ML18051A893
| ML18051A893 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Palisades  |
| Issue date: | 05/16/1984 |
| From: | Paulson W Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| To: | Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8405180055 | |
| Download: ML18051A893 (8) | |
Text
May 16,1984 Docket No. 50-255 LICENSEE:
CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY FACILITY:
Palisades Plant
SUBJECT:
SUMMARY
OF MAY 2, 1984 MEETING On May 2, 1984 members of the NRC staff and a representative of Consumers Power Company met in Bethesda, Maryland.
The purpose of the meeting, requested by Consumers Power Company, was to discuss the licensee 1s plan regarding function and task analysis for the detailed control room design review and emergency operating procedures for the Palisades Plant. is a list of attendees.
The licensee outlined the interface between the emergency operating procedures, detailed control room design, and the safety parameter display system (SPDS).
As shown in Enclosure 2, the licensee plans to complete the plant specific function and task analysis prior to implementation of the SPDS.
The NRC staff indicated that a function and task analysis is not required before implementation of the SPDS.
The licensee also discussed 11 success paths 11 as shown in Enclosure 2.
The licensee plans to use plant specific success paths, transient analyses, and information obtained from the development of the critical function monitor to identify the operator 1s information and control needs.
The critical function monitor was developed independently from the emergency procedures guide-1 ines.
The NRC staff indicated that the licensee should provide a description of the process to be used for the function and task analysis in future submittals.
The process outlined appeared acceptable to the staff.
With regard to the questions raised in Consumer Power Company 1s April 2, 1984 letter, the NRC staff stated that the licensee 1s previous submittal on detailed control room design review was not acceptable because there was no evidence of identifying plant specific operator information and control needs independent of the control room.
The staff also discussed the relationship between Regulatory Guide 1.97 and the function and task analysis.
Enclosures:
- 1.
List of Attendees
- 2.
Chart EOP Upgrade cc w/enclosure See next page DISTRIBUTION
" Do!;;_~-~{1 ORB #5 Reading OELD ACRS (10) cc list NRC Participants Original signed by Walter A. Paulson, Project Manager Operating Reactors Branch #5 Division of Licensing NRC PDR DCrutchfield JTaylor NSIC Local PDR WPaulson EJord 1
a~n
/
DL:. *
- 5 WP~~ 'o :jc DL: ORB #5,/(~
~DCrutchfield f84051 aoo:::s=-=5=--=a:-::4-o--s-1-6--~--,
PDR ADOCK 05000255 F
PDR 5 lip/84 f" -,57/b/84
UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION WASHINGTON, D. C. 20555 May 16, 1984 Docket No. 50-255 LICENSEE:
CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY FACILITY:
Palisades Plant
SUBJECT:
SUMMARY
OF MAY 2, 1984 MEETING
. On May 2, 1984 members of the NRC staff and a representative of Consumers Power Company met in Bethesda, Maryland, *The purpose of the meeting, requested by Consumers Power Company, was to discuss the licensee's plan regarding function and task analysis for the detailed control room design review and emergency operating procedures for the Palisades Plant. *Enclosure 1 is a list of attendees.
The licensee outlined the interface between the emergency oper~ting procedures, detailed control room design, and the safety parameter display system (SPDS).
As shown in Enclosure 2, the licensee plans to complete the plant specific function and task analysis prior to implementation of the SPDS.
The NRC staff indicated that a function and task analysis is not.required before implementation of the SPDS.
The licensee also discussed "success paths" as shown in Enclosure 2.
The licensee plans to use plant specific success paths, transient analyses, and information obtained from the development of the critical function monitor to identify the operator's information and control needs.
The critical function monitor was developed independently from the emergency procedures guide-1 ines.
The NRC staff indicated that the licensee should provide a description of the process tri be used for the function and task analysis
. in future submittals.
The process outlined appeared acceptable to the staff.
With regard to the questions raised in Consumer Power Company's April 2~.
1984 letter, the NRC staff stated that the licensee's previous submittal on detailed control room design review was not acceptable because there was no evidence of identifying plant specific operator information and control needs independent of the control room.
The_ staff *also discussed the relationship between Regulatory Guide 1.97 and the function and task analysis.
Enclosures:
- 1.
List of Attendees
- 2.
Chart EOP Upgrade cc w/enclosure See next page
//
q.. /
'l ---*
/
//
I l
'/
t/ /. u:_) * *,
- 1 a i. J. *** -
\\.,,/ v u._._,
~
--~v Walter A. Paulson, Project Manager Operating Reactors Branch #5 Division of Licensing
i L
Mr. David J. VandeWalle cc M. I. Miller, Esquire Isham, Lincoln & Beale Suite 4200 One First National Plaza Chicago, Illinois 60670 Mr. Paul A. Perry, Secretary Consumers Power Company 212 West Michigan Avenue Jackson, Michigan 49201 Judd L. Bacon, Esquire Consumers Power Company 212 West Michigan Avenue Jackson, Michigan 49201 James G. Keppler, Regional Administrator Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Region III 799 Roosevelt Road Glen Ellyn, Illinois 60137 Township Supervisor Covert Township Route 1, Box 10 Van Buren County, Michigan 49043 Office of the Governor Room 1 - Capitol Building Lansing, Michigan 48913 Palisades Plant ATTN:
Mr. Robert Montross Plant Manager Covert, Michigan 49043 U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Federal Activities Branch Region V Office ATTN:
Regional Radiation Representative 230 South Dearborn Street Chicago, Illinois 60604 Resident Inspector c/o U.S. NRC Palisades Plant Route 2, P. 0. Box 155 Covert, Michigan 49043 Lee E. Jager, P.E., Chief Environmental and Occupational, Health Services Administration Michigan Department of Public Health 3500 N. Logan Street Post Office Box 30035
-Lansing, Michigan 48909
Name Walter Paulson Fred Liederbach Larry Bauer Voss Moore Ray Ramirez Joel Kramer Carol Kain John Stokley Michael Goodman ATTENDANCE LIST MEETING BETWEEN NRC STAFF AND CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY Affiliation NRC NRC CPCo NRC NRC NRC NRC NRC NRC Enclosure l
EDP Gui r:el i n~s Pl an i::.
Sq~~c..:. f i. *=
Teci;r1ic.::~1 G Lt i d f:? l l r-; :.~* *=
DCRDF:
=
SF'DS Plant ;::;pe-=1*r_1c Function and Task Anal!sis (Identify Or:-,er**at1~~-
=' s Infcwn:atic*n ac:d c:c.i-1-t.~*cr 1 t\\!:.?it~'1j*-::.;
SPDS Saf~tv Analysi~
\\,'er-1-r-\\/ Tti-:3.t
- i-Jfjl"'Op~- i ate
~ ;~;~.,, ~~1~~ e'.T12nta-::.i on
""" *~* * --, I - C *-* _.. _
Ir,fcirmation anci Control is Avail-able to the Operator and Meets Human Fac-:.ors G :: t i d,,.,. '. i r:o.,. *-:-;
~1~.~,1~1i~1:::.~*u~
.... =i=ct~_ =t.~l:::"':Ic=*===*n=11=11==-=*:*n=t=. =~--!
M'tt--------~ :: ;.::. ::;o: L, ti O!l ::::esul tin i; Fr-om DC:l=::DR Human Fuctors ~e.,1ie;,.1
(~':J ~
p,*oc..edur-*e
'..J.:.-l!. k U-.r*o~1qh at Si 1nu. l -=~ t.1.:~;**)
~mp 1 enien t Up*Jt*adeu r*u. t..ur t:'
- 1. :_ '"::::
.::.~d~_-_,**.:l 1:.J1*
Er*:i*:-.}
- ... ~,c~.t-.... d L..ii*1 f"l,,.1*1 L
~*1..-;J ~ f L -*
- ~ \\ t. 1 ( 1 I *1 ~.
- _ *=*
r t2 !":~* L) l \\.' t'
- .. ong T er* m Ccm.ner1 t F\\1:*::.;ulutio1*, F*rom l!C.:r:~r~ :*hJ1nclr1 F:-i::.tctc.:irs F\\t*.' v *1 e~.. J
---i
IMlCI*
Clll11111A 1n-
-.1uan lWL>UIA1'M1
- lfflia RCS INVENTORY CONTROL Ir lea,_ Alll lflMI..
ftllAIUlf HCaJUalA HlN lTL.c. ll\\Jl..f>\\~,~.,;:~ C.& +~
C.Ol'"Q.. i,._ C:..:t"c,..-e..J.)
",.,).
{I\\\\\\.,.,;\\,\\.\\c.. '"'"a.... -s°'~* """'l's
.,...,a. \\ \\t...,*"t' *11.e. ~'~ P"""P i~
Pf'._~""\\ \\""'l e11.....t., '"'l-.e."tu,, w-.."te..
'"" +* K..... kL'\\..... '.'."'
F1 o*
llCI.....
l<**Plll lW\\>llAI *.,_
Hilll 111*:" Nr**m* 11111.. '"'1 lllll
_,_ *111 *I nYnn
"'..S)
LTI..e. l"L~ i*u\\:~"'t... s
""L C.OW'C. \\I, C*... ~*-cl]
tc.-1 llllOUllCI Tlltl __ B llCI lllVllnOllY COllJllOl 10-lof
CIHlllHA I
I CAUTIOll MIT LIAVI *Al RI-Al _, ** D.. IHUUI INI MCUVl"1' ACl.,......,..l>Ulll ltll I
.. 111*1-111*1 "",...,
HUlll*WUnl IU I
- llll*l*lfll-*llwtl...
WlflflllWllllHlhHll 11
........... Vil **
11.... OllllOll 111111-111 H*
.-111111..
- 1*1.,.. '
. r.t.~
l'T"-e.. ll"l.."'s. ;....tl'c."'~~'!i>
l\\o re.<t.t..-\\.* *J~.*
1
~\\ oJoi.li.. ~1 H~:!
uu1*-..1.. <1M1111*an
- 1-1.. 1 -
11u111.. 11111vt* *m***
- *IMt* lwt,...,,_. U¥11....
- l*llltwl.IUAWIN.AIU II Mii* 11111u1 n
- H***H*
fl..,........
RCS Iii CORE HEAT REMOVAL
- .,..,.n..
PIWllllWlllU9 IYlhUUll
.u*ra***Hwn
- ao1111t '"'
1CC1111n111 Cl<<lll.. 1 *r*
............ "ti cu *-1***,..-
111
............. llwtl......
WllMll 1111 llMNWll UVll IH1*n*n***11*awutaaf llWAtUl... fl.. llVU II flW *ltlilllfU...
... CtlfHl*C.H... Ml*
lm9111ftll C"""'11ft
- **cm-n*<.-*
10-1°'
CUl-152
~
(
FUNCTION MODE SOURCE MOTIVE PATH SUCCESS CRITERIA l'IGURI!
RISOUllC!
TREEP CAUTION CONTAINMENT TEMPERATURE AND PRESSURE CONTROL DO NOT LEAVE CONTAINP.1ENT Tn11' ANO PRESS CONTROL UNSA T1SFIED WITHOUT SEEING RECOVERY ACTION l'ROCEDURE CTPC-2
'i
- CDll'lll' FU COOLERS su=m*ATH CONTAllllEllT FAii CDOLllG SYSTDI CDNTAllMENT PRESSURE
> (.II PIH CDll'MT FAN COOLERS
- C1Jl111T FU CDOLERS PMl*-AYAIL NII AVAIL Ullf1' 09 USKT 01 CDNTAllUWIT PllBSURE
<U1 PSIB YD COllTAt..ul' T£191ERATURE
< trall *F CTPC-1 c:unn FH CDOLERS l
10-11 I SUCCESIPATH z
CDNTAI JlllEllT Sl'RA y SYmll CIJNTAU*EllT PllESSURE
>(tll PSIG CDNTAUIMENT SPRAY FLOW > 11*1 GPll CDllTAIUIEli"VEWERATURE MID l'RESSURE CDllSTAllT OR DECREASING 10-10 FIGURE*
RESOURCE F TREE-CONTAINMENT TEMPEFIATURE AND PRESSURE CONTROL ct)~
CEN-152 Rev *...&t
/