ML18102B628
| ML18102B628 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Salem, Hope Creek  |
| Issue date: | 10/17/1997 |
| From: | Baker E NRC (Affiliation Not Assigned) |
| To: | Eliason L Public Service Enterprise Group |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 9710220444 | |
| Download: ML18102B628 (15) | |
Text
,
- .~-.
Mr. Leon R. Eliason Chief Nuclear Officer and President Nuclear Business Unit Public Service Electric and Gas P.O. Box 236 Hancocks Bridge, NJ 08038
Dear Mr. Eliason:
October 17, 1997 This letter is in response to a request from mr. Carey of your staff for statistics on allegations received by the NRC concerni'.ng Salem and Hope Creek.
The attached tables provide a breakdown of the allegations concerning the two sites by source category, as well as a comparison to allegations received at other operating sites for calendar years 1993, 1994, 1995, 1996, an 1997.
If either you or Mr. Carey have any questions concerning the data, you can reach me at (301} 415-8529.
Attachments:
As stated cc w/attachments:
DISTRIBUTION:
P.UBLIC
/FILE CENTER EBaker CMohrwinkel FMiraglia RZimmerman BBoger DJaffe LOlshan DVito, RI WHehl, RI See next page Sincerely,
- J/
Edward T. Baker, III Agency Allegation Advisor DOCUMENT NAME: P:pseg To receive a copy of this document. indicate in the box: "C" = Copy without enclosures "E" = Copy with enclosures "N" = No* copy OFFICE NRR o/ill I
I I
NAME EBaker L/.!£.../
DATE 10//7/97 10/ /97 10/ /97 10/ /97 10/ /97 I
\\.
UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION WASHINGTON, D.C. 20555-0001 Mr. Leon R. Eliason Chief Nuclear Officer and President Nuclear Business Unit Public Service Electric and Gas P.O. Box 236 Hancocks Bridge, NJ 08038
Dear Mr. Eliason:
October 17, 1997 This letter is in response to a request from Mr. Carey of your staff for statistics on allegations received by the NRC concerning Salem and Hope Creek.
The attached tables provide a breakdown of the allegations concerning the two sites by source category, as well as a comparison to allegations received at other operating sites for calendar years 1993, 1994, 1995, 1996, an 1997.
If either you or Mr. Carey have any questions concerning the data, you can reach me at (301) 415-8529.
Attachments:
As stated cc w/attachments:
See next page Sincerely, Edward T. Baker, III Agency Allegation Advisor
- Mr. Leon R. El i as on
'Public Service Electric & Gas Company cc:
Jeffrie J. Keenan, Esquire Nuclear Business. Unit - N21 P.O. Box 236 Hancocks Bridge, NJ 08038 General Manager - Salem Operations Salem Nuclear Generating Station P.O. Box 236 Hancocks Bridge, NJ 08038 Mr. Louis Storz Sr. Vice President - Nuclear Operations Nuclear Department P.O. Box 236 Hancocks Bridge, NJ 08038 Senior Resident Inspector Salem Nuclear Generating Station U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Drawer 0509 Hancocks Bridge, NJ 08038 Dr. Jill Lipoti, Asst. Director Radiation Protection Programs NJ Department of Environmental*
Protection and Energy CN 415 Trenton, NJ 08625-0415 Maryland Office of People's Counsel 6 St. Paul Street, 21st Floor Suite 2102 Baltimore, MD 21202 Ms. R. A. Kankus Joint Owner Affairs PECO Energy Company 965 Chesterbrook Blvd., 63C-5 Wayne, PA 19087 Mr. Elbert Simpson Senior Vice President-Nucl~ar Engineering Nuclear Department P.O. Box 236 Hancocks Bridge, NJ 08038 Hope Creek Resident Inspector U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Drawer 0509 Hancocks Bridge, NJ 08038 Salem Nuc~ Generating Station, Units 1 and 2, and Hope Creek Generating Station Richard Hartung Electric Service Evaluation Board of Regulatory Commissioners 2 Gateway Center, Tenth Floor Newark, NJ 07102 Regional Administrator, Region I U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 475 Allendale Road King of Prussia, PA 19406 Lower Alloways Creek Township c/o Mary 0. Henderson, Clerk Municipal Building, P.O. Box 157 Hancocks Bridge, NJ 08038 Manager-Licensing and Regulation Nuclear Busienss Unit - N21 P.O. Box 236 Hancocks Bridge, NJ 08038 Mr. David Wersan Assistant Consumer Advocate Office of Consumer Advocate 1425 Strawberry Square Harrisburg, PA 17120 Manager - Joint Generation Atlantic Energy 6801 Black Horse Pike Egg Harbor Twp., NJ 08234-4130 Carl D. Schaefer External Operations - Nuclear Delmarva Power & Light Company P.O. Box 231 Wilmington, DE 19899 Public Service Commission of Maryland Engineering Division Chief Engineer 6 St. Paul Centre Baltimore, MD 21202-6806 General Manager - Hope Creek Operations Hope Creek Generating Station P.O. Box 236 Hancocks Bridge, NJ 08038
\\.
RECEIVED H&I SUBSTANTIATED OPEN RECEIVED H&I SUBSTANTIATED OPEN RECEIVED H&I SUBSTANTIATED OPEN RECEIVED H&I SUBSTANTIATED OPEN SALEM/HOPE CREEK ALLEGATIONS 1993 ANONYMOUS CONTRACTOR LICENSEE SPECIAL EMPLOYEE EMPLOYEE INTEREST GROUP 3
2 4
1 1
0 1
0 1
0 1
0 0
0 0
0 1994 ANONYMOUS CONTRACTOR LICENSEE SPECIAL EMPLOYEE EMPLOYEE INTEREST GROUP 4
3 11 0
0 1
5 0
1 1
7 0
0 0
0 0
1995 ANONYMOUS CONTRACTOR LICENSEE SPECIAL EMPLOYEE EMPLOYEE INTEREST GROUP 4
1 14 0
0 0
7 0
2 1
5 0
0 0
0 0
1996 ANONYMOUS CONTRACTOR LICENSEE SPECIAL EMPLOYEE EMPLOYEE INTEREST GROUP 16 6
23 1
0 1
9 0
1 1
8 0
3 4
4 0
OTHER PRIVATE CITIZEN 3
0 1
0 1
0 0
0 OTHER PRIVATE CITIZEN 4
2 0
0 2
0 0
0 OTHER PRIVATE CITIZEN 1
2 0
0 0
0 0
1 OTHER PRIVATE CITIZEN 0
4 0
0 0
0 0
1
RECEIVED H&I SUBSTANTIATED OPEN SALEM/HOPE CREEK ALLEGATIONS 1997 ANONYMOUS CONTRACTOR LICENSEE SPECIAL EMPLOYEE EMPLOYEE INTEREST GROUP 6
3 7
1 0
0 1
0 1
0 3
0 3
2 3
0 OTHER PRIVATE CITIZEN 2
3 0
2 0
0 1
3
- ~
ALLEGATIONS RECEIVED - 10/1 /97
- 10/16/97 Site 1993 199411995 1996 1997 ARKANSAS 4
41 8
2 4
BEAVER VALLEY 9
7 7
5 8
BRAIDWOOD 3
11 3
10 12 BROWNS FERRY 40 15 13 25 14 BRUNSWICK 25 11 7
8 17 BYRON 3
8 4
6 10 CALLAWAY 5
2 5
7 3
CAL VERT CLIFFS 6
7 8
9 4
CATAWBA 3
7 2
5 3
CLINTON 12 18 8
20 29 COMANCHE PEAK 19 5
14 20 12 COOK 6
10 4
4 4
COOPER 3
15 11 14 16 CRYSTAL RIVER 5
3 6
21 17 DAVIS-BESSE 10 10 2
12 5
DIABLO CANYON 13 13 17 21 15 DRESDEN 12 13 12 12 15 DUANE ARNOLD 2
2 2
3 FARLEY 1
2 3
6 2
FERMI 9
19 8
21 4
FITZPATRICK 8
3 7
5 3
FORT CALHOUN 7
4 4
4 8
GINNA 1
1 1
4 1
GRAND GULF 3
2 2
10 3
HARRIS 2
4 3
2 2
HATCH 4
8 6
5 15 INDIAN POINT 2 6
1 6
6 8
INDIAN POINT 3 25 14 11 6
14 KEWAUNEE 1
1 1
1 LASALLE 5
15 7
11 11 LIMERICK 16 12 4
5 6
MCGUIRE 8
3 4
1 MILLSTONE 42 45 47 77 59 MONTICELLO 2
6 3
NINE MILE POINT 10 7
11 14 7
NORTH ANNA 12 2
8 4
5 OCONEE 1
4 1
8 1
OYSTER CREEK 9
3 5
3 6
PALISADES 5
6 9
7 3
PALO VERDE 40 23 18 22 17 PEACH BOTTOM 6
8 3
4 5
PERRY 8
7 2
10 9
PILGRIM 19 9
8 5
2 POINT BEACH 1
4 3
5 10 PRAIRIE ISLAND 4
2 3
7 4
QUAD CITIES 5
9 7
13 10 RIVER BEND 22 11 21 18 7
ROBINSON 4
3 3
1 1
SALEM/HOPE CREEK 13 24 22 51 21 SAN ONOFRE 13 16 32 44 28 SEABROOK 4
5 3
7 1
SEQUOYAH 31 8
19 29 9
SOUTH TEXAS 38 21 15 25 7
ST LUCIE 4
11 21 47 58 SUMMER 2
3 2
9 SURRY 5
5 3
3 1
SUSQUEHANNA 7
8 8
35 17 THREE MILE ISLAND 7
3 1
3 5
TURKEY POINT 13 9
12 16 17 VERMONT YANKEE 3
2 5
11 4
VOGTLE 7
11 11 7
11 WASHINGTON NUCLEAR 8
6 14 19 19 Page 1
+*
ALLEGATIONS RECEIVED - 10/1 /97
- 10/16/97 Site 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 WATERFORD 5
3 16 21 12 WATTS BAR 69 64 50 29 14 WOLF CREEK 6
12 6
13 14 ZION 7
17 8
14 42 Page 2
Al_L,IQNS RECEIVED - MOST TO LEAST IN 1997 ---7 10/16/97 Site 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 MILLSTONE 42 45 47 77 59 ST LUCIE 4
11 21 47 58 ZION 7
17 8
14 42 CLINTON 12 18 8
20 29 SAN ONOFRE 13 16 32 44 28 SALEM/HOPE CREEK 13 24 22 51 21 WASHINGTON NUCLEAR 8
6 14 19 19 PALO VERDE 40 23 18 22 17 CRYSTAL RIVER 5
3 6
21 17 BRUNSWICK 25 11 7
8 17 SUSQUEHANNA 7
8 8
35 17 TURKEY POINT 13 9
12 16 17 COOPER 3
15 11 14 16 HATCH 4
8 6
5 15 DIABLO CANYON 13 13 17 21 15 DRESDEN 12 13 12 12 15 BROWNS FERRY 40 15 13 25 14 WATTS BAR 69 64 50 29 14 INDIAN POINT 3 25 14 11 6
14 WOLF CREEK 6
12 6
13 14 BRAIDWOOD 3
11 3
10 12 WATERFORD 5
3 16 21 12 COMANCHE PEAK 19 5
14 20 12 LASALLE 5
15 7
11 11 VOGTLE 7
11 11 7
11 POINT BEACH 1
4 3
5 10 QUAD CITIES 5
9 7
13 10 BYRON 3
8 4
6 10 PERRY 8
7 2
10 9
SEQUOYAH 31 8
1.9 29 9
FORT CALHOUN 7
4 4
4 8
INDIAN POINT 2 6
1 6
6 8
BEAVER VALLEY 9
7 7
5 8
NINE MILE POINT 10 7
11 14 7
SOUTH TEXAS 38 21 15 25 7
RIVER BEND 22 11 21 18 7
LIMERICK 16 12 4
5 6
OYSTER CREEK 9
3 5
3 6
DAVIS-BESSE 10 10 2
12 5
THREE MILE ISLAND 7
3 1
3 5
PEACH BOTTOM 6
8 3
4 5
NORTH ANNA 12 2
8 4
5 COOK 6
10 4
4 4
VERMONT YANKEE 3
2 5
11 4
CALVERT CLIFFS 6
7 8
9 4
PRAIRIE ISLAND 4
2 3
7 4
ARKANSAS 4
4 8
2 4
FERMI 9
19 8
21 4
CATAWBA 3
7 2
5 3
DUANE ARNOLD 2
2 2
3 PALISADES 5
6 9
7 3
FITZPATRICK 8
3 7
5 3
MONTICELLO 2
6 3
GRAND GULF 3
2 2
10 3
CALLAWAY 5
2 5
7 3
HARRIS 2
4 3
2 2
PILGRIM 19 9
8 5
2 FARLEY 1
2 3
6 2
KEWAUNEE 1
1 1
1 SURRY 5
5 3
3 1
SEABROOK 4
5 3
7 1
MCGUIRE 8
3 4
1 Page 1
"f-'
Site ROBINSON OCONEE GINNA SUMMER ALLEGATIONS RECEIVED - MOST TO LEAST IN 1997 - 10/1 /97 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 4
3 3
1 1
1 4
1 B
1 1
1 1
4 1
2 3
2 9
Page 2 10/16/97 1
DISCRIMINATION ALLEGATIONS RECEIVED - 10/1 /97 10/16/97 Site 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 ARKANSAS 1
4 BEAVER VALLEY 4
1 2
BRAIDWOOD 4
1 2
1 BROWNS FERRY 5
4 3
5 2
BRUNSWICK 6
1 1
3 4
BYRON 1
1 CALLAWAY 1
1 1
1 CALVERT CLIFFS 1
3 3
1 CLINTON 2
3 5
COMANCHE PEAK 1
1 4
1 COOK 3
1 1
1 2
COOPER 5
1 3
1 4
3 DAVIS-BESSE 2
1 2
1 DIABLO CANYON 2
2 2
6 3
DRESDEN 3
1 4
2 DUANE ARNOLD 1
1 FERMI 4
3 3
4 1
FITZPATRICK 2
1 1
FORT CALHOUN 2
2 1
1 GRAND GULF 1
3 HARRIS 1
HATCH 1
1 INDIAN POINT 2 3
1 INDIAN POINT 3 3
3 5
2 2
LASALLE 2
3 1
LIMERICK 2
1 1
MCGUIRE 4
MILLSTONE 11 15 12 30 19 NINE MILE POINT 2
1 4
1 NORTH ANNA 1
1 OCONEE 1
1 1
OYSTER CREEK 1
2 1
1 PALISADES 1
1 1
PALO VERDE 14 11 4
4 2
PEACH BOTTOM 1
2 1
1 PERRY 2
2 1
3 4
PILGRIM 2
2 2
2 POINT BEACH 1
1 1
2 PRAIRIE ISLAND 1
QUAD CITIES 1
2 2
RIVER BEND 6
1 10 9
1 ROBINSON 3
1 SALEM/HOPE CREEK 3
6 7
9 2
SAN ONOFRE 5
4 2
9 5
SEABROOK 1
1 SEQUOYAH 11 2
3 6
2 SOUTH TEXAS 16 7
5 7
2 ST LUCIE 2
3 2
SUMMER 1
SURRY 1
SUSQUEHANNA 2
1 1
1 THREE MILE ISLAND 1
1 TURKEY POINT 4
2 1
VERMONT YANKEE 2
1 VOGTLE 4
1 2
WASHINGTON NUCLEAR 4
4 3
3 WATERFORD 2
5 7
2 WATTS BAR 18 18 16 6
3 WOLF CREEK 1
1 ZION 4
1 7
Page 1
DISCRIM.ON ALLEGATIONS RECEIVED - MOST TO LEAS./1/97 1 0/16/97 Site 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 MILLSTONE 11 15 12 30 19 ZION 4
1 7
CLINTON 2
3 5
SAN ONOFRE 5
4 2
9 5
PERRY 2
2 1
3 4
BRUNSWICK 6
1 1
3 4
DIABLO CANYON 2
2 2
6 3
WATTS BAR 18 18 16 6
3 COOPER 5
1 3
WASHINGTON NUCLEAR 4
4 3
3 SALEM/HOPE CREEK 3
6 7
9 2
QUAD CITIES 1
2 2
POINT BEACH 1
1 1
2 PALO VERDE 14 11 4
4 2
COOK 3
1 1
1 2
INDIAN POINT 3 3
3 5
2 2
DRESDEN 3
1 4
2 BEAVER VALLEY 4
1 2
SEQUOYAH 11 2
3 6
2 SOUTH TEXAS 16 7
5 7
2 BROWNS FERRY 5
4 3
5 2
WATERFORD 2
5 7
2 VOGTLE 4
1 2
PILGRIM 2
2 2
2 FERMI 4
3 3
4 1
FITZPATRICK 2
1 1
FORT CALHOUN 2
2 1
1 WOLF CREEK 1
1 DAVIS-BESSE 2
1 2
1 LASALLE 2
3 1
LIMERICK 2
1 1
TURKEY POINT 4
2 1
THREE MILE ISLAND 1
1 OCONEE 1
1 1
OYSTER CREEK 1
2 1
1 PALISADES 1
1 1
SUSQUEHANNA 2
1 1
1 PEACH BOTTOM 1
2 1
1 BRAIDWOOD 4
1 2
1 CALVERT CLIFFS 1
3 3
1 RIVER BEND 6
1 10 9
1 COMANCHE PEAK 1
1 4
1 BYRON 1
1 CRYSTAL RIVER 2
1 4
3 CALLAWAY 1
1 1
1 PRAIRIE ISLAND 1
VERMONT YANKEE 2
1 SURRY 1
SUMMER 1
ST LUCIE 2
3 2
NINE MILE POINT 2
1 4
1 ROBINSON 3
1 DUANE ARNOLD 1
1 NORTH ANNA 1
1 ARKANSAS 1
4 MCGUIRE 4
INDIAN POINT 2 3
1 HATCH 1
1 HARRIS 1
GRAND GULF 1
3 SEABROOK 1
1 Page 1
OPEN ALLEGATIONS AS OF 10/1 /97
- 10/16/97 Site 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 Total Open ARKANSAS 3
- 3 BEAVER VALLEY 1
3 4
BRAIDWOOD 1
4 5
BROWNS FERRY 3
4 7
BRUNSWICK 1
3 15 19 BYRON 3
3 CALVERT CLIFFS 2
2 CATAWBA 1
1 CLINTON 1
14 15 COMANCHE PEAK 1
8 9
COOK 1
4 5
COOPER 1
7 8
CRYSTAL RIVER 3
2 6
11 DAVIS-BESSE 4
4 DIABLO CANYON 1
2 9
12 DRESDEN 7
7 DUANE ARNOLD 2
2 FARLEY 1
1 FERMI 4
3 7
FITZPATRICK 2
2 FORT CALHOUN 1
3 4
GRAND GULF 1
1 2
HARRIS 2
2 HATCH 1
5 6
INDIAN POINT 2 1
3 4
INDIAN POINT 3 1
4 5
KEWAUNEE 1
1 LASALLE 5
5 LIMERICK 3
3 MCGUIRE 1
. 1 MILLSTONE 1
3 22 32 58 MONTICELLO I
I 2
2 NINE MILE POINT 1
2 3
NORTH ANNA 3
3 OCONEE 1
1 2
OYSTER CREEK 4
4 PALISADES 2
2 PALO VERDE 1
6 7
PEACH BOTTOM 1
3 4
PERRY 2
5 7
PILGRIM 1
2 2
5 POINT BEACH 1
7 8
PRAIRIE ISLAND 1
1 QUAD CITIES 1
5 6
RIVER BEND 1
1 2
ROBINSON 1
1 2
SALEM/HOPE CREEK 1
8 10 19 SAN ONOFRE 5
12 17 SEABROOK 1
1 2
SEQUOYAH 1
1 6
.5 13 SOUTH TEXAS 6
5 11 ST LUCIE 1
1 29 31 SUMMER 1
1 SURRY 1
1 SUSQUEHANNA 1
10 11 THREE MILE ISLAND 1
2 3
TURKEY POINT 3
7 10 VERMONT YANKEE 3
3 6
VOGTLE 4
4 WASHINGTON NUCLEAR 3
10 13 WATERFORD 5
5 WATTS BAR 4
6 7
17 Page 1
WOLF CREEK ZION Site 1993 1 OPEN ALLEGATIONS AS OF 1 0/1 /97
- 10/16/97 99411995 1996 1997 Total Open T
1 9
10 I
2 30 32 Page 2
PERCENT SUBSTANTIATED - YEAR RECEIVED - 10/1 /97 10/16/97 Site 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 ARKANSAS 25 25 50 100 BEAVER VALLEY 11 43 14 BRAIDWOOD 33 44 67 40 14 BROWNS FERRY 35 53 38 29 10 BRUNSWICK 42 55 71 60 100 BYRON 13 33 33 17 CALLAWAY 60 60 50 CALVERT CLIFFS 50 14 100 CATAWBA 33 43 50 40 50 CLINTON 11 50 50 44 50 COMANCHE PEAK 37 60 29 33 50 COOK 33 56 50 COOPER 67 33 64 54 17 CRYSTAL RIVER 20 67 33 61 27 DAVIS-BESSE 20 40 50 27 DIABLO CANYON 8
62 50 26 33 DRESDEN 55 33 55 40 50 DUANE ARNOLD 100 50 50 FARLEY 33 33 FERMI 56 26 13 35 FITZPATRICK 67 43 FORT CALHOUN 14 50 50 33 GINNA 100 50 100 GRAND GULF 50 100 33 HARRIS 50 33 HATCH 50 38 33 50 50 INDIAN POINT 2 33 40 40 20 INDIAN POINT 3 40 29 18 20 10 KEWAUNEE 100 LASALLE 33 27 67 20 LIMERICK 44 33 80 MCGUIRE 13 33 MILLSTONE 48 42 23 28 7
MONTICELLO 100 NINE MILE POINT 10 14 27 8
20 NORTH ANNA 17 25 50 OCONEE 50 29 OYSTER CREEK 22 33 60 PALISADES 20 33 22 33 PALO VERDE 13 41 44 43 20 PEACH BOTTOM 25 33 67 PERRY 25 43 50 33 PILGRIM 21 11 POINT BEACH 75 67 50 PRAIRIE ISLAND 25 50 17 QUAD CITIES 20 57 40 33 20 RIVER BEND 50 55 43 24 ROBINSON 50 50 100 SALEM/HOPE CREEK 23 46 33 23 36 SAN ONOFRE 8
50 38 22 20 SEABROOK 25 20 SEQUOYAH 23 13 44 41 75 SOUTH TEXAS 42 43 40 28 50 ST LUCIE 25 18 60 56 55 SUMMER 33 50 71 SURRY 80 20 33 33 SUSQUEHANNA 29 25 17 50 14 THREE MILE ISLAND 29 33 50 33 TURKEY POINT 54 44 36 46 40 VERMONT YANKEE 67 50 40 13 VOGT LE 29 36 27 71 29 WASHINGTON NUCLEAR 50 67 50 31 Page 1
Site WATERFORD WATTS BAR WOLF CREEK ZION PERCENT SUBSTANTIATED - YEAR RECEIVED - 10/1 /97 10/16/97 1993 199411995 1996 1997 60 67 I 69 30 48 47 35 43 29 83 58 17 42 21 50 44 11 Page 2