ML19241B976

Deposition in Form of Affidavit Re Absence of Definite Strategy for Nuclear Waste Mgt in Us.Prof Qualifications Encl

ML19241B976
Person / Time
Site:	07002623
Issue date:	05/25/1979
From:	Cochran T, Tamplin A National Resources Defense Council
To:
Shared Package
ML19241B972	List: ML19241B971 ML19241B973 ML19241B974 ML19241B975 ML19241B976 ML19241B978 ML19241B980
References
NUDOCS 7907250497
Download: ML19241B976 (19)

Text

.

..,-..r.,

w. n..r *;

Ld.r

r. a Le.

v C,o,. 12 o w

,,,,,,. -..,. nr r...,. n..,

-a v 2.n ec

.. v v z..

.......,.L-.,..n.

L,.e

)

w.

)

" C,N " o..

u~".t o.U.. ".'

) D >. *..

'.Ic.

'1 0

.S. 6.?,',

C U'.#.".

e n..

)

e.

(Amenc,r.ent to Operatine. License S'IM-177 3

)

. /, 5...

for Cconee Spent Fuel Transportation and

)

Sto. age at McGuire 'Iuclear Station)

)

K'

.f

( ~.

~

g b.

/,

.. 2 N.

' s,,./

n2: 2 nv 2 or

-N;% #.

e

m. n'.M o.r n.I e~t.vD T.u.n.'.t.n, 3 o. C e C.u..n.'.'.'4 n'.o m. u.r. o.."n.

4 v

City of Washingtod

)

) s3:

D.;.a -

.a,.

v,.e C v,.,.,. _.,.a

)

w

.q.-

w, -

.o..

m. n...e.1 4 1 m.n. d m.i W r... 3d 3. c m C.w.

'..,e.4

.4c..

4 ww e

3 duly 3*4Crn, dO hereby depCSS and Say:

l go i t n l{ o.,(j h l JU

1

4. 4...a,

..a tt.. 4 o A Sw, 2a-g-w- p s

.w.m.

w s..a

• w A

w-s

...e y.cca

.a.-

Aa

.v.

..,..y-p..a...

-'.a.

w-.4..4o a w., e n..

.. w C.i a,.

s.. ~..

.2.

...: -a vwaw-

...'.. a

n....e... o "u "....'. a d.

-.. C '; O.e ",.' o. '.v* G.. - "w ;. o r'.

'.I ur ' s.'.- '.ia c., w,

3 v

a Re o.~

uw o +..u.e P.-e s i. A e..~.

Re y o.-u )

L.

L,.. - u.

19e9.

(

.v.c

.~-a 1 e e

m Several waste management issues were left unresolved.

The IRG Report indicates that, depending upon the waste manage-ment stratenv chosen, the earliest date for the opening of a w a

.a..i o,.a.1

- - -.4,a c..d ". e

'a u' s a.

- a - c a~.4 _ - -'.i.=.i..

..".a.

..'..,o

.,a w

. c. 2 e

.o,0..35. -1/

ws w

c c.4 ; n e

.a n..~

..a.a,

1 a u a-c.a.

.e., =-,

a..';r c ~ " ". "-

t s *w. ' '.a..,.i e s s e t

.# c. "w."..i.n '..". o I nG o.n o. "..

'.^..e c.". ^.i c o wi.l.' "e

..y w

~

=ade only after necessary Environmental Impact Statements f.o a.-ad w'.. A ".". o-

'. 'i.:.'. M.. "y.CCe s

4-C -.u 1 s m a.

7.- 4.. o. 4..

a-'-

^-

c a

-y y

.v v

c i s...-. 4.. ;-

3,,,..,."y C a~

• a~,

'.".".A.

P - A a'*.4C' 3.". *.

• 1.4 _1 7 "u e n s % m

• C

.". C e s c.'

'~ 3 d w

3.-,.a..

m..u.g o a g.4 A a.. r 3 C3.4 ri

,.ae

.4-vu--o...'y

- a.4.. :

-n w.--

w.

y y.

a y e7w.oA u,7 b.g

• %' C... 4.. 4 c.w - w 4aw.aw C gu,seu C.,,. d4-n a.i n3

- w.3

, w b3 4

. 4 =.b.

s.

n wo w

.v. w s'*. A... 4.. 4..c

-, 4 e.. C :.2 4 C.; w,.,-

u.u.a

-%-,.n...

A..,. :

2.. a 4a*Ca..

,1 C' a n.s S

n, c,

w w

ww.~

w s.4C..

.m..a.. e. w.. A...

m e a.e. g.o.

7, Cn 4C..a.

{.a-ge*4m.

..C. i 4 wag.,7*

w,.

y.-

.a y.

yw.v.

4

.i..

a.4 a

e o.i a n. 4 Cv m w,

m,

..C C e.

s..k. - a a. g,-a 24 t, A a.4.1.b 4.

n1 at

-w...

..v

..v..-.

W f.4..Ca..w. s e. n gaq.'-m4n

..a d 4 P.T'.%. a. 9, v.? 4 w,,..' A

.%. w y.

2-..

-e s

p.

a w

7 ~. 3**

.7.

.,a w

7 A.....b.

..,n,o.,4.....

r*.a -

4..s,

. Q

-e.-..--

j,-

,a e

w.. w c-....

s ww. - -

4

..;..a

.q

. L..'.

,7 p 3

-.. C c

,4 g,

4 m..

h. p. a.-

4

• 4 w.

a u..

wy e 3

.1 a.

W,.

.' O. G. g m..d y

,a L1a -

r7*

7a..,

1, 3.,.

a

,,,.2.

. y r.

1*

\\

.j a 2 - e.

a

, -- a) 1-,/

C.r

.c. a n n.-.

D.a Cw.-

n

.k. a aA

.D w a c.---,s.....

u.

. u. a_

...n..,.n.a.c.

D.. a.*. a *.,

..a

.- v

.,. g.

G ~- ' y

c...

"L'.'o..'.- e-..a.

.NI '. a c o...a..,

1 c l. '.'.,

.'.1..,.-*.".

.'3.-,

.,m.

CO-bJ.

• m yy 1

1, rM t 5 (.

f.

s t

Ui I t

U.. % - a e ~.~. " v y..' ~..

n' a_.- o_ a' a_ a e.' a - '.i -. a

m..'..

o.

.=

e n..

e -.'..4 e -

4 n_., s.4. a u,, u, c +. 4 a

-- a

. c... c t.,.,.:

.u. a 4..

.o -.n

a.. n_

a,.'.._,a-.

m-anc reposit.orv c.ceration in 1993 at

,ne earliestr again with a c.ossible 5 ear delav..

The third option creates a process by 1991 for choosing the nunber of cualified sites frcm *.alch the final choice conca.

"..4-

- p ~. w c "u ' d.v' ~.' A~A."".-^...a..

A C s'~a~

^i a'. he

..,de_.

a beycnd those already censideredr the final repositorv. coulci ' e c

d p r,,, r. A v e -.4 C e a-.4n,a.1 4 n + n' o_

l 0 0, J' 1 9 o, no - e..4 c c*, a s-

,, ~; e.. %.o

.s.

r v.

e m

c.._ c

.,s m, 4--c..a

m..,. e

,w

... a.4ca,

...a.

,.2

... e,_... e s '

n' d..'. i.. -

+. w w

m istration tar 9et date for the oceninc. of a renositorv. is 1990.

I

• . 5 e., - 04o *- is al.lcNed

+o o." c==A

'. ~. - F1. o o.

1. = C.4 1 4 *, "; C C t'..' A "a r-J-

-r C ".~.. "y ' * *-

A-oa.".'..".

U.^ W e V P ".,

^-.. 4 a"

.# ' C'. '.'." ".

N. '..'.I

" S C ' i. "e O, a '.

'..c ~4 ~,

c...' ;- 1000

1. " e l a s a' u..D'.' i a s. -7 ;/

.-l a.'.'.. *J -.. n.1.i a 'Ia

"..". e i

c".e.. - a w-5 "y. ".. *

.#' a '

a - v "..' 3 e " " #s^.1.a.".1 u' " * * ' C ' ^v.* "a.

~~^

~

y.w A

~.

a.b.c,. n.1 A.

3_

n C + n~A

+ n' w.s. u..b. t:

79 3 a_. '.:.3 s +. A,,,

'.o, o n 4-e, c.; '

7. r,

-. u a

.n J

s a

.a

~

c "..' j'..#.

c a ' '..i ~d

.'a e.T a "m' '

• A u' d'

' ' ' ' '. ' '"...aA.*'m..

.#'.~.,'"

~

._"yv"___~--;'.

^

..#~a'

• c

.a.'=- C4: c

,.7 t C..-

h. a_

J4 3

/

a ')

, -.. o_ q nm

,b7 y<

..-v y-.

t,,

b. n-1.

y a

.2. -

.4 g...u,.. p.

n n g g.4.,.

.., 7.', q, b,

,...'_.b.*._3

.4

- 3,.a, -.

a,e-

.a -

w..

t

.-y

...,e y.

.,. n 3. J 73 3..

w*

.w e

'a

.T.3.,2

• o

.J a -

, -,... -a a

-..o_ a

-..3..-

u.4o y v a u,

.W 4

,J

. h..s.

...C,

. ~ -, -

--o-y..

-..4. ~p 3...m,,m..,,.1,e

.e.J C' g J. n...a c u..L.

m.

, a v m,. 4

_3.

".,4 h

',3,r._,,.

.g s g m,

3,, 4

,,g

..v..

h w n. m g.).E e,.,.**. 4.3 g 'gC s..I

.h e

.7

.==3,=.,,.3, n y.--

• • "'("

7. 3..* g.

d=

• • d'%

.v y.

.~.

y y

3 3 a

.. 4 m

Wa a..

v.

m..o-,4.s..*

'a,s,.e.

n.

.a

=vs J

,, c ~, a-9 5

2,.y C

.4. --..

• ^qN 7

a

b. a A.1.3 - a.b. v I.,.

7n*

, - J' v9

..e

._,.a-r.a.

..a.

7

• r

%4,

..3-aua

[ C., s o

.O.~^.

t_,/ G *.

.w

-a

.vs 3

...w v

g.

D.. a. e._. ~,

9.

m,

..n \\,

m..b. a..M..

-..5

a. 4 7.k-

.J.:-,.e_,a f,.1.,

.m A

g a. '- - - i.a c \\,

^

-an

m.

v

~

s-

/

~.'i '..'..: o,

.7a a-. o

• ,,i f.

,,,

• n. - - 31, -

n o. a.J..

-...,.;-,.,,,..c.-.

....a, r- -

.ss.1 4

y---

---.a..n..g.,.,

~,( T,/ T.*.C.

(J' V n *. m,

G.q. C o -,.._ ~.. a.... m:

C

,e O s n

.'.i'

-ys.

.T a.

.y

j 7 7, ~ o,

m.

• a y

., l-t l} (j a J

2

m..ee.-,,,,,,a.,._

a.

~.g b.

.e., c -.. o~

403 ev...

.,. 3 c.,. e w..

s -

a.

, a

,2

- 0

^a.v,e (c.yaci ";

4..

" a =.. '000),

-. y c..i " =..' ".

7#

..".o a

j r'positcries are more conservat:.ve y e s :.w~ n e e.c.,

..: t n e v.

w.i.l.' h a..d l e e n l v.

3 3, 0 0 0.T." ),

• he.".

• .".e

..u:. " e. c.#

yo2.4--.. des

-o-will be 3 times greater, or 9-18 repositories.

Thus, Duke ca:".ct necessarily count on utilizing the first r e c. o s i t e r v..

r.

....,,, ~e

= c i.,1,

.ca.

.1.4.,.4

3. y..as a.

D "m.". _ a.' c ca....o c "..-

b a

c..

.".2_

1. 4 c ~_...~.. -..i ' 1. L,o-n

-aec s.i -.- "; *.

..e a --- a.'.' c.#

4.3

..o-e.

1 d

~~

m.i e n. c a '.'.'. a_ n d ".

D u*.k e

..'.a" . ' "e

.v~a '.

_e m.. -..,e.s-r ' a r-a

--a c..a c.

.o.e. da-'das "evon- '90.0 *o 4

4 m.io-

.n-"m.-e a"

aye..-

1. ua.'

d -

m a

e a c,.1

.e.e o A s a.- n

.m e s.

y a--

.~

aa,

.i*..i-s 411

v. n n. a_

b.a.7 o r -

L.

t..,.,.1 4o

....,.o a s/a_,.

u..b. s-n a

a

.. -. m.

e,1 i

2. 3.,

u b.a.

1 o.'30 6 3.*,. n.

a,.o,

.v. 4. h.

uw a,, a. _7 a-o

-a.

-.e m

ay-e.

--.~

y C ' "y a b'.i.V, a

$,C ^."_ ^-.' ". 5

.'A. ~ ^%' i - o

'l u -.' "- ' "

^

- * ' ". ' C.".a" a-4a6,w

---

.a.%...E.=.a.

.. b. p e. b. g.w bo nv. meg gA 3 C 4 m..

..,,,.,,J,a ;, ; 3,,, &,

• . m

.,.,w

-v

,m h..

... - y vy a

.s. i m.v.

g g a. e, h. 4 m.a n.a

• b. n

_o_%g.

4.1

..Sa w e. n n. 4 - m

., i, 3 w

.w

.w w i v w.a w

.v w w.

yva.w.;

4

-3/

,v.,,.

1.,.,.a.ea.

a ma

- 1

. m. A 7 Q v w.. p a.

",.a..+=.a

..b..,.w o L. a s,....,n..

.J..-3'.

eng..

S.

a u 9..

c.

yv

.- i

k. w, w,

-,~-a e C m.'

r.k. p m C C.1 T',....

w T4

• 3 :

v

.a

.i.n.

4,e e.. n A 23m

-s,.,

v

. - y

..p.w a.

.9 m

.N _

7 - -

+3

'q w

w 7 u.b.'l-W-

-,, e 3

m m,.w..a 3

/ *'

w*.A

- *, J me 1

j

- m.,. a. ~;

.e n e m q m.

~o w

7

.m

.o /.,

6 y

4 '

• t /

Nd ;

mg.

.N. d 7-. w.Ne,

.e

,y

[ w p 33.h y C wg.

.V % a M=

u-.

e.

w--..

7 S

r %..

. - -w M -

)'.7, C'

' n C.,, - e.. s V

'L.m.

2 1 ~

3m,,-4 m.

a

~%

.w-

@~~

9 d.

--*.43..-

..* 3.%.

m

."E..,.,.d.g, d.

.O,,,_.pg

(,%. e. ;,,'4}

g,,,,,,,g e

I

,,g,g j,...

s.

..[.M.

N.

,u'.."-

. [--

bY v

..M..M.Mg....-

.-.m.g.q

_9gi.g p q g

gag

.v.i..,.

]p r

.g,

-...hw -... 4.].9

.4

]

y

,e.,,,,_.,,.

..M.,.

v.N.....3

-..g.

-4 O

0. /

O a.-.-.

y.

.g

w.

• e t

, =

.a.n

.~"

=-

.="

.=

?

==

1

-=

..Z a

O O

I s,

e

~4 w

-s M

l l

Q 4

Q l"*

fe 4

c: e

.,* i..' '.

e _ -.

.:'.b=

-" 4

. ~ -

I 6

Go A

.a

.,,e 41

.h'.

w i

=

CZ U

'A < M 9

2:

u

'.,' w-l:

, M -.

w 3 C s

e w

. " " - 9

.i t O :

U--+

C O

"4 e

i I

e i

f f

f b

.i I Z 7 : -"

4 7

?4 1

8 8

8 1

8 I

l k i. 3 %;

9.

M

• 4 e

a i

e a

a e

s y

6..

~

2 l

=*

8 3

s.

g

-sw.

a.,

n..

.e

=

ag..

VI

• 1 b

6

'.c wI

6..

.1 N

I

)

A g

M L

=

w

=

1 L' -..

w 6

q w

w

. - -_ e

?--

• n

,, ~

}

w

.l.

3 %,

d 3

==

N e

e a

I i

1 e

q L,.-

i L O

~

t s

e e

i i

t li-= % %

g Z

04

.4 8

I e

i 4

e t

0 t

=

=

e 3

1

,a a

p e

~

.1 l

a

=

.*,'. 4 2

a

~

3

L L 4

Q 4

E

~*

Q g

.J i

.s

< =

~

< O

• J w

W m

==

T

=

aa O

.O O

4 2

O a

7 L.

y w

a a.'>

T.

f g.

S -

3 ;.

.1 3

- - i

's 2

s =0 b

L

.L,

.?

.g g

..=

,L

.S, w

M h

e.

9.A.

O m

4 m

e M

.,D W

M

.I

• j

.lm

,l 6

.)

\\

l, p

.l, e

s -h f kd

-i e 2

a

, c =. m2 a y y-. -..,.

g.r m,

e

,97.-)

"c o

..a L.

a._

s u ~ ~ e " "- -.. -. v.

..". - =- = s e "-

wm i

_3./

.w

,., -,,. 4....

--y--.,,

n,.e..'

3

.'..'A,

'-^* ;

,', 4

---..-..s.

".'."."s

...m

~

^

Units 1& 2 336 locatiens Unit 3 474 locations T o *e a.1 8.10 1 cC,

• 4 r.s

. e '.9.-. $, -y 7,

19/o, gu.'r.e.-acups od w,y-v73.1. c

.4.".^ - n a S e " ". a Ce..

r g - --

y.

C ' ^~ a C.# " *

• C#

.b. o.

"V"...'".

' ~ 7

• CO'

.'.a s' o'.lC C ' ".i ".*. S '. v^ 70

_ICC'-

.s y

~i

_.6/

^...s.

7.#

.n y,_. - ~. e d, +."..' a-

v. o "- ' d

'do

..-^v.-

m m

UniCs 1 & 2 750 locations Unit 3 474 Total 1224 lccations

.r..

v,.- a 2..

C

..,.;,,4..

e. C.e.

u,., -ao.

1,/,- 3,, C,. 4... S

.u,..ow w

. m..,.4..

e 7/

7,w*

w..

w.

.s

-..--.e.

e.c,

• b. 3 a t *-. w.a.o A--

m., h 1. 2

.?. Q '.

",aS#d

". ". D u..e

.#.'^ - '

a \\r,.

l o. ; o.

t,. 3 4..., e 3,

c

• k.a g.. ;

g 7

",C ^.'

.iS 1

.""."..~.'..'d-

1. .". 5-

". O v

3 3 a.

.W. 4.... o... -

,1 7 c, q. g A, ' C C ^ r.a o

'a".l..'

I c

7 ".O.

" ~ ' ^ ".

C^s'..'."y.'*-

-.- o

. C O o c' c

.o

.v

-yv.

.4 C.#.

.. ". '.'A.

' O ~/ s3 * * ' ^ ' d.' ". '7*

"s."...

7 I'".".^-

W.".'.'

w-

wv*.

=

w.v..

j

=s w.w s.

~~ ~~ --

1. ..~. a.

.. '. '.. - C.#

"... e.M. ' "

'.o. '3 O v ' o c.'.= - e ^.#

"."..i". '.

d C

a y c'. - -

v E.*

7, q.4 44

-.o L e.p..

44.4 d-

_, s.

,w-M J,

M

-..,,,=,b.1-m n.

w c.

.g q

....a-u a

..==

m o v.~

s mJ

...e

.-3 4 9 a5--

w w. e - c....

4..

.k.,,.

C v.3

%. a.

e w n. O e.. w -

.J 2

w w

m,.

m

-a

. C.e V.

.yv..

.J y

y.

w T.., 4. --

4

f. w,...;.. - w.4 w..

2.,.,.. 4 n..w

..A 4

a

1. . 3,

n... n J..t.

w....., _

..w w

.*9 M] ]

y.C.

]

g

-Dg3

- y y'..-.i.

..'.]..-

]q..

gg g

d a

.5 E

.-*8'".

]-

v a

w h..

b a.

..2 A s 3 74 31

• 4 J.

4 3 '-wa

.i... h. a.

2.,. c...,

w w. w o.

-.4,3 J,

w.

ww s

.h

.2

. 4..n 7 9......

.v0.

4.-

W..?

1 a..4.4.

.W

-, w.,a

.4.

o.

6 A

.aCn-Qu..j,

..w wJ

-..-w

. -. 7-

.s w*

)

.uk

.nH%

• 6 8'E

[

~/

W h.

1j

/

.w

-e p

,w rr

?

a.

[

t

-e S/

., / a,. _

.v ;4,,.

.0/,0

.C

.s.,,..

w

, %e..

c

---..c.

. o.

..".a

.-a-uas-

~;

" i m -

.s r.C.. s '

4 '.

.=..-a

.- a _

.'.u' -

_ -. ~.

Duke, but no transshicment is allowed, then accCrding to Table

.v y 10 8 '

..a_.#,%_.' i.~, o #. U.. 4

• 3 and Oca".ea 1.0

.1,

.rC o is lc<-~ af _a.r tF.a.

a o

a.'.'.'.ua cu o# s a c e a *.

+..".e t.i.~..a o.#

6.'.e J "u.1 " 3, 19o3 d.iscV.-.- a e

O.#

I.?.it 7 n

-.e. A 3 m S a-n.:

m..a.a,e n a v _4 n u a O.c An

. e S o-C u:

.L.-

3 no S.,, n a m

eu--

.v s.

e-.

v o en..1 _4 s - 4.

ys.., 4 1, b.s.4.14..

e., 4 -

g e r, o..=

.,qp.1 1 h e. 4 m.w o b.b.a-a g.-... s

• a. e.-

a-w.

y v.

.s w

u,.. r%.1 r.%., 4.

w -3 a C c=.4

.%.va..

.I 9 Cl' _ l O C, ^0.

s y.

.uy a

.v J

.v. - <o,.i

• e According to a March 1978 estimate, fuel 1Cading was sched-

-. a.A s

1

.'.1 <, <= u.4. n r ?,, 4 *. 1 A n v u,,,,,,. _c,/o 4

a

r '., 4 &

7 a

s

w... u v...

4..

cti:'y a.av,,

e-

.v.

1a30.

C C... ~.3,.. 4,.1 O e

,t.4C..

a vv b.Ae r.4.,..

4,i u,d.i o 1G.C.: C,.

r',4-y 4

r.

3 v..-

s

-4,/

u,.M.

..M.

, )

W-J., C.

.M.b.

NW

..-w..

.w.

m..b.a g.n. 4 1

yCC.'

u' e S.' "".. a ^ ~ _ ^

"u "v.1 5

~*C

1. ' a_ '

- a s e... '

a_.=.

~~ ' ". '

_v

-'-10.s/

( 6.. m...

9

'.'. 7 b

4., 1 7 C,=.,,. o.

-v.-.

-,..4w

.i CC,a4

,w aya v.

6 C.. o -a v-s a.r h.,.1 4 a.

L9.n.a o..b. 4 v. A

[ o','.=

101,

.%)

eJ

. b. e

. Soa....h 7. 4. d..,.v.._

-a....

a s

2-4.

i v.

.a,,

b a_

. a y -

a, a. 2,..:. ;

S.,

a.r.,

.4.,m,,.,.

a.;....

. -....2,.,,,.,.,;,

u,..-

.v.

...w-

--w L r.

.e. o.,3 J,2 a *,.

..T m C.. i.v. =.

7'.. 4.

M w

f n..'.'

n,,,._

Q.,,"

.r em a 4

w.

.,,,.4...,_3 p

w.

.- - - w

..a,we

, J.o-b om,,,,

O" j -.. _

g, '.- -. _4.. y

,....~a.w,.4.,_*

a.

_.a. v1.

.G y

y 1" ~-

n.

i 3

, a%

v

..e.

.e< Q,,..4

.q.,..

p,,,._

n.

q n,,,,. a_

v...

,,_e,,na,..3.,.

a v.,. a v

.;. ". ( ".e.- f. a ~

g g.v. I'

~ *' r-e

.c....,,.4,

'.?.a r

--~.v.,.4,.....

.?.4.'

"'==

a 3 " ; a r"

"-O,.

s r

-r

- -- ~*

.%au.

n o,..'a.,_

,ec...

C.,

4

~---.m 1..c e.. '.. a.n..-.*

m

.C '..'P..

• 3 7.' a TC

.4w-e -

a -

73 1 ^. 1

-2 s.J u.. L..,,...a _ ;

- r

.n.,

. o o

o/

a,, s.,

o. n... p. L v,... y,.., -

a

t. e,7., iw - u _ _m-v.,..,-

,c.,.,. 4

..,...c.

6.-

--e s w...

w..

w9 9,

.9#9 1d%==y v

.%.8.M..

9. #

p As,,#O

[9' s,'.d%.4842..,,),

- y -.a..

.g

]

3 m

vw f.w,,,.,.,.3

. f..g g. N.si'_ -..,

y-

3..'.

M '

%d f Jq/

? ?..<*.

• • "M.

.4 T

/

T p

1-w

..=.=...n..,.-_

.a.*a*-

-,."=*,A v

V 4.

.V O. a _*.,. *- _3 N

_..m q,

=.* Oa -

w

.w w 7 -*. * =

--3

b. #%,

"E W ]

9.%

M#

, = =. -.. w

.'=G

,a Y

%, 9. d O

" Q

'4 9,,a.

a.*

w

..w.w-

, J.

,'34..%.

w %

5..'..i.. - U...'

G y~._... 7 " c_ '

.o - ^v - _'

F a..' c....". u2.-.' C.,

7i'*.

, n 7

tU^

' s

/

.4..

.oa7. ca; 22.e

.-.a_.

a

..e.

n.. 4.. 1 n,.,

.c,.

p.

..,.,, e e

, 4s s

.4.. _,,,..,

m..u.e c o.1 u

W...

y will thus Icese I'CR in 1986-1987 and space altogether in 1989-1990.

If Unit 1 fuel were stored in the Unit 2 pool, these

.e, o 1

.a.e e s*.o ma a.

.o.cu,1d cc u,.

e,

,,e T.c.

O c

..o m_

.,/ o... -.a u-Mc Guire, the spent fuel storage capacity would be filled scener a.,,

m u.u 3, 3 *.

.t.

ea g.e.,. o.,

4 u.n 7mga. e. e n o. a.". # " * "..'.'

a s

a

^C ""."a'

""y'**-

~ ~.

...y

~.v, a-. o.

c. c s.i.^."-.

. u..

,,,.4,c._.

.,_e.

2,.a

( l o o. g )

.e. v

-,4.,.

e r.

y

.v se u 4o.

• oc

-7 a.b. 4 -..o n

• c.4 Oc

,ea-4,,e 1

4. o

.V., t" u.4. e.,' 2

.,e*.

m.W. a. c.

y.

m a

4 the scent fuel storac.e eroblem at either station.

It appears e

-..A 43 4..

4,-*

n 7. m.... 4.. ~y

.eg-s.'.. a.

o.

,.f o.,.

n. c,-.. 4 o g

• w i.a

6. 6. 3.

a 2

i,

-v3

--. y a**.4 7..,

-W

,r:4 4. _4 n..,.1 4

n,

4... a

• n., i,

• k.n c.d u,,,. n.

a h.,

,7.4 1 1.

~

.. < w st y

y

.' 1.".

w m, s g.w., p..

?,

..a..v,..A,,..

C O '..". c'." ^~.."yI,/"."-~,,

..e,.... - -

-v

.. - - w.

w 3..r.

a, v,,, a-

, ;, O.:

m.A.,.t. a.-

p C,.v.o.,

m...

aun.ab.

u I

m,.. -

,._.4C,,.1 3

-.. c., G.

.w..,.

c,.,,.

--... A y<.

-..j

" e a" "fC ". u~ ' ** C

'..".o

' ' ' a ~ * ' C.". 7 ' ' '.- o.

'.v'.' a'.' "..'o y a --

4...e.,

4 s.a. 4 - - 4.. -

-W..

c...,,,,,.

vu.

-3.

y.-

yy.

y y

.4

.an C.

ay-..

--a.

e., a 7

, c a,-.-,

--..o b1 a.a

.e,-. "1 LCr s.o.

.O 4

.6 m

..,, e,,, a.

a aL_.

.u o.

-c.,,

,4 c,,... a a r*,.,+.

1.*. /

.u. 4 =J -. a

.s

-%w wm.

e4 A1

..FM,.....F9...*.

.8.#'.%..-

, Q C.,.,..

SD'-,

q f,,.

s

....9 O..

...p

]

W.

8]

../

p

.C. e,se.',. a p r..=..

.C.,

3.,~... 7.*. d..'

Cb

- i.

. =

-..v.~

a,T. e,, a..3

.C,,,,,,a.p. p.,.u....

3a, 7.,. a w

G g-

- = -,

• s

• n.. o., '. a.

.,1.

p

• C. * *'.

. O,,..J,

.4-i 1?

r' f)9 l)/

,o

,,-.4-,

4 4,,,.2.

. a. 2

--,,.,aa

.m

. 4 - a.,. a.4..,

-.4..._,,.

%. 4 m

-a

. - a. a.:.. e-

, c ~. 4,-.

..,..c. : 2_.,. o.:

.c., a.. =. -e.

u. e, u.

..w e..,. _- c

..--u.

and Cconee to Catawca.

In fact, Duke Power schedules for their so-called cascade.oroc. ram anticic. ate tra:'sfer of fuel from Cconee to Catawba as early as 1931 and frca Mc Guire to Catawba in 1985. --12/One can anticipate further action to o.,. 4 ~..,.

_4,

..,.a-e,.

.e,. e,.

.c

~,., m.u a, s n 3 s... ;,.,,, s. o a c._. a.,_

.C.

w. e s u.t.a_

sys~a..

r E ' "..". c # ".".a.= c-

.'.i c a.. s.i.., = c - 4 ^. a-

'.e.' u.". e u _. a... a d ' = '

'-"4...

..'^ a..s.4..g

= c.4 a

~-.k.e

-e'c ^.

a~~a

.ic. a"." o s s

• w.".a-s t'." c e c,^ a.r..

7

.-a to be granted and to be granted on the sa:s basis as the cri-9 4..,.,

,-.4,.,

- a,,.4.. a n.

.,, :--.....o.

4.

C., c,.- C u.,.4

.a.

~a.

~..u. a

-.~.4 m

m s C.".e...e 1' s b ' a~ e c' ""ro *

"-.'~.a- = o o "J ^y ~. 4 ^. ".. ".. =. - s e ". 4 e a~

o.#

-m

~~

~.

--- ~-

."a "a'"

^ ~

.=

w.4.i.t

.s e

1. 4 C..s.'d

"-."a u'

"w.#.~..a ' "

w a".i ".'.d-..a.

". ". a s "w w".C *- 3' "- -.. -

a

-A;

• *, n. a a-b. 4 m..n.n.

c 4

.q

,.1 3.1 -. o e 31 1 C.qp A o.i a '.4...o.;' " a s.i :.

k e

y. %

a r.-

f:.

-,.wma-.--

Q.C g g e 4 e. n..

4-m

% g e.s.

2.4.,,. 4. - -.

e..

.m,. Y.4 9

a...z.~..

M.a em o.-

7

-u; w.

a.w w b.t::

w o a C u.m., a a h.u. =. a-so s.h.,... 6. 4 e a L. 4 a a-m.4 k.*w,.. a a-b..i n ~...a n. _w a-r.

a

~Sw

.L w

s 4-a

e. a wa.,3 4

nd.

v.

..n.

,. - g,

m v., '..,

• ',a.

1.,. ?y..--...

a,

,4-

.. r L.%. a.,,

• .m.

". e.O. 5, %.

.=

.t.

s7 y

w

>b..,

b.,,,

3.,..a

%. a i, -

.n.

p -

..b...m W4

.y~

w,Y..a 4.a.

Wa f L a,

4 ys u..-

s

-A.'__"^...2.'

7 C.'a~

~..".a 2d C'-.*.~2--..'..;

<~.'.~.'"".a^,

-^

• ^

.G..'. ' -......,

• a

%., a-

.m m.k.

,, aA.

m,.

.-u

.'.9 b '.. a_ _,

.'.1.4 W,,*

.O.

• 3 r.

w,

,.4..,...-

.?.a,

.O, L.b., ; a -=..

F, a w, *' -,

a

...t w-

..-m..

0...,..

r..i.1 a-

e..

r*

• -c 5-.

a

.l.o

4..*

.C"O a *

,..s

! [I d

4 1 t.?

C.

m

,u..a_A,

.. o -.m...

, A...,c..,,

a_

m -

.. e

.a we,.., m.

.,. :, e.,. ~ a.,...,a.-

v.-

.;a..- a..

... ~.

m.

r av s

• ac

.. C L.1. 4 kg

+ a..a C,.

a..

+S"cy

• ? n ;

ao o..c u

w..

-u lost as noted belCw:

OCCnee (with ISFSF) 1Q93 (withCut ISFSF) -

1987 MCGuire (with ISFSF) 2005-2010

.oeo

(..,.a.w... C L,....c.. : - ).

'yy- -. C a "...is S.4..C a "w.".<.=..'d. c '~ ".'.- a "y C O.' 5 a _- a a_..."y*."..

.. ".. ' =

s

..' ~.". ".'.. t a - ^-.

u.~.ie n. a _, a D u.~..

=C.1-

.' 1 a.....,.. 5..

. '... " - - - =. =

. * - ~, -

c u a t.u.

e, 4 -

-..a C,..

a.,ao me u

u C,,n..

m,4 s..e a -

C o..e a.

-. e

-. will provide you with the

.- a.. C.h..i.. c, oye.,-

-. o y o s e d a C.".a_ d u ', a# r..

e.

4

.c CL.-

C y.i.. a.,,,., n w,

. u. a.

i.

w...

..C,S.

I 7.

mC eA. a C.u. a A,, T o. dnaS "1 C. ~- -,. a. C.n.. A a, u.k. a y a w-e.

4 n a=

g 7. 7,

• 4 e. mJ m O.4 C e.

4.. e a

,Ca w=3._.'e..

c m

v y

a.

.; y 4.. C., v, m,

u.m,..e

.m 4...e.

4 n A. C L,a-.

C L, -

n.

..v t,n. -

.. g g g,, a " * ' "v ".

C-.

"y O.' c ".".

• • • .A.

-w u,,y.

v.,

.T. a-.v C 3 1 d v s r.L,.4 -c-

• b. a_

.._A

.J.4

.3 C.4 e,., n

-. a f

t g

be yn g..a -..a a.i.

.WC ".". ' C r.

w" ".. a "y ".,' a~ A un

-a 7

• O La L,

..n.i a. *._, A-7.4.

a.,

..4..'

3..,4

.y 4.,,

-v 7

.-a s.. g 7 4..., - 4.3 13.a 1 c-c ya

. - -.. " -,.". a G e C ^ ". "

4. g bg r e.=..I a = a M-I O.,. '.,

-._.d_.=.

.=.b.._.a

,E e f.u, g c9 s

y

..y

-~

C C ".."y.l o ~..' ' ". C.#.

".". e a~ a.

• a. # " G '.4.*. "; C '.' " a. a'.

.',/

.--.,...2 C.

• IO..a

.i.~.... p A--

.,q

..W.,

,a y,4 J

v u

.. a.. A a-2,.6...

• t.,.

1-i

==.~-

.n_

1 Y.3 e.4.

.g e,.'f.

a.

4g. 3, c,.,

0,.,,. a b..

7. C, ",O.

m b..... -

-c

...e s -.. a s,

y

• b. a.

v n v.,

.'r.4....,. =,.

,s, c.

....aA.,'...

g...6...,....

..,....a..4 - m......

a

~

b q

W 7

i.._

.O

.. g

-,s, _.4

,.--i,.,,..

3,-

n,

.e......,.:-)..a.-.., -._. C

..a__,...

4 a

v

-yy 1=.

~-..,a.

z...

.=L,+.,,._,..

e,.,., w o.,..,...a,-

c.,..,,.,

n

.....sw.,,

-w...

T T...i- '

. m,.

,J.2,

. w'...

m. e. a. - y e,.....,a_-

.. e, 4.i.:.4

,. ;,,,,. 4 c-

.i

.. u C a r.a....W. es r 7 3,,.i 3,, 2

,1,_,_*, / ~,- "

.4.'.a, s e. n..

)

• C. r, r,,,

2 a_

9,,,,

.f._,...,.,a,

'-',_4.,.. _

J C n. a - - - 4... -. ee.,

, -,,, a.,

. u -..)

.v.

-e,

..3,,,._3 _ a.

, a,,.

'.s,..

.T.:

. 1,a.

~

0 ('s ?

L I. )

3 is lp i 2

10

. 4 4.b 4.. 2

~. ~a C W

,.,,.L

':'., 4..4 c--

,n a. sv e

..C.".,.

'.9.

a.

C 2o

.v. -....

.a.

.w,... -.

a. o

.v-,,..a4.

n a..

w 1 4 -n,

. y

. uw..

,-w..a

..., 1.,. n-

..O m,.a--

w 4...n-a a -., 4..,.1 3 e -

e. o a. 1

, c.'e

. -1 l, /

L.,

g.7 3 4..n.

.3.w-

- - 4 4 6.,

b. c

.Qyy7..

.Oa a-Q

.. ~

.y c a..~. ~ '

u=.ra v. e -

• o

'.P..r. C

h...

• a -- ^ c. a * ^.-"; 7 e', ".".i-.- a. c k '. c. wou'd a

a

.w w

give Duke Pcwer until 1987 to build an ISFSF at Oconee.

At the same time, without going to neutren absorbing racks, an ISFSF could be constructed at Oconee by May 1982

(

4...,_ o.

, c s a-v-L.

a.

...,... c a_._= '4

.i s ~.. A a

=. n = 3 i.:

.,_.u. a_ gac4 4

~ -

yC

e.

• n

a. n

.,4 C...

n..

b. a.

r.Ti.k.e a-o C

.n. S.4 4 o. w i 4 4.. A.i C,,

a

• b..: -

-. r w

w

.a D.2.... n 7c..3

( a.n. A n a s

,.ri, b.7 o m

v.- e.

- w._. A. o.n.. )

m,.1 o,.,..4.. n e r,

b. o.4.*

.vv transshipment cascade crocesal.

In their answer to NEDC Interrcgatory 10, the Acc.licant i.. d 4 - ' "_ a s.. ". - - "-'.0a"..'",~..a_...

v. 4 ' ' ~ ~.cvid'

1. C'..

r*~

nea,

'~

3

-u 3

-1 C m, *- v.s ~wa C.n..l o o.n. 4m.7 1 g c. '.

.c o e y C S c,A.7.f u,...W. 3 -, 4

..o.

.y r c L,. 4.- o-

-..u r

w a.1 1

.)

a -c.

4,., n S (.*,. e.,C *, e ) 4.4.'.7

.d a,...

14-a.. -A

..w s.

.w

..we cp-o-b. 4 e

_w y

C.".a.s.>.2a.

a..w'v. O a.'+...i. s (cea-n'.#.#.4 4,..' -

o^.#

b ' 4 *,.'.. ";

d a

-.. C' e =..--.

a v&

C.

.".E" a-ya " 0).

D u.b. c'

.UC 'd e - "..". " a-

,."-a""-

a S o-'~.a

~.. ". ' - ".".O.c e

.d

• 1.* wp Cr

..- og a..C 4

v st,A L,..

,. 4... o.i...

b,a4 -

,.2,

,o.

3

~ ;

e e

-w a

w..a-w

-C

• L..,.,.

..a. a.

w., n.

6. 4

...n, ;.., * *

%p a.7 7 4..).p A.

..n_...

_..a-..

..b..

2.

y

.v

.A

.a es,.'

r,,

a w 6.a.-

.... 4..* 700 -.

.L. a.i

• . ?.." 6 m

,..c

.-w T...a e,g;,

10,

..n 4

.-~;

.k

.. y y.1.i,

a-.a7

e. 4.

..4..,

.W W

.. 3.

gwi 7 A 74 J

et..

=.

..n.

e.

e e

.c a e.. 3,...

.9-7

....O.'.

y'.L a v _ ~7

.., pg...

NA t.....-g. 3._

9. e ]

] g. q a.

.e.v 1:

,w N

4

,.4.

9/

..J, f

9..%. 6....

.d'.

j iw.%J, L].-.

N.

T. 'g.

p...w

-w g

7 pg ] q.._...P

..9'.#'.

.O.-

~

- y c]...

1

• b v

%'. 9.Q

...g M

c.

M

$0A.,-

g,p

.-r..,

e...

p O

I

.s.,

D 39

,s

.. ~ ~

f:

aO4 I (a.

) t;

\\

pU t

1,

---

.....e.:,

a-,-

.w,.

e r..e. -

a --

4

... u m a y u,,. -

. ~ - a

---..a.-,

,oo.g

.,.u. o-

..--o--

ege

.na

,, w 4

.e,, m.

2.

c

.,4 e

a co"

.=,,, -

-,--..o=

---

.a.--

e r

.m, --o---

a s o -.. - - 4,.

,.-.4-c

.., a

,.. c,

.y - - v.

o r---

and is allowed, Da'.e Power will have to build an ISFSF.

At that ceinto all the transshipment cost will be added cost and the overall cost of the ISFSF will be greater.

Con-s..t.-

4.,,n c.c a,.

1.e r..e r.

a ec,,,.eo-

-.c.e w4, 7--

... =- -

.". a i - sre n "-

fuel needs to the year 2000 (and beyond f they build a larger C.". a. ',' '.<.i'. ' ' '. '. ' " -

~'..e"s"..i~.~"..a.".*..

y All the above statements are true and correct to the best of our perscnal knowledge.

,7

,A-

/,

1 f

,/ l st o'

/ /

)

n U... l,. %I'*

.-...%y - -.e.

/

Y PO m D ~,

s

m..w. C.,.,

,w bwv..,..f w-7..s, d

A.-

JWC

..- w e4mm J

a a.

-w J e,.

eVo. L3 rJ (.,...

=

u..,...

-.,e...

0

/

/

/

.f

/ /-

,r-

~

f, f

YY %'

O. g. h *

%. *' v-e l-3 vs.

...-t h by -

c 3

4 iOi

..n.....

m... 4..

~

4..

4

- -. 4.. w 4.:.

..L.....a,,,,.

. 0 7..,

?

w.

-w_..

2..*..

4..

.a. 4,

.w. a... 4.c

..._ r? a. 3.,. ;

.y c,,,,,

3 '..'.'.3 w

w..

w.---....-,

C,.., e., 1 a.:.7.

e..

.~4.,.

v..

p %.. -).

i

.3 3.4e-4.o.f.e i C s - U n.i v e a.4 "y" c#

w a...# ^ *".*..'. =, ' e.".,=.' 2 ",

c c

C u.1.,.:., lo o 2

A-Os

...3

..Im, t..

-,,,.,3.o

. 3.,w i.,,

v.,

u

..o

,,,,.1 n

.,24.-a w

e,,.., c--

g..

w..b

=#

=

%s b

-Q,

.a

. ac.

=.

4..

• % _. 7.%..i.S.-.

r. ^ m. c.w.,1 1

C O e/ w.i. r.m.m...p, 4.

1. % =. A.e 73. 9 **

.* A

.e. ^ 3..c. c.

c 9.r*

w 'i A.

6

.w

.c.

w

.. w w

C*.

Q,w,. -.

• .=

s.

.um. /*

."9.a m

I ') d 7 3 *, % 7. "-

.,w.

,,, C 3.%...$

.' 6 s S. - - - p

-e s J f.S. -

4 e, w =. 4..

w g

n' a -

--w a

j w.O C S S v.,5g c

h. O.

.. pm t.r. T c M C*.

tE3.,. 4 A., 'a

.'* 9 A %.I.3.

S eE

s. S a'a 3

=%

aw..s w -

.- w a y v

..w

, g 4 m a.. p,.

,=.w..3-.. -73

• i.v.

.3.-

.. 3.

S w

.e. 3

,.n

.3

=,.

w w f

.w 9..- e.

.-.. w

. ;e f.,

-w,=

ae

.S,.

e c.

• a.

g m.

e.

..J

w. =.q w.,,,

.a..

w

v..*3,.

w m,.e w.m. =

4.9..O.=.%

.*3-a, w

- s g

w w

w s.

~...,.

1 c.. a-3 e a c ~

3.

3

..l,.....

....p.

.w w,..,s c._._-

..c w e, u. w,. m.. e.n.

w a.- e

.e

.-w w

2 ww ww

-w w

.w.--.1 e.- - n w-6..e.

O m

C, -., a.

w,..-

-4 3

.a.

a

.w w..

.w

..w 1 3 '3'".7,,

7, "t.".",

?

3..r

,., n o

?.a.4,7o.-...,a. v s, T u, L= C w 3 n w..

7.i..o_....r..w. o,

6 3.i., e.

e

.e s..

..ww w

w ww_j 2. a..,

7. 3 1

a..v

..m

4. '* a C'.4 m..

5 4

.w,2 4 e 5..

.,94,

.-7 4. e..m.

h. a

b. 7 2

% o a. m.

w w

w.

m

. = ~.

.m S.

g,.

4 w e w-w w.

..m,,...w a

5..S _ f.3....... 3 vc..=.O..=.mw..,.e..m cw

'..v r c.. o e. m.,=e

=,.

S

=.

2*.*.

w

.=.-74 h...

m.S.S..:. =. =.

6, 4

4 L.

4.....S S

L4.;,.., 4 '... 4 m...

%. 4..

W. 2 4

4 w

. wt w.

.4 e...

5. = 4..s..=.

4.

.6 w

.S. w.,..

...!* 3 ww*

q.

=.p a J

.m

.=aq.., g,. 3

.S

-S.=a..

=*

G.....p

.ww

.w.

we -

3

..~. se = =

w..a 3... w w.-

4..

,~ -

......iL,.=

• -.w.,-,r.

a..m.

w.

~.

%. b = S........ -,..

=m

.-w..m -.5 3.,

q....=.c..

%. w

.. =.

,.fa, w '... em m 3

.e. o.

% w.m. w.3.==... m.

w

.* g 1

m we.

.v.3.,.=.,..j.=..,.s.pq a..=a

.,,,=,s.-..

a Y %,.w-..=

..d.

o..

w

..ww

.w f

w.

. a..

..a.,.,.

...a 2....3.,,..

..r.,...r..

wC.......

m w

w-

", y - w 4.e.,;-

6. *,,. a a w _4 m,.~

v3

..C.'" "

m v

w.;

..O,'* O.

b. 3=

7.S..e.s

"".2..=.,._.S...

=

w,..-

ys - -.

m

.v m

...,3 a.w3.,

n,.,.:

..63.

.w a-

-~a 8

m4...

,s..

-) ;

.. A

..a '.4 w,.4 2... -

ww s

/*.-... 4..a3 m.

." y - n o Mi,,'

3 w

%. 3.. r O...,. 4 4..-4.., '-

w,,..

.e ww...--

.']*

• 9 L, a

.i,.%.

.=w w.i a.

m..

a.

-. =... 5a

,.9

..,.3

.^9..9..==a.

w

• -a s

9..

w.-,

6.

w...

4

..O "

3- --,1

=qa

.w..s.-

."'.3m..

4 w--

.~

**3.. 3q3

?.

ww 9.. " *.

9 i,.a..-. a m.a =.

g_

.OsI * --. 3... g wm 3..,,#J 2.=..= r.g e=.a.

..a. 2

.w

.***'3a

• --..*-S

.-'w.--.*~~***7

- - -. +

• a 4

J. a C 2 4

'...W.

...g

-Y..3-e

..f..

3

.,L y..O...3

. --".. - -- 1. 4.-..

.O.s s..*,..% _,..,,,.

.9

...e. 4.

,m,."..m.J

..a.=..*.=-...

4 J,

. /.- _

~a

..a.....,, -

r.,,..

--==

.3-

...g.7......,.-

. O a.. a..O

.w.

w.

s...w..

.**-w*.

e,.,,,3,..,....

r,.,.".,,

-.t....

~.,,.;,,

o v.w.

~ :

.... ---. = a.;

....4..

wa,

.Ca,;.. - -.. -

-u,

- - *.n w,- -.... -..

4

, ~..,,. -. --

w---~

.. a w...

~.

y,....

,.= w ;...

,.=

.... :w.

e._,.

w..

a.

~s

" '_a,.. "* } ". *. '...~ 4 e

.a.. =,a I a 7.-

7.*

.w 3_.g#.,..

.w3

... ;-i..

w ;.

.~,..3.,

3

-*A.-

t 3

-.T a.

.w.....,...,.4 4}*O*I.. J 3 *3..... "

..G'.-

.'.C a Y m.5. %=

" 2,

' "... =...=w a

• bw

..n.

"4*"

~#

- ~ C.== 4 C

- ~

l 4] U

. Q e'

j. ,

i O t.

U

O c.

a.~n.e.

1'q<3 e.:-=..,.w..:

C m,..a..w,n,

a..s.. D.

%....., a,

Business Address:

Natural Resources Defense Ccuncil, Inc.

a l " b' '- 5 S * -

7 "b5 hashington[eatDIC.

2bO (202) 737-5000 Ecme Address:

42,o-sIo w.. w 3 0

• w...c w e_n..

u w.

e,,

t.Oe

.s..i.4..,;...,..,

t. 4.w ;.4.. 4 a w

.w (703) 532-1044

.r..u..O r u~.m..e...

.u. - -..e v.

_e-r

..es,u-ces C e #. a.n. a e, ' C w u ". -.d.'

e 19i3 y..o-oa."w.

N. a " ".-,1 n~ 4 'x o

.".~.a...

y~ s "._i..c.^r.',

D.C.,

.ce.a..d o. S ~. a." " S c ' u' n - ' a- -,

c.

-la.'c ~'

"~ ^

e n e r a. v. R&D "olicy principally nuclear energy issues, the e

breeder reactor, plutonium recycle, nuclear weapons prolifera-S a. e,y b, a ;

a..;

.e..,~a 4 c.

1 C n e.-, a-., e e a,

,.4..,.w a.

C e.. a-,u,, u., U.

ua

m. -

4,,.,

s y s, u.

w.

a v

w...

( a m.e ) C D.

".u C.l o,. a.#

".e,. "y

• s.i.#_3"'~.*^".

d

.g

k. o,

.f, g y.s..e - g u e

c.

.r..a_ w ~j c

w

---w w.

-.~

w m..

.ia,-

,q p, aw,*ac...

C ".".s u.l ". ' ".'.

"O C ".,...y *." O '..i o " ~ o.".e _" '..' C "-

i

...2, n o, g.w.

• '. o.

- u, -,. n.e in.

uSOS C.

".'.".i^'"

(, i, "v3

-.. d

.4... n...., *. 4

., _1 v,.v1e a

,r w

y (o) Uv. b...'4

~

(w) a' a, a,,.C c 4 a.h..

.7 a. a. *

<*o. c.w. O l c,y 4 a s,

b

, A e. a.w.; ;. r,

w 3%.-

.w

-. ~

- v

..w a

ww rm

.,,.. ^, O.#.# d. ' '

^#

v.

. _n~.'..-

. e. 2.

,1 r 3 3 _-

.a

n. o. a a

.o.n 2 - 4 n.w o w n

.w -...,.

.. m

.-u 1.a,* q 3 3 a..m.. o g.- ( { *..*, ),.

• fo...".,-."

o #.

P, ^.7 ' ~

7..". s.'. ';' ';' O s c o,.'

• C.". '.'. " '

• _* ~ v~ ~. ';

..e.' a m...

s

. v a

.~

w

' a~ v^ - "; ' '.. _' _'

s w.

n'd",s sv-a"

"..v^ n "y.*'..' i.# ^ ". a *..' *w.*.

n' d "..i s ^ " "; D ' ". e _', 0 ". a* ' a-

.a C '." u#, "'"

u v.

.u.

'". m "./

(v" w e.

• a nJ

• a p;.,,, w 4.;,

b. a.

'pw,w=.1o.,.*.

u

-_=.,4m.. 3.* A."

.%.f. S. s..3..w=

.D _w m,.*.4. _J g.

a

. -y s.

i

-..v I -

• 4 *

(*e *.".*. 8

.. 5 1.. e. m s n.J.

b. o C.TS, n*

O.1mn

.s..u 7.

g w.wa a..4 P '".'.'%

a W,. c.

.,,.w.,.

a

ac v... -

4 9

.w v

3:

C v.

. w g.7

,. w

. 1

.c.,-...,

0 6.., 4.. qn. 4 a..,

o.3 g.

g v.,. n _,-..r,,-

w.

e e

-.. a.w.

..g...

w

-j wn

~..,

m..

.w v.#

w

,c 7..

'".r..i. o.w

...3.. 4 a..,.1

.T... a e ** *..i..

• r.s O. ~c, f.4.s e.

• bs b

• l*."".r".

a a t,. e. p

.m

.'. y _

J w

s-

-a

..w-w Tg 3.1

{.. a.1 n-

[,3.. m.*.

Cg w.. g r.-

<, e-m... - a v. 6..

{u~

9.aWp..

%..,. v.1 s

7

-.. ".g

~

g, v.

=..b..a

'. t', a 4 a.., -

n' -,, 3

-J C4 -

~ ;

0. a, w 4.. 7 v

w.

r*

'..'."""7-0,...~ < c,.4.

ww.a..

3..;

ma w

4-.

-,.L w

.-ya,

..b. n

'.s,..'...

p.,....e_*

a.

.C w.s.,...

4. m.w a' g 7 n 7 -.;..,3,

• ',..1a.,.-

• f-w

.s L,

~- y ew w.

., a...z. v y... a...... %. n

r. a. 5 2.,., '

r e w -.,.s p.

-.. a.v.

r,.m..,. n,.v.

.4 m.

O..n. g a..,,,

2.

A m

T

j a

w.

I -

...3-..

.O L,....,

3 r., 4 n.4

u.. 3 4 4 ms.. a i

.""'o,4

.. a O., m, w,. -.. L W

.O,.. 3 3

a 4 -. w,.*

"3,. a.7 m.. r.

,3.,.

CU

• '..a..w.,..

3.,,. A-4Wa

.T m

..,. i.,

w.. a

..a

... +.

.y.

S

%. [

.b. a '

• e.e.1.S. r.m*

a.5.

L..., w p=.L. a c

.r a w.

O....A..

".,.e.. a _I Cw.,.=.w=.'.I e.

1. 9 L I

a.

-..w

..--y; w-

%,.w m...

p

" L....

h. 2. J e.

. 1 J

- I

-.A w '.

r.L..,. b. a a '

.O n.,..

.aw..

7

.a,,.

w-w.

L.

=

b.v. -...-

.--w b

7; 4

e

. ss..

w.

=a y

. -.' 3... -

a.w.,

e.=.

.?. w-..,.. p. :.. - _

L" *.. <.= 3 v.

,7,

._i3 an',

r-*

m-

.~.

.4...

_4-y,

". t, w w

_v.

o -.-

.J

.'.c r....,...-n

'.'4,. a 6.....=

.w-w w.. ce..'.3.....

.s 3 e.,. 2 4 V

.-a 88 r.

,r f

.)b-

-a ev w.

],

Q-

]8 a.

. u %., -4.

q

.,. 4.% g.g p 9

..a

• )

89

..P.ua

9..e F Q,,

• )

..84.I.

- * -.u

]W

~.

g

.,J. s.

e n =., : 4 m.. r=

4..m..T A 4.- -

n-,n.m.n.*

.h. p, w 4

s. ? s-p

......a.v=n,.-

a

3..u

• "a_ A_ 3.v. 3 T

{ * * ~.* p a.-

• p-.

w--

n v--

a

....=dp.

• • -..3.w,,

h. a b*,. 9. $

a w. 4..

.m....4

. ~-

_ a y. n.

b. 3

.=,og

_4**m

.* h E

9, y;,.. -

• p

. 3a e.,

s.v-.-=,-

s.

.~...~.;

w..M

.i....c.I.,.e.

%,, CI,,

w.

..b. a-

'.e v...

a.-

""^.,,**N.w'*

u

• ^ 4 w w. '... 4 b M.a. ="a* A -.-

p-

• .. a a

...3.,._4m.,.w.

7 w*.b

• w

• =..

=.

+

v.

'.f...'.a 2. r a ~-l,. *-....

.a.

.%a

-2.

.. s a.

en

..4.

aa.

,s,.e..c.....'.

.s u J... a. - w

~.. -4 r -.

.*=

-.w,

=.=w w.

w w..

w.

6,

3. " u ;,.i g gi.

C w-.l.....

.]d C.4

.~ a C

.g.

N a.gW9 gy

-- -a.

Q

..g.

-..---a.-..

a n s.-1.,,..av

1. e

.s 9

's.

m..u. -., e a.,. <

,,w.,n, ow

....D.

s.

w...

..n y;-

.u w

r..... _. n.

n.....,

ga.r.,.i..;.--...

.,.. n.

1O ~,.*

2.y. 4 1

.i.7,.:..

e.n. a-,% _- -,_ e e,..

..a-e

..g

--.............n...

7*-......

D.o.,

.C g n. u -- 7 e e n 3.e m.'.*

• c

,2'..,,-....

v.

v ew no.vc

,.o..

.--y.

...C1n,-

y..t_

- - ;.4.. u..

e...,4.-

a.,..,1 e.: 3.o.

.-k. n L.a.

C _4 o.

14 q...a..

c,,.

• w-

_.3

- "; C i " *

.'.'~'.'#

.i 4...-

...,.. g g.4 A, o..,.i.e

.,,..,7-...n....

4..

1 n..

...n..o 1

i~.;

~.

m.

ta.'

.# a s"- WeedO.-.eaC*0- p Cg m,m,-

n a

• 4 ^ n.'.' e.. n..'~n- " - o '.4C ";,-

u'.. d

~

r ad.ia *-.i c n s *w a n d a..d e.

N. rO *v e 3 hoCP, T.". n.

L.i L.4 d

.'in *,.1 F's* P n_ ado-a Re a C *w,.,.. Au vn.I.4

r... o.. a.1 c..d

...r

.v..., C C....., C.,n.

n n

3 r

u-1969 - 1971. L.4*+-n.w._'1 C..4 C-D _4,f. s 4 " n, S C i e *. - i.#.4. SL' ~-o."

7'"-

'*s 4

o Fort Ord, California.

Modeling and Simulation GrCup Supervisor.

Supervised the activities of 10 operation researCh analysts engaged 4-

-p-.,.4

, -y

.oce-.,-,," -n. "...c."

• o

• wha c ". '.1 u,

• 4 c r. o.# ----c'ed U.a~.

~

- -.. e.

e.-e

.a

~...~ e-.s a.4

-.' "./ U.S.

.h._.v.

'"C'.".-.

...~..-.4 C,' '.' #

1 e

u-0_,

w

.a.-="4

..g.

.7a..,-.

m.., a ~., s..,.,

..u.i_ o s.

..o u.~

- r u

~.A._.,._4-.

. o

=-.s

-,c. a.u..;a.i-

,.c

-.. :.., 2.,

r.

n :-.

a,,

...e

.,u....,.

a a.s.

.- a ---.-

~...A.

ae

-u-....

Ci.......,n,.

0.,...

4 n.

. n. a..

x.

.s_.. ;

C,...y,..,,.

4

c...

e Jo o _c g. ".. ".".. C.. C "... a d i '

• 4u.C.. - md""*-4 C ".. 4n "e'~.

• '.""yw'"-

s V. ". ".".. s u' ~-

~ -

e.v w -.,..n.. v.,A p e3.1_4 4 -. 4,

cu S w,...t

. =A T.a *4 e m

n. o n.l y..,*-.p

• c 2

w 4

w ta n ' p

• m

., s b'n' m.

• v. t.

s.

O n.e.

.A -

O.., *. n. p SL, e.e 1 0. ( Q. M..e,/ o.

_4... O: C - 7. O

.,.d O, C L. i A n *,

o

-v g? C w.,, A C.,.

CL....td.* ' "..,,...

".).a..6L,c _.,,,.,, 1

.a..., e a.

r t,

nC,

.w.,&nr 1Of~

1.O 6 *i. t % A n b 4 7. p.. 4.. n_.- - 4

..,

• t., e.h.t,.. *7o "n.

ce-w s

. J-s-

. a n s

.h.

i k.4 W

-4

-e.

-. a n..y Oh.y 4-

• M,4 e v.

54

)--

--~

~..

u...a.,,..

~.

gG,n

'-J"--

• <.L-.

'~..

-=

_t gw.,-wp

) - w...4..e.

s.,w..c. n-

- n, 1 1 r.,a.. g.. 4. y.

g..a g u

r..t,. "a G a. #.".

. '. - - - +

u

( e..w w a

~"'~~

3 y..;.

u 7 w - i. W m... m

• • ,.,,. 4, a.1

, L. O w.

..w,, f D.h.e. e 4 m 3 4a a

.f'e _.= 3 n.

h.

a v.....

..g w.

y a..4 3_.44 4-

..A..

g-7a..

'.

• c.7 W

t.

a---;.4

.e..

w.m

.-,,.,, C. 4 v..

y.v..p p

. = s.n... p

.3 s;...... -....

m

e. ~% *a..m.. s,.

y.

7 0., 4 a

_ 1 0.~ ~. tf,. A n_.. b _4 7. t '.

e... n_, 4

.., ".., e b... _4.*. 7

,. n.

a e.,

6,.

m s

.s u

. r C

u. a,.~ u n,, -

n. n.

4 3 4.<. - 4 n a.p=.e

.e_

C.,.,.,,

w..n... a...

m,.

s;

.y y.

.2.

a

.. u,_4 4..,

ta,.

7..44,o

.t.,.,._,.

. c _'.'......, 7., a. A.

n.a,_7.,%.

0. %...

4 r -

~

a O.L... < e

.a c3 c.:4 a

-,C.4-4-

---,3....

--.b.~-,

• f g..4

'. 4..A g..e.. n. _.,. 4a. _.. p.,

. y..

2

..a 4

.e a.'.... ' i m L

., p e g. a.

O..."*.

. O.%.* _. 1 *. !.*.'7.

T *.,.. d a

b..a '..

?.'. _.. n_. 4_ _

a c

....--p o.

f

.r..' a. r.

4.4., 7.

p. ;.a.. p.,.. ; p g....

• ,, i

.-[.1...<..

u a.,

.--..,,f.,.r*.

rm----,..,

g L.s.

. ~.

a.

.' D.....

.a st.3 4

7 6..

4m,'

.c.e C C _4,3 w_..

.,-*w--

'.*'a..*a,.w Cp C.4 a.

n d..w4,

.e t.' a '

W O..W... e 4

.c C-

.4

~ a

-vw 3.,

.,.,.4

.f.

q 3

C.,. :. ; w...^ a 4

.S 4.

b.

4,. n.

.' '2

• *g y.

1..'I f,.^.

O, 4

• ].r. k. 4.

~,. -,

y., e, a,

s. y n.

.s r*~~.b...

r"%.

3 es

_4 g

.,. /*=,,.

w.

w.h. 4.3

,,,3,.

3.4 w.

D, r.,.,_

-w-

. v

.f

.,y.,,

,b+

I

, % 8 e%. T' 9 g l

qs

'" " k Lg y p'g>dW,, '

,'s r

v b, n..

I h L.

. 4 tb iV

a.

r - c,..,., =.u...n,.

~.--.

n,.,._.

n o

,s..

fa....

...,.4w.. -o.-,1

,e

-4.

,A

.,.o.,-.

w.~

. _.w m_ o_ s o _w

=,.e_,,.,.-.,w.

..u. m_

- a.--

. ~. -.J~~.~-,

. ~. - =.. -.., - -..,

z.-,..-.,.. -. c

.-.c,"=..

.a.c.

a-

- ^ --

-w 1974.

Reviewec in Science 176 (April 23, 1974), pp. 391-393.

C C "s G O. r S S 7 C' A' '

"r c " 7 '.f F". Y 1.

ae.co e 4.he SL,wC.3.4 4ee on n.1.,.cn...e.,.

a..a s.

r a..cs

,e.we, w

e r

House Cc=mittee on Science and Technoloc.v.r July 18, 1973 7

r

.w

.c~.ewa

...o-

.O i 1.w.

..... 4 + % a C.o.

.e..n.e v

., a,., A

.r...4.w,.,....n...,

• r~,e.

a c

C,. 3.4

.3 o C.,., _. - - - - - -

.'.e v p..

e. ' a~

-.r. a

.1 3.-

n'-_,4 Ja

.o 4-a,,.a.

a' s.

r a

A17aqa*4cns, Ju'v.

') 4, 1 9 ~1 1'

-.~..s_v-*

= e c e n ~.u.,

~e;.C e

u. e c L, o%,,,.3.4. u.s., a Cn rCaa41

.m, A

v. L.

.1 a,w r

~

t w-.

t-w a.

- w'

- e/

..o u a c C

...4--an C ".. CC.' 3.". C '

a.". C "A e C."..".C.' ^ F;';', v U". "-

.r

-a

'u.

-.". d ^ e' V e " ~.....*. *-,

.n e.so.. t,

• u. e c t " C " "..*"...i ' '" a e C ". r.'.e " y~';' O.e 4c"^b.

u

's.

o,

.'4, / /

'~

es, Ju..e c '".a' e Cc~...'..4 **e a o n

.r..G.. g v. a.. A N. a '". ' l ^ne v

-t.

u

-.. f s '. o.

...,. 4 w n.... n~.

e: -. -uz

,, wm s u.a

$ g u,,... 4 u n o C,..

.r a

.e

.ne.,.

4--no s

a.

r.f n-w -.1 70, 1C7',

- 33 w.

e

• 7 S.1,w m-,---,

Cvm......---

C.r.

N... n w C,u. e a er C

.~

-..A

~ p, n l w

.a.n. -.

e.J. v, n

s. u. a. 0L,u,,

4.u r.. a -.,

v. C. S a,..n.n.u.

~

aa,-

e o.

-n-

~........ - -

w..

' C -

.C, b,.e. n o,' -..

4

.3 n r o _w ;..

w,.. A ". h,...., 1 3.e.cLL.

ae,

?., _w e b.

90, a

w-

- e w..

-.m 7.

n g.-

n h b. n

.O g.h r..... 4 A. <. a

r. g e e 4 _* r

u... n 1. n, w J,.S

• O r '9, * ! a.,..p-a.

L.

..a n..

~w

.w-C ^..... i '-. a a-c~w.i. a.. ^ a

.'.".d

'."C-."...^7 ^ ~~-,

.'t...$._-.".

..C ~, ~

^.

c

• ?,

s u

y

].

O., p.4,=,

.b. o-C,,bg,.

.=.4.

na c..

r a,.w

7. 4.

4 b.a

=*. 4.wa

..o U..s,. ; a

--L w-,

. 4 s s a..

.s e.. " - a w i. m s&

Te..e.,',,_,.

.._..e

_.,,,.',,. -a.,.,..

,,,,,: A m m a.q 4 ~

22,a w

.. a.

w

-.o-9

-w.3C,,,J-

• • 3 J

b

'9"

. C. "s0"

c.. -

-o r 4-.,,w.,

- d,

--=;

o..

c,,,a _ m e s

%. n

~- 4.

(~ ~.... 4. n o c... '... -

- a.w n..

c. L,.u,,. e. 4-.-.a.

.~.

a V--...

i..

9

.O.n,

_4..,

-.u. a **

4 a..n.,*

.".,,,A,n.*.

• we,

..a m..

O w,. g m

33

,.. * * * (*

7 Q =, "-

7 a,a.

aw w

.4.

7 _ e g w. e.m. -

e c,s

e... 4. m..e

-w

.)

1p C.,e.*. m w. s *. 6. a J.

... - -.b, e..... i. n o, % e.

." n _

.e C..

4 4 b. a._

.,.3--.....p..-r

• • oa C ^ -.'.'*.-.a --

^~ ~

'aw

.".e' r.-.,."_-^--~..a...'.,

7. L' ' e-F'...'

-'"- ^ "..

^ --

• ....~~-

-..A-

...m. 1

• , 4-J,

....4.w-c*

,., 3, ;,.,-,3.,,

..,e

,3-....

w -.,., w...

.n.

...*.*: e 4 Ov 1

--.y.-

-a..,

• s3

.'9

'. ', ",7.,

,..+

1' J

• • • na.m..'

{.%~....._

,a,

• .,. 3 a g, w O, g a.w n +. L. a.

v g.4.

.r a. v -,- m.

'.'. n, w 4.a..-

s.

~~

u_

m

• l"., _v s a d,, w y-

+w eweq

,m.

L, c,. -.a. r 4

.e.

wa 1 q.

.,,~,O,,

• 4, a,

3..

7. p

,ea.

..W. C-

.C,,.6.,,

m.. 4..

n.,,.

m,.,.

r3, s,,..,,A.

. L. 3

,,,,.,..,.4 e....,.,

• J..m,.-~n

.-p C%

3a e

-.==.4

..~,7-w"4.e.

...3=.- -.t

._.2.,4g..

.s

..., J.*

W a

3

...m*

3,w

...N.;;

ea[

w a

.b.

7...N..

w Nw f

9,

D i

m

.

• 4 3

U, Vs*

)

f f\\g h

u-,',,y /

-544 I

34s e.

e

.a

,-.e

%p.,h.

)

,' y

• d Q,,') d; f. j q

n () l;

< - ~

O l b,,)

er

"..W. a., a C. C.u..w.,.. r

o. b.. J.

m e

a.

-,ea.

y:

ww-

.O f - : - - a.m m a r w e p r..n-m -- m, m.ma 3 v. L. e. ? ? -=,

- -. s u..-..-

w......

.....,.-m C ra r*

• 3.*. m. '.m wa,*

-. n.. c....

r - o f,- a - -*r

• ^FV.

f".n'.'.S.T '.m

• V". 4' T".W" A 'U' '.v' ".,

r,U w vb r i.L p e 4. 4.o..s u.a 4 b.e ". "..C

• m o A....e..d

.' O C.:'.o, ' O. 7 0.' r...e. u.e o# -..d i "i d" ' ' s o

.n, d 4, s. 4 C n O.c.

I.. A 4,7. t... a 1 S in peSs,.4n.--w.a?

n'. eas, a A.

.~ e ~r,L~ - ~,

4 u

n

~

.w ww u p~,4 4,5 4.. g u.,.n.aa C.

c C e n y a ~. 4 C.a.1 e

.r.." C 5 '. " e " ( ~C c " *.

10 'i,. ) o*

e

~e-r y

w wa w

w.4 6 k. p "s.".u."

R. ". a ~.." '.i."s y

C w^....o..~. ". S C n t..".n C'

a " ". '.* e ".- C '.- ". O '. "..". e '. ir'. * ".. *.. C r'.d

.=. " C Cw*~......,~**.

" ~..

-';, w =. 4. 1 3 r

( s*o.*.,

1 C. I o' ).

U.n 4.

3

.n

.u.

r C w-.... -... a" 'v ".0"C Ca

'.I.O.C ' u-

", e.a. i c '.:a -.4."-.4.o ",.

's"-.' e

.W.-. '. ~i.. =:.".c -

C-

.s

,,.a 4 6 4 m.. ag

2...o..

.O, n.,

3...

3 - m. a m

-...9.""..".)

v' t.' ". o 9p.'

w, h,...

.* t *s )

..v w

w

,a., a e w t., -

a..

m. u,.a.~ 4 n e.n 4.4...C..

. e n A

u. o n...o..a

.e,c-4.C.

.e,..,. e,-. 4 e_:,,4 a a,-

4,

...a oe C.-

s

~

.,--w..

.~r

--.4 n.

o*e, 4c. ct.,.4de.e,.. c.. n.o e.,Cdv a.".c' i.

.e.u c 4 n

a--w

~

G v..a d e.v.~ o s "w. e c #

1 2

e R1d 4 '

• 4 ^ n Wo.*..e.* s " (CC* ^be-2, 10~ia),- wi *..h A~"".u-R.

• a... '.i.".

e u..,. e..

e.,., -., 3.

.o,, 1 u..

.w..

--.....4-_4,,.

e,,

.o.a.e

4.,_ n._.,, n.

. 4.,.,

..-m.....

r aa u..,.,.. g,.

c.,,.

1".1.,.,.-.4,...

.,., A u.w. o m_,2,,.4..

r.i e...,,...

c,. u,. 4.-

(r..

a.i t - aw u.

f 1,. 0 / 3 ),.

.l.4. b. r.w

u.,,,.

.O. e m,...m7.,..,.

y.

• 4

b. n ?.,. 4. - s

. ~m.., 1.

3..w =.,. s 4

.. ; a C

.C., h,

e... o....

...-m.e.

.O,. 'm.1. w-

• , n. ;

~

o...,

..w.

.U. 2., s 4.. y,.a g..

O. 1,, i..i. m. _4

%. o.

'."w,..e.,%,-4.... " 1 s... c.. 3 g'",o a.

7*

.. i u..

-w wp

-, / "r J,.

'd.4*..*,. r.,. W...

.O.

m. u, 7o

's 4

w

.A La,',.3

=

.cw

.s.

a.

w..-.

.. ~.

If.9,

/*

4.

4 p... a

p. J.

b. o

• • ,4 b y C=

--3..I-

• "'n.O*,"**.**

v w.

3.

e.)

gy..,c.4m 9

4 e

w-

-v 42 w

.. ~...

w..

w..

I.O. q J-_.,4...

-.= <9

. w J e S

.w.

.!.'fm 4e.Ia,.,f y j, e.

(S O*

fH 3,,.

7Q jj..,.

-a

.w

.i.

v

..i

7. 4..%.

e,..%., -

m,..y.1 4-a

.s.

't - %. n.

.S. w.

D, =. 4 a.1 a.

.?3 ;.a.. e.

a' e. 4 a. 4.

m

• • • C.*.?.

u Oa i w

. ~ - -

3.:

v w.

s,.

..%. n C.,v,. 3.n

'....' a.

• • ,. e m..%.

..).4w e

,. w

.;,.w

( '. %,,, y...%., 3..w.

' C, - * \\

m e.

!/ p

.4.

g

.s.

a..

s O

8*9 or.==

1 4

..y.,,-..e D. a...

4 -.... =. A

2. ~, A.i

.4.-..

2,, w-

, e i..,,.

.c

.,,, A e.

n

~ u. y,.

e..~.'.

m

,u m

m

.w

.~..

4o

• e.,%...4.,

a 4

.-J. p.. t 3.

..a.p

• • ..4.,,=.3...-

O.

-. n,

4 m..-

.7.....;

• ,n m

43 i..

.w

.w

.w w

y.

A "."*.%. a

..,.._4,a

."."..p... {..

4.e, 4,.. '..,,..g..,,

"' g.J3,.%.. 3

.. 3 q -..,. a...q

.4

... 2 C ~..

4 - (.1.....' ', -., '. ) -

.r..."..'."..

4 p,,4.,*4m

.O.-a 4,

A-J-,

U.,.%

Q,w..-..4,*

3e S

n.,.,..

, u. 3 7 _,:

C 7,,.. _...

n Oe

...)m.

.y#

.. 9

-,3 9 [..

.., e Q S..-s.I.

]-..

.,.a

....,,g,,.

.,.pb 9.

-].

w-w gg g,,

y 8

. " -... ^, ~.".~ O

~".I

-..s C.

O.'"..'.".'A,_a' D.,.a.=.4,"_~.

.'..A

^"3." '.'."._s-3 w.

'.*e.

O,.J -*

( **., b. 1 *

.T..

.... *..-..e

.---.3"-

s e

..,"",.)

,n..

,g

.,j,,

g,,,,,,

-~

.J......-...

r\\

e.

l-

/

\\

s I

N h

f

.P

m. w.m...., a-

~ ~. % s, w,.,

D..k...J.

.)

_aJ4..n.

n.

y g g=n v=,._=.1...e.J q r.e m e.,.,

o,-A m m m. m s m.,sv ~.

prm,,

a.-

. e -.

.R. m.

.s

.e.

%.., s2

e.,a. a u-.' ". _' "..'a-_'

D.'aeo s ' _ C..' ". "_ _ 4 ',

..y'"

_.T,,.

.'M c i a a-Wa s a,

• c.v.u c.h.,

n.'a c 4 c c.., w

.'..'.u..w."- - :

n.....i i.n.,

Mav 1, 1975

'..c " 4 - v.,

N,b..'~ab.'".a".,

C u...' ~.- i '

G-a

Tc e *- 4..c nv.

m'*-

t.b.e W i.".d a ca.' e A

3

_4. a.4.,.,

.e e - _n..

e.. 12, 19*i7.

w

_ w r

=. c.. n_

,,,- u...,,.-

4 c e.

v. - a a_ n -,., A.-

n,- _ _. _Jn_

_4 n,., =. n e 4.. -.,

v..L,-._,,,-

.m

.w.

-_c-a.

o-4,

."._.,-..,_..,.,ae

..w. o. e._,L.,.,.,,.- z coAo, w *. _-.,. c., e s i,

i r

-o-~~~--

---

*6

.rran?. von Hic..cel, Robert H. Willians ( enbers of the L'23R Re*7i3W

---. 4.- C.....

..oM,(n'y-

.' C 7 '.

c

,n

.. a =,a.. "., C.. c.

' e~=, '... " -. ' '. J.

'-u""- ".a-

_4-w

...m

r. v.,y,

.r..e.... z..

a - --

y. n... (.u.,.

w.

1,

.t o, e- ).

e.,

_w

' he Breeder Reactci : A Poor Euy: Costs Cutweigh Senefits for the Liquid Metal Fast E.

eder Reactor (LIE 33) as a New ne-cy Source,

'. 7s~).

. d. e'._-.".'..- D.

"w'....'.4".,

( v~ u..a.,

U. 4.

". J.

GL'S/a

- y -.1 c a *- 5 y

.s 2.n,a.e.a4

.a D n a A m.e.. 1 n.n. : c..,.,.

• A. n

'.,1. 4 ~ ) 1_, e n A T. a A - - m * =.-. c - - y

+w

--n.

sA..... -

.,... y _i _4..

c.

4,. 4 u. 4 G a-r.u s,.

.w.,

1. q I a ).. a.

w

v...

_w, mye w...

q-3..

s ---

n.

-y.wc-o..

.A 2._-..u...--

p,..,.,~4...,.

.c o -.n 1 e.

m.s. 3 r p. n. J., -

.._4 w -. (*.

- _3 u...

... ~.

w.

.. _ ~.

-7 t'c.1

. ' ".. '.. '.?. v.

O,,

r\\.

m,.. y.1 4., '..w. a 2,, _* _* n u. _4.,, #.

. a. n 3.

-... 4.- cC _4_3__4__,.,

J

( *...I. 1 0 I 't ) e

..v s.

-. 4,m w....

.?s p.n,.,.

g.n.

u. a_ '.'. _4.q.. a g _J G. 1,..=,. _4.=.

.~7 3. c.. m _7 F.*.w. n 3 _*

.=.m..--...

", g g 4 f

7

-7,

( c > -,...i..,.': ').

..'..7_'_d..

.') y -..".

.A

.e."..".-.

G u =..". e'a G'. -. s.

.i-.-"...-

a-ty

.\\

s. a r -.e

• v.ia -

.........s r * *.*s. L

-9

. a,.,

3-,.

w

.._-.3-,

.s J3

,E w

4 7""-,

• .--_..mw.

'.*.w.j,~

.C.

,. a.

"..w.*=n=*=w

...w.

• m.m. - - * * * *

• *. m.*. 3 3 we

• 'a.=,.e,.

O e.

.d

.ew-y..e a..- 4Lw...

r...,.. _'.,...4*...

s w.. a.,

w..

.%a.. n

2. L..-..

..e.....,.3 n.s i.,.w,.,

4...

s.a-

=..

m, a,., J

/*.,q.,..,,,3,

- y L.w..,

(.* f.,.

m.a.

7_"_'""", \\

Ce 3

%2

.s s.

.r..._.,-..n,-

-.. ~,--

.~

.u..--

_-=,...,

c..

w,

~-

2..

...,a 3, a_..a.

r..

_A_

_ a., _' c_, 2. ).

w

.,q.... _....._,

" ', E 7 C r ~. 2., ~- -.,,?.. e.:. _.. -., t e..n _ 4.

-%..,._4_-.-_n_...,-._

... ~,....

.c.,.2..._,.

C..

._de--

7 " a _'.,

t' G '. c.". ^ 1, "

.T,_ _= _" _

+

^ "

(t

_1 3,,*i,- '. _ ".. ". a.".

a

~

-r....

-.. a.

2...-

,.... _4.

%.. o - :..

,..a.

...a

-, w

-w r.._,-.-...a...,

o.,.....

.r,,-~--.

...n-

_-u. A a.

r. - -

. a 2.,'.,.~,w.,

m..

9 u

aa',

v-..m

. o.

., ;. - n. s.,.,.,.,. e b, u.

e -,, w.. f

• • t"-.1.p p a ' a C h i "..-

-,. -gg y7.

u-...-

4...

w. 3 p e..*

./.,wn.,.m.

9.

a. a

• A 4

Qpn p

.s

~

- J. -..,

..O d g

'****-ie-

?

4

,.=,J

= =..

- ~ - -

..,.,A w..

• ? d%a Q S A.T5

_4,,,,

F.w..S S

w-a-

~,* * * - - ~ ~ - -

.w.

U a <*.*5----- -** * ** V a c A e.

2

-,-a

u. a

_4e

.C., _4 e.,,., g

• • ,..

• q _4m.

g.4 a

4 -,.

P - - - w"a" 2Me m3a-J,%

w S,,

• • ,,.,,.,,,..,,,,.3,,

_4.,,

L,.,g.,.d.,.,.._,4,,,,,,,

.,a.4 5.,,.w.

4 y 1* *.

e,,

-C,

%--u..

7

...t 7.'9.. _.....Q**=..,.I

-,g3n,,.,,.,,

Qf._ m a, a,,, ;,= *,

=b

.4 w ads.

\\.

~,,a

'U g

b, On 1 */

- E r

t

< si f)

r.".b.-.,..,

.O,.

f. _-, u.

a. p

t..b.. '.'./.

a a

.ccce s ;.n

• *...s u. o

.t ; -. -.

.o,--

, e C.,

.a

,4-_...-A..,,

c..- -... t.

r 4.,., ?

O

-4

+c-*

~rv--

s

,-,9

.c t.. i _..........

.- n.

-. c, '

,r,

o..

.,-,u.,

p. =.,u.'.,

I'..'"."--..s.u..."; C ^..",a ".

".,n. ". a ' c. :...n...o-C-.....'..""-.".<.'."...a...'-'c..

~'

r..- - v'. -,

C.'._'_'#-.-._'.'.,

C-.....'.-.",

.o

m..

Evidence for Prcdu.c.tica of the M* (1400) a n d * (1400) in the Reacticn C. o (n)->c.on iT (n) at 2.8 GeV/c with T.C.

Bacon, F.M.

Bense, r

~ u' '- e.. o-7' 43 (1 0 o' 4 ).

m,.. a e -.. o_. o,

c.".v. s. e v.

7

+w n

C c.'..e'a. d e c.'1 o# 7so"a* P-c'"c'-4 c ". 4.a. "p a.d S.

7.". *. a ' c '- 4 0.s a'-

e e

2.8 GeV/,c., with T.C.

Bacon, F.M.

Ecsse, and others, Phys. Rev.

(, o. 0 / J.

A-O_.,3,.o 3,

. a..,

...S.

a.a.d o.".. D. D M e r o."..'. "."' ^a "...':.

Soft X-F.av Irradiatiens of Acetvlene Methylacetylene, and Ethvi-acetylene in tne Gas Phase witn anc wi-hcut Aca;.xtures of Ncole Gases.

M.5 Thesis (unpublished), Vanderbilt University (1965).

- a m ' ' _-

o. -

d"

-d n

4-4-

.. 4 _,

o -.

n.a u a_ -..

. a..e--_4

..o-

=-

e

)

E I.2 I,7 / m..

J-3, o,,.., 4----.

4,

( u u. _s

u.._ a ),

27.,... a, :, 4 3..

,,4..,

w

...3.

(

.2-3, 1 o

-u_

._.u_o

N'

%q

/v s.3

..\\,.,. :...

.J q

C-u 9

--i J L; y 2 m2 6; a

,j w. r_ -.

c.-~-s d.

n W.&..

s3,

N.

DY

._s.je t s u > g, : d V<

s

- ~. m.vo wr -

~.e., Lm.r.

m.-

D

.a..r..o. r nRI.er er v

I have been trained in both physics and econcmics.

I received two years of college physics and advanced mathematics training at Franklin & Marshall College in Lancaster, Pennsylvania during 1971-72 instead of attending my last two years of high school.

I was allowed to attend college instead of high school by the Lancaster City School board by virtue of independent study and exceptional academic performance;bv ac.e 15 I had cassed into collec.e-level science.

I entered Harvard College in 1972 and studied physics nd 'nathematics until the scrinc. of 1974 At that time, I 4

vent on a 1 eave or. acsence :or tn.e.vear or

.3q.,/4 Durinc. m v. leave I worked for the Honorable Birch Bav.h, United States Senator from Indiana.

Durinc. m v. stav with Senator Bayh, I corresponded on his behalf with key con-stituents, business leaders, financial supporters, and other Senators and Congressmen in matters relatinc. to enerc.y issues.

Further, I perscnally wrote, or assisted in writing,.

~

ten statements delivered on the Senate floor on enera.v. and other 'ublic policy issues.

Finally, I did basic research e

fundamental to the Senator's voting on key technical and economic issues in energy legislaticn.

I returned to Harvard College in 1975 and studied e c -.c.. 4 s

1. .o.

"e=.

a.~d a

k.. ' l.#.

D "..4.. c,

• ".4-

• 4. ~c,

7 a -..

o v.. v v.1 e,w ed..,

n-P.G,.aessC a-

.J m

.w...a. da

.,.u.

A.....

n.,1.,a., _ e s a.

s.,. a.4 u..

v

" i

- i

^ l

^#

b' c".. c- -. Pu.4-o. n ' 4 ";

.'L._ n s..- '.. v~..

a..d-

"..". e. ~o "..r. o d."f C

v..

-_"'*.o.

l. o v a l c #.# ". -o m#

"m V, s.

d e ". 4 ~.4 - * ~. '.k.i. c. a *.

"...a

~ ".

a w..

~

7 C w^ ". " s e s C ".

3

~

Le e m

.c... a mm. a.;

4 ui)h d

~>%.%

A N.r. g 5. <, a " e.k.

0A

-0 nme e

1 4

. k. a U.b

~.be w.e.

m

. n U

k. W

.w w

4W.

s W

.w

.v s.

daA 3

.a

. e e.v ~ a.. m y.- e.

T*3.4 a.w

..k.. g m a.

. -. a.em.

~

m..m...a v.

g e. m v. Q.m.. 4 r=

2,..

m.

o.

o

- *. c.e. s.a. d he.

.gp e. 2..-.-

4.e.

h. a

.En d g.w.1 1

. M yvsw e,

• 2.w.=..~.~c a..

[ ' 3 o* c*

aq a m e.n..a. m... m. a-of v.

o

-m

--v

..o....h e,.

4.

.., 1ds. O c.. 2.z. a.

u...,.r..,,.A.,

.WdO P.-

3 4

v g

w w

w w

1. . w w.

).

..O

. v.'

N

.%. [w.... N b.

..MN..

D, M....N. w]..W O.-'..

N 9

Y j

O w

O w

w w

w

-.*.OI)w..Y Q.Yu] w.

9 d

-w a.

"e C.",e.' ' s'."-.~. o ' ~ '

... d.

d a..'.4.c '. m-.-'.k.."*."

d s w* C.' '.'

v ".o.i c. o

~.v w.

.%'

• a..m..n. 4 6

.%.w.w =..v.i.

3 c % w 4..,;.

m., _J

. O,. -

.J m.w 1a..J + -.

U.. m.j w w,

• a.

..n.

a..h. a.

T

.y..

w A

. ~.

si.E

'.3 * ~

..G.e.. h. D 7h a

.E.4. r).

m. 4.m. a.

a m

• h. *" a. a.

,j

.=

m w

- * ~.. m c-

,a

• g.7.v-s r

m

= A.4.. ~,

. a.

.wg

.sa. 4 4 2 7 e 33.

T~

..., 4 a 1.-. 4 c;.

w,

.v.

.. ~

w

• o C w...mm.-=..

'a A..

C-

.. h.

J -,

L.

• ..'v.2"*..".'.c'7.**.*.s

,' a,..-2

r.. ". C - w* g';

e w.

v-yw 7

13.*

,,, C 2 m L 'fm.6 Wa * * -.. -.-

C d cQ.

.T.

Yo5

.a J

L w

w f*

Ac m.-

v

. n.:

- kk

?v p 6

I.' ) ()

-V iL,,,

Iv tG.

. freelance writing project to produce a bcck on nuclear

'...M a - -.k.

o."

.T o / c 7 - o s.' ".i n d "a"v-o

.".a.

t '...-. ' d-wea76.7 s.

1 u-

~

w States Senate Subcommittee chaired by Senator Jchn Glenn on the results of the book project:

a 400-page manuscript describing in unprecedented detail the design and con-struction of over 50 atomic and thermonuclear explosives.

United States government weapons experts testified at the hearings and praised my book for its extraordinary thorough-ness and credibilitv..

In early May of 1978 I traveled to the Los Alamos Scientific Laboratory, where I conducted research at the National Security and Resources Study Center that once again gained international recognition in nuclear weapons studies.

In early June of 19 73 I was informed by the Department of Energy that my book on nuclear weapons was classified

" Secret Restricted Data" and that my kncwledge of nuclear weapons design was such that anything I might ever say or write on the subject, including any calculational or other notes, is to be considered " Secret Restricted Data" until c.1 eare-sy a c.1assification review.

I was issued on orrice a

at the 20 Massachusetts Avenue, Department of Energy building that contained two safe-like file cabinets kept unde r armed guard.

I was informed by the government that this office was being made available (free of charge) to me for my use so that I would have a safe and secure office in which to continue my work on nuclear weapons and national security issues.

In September of 1979 I began work as a consultant to the Natural Rescurces Defense Council under centrac: to the Department of Enercv. in a croiect s t u d.v i n c. nuclear s

waste disc.osal.

This cro4;ect, ccc.e:her with m.-

earlier interactions with tcp Department of Energy decision-makers, gave me insight into tha decision-making and pla.rning

~ ~- n n a s e s-

.d.e..u..e,

.u.e ne u,-

..en v:.=.a--..

n.

--- o o

r u.

r..'..,.1 1 ;, A - 4.. c,

.u. - ; -" 13 3. ". u, s -

a7-...

-N. o we a '.s

-a

--c

-., e,

- - -.r a : -

.,a n a,,

s..- v -..

ynn ;

na u,as 2---

~.u. a.~..a--..

ce-- -.'

s e.-

w-a_-

w---e as v...o u.i..

a rw e -

-a

- A a:a,ae n:

~,~,-4e-4

-,,-ac A-.o

-a

- -v

-o s-

--i-T h e AC L'v' retained me as dn independent expert en nuclear Weapcas.

. -- r

,1 0 l.

8

' t fj "

I l~

l

.m

...m.-

.,_a 0.-

.=.a.--.. 0-n-*.~

w -

~~' '

y--

.2..3

• _~. q.3

,,a--

._--....m.

.,.,o-

.u. -.. : - -

%, 2 b.

. =

o.

---

e.

T a,. '.. n e.q s a i c e k.e.. e~,,

m

--ei

._.s.

How.any asse:.blies in a full core?

u.c v. ~.. " -. ". c'ra c.# ~ "2

.i.. s, e.. +

1. ue '.

c o ' '.)

e Ecw.T.uch space filled at present?

N. P.o.n i s.n e.v.'. d 4 -.'..'..-,e '.

a-

.M. r..y

..e._,.

..da-g,.1 1-

%g 44

~- b,.*., e d.. a.v.

7 c,..r.., n---.r (g *

.g.b. s n *,,,n

} ".)

w i7e S

'..d p., e-3*a 3,,*,,-a g.y e,. a.4Cn D.I'."c.

.y-.

'.,.'.b.,-

.-s t, A.J { 4.

,7 I.-

e C a.4 A 4-g n W 4

• b.

e e e c 4-

• 0 7".'.

~, ' !'J.#l # ~ ~;' '.

n y

~~

a c7

..1--

,,-4i

-,, a 4 -

-C O..n

... a 3.r r.

,",4

',b'a0

--..C v--.

a -,----- -.

3

• ,, -.. -.a

';.3

.,4 3

y

.3 g

s*

J

.4

.a a

.a, en,

's, f.7p -

sY,----;

2.,.

.. a

• 1

%D%.

9

.me

-m.

bt T.MM' --..s i

=;,-

7 9 O) '4 j 'j a r.i 1 / I

,