Similar Documents at Surry |
|---|
|
LER-1978-035, /03L-0:on 781007,during Cold Shutdown,Valve Pit Flooded While Draining Circulating Water Box D.Caused by Damage of Valve from Flooding |
| Event date: |
|
|---|
| Report date: |
|
|---|
| 2811978035R03 - NRC Website |
|
text
NRC FQRJ\\i366 (7-7~,*
U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION LICENSEE EVENT REPORT e CONTROL BLOCK:!
L _..___.__..,__.........,._....,_........ 10 (PLEASE PRINT OR TYPE ALL REQUIRED INFORMATION) 1 o
GLJ l VI A I s Ip Is I 2 101 0 IO I - I O I O l O I O l O I O I O I O 101 41 11 11111 101 I 10 7
3 9
LICENSi:E CODE 14 15 LICENSE NUMBErl 25 26 LlCcNSc TYPE JO 57 CAT 58 CON'T
!IE]
7 a
- ~:~~~ L!:J©I o l s p I o I o I 2 I s I 1 101 11* o I o l 11 11 s 101 :y o I 3 I 11 1 I s I G) 60 61 DOCKET NUMBER 68 69 EVENT DATE 74 75 REPORT DATE 80 EVENT DESCRl?TION AND PROBABLE CONSEQUENCES (10)
I With the u..'1.it at cold shutdown, motoY operated valve NOV-SW-202B was found to be
[£TI]
inoperable in i_ts automatic mode, i.e. unable to shut automatically in response to
~
1a LOCA-p~~s-olackout event.
This condition is reportable in accordance with T S r
( ")
ITTIJ I *. o.o.~.o.
~ *
~22 valve was shut, therefore, the health and safety of the
~
!public
~
[Q]IJ 7
8 9
[£JI]
7 B
==
CAUSE
SUBCODE COMPONENT CODE COMP.
SUBCODE
!, i,~,
1C I~
~<.::) L.:_!\\:.V IV IA 11 IV 10 IP I~ ~@
l e-1
---..J 12 13 18 19 SEQUENTIAL OCCURRENCE REPORT REPORT NO.
CODE TYPE 10 /3 15 J I/I I 01 3J L!J 24 26 27 23 29 30 VALVE SU8CODE LU@
20 31 ACTION FUTu?:
5i-'"7D0WN Q
ATTACHMENT NPRD-4 TAKEN ACTIG:"11
- "\\, :,_.:.:. -
\\:::,;..:OD HOURS ~ SUBMITTED FORM SUB.
PRIME C:OMP.
SUPPLIER REVISION NO.
LlU 32 COMPONENT MANUFACTURER 80 Li@I z;,?
i =*._3 ~ I 0 1 °1 °1 °1 -~@ ~@)
33 J4
==
36 37 40 41 42
~ IR 1 1 I 6 I 51@
CAUSE D::SCR!~::;~. :.~.;:; ::.'"?.::G,lVE ACTIONS@
43 44 47
!The motor *:':'e:-=.'.::2::,~c.:, da;naged by flooding of the valve pit by water pumped from
!Unit 2 conc.e.~er "D" Waterbox.
The flooded motor was replaced, thereby returning IJJI].
[!]}]
1the valve to a fully operable status.
QTI]
1 a
g 80 FACILITY STATUS
% ?CWER OTHER STATUS DJTI ~@ JOJO IO l@...___ ____
NA __
~
METHOD OF
~
DISCOVERY DISCOVERY DESCRIPTION ~
~~~[_O_p_e_r_a_t_o_r_o_b_s_e_r_v_a_t_i_*_o_n _________ _,
a g
10 12 11 44 ACTIVITY CONT::NT Q\\
RELEASED OF RELEAS:
AMOUNT OF ACTIVITY~
~
EJ@ W(§)l NA J
7 a
9 10 11 44 7
45 46 so NA
_LOCATION OF RELEASE @
45 so PERSONN::L EX?OSUR::5
~
NUMBER
{:;"::;,. TYP!:
DESCRIPTION
[iJl] 10 IO 10 J~@...___* ___
N_A ___________________ ___,
8 9
11 12 13 PERSONNEL INJURIES
~
NUMBER DESCRIPTION6 80 NA
~
[O 10 10 I@.
a 9
11
'-,2~-----------------------------------------'
8 0
7 LOSS OF OR DAMAGE TO FACILITY '4J' Tz'PE
DESCRIPTION
~
~
tJ@
1 a 91 ~o:---------~-----------------------------------8~0 NA PUBLICITY r;;,,.
1SSUEDC,;\\DESCRIPTION~
l'yjM-1) '1 0';.:' -..ff\\ ""11 NRC USE ONLY ITliJ ~ei._l ________
N=A:.:;__ ___
~_
.*. _... _i:_.i,,_.*.. _J-'":_.}_v_c,t...._____
II II I II II I II I~
7 8
9 10 68 69 80 ;
NAME OF ?REPARER __ T_._L_._B_a_u_c_o_m _________ _
PHONE: --.a.( 8_0_4_.:)_3_5_7_-_3_18_4 ___ _
0 [I.
1---- -.
..I-'.,--.,.-
I
- * (AttacJ-im.ent~ Page 1.1)
Surry Power-Station, Unit 2 Docket No: 50-281 Report No: 78-035/0JL-0 Event Date: 10-7-78 Failed Motor Operator on Service Water Valve
1. Description of Event
During a cold shutdown period, the valve pit, containing HOV-SW-202B, was flooded while draining the circulating water box D.
The valve operator was 3~~rted by the flooding and the valve became inoperable in its automatic_-
i:!Ode.
The valve is required to shut automatically on "LOCA-plus-blackout"
£or c~rculating ~a~er conservation.
- ="e £ail::=-~ 2= the automatic function of the valve because of damage to the ~-:-'-=~,,~or :::o~""~ ----.~stitutes a condition that is reportable in accordance
,.;it::.
-=-.-;-,,,,...e_-::-, :':::-:::<:::..::::_cation 6.6.2.b.(2).
- 2.
Proo2-.=_2 -:::o:-.:s2::e:.:,==:c::S and Status of Redundant Systems:
-:::::,::':! -,--=2.,-=: ::C!DV-3W-202B incorporates an auto-close function as a means of conse=-:-'~g c::..::-=-~a=i__~g water during LOCA-plus-blackout ~onditions.
The valve was --....: ____ ::::e =2.uure was discovered and remained shut until the operator was -.-"'-:;--- -:-=-,-.
- -:::.2 health and safety of the public were not affected.
- 3.
Cause
- --"' s 2-.-e::1:::: occurred because a drain line _could not accept the volume of water-::~~ i:ron condenser 2-CN-SC-lB (D-Waterbox) to station drain to facili=.s_te 2 -,.::-;ntenance operatio_n.
The water filled the valve pit, containing the 1*1017-s:;-2023, thereby shorting out the motor.
- 4.
Immediace Cor=ective Action:
The valve pit was pumped out, and the motor tested for grounds caused by the water.
- 5.
Subsequent Corrective Action:
The motor was replaced and the valve was made operable in all respects.
- 6.
Actions Taken to Prevent Recurrence:
Personnel are instructed to control the pump discharge so as not to endanger adjacent equipment.
- 7.
Generic Implications:
None, the failure occurred due to water penetration of the electrical components.
|
|---|
|
|
| | | Reporting criterion |
|---|
| 05000280/LER-1978-001, Submit Licensee Event Report No. LER-78-001/03L-0 Re Hydraulic Shock Suppressor Found Inverted with Empty Reservoir | Submit Licensee Event Report No. LER-78-001/03L-0 Re Hydraulic Shock Suppressor Found Inverted with Empty Reservoir | | | 05000280/LER-1978-002, Submit Licensee Event Report No. LER-78-002/01T-0 Re Additional Radial Peaking Factor Surveillance | Submit Licensee Event Report No. LER-78-002/01T-0 Re Additional Radial Peaking Factor Surveillance | | | 05000280/LER-1978-003, Submit Licensee Event Report No. LER-78-003/03L-0 Re Failed Heat Tracing, Panel 8 Circuit 24 | Submit Licensee Event Report No. LER-78-003/03L-0 Re Failed Heat Tracing, Panel 8 Circuit 24 | | | 05000280/LER-1978-004-03, /03X-1 on 780305:loss of Svc Water Flow Through Charging Pump Intermediate Seal Cooler Was Caused by Corrosion of Stem of Discharge Gate Valve;Corrosion Was Galvanic(Brass Touching Bronze);Problem Will Be Studied | /03X-1 on 780305:loss of Svc Water Flow Through Charging Pump Intermediate Seal Cooler Was Caused by Corrosion of Stem of Discharge Gate Valve;Corrosion Was Galvanic(Brass Touching Bronze);Problem Will Be Studied | | | 05000280/LER-1978-004, Submit Licensee Event Report No. LER-78-004/03L-0 Re Loss of Service Water Flow Through Charging Pump Intermediate Seal Cooler | Submit Licensee Event Report No. LER-78-004/03L-0 Re Loss of Service Water Flow Through Charging Pump Intermediate Seal Cooler | | | 05000280/LER-1978-005, Forwarding Licensee Event Report No. LER-78-005/01T-0 Re Westinghouses Error in LOCA-ECCS Evaluation Model, Which Will Result in Higher Calculated Peak Clad Temperature | Forwarding Licensee Event Report No. LER-78-005/01T-0 Re Westinghouses Error in LOCA-ECCS Evaluation Model, Which Will Result in Higher Calculated Peak Clad Temperature | | | 05000280/LER-1978-006, Submit Licensee Event Report No. LER-78-006/01T-0 Re Seismically Disqualified Two Pipe Extensions on Fire Protection Yard Piping | Submit Licensee Event Report No. LER-78-006/01T-0 Re Seismically Disqualified Two Pipe Extensions on Fire Protection Yard Piping | | | 05000280/LER-1978-007, Submit Licensee Event Report No. LER-78-007/03L-0 Re Leak on Body to Bonnet Joint Diaphragm Valve 1-CH-98 | Submit Licensee Event Report No. LER-78-007/03L-0 Re Leak on Body to Bonnet Joint Diaphragm Valve 1-CH-98 | | | 05000280/LER-1978-008, Submit Licensee Event Report Nos. LER-78-008/03L-0, LER-78-009/03L-0, LER-78-010/03L-0, LER-78-011/03L-0 for Surry Unit No. 1 | Submit Licensee Event Report Nos. LER-78-008/03L-0, LER-78-009/03L-0, LER-78-010/03L-0, LER-78-011/03L-0 for Surry Unit No. 1 | | | 05000281/LER-1978-011-03, /03X-1 on 780305:During Normal Full Pwr Oper,There Was No Svc Water Flow Thru Charging Pump Intermediate Seal Cooler 2-SW-E-1B,due to Failure of the Coolers Discharge Gate Valve | /03X-1 on 780305:During Normal Full Pwr Oper,There Was No Svc Water Flow Thru Charging Pump Intermediate Seal Cooler 2-SW-E-1B,due to Failure of the Coolers Discharge Gate Valve | | | 05000281/LER-1978-011, Forwards LER 78-011/03X-1 | Forwards LER 78-011/03X-1 | | | 05000280/LER-1978-012, Submit Licensee Event Report No. LER-78-012/03L-0 Re Inside Recirculation Spray Pump 1-RS-P-1A, Failure to Rotate by Hand | Submit Licensee Event Report No. LER-78-012/03L-0 Re Inside Recirculation Spray Pump 1-RS-P-1A, Failure to Rotate by Hand | | | 05000280/LER-1978-013, Submit Licensee Event Report Nos. LER 78-013/03L-0 Re Six Snubbers Not Meeting Test Criteria, & 78-014/03L-0 Re Mount Plate Was Warped, & 3 of 8 Bolts Were Insufficiently Embedded | Submit Licensee Event Report Nos. LER 78-013/03L-0 Re Six Snubbers Not Meeting Test Criteria, & 78-014/03L-0 Re Mount Plate Was Warped, & 3 of 8 Bolts Were Insufficiently Embedded | | | 05000280/LER-1978-015, Submit Licensee Event Report No. LER-78-015/03L-0 Re Valve Cleanliness Inspection Found Foreign Material on Valve Seating Surfaces | Submit Licensee Event Report No. LER-78-015/03L-0 Re Valve Cleanliness Inspection Found Foreign Material on Valve Seating Surfaces | | | 05000280/LER-1978-016, Submit Licensee Event Report No. LER 78-016/03L-0 Re Valve MOV-RH-100 Was Not Opening | Submit Licensee Event Report No. LER 78-016/03L-0 Re Valve MOV-RH-100 Was Not Opening | | | 05000280/LER-1978-017, Submit Licensee Event Report Nos. LER 78-017/03L-0 Re Not Documenting Four Electric Maintenance Procedures & Two Periodic Tests, & 78-020/03L-0 Re Suspended Air Bubbles in Reservoir Fluid | Submit Licensee Event Report Nos. LER 78-017/03L-0 Re Not Documenting Four Electric Maintenance Procedures & Two Periodic Tests, & 78-020/03L-0 Re Suspended Air Bubbles in Reservoir Fluid | | | 05000280/LER-1978-018, Sutmit Licensee Event Report No. LER 78-018/03L-0 Re Two Main Steam Safety Valves Were Not within Plus or Minus 3% of Setpoint as Required | Sutmit Licensee Event Report No. LER 78-018/03L-0 Re Two Main Steam Safety Valves Were Not within Plus or Minus 3% of Setpoint as Required | | | 05000280/LER-1978-022-03, /03X-1 on 780726:Hydro Test Pump Failed to Build Up Pressure During Attempt to Fill Safety Injection Accumulators Due to Lifting of Its Relief Valve.Valve Replaced & Checked.Accumulator Refilled | /03X-1 on 780726:Hydro Test Pump Failed to Build Up Pressure During Attempt to Fill Safety Injection Accumulators Due to Lifting of Its Relief Valve.Valve Replaced & Checked.Accumulator Refilled | | | 05000280/LER-1978-022, Forwards LER 78-022/03X-1 | Forwards LER 78-022/03X-1 | | | 05000280/LER-1978-024, Submit Licensee Event Report No. LER 78-024/03L-0 Re No Alarm During a Planned Release of Liquid Radioactive Waste | Submit Licensee Event Report No. LER 78-024/03L-0 Re No Alarm During a Planned Release of Liquid Radioactive Waste | | | 05000280/LER-1978-027, Submit LER 78-027/03L-0 Re Seven Snubbers Not Meeting Inspection Criteria | Submit LER 78-027/03L-0 Re Seven Snubbers Not Meeting Inspection Criteria | | | 05000280/LER-1978-028-03, /03L-0 on 780916:snubber Not Meeting Inspec Criteria Caused by Low Oil Level Due to Leakage at Mating Surface Between Body & End Plate.Holding Bolts Were Tightened & Snubber Was Refilled | /03L-0 on 780916:snubber Not Meeting Inspec Criteria Caused by Low Oil Level Due to Leakage at Mating Surface Between Body & End Plate.Holding Bolts Were Tightened & Snubber Was Refilled | | | 05000280/LER-1978-028, Forwards LER 78-028/03L-0 | Forwards LER 78-028/03L-0 | | | 05000280/LER-1978-029-03, X-1, LER 78-029-03L-0, & LER 78-031-03L-0 for Surry 2 Re Critical Below Minimum Insertion Limit on D Control Bank | X-1, LER 78-029-03L-0, & LER 78-031-03L-0 for Surry 2 Re Critical Below Minimum Insertion Limit on D Control Bank | | | 05000280/LER-1978-029, Forwards LER 78-029/03L-0 | Forwards LER 78-029/03L-0 | | | 05000280/LER-1978-030, Forwards LER 78-030/03L-0, 78-031/03L-0, 78-032/03L-0, 78-033/03L-0 | Forwards LER 78-030/03L-0, 78-031/03L-0, 78-032/03L-0, 78-033/03L-0 | | | 05000280/LER-1978-030-03, /03L-0 on 781009:w/unit at Rated Pwr,Charging Pump Component Cooling Water Pump Btripped.Pump Tripped on Overcurrent.Caused by Corrosion Damage to Motor Bearings. Pump & Motor Rebuilt & Reinstalled | /03L-0 on 781009:w/unit at Rated Pwr,Charging Pump Component Cooling Water Pump Btripped.Pump Tripped on Overcurrent.Caused by Corrosion Damage to Motor Bearings. Pump & Motor Rebuilt & Reinstalled | | | 05000280/LER-1978-031-03, /03X-1 on 781001:during Normal Operation,Channel I Pressurizer Level (Protection) L-I-459 Drifted High.Caused by Drift of Electronic Zero Adjustment,In Conjunction W/ Leakage Thru Transmitter Bypass/Equalizing Valve | /03X-1 on 781001:during Normal Operation,Channel I Pressurizer Level (Protection) L-I-459 Drifted High.Caused by Drift of Electronic Zero Adjustment,In Conjunction W/ Leakage Thru Transmitter Bypass/Equalizing Valve | | | 05000280/LER-1978-031, Forwards LER 78-031/03X-1 & 78-038/03X-1 | Forwards LER 78-031/03X-1 & 78-038/03X-1 | | | 05000281/LER-1978-032, Forwards LER 78-032/03L-0 | Forwards LER 78-032/03L-0 | | | 05000280/LER-1978-032-03, /03L-0 on 781011:heat Tracing Circuit Faults Had Occurred as a Result of Boric Acid Incursion.Faults Repaired & Circuit Current Verified | /03L-0 on 781011:heat Tracing Circuit Faults Had Occurred as a Result of Boric Acid Incursion.Faults Repaired & Circuit Current Verified | | | 05000281/LER-1978-032-03, /03L-0:on 780921,heat Tracing Circuit Manual Boration/Boric acid-to-blender Failed.Caused by Boric Acid Penetration of Heat Tracing Tape Circuits.Heat Tracing Tape Replaced | /03L-0:on 780921,heat Tracing Circuit Manual Boration/Boric acid-to-blender Failed.Caused by Boric Acid Penetration of Heat Tracing Tape Circuits.Heat Tracing Tape Replaced | | | 05000281/LER-1978-033, Forwards LER 78-033/03L-0 | Forwards LER 78-033/03L-0 | | | 05000281/LER-1978-033-03, /03X-1 on 780926:circulating Water Outlet Valve MOV-CW-200D Failed to Close When Operated Electrically. Caused When Actuator Cam for Shut Torque Switch Became Wedged Against Torque Switch Hold Down Screw | /03X-1 on 780926:circulating Water Outlet Valve MOV-CW-200D Failed to Close When Operated Electrically. Caused When Actuator Cam for Shut Torque Switch Became Wedged Against Torque Switch Hold Down Screw | | | 05000280/LER-1978-033-03, /03L-0 on 781015:heat Tracing Circuit Failed. Caused by Old Boric Acid Buildup & Penetration of Heat Leakage | /03L-0 on 781015:heat Tracing Circuit Failed. Caused by Old Boric Acid Buildup & Penetration of Heat Leakage | | | 05000281/LER-1978-034-03, /03L-0:on 781006,w/unit at Cold Shutdown,Snubbers 2-RH-HSS-20 & 2-WFPD-HSS-9 Inoperable.Caused by Low Fluid Level.Defective Snubbers Dry Because of Leaking Rod Seals & Mechanical Damage to Seals.Snubbers Replaced | /03L-0:on 781006,w/unit at Cold Shutdown,Snubbers 2-RH-HSS-20 & 2-WFPD-HSS-9 Inoperable.Caused by Low Fluid Level.Defective Snubbers Dry Because of Leaking Rod Seals & Mechanical Damage to Seals.Snubbers Replaced | | | 05000280/LER-1978-034-01, /01X-1 on 781101:noted That 17 Spare Process Piping Penetrations on Unit 1 & 23 on Unit 2 Were Not Capped in Auxiliary Bldg.Caused by Failure to Properly Complete Capping at End of Constr | /01X-1 on 781101:noted That 17 Spare Process Piping Penetrations on Unit 1 & 23 on Unit 2 Were Not Capped in Auxiliary Bldg.Caused by Failure to Properly Complete Capping at End of Constr | | | 05000280/LER-1978-034, Update to LER 78-034/01X-2 on 781101:17 Spare Process Piping Containment Penetrations Were Not Capped.Condition Has Been Overlooked Since Const.Design Change Approved to Weld Caps on Open Ends | Update to LER 78-034/01X-2 on 781101:17 Spare Process Piping Containment Penetrations Were Not Capped.Condition Has Been Overlooked Since Const.Design Change Approved to Weld Caps on Open Ends | | | 05000280/LER-1978-035, Forwards LER 78-035/01T-0 | Forwards LER 78-035/01T-0 | | | 05000281/LER-1978-035-03, /03L-0:on 781007,during Cold Shutdown,Valve Pit Flooded While Draining Circulating Water Box D.Caused by Damage of Valve from Flooding | /03L-0:on 781007,during Cold Shutdown,Valve Pit Flooded While Draining Circulating Water Box D.Caused by Damage of Valve from Flooding | | | 05000280/LER-1978-035-01, /01T-0 on 781109:study of Calibr Techniques Showed That SI Accumulators Indicated Level Would Be Lower than Actual Level.Discovered After Rigorous Review of Factors Affecting Instru | /01T-0 on 781109:study of Calibr Techniques Showed That SI Accumulators Indicated Level Would Be Lower than Actual Level.Discovered After Rigorous Review of Factors Affecting Instru | | | 05000280/LER-1978-036, Forwards LER 78-036/03L-0, 70-037/03L-0 & 78-038/03L-0 | Forwards LER 78-036/03L-0, 70-037/03L-0 & 78-038/03L-0 | | | 05000280/LER-1978-036-03, /03L-0 on 781107:failure of Heat Tracing Circuit 24D,Unit 1,due to Boric Acid Damage.Heat Tracing Tape Replaced | /03L-0 on 781107:failure of Heat Tracing Circuit 24D,Unit 1,due to Boric Acid Damage.Heat Tracing Tape Replaced | | | 05000281/LER-1978-036-03, /03L-0 on 781015:compensatory Surveillance on RCP Cstator & Hearing Temp Had Not Been Performed.Caused by Failure of Operating Personnel to Restore Process Computer Trend Block Following Computer Reinitialization | /03L-0 on 781015:compensatory Surveillance on RCP Cstator & Hearing Temp Had Not Been Performed.Caused by Failure of Operating Personnel to Restore Process Computer Trend Block Following Computer Reinitialization | | | 05000281/LER-1978-036, Forwards LER 78-036/03L-0 | Forwards LER 78-036/03L-0 | | | 05000281/LER-1978-037, Forwards LER 78-037/03L-0 | Forwards LER 78-037/03L-0 | | | 05000280/LER-1978-037-03, /03L-0 on 781107:procedure Deviation Found Re Filling & Venting Reactor Coolant Sys on 770105.Procedure Deviation Was Misrouted to Records Vault W/O Review by Snsoc.Deviation Has Now Been Submitted to Snsoc for Review | /03L-0 on 781107:procedure Deviation Found Re Filling & Venting Reactor Coolant Sys on 770105.Procedure Deviation Was Misrouted to Records Vault W/O Review by Snsoc.Deviation Has Now Been Submitted to Snsoc for Review | | | 05000281/LER-1978-037-03, /03L-0 on 781022:with Unit at Rated Pwr,Panel Indicator for Radiat Monitor RM-213 Monitoring a Steam Generator Blowdown Read 0.Caused by Loose Connector Joining Detector Cable to Electronic Chassis | /03L-0 on 781022:with Unit at Rated Pwr,Panel Indicator for Radiat Monitor RM-213 Monitoring a Steam Generator Blowdown Read 0.Caused by Loose Connector Joining Detector Cable to Electronic Chassis | | | 05000281/LER-1978-038-03, /03X-1 on 781030:boric Acid Flow from Boric Acid Tank to Blender Was Interrupted.Caused by Blockage of Crystallized Boron at Elbow in Line 1-CH-356-152 | /03X-1 on 781030:boric Acid Flow from Boric Acid Tank to Blender Was Interrupted.Caused by Blockage of Crystallized Boron at Elbow in Line 1-CH-356-152 | | | 05000280/LER-1978-038-03, /03X-1 on 781108:review of Operational Data Showed That Quarterly Calibr of Nuclear Power Range Instrumentation Had Not Been Performed Per Schedule,Due to Scheduling Error | /03X-1 on 781108:review of Operational Data Showed That Quarterly Calibr of Nuclear Power Range Instrumentation Had Not Been Performed Per Schedule,Due to Scheduling Error | |
|