. Quad.
B In ide e.
hield CF-6 316 No No Yes No fix. Bldg. Out ide S. Shield DU-32 340 No No No Yes U.E. Quad.
Itx. Bldg. Outside Sec. Shield 14S-202 No Ye u h
h H.E. Quad.
x.
E dg. Outs Me Sec. W eld MS-203 337 No Yes **
Ho no H.E. Quad.
Rx. Bldg. Outside Sec. Shield MS-206 337 No Yes **
Ho No U.h,. Quad.
N**
8'
" i MS-207 337 No Yes **
No No U.E. Quad.
1480 306
Page 6 of 15 T/ ALE 3.16.1 CAFETY RELATED SHOCE SUPPRESSORS ( SNUBBERS)
Snubber In Snubber Snubbers Snubbers High Radiation Especially Inaccessible Accessible Snubber Area Iruring Difficult During Normal During Normal MK Ho.
Location Elevation Shutdown
- To Remove Operation Operation
- x. Bldg. Outsiae Sec. Shield MS-292 337 No Yes **
No No N.E. Quad.
Ex. Bldg. Outside Se. SMcld MS-286 337 No Yes **
No No N.E. Quad.
E' d
PR-38 326 No Yes **
No No H.E. Quad.
Rx. Bldg. Outside Sec. Shield PR-3 326 No Yes **
No No N.E. Quad.
l I
Ex.
g.
u i e.
d PR 10 326 No Yes **
No No 6
U.E. Quad.
Rx. Bldg. Outside Sec. Shield pg 326 No Yes **
Uo No II.E. Quad.
Ex.
g.
a i ec, ed PR 12 326 No Yes **
No No 6
II.E. Quad.
Rx. Bldg. Outside Sec. Shield pg_3g 326 No Yes **
No Ho U.E. Quad.
Ex. Bldg. Outside Sec. Shield PR-M6 309 No No no Yes U.E. Quad.
Rx.
g.
utside Sec. M eld PR 15 309 No No No Yes 6
H.E. Quad.
PR 16 Rx. Bldg. Outside Sec. Shield 6
309 Ho No No Yes H.E. Quad.
Ex. Eldg. Outside Sec. Shield 326 No Yes No No p 3 U.E. Quad.
y Itx. Bldg. Outside Sec. Shield 326 No Yes Ho No PR-50 U.E. Quad.
Rx. Bldg. Outside Sec. Shield 74 309 no no No Yes U.E. Quad.
Rx. Bldg. Outside Sec. Shield 309 no no Uc Yes H.E. Quad.
Ex. Bldg. Outside Sec. Shield MS-200 338 No Yes **
No No S.E. Quad.
Ex. b1dg. Outside Sec. Shield MS-2016 338 No Yes **
No Ho S.E. Quad.
Ex. Bldg. Outside Sec. Shield MS-205 338 Ho Yes Ho No S.E. Quad.
I480 307
Page *( of 15 TABLE 3.36.1 SAFETY ltEIATED SHOCK SUPPRFSCORS ( SNUBBERS)
Onubber In Snubber Snubbers Snubbers liigh Radiation Especially Inaccessible Accessible Snubber Area During Difficult During Normal During Formal MK No.
Location Elevation Shutdown" To Remove Operation Operation MS-291 Ex. Bldg. Outside Sec. Shield 338 No Yes No No S.E. Quad.
Rx. Bldg. Outside Sec. Shield 3141 No Yes No No S.W. Quad.
Rx. Bldg. Outside Sec. Shield 1
3 41 No Yes No No ES-27A S.W. Quad.
Rx. Bldg. Outside Sec. Shield MUE 10 4
318 No No no Yes f
g S.W. Quad
_j Rx. Bldg. Outside Sec. Shield 318 No No No Yes S.W. Quad.
Ex.
dg. Outside Sec. Shield BS-5 335 No Yes n
No No S.W. Quad.
3g_6 Ex. Bldg. Outside Sec. Shield No No 335 No ies **
S.U. 0.uad.
Ex. Bldg. Outside Sec. Shield BS-26 No No 337 No Yes S.W. Quad.
Ex. Bldg. Outside Sec. Shield 297 No No No Yes S.W. Quad.
itx. Bldg. Outside Sec. Shield 297 No No No Yes S.U. Quad.
fix. Bldg. Outside Sec. Shield CF-7 297 No No No Yes S.W. Quad.
Rx. Bldg. Outside Sec. Shield
_g 297 No No No Yes S.W. Quad.
Rx. Bldg. Outside Sec. Shield 308 No Yes No No S.W. Quad.
Ex. Bldg. Outside Sec. Shield 307 No Yes **
No No S.W. Quad.
Rx. Bldg. Outside Sec. Shield 291 No No No Yes S.W. Quad.
Rx. B]dg. Outside Sec. Shield 291 No No No Yes 4.W. Quad.
I"x. Bldg. Outside Sec. Shield g_,3 291 No No No Yes S.W. Quad.
dx. Bldg. Outside Sec. Shield 25 293 No No No Yes S.W. Quad.
1480 308
TABLE 3.16 1 SAFIXY RELATFD SHOCK SUITHESSOHS ( SHUBBFRG)
Snubber In Snubber Snubbers Snubbers High Radiation Especially Inaccessible Accessible Snubber Area During Difficult During Normal During E atl MK No.
Location Elevation Shutdown
- To Remove Operation Operatien i
Ex. Bldg. OutafAa Sec. Shield 295 No No no Yes o.W. Quad.
Ex. Bldg. Outside Sec. Shield DH-24,
S.W. Quad.
295 Ho no No Yes Rx. Bldg. Outside Sec. Shield MS-208
'338 Ho Yes **
No No H.W. Cuad.
Ex. Bldg. Outside Sec. Shield MS-209 338 Ho Yes **
Ho No N.W. Quad.
Ex. Bldg. Outside Sec. Snield MS-210 338 ido Yes **
Ho ho U.W. Quad.
Rx. Bldg. Outside Sec. Jhield L'S-2H 338 No Yes **
No No N.W. Quad.
Rx. Bldg. Outside Sec. Shielu 7,_gyg 338 No Yes Ho No II.W. Quad.
Rx. Bldg. Outside Sec. Shield MS-213 338 No Yes No No U.W. Quad.
MS-2g Rx. bldg. Outside Sec. Shield 338 No Yes Ho No N.W. Qu,u.
Ex. Bldg. Outside Sec. Shiel'd~
L' -215 336 No Yes **
No No N.W. Quad.
E-287 338 l
Ex. bldg. Outside Sec. Shield Ho Yes No Ho H.W. Quad.
Rx. Bldg. Outside Sec. Shield E-288 338 No Yes No No N.W. Quad.
Ex. Bldg. Outside 9cc Ju[eid FW-ll2 320 No No No Yes H.W. Quad.
Rx. Bldg. Outside Sec. Shield pg 320 No Ho Ho Yes N.W. Quad.
Ex. Bldg. Outside Sec. Shield 141-108 320 No Ho No Yes H.W. Quad.
Ex. bldg. Outside Sec. Shield pg 320 No, No No Yes H.W. Quad.
Rx. Bldc. Outside Sec. Shield DH-20 298 No no No Yu U.W. Quad.
Ex. Bldg. Outside Sec. Shield DH-21 298 h
h Yu H.W. Quad.
1480 309
TABLE 3.16.1 SAFETY RELATED SIIOCK SUPPRESSORS ( SNIIBLhllS)
Snubber In Snubber Snubbers Snubbers j
Ni6h Radiation Especially Inaccessible Accessible Snubber Area During Difficult During Normal During Normal MK No.
Location Elevation Shutdown
- To Remove Operation Opere. tion DN-22 Rx Bldg. Outside Sec. Shield 295 h
h No Yes N.W. Oond.10-216 -
Int. Bldg. on MS-V-1D 355 No Yes ***
No No MS-217 Int. Bldg. on MS-V-lC 341 No Yes ***
No No
!/.S-218 Int. Bldg. on MS-V-lC 341 No Yes ***
No No q
g IE-219 Int. Bldg. on !E-V-lc 355 No No No Yes MS-220 Int. Bldg. on MS-V-lD 355 No No No Yes
!E-221 Int. Bldg. on IE-V-3D 3h1 No Yes ***
No No MS-222 Int. Bldg. on MS-V-1B 3h1 No Yes ***
No No IE-223 Int. Bldg. on MS-V-1A 3h1 No Yes ***
No No 10-22h Int. Bldg. on IE-V-1A 3h1 No No No Yes10-225 Int. Bldg. on IG-V-1B 355 No No No Yes10-226 Int. Bldg. on IE-V-lC 355 No No No Yes10-227 Int. Bldg. on IE-V-1A 355 No No No Yes
~
10-289 Int. Bldg. on MS-V-1A 355 No No No Yes10-290 Int. Bldg. on MS-V-1B 341 No No No Yes MS-228A Int. Bldg. on A-RV hdr.
337 No Yes ***
No No IE-228B Int. Bldg. on A RV Ndr.
337 No Yes ***
No
!!o MS-229 Int. Bldg. on B RV Ndr.
337 No Yes ***
Ho No 1480 310
~ ~ -.. - -
Page 10 of 15 TABLE 3.16.1 SAITI'Y RELATED SHOCK SUPI'RESSORS ( SNUBBERS)
Snubber In Snubber Snubbers Snubbers High Radiation Especially Inaccessible Accessible Snubber Area During Difficult During Normal During Hormal MK No.
Location Elevation Shutdown
- To Remove Oparation Operation
!!S-230 Int. Bldg. on C RV Hdr.
337 No Yes ***
No no 1E-231 Int. Bldg. on D RV Hdr.
337 No Yes No No IG-65 Int. Bide.
31h Ho Ilo No Yes
!E-233 Int. Bldg.
314 Ho Yes I;o No g
g MS-234 Int. Bldg.
314 No Yes ***
H, No fiS-235 Int. Bldg.
314 Ho Yes ***
Ho No 10-236 Int. Bldg.
314 No Yes ***
No No IE-237 Int. Bldg.
31h Ho Yes ***
No No MS-238 Int. Bldg.
314 No Yes ***
Ho Ho IE-239 Int. Bldg.
314 No Yes ***
Ho No 10-240 Int. Bldg.
314 Ho Yes ***
HU No IE-2h3 Int. Bldg.
314 Ho Yes ***
No No IG-277 Int. Bldg.
320 Ilo Yes ***
No Ho IE-2T(A Int. Bldg.
320 No Yes ***
Ho No IE-2h7 Int. Bldg. Near EF-P-1 300 No Ho Ho Yes MS-245 Inc. Bldg. Hear EF-P-1 300 No Ho No Yer 1E-246 Int. Bldg. hear EF-P-1 300 No Ho No Yes iS-270 Int. Bldg. Near EF-P-1 300 Ilo Ho Ho Yes 1480 311
Page 11 of 15 TABLE 3.16.1
~
Sl!OCK SUPPRESCORS ( SMUEBERS)
CAFETY IMATED Snubber In Snubber Snubbers Snubbers liigh Radiation Especially Inaccessible Accessible Snubber Area During Difficult During Normal During Normal MK No.
Location Elevation Shutdown
- To Remove Operation Operation MS-271 Int. Bldg. Near EF-P-1 300 No No No Yes FV-121 -
Int. Bldg. B FW Catch lidr.
325 No No No Yes FW-122 Int. Bldg. B FV Catch lidr.
325 No No no Yes EF-Th Int. Bldg. Near EF-P-2A 302 No No No Yes No No EF-75 Int. Bldg. Near EF-P-2B 302 No Yes ***
EF-76 Int. Bldg. Near EF-P-2B 302 No Yes
- n, No No EF-85 Int. Bldg.
302 No No No Yes EF-87 Int. Bldg. Near EF-P-1 302 No No No Yes EF-88 Int. Bldg. Near EF-p-l 302 No no No Yes EF-89 Int. Bldg.
305 No Yes ***
No No FW-116 Turb. Bldg. A FV Catch IIdr.
323 No No No Yes a
FM-118 Turb. Bldg. A FV Catch IIdr.
323 No No No Yes DCll-58 Aux. Bldg. HX Vault 286 No Yes ***
.'io No DCll-59 Aux. Bldg. HX Vault 286 No Yes ***
No No DCil-68 Aux. Bldg. HX Vault 286 No Yes ***
No No NSE-12 Aux. Bldg. IlX Vault 286 No Yes No No USI+-13 Aux. Bldg. HX Vault 286 No Yes No No USE-lh Aux. Bldg. IlX Vault 286 No Yes No No 1480 312
l' age 12 of 15 SAFETY llELATED SIIOCK SUI'I'llESSONS ( SNUBBEllS)
Snubber Snubbers Snubbers Snubber In liich Radiation Especially Inaccessible Accessible Snubber Difficult During Normal During Normal Area During MK No.
Location Elevation Shutdown
- To Remove Operation Operation NSE-15 Aux. Bldg. I!X Vault 28h No Yes No' No NSE Aux. bldg. HX Vault 28h No Yes no No NSI'-17 Aux. Eldg. liX Vault 284 No Yes No No MUE-6 Aux. Bldg. Valve Alley 283 Yes Yes yc3 No MUE--T Aux. Bldg. Valve Alley 283 Yes Yes No Yes Mull-318 Aux. Bldg. Valve Alley 288 Yes Yes U
Yes MtRI-319 Aux. Bldg. Valve Alley 288 Yes Yes No yc3 12JII-321 Aux. Bldg. Valve Alley 288 Yes Yes No Yes Mull-322 Aux. Bldg. Valve Alley 288 Yes Yes No Yes DIlli-196 Aux. Bldg.
297 No Yes ***
.fo No IlSE-T Aux. Bldg.
295 No Yes ' * *
- No No NSE-8 Aux. Bldg.
295 Nc No No Yas NSE-9 Aux. Bldg.
293 No llo No Yes NGE-10 Aux. Bldg.
291 No Yes No No N3E-11 Aux. Bldg.
291 No No No Yes NSF-18 Aux. Bldg.
291 No No No Yes NSE-33 Aux. Bldg.
297 No Yes No No HSE-37 Aux. Bldg.
293 No No No Yes 1480 313
Page 13 of 15 TABLE 3.16.1 SAFETY REI ATED S110CK SUPPHESSORS ( SNUBBFHS)
Snubber In Snubber Snuocers Snubbers liigh Radiation Especially Inaccessible Accessible Snubber Area During Difficult During Normal During Normal MK No.
Location Elevation Shutdown
- To Remove Operation Operation MUH-311 Aux. Bldg. N. End Valve Alley 295 No yes...
No No MUH-312 Aux. Bldg. H. End Valve Alley 295 No yes...
No No DHil-107 Aux. Bldg. DH-P-1A Room 275 No Yes
- u No No IAiH-188 Aux. Bldg. DII-P-1A Room 275 No Yes ***
No No SPS E-2 Sux. Bldg. Dil-P-1A Room 275 No Yes m No No SPSE-3 Aux. Bldg. DH-P-1A Room 275 No Yes No No m
SPSE-12 Aux. Bldg. Dif-P-1A Room 275 No Yes No No m
Dlill-197 Aux. Bldg. DH-P-1B Room 275 No Yes No No m
Dlill-198 Aux. Bldg. DH-P-1B Room 275 No Yes No No m
SPSE-7 Aux. Bldg. DH-P-1B Room 275 No Yes No No m
SPSE-10 Aux. Bldg. DH-P-1B Room 275 No Yes No No m
SPSE-11 Aux. Bldg. DH-P-1B Room 275 No Yes m No No BS-19 Aux. Bldg. BS-P-1A Room 275 No Yes m No No SPSE-5 Aux. Bldg. BS-P-1A Room 275 No Yes m No No SPSE-9 Aux. Bldg. BS-P-1B Rcom 275 No Yes m No No BS-21 Aux. Bldg. BS-P-1B Room 275 No Yes m No No USE-2 Aux. Bldg.
310 No Yes m No No USE-3 Aux. Bldg.
310 No Yes m No No 1480 314
v Page lh of 15 TABLl: 3.16.1 SAFETY RELA?TD S110CK SUPPHESSORS ( SNUBBERS)
Snubber In Snubber Snubbers Snubbers High Radiation Especially Inaccessible Accessible Snubber Area During Difficult During Normal During Normali Fi No.
Location Elevation Shutdown
- To Remove Operation Operation l NSE-23 Aux. Bldg. NSP Discharge 322 No Yes No No man NSE-2h -
Aux. BJdg. NSP Suction 324 No Yes ***
No No NSI:-27 Aux. Bldg.
320 No Yes ***
No No NSE-29 Aux. Bldg. US to SF Cooler 320 No Yes ***
No No A
L RW-72 Aux. Bldg. HX Vault 290 No Yes ***
No No RW-73 Aux. Bldg. HX Vault 290 No Yes ***
No No RW-75 Aux. Bldg. IIX Vault 290 No Yes ***
No No RWE-8 Aux. Bldg. HX Vault 290 No Yes ***
No No RWE-9 Aux. Bldg. HX Vault 290 No Yes ***
No No RWE-10 Aux. Bldg. I!X Vault 290 No Yes ***
No No RWE-ll Aux. Bldg. IfX Vault 290 No Yes ***
No No RWE-12 Aux. b1dg. IIX Vault 290 No Yes ***
No No RWE-13 Ar. Bldg. HX Vault 290 No Yes ***
No No j
l RWE-lh Aux. Bldg. HX Vault 290 No Yes ***
No No IPE-1 Intake Ptunp House 290 No No No Yes IPE-2 Intake Pump House 290 No No No Yes IPE-3 Intake Pwnp House 290 No No No Yes IPE-b Intake Pump House 290 No No No Yes 1480 315
Page 15 of 15 TABLE 3.16.1 SAFETY REllTIG EHOCK StHTHEMDONS ( MLPBBF':0)
~,
6 Snubber In Snubber Snubbers Snubbers High Radiation Especially Inaccessible Accessible Difficult During Normal During Normal Snubber Area During' MK No.
Location Elevation Shutdown
- To Remove Operation Operation IPE-5 Intak-ump House 290 No no No Yes IPE-6 Intake Pump House 290 No No No Yes IPE-7 Intake Pump House 290 No No No Yes IPE-8 Intake Pump House 290 No No No Yes IPE-9 Intake Pump House 290 No No No Yes Cylinder No Cylinder-Yes Reservoir-Yes RCP-1A Reactor Bldg. on RCP-1A 3h0 Yes
+
Reservoir-No Cylinder-Ho Reservoir-Ho C711"d*#-"
Cylinder-Yes Reservoir-Yes RCP-1B Reactor Bldg. cn RCP-1B 340 Yes
+
Reservoir-!{o Reservoir-No
yli nde r-No Cylinder-No Cylinder-Yes Reservoir-Yes RCI3-10, Reactor Bldg. on RCP-lc 3h0
- 8
+
Reservoir-No Cylinder-No Reservoir-No 7 "
~"
ylinder-es esenoWes RCP-lD Reactor Bldg. on RCP-1D 3h0 Yes
+
Reservoir-No Reservoir-Ho Cylinder-No Modification s to this table d te to changes in Lich rada ntionnrnna sbould ba enh-ittoa to the NRC s part of the nex. license amendment.
,, To be inspec ted with the " inaccessible hydron1ie m nbbar " cronn u, To be inspet ted with the "acci suible hydrnulic nr abbern" Froup
+ Hydraulle sr ubber cylinders ti > be inspected with the "ir nece~ible hydron ic nnubber" 3
Reservoirs 1 o be inspected vi.h the "accensible hydraulic snubber:
" Froup 1480 316