ML19241B974

Deposition in Form of Affidavit Re Storage Capacity, trans-shipment Schedule,Fuel Assembly Discharge & Other Related Matters

ML19241B974
Person / Time
Site:	07002623
Issue date:	05/25/1979
From:	Tamplin A National Resources Defense Council
To:
Shared Package
ML19241B972	List: ML19241B971 ML19241B973 ML19241B974 ML19241B975 ML19241B976 ML19241B978 ML19241B980
References
NUDOCS 7907250485
Download: ML19241B974 (8)

Text

t

.m.~

e p.,... -

vn.

v.s.. - m es..L Q..~. 6 = v2 c'

'.L.~

%.A U

C -...- - - -,...

,, n....,. :,.,.: c...., - c

.,a.

... = = - -..

c m Oc

-w,

)

DCF," PCWER COMPA';Y

)Ckt. Mc. 70-2623

)

(Amendment to Operating License S::M-1773

)

for Cconee Spent "uel Transportation and

)

Storage at McGuire Nuclear Station)

)

~. \\ \\ fDr j /.*1 y*

^

m

,,g....

,w pm JC

.~..'....v.%

y-.

- - - -. ve-m.

/

a " '.. w a. e,

C.

..J.

S

,V

.M :

- w 2*. J -

's.

.3 a...

L

,.., - ) :.

JU.,

"~

3-c.

g,,s t

',la o ". 4.. g. n

)

C.i

• c #

-j

. - - ~

5 s'

)

SS:

.N

)

1 a -.. 4 r.-- c.e C o 7,,.m c.

w,

De

.~,.Ms

",f

~

%/

ilM wo ;,,. : :

.2 -

a.,*,.

-.q,--,

o..

m.,... _- 1 4..,

o..u.. m. r u

--..g T

-r dc harehy depose and say.

/

Ch czo 485 I4l

i w,e

.e.- 3 s u e.... i a'

.~.4. a'.i'. '"

"'a'

.-.c

. 3 n.,,.

a_

c r..f g_ _-

., -,. y e.. - e.

.s

.4 a

.-,~a

_4..eg..

a c,,.,a-._.,-__4,,.

c_,

r.e..-.e..

r :

2...

- _ = _

.2 2

. o...

m e

a

,,s W.41.,

u.,e C

na--..,

ag u,.. a 1 _4,,o..a c-A 4,

u. u, a se 4es. o.c w -,,_

- _ w on a timelv. basis.

This carries with it the assumption that estimates of the future electrical demand in their service area is correct.

Such estimates involve significant uncertainties for u, c. o_ _-k _4.. s t.,.. _4._ s.

u. a_ m.,. o_

..t. a o 2

- c

.c e - -- _'.a.v, a n c G.7 e, '..".

"v #_

". '.. ', ' (..

9) state a _" _# ' d.= s.4 ',

I n *-.". a _i _-

-4 t

1

u. a_

u -

m -

v.,.. o_,.

_4 -

e.., -.i.. 3 s c..ect _, e c s

,,,a ce c, r, v _i _..

uuicea

.va a

.s. a v capable of storin~ spent fuel generated by Duke's system until w

1995.

They present the followin schedule to support their C,,.

On

_4c...

<~,..... a. c.; ; ;

e r, e. e,,. ( p 1.1... a.. ).

Ca.a a

~

n a.

s..

C 6 :.,. i. m n.

U

o. r. s. + 4. r.

C..,3c3 t'.3

4. *..,

^

.u v.

..u Q C m e. c a w.

(f a j. ]

.s r. A. ?

• /.7 s/ */ -

7..'.; c.,

(' *e. 9 \\

O ea vj Le ;a +. 7 10,/9*

g-,

r 6

6 we w

'Ic Gui re t f.n. 4. *- 1 ts.. / e n

(.: v s,ami V

v / ou

{ps*.

Q d / O..^

...O.

E i

'...,r,,3 I'r;*

1 q,,i ; s

/=.*3 V

-i m.

\\,l 4

v s+ w

.j t., 4 t

Ua s w U I,f ; 4 l

. v; )j C '-..= r. s~ '.,- a a.

br n.

pt

i..,

e-+.

• a V i/ 00 (Or;j t

• p' 4.- =

gkl l}

QQ: :

f--

f...s a

t r.e

.?

0:~-., ::

\\c.

.f I

w a 6. s e

r 9 P!.

"5 l'a j.

• g ],/.

( ;....;;j l'*;..

^~r~,'.

.{...,33j Uet.

4 U r. i " 2 01/92

< : : c. t s..,

t (c u / c

.ra t

't S

..e

.3 1. c b.o A--

..w., a-

.r., L. '.. a..-

.o m,a e -,. t - a c.

4.., a s c..

u.t:-

4,

c:. c-

..,..e..

s

.v a

a--.

s

.- - -.,. ~ _4 n

,3.. m_

.., ' 4a v a a c,.s,

m.2

.,2..

a___

o m.

s

....a I.

4s,

's ae

.i..d4

=-=d c, - _,,

w

.co-.

... e..

a very optimistic to assume that the waste s:crage problem will be resolved bv. 1995.

Moreover, this ambiticus c.lan of Cule Pcwer involves the assumptions tnat their electrical power demands are correct and that the facilities will be ccnstructed and licensed

.' t c.- a ~ a,

-.w..; a-

-a 494-=s c..

.. '. = -c..

w ad--

~ 4..o e.". c +-, ' a -

av a.

all subsecuent cransshipment (a series of licensing actions) are a.' ' -'a'a d r.'.'.". a

+s' 4".'.a2 1 ']

b " a'.i ~.

a 3c.,

.m_i.c, *c a Du'.>.a. c w e _-. e.. _ a.d '.., - ". a #

.7 _' c a"..

s

"~a i

o

_v proposed transshipment schedule through 19 91, assuming the Oconee rcrack is ccmpleted on schedule:--1/

Summ.2 ry o t~ P roj r :.c.! C.;s c:ti c F1.r T r:ns f e r.s

_ _ - - _ _. Minimu a :n !!c0 aire, Rar ck 1,2 C......,_

. c.: r Cconce-M:Cuire 1 Cc e n c e-Ca :: a b.t - '.._

=

McCaire-Cc :a IF3 0.

...0

...w

.0

.- 0

-0 c,

so 1"i

'56 20 0 ~

taa

• 0 1 :ao 0

9 :.,,

0 0

t,..

y,

.gj.

..Q i 32-

.g 1;

3 r, a f.

.p

-.,.7,'3

.J.

t: -

n

,c

1.,v 3:

U s

t U

is

^

.~...... -

.. y

.w.

,9 n

3--

s..

[gSg

'O

- - - - ~ - ' ' "

- - -_.--'I.

~

- - - 0

-: r_

O

... 0 Mpw wJ,,

j4

'fs

.gnqa, k *I 1

,4 q '

• tir.

j,

4.**

..y w.

. ~..

...,,.,b_...+.*

• 4.-

.}

awa v.e-

-a u u

.. ')

4m".

I4'p 0

,. /

'J _, c. o ~,

3.

C

J

.%,,. :oo. 4

-.,, n-y 4

t s.

1 e....,-

3.,. -,, g a.,,,...' 4.,

a,-..

. a.. t..2 u...

y

..a. _. -

.,..y,.-...a_....

a C.a.O_ A,,13 a.i 1

.., 4

,,, -- (, e.

,u

.a.n 7 o,. _-

.a a... aa 7

,,.. ;. a.

.,,. o. a. 3.

..u..,

4

.oc.

a,.4-.-

(i m.

.--)

m.

w.i.'.1

.-e su.i.- e t.~ a.. s a- "..i r..e.n ~..i.n 2'. 9 9.7 "n".e.- a_

.i s l.i...' a.

.- a_ a s e n

.c assume that Duke Power's seent fuel storage proble.m will be resolved by this time.

At the sc me time, this propcsed trans-shipment schedule is predicated upon the construction and licen-c.4

~ c '. '..k. o C..t *. ' u ) a - e ' -..

b,";

- ' S.'

...d

'./OJ'.

~

.y

~

//s Allcwing this optimism on the eart of Cu%e PCwer relative a

e u3.,w <, s '..'.,

4..i s ".k.a -. -. a.. x.=. ' -"; '. o '.'.' ~ e

.". '...".a'-

a

~.

r 2ec.,,,no-

,- a.,,. 4.. e. c. w,= n e a d." c.

m'..c' ". e c....' a *. 4..

a.."

licensing of the Cherckee station unit will be completed prior to 1 C. C..'..

nu "- _. e.n '...i s '..i c.u.v. ass"..

• 4 c.. d c a_ s

.c *. k,"";

".. a.m. '.."-b..

a" I "%.i s "..' a '.-

w".'

."ue'

<-" c _' a_ w '..' '. e u3e4- ~;

hu ns u.'.- s D

. C'.ie"*

L'"*"a a,

.'4 Co '.4

• a C.-

C ' *.' b'",.'.

U.C '.*' a ". a

""a au

- ~

usa. o#

-. ' '..' v ~ ".. ~..h

.'" a. # ' ' a.7 4.. '* 'v-'.a.

W.'.'.1 U

...Vc.' *le a.* ~o '.1.I a.-

~

' ' a ' " ';'

u

--1 4.:

c..o a c.h., - a.

re.. L. a.

- n.-

.2 e O.

.w

.1 7,.,v. 4., g 3..,. ;. 5.. :..

2 n.a..

~

.v

...a v

~

y xe

=..".a.'.'

u,, a,

"..".a s e a s *..'.~..

a. e "j. -..', A.i.=,v- ".... - o

..m aa.. ~ ~ ~ - ""e w

o

- <~

7 w.-

va.~s 3 m m., a, e 4,. -.

~

-w

.w..a.

• ?p 3 v.. --...

$J. 4

.. i

.b.,. o

=

C C *n*."9 A O

..ew J

.Y--

.3...~..

O 4,f.. r*.,,.4.w..3

.v a 7

.v. o. w,,.a=w.-

t u

-aae b*

4 3

..u

.. L.2 j 7

,e "T J w.

e O

14 m

c.:

L-- -O 3 8.

e', 9.* -a

. J 3 e a 6y

%.,.) _4

)

3,m,/;

y eg w.b. 3. v e.e.M f 3

.N

)

.%8O.$,w.

. %E n.

w

- a.R**.99.,.]. w.9.3,/.. % D

.w

.J 3

].

2 w

..m j

.C a.

(. 4

....3

v. p 3 g ~ a'm.

• ^

u, b.

h]

J' q q g... b.' _i a ; j t. =.=

_1 O,, uO O*

t)e g -

l, q' a

%...._., e.,.,m.._. o_.

m,

m. x..,. wc -.. c....". a_ ^"a~=--".'.."~...

... -.i a 2 a_

-_2

..... a.

-m w2.,,,....

.: 4.e.

.,c-

__ m_ - - a.w.,..., <.,.:....

v._

a C.".'."~-.a.

u'

- ' '. ' = -.

'..a.

..'--a

1. .". -'-..a, C.".-'.'~^ h.. o 3~

and Perkins were chosen as the mean between the Cconee and McGuire a*ac.

rc.- *.".a

c. u.-" c.c.e s b.e -a.

..".e s e

a. s *. 4 ~...'

• a s a'..c u l d "e ado _,ua'a.

c a

In 1992 shipment from Cconee, McGuire and Cacawba to Cherokee w.,.7.,

w 4--

' ". e s w.'ca

.e

--gu..-ad.

".'.".a.

.# c.'.l - w.i. c,

..' ~ u o u'.. v..

'w.

u.. _ -a

.o-v C,,;

_4-u C.w.o..m...n.o s.

ym-e.

C.". :_2 _- C.. a o_

D.'.e. c.". "..

a_

P....'...e.a~."..'...^.a..

I.

7 CCmsneo.

\\t.e/a",u,_4 o_

M. u. *,.. h,e. - c.

s w

a s O Q' OU 1G3 e^

1 0, 8 "/

60 13hh OV DV

.s ep

-n r*

1 0 _0 0 60 0" 0 1Ga.V Ov OV OV s

en en en s

.I O O..*

ou 43 60 f*

e s 1 h,,

OV UV D0 V

)

s

..v m

.7f-0V CV OO 3U

3...J O

,4,,

-e

,. n

-*Sw-e

• I Q J ed

• W i

a

,e g

.w gJ d

.d W

W m

.m.,.

.",b.

.,f a_

(*, n...w_.

".'. S ** 3 w;

m '.

. s..

.O ". e., m m,.

.. g.: 3--

.' O '. ]

w Q o m.. 1..i.._n

^

,?,,.

.w

.e

• q E. e g...

8., h E,,

.g w a.. ps.h.*.a.

..e9. 7.. w. S.pg.aa..9 y, m... e.,,.

e_. m g eh

1. 9',

y

.,,, e ', e. 3 7 a

a

.a

-_m w.m M.,..,...,3

• c 9 tu*

A sm.* g. 3 7.

w.9..,..

7,...a.,d-

1. %y M,., p

(*y,.,,,

4,,,,..

_f,,_ ;,;,,,. y,n,,,,,,;_

3, p.

w 4,,

3 p

-..u v.

wy

..,.g ai., p.m _.:n, _ 3_

., e..n o pa.

a.

u.

O n e'.'**..==8

,J.

=

• ; e,*a.s u.Wp

,.a..*..a.;,,. 2..a.

_,,-.'. 3, 3,,7

.a.m s_

_ ~

• e.

w_

3

.eb s

. s yee

(.J

.%.").,

--%'.M seh p

a-3b-O'.

[

a -.qe.C g

.e....-

.d.t..

-t O

• 8%

N..a=4. ].mv.. f.

,.. W.9

..a.g

"'W Y'

e _

W'

a

..u. n.

a--

,_,,,, x.e.

.,s.

- 2

. e m.

.....a.

.s,...a

.-y-~

2,

. ;. s.. -.. ". - - -. -

..'..a.=.."..'_...a.

c

..m. e u.,.~,.,.:,

C,,.,..w, c.a. o

... a.

w u - -.

1-)

lo.o.,

60 1993 60 60 130 1994 60 60 60 150 140 180 180

, c. o. s-Ca

V, Oq,J

.sU e

.en

. 2. 3

.,. c.

s s 30u 180 120 300 280 300 5,0 c " a-1.c".---;e L

,-4.;-

W C, y

us,

m. m,,. 3 1 O y,.3. c. o P,anA r*

• 9,q

.la vv

..e '49. 7. 7... f

_i.

"..".e s o.="u.l a*4 -..a-s ". C w ~.". ' '.

",_.".a_

D u.'. o.

D.r.we m'.=w~'do

^ 7. c..

~

, q.4 a.'

a.'.I. C '.v'

1. .^.'* -.n'.#..*.*'..i..".".".

C.#.

C.". a'.

7CD.-

a'".". S'a*4 C ".

v".".'",

L. e m e,

.b.

7 0 0. *r

( y= w m,7.4 4 4..g

.3 1.1 h..h. a.i.w S a-....n

• 4 e n..c.:.

,s.w a m,.i. w a m. ',.

m..b. 4 e w

6 w.

. -q

• s u.

y..s.

~

-.v d=.o, 7 0. 9 *,.' a a.. o.-..- n....a.' ;- - - 4... _' a-v.4 - "..'o.

".-..". t:.e.e. v.1 " ~ 4.

-y f

b. a

c. m,3.. J e.9.s 1 C *4.;..m

• q 3.'

.s w m, b.

,.g==q Jy y,

,.s.

..e C w.. a 4 4. n..

.i. : = '.. '

'..".o

'....=-.- '.'...; n e.i...-.' e A-

-n-'4 g - - - -.. y~

ma 1s. ^1 A.,. 3... g.6.,.3 m.

,.e.

• C.**.*"*."

..C L,.i 4 ba

e. n e.,,..iweA

,.n. e.. p.

5,*'

s.

7 ~A g b

W

.=

v-.-

WS

..O

.O.g.

..S..._.M_

].M.

M. Q C Q_ S Y..-.;

..O.

Y.....

7,--..

.T...b a. 4.-

m,,

a m...*.*, r',*... o

..a -.

i 4 b.,

1.-y.?.,.=.,...

.A e

..-7-..

,2.M

'.=.b..,*-

a b. a 4

• • * "'** * +

v.J

-..,,..,.J..m..

M gb,,

4..

..h. g;.

,^,.,

3c.

Jm Aa-

.-, _i e,.w.

m wwa.

a.

,,,,.,,,.w..

$."4 W V b..

.D",e svb M.

.*M

.....M.

L..r9. % $..

].M..].

.. ". *. * * * = -

• w v -

..;.* *=

"' s

. 2

• ' r ' g a. -

e. n.s.i.%.

%. u,..a.

e. a.

K.,.,..J.* 4

,4 4.i 4

.s..'

.=

2, 3 '-.

.a

.a y.3 -..

y

.v

.s w..

D m.

,.a J..,

J.7.i 4 a d.

-.Y...a

..4.. 3 4.

.J L

- - = = = * *

-a 2-*-

m.

'.a Ja c-A ** " " * * *

• e,- --

w-

.-a N.-

,ne

,,,,..N.E s

N O,,,

,O,O,-,4,

,,,(,,9,w,E,r.

,$,,,,,,,,.,,6,. A M..

.,,,....-.... g

)

O

.s W

(

.==.w

%..;.a g

.A ps L,

,3 S'

.m gao a

,ao 3.

')

y-

.,,. h. n

..i..

n.e.

• A 3.**...

. m o 3.,,.

.,4 ay..--

,s y

wCUIse N e I.

C C C." i3." 3 d W b "..". ". $. ~*- /*

• O **----

~

• • • • • • ".M*V"...

• • -'"3^'*C'"

~

."31"***

s.

l{ bn

. G '*

l tO I)

.b a...' _' _' =_.,.

-_4 3

.". o m.._' ".

o " s ' c.".

'u,.--

_o ~.-=c,..a-

x., -

c.

_-m_ _,.

a.,.-_4.,..e..

4

_w -

c,c.,,-_ __ m,.e _4 a _,

-....nc,...n...

-..m

.a.

. e y

_4 4..A_

.., n

-.:.._. C

.ms e e.. a t,.

r--.<

-m cates that the cost of ISFSF would be $34,500 per rack location.

It is not clear here whether this cost means per assembly or not.

In the EIA for this procedure, the NRC presents an estimate of

• ) /

$9,000 cer assembly for an ISFSF.

The Dec. art.ent of Enerc.v.

7 /

d

/

( D,..r. )

.o. n e n... a 2.

as-4..a o o# a w...a.

c . 0, 0 0 0, e a c..c '....'..', ~. ~ I.. "-.". a SO,n.00/

1. 4 4 -,'" _a

., a-a"..,'- uae

.". a. ~v.r.

--p"-=

a-se~,n..".

c _

w-o. o..n.. _.

m. u.e 1 4 _c,

4..e

.cm e.,. a s a e m b.' 2" d.isc.".a-e

.# c. 0 c..e a w.d l.' he c

y some 4,500 assemblies (150 x 30).

After reracking of Cconee 1& 2, w,m

.q 4,, w

--n

w.,.n.

1.,00

.='~~~a.

T.".'a n-

. ad"4"i

.=.'.'

a'On-s e ~' ~- ' -

a a

w _, _.1, a.

L

--..,--.c,A,.

eb*

$70,'00'ay=

"."..'a-

.ic L.' d m,

v f

--f..c--..-

6 -...i.' '

-o--

en e

A

__1,-

m. u. 4 -

i

,--c,,

7s C _:

.w. a-e.a a.

s

. )

~.74-.

wc w4 e.s _- a e. c-..

C,.,....

-a a

C# -". " - %v - v.. ^ a

1. _ a w.'_'_4"'., a..u

.a C.1 ' 1 /' m; s..h. a-

~ a-A

~-

.c ".L~ ~ "_ _4..

". a t

v.

e c,, _4 ' _-.,., A...,

_a -..

,f o..,.

..s..

v

m..s.n.-..a..,

.'4 e,a L, a n,

u.. A.

w, -,.q k, -,,

av.

e a v.. ~a A,

n

-7.-..-a a-a..

__,I9}

1.?.

u... b 1. _i a..g

,-,n,.

. b. a 4.-

3

. - Jo.

_4... n.

'..".c4... - -. n. a*. S.. *- I " 1

.".2..' ".a

=

a n...o

.,s-4.,

2 _..,. c,

a a a

..~.3

2..-

c,,.._4 -

.y.

a.

.s

-4 ar--

a

, a ---

--,-a-

..c,.

.a

.,.,a-.

a v..c._

.e s

4

...,4..*_.

r-u.

- : -.4.

a

,,,3 23 O f *.^.e C a p i t2 -

C:.

o #.

~.".a-

/ - o. s c -.,.- e

-..A-

.a 7a.. e

.". a i-

- e.

m

-4 G..

.e.~,

v

.r.

C, v.D-_-

-~~,

..u.r.g..gpg-

.u-

]

3

-gi.

9

t. -..-.

-,g

-,,h,%y1

_g

~. -, -~~

3m s - c.. n -.' 3 / s,

= = = -. -

0 bt._,,

y

• t () 4[8 I) l'

1

.e

-. 4. c..

.#.. ^.=. v a.n.

C.#.i..."_'.".~. -.i.. -". a.

C C ^..c.s s

v.

.,-.m

.c r..m. > a c -...r _: _,

_w,_

m..u. m,

_4 - c.. _..

c, c,,,

n,.

v.m

-....o a

,,7 o.s.e.

m... o_ g-3,_,-

. c.a.,.. r a

_e r

..w.,_.

.=y

,. w _7 a_.a..,..

f e..,,-

a s ~. c " a c_ a-.# a c.4 1 4 6 4 e s.i.

w _i _i l w.a ~< e

• o t,.4 7 a addi" 4 ^"..a l see r.*-

1. " e l u

the near future.

The most prudent course would be to construct them new since the cost of additional stcrage would be only a s.

u. a,,. d r,.d. a e,C O.

s, u 4,.,

c,., A

.e,., C

_4 e, ce uw.e Cns c:

t 4

6-.

- - - 4. _4

.., 7 a.,.

,c_g

_ g _- m. e g...

C...' '; ??

C_

,4A cr,a a-s.e. *w

~ _4.,.

o.

w e

... a a

...a w

y

-2 w

s

.o...,,,.

., 4.,., c.

m..w. _4 -

3 - -, -.w...e t. 7 A :.. 4 :

w a

-ry we.. -

_.v 6w..n

,,,.,. -a.

n.

...o-

-.c

-,, - g7. a a.u. _i n...n

- gen _,a g n_aa r _ v - _.,.. a g..g

..4ggg c: g, g,..

---w, e

m -

the uncertainties associated with the forecast of electrical s'..a.nv d e...'..d, ~.". e ~ 4...a l v c c..e.

• _-uc 6 4 ^.

m'.". A.'.' c a.. s _i.. ~ c#

' u'.... e d e

e.=.c ^. a-u'.."

.". e ~ 4...o _' "y

_'.4 c '...=..'.. c_ c.#.

".".a

. a r a..' _-;

. '.. a a.". _i -.. m... a.

--a s-n 2 s _i d ^ a, '..h t'. '" 2

_4

.I i '.' *."..'. s.

.'., c' s -, - v "_ w'.".a"-..4"."

..b. u'

". " - c# ".'. s.c '.

4

1. ^

- ~

.y a

'e _ _7 _' '.- s. s '.'. '.- a.

'w"_..n

.D *..'u

' a-

,1.,....p a

v. n.,. r.. - -.. +.'..- $ c s.

b a.=. 4...'.,

. 4 y.

h1 ay-..

....,1

.-.-g a-

, e :- - n...a.

,. e

.w,

,w

-..a.-,,. e c.., o.u.,.

--,2 u,.._,3_

c..

a - - - -... o.. 4,.,,

n._

...t s

a --

o _,

v,.. z

.,.,.p ga-n_.

.u. ;.. 7 w a....

v.

t

/m l

l

/

/ I )~.' 7'a P,,<%. vbl h1.. G.w',.,i

..,_.,.4..p

e.,

3._-_..a..._

...,e y.

.c., -..,;.

-a

,., g _.. a.

. w a... /.

f

- x

'5. 3.... c. s c.

A 9

I A

< si

<i

/

s s(,V",^ ' '/

]Oy s

n,,,_

w j

..-f 2_.N t

m.

gg.W q

. f.

to