ML19206A107
| ML19206A107 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Crane  |
| Issue date: | 12/08/1971 |
| From: | Morris P US ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION (AEC) |
| To: | Brosnan T NIAGARA MOHAWK POWER CORP. |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 7904180042 | |
| Download: ML19206A107 (7) | |
Text
.
f
~
DEC S UU r
m t
E.r. 'Utoras I. BroSnan Vice President cnd Chief En*;inc.er g
Niagara Pohatik ?ocer Corporation 300 Erie Boulevard West Syracuse, New York 13202
Dear Mr. Bronnan:
At our recting en roverho-13, 1971, at thich the Director of Reculation, W. Ibnt:ing, c:mressed the intent of the Cornission not to accept rppli-catienc, in the future, that trere inadeauste er 1*tecletc. I ~tve nore
(
cza.: ales of deficiencies in coplications received vit* tin the innt vear or l
so.
A reques t was nede at the metin;: to provide these e:cnenics in writin:;.
t e
In response to thin rmuest I c.c sendina vou copics of the notes frca which I spoke. As I stressed at the teetint, there uns not = cant te be smy particular priority attached to the order in which the iters were 'nentioced, nor ucre the lists tennt to be cer.alece or definitive in any scuse.
Feithcr vore the er.= pics reant to be car,ina.
T~ icy rere prescated then and are provided now as hopefully helpful :;uidance to you in providing applications that can be processed e:acditiously.
f Questions and discussian brought cut other points, our positions on which t
are the folleving:
I
{
CP applications should be bnsed on pre 11:sinary designs, not just conceptual desipus.
OL applications should be based en final designs, not anything 1csa.
Technical specifications are an inportant eart of the entire desim and safety analycis nrocess. Since they becere a part of the 11ernse, their nature and their banes should be nn integral part of the devalen-
- ental process of olant design and nrorosed oreration.
Both CP cnd OL applications should include sections on technical seccifications. At j
the CP staae actual nu crien1 11 its =rr not be ahic to be specified; neverthclcss the aramter o r lirits that vill need specification should be identified nud the vrr in sdtich nic:crieni linits vill bc specified should be identified. At the C1. s ta-e the acttn1 t echnical
{
specificaticas and their bases - which should be an int grni c.'rt of 43 010
'. fi ?
/
a 79042800 0 g
DEC B BA Mr. Diomas J. 3rosnan the rationale of the safety analysis recort - should be supplied. In other vords, the technical specifications should be evaluated at the sarn ti=c as the final desig - beth by the applicant and by the AEC.
Obviously, ser.e ratters that entnet ressenably be errected to be complete at the C? sta;;e cannot be dealt with definitively in the CF application.
Nevertheless, it is clear that these r.atters vill need to be dealt uith and to be well in hand at the CL c tas;e. Etc AEC needs to have infor=ation at the CP stage as to how this vill be accocolished, to conclude that there is reasonable assurance that it vill be acco=plished.
Finally, I expressed a plea for suggestions as to how cc:=unication to and understanding by the rea lctory staff of the vast a cunt of technical infor=ation could be improved or accelcrated.
I would welcore any thou;ats you might have.
I S incercly,
crii. l U:'dhY tu Petar L Moff 5 Peter A. Morris, Director Division of Reactor Licensira
Enclosure:
Notes - as stated bec:
L.
- tn t ing, DI E. J. Bloch, DR C. R. Beck, DR S. H. H anaue r, DR C. L. Henderson, DR H. Shapar, CCC E. G. Case, DRS L. Lov, CO R. Cunningham, DPL L. Rogers, REP DRL M. M. Minn, ASLBP DISTRIBUTIO:!-
S upple -n,'N""'"
D R R/F D RL R/F PA'b tris
'* 3 t e :
I d ? - t i c r '. letters cent to attachcd list cf addr:===ees.
i D1L:DIR Im78,R1-2 CRESS en cg >
- ms, m,
m mtuanl 41~..011 m
i l
l 12/6/71 em >, -,f..y,..
[
w.
. s4% e s e a 4.ui a rt'u aw a... ove w %e
. t % :escs
,.ev s w
A.
INCO:'?L~f" /2%IC1. TIC'3 - C0!C3CN FIDBL723 "lDT AVAILABLE AT TIIIS Tr'Z" "TO BE PRG"IED LATER" 1.
SITE 2ETEORCLOGICE DATA.
2.
ESTIEEES OF RADICISCIOPES CONTAETED IN IIE LIQUID A!TD CASEOUS EFFLUO;TS TO BE RELEASED TO UIZ E I7ILOICCNT L"iDr2 N0?2'AL A2;D ABNOR"JJ OPE?JCIONS.
3.
D!CA Si2?ORTI2:C ?EZIO?;'ANCE OF EFEUEiT IDNI'"DI nic SYSTEPS -
SC3ITIVIIT & ACCU?ACT.
4.
BASES FOR ?L"2 PrJO?"J2'CE.
5.
BASES FOR RADIDACIIVE '4ASTE TFJ.A :CliT SYSTDS PERIDP2'JJCE.
6.
PROCESS A'D II;STRC'OITATIOli DIAC?RS.
7.
DYNA!'IC ANALYSES OF SYSTO'S, COMPC:iniTS A';D STRUCTI'Fl.S FCR CAPA3ILITY IO 'JIIISTRID EATIHQUARES.
8.
PERFORF.ANCE AND RELL*C2ILI'"Y DATA FOR DERGENCT DIESEL COIERATOR STSTO S.
9.
QUALITY ASSURANCE ?IA13 FOR OPERATION & MAINTZNE?CT.
10.
PREOPERATIONAL A'O ACCEPTANCE ':ZST PLMIS.
11.
DIDI3 TRIAL SECUPlTI FLANS.
[
- 12. TEGI S?ECS.
I
?
I t
omcz >
I-----------------
sununc >
-- rl{} --9$tO l
[
OATT >
Form AEC-3ts dev. 9-3h AECM GN a u s cov a *wa % ' -** ' % 3'<E
' n t - l e -4 *
- p l
_2 B.
ULCECUCE DITO?20CIO'; A"U A"ALYSIS STATE:CCS A2;D CCNCLUSIONS WIZIOUr DISCLSSION OR MIALYSIS OR OTIER BASIS. QUESTIO!!S STILL E!CO:2LE*E, E727 "J'O QUESTIONS AS~ED Pl?EATEDLT OF SM2 MA';U7ACIUPCRS M!D A-Z'S IN OTHER CASES. E.u!'PLE - VI32ATION AND LCOSE FARIS I'ONITORE!C HAVE BEEN SUBJECT OF QUETIONS OVER TWO TEAPS, YET RECE';T RESPC:GE WAS '*ICSTS A"E PLM!NED M;D WILL 3E
/
UIPLCC;TED." OTHER TY?ICAL E7.f.?LC OF INADIOUATE Pl!IEIAL:
1.
AT CP STAGE, PRELIME* RY DESIGN NOT AVAILA3LE, (H )
A 2
2.
AT C? STACE ACCID"'?I C0:5L'QUE:!CES JT BASED ON ACIUAL ??JLEENA."Y DESIC'l CRITERIA.
3.
DESCTJPTION OF KIALYSES USED TO DETER'2:2 UIE ADEQUACT OF STRUCIUPAL DESIC13.
4.
LISTS OF I'iDUSTRIAL CODES K:D STMCARDS THC AEZ IU BE USED.
5.
MTALYSES TO VE? LIT ADEQUACY OF DESICT OF MADi C00LMIT PCf?
FLY 7dEEL AT MAXE.T'i ROTrIO:L\\L SPEED.
6.
BASES FOR SELECTICN AND LCCATION OF EFII.UE:iT 10:i1TCRI'!G EQUI?:!ENT 7.
BASIS 70R Sr.'.ICTION OF VALL".:S OF METECROLOGICE PAPESTERS USED IN ACCIDDiT ANALYS!S A"D EFFLEENT RELEASE CALCULATIONS.
8.
SEISMIC DESICI C?lTERIA IUR U;STRCT..TATION M;D ELECTRICE SYSTE!S.
t 9.
DEC?lFIION M;D RESULTS OF QUEIFICATION TESTS TO ASSURE CAPA3ILITY I
EQUI?:ENT PER3DEMM:CE IN Mi ACCIDENT ENVIRON! TNT.
t
- 10. ANAllISES TO VERITY "2AT THE OVERFR:3SURE P20TECTION PE07IDED IN THE DEIGN 07 THE ?'IE'ARY COCLANI STS EM IS ADEOUAT2.
r O m CI > I-i SURNAWC >.
-f DATE >..
Form AEC.3 t t i Rev. 3.'3) AEC.M 0240 2 s s ms.ww
- ='a.f m en ct, at t s t e-e e
11.
ILLECDLE DP&TNGS.
- 12. AT OL STAGE, PLNC 25:: CD:JLETE, FINAL DESIGN 80* C0!TLETE.
13.
DCD::SIST": CIC - DIFFE"G:2 EVES EOR SNT. EQUIT*E:2.
C.
GE'IERIC S AFETT ISSUES "LEFI FOR LITER" - PE03LES OF 2-STAGE P2VII'J PE0 CESS AND PPOELES OF II'!ER VS. OLD~1 APPLICATICN W/0 U? DATED DEORMATICN.
1.
CONTE 0L OF ECD"0CEN POST IACA.
2.
ECCS PERIUP2'.iNCE.
3.
TUR3DC MISSILO FAILUFC.
4.
AT'JS.
5.
COERCSION, POST ACCIDrir.
6.
PIPE k'3IP ANALYSIS A'iD P m TECTIO:i.
D.
COMPA?ISC'i U/?P"VIOIS ?TJS LIST.0F DIFIERE!CES AND ANALYSIS 3 ASES.
E.
LIST OF CLCCD F'.0M C? TO CL 3-1/2 IEiTHS ID IDEiTIFf 16.MOR CEAL~ES.
7.
AMEND?E:!7S i
SUPPLEE CS DO ZET REPLiCE ORIGINALS, i
i 1
emcz >
g i
f SURNAWE >
h.7.h.g
'a I
mt>.
l.._.__
__.......l..........
[
.. c..... u 2.s n..cw awi
i f
I Addressees: DEC S ED Mr. Duane Arnold President Iowa Electric Light and Power Company Mr.
W.
E.
Ehrensperger Vice President
' Georgia Power Company Mr. Donald L. Aswell Production Manager Louisiana Power and Light Company Mr. Paul H. Barton Duke Power Company Mr. Harlan T.
Holmes Arkansas Power & Light Company Mr. Charles Sanford Vice President - Engineering Iowa Electric Light and Pcwer Company Mr.-George Kinsman Senior Vice President Florida Power & Light Company I
Mr. Robert A. Baker Executive Vice President Public Service Electric & Gas Company f
Mr. Thomas G. Ayers President Commonwealth Edison Company Mr. Ruble Thomas Vice President j
Southern Services, Inc.
t Mr.
A.
P. Perez President Florida Power Corporation Mr. Stanley Ragone Vice President Virginia Electric & Power Company O
M,,0 ~ C.?. 5
a.eLu e
- n
-~
Addressees 2_
~
Mr. Douglas V.
Kelly Chief Mechanical Engineer Pacific Gas and Electric Company Mr. Joe L. Williams Vice President, Engineering
& Construction Portland General Electric Company Mr. -James E. Watson Manager of Power Tennessee Valley Authority Mr. John G.
Miller Vice President & Chief Engineer Metropolitan Edison Com.pany Mr. William A. Conwell
'Vice President Duquesne Light Company N
f e
e 4rC16
_