ML18051B079
| ML18051B079 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Palisades  |
| Issue date: | 10/01/1984 |
| From: | Johnson B CONSUMERS ENERGY CO. (FORMERLY CONSUMERS POWER CO.) |
| To: | Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8410040384 | |
| Download: ML18051B079 (11) | |
Text
consumers Power company General Offices: 1945 West Parnell Raad, Jackson, Ml 49201 * *(517J 768-0550 October 1, 1984
- Director, Nuclear Reactor Regulation US Nuclear Regulatory Connnission Washington, DC 20555 DOCKET 50-255 - LICENSE DPR PALISADES PLANT - FIRE PROTECTION - COMPLIANCE -
10 CFR 50.48 AND APPENDIX R,
TO 10 CFR 50 - REVISION 4 Attachment lC of our submittal dated July 16, 1984 identified deficiencies and proposed' corrective action with regards to emergency lighting requirements (Section III.J of Appendix R to 10 CFR 50).
The corrective action consists of two parts:
- 1) compensatory measure to provide an adequate supply of portable emergency lights and 2) install 46 emergency lighting units by October 1, 1984, as necessary to complement safe shutdown procedures.
The proposed compensat~ry measure is complete and available rescheduled the completion date from October 1, 1984 to the 1985, for installation of the 46 emergency lighting units.
retransmitted and revised to reflect this information.
for use.
We have end of April, Attachment lC is The original schedule was not met for the following reasons; 1) estimated manpower availability did not (and could not) anticipate recent Plant forced outages, and 2) the original time scheduled for installation of the additional emergency lights was underestimated.
A review of the current status of this task shows that the design is complete, materials are.on site, mounting bracket fabrication is in progress, and electrical work and installation will be completed by the end of April, 1985.
8410040384 841001 PI)R M>OCK 05000255*
F..
. PDR' OC0984-0020~~NL02 If
. Director, NRR Palisades Plant FIRE PROTECTION - REV 4 October 1, 1984 2
Recent fire protection submittals have been submitted entitled, "Fire Protection - Exemption Requests and Modified Commitments - Revision XX."
The title has been changed to "Fire Protection - Compliance -
10 CFR 50.48 and Appendix R to 10 CFR 50 - Revision XX."
Brian D Johnson Staff Licensing Engineer CC Administrator, Region III, USNRC NRC Resident Inspector - Palisades Attachment OC0984-0020A-NL02
FIRE PROTECTION -
COMPLIANCE -
10 CFR 50.48 AND APPENDIX R TO 10 CFR 50 - REVISION 4 INDEX FOR ATTACHMENTS NRC APPROVAL ATTACHMENT STATUS 1
N/A lA OPEN lB N/A lC N/A 2
N/A 3
OPEN 4
OPEN 5
OPEN Appendix A N/A Of Attach 5 FP0484-0001L-NL02 NEW INFORMATION THIS SUBMITTAL (YES/NO)
NO NO NO YES NO NO NO NO NO October 1, 1984 TITLE APPENDIX R REVIEW PROCESS (Original Submittal April 23, 1984 - Rev 1 July 16, 1984 -
Rev 2 August 10, 1984)
ESSENTIAL EQUIPMENT FOR SAFE SHUTDOWN POST-FIRE (Original Submittal August 10, 1984)
FIRE AREA IDENTIFICATION, AUTOMATIC FIRE SUPPRESSION COVERAGE, AND FIRE DETECTOR COVERAGE (Original Submit.tal July 16, 1984 - Rev 1 August 10, 1984)
EMERGENCY LIGHTING (Original Submittal, July 16, 1984 - Rev 1 October 1, 1984)
MODIFICATIONS TO PREVIOUS FIRE PROTECTION COMMITMENTS (Original Submittal April 23, 1984 - Revision 1 July 16, 1984 Rev 2 August 10, 1984)
EXEMPTION REQUEST - SECTION III.G.2 OF APPENDIX R TO 10 CFR 50 SERVICE WATER PUMP SEPARATION IN INTAKE STRUCTURE (Original Submittal April 23, 1984 - Revision 1 July 16, 1984)
EXEMPTION REQUEST - SECTION III.G.2 OF APPENDIX R TO 10 CFR 50 ENGINEERED SAFEGUARDS AREA (Original Submittal April 23, 1984 - Revision 1 July 16, 1984)
EXEMPTION REQUEST - SECTION III.G.2 OF APPENDIX R TO 10 CFR 50 RATED BARRIERS (Original Submittal April 23, 1984 - Revision 1 July f6, 1984)
TEST REPORTS WHICH SUBSTANTIATE ATTACHMENT 5 -
ITEMS a,b,c and d (Original Submittal July 16, 1984)
FIRE PROTECTION -
COMPLIANCE -
10 CFR 50.48 AND APPENDIX R TO 10 CFR 50 - REVISION 4 INDEX FOR ATTACHMENTS NRC APPROVAL ATTACHMENT STATUS 6
OPEN 7
OPEN 8
OPEN 9
OPEN 10 OPEN 11 Approved 2/8/83 12 Withdrawn 4/23/84 13 OPEN FP0484-0001L-NL02 NEW INFORMATION THIS SUBMITTAL YES/NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO October 1, 1984 TITLE EXEMPTION REQUEST - SECTION III.G.2 OF APPENDIX R TO 10 CFR 50 COMPONENT COOLING WATER ROOM (Original Submittal April 23, 1984 - Revision 1 July 16, 1984)
EXEMPTION REQUEST - SECTION III.G.2 AND III.G.3 OF APPENDIX R TO 10 CFR 50 -
CHARGING PUMPS P-55B AND P-55C (Original Submittal April 23, 1984 - Revision 1 July 16, 1984)
SUMMARY
, PLANT MODIFICATIONS RESULTING FROM "APPENDIX R SELF-AUDIT" (Original Submittal April 23, 1984 - Revision 1 July 16, 1984)
EXEMPTION REQUEST - SECTION III.G.3 OF APPENDIX R TO 10 CFR 50 ENGINEERED SAFEGUARDS PANEL ROOM (Original Submittal July 25, 1983 - Revision 1 July 16, 1984)
EXEMPTION REQUEST - SECTION III.G.3 OF APPENDIX R TO 10 CFR 50 CORRIDOR BETWEEN CHARGING PUMP ROOM AND SWITCHGEAR ROOM lC (Original Submittal July 25, 1983 - Revision 1 July 16, 1984)
SECTION III.G.3 OF APPENDIX R TO 10 CFR 50 CONTROL ROOM (Original Submittal July 1, 1982 - Revision 1 July 16, 1984)
SECTION III.G.l.a OF APPENDIX R TO 10 CFR 50 REPAIR PROCEDURE HOT SHUTDOWN INSTRUMENTATION (Original Submittal December 6, 1982 - Revision 1 July 16, 1984)
SECTION III.L.4 OF APPENDIX R TO 10 CFR 50 LOCAL TENDING OF EMERGENCY DIESEL GENERATORS (Original Submittal August 10, 1984)
FIRE PROTECTION - COMPLIANCE -
10 CFR S0.48 AND APPENDIX R TO 10 CFR SO - REVISION 4 INDEX FOR ATTACHMENTS NRC APPROVAL ATTACHMENT STATUS 14 OPEN lS OPEN l,K04§4-000lL-NL02 NEW INFORMATION THIS SUBMITTAL YES/NO NO NO October 1, 1984 TITLE EXEMPTION REQUEST - SECTION III.G.2 OF APPENDIX R TO 10 CFR SO INSTRUMENT SEPARATION INSIDE CONTAINMENT (Original Submittal July 16, 1984)
EXEMPTION REQUEST - SECTION III.G.2 OF APPENDIX R TO 10 CFR SO CABLE SEPARATION INSIDE CONTAINMENT (Original Submittal July 20, 1984)
FP0984-0001-NL02 ATTACHMENT lC Consumers Power Company Palisades Plant.- Docket 50-255 EMERGENCY LiGHTING Original Submittal - July 16, 1984 Rev.ision 1 - October 1, 1984 5 Pages
Requirement ATTACHMENT lC EMERGENCY LIGHTING - REVISION 1 Section III.J of Appendix R to 10 CFR 50 requires that "emergency lighting units with at least an 8-hour battery power supply shall be provided in all areas needed for operation of safe shutdown equipment and in access and egress routes therto."
Emergency Lighting Review Finding Consumers* Power Company has evaluated our fixed, sealed beam emergency lighting units and has found them to be inadequate to comply with the above requirement.
Compensatory Measure Until additional, permanent eight hour emergency lighting can be installed at Palisades, a t~mporary lighting supply has been established.
This short-term compensatory measure is currently available for use.
Administrative controls will be in effect until completion of the permanent emergency lighting modif i-cation.
The permanegt lighting i~ scheduled to be operational by the end of April, 1985.
The short-term compensatory measures address the following considerations:
- a.
An adequate supply of portable lights is stored under full charge within boundaries of viewing gallery area.
This location is*
a readily accessible area for operators, the shift supervisor(s),
shift engi~eers(s), and maintenance personnel.
- b.
The operability of all portable lights will be verified once every 24 hour2.777778e-4 days <br />0.00667 hours <br />3.968254e-5 weeks <br />9.132e-6 months <br /> period to ensure proper battery charging and good working order.
- c.
Personnel listed in Item (a) above will be required to carry subject portable lights when performing Emergency Operating Procedures (EOP)-10 *. These procedures deal with fires which threaten safety related equipment (EOP 10.1) and alternate safe shutdown (EOP 10.2).
- d.
Light carrying personnel can perform remote manual activities with "hands-free" because the portable lights available are engineered wi~h a multi-position head, wide/narrow beam adjustment and horizontal or vertical base positioning.
- e.
This short-term measure supplements the permanent emergency lighting already in existence at Palisades.
Therefore, the number of temporary lights available and the use time per light is considered adequate (14 lights with 2.5 hours5.787037e-5 days <br />0.00139 hours <br />8.267196e-6 weeks <br />1.9025e-6 months <br /> of use 'time per light).
FP0684-0001-NL02
Attac;hment lC
.. EMERGENCY LIGHTING -
REV 1 October 1, 1984 Plant Modifications 2
The existing emergency lighting system at the Palisades Plant is to be expanded to add 46 emergency lighting units in various areas, corridors, and/or rooms throughout the plant.
The attached study indicates the location and coverage area(s) of each new light.
This study is a direct result of walkdowns of EOP-10.
Implementation Schedule Compliance with Section III.J of 'Appendix R to 10 CFR 50 is scheduled to be complete by the end of April, 1985.
FP0684-0001-NL02
Atta~hment lC eEMERGENCY LIGHTING -. REV 1 October 1, 1984 Emergency Lighting to be Installed at Palisades One unit per item except if noted otherwise.
3
- 1.
Control room south wall above telephone to provide light for C04 panel.
(seismic mounting)
- 2.
Shift Supervisor's.office to provide lighting for shift supervisor activ-ities.
- 3.
Two units in 1-D switchgear room to provide lighting for operating bus.
(Seismic mounting)
- 4.
Cable spreading room to provide lighting for DC bus and battery room door. (seismic mounting)
- 5.
Switchgear room 1-C in NE corner to provide lighting for DC distribution panel (DllA) and battery room door.
(seismic mounting)
- 6.
Diesel generator 1-2 room on west wall to provide lighting for C-26 panel. (seismic mounting)
- 7.
Turbine building 590' level near west door to lube oil room for access/
egress.
- 8.
Turbine building 590' level near east door to lube oil room for access/
egress.
- 9.
Turbine building 590' level to provide lighting.for CV-0522B.
- 10.
Turbine building 590' level to provide lighting for FW pump (P-lA), gauge board (C-24) and P-lB trip.
- 11.
Turbine building 590' level to*provide lighting for switchgear lA and lB.
- 12.
Turbine building 590' level above turbine building (east) access door to intake structure to provide access/egress lighting.
- 13.
Turbine building 590' level above door from transformer area near P-lB to provid.e lighting for access I egress.
- 14.
Turbine building 590' level to provide lighting for access/egress* to aux-iliary feedwater pump room.
- 15.
Turbine building mid level of stairway to condensate pit for access/
egress to auxiliary f eedwater pump room.
- 16.
Two unit, turbine building 571' level in auxiliary feedwater pump room to provide lighting for activities in room.
FP0684-0001-NL02
Attachment lC
.. EMERGENCY LIGHTING -
REV 1 October 1, 1984 4
- 17.
Intake structure 590' level above north door to provide room and access/
egress lighting.
(seismic mounting)
- 18.
Intake structure 590' level south wall to provide lighting for P-41 and associated panels and gauges.
(seismic mounting)
- 19.
Intake structure 590' level west wall to provide lighting for P-9B and associated p*nels and gauges and also east door for access/egress.
(seismic mounting)
- 20.
Turbine building west mezzanine 607'6" level to provide lighting for hogger.
- 21.
Turbine building west mezzanine 607' 6" level to provide lighting for area activities and access/egress.
- 22.
Turbine building west mezzanine 607'6" level to provide lighting for access/egress.
- 23.
Turbine building south mezzanine 611' level to provide lighting for load centers 13 and 14.
- 24.
Two units, turbine deck 625' level south wall to provide access/egress lighting.
- 25.
Turbine deck 625' level east side to provide area lighting for access/
egress.
- 26.
South cable penetration room 607'6" level to provide light for C-150A panel.
(seismic mounting)
- 27.
Auxiliary building C33/C40 panel area 590' level to provide room lighting. (seismic mounting)
. 28.
Auxiliary building bornometer area 590' level to provide room and access/
egress lighting.
(seismic mounting)
- 29.
Auxiliary building access control 611' level to provide access/egress lighting.
- 30.
Index number reserved for internal use.
- 31.
Index number reserved for internal use.
- 32.
Index number reserved for internal use.
FP0684-0001-NL02
Attachment lC
REV 1 October 1, 1984 5
- 33.
Auxiliary building 590' level in location to provide access/egress and boric acid room lighting.
(seismic mounting)
- 34.
Auxiliary building 590' level CCW room above access. door to provide access/egress lighting.
(seismic mounting)
- 35.
Auxiliary building 590' level CCW room on east wall by P52C to provide area lighting.
(seismic mounting)
- 36.
Auxiliary building 590' level CCW room to provide lighting for J-1143 disconnect switch and room lighting.
(seismic mounting)
- 37.
Auxiliary building 607'6" level CCW room stairway to provide access/
egress lighting.
(seismic mounting)
- 38.
Auxiliary building 607'6" level CCW room to provide activity lighting.
(seismic mounting)
- 39.
Auxiliary building 590' level east wall charging pump room to provide lighting for P-55B and P-55C charging pump.
(seismic mounting)
- 40.
Auxiliary building 590' level east corridor across from charging pump room south entrance to provide access/egress lighting.
(seismic mounting)
- 41.
Auxiliary building south stairway one level above engineering safeguards entrance to provide access/egress lighting.
(seismic mounting)
- 42.
Auxiliary building 570' level east engineering safeguards to provide access/egress lighting.
(seismic mounting)
- 43.
Three units, auxiliary building 570' level west engineering safeguards to provide access/egress and room lighting.
(seismic mounting)
- 44.
Index number reserved for internal use.
- 45.
Index number reserved for internal use.
- 46.
Turbine building 607'6" level at top of north stairway to provide access/
egress and area lighting.
Total 46 FP0684-0001-NL02