ML19224C242

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Reply by State of CA & CA Public Utils Commission to Az Public Svc 790518 Response to Environ Defense Fund 790507 Petition to Intervene.Certificate of Svc Encl
ML19224C242
Person / Time
Site: Palo Verde  Arizona Public Service icon.png
Issue date: 05/24/1979
From: Kerr J, Mcckenzie V
CALIFORNIA, STATE OF
To:
References
NUDOCS 7907020003
Download: ML19224C242 (8)
v • d • e


Text

. .

TC Doggf p iM h

u, U'IITED STATES OF AMERICA a n . r C4. nu, t n.=.n n ..

g ,;l

-+ 6%'T ,

a lir

.n. n.:.v. r. n. t.rzw_ e - cs sy yb ?

it s-~~!

\ $@%s- #l > -

BEFORE THE ATCMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BO'.\q$ $

6M o

In the M.tter of )

ARIZO"A PUuLIC SERVICE ) Docket Nos. STN 50-592 COMPA. , .w al. ) STN 50-593 Palo Verde Nuclear )

Generating Station, )

Un it s l' &5 3

. _ - . _ . - )

R= =. ar v. O .= m 1.u.= r.

. -= 0 .= u

OF T'4E STATE OF CALIFORNIA AND T:IE PUBLIC UTILITIES COIOIISSIO:I 0F TFE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

~

m0 mv= 00r_ m ua =. p r.mr.t.,A.> m

~ A 4--e r n..=_S r 0.,Lq. = m0

v. u. .v_.= _=m. e. r o.'I c. C = r .=n~s n v. 0 r,Iv_

. r .v . .. . =.n,.r= 4

=

07 mM. 7 .=.'IV_T E 0 a? '*.T.=.?.? ?. a' '.u nsc

. . . "=. =_. .A'. Q 7 ".- LN. ,TD,

,,n=

v....-- =_ . r_= . . .-= =

,J _z., C = ., .4 ,<. . ..s :.z. . u . :

5066 State Building San Francisco, California 92132

( i: ~ =\

-s] ==~_an-ss t -w- s nw n v,e.. a. g-, ...m.

  • * *wv. w .b. o. O.-,6 c e = .*n. w*#

. - b. 2

.. -w=.0.s 2

^ P v* ( p-. ' .&.'s evm.. e..d_.. a p m. _A *w..

  • . a. .C . , k, .' 2 m. '.'~_2.* 8-As-- -2

.r

h ^

. - -C .Q

  1. " b "^*Q I j - , ,,, v s "...N. -.. 8w .- O. s . O. ~ <.a . , N. - w-..'

O *...M F. - O

%gn GM9]NE 206 _Z U 790 7020co3 @

TTT J ^w * .". *. n' "y ,c'd c a.r.*. s c .4 *. a d. S .4 a. . " ~. a C ' t.' b v .

- N. . " *~* ". . 40:. U.e.

. 't e' ', ('ct_?'>

as a primary basis for their contention that EDF has no " standing" in the proceeding and its participation as recuested be denied. CPUC b a..-7 4 a v a. s t .h.e * *ha. . .l a. 3 _o

_ 1 b a s ' s .' o " d em*. e . _m * "m' .a. 3 " a- *. m= ." d * ... , *. o s u a " _ ' . " .

equity in a Federal court is not the same criterion the Board shculd use to determine whether EDF should be allowed to participate as an intervencr in an Atomic Safety and Licensing Board administrative licensing proceeding for participation in the limited area it seeks intervention. Morever, there appears to be a cuestion as to whether the salient findings of Morton are really pertinent to the instant proceeding.

It appears EDF does have a significant membership who will be affected by the proposed nuclear generating unit and attendant transmission lines in Arisona and California. Attempting to dissect the precise interest of each of their members who will be affected in some way by the "proj ect" would appear fruitless, hypertechnical

.n .e. A L,.e..e.a. m a s s ao .n , . T.ha. .Pa ., +. a. x R~. e

  • s ~.. .%._a _.
  • 777 deaw m e >..a.z a. o. 1a. 2 6 4

- -. ~.._1 .* =.

wse C C n *v we ..e. *wa e ey.w . n s_ c. aa s e. 3-w*, . da s ww .s q 4. s 6v, a p n. ./

e c.e. . D,.,*. ,

  • o *..w.e. w . o. n e v.w A. . . . - -

J e. d .e.*.

ie n g. m .u7- .J. nwe

  • e
c. .e. . a a lo4

.w.. *wh. . .O *v C e .w *. c 4 n 7D.7 . m. ow... u h a .w e. J e.

.. ...*w4- we.e.t-

. M. O ... c. 4 sn ma *>,ep

.. . .g k4.o .g4- u.a w .s **

. . a. n. . a. 5 % ws,r .. .

  • %p ep.w e. t a n. *.  %.._ms. . a. .e. n* . g .y e o. m. a --*
  • m. e--j ' ? ,.

4

-.e d--u-.

4 a g

  • o. d. U S4 ' s.h.p d

.a e a. n *..b.o. 4 -w- .d. .e*e w w

  • . h e 4 .w w .h.c . w

< o. . o. s *. ea . o m.

e w o. e. c e. .a. s. d.

bctr 7'T.

4 m.. %. 4 e 2 3 .e o. w.*.. 4 r. .r. .3 e. v- *. s C ".." d ,

. O vh 'v' -' ."u' w' ' ,V , _ ~.."...ha.". . w C .# ~.".o. 40" --. Wvm. -

ngad -- ou*m *v g h. n. .g.h c .* e V a. " s ' e " ew* ".

. . .a. o a. s s ' " W _# '. '.".

, k.

- ..#.-- * . ^'#a.".*. ba..#^"a. " a.," -.. .

w e *4 - I ce w e #

m..u /. J .e. 3- - w .c o. . "-4p.

A .w - S - e. w ns. e. k p..b.- _g 9 .+' .

g***, t.

. o. w e .e. . - .e. 3 v ". h. c. 4 .w e. .-

e _ .

.se.c.s

. A .* $. O . f-14*.s,Wa@C 4cm e'.s.

6 e .h. e. u-w . ,1 .e-*4 V '. k.C ta p o.

. gL.71 w,

e n..*

wkW *..k. o.

-m Q o.neyv w

.w A . e. a. vn e-w., . e .w e.

. -..b. o.

g *.

  • g .w e. . s.jt e . g 7--4 .
o. n. *v w

. o 1.Q.

  • 4 mw. e. c .h _J y.e T. h. .e. m .
  • v.

-

  • b. w.

e w ---J - c =. .J e. e. . *^

.v -

7 o. 3.c ' .7 s

- ,r .w o. y. e w s. g s. e. ..

r t. s v n" ~j 4

LD0 Lt.

O

the interests of the EDF membership in this T.atter may be prasured

.e .-s.e .. '. h a. a s s e r'. .* c"..s -o d e b/' a m- a.. b a. ." ^?

v. *..k. a. .n o .- o .# _a s v v a. .- a. .' 3 . .= ~. _= *. a. .

.V A

Joint Applicants' untimely Response also asserts that the Petition of EDF is untimely. EDF asserts it became aware of its essential interests in this matter as a result of an inadecuate and inappropriate dd scussion in the DEIS regarding the issues of conservaticr and alternative energy sources. The Board has discretion to alicw intervention based upon a concern discerned frca the DEIS . CPUC believes that although EDF could "cctment" appropriately on the DEIS during the ccament stage, its proposed involvement entailing a

" systematic comparison between the utilities plans on the one hand, and alternative energy supply sources ... currently available to the same utility ... on the other", may be a very important issue in this case which EDF believes it can contribute to helping the ASL3 resolve.

The CPUC verifies EDF's assertion (Petition, p.3) that the Cal-4 .co v ..,.4 _2 u 7.~,. 4 _y ., 4 . e. . A m .4 m a .# .#.-a. d v e .". v b e a.a .# .4.._*

  • e '

. "r's

. c..e.a .' v s .' c

, _ ,@.._'m'.". w _a s A

e

,v .n a. c g e.. 9 .

1.9Au *o-a. n ". a 4 ev r. c .ei . p y .t A a. p.*v .* _a .n y , .m a. n. ..u

n. m A .R .e. g m a. n. a. w. ". vm a $ a.

-S .e. a. . .b. a. .n

, ~ 4 7 4

  • t.

4 .e3 v4 e g .77.4 .a.$. sg. Cuw g.e4 .7 ,y 2 # :"7 4ew h a. .%. .. 4 * , a A e, mv e y.w a. .q. a. c. ,

uw. *. _s , u

a. , r 4 A. a. e.

. n. a. e,

-w , % o4 a. m . e. e A. ~,o nmene w.s-- a. X e ....t .e. m w

r 4 ns .e k ,. =. ~. cw .'

.n a. ww 1 4 .n .e. A. a. <.

..a A- a.e.m a. n. .e -

Pe a v..wm.._o 7. .w a. p. ev .n wd tg J. 7 .* 4*

am e.*. w

. .f hw g *s .a *g *O* '

. vv. .

.b. a. 7y e..d e. $. *w.L.a. ..w O. .w a. ~qw a . ,7 a. _n .e 4

. yen.wege-

. s..a. 4 OJo cc,,e .4 .e. *k4s

.. Casa.. o v .d .e. ~. na-c

  • A y y .' 4 a.c .e. ~. s .e r. =, kv a. .c ry.

e ,- w

.e .k.e v u .' A. a. _

p.a. e. .e 4 7 a. ab ws^ 'au .T U r. ' s C ^s" u *. *.".*. .# *v P. **

.# .# 'ha"

-.+: b u . ' ..#

- a. v a. .. .b. ' s ' .# * .~s '. a. W a. .' s~ .". '.

va .n *..k c .4 .n C Wn. . a ,/ .4 A- a. .v e.n a. e, d 4. 7 .' .w o. . 3 *. a. 46 T 9e v C .d e.~. n..e y_7 .Jm. o .n.~. s m.. e er b o. i ..# a. <- a.

~V .4u _,~v ~, 74

.v .. _4 ~. r..er. t O-

. / -yGm ., ~w .4 n. 4.2y * .sn w* e.

4

.e. ~..u.a w 2

e a. . . . . ye e .,~< , - -

w .e. . C .m a. a n.O u, v n n

n. n. . . . . a. n. .a-+7 r

o .] e V*m e

c,6 4.l t/ o e. k. h.

. a. 7 .Y

_ O * ..t a ft e.e.cch v .4no 6 aime *e 8 y y l _4 e c .c o, .q

. vm .c _A a. e

  • a. yn
a. *v h.4a. __...a.

J qq. c*

1'.- p' n, R. $",

.UU LLU 7

h e a ." _* u s . -. n.? wv^ u -_' d ya-pa _=" t o . h. a v e- .= ".o,'".

. c a r. . ~ _' " u ' ^ . . . -. .. o . a.

_ .n

  • e h _do e p ." .o e a_ d _d .4e -

a.r.d *..o u'_' d. "u e c^ ' ' c"a _a d. e o k.a '7 =_ . k.. _.a_ * " a . . . a. . . *. _* o r. .e.

tested.

V Joint Applicants also assert (?.esponse, p. 12) that the CPUC wi .' 1 . k. a. c o ..s 4 d-a .a .d .n 3

".n.a_a d. ." o ." .. "a.w -y

= aa._4 v a..d s- c _' _' _= "v _4 .' _* ",7

^'

v.

alternatives" and this fact somehow should be considered by the ASL3 as the basis for deternining that intervention be disallowed. In response to this allegation, CPUC states that EDF has not indicated o e-n a_ .c U C w h a *..".a ." or *oo wh.a*o _ a_ x *va_ n _4 '. w 4_ .1 _' b, a_ _4 .".". c 2' v a. d. _4.". ..".a.

future California proceeding. Whether the CPUC will be considering these issues in its proceedings is of no moment and, nevertheless, would not enable the Board to consider such evidence 'n this licensing proceeding. Evidence that may be offered in the CPUC proceedings will not enable the NRC to review and consider EDF's "model" i.i this Federal proceeding without that evidence being introduced in this record. Therefore, it will be necessary fer EDF to make and offer a v.s _4 ua a_ .,.A C a. a- ue 'u s 6. a..&.._4 .g

  • 4 .. *..h.a_ _4 w C o . = ..p . *. 4 se m. s 4 . . R N ma

. .. b._4s 1.T O. s v -e.-mv_ n. d _3 .,*. 5=

a vm4 . . *., 9 n n e e _7 4 c o .e.*. aef s 6 a *. .. am..p

.. n* s (y.

n 1 O )

  • h.=. *. 'w* p *_ *_._* _... J

- . *b.a.

.. r w n. _ _c 7..a. . e_ u, ea - . .._> c e s . . .

..s- na _ r.~. m. .rC na .- a. ,, n v . . _a - . e a .n, _> _. 8. . _= _~ ~_ , ,_,. .. _ . _, _ > . , ,

. a_ . . a , _ . .

3e

, "^ "

.=. v u. . =_ a' _ . . - " o .r. s a. "". o . 4_ . . . . .. a. c .' ".." a_ .e " w."._4_.^ ". s ' .. ^ " _' .".

.e...- .. . a ". ^. v. .e. " --a 3 3 _ .= . a. .

nha__, .3- no.ca.".ad" "n_'_'_' . e o_ a_. s e e ." _' _' v..a .o . .

. . .. . - ".=.

. b. a.

. _' . . =_ " a .c. . a d

. "..e_'_'.'--.._'_c.

a g a .. , . a .c. . . < , ,

w _a_a _a., _ c a _ - <.c. e ~ a_

ro

..u.p a _ .n. ,a u___ u, e - , _< a _< . . e-

=..a n m . a. . _ . . 3- .> a a_ .e..____

.<,e,

""co.'

e, .bau .m ]' S.

. v a e..

~ ~ ^ c. ^+ s a_ d.

, _7". _* .e,

_' .. e . _-ae _ ."o..d ^- ' " a. ." a ..- b _a s _' .c- ..--

denial. EDF's scenario on the supply and demand issue, as well as

_4 . s a..a. . c,,,"

s c ^v . .. e e ." ". o . *_v a r. c v ..v a

. _... _* ^_ r..e. , ~. 'v , 'n_'_'

a_ ', a. d ' .' .' a .* a. . .

.. . ..".o..

v 1

M .S . 4..P 3 ,n _4u q f s e.,,e.noso7s p - or ff s *w a *.,p_4m..a . .6 e v .r 4 s u, q p_. eff _4.,,. _..h.a s a. , . o. .- a_ _o .e . ".b..,.

.=. o _= . A. +.

. . . ~ ' .'L d m. . e . , *" a..+'."a_~.~, .ee g _."a_

^"

_. e_ xc, a n .

_ .".a_

. " *-. . . e ." a. e =_ ^_

states" to make the same contentions and offer tha gape ,pqcjo" en DO (l;

o s ue s w.h d a-.h. a "v ". d- " a ' e " a..v ' " ^ .

. - . ~..a .n-

- - c- ' " a..e'- *- s" w's".a.s

..-^~a.. ". .". ' s interested state representative will not purport to "adecuately represent" EDF's contention in its " statement of issues" and evidence offered. EDF and the CPUC do not have "connon interests" to be represented by a spokesman under 2.71h(e)(2).

CONCLUSION Sased on the foregoing the CPUC believes the untinely Response of the Joint Applicants does not significantly present a basis for the Board to deny the Petition of EDF for Leave to Intervene.

Respectfully submitted,

/s/ JANICE E. KERR oa.4na_ -- ;_. .s. aww ..

n

/s/ ,hmJCcvem _.4 v. y e p ::.s TT

.ae.._..u-_

T,' -

A n.m_ a_ ne_ T,~ .

. '. a n .': a e. . - -_4 a DU,.,

v c.,_

ww%,a. =.4,..S

---w.

Coam.

w T. .w g r. C .4---

ena, J

. Fe1J- u - - .'-.< . a w n. -O- C. 2 ' 9 ?

Rs.

- - e wm.

. a n -e .P n .m +%a 2,

k.*4m- ----'T-2' t-4am--

.M. ,e " .OU, 7 C. ", o.

. u* ~ ~. .. d g e d -.r a. g .*' 6. .-

h. a C

---.a. c* m. .# Fo*J- - - - ' . .-+w.2 e 266 250

Ni n3 y

a 4 El U urm._e , a

.e m. n . r e_ C.r n.v._r:.._r C --

sogh' , % , ,-

. _r .u, u .cen,r.n.n.:.v.

.s nom r

-a e .v..,.r.e e.

_ . _-- .u.

q,1 f.g ~

~j

  1. 6 s ${s

.=. _r .7 0n _ m. .u.r_ v A"Cu."v' Sn'.Tr_m.v. nT..n _' _ C r.". S .". ~-

- . .u. .n A. .D m ,

In the Matter of )

ARIZONA PUBLIC SERVICE ) Docket Nos. S~N 50-502 t vn-Ta -n-COMPANY, et al. ) S .n.

Palo Verde Nuclear )

Generating Station, )

Units 4 & 5 )

)

C= n. v.r=.v1U A.=_

U ,. -:=

_ m.6/r-=_U_

I hereby certify that copies of the foregc*ng Reply of the People of the State of California and the Public Utilities Commission cf the State of California to the Joint Applicants' Response tc the Petition for Leave to Intervene of the Environmental Defense Fund have been mailed,all postage prepaid this 24th day of May, 1979, to the following:

Robert M. La o, Esc., Chairman James D. Woodburn, Chief Atomic Safety and Licensin6~ Ecard _ n -e.e . . c_ o_ .m U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Ccamission c u ew,_ _4c ma-._e e o n se

- . . - n_-

. ....o. . ..

Washingten, D.C. 20555  ?.o. Box 631 n

_ ,. -.w.2.. m. +r , c. x c,_,, _: r; a a

,7jn.

v - .v.

G J _4_* 1 4 .m. shf ' ...

C v,..>.4

. . _e s _4 v .n.e .- 22_. ..,a o -_ ca c._,_4 . ,x U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Cctmissicn City At crney Washing cn, D.C. 20555 F.O. Scx 6a53n,

.,-w-

_,_ ,n.

. n,

- - - - a . . r. , un

.n . . r,...e...._n J. -.-ws

. e.

o.e ,me.n- Ae-ave_e -,2-e- '

.-..=s--.***

uh-... a_ e 7

- '."v' _' ^. , ~ k. ' a ."

2. _4 _ew .. o_ _4._

e n. a c e c.m e. w. ...=.4a . e

_ _, m_ e . _e _e -_

"..._' ",a_"e.* /' ^"

r. . e e . o_ o .m

- _. - 1

.. v. Wa .= .". _' . . e~ ~. c . . .a. s .e _' e-- . o_ . . ..M. o . _c ~ a_ "

. e .

a ne g . . . .- . w.1e _2 3 . ,:, .. " . .Ava"ua

_ - - r _d w n ." ' C. 7 _2 " ~ a_ _' _',

"."._4a..'

u S e _o . . _' a , WA .C 8 _' 0,;

A e -' _' . . . u' . . . C ' . ~, _

n . - . ,-.. . m_ ,7 e, g e . o. ,

O_ _p .m 3 m a_ p. c ... .vbu a__ , _, , ---_ F"Q - ' ."* d . . } .Oe.p v ,.

cI_o_"_*^^._o _.. C c " . . "s

. =co"d

- -- u .# Su . a"v'sc"s

n. . : x _, _, ,_

1

. _, ,_ 2~ u . .k. T. .h * " d_ Ava"ue

-ve -

n' . . e =_ _' a_ a , Cn' C, *, n. :, '_

Phoenix, A~ 35003 v.4 ,. k.a

. . a_ '_ V. . G ." o .".~. , _ s v.

. "n.r, _ v. . r'.

Assistant Attorney General Senicr 7 ice President 200 State Capitol r _' .= _= s ^v _I_'e.."_'_' C .... =

..v 1700 West Washing cn  ?.o. Box 952 runo

~ ~ w .n e - .~ , Au- 5:.00~.

_r _' e.c.e., . .v. t ,c c c, c ,

p n ~s

?r b i

David N. Barry III, Esc. Gordon W. Hoyt u' a r..ew e A. ~ =. o .l a. .o, - a* c. . U *. .d ' .4 . .d a.

e a D 4 .- a. . ^+ ."

Qrs,*

P. nu .1 4 _Pc .m.m.4 -o _ AT.4 _q ev.n. R e v . . h a. .w n O v c. v.e.n e _c .e. s,v Pw .4 "s.,s ve .P n .e. .n. .%. 2. 4 .m. .

P.O. Box 300 P.O. Box 3222 Rosemead, CA 91770 Anaheim, CA 92303 Byron L. Miller Jack E. Thomas Assistant Vice President Vice President Nevada Power Ccmpa y San Diego Gas & Electric CO.

P.O. Box 230 P.O. Box 1531 Las Vegas, NV 89151 San Diego, CA 92112 Gary E. Craythern, Engineer Arthur C. Gehr, Esc..

Cm*y" i

o .r G .l a n d--o .l a. Snel.l & Vs 4 '._~ a_ .

119 North Glendale Avenue 3100 Valley Center Glendale, CA 91206 Phoenix, AI 35073

=. oum 2 ., a. 'v .

. .q . 2 s a. 4., _ . ..$ .4 n ew. . . 3._2 .%. .. , S . ,u s. .r.o_ . .. .n. 4< ,.4. _e c .:, _- .

su . .

City of Pasadena Mark J. Urban, Esc.

100 North Garfield Avenue Counsel for the California Pasadena, CA 91109 Energy Cennission 1111 Howe Avenue Everett C. Ross Sacramento, CA 95825 Public Utilities Directo" C y o^' 04 "- r a-"' v R$~d

^

3h50Mai N^va-edde SEreet P.b. Box' 79[

Riverside, CA 92501 Tempe, A" 85231 Atomic Safety and Licensing Atcaic Safety and Licensing Appeal Board Board Panel U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Cennission U.S. Nuclea- Regulatory Cennissicn Washington, D.C. 20555 Washingten, D.C. 20555 Decketing and Service Section Dr. Stanley L. Dolins n.v.

v e w.e u C..., . a no.,,,c,...

4 -g ..vv.y ee4, C...m .4 -w. n na oe w, ..

4 es c. .4 w-n/ . . . ._,ww. , . , , : . . . . .

_...$c yw eekJ.

w u . e. .* a n

$ . L . . -, D . L" . -9n0:4 wsss C..vg.w n -w o.. we (Frr*N) s

. n, C .p.e. .t , a. n vc ~ %. v. a w U"VnW .w. a m.e.

. w.n ,

M. .a . .. s 4..omea P . .v . .u , T_ _e a, . 7. " Q Q '[c_ e_ *. 'A' S i. b. 4 ". e~ ' * *'

Ofa- 7. 4 .M--q

  • 046

. - 06 I CA.9* 4 vo n . 4 e e.

w . O .3

. - - - . . 10 . e. %= 3. .%

E. m. . C, O. ",

ne .e.X' 3. 2

- . 1 A. 4 .e.g. :m su c .u. n. a. . 2 x3

. . 1. " ., e..

C l.o g r. ,.

- .'. 023e,- ~ m

s. '(

y , , wC"w am% ,w . . a. .m. *?.

.. vQ .~ %..2 .r ; 2

~ W .4 .p .,

m s. C . a.

c*,..H'*-- _g, - * -c, 'ge , .. . Q_c .4.,

r

..v..w.

,4 w a r. .e *.*s e ,. p o. .es. r. . e.- a.

. 7. , . . 4 -s.'3 se,, ,. , , , ; ,_,.'--- --* *

, , , , ,, , ,y 4 ,,

1;;g

.s O . %.

s -. c-wes., gy

~w. - -w a

  • L*

L%2

  • * " ' - - - - W-5"-,,'v-

~n, 9.m:::

- -----~~---

e W a a .%..t m. . g. <w

~ n .e.

Rm L Qs p , *s:w -

D-*'t****[ f * "'s-<

, l r I I *

\ g MI()f

. ...w_.. . .. .._ .

]\llA ] U h ^-

, m._ s %..... . . 5

2. , % .* .2w , **w Lw d

.' Jw&ge M m m m. e 4 m

.AQq...e.

w ..w. .D v v .. .

C vv R v"; Qu a~o 2..t s wouw- - - 'A.t.e.y.

c w.=... ..- r w n .n. e. e e,

. w '. s , .w" .2 C2O.

, .w

( h .' s /\

L v .) (. J u

.

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML19224C242&oldid=2389225"