ML19257A834
| ML19257A834 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | 07109044 |
| Issue date: | 12/04/1979 |
| From: | Cunningham G GENERAL ELECTRIC CO. |
| To: | Macdonald C NRC OFFICE OF NUCLEAR MATERIAL SAFETY & SAFEGUARDS (NMSS) |
| References | |
| 14968, NUDOCS 8001080691 | |
| Download: ML19257A834 (56) | |
Text
?Qk gj W e : R R.,7 L [q;gL E C T n i C
+
NUCLEAR ENERGY n-m t:
e ENGINEERING GENERAL ELECTRIC COMPANY, P.O. BOX 460. PLEAsANTON CALIFORNIA 94566 DIVISION December 4, 1979 Mr. Charles E. MacDonald, Chief Transportation Branch Officer of Nuclear Material Safety and Safeguards U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Wasnington, D.C. 20555 Ref:
Certificate of Comoliance No. 9044
Dear Mr. MacDonald:
The General Electric Company, Vallecitos Nuclear Center (VNC), has for several years made shipments of radioactive materials in the G.E. Model 1600 shipping container.
Over this period a number of changes have been made in the draw-ings for this container.
Most of them have been minor, either editorial in nature (e.g. changes in drawing titles) or reflect the "as built" character-istics of the container system.
None of the changes have negative safety significance.
Accordingly, VNC is submitting copies of the updated versions of the drawings listed in Certificate of Compliance 9044 In addition, as Enclosure A to this letter there is a listing of each revision to these draw-ings with explanations, where appropriate, demonstrating their lack of negative safety significance.
Therefore, VNC requests that Section 5.(a)(3) of the Certificate be amended to read:
5.(a)(3) Drawings The packaging is constructed in accordance with the following General Electric Company Drawings Nos:
10603986, Rev. 4 174F237, Rev. 4 129D4612, Rev.1 106D3973, Rev. 5 913E307, Rev. 1 212E255, Rev. 7 178B9856 135C5598, Rev. 1 106D3989, Rev. I 129D4687 12904688 195F466 8001080 10" E3 1705 131 C
GENERAL h ELECTRIC Mr. Charles E. MacDonald December 4, 1979 Page 2 As VNC has discontinued the use of water for the shielding of neutron sources in f avor of a borated polyethylene shield, the phrase "For packaging of other than neutron sources" may be deleted from Section S., and the phrase "with no additional shielding within the cask" should be removed from Section 9.
VNC also requests that Section 5.(b)(1)(i) be amended in part to read:
".... submittal dated February 12, 1969.
Also, byproduct material and irradiated soecial nuclear material in special form."
Enclosed is a check in the amount of $2,800.00 for the amendment fee.
Sincerely, h [- (
G. E. Cunningham Sr. Licensing Engineer GEC:sl Enclosure 1705 132
ENCLOSURE A REVISIONS TO THE G.E. MODEL 1600 DRAWINGS 1705 133
ENCLOSURE A REVISIONS TO THE G.E. MODEL 1600 DRAWINGS I.
Drawino No. 106D3986, Rev. 1 Rev. 2:
This revision added an illustration of the modification to Drawing 10603973 (fireshield cask assembly) showing the installation of four equally spaced I-beams perpendicular to the existing beams to raise the cask for easier fork-lif t handling.
Rev. 3:
This revision added a G2 Assembly (Drawing No. 913E307) to identify the 1600 casks that were modified to allow the installation of redundant ears.
Rev. 4.
This revision changed the title to retlect the current identification as "Model 1600 Transport Container" and also deleted the parts associated with the two horizontal shear bolts (P4, 6, and 6). The two horizontal shear bolts were changed to four vertical attachment bolts as the result of discussions with Commission personnel in 1969 to improve the attachment of the jacket to the base.
However, the drawing revisions eliminating the horizontal bolts were never com-pl.eted.
Part 7, the ' internal wire seal, was deleted.
The seal wire was relocated to one of the following optional locations:
a.
Through the old horizontal tie-down hole, or b.
Through a hole in a vertical tie-down bolt assembly and a hole in a gusset plate or nut welded to the gusset plate of the jacket.
A note was added to indicate the requirement for the separate transport box for the two redundant ears and eight instal-lation bol.ts for assembly G2.
The two inner most lead liners Part 10 (Drawing No. 144F650) and Part 11 (Drawing No. 693C293) were deleted from the assembly as unnecessary as they have never been used in the Model 1600. The designation of assembly G1 as "1600 Series cask" was changed to " Standard Model 1600 cask assembly" and G2 was changed from "1603 Series" to "Model 1600 cask with Redundant Lifting Ears." The shackle and optional tie-down yoke were added. 1705 134
II.
Drawina No. 129D4612, Rev. 1 This is a new drawing which is a fabrication drawing for the redundant lifting ears described on Drawing No. 913E307.
III.
Drawina No. 913E307, Rev. 1 This is a new drawing showing the addition of redundant lifting ears (Part 26) and threaded plugs (Part 27). The redundant ears are used only on Model 1600's used at reactor facilities required to follow Regulatory Guide 1.104.
As these ears are only redundant they do not affect the safety analysis for the regular Model 1600 lifting device.
However, a structural analysis of the redundant ears is enclosed as Attachment A.
IV.
Drawing No.178B9856 This is a fabrication drawing for the radial spacers and plugs for the Model 1600.
V.
Drawing No. 106D3989 This drawing describes the 26-inch lead shielding liner.
This drawing was referenced in the original applications for licensing the Model 1600 but was not listed in the Certificate of Compliance.
Rev. 1:
This revision corrected the weight and listed separate liner and cask weights.
VI.
Drawina No. 129D4687 This is a new drawing describing a tie-down yoke.
The yoke was added to the package assembly as a multifunctional improvement to the tie-down system.
It covers the jacket lifting ears in transit preventing their use as tie-down devices.
It also serves as an improved upper tie-down fixture.
VII.
Drawing No. 195F466 This is a new drawing which describes the fabrication of a shielding liner for neutron sources. This liner eliminates the need to use water shielding for shipping neutron sources. Measurements on a similar liner for the Model 600 Cask showed the liner to be at least as effective as a neutron shielding material as water. 1 7 0 5 l b,_
VIII.
Drawing No. 129D4688 This drawing details an improved closure seal.
IX.
Drawina No. 174F237, Rev. 1 Rev. 2: This revision increased the clearance between the hole in the shackle ear (Part 14) and the side of the jacket to allow the installation of standard shackles without binding.
Extra material (0.750") was designed into Part 14 between the jacket and the hole.
Calculations demonstrated that the extra leverage of the relocation was more than offset by the increased weld area.
Rev. 3:
This revision eliminated the holes, pipe, and nut (Part 5 and 6) associated with the obsolete shear bolts eliminating section detail C-C and increased the diameter of the ten hold down bolt clearance holes by 1/4" from 2-1/8" to 2-3/8".
This change was made to reduce the rubbing and binding of the bolts on the jacket during removal and installation.
Alternative weld and fabrication details were shown to more accurately indicate the "as built" configuration of the 1600 jackets, and approved equivalent paint finishes were allowed.
Rev. 4:
This revision changed the title to the current nomenclature jacket "Model 1600" and added a new optional Part 37 (1/2-13 hex nut) and optional 1/8" diameter hole to one Part 28 to accept the lock and seal wire. The size call out for the energy absorbing angle was made optional to allow the use of 1-1/2" x 1-1/2" x 1/8" or 1-1/4" x 1-1/4" x 1/8" angle.
Crush tests described in the attached report (Attachment B) indicate insignificant differences in energy absorption capability between these two sizes of angle.
Part 5 and Part 6, deleted in Rev. 3, were made optional to provide for their presence on earlier jacket fabrications. Optional lifting ear exten-sions (Parts 38 and 39) were provided to accommodate all site fork trucks.
Specific priming and painting instructions were transferred from this drawing to the specification. Detail "Z" was clarified to allow the use of either welded plate or angle in the jacket fabrication. The optional weld detail was labeled detail "G"
for clarity.
Parts 35 and 36 were made optional. 1705 136
X.
Drawing No. 106D3973, Rev. 1 Rev. 2: This revision added four I-beams (Part 13) and 16 spacer blocks (Part 15) to elevate the base for improved forklift handling.
Two pieces of 1/4" plate were welded to the bottom of the pallet to prevent damage to the nuts (Part 11) from forks entering the base assembly. The length of the fork block plate (Part 12) was reduced from 46" to 45", and the corresponding fork clearance dimension was increased by 1/2" per side.
Rev. 3:
This revision reflected a strengthening of the welds holding the I-beams to the base.
Rev. 4: The length of the locating pin (Part 10) was increased to ease assembly. The hole in Part 4 previously used to accept the shear bolts was eliminated, and painting requirements were modified.
Rev. 5: This revision changed the drawing notation to reflect the "Model 1600" nomenclature.
Options were shown for the four tabs, Part 5, which hold the energy absorption plate, Part 2, to allow the installation by flat head bolts or tack welding and for rotation of 450 These tabs are not an active part of energy absorption system and only provide retention of Part 2 when the cask is re-aved. The option to remove Part 5 was also provided. This change was made to improve decontamination capability. Optional threaded holes were allowed in Part 2 to provide attachment points for removal of Part 2 for decontamination, inspection, and/or repairs.
The 1/4" hole in Part 10 was made optional, and the corner break was increased to 3/16 + 1/8.
Painting specifications were also listed.
The size call-out on the energy absorbing angles, Parts 6, 7, and 3 was changed to allow the installation of 1-1/2" x 1-1/2" x 1/8" or 1-1/4" x 1-1/4" x 1/8" angle as options to the existing size.
Crush tests described in the enclosed (Attachment B) report indicate insignificant difference in energy absorption capability between these angle sizes. An optional gusset was added to Part 12 to help minimize fork lift damage.
The old horizontal tie-down bolt hole was shown as optional. 1705 137
XI.
Drawino No. 212E255, Rev. 3 Rev. 4: This revision replaced the typical weld symbols with specific weld symbols for each location and added internal seal welds to backep the structural welds on the interior of the cask to eliminate the possibility that contamination would be trapped in the weld root voids.
Rev. 5: This revision changed the material of the drain plug (Part 15) from stainless to brass to comply with the fusable plug requirements for neutron source shipments.
It also changed the lid hold down bolts (Part 23) from stainless steel to cadmium plated steel.
No reduction in bolt strength resulted.
The requirements for all exposed stainless steel surfaces tc be No. 4 finish was added by Note 2 to improve decontamination capability, and the note calling out the 1/16" diameter hole in the lid bolts was deleted as no seal wire was to be installed inside the jacket.
Rev. 6: This revision pennitted an alternate weld method which elimi-nated sharp edges at the top edges of the cask between Parts 5, 8, and 13. The lid clearance callout was changed from "1/16" maximum clearance all around" to definitive dimensions on Parts 2, 3, 8, 9 and the thickness of the lid shielding.
Three radial spacers were installed (Part 25) to limit the distortion of the assembly during lead pouring.
The note calling for "Approximately 1/3" dish" was changed to "1/8" dish." Five holes in Part 11 were allowed to provide lead pouring access.
Plugs for the access holes were also provided.
A test was added by Note 3 requiring a 1/4" diameter steel ball to pass through the drain line (Part 20) to ensure opening clearance, and a roundness tolerance was added to the 38-1/2" cask body diameter.
Rev. 7:
This revision changed the drawing title to reflect "Model 1600" nomenclature and two references to obsolete hardware were del eted. The next assembly reference was changed from the obsolete pallet to the current top assembly drawing for the Model 1600 package (Drawing No.106D3986). The drain line plug description (Part 15) was referred to the NRC Certificate of Compliance (9044) to incorporate the requirements of the certi-ficate for various package loadings. The description of the lifting lug installation bolts, Part 21, were changed from stainless steel to ASTM A-193 Grade B6 to meet the requirements of proposed Reg. Guide 1.104 for handling the cask at reactor sites. The requirement for cadmium plating on the lid bolts (Part 23) were deleted; the plating is desirable but not necessary. 1705 138
The new seal concept replaces the present gasket, but the present gasket is retained as an option. A "NOT FOR FABRICATION" note was added since all further 1600 casks will be built with redundant ears.
Options were allowed on the pipe plug and socket on the cask drain line in order to allow the use of theproper plug for rarious shipments, and to aid in the maintenance of the socket.
Threaded inserts were provided for the cask ear attachment as options to allow replacement in the event of damage.
6-1705 139
ATTACHMENT A STRESS ANALYSIS OF THE REDUNDANT LIFTING EARS FOR THE GE MODEL 160D SHIPPING CASK 1705
',40
,#,'O ' b-ATTACHMENT A Stress & Fracture Analysis Unit DISTRIBUTION M/C Mail Code 775 Recuest::r M. E. Saubv 138 DRF NO*: A00-576 Resp Engr D. E. Waarth 775 775 Sb/5 Mgr T. L. Gerbar SFAU Mce S. Rancanat5 775 T. Hall VO1
.(FOR INTERNAL INFORMATION ONLY)
COMPLETED REQUEST FOR ANALYSIS R5FA NUMBER:
79-25 RSFA TITLE: Primary Stress Analysis of Redundant Ears en Series 1600 Shipping Casks REQUESTED BY:
M. E. Saubv DATE: 6/19/79 CHARGE NO. v 140 RESULTS AND CCNCLUSICNS:
This primary stress analysis demonstrates the structural integrity of redundant ears en series 1600 shipping containers according to the requirements of NRC Regulatory G'uide 1.104. A sumary of stress results are tabulated on the fo11cwing page. This document completes Task 7 of EWA No. EAC 52-45 Rev. B.
d' (OW$&{
[9' lt.' l 4l u 6 - 2 ~l'- 79
. 'e Prepared by 1
RESPCNSIBLE ENGINEER: M' A
COMPLETION DATE: anane Stress & Fracture Analysis Unit ACTUAL MAN HOURS:
an A c. Weerth VERIFIED BY:
,'s
(/2%9 ACTUAL COMPUTER COST:
R. Sears Equipment Engineering Ccmpenent e
m.
1705 141
t STRESS SUPHARY TABLE ASME CODE STRESS STRESS ALLOWA8LE MARGIN LOCATION **
CATEGORY LEVEL -XSI STRESS -KSI prt ALLOWABLE 1
P, 18.20 22.50
+19 2
Bearing
- 22.15 22.50
+02:
14.76 22.50
+34%
3 P,+Pb 4
P"
- .1, 63.75 M
32.%
<1#7%
5 P"
2'.. ;?-
63.75 4 64 l}.86 8M 6
P" 40r;M 22.50 MM
~
6,43 63 8.87 22.50
+6M 7
P,+Pb 8
P, 9.13 22.50
+59%
32.86 60.00
+45%
8 P,43
- Assts:ed lifting heck diameter is 1.375 inches.
If smaller diameter hecks are used the bearing stress allcwable will be exceeded.
- Rafer to next page for the identification of sturetural locations.
1705 142
GEN ERAL h ELECTRIC occuugNT No.
ggy, yg NUCLEAR ENERGY DIVISION surrrue. 3 3ENDING AND MEMBRANE STRESS l
3 AT TCP OF WELD PLATE SENDING 7
I r
O i
MEMBRANE STRESS 4
1 i
\\
SHEAR CUT ALONG STRIPPING S
DOTTED LINES OF BOLT TH E DS
\\
7 hII[I 2
BEARING STRESS STRIPPING OF TAPPED THREADS m
bllf.
4 BENDING AND MEMBRANE STRESS O
IN CYLINCER WALL N
W i
i STRUCTURAL LOCAT!CNS CCNSICERED IN THIS ANALYSIS-1705 143
~
f
~ ~~
l
~
T.~....~
t
GENERAL h ELECTRIC OCCWENT NO.
REV.NO.
, NUC1. EAR ENERGY DiV131CN SHEET NO. h TA BL E OF CONTEN 7~5 Psoe r
In fro duc + ion Magru fude 4 Direc+1on of Loadmg 6
7 Stress Analysis e
- Locahon./ Ligamen+ d4resses to
- / ocation 2 Bearmg af Ear Hole
/0
- Loca+ ion 3 Weld.s fress es
/3
- Lo ca hon '+ Bo/f A xia / Sfress
/9
- L oca fion 5 Bo/f Thread mg 20
- Lo calion & Tapped 7hreao' mg
- L oca Fion 7 AtYracin mess i' P/a k 20
- L oca fion B Cask Cy/mder Jhe//Wa//
2I hppendix A BoH/Threao' fropen'xs 24 App.en dix B
Mafena / Proprhes 2s A pp en dix C: Safery fadors 2 ca A pp en d ix
.D BILRD O.i Program 27 3z Re feren c es 1705 144 O ON WMNM6MN.me e
.e
GENERAL @ ELECTRIC DOCWENT No.
mav. No.
NUCLEAR ENERGY DIVISION SHEIT NC. [
INTRODUC T/ON The p/o,oose and scopeof /Att/4e Jfrucfordlp/a ana/
ur demonsfrdfe ism fegrify a f thc redunc/anf ears on casks Senes /603,shie/ded.shippmg
,s to Me re9uiremex 7 or accor dmg re ference 2
as mferpre fed by re feren ce 3 acW// /0H&/
Se[efdMc8
.l
/O'eMb/f/ef re7 utrements as fo //ows :
sha//.be The design rafed' /aaf W,/udes the e
20,000 podnds. This mc l sueigh/ of the cas/c as we//
dea e&e cask
- pjy/oad and exc/udes as any /iners.
the weigh t oi The pair of redu'nea' nf ears is /o sul$or)i 3w see references z// ff a
3 such a f the not mdPe an an9 e do es+han.?/o* measured cah/e o f insre from the verhca/.
GENERAL h ELECTRIC DOCUMENT NO.
MEv. No.
NUC1. EAR ENERGY DIV131CN SHEET NO. [g MA GN/TUDE' f DIRECT /0N Of L OXD/N6 i//usfrafe #wo
/osc/ms Figures la /.IAdefmec/ m teference./. j conc's hon s iden//hed' ai flge /sadmg CaJe I
/s cabres con dibox w/7ere the //frmy/o* from &
>7 fed ou/werd (f3 7%e /cadmg
+
are ort ver hea/. Case.E reJen orienfed mward (-to' #
cah/es wJ7ere e //ffm con di ftoM from Me are Ver f/c a /).
X k
K K
30.463 30.463
- 30. % 3 30.% 3
+
s s
a 3gl x
so*
30 3o 1
I i
s.d '
r.19 Us.2fg.24
"~
$r
~
n v
k K
5W=60 3W=60 L OA D CASEI LOAD CA5E TT Fieure./2 Figure 1b 1705 146
GEN ER AL h ELECTRIC DOCUMENT NO.
REV.NO.
NUCLEAR ENERGY DIVISICN SHEET NO. 7 S~~RESS ARALYSIS Fiquee 2
iilustrated below' idenMes Nie sfruchiraY loca hans conside, red m Mu analysis.
BENDING MiD MEMSPANE STRESS 3
PLATE BENDING 7
6 MEMBRN4E STRESS 4-1 I
\\
STRIPPING 5
SHEAR CUT ALDNG COTTED LINES A
2 (Ill{I
)
2.
SEARING STRESS STRIPPING OF TAPPED THREADS muit
)
SENDING mfd MEMBRhiE STRESS klO LJT6 2 IN CYLINDER WALL w~
4705 147 W
GEN ERAL h ELECTRIC DOCWENT NO.
REV. NO.
NUCLEAR ENERGY DIVislON
$NEET NO. $
L OCA T/ON (2)
Ligamen t Stress e s Me compure shear-outlbe //ffmg In order fo Which reac!
mfernal force]
force are reso/ved mto p/ anes con 0/V7/
ihe M M/m u m ll ancM $
omal area as /Hus fed m c ro s.c -sec
/~/9 0re 3 b e/ou). LOdW Case Z l3 /tmiimg.
"A i KMA A
xT a
A" 4
j V
iTa vi 2.53ize
.A
_t.
Va II g g naure 3.
2.n uzs a
30 4G3 I
to
- 5. 2 9 "
Fy = Jo,$63((sm to )-cos /o') ~ 30. 0 Fg = 30.463 b~quilibnum :
n E M, = o = M ~ 'W
~ 2*53 '" Y H* 03 ' 2 5 5 Eg. I A
B A
Eq.E 1 Fy = c = 30.0 - V ~ TB A
Eq..LTi 5 Fy - o -
- 5. 2. 9 - T - Vs A
=
1705 148 I
GENER AL h ELECTRIC DOCWENT NO.
REV.NO.
NUCf. EAR ENERGY DIVISION SHEET NO. 9 Tl1/J
/J c7 37b?lird//f /Mk/drM/Mdfe bowe ver/mg astompFisnsby makm pro 6 /cx1conserva/ile Jimsbf 2
i Jo/uf/on May &C ob /d/ned' Wn%cuf re.?orfing fo inc/efernmde aus/yja mef4oc/s.
For 1%e era /us//sn o F pnmary mesu brane j&e.r.re.r we my Ms = Arg fiffste.ss O.
conserva fwe/,y ausum e o f re/a fwe s
on Hie Ams Also'Vg, a five fy allum, id /M/ TA = VB -
TA >
csn.regeen//y i;' may de con.r erv l
7/7efefore, We Mdy Wrde /Ac io//sising -
TA = Y
- S 2 9,f2 = 2* S W Pom E. E B
9
- 2. 5 31 7. 5 3 2 96 g Rom Eq. I Tg 2.,g Ta
=
frsm fq. L7 J/g = '30.0 - Yg
= 2 6. 70 4 "
7/;e pn> nary MembraMe sfresJ /MlCHJ/!V wi#
Mo w 6e ca/co/d /cd' & 7',osia f A -
a' = Tg /A =
- h. 6 + 5}2 93,s
=
- 0. 90o /ai 9 09I ksi 1 - VQ A - 2 6 70'+l2 937 5 =
Pm - R * + W -
18.2 0 kii < 2 2 r xsi f
1705 149
GENER AL @ ELECTRIC COCUMENT NO.
REV.NO.
NUC!. EAR ENERGY DiVIS!ON SHEET NO. /O t
- L OCA TION @ Beanng af Ear ho/e This beann4 sfrers ca/cu/a hon
/Mi//d/ y/c/c/iMc] /J d.S S V P / C S S a t>:7e m orfer to p'erno Hea'U.de ;fo// bc'dr/ng ared fo occur o!
O eve /0,0 e? ]{/g /Mch d/dM7efdr Sf?dCA'/e,0/r7
.30.443 = 22.15 ksi < 22 5xsi d a,e,a, e j e g,,,,, =,,
fo /he aboye fixo'in Accorclin9p/ irs w//4 c/antefer.g g/ess t
c skae/c/e floa>1 137s' />>clees wi//
exceed M*se bearing sfress s#casaj/e.
- Locahori @
We/d 5fres.r V=l g_ o.707$,c o.,o, QQ g,
.L A
j.
e,,
0.7o1(bc.o.,o7(@)
M
-=
[
Sy I
A F
T.;
]
O.707 t'gy = 0.E Fv/A h/A// hse where I and A are iMe e - o.sopy Mom t n l O! In tr //2
/
dMd
?dC Crof.f Jfc/50Md/
\\
7 y o f /J e minimem i
0 'o%
o.,oyrH 5
area f
fl rodf cross see hops o*
1 2
one /]#ef.
i fiaure 4.
1705 150 I
i
GENERAL @ ELECTRIC 00C' mtENT NO.
REV. NC.
NUCLEAR ENERGY OlVISION SHEET NC.
//
Weld 9e.ome&Y f cross-seehon proper +ies :
Ara d mmimem Mrsaf
~
L ers.rs ree hon o r' we/d :
~"l'")
A =.707(c.3rr)(ii)+612r)(3),)
A - 3.18!s in
-=
1 i
Defermina //s>r o f b/e/d C6
--0.707612r) 2)
2.2s (377 (}-i./2T nS
(~ Op. 67s- })
5 4}
+ 2.0 ( 375 0
=
g p,,, g uI y
2; 4 0 31 m. ~^
^
h 7%e momeni' s/ Inerfia a r fje Mrs a f crs.r.r.ru no n :
n1mmum 7076 37')l 'Y + r. 2s f707p 37r)(6. 278)
+
z.
707 ( /2r)(i.7)I 4,, g 9 (. 7s 7} (. / 2 r) ( 4. I s 2 1) #
f
/2.
.vo,6377)(z J ', 2.o (:70,) (.1,r) (2 0rs)' +
/2 7s7 6 ns)(!.r)' + i.ro (707)(.i:r) (p. Sosif +
/2.
707 6 375)(b.7T), 4.77(707)(.315) (.Z 2 2 / 9)
/2 I~
55.77/
/>7 c = i $. so - g =
- 4. f m.
i 170$151
GEN ERAL @ ELECTRIC 00CUMENT NO.
REV.NO.
NUCLEAR ENERGY DIVIS1CN SHEET No. /2 N@$ 3311$$
L ca d' case 7T deve/ ops //4e mos/ /in?i/m fle c'Oct6/c,C /cf jve/
Jf/~esS Jfe?fe
/H 1
/
N7smenf.rnaX/m/ZIMg fl7e
<?pp//ed ber7d/Mg b
~
2.sist-)j3o*
n
$ = 5 2 *)(d.& ~2 9536)f2o(2 81 5,1f
'1
/3 U
M = l O3. 75 "'"
' "~P "'A on ro, i,F-(
(6.4-2.ss u.) %sa-7h pnmary enen14mie p/us Aendmq we/d 3/res.r
/M/ ems //V /J n1aX/><r u> s 7 pl#' g 8 ! llte Vof of f)78 We/d.
d = '7 7 I5]' > 7IS = 7I~' ' 7'-]I' ')
- 7'7 k *)
I A
2 (ss.77/)
2(3. isis) d = - 4. 9 2.8 to I j
^t'xy = d = - 4. 92 8 v s I Fv Bo*o
= 4.7/5* M31
'c,Y 2A 2 (3.18ts)
=
=
from
- be +bree ske:s
?:ompenenfs d, Any and Tay ihe fo Howm'a pnmary mem me p/us bendm9 sfress m fe>1si/y is ob famed STRESS COIPINENTSI IIIXI= -4t:2. SIGTY:
0.
SIGI:s 0.
TAUITs -4f28. TAUX:s 0.
TAUT:s 4715.
PRIX ! PAL STRESSE3a S1=
!?40.
32s -2089.
33= -87t9.
STRI33 IXTINSITII3s 31-8:=
804f. 82-33:
4711. S!-53s 14780.
Pn, +Ps = /4. 7& tsi < 22. 50 xri 1705 152
G EN ER AL @ ELECTRIC DOCUMENT NC.
REV.NC.
NUCl. EAR ENERGY DIVISION SHE ET NC. /.7 L OCATION @
Bo/t A xial S+ress Maxim um and mininrem expec tes' ash reloads are cd/cu /2 fed' a ccordin to p+be procedure ou//mec/ m ref ee for the ca.re of a Jo ff-/b app /ied o
rhnent dimensions
- for a for e.
oft are obfamed te fer.f-8 UNC
l' b dm'a sta ar referpnce 9
the forgue pre /oac/h ~~ sl, ence 8.
A from c-rela rien is given by T" ~FA
~ Esec/hka ~', F(1 (' D/- Da' i~..l r,'secj9 % d >
3 NDg,z.Dc )
WbCFC F = bo# pre / cad'm pounc/J T=
app 7ied forque = 36o m-/b Dr= beanna diamefer under bo// headj for /"bcH wdh heav)/hezaacn head dia. = /. 6 2 5 c'Jee referexcc 7)/af d/dpre.fer of bon bole /M p Dc=
/./2 5" csee teferexce 5)ferenee 8
//ch dia.= o. nea(be/ ween d=bo//
re cienf sf /ricfion l!
co e
=
ce.c Je:'weu
- o. /
az
+4 reads - ran$ fncfian coerken f o under a//
f=
thread /ead' pa9 e = 2.4533*/ o.2 head -
ra>ra es be fueen D. /
2
/
c( =
/3 -
(hah, referencethread on9 e - 30 (reference e) see 1705 153
GENERAL h ELECTRIC DocuME'JT No-REv.NQ.
NUC1. EAR ENERGY DIVISION SHEETNO. /$
(,Z,y;=,f=b.fo)
Nin/nu/P1 Sft/cd/ '
o G2742/
?
z.84719 ggg _ '9188 f {0 989981/3)
- 0 2F 3
/.17s-2
\\
W fptuj =
/ 3 b' Z /$,
i boh' NAX/rnUni lftl Gad -
(for ;j:k = 0./o) 9/88F_ {0 994 99 l 4 _o. IF { 2 84 7/ 9 9 /S'88 S' h gg_
2
\\
3 L
/. 97s-Fpinx = 252 0 /J. =fj,'
rac s,c-e, fed,ses,.,ac,u-,
pag //
pre /oad in the absence o f a/
e are
/mi
/o Me case o
bo y
////Iny// and areciafe/properf/r3 for
/oa dJ. Sec f/On wferna/ c?nc/
+he bo erfernal threads are c'efersumec/ m enda A enc / are presenfed m
'e fab /e de/ca) fen $i/eArea 0.593(s m'
=
Bo//
i:27in' Bo// /Arcad'thear Area c si'npp ing)
J.768 Tapp(ed fbreas'shearArea =
k+4%
i>r sfnppmg) 2.A91 E
iYolC bbd! ICdf//19 JlFeff CS doe foera l
pfeloade/see are &/ro c.
1705 154
~
G EN ER A L h, ELECTRIC DOCWENT NO.
REV.NO.
NUC1. EAR ENERGY CIVIS:CN
$NEET NO.
/8" bolb pre / sad wifhou rfeJulb/Mg Jl//m 9r/c blf duC o
Sfi~fJJCS h
/oads :
r's pre /had
- Maumum 4s# /erwo+7 due W=2520lD.59"i%=
$. 2 C A's/,* f,,,, 'h. 2ftr /
Maimum 6s// /hread.c/nppm9 due h p/ksi reload l* 4 2.
2,8t T# 2520filg'
=
Z. N KJ/ }
& ~ "$. hs MJ /
Maximum fapped' /4 read sfryping due fapreload T' = 2 520/A+92 '=
- l. ?? icsi p,,.,
= ; z ~,
/
- 2. e_
j,of 2,02/tst Ma.rimem 4eann$ sfre.r.r under do// Ano' dg,,,.,,, = 252o /s ( ^l'i) *- (1'=l =2. 33 ia i
~
- Manmum beann9 skes.t A/ain ca rk f' ear d ea,i,,9 = 4(zs2c),//f(cs)- =
- 0. /J/ xri
- himum bearm9 3fress 4/ain cask f ear d,,,,,g = 9 (/3sz)//4(r.s)- =
o.07o xci g
1705 155
GENERAL @ ELECTRIC DOCWENT NC.
REV. NO.
NUCt. EAR ENERGY DIVISION SHEET NO. /[gp 3
Bo// forces due fo i;//mg are maximned
' un der the condifisns o f /osd esse
.E which deve/0 D J
/!h e Fn d !/ M u m apphed bendmq ',nomm7'
~rde bmding mom.enf afp//ec/ sac / caJe E,/ cask
-fo Me ear in ferfaiede termmed' for
/J below (refer fo Figare 8 on sheef /B for O'/meks/snJJ
/ l= 30 (4'. 4478,)+5 29(&. &-2. 9534) = /5~2. 72 k-in V
/ us asu era /eafe /he bearm9 sfress Le/ueen be Me reduedanf ear anc/ +he Vse a,o,o//inlmsmeniand (c) pre / cad' teru from cf.) bo//
cask he
'he (h)dia //y f muaed campseent o [fre.ss Me ra 711ese bearmg
.s
//ffmg'bafious are sup'er lo orce.
diJfri enm osed be/ow, e.rfa6 h.r!,
f~igure 7, f Jepara f/oM in ors i
in befueen
&e degree o
fhe reduxc/dnt ear and' /4e casfg..-
b
,;.s o.o70 xs 0 650 xs 0.0 fo9 esi
' s ' 9-x s f
eas e
e m
e4 E
c
+
4 c
=
r 4
S ep3fa nom 0 250
,Y r Y S T m.
C T
r 5.855 l
Ca)
(b) c )
(a + b + c)
(
~
-. Figure 7
m
- 795
- 5g
GEN ERAL h ELECTRIC ooCUMENT NO.
Rgy.NC.
NUC1. EAR ENERGY DIVISION SHEET NO. /7 7~4e bcanng sfress magmfoo'e1 i//us r'ra -
te d in Agure 7
are obfamed as fo//ou)s consen/a flu,3re/ sac / besnug is (a) Mmimum e /y a s.fu m e s' as com -
puteo' on
.sdec7 /5, f,
= 0. 0 70 xs >
(b) Bearm9 foe fo Hie deno'mg inem.en
/sy is2. 72 (s)
r 0. 850 x.s i a'gdE"".9
5 5.5 (/4-) 2 (c) B< anna due tocomfon.en f of Me hffm,y sii 3rd Nie ra&s//y /sas' Fu S.29 dheanng g _= g(,f = 0. 0 6 9 /a i F* rom
/be superposi fisa of }tanng 3fress chs/n 4yhaas shown m nguse
'( M '"'Asepara f/sn occurs over fbe 6s fo m E
b ' Cd f /a' ' S k ' " f ' r ~
Conse7 yen /l/y'Mia f
$y coaserva-6.85 5
,trm
} race -
1e 4sfem
/Ve/y be
&1 sun <ect o f a#ac4n<a t bo#s dare 7%eir po>r 8.s a re.ru /t o /
pre / sad cpercomebea ding mom en f.
Th<
Me appbec/
f,fe,Od/r o! 87YdckMfMl /10.l!s did
/M n
Yp 1'
bear /My 2GMe
/kg ode pre / cad,/ cask /ef(edac~
.aof'
//ere fore Me ear m
Mese bs overcome.
170C
!R7
GENER AL @ ELECTRIC NUCLEAR ENERGY DIVISICN DOCUMENT NO.
ggy, No, SHEET NO. /8 f/gute 8 3bo4>s 2
drce bedy' h&&d9ran fbe redy>rclan / ear w/4ic a
- u. rec /
or fo de krmme fbe lca. rwa c/ere/ opec /
/oac/ case Z.,indir of afac4wa7' boH3 Nrt bo#pm
~
th for F,_v, c 4.g.7g_
8.M5 2.7/5 2-GA i
e -.,,
o
' ' ' - ~ =32g
/
i 3
y c
Resu/kn1'of Omp es-
&1 P=
sion block.
=
9 2.
8.286
,,c1 Fv c
7
,e 4-u
[
d-
=
Ty fy = 30. co" f*ta. 8 5
Fy =
S.29 4-1 6
Z M abovi- 'P" =.16 (4.4 478) +
29(,2894-)- 7.NfT
^
b T = fo7.43 2./
. 757- =
8 7mn*
3 2.2 es 737'1 The fo rh / s ia x i m u m one/ /sss' on /4e reoresen fec/
bo/f rsay eon rerva /ive/y' be/he,mina/ mu by Me som o.f
- 7) anc bo// _,o re /cacl, ) am e/y Max boJf i>ad-
. 7& + 2 51 = H-e2 *= n#
7.98-16, So 1705 158
~
~ ~ '
G ENER AL h ELECTRIC DOctJMENT NO.
REV. Na NUCLEAR ENERGY CIVISICN
$NEET NO. /$
mem brane boH 7h maximum pnmary/ sad case a may sfren infensify for now be de/crm mec/
/04
/7,69 G'=
pA- = /A-2-2 /O. 5 93G =
l0 50 x.r /
A
/3 6/ xsi 7= [] = so.o/'/(o. sri) =
Asme /er L olex % im um ~ ~ <
k a oferna/ /hecas'.r (refeeexee 8) fr~om
/ke sfress comosxen 7's 9/rerr
- above, 7% pnmar,v.r, bess mrea.rdy becon=<.s -
.g 2. y t, p - )Q24 4.y
- J'h l? x.rt < 4 3. 75 K 5 /
2 g
- L OCA T/ON (5) inpoina ofJo# / breads 60/f t% read. shear auf /. e. s/nppmg'fx
- r f+heshear area o
was compJ.ses' in,4pp<n 2 2
A erJ A' - droz,7 in 6.9$
ic.5 r= As ll. : 2 / m = l c. n xs i "b =
t.9fg Pm = 2 T = 2 (/0, 9 7) = Gl : N.si < G 3 75 /a/
ll. 8 8 en e
e 1705 159
~
GENER AL h ELECTRIC DOCWENT NO.
R EV. NC.
NUC!. EAR ENERGY DIVISION swerTNo 20 LOCAT/ON @ Jfnppmq of fappeo' 44readi Ae.s/ns for fappec/ /Jrreac/ shear ou/' fed' m Jp,pm$fx om Me. shear area was compo A
or As = /. 442 in '-
4.2 I 10,5 r= Ar5 = ti. 22/ #2s
~2 =.7ng;isi E.
g43 Pm - 2 x = 2 (7. 7si) = in=c-xsi < 22. resi
- L OCAMN @ Ear-Ca.ck Afaclirrenf P/afe For load ca.te W Me afachmenf p/s/e separafc.c from Me cask a/ong a nssece mes.sored of approximafe/v 4.272 mcheso/s fe.. Conse-the donde of ;%e rtom 9kn//y Me fo//sa.>m 7 o'ia9/sm apphes (see ngure '9 befoca)fre,e boc M
^23'0/*22]G)
- " T ~ j.gg(i.ssf * %.iq*'
h 6
l/.rs-T =
F&
li. :.2
= j. w i kS I
=
M
)
]
A g.'
/sr(68
,,,_4
_ /. 2..T i '
~
, ry r-/4 9 donscrVa!)t/el)JfreSJes for compy7%/ com binth9 l}e beho% 9 and.T}iedr 9
Me primary mem brane, '/us bens %9 E
/n fkt / c/locJis79:
.S lfC.SS /MEfHJ/if~
r CJV/7'J' h>, t/g * )b' +9l = s' 4 7l G7 WJ l < 2 2. St<J t..
1705 P60-
GENERAL $ ELECTRIC NUCLEAR ENERGY DIVISION DOCWENT NO.
REV.NO.
sNErr NO.
2/
L. 0CA T/0N @ Cask cy/ meter si;e// Ws//
7~be BZL 2D0.l lo' mpafer Program (rcferenee /o is usecJ fo deferni>,e cask.rhe// s)ftesses 7e.ta//mg,c,sm
~
ease I f
oe /sadmg a;c rigid rec tan ao/y,r e?17ech men f.r /c Me Jbe//
a wa// a.r'/Hosfrafeg' m f/9are /o. Loadiso case
/7
/s //mi rmg m 7%f if roui-msnren /
raiz es fbe am//ed bending / sad caset os f4e a7?ae'4menf.
Unir are sup'erimposec' fo recreate rhe/oad on
/be afachr-rexf. /fe'su//ing app //ec sfrcsses are Oren obfameo' ;from
?4e Superposi fion
- 2roces).
,/
M= /52. 72 x-m - tML Fy= 30. 00 x
+ VL 6/
5.29
=+P Fv q
b.o" BIUDo1 iVoMmc/d/p
$}~
7~be maximon7 prim ary
-q mem 6taae andpnmary
/e membranc alos seeondary
, \\
,. - F bepdmg Jrress qWery-M
%-G' g
Jiry occurs m hic Circemfere>rfia /, d 2.ns direc? ton, a f loca fton A.
Fiaure /O.
- 795 7gI
GENERAL @ ELECTRIC NUC1. EAR ENERGY DIV151CN DOCUMENT NO.
REV.NO.
s m r ~o.
2 2 7~he superposifiou o l Uni / /oad cases for sfress m
the cir c umferen fia/
c/irec fiori a f p o m f A' may be de?erm med from 1%e sfress oulpuf 7'or P- / poco /6 and ML - /00 000 m-/b found m Appendix.D.
/
/nfebrstf)/ : y membrane r rcss f~or primar S*7 oc f
- 20) * ',' f *,$ l'52 8 /]
p,
/
Pm = G'pm =
9.13 's kS!
< 2 2-5~ kJ!
For pnmary membrane p'/us secondary best dmg ffress mfe>u/ 7y dp +6 icooo (-/7623) + /D0000 (-/s~4/i)'
"**0
=
m
- 32. 84 x.si < 35m - 6 c' rri Pm' + 9b = c'p,ys, arccedJ' lbe Anu/./
/MfenJ//y'owever'e N;is S/rcs]
h
/>e fcgy/9fory o f fe fefexce 2.
lo' r,lpnmary crifcria WaJ mfexd 9utde
/1ef fecf/ opt sfresJeJ f44U/rdo' 0
rsam f am e9y///brwm ! Jeesndary do of h H m bendm9,eg(6)y. fresses J If sAsa/o' noted rhi-rhis ca r sr
.for,0rcJJure V'eJJe/JAJRE code pnos(rary,oA'sseco)ns' re erencd
//
,%e 1705 162
GENERAL @ ELECTRIC DOCUMENT NO.
MEV. NO.
NUCt. EAR ENERGY DIV1510N swerT NO.
23 (Hg sfress mkam'y is knu fea' J j' Sm)= 6 0 KJ/(Jed Aff eHdM 8). Per &rc code (ref.It' ep farigue era /uaficx is re]a uirecl for, dicafz-1f4e/o' lk may bc P+4 J&c.sses. Juch en erm i rribde er /ua fisx in
- i. e.
cas loadmg cycles
//fted one nusu u hmes m/4a f in
/he asA cghes'-cr fafi4ue hi/ure wa H adjacen f
+o fhe reduxe7dk f ear n
1705 163
GEN ER AL @ ELECTRIC DOCUMENT NO.
REV.NC.
NUCt. EAR ENERGY DIVISICN SHEET NO. 2h a
/PPE'NDIX A
Bo/f a>1d threed secf/oriyopefies for bo /k mferad/ anc/ ex-7erna/ /kreads are evalua fed for a standere/ l-suhic 2,q" 2 %" bolt according to Me procedures oyllMCW /M referCMCe 8.
- Rnsile Jlrer.r area 7or A/9 7 J7'resis/4 1
ho//J
/d/Nr Wal/>/00 k.t /
A = V[k'" - $g#)* T().ozo.rl= 6.s936 m '
=
g
- J /7 e a r a r e a of Erferna/ / dread's (i.e.
So//
M rcac/ sfn pp m g)
A - & Le 4,,,,_f + o. s n34,_, - Knn,)
s As = T(8)( ??b;){89) j + 0.s*7735 (. 91 89) ]
erkena/ (40//} /bresh As =
I, '768 i 3 in
=
- JJiear area b l' inferna / l breads (i. e.
s fripp my a f. fapp<d Mrea s's)
A = W M l e.D.c m,,,
h + 0. 57735'(.bs_- En f' S
A,- r(s)p.067)" (. 9es)[y o. sms-(. sa 3. 9zu),
1 i
- =
As fjj.f;2 m* =
mrerna 6+md) /4resds 5
mP! rd' as f
ns' fe : Engmen?cnf Amf!4, L, "dr be cs e
Le 7,92-tv- (/S 2sw.ssu -J49.2s'-i.u-5'77m.
- 1. ce?)
1705 164
GENER AL @ ELECTRIC
~
NUC1. EAR ENERGY DIVISION DOCWENT NO.
ggy, so, SHEET NO. 2[
APPEND /X B Mmimum ma fena i roperhes are Aases' ahost pubh.ched' m os ASME code m
reference a r tabu /afed be/ow.
e Type 304. Thin /en.The/ P/a/e @ /Oo'r 75,000 ps, d uth~2+e
=
d yie t cl so, c o o p s i
=
20,000 pss Sn
=
d pc$imitgochanal
=
22,500 p.su e A-l93 Gr. 86 SfImless Slee/ Bolfs @ /co f 110, 00 0 p s i d oth-2+ e
=
d ynetd 85,000 ps,
=
28,500 ps, 5m
=
d pr opor tionaI =
63,750 ps, inmit orAsn-
'" Thi.c aoHur teesmme>drdefm/ba? #r a /
h m i / r & c.rs be ed a.c y
1705 165
GEN ER AL h ELECTRIC NUCLEAR ENERGY DIV!SICN DOCUMENT NC.
R EV. NC.
SHEET NO. 2b A P PEN DIX C
This ceppendix esfabhshes the facfor of u/fimsfe failure sefety wi& re,.cpec+ facriferie c/efmeel correspsndiae to }he m
re ferewc'es 2 and 3-For Me fai/ ore condihon Sinn9 norma / opera fion ya 14 7 = W/
dy (iiesca tailui-Q
=
s
' '2
- . We lure = A da!
fai/are rai iW For the design condibori sw a 13w 2.
2.
sw/1 d n.
s eu.2
~
=-
-=
?c=
A 2
2 Q
9 (s ce A pp end m 6 for c% = 3 dai-)
4 3Or Wc;es,y = 7-(- A d u.12
= fe',]p
- 3afefy Fa*ehr mf4 res,oecf r's lai/ure Safefy Fac hr - Wp /Wo = /0 -~--
5fatic G4swmm9 zysume lsadnckr=2)(Wi/2) 3afely Facfor -
Dyiiams :~
~
1705
,i66
e.
n..
se e
SOSO la e
- a es e
DOG I le e se BWMSD EP&P STATU$s se e
DOS 2 la e se se e
sO63 la e se LEVEL 2 s
se 6084 13 e se se e
G.E. PitOPRIETORY CLASS OF PROGRAH:
HAGS ls e Se es e
6008 18 e se se e
los 1 la e se CLASS lit se e
DOos la e a
se onesessessessessessessessessesemessessessessessessesseessess 1003 is e e
sesseesseeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeessessesses
'nO70 is e e
0078 la e e
0072 is e llOOlFICATIOtt tilSTORY8 O
0073 la e e
18118 VERSlote, SUPERSEDlHO Tile OstlOttlAL BIJLLRD PftOORAM g
0074 la e a
0075 18 e FROH CDal. Cot 4TASHS it4E FOLLOWlHO t10DIFICATIOt43:
e
[Q OO7e is.
e 0077 la e 2-75 FIRST llot4EYWELL PRODUCTION VERSIOft b
e OEtif RAL CouttaO CLEAla-UP Ario OUTPUT IMPftOVEttEtti 007s la e 3-78 e
0079 le a 5-78 OEt4ERAL CODil40 Cl.EAtl-UP At4D OUTPUT I Hi*ttOVEttEtiT 0000 la e
stessessessessessessemessessemassamassesseaussessamammessamousasasseusemese Oost la 0082 18 0063 18 0084 18 g
IU 0083 18 0088 la seems ses e
messe asume emes e
r4 00 7 i.
e e
e e e a e e
e.
7 00..
is
.e..e e
a me.se e e a
e L--
0089 Is e
e a
e e e a
e e e
e 0090 is e
a e
e e
e e
e e e.
s Q
0001 13 emens ese emesse e e eenes ease aus
~
[
0092 is 0093 19 0094 le p
OO93Als PROGRAH PSTAGE 0098 83 LlHRI3 IS.3OK.. LOK 0097 ISS PitttF L 818. R. R. PEllH/B I Lf4Dolli 0098 13 DATA
//
0099 s DATA le 0800 s Ef4DJOS TOTAL CARD Coutti 18513 JOn e 00050s
@=D 0
v o ACTV-Ol 3CAHD eOO95 PSTAGE 06/13/79 SW=OOOOOOOOOOOO m Rust e88LHD (H NtP eettt0 PSTAGE - ST ANT PitOOR AHee som VEttSIOtt g: ATE 8 038779
=*e (m)
Q e tsOntiAL 1ERttIteAllOH AT 022042 I l020 Su=400000000000 D
E59 C
Jon lH CLASS 2 Oil SYST EM D PftlORI T Y l g
Nb
( J1 START 17.000 LI t4E S 271 PitOC O.0002 1/0 0.000 IU 17 HEHofty GOK SLOP 17.508 Lifti T 10240 Lill! T O.1300 LI tti T CU 17 HeT 143 Q
g l
h y
SWAP O.000 LAPSE O.001 FC D TYPE BUSY IP/AT FP/RT IS/sc flS/eE ADDRESS Ts/PKs b
l\\
N
// ft tiSU4SO e 28 0
l l
1 0-12-05 le R H5U4SO e 26 O
I I
1 0-12-01
-... - = =
9%
0 0
60 60R O-08-10
e
.g o-o' Ill WRC107 PROu s?,27. REV 4/73 740TATIOtt AaltEES WI Til s._..
EXCEPT AS flOTED Off litt'UT DATA Salt.
Mil MS (tH T
- LOC, C
iHPUT l.00 1.00 1s.000 0.n00 0.
O.
Cl C2 2.700 7.000 P
VL VC HC HL HT 0.
O.
O.
O.
O.
O, lHITI AL aTRESSES HEXT TO ATTCittt4T SX8AU)
SXfAH)
SotAH)
SXfCH)
SOICill 0.
O.
O.
O.
O.
O.
O.
O.
INiilAL STRESSES AT LOCoSORT(H Tl SX( Aul-SotAUI SX(Cut SO(CU)
SotCH)
O.
O.
O.
O.
O.
O.
O.
O.
EHIT8AL STRESSES AT EDGE OF ltElHF SX(Aun 80(AUS SX(CU) 00(CU)
SMiAH)
SoIAH)
O.
O.
- g 0.
O.
O.
O.
O.
523 W.P U T
/
- .24t?J3 08.00 7AN144 a se 08.00 SETAt4.le o.20s s
SETA(28= 0.288 StJLAARD COEFIClENTS HEXT TO ATTCllht4T AT LOceSORitHaT) 4.595 4.005 44X/P stX/P O.020 0.020 HX/fl0 1.877 l.877 HX/HC O.029 0.029 14X/t1L l.860 1.860 0.029 0.029 HX/t1L l.919 LAO /P l.989 O.005 0.065 ilO/P 0.786 440/HC 0.750 110/ttC 0.074 0.0/4 2.572 2.572 HO/HL 0.020 L
HO/ftL 0.020 N
4 c3
'\\.
Ln TO SillPPit40 CASK CYLitiOER si BlJLAAftD ANALYSIS OF REDUNDANT EAR Ill CVLit40EH WALL OF CASK ilEAR Al tacit 1ENT PLATE s,
Oil A CVLillDHICAL VESSEL STRESSES RCTOLH ATTCluti LOADS P,VL. AND #1L s
l.
O ts C.
shee f M* 2 9
(..
T
=>
o cb 1
i l
a
\\
4 aMMCC
=NCON
=MMCc
-NCCN
!== e o IMN M
.J = c cl ZMN M
c cec e Q-n e occ e c.= a n C
wTN T
e O.
wVN T
w e O.
.O.
a
==
a e z
e e w
.J C w n
(
a=MCM
.= n
~~MCM DON N
DON N
J W QC@
Co@
>WD weh N Q >=
wen N.
e.===
4 e==
e e
M.a J a
o L aC
< Q
=MMCC
=NCON aMMC@
NCON Q h==
.J== c ct CMN M
J=c e
EMN M
==
g<
u=o e unc e own e ueC e Ow=
~ea M
-wN w
-en n
-wN s
Zg
a e
=
a e
.}
L U.J u<>
.= > u q
=
-=MCM
=>
O
~~MCM 3 e es N
3eN N
n44
= 000 e
e.=
00@
o k
J
-oh N
J
-aN N
C22
><C C
e=
a
.J Z
- == =
e w
a e
s o.
a.
ez 5
at n I
=MMCC
== N C O N E aMMCC
-NCCN Wg a
T nC
.J = c o ZMN M
.J.= e', a EMN M
nJ GM Q0C e
><E Q== O DeC e
.e W nt O
=TN T
2Q
.o
= a.O nC n w eo o
=vN T n
=
a=
a e aC C
2
==
e e nJ
.Z.
ChZ
=
b w
4 e
2C4 EE e
g
.J 3
>w
.J
\\==
2:
==MCM a=MCM Q J.J
=
- =
3ON N
3ON N
e...o n e w aC e
g o
.J C.
e..s c o w
e>
N 34
.C
>.= a N g
3C e=
=
3C e====
g C. C O. O CKn e
.1 C.
wo
=O C.
-C
-NaMMoe aNCON
- N a= M M o o ahCCN
.# C <
3
=O 3
=ZC C
.J== c e MN M
.J = c e 2MN M
a-a
<-a
- o
<*o
>a 2-
.-ea a
~wN
>.~ea M
-wN w
=>>
a e
.N
a e z u ;;
gN
=a aa
~
.c+ s
<=Q u
*
a ut
>Ca=MCM CC==MCM C >
3C C
<03ON N
Oe3ON N
En<
ce e aC W ch.<SN WS
><ne e
e w
N
<ng O *w@N N
N e=
=
Jna N>
WN e=
=
a
'?
33 e
swC L a.
.J
=c>
- * * = xa 3
3 s
3 3
mmo 33 W=
3CC4=
W C aC -
k=
X C 4==
XC<=
e a'.
DC ZQ e n e= a meme 40 were e#Ne
%*4 43 1705 169
A 6% 1 Q
I.
o g
OO49 OO49
)
OO49
)
OO49 I
1 1 2 12 L
12 H
1 2 H
LD 74 D
74 D
74 D
74
(
1
(
1
(
1
(
1 R
E L
0' E
4 S
t OO49 S
)
OO49 i
)
a U
12 U
12 L E D
74 D
74 YEV
(
1 CT 1
A KLL SPA A C OO49 CTI OO49 I
OO49
)
OO49 l
I l
12 L
12 H
32 NR L
12 C
74 C
74 C
74 C
74 0EO i
(
1
(
1
(
1
(
1 1 1 d l t t i i i t
PcL PAY IC OO49.
l f
l T
t OO49 O
l u
82 iSAA l
u 82 g
i C
74
= i C 74
(
- 1 0RN L
L
(
- 1 R
1AO t
L i
T E
L T
C R1 4
A C
=
.... =
A OOOO EK OOOO OOOO H I
)
OOOO S
H I
)
M 5L SD L
M LD
'N B
TAf 1
B B
g EA S
(
(
NC SO s
(
(
H A
0 i
SL t
DF4 l
l E
l 4 O A.
a RR
=
t L
u TE L
OOOO DLL OOOO
)
l t
Sl U
ELV.
u i
3 S
B A
t LO S B f
T 3(
UP A(
T ;(
I J0 U0 F
T.
O0 O. 0 ORS 0
ED 0
=0 OOO0 l
SDA U
0 U
l O0O0 S
(7) OOOO
)
i 4
O 0
(7lOOOO I t 0
l H
L H
SiL l
G1 T
A A
l A
A YL Te(
(
LVT N
H=(
(
I =
M2 ACH a g DL C
fC N
I I
UV C
ANC
(
L T3
~
T3 II CR T0) OOOO R0) OOOO D
T XO A6U O6U SA 4f
- 7. (
S. 7. (A A
AE EF ASH 0
TT 1R C2 LSL
= /,
UU O
JEO PP T L
lRI T1 M=
U U
e U
U B1C UU El MOAI MOA1 Tl AOA1 M0A1 8R OO 8C SSTS SST8 AC SST8 S8T8 4
N C" Q ~
)
o-G.8 e
DUTPUT EXCLUnlHO lillTIAL STRESSES OUIPUT FOR HL=100000 EDTilER LOADS ALL = Of 14EMT TO ATicist 8T (U=0UIs3 L=lHS3 HaCTitLig Cle 2.7503 C2=
7.000; (AU)
(All (But (BL) 1C03 (CL)
(DU)
(DL)
-18875.
8035.
18675.
-8035.
O.
O.
O.
O.
80
-15411.
4849.
15411.
-4849.
O.
O.
O.
O.
TAU 0
O.
O.
O.
O.
O.
O.
O.
48 15875.
8035.
15875.
8035.
O.
O.
O.
O.
(AH)
(BH)
(CH)
(Offl SM
~3820.
3820.
O.
O.
80
-5281.
5281.
O.
O.
TAU 0.
O.
O.
O.
81 5281.
5288.
O.
O.
AT LOC
- SORT (RsT) (U=OUT33 L=lNS; HsCTRLis Cle 2.750g C2=
7.0003 (Aul (All (But (BL)
(Cut (CL)
(DU)
(DL)
-15875.
8035.
15675
-8035.
O.
O.
O.
O.
80
-85488.
4849.
15411.
-4849.
O.
O.
O.
O.
- O.
O.
O.
O.
O.
TAU 0.
O.
O.
88 15875.
- 8035, 18675.
8035.
O.
O.
O.
O.,
tAH)
(BH)
{ CHI (DH)
-3820.
3820.
O.
O.
80
-5288.
5281.
O.
O.
TAU 0.
O.
O.
O.
41 0281.
5281.
O.
O.
b4
'\\
4 N BlJLAARD AllALYSIS OF REDUNDAhi EAR TO SillPPlHO CASK CYLlHDEf(
O STRESSES til CVLit. DER WALL OF CASK HEAR AT TActittEt4T PLATE W RCTOLR ATICitti LOAD 5 P,VL.AND HL
(*H A CYLINDRICAL VESSEL s
s e
e
GENERAL h ELECTRIC DOCUMENT NO.
REV.NO.
NUCI. EAR ENERGY DIVISION SHEET NO. J1 REFEREN CE S 1.
Enzpneerme. Work riu/horizahon No.
EAC 52-45 Kev. B enhMed Laboratory Ex 2+nma hon, o f Brunswicx -I Neutron Source Ho/ders 2.
U. S. Nuclear Regolafory Commission Guide
/. /d4 Jec hon C 3 Rle u/a foryOverhead Crane Hano%g e hHed Svstemi for Nuc/ ear Power P/anfs february
/976 3.
L e fer from 6.E Cunnmgham fo i c..
Li Hmg
. Devices - NRc Hall Sobjec+:
Regd/a /or Guide /./c 4 (Proposed), dafed June / 9, y/.9 79 Drawin$: Alumber 9/3E307 Rev 0enh//ed 3enes
/603 JAsppmg Ca.ck 4.
'5 Drawmg Number /29D46l2 Rev.O enh Hed: R.Edun dan f Ear 6.
ASME Boi/er and Pressure Vesse/ Code.,
5ec hort 7Ti~
Nuc/ ear Power i an?
o/
Componenff 1)ivistori Z' Appendix I
/97-1 Edt hon 7
Amencan Nafiona/ Standard Souare and Hex Bo/fs and Screws ANSI' 818. 2.1
. /972. _....
I705 172 ~
GENERAL @ ELECTRIC t
NUCt. EAR ENERGY DIVISION Occ JMENT NO.
ggy, go, SHEET NO. [s REFEREN&S - CONT /NUED U. S. Deparfmenf a f Commerce Na/iona/
8.
Bureay of Standards, Screw 76ead standards i'er Federa / Services, Handboo K H28 Parf I
/.957 Design News.De.rign Aids Rep"nnr from 9.
/ 9 72 1550e enhfled Torque May 22'/ts "
on Bo
/O.
User's Marival BILRDO.i - Program for Bi aard Stre.cs ca/ccdahon 6enera /
/
E/ec fnc.Documenf No. NEbE -2 /3/7 C/ ass.1T June /976 ASME Boi/er and Presure Vesse/ Code n.
Sechon.227, Nuclear pwer P/anf Compo'-
nenfs Division I, Sub.secfisn NB
/974 Edition 1705175
O 9
ATTACHMENT B 1705 174
a.
cc:
J. D. Tuttl e J.
I. Tenorio R. J. Pomares l
May 16, 1979 TO:
T. G. Hall SUBJECT Energy Absorption of. Steel Angle I.
A series of crush tests were run on steel angle of various sizes.
I The following table summarizes the energy absorption capabilities j
of the materials tested.
A full data package is available in my a
files under " Jacket Base Crush Pads."
i 1
l Total Energy Absorbed Energy Absorbed Per Inch of Deflection Per Inch of Angle Constant Rate Anale Size (Inch Pounds)
(Inch Pounds)
A 772 112 0 )
vuaa=,r,<,s,c.--of rA.x.
1-1/4x1-1/4x1/8 1-1/2x1-1/2x1/8 1170 n~ aw a n. ~4=A.
687 1-1/2x1-1/4x1/8 1180 782 l
1-1/2x1-1/2x3/16 1960 1740 1-1/4x1-1/4x3/16 2070 1920 1
1-1/fxi-1/tx1/4 3240 2920 1-1/4x1-1/4x1/4 4000*
3440*
Notes and assumptions:
1 1.
The contribution of the skip weld to energy absorption was ignored.
1 2.
Contributions due to friction, impact velocity, angle of force application, etc. were ignored The test results are based on applying the force to the angle with a 304 stainless anvil.
The f ree leg slid across stock mild steel with no special preparation.
See figure 1 for test setup.
.I F
l' Block j
Mild Steel
/
Base w
Figure 1 1705 175
T. C. Hall May 16, 1979 Page 2 3.
Nominal angle is supplied within a tolerance range.
The following chart lists actual sizes for comparison.
Nominal Size Actual Dimensions 1-1/4x1-1/4x1/8 1.225x1.238x.121 1-1/2x1-1/2x1/8 1.473x1.477x.125 1-1/2x1-1/4x1/8 1.228x1.480x.125 1-1/2x1-1/2x3/16 1.460x1.455x.187 1-1/4x1-1/4x3/16 1.219x1.218x.191 1-1/2x1-1/2x1/4 1.503x1.504x.255 1-1/4x1-1/4x1/4 1.304x1 289x 237 4
See Figure 2 Figure 2 The total energy absorbed
}
Extrapolated per inch of angle is that g.
area shown striped in Fo rc e Figure 2.
It includes area under an extrapolated section of the force dis-placement curve.
f j
A B
Displacement The energy absorbed per inch of deflection is the energy under the force displacement curve between A and B (shaded) divided by the displacement (A B).
This provides the con-stant rate value of energy absorbed for the portion of the force displacement curve where energy removed is relatively constant with displacement.
5 The values with asterisks (*) indicate educated guesses based on the behavior of other angle, f
/
s s-R.
G.
Sears RP&5 Equipment Engineering
- 1. ~ e3
--sm 1705 176