05000277/LER-1979-049-01, /01T-0:on 791101,four Seismic Supports Found W/Safety Factors of Less than Two.Caused by Engineering Design Deficiency.Redesign Performed.Corrective Action Implemented within Seven Days

/01T-0:on 791101,four Seismic Supports Found W/Safety Factors of Less than Two.Caused by Engineering Design Deficiency.Redesign Performed.Corrective Action Implemented within Seven Days

ML19210D625
Person / Time
Site:	Peach Bottom
Issue date:	11/16/1979
From:	Cooney M PECO ENERGY CO., (FORMERLY PHILADELPHIA ELECTRIC
To:	NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION I)
Shared Package
ML19210D618	List: 05000277/LER-1979-049, Forwards LER 79-049/01T-0 05000277/LER-1979-049-01, /01T-0:on 791101,four Seismic Supports Found W/Safety Factors of Less than Two.Caused by Engineering Design Deficiency.Redesign Performed.Corrective Action Implemented within Seven Days
References
LER-79-049-01T, LER-79-49-1T, NUDOCS 7911270405
Download: ML19210D625 (1)

LER-1979-049, /01T-0:on 791101,four Seismic Supports Found W/Safety Factors of Less than Two.Caused by Engineering Design Deficiency.Redesign Performed.Corrective Action Implemented within Seven Days

Event date:
Report date:
2771979049R01 - NRC Website

text

b

' Unit 2 LICLNSLL LVi N 4 it Ll'Ull I Re po r t. No.

CONTHot utoCK. l l

l l

l l

l ii.LE ASE PHINT oR T YPE ALL REQUlHED INFORMATIONI i

b PlAlPlB lSl2l@!0lOI-l0 l Ol O! 0 0 I - l 0 l 0 l@l 4 l 1 l 1 1IIl@I I

l@

a s uCENsEE CooE 14 is uCEwE Nu.mv.

n a,

ucENsE T vat es u'^rw

• s'T i-l 7,TS l Ll@l0 I s I O 0 1 O!2 17 1_j@l 1 11 IO 11 71 9 l@l 11 11 11 617 i 9 l@

7 EVENT DESC IPTION A 'O pro 0AB E C S NCES I :r l As tart of the inspecticn progran being performed in respcnse to IE Bul-1

,3 l letin 79-02, an engineering review of vendor design revealed that four

]

4 i seismic supports associated with the 1" control rod drive piping had l

'TTl I anchor bolts with design safety factors less than 2. Four of the six l

c I anchcr bolts on each support were found to have safety factors less than l

1 2. Failure of the supported piping would not have prevented the control

• l i

FG 1 rods from scrm Ng.

I b 9

$YST E M C A UL E CAME CGMP VALVE CODE Co0E SudCCOE CO'.1PONtNT CODE huuCODE SubCOOL

[ <>

lR l Bl @ lB [ @ [A l @

S Ul P l 0 l R lT l@ l Aj@ l zl @

8 0

10 11 17 13 id 19 20

' ( UUf N1l A L OCCuh Ht M:t ntPOR1 HIV'SION

_ EVENT YE AR RLPQHT NO CODE TYPE NO.

@,"LE nsnQI 71 o l l-l l 01 hl 91 l/l lo 11 l l Tl l-l l ol i"g

_ 21 22 23 V4 4G

/#

/H

.l 30 Ji 32 ACTION rotunt EFFECT

$HU I DOWN A T1 ACHYE NT P.Pn O 4 PnlME COvP COYPONENT TAKEN ACTION CN PLAP T METHCO HOVHS./

SbuMITTED FOHMbuH SU PP LI E n MANUFACTunER 4

lF!@lFl@

lZl@

lz@

Ol01Ol0l [Y @

lU @

Al@

3 2l O l 91@

33 34 35 3 r.

31 ao 41 42 43 44 41 CAUSE oESCRIPTioN AND CORRECTIVE ACTIONS O

lN, von-censerntive cendition was caused by an engineering design l

Ii Ideficiency. A redesien was terforced and corrective actions implemented I

i> l within 7 days. The anchor bolt safety factors of the above support s new I

, ! l exceed . Future rework will be nerformed to bring the safety factors up 1

iB l to 5 1

0 9 80

.FA(H11V VI IHt 3P ilF

• q e

"!9 l ^ @ lo.PGAkHl9l9@lNA lDl@lReviewofVendordesign.

l ST/M UN 9

OTHEnLIATV5 l)1Lf QVi llY Ut'sCOV EHY DESCHiPfiUN ->

" JTiv., Y coLNT AMc,uNT o AC1 virv @ l LonO~0,REuAsE@

nEum.En nr m u m A 1zl@Izl@l l

NA l

NA 8 9 10

?I 44 45 80 PI H'.or.t4( < l s PO'.uf t E r.

Pat iMtit H IvPL bl LLleil' l H 3'4 II l 010 l Oj@l Z @l NA l

i>

b) f3 l't H hQP.N L INJUtIES W

10 l@CE5CHIPTION

'f P.HYtlE R 1 1

'I l I O 10 l

NA J

u A b A /N. a l

d

'A 11 12 Up t O% Or OH isAMAoE TO F ACiLITY.

I vPt O(L(pierigag m izle!

n 3 w9 Il 9 10 p

I".5Ull[@ltSLHtPflON IN NA l

l l l tll11lt il ll o

44

'J 183 c.C se9 c0 &

NAME OF PREPAHEH P*lON E-