ML18047A256
| ML18047A256 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Palisades  |
| Issue date: | 03/25/1982 |
| From: | Johnson B CONSUMERS ENERGY CO. (FORMERLY CONSUMERS POWER CO.) |
| To: | Crutchfield D Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| References | |
| RTR-NUREG-0737, RTR-NUREG-737, TASK-***, TASK-TM IEB-79-01B, IEB-79-1B, NUDOCS 8203300245 | |
| Download: ML18047A256 (14) | |
Text
' -
consumers Power company General Offices: 1945 West Parnell Road, Jackson, Ml 49201 * (517) 788-0550 March 25, 1982 Dennis M Crutchfield, Chief Operating Reactors Branch No 5 Nuclear Reactor Regulation US Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 DOCKET 50-255 - LICENSE DPR PALISADES PLANT -
TMI ACTION PLAN AND SAFETY EVALUATION RESPONSE -
ENVIRONMENTAL QUALIFICATION OF SAFETY-RELATED ELECTRICAL EQUIPMENT -
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION NRC letter dated February 23, 1982 and entitled TMI Action Plan and Safety Evaluation Response* - Environmental Qualification of Safety-Related Electrical Equipment Request for Additional Information, requested Consumers Power Company to provide Franklin Research Center with identified information which was needed to complete the review of our installed TMI Action Plan Items.
Attached to this letter is our response to the request contained in the February 23, 1982 NRC letter.
All items identified in Appendix A and B of our attachment ie SCEW Sheets and References are being sent to Franklin Research Center along with this letter as a full submittal.
All NRC copies contain only the attachment as per your directions in the February 23, 1982 letter.
Brian D Johnson Senior Licensing Engineer CC Administrator, Region III, USNRC NRC Resident Inspector - Palisades ATTACHMENT
--e203aoo245-s20325 __ _
PDR ADOCK 05000255
- : P..
PD,R
NCR REQUEST Ala.
ATTACHMENT ADDITIONAL INFORMATION EQUIPMENT ENVIRONMENTAL QUALIFICATION PALISADES PLANT DOCKET NO. 50-255 Identification of all TMI Action Plan equipment installed as of 1/1/81 is requested.
RESPONSE TO REQUEST Ala.
Equipment installed prior to 1/1/81 is itemized in Table 1.
NRC REQUEST Alb.
Identification of TMI Action Plan equipment installed with implementation aates after 1/1/81 is requested.
RESPONSE TO REQUEST Alb.
Equipment installed after 1/1/81 is itemized in Table 1.
NRC REQUEST Ale.
The correlation of these equipment items with the specific sections of NUREG-0737 [7] presented below (as applicable) is requested.
IIEl.2, IIE4.2, IIE3.l, IIGl, IIF2, IID3, IIK3.12 (Wx), IIK3. 9 (Wx),
IIK2.10(B&W), IIB3, IIE4.l
\\
r" RESPONSE TO REQUEST Ale Applicable sections of NUREG-0737 are included in Table 1.
Items IIE3.l, IIGl, IIK3.12(Wx), IIK3.9(Wx), IIK2.10(B&W) and IIE4.l were determined to be not applicable.
Items ID2, IIBl, IIB2, IIFl and IIKl were added.
NRC REQUEST Ald.
For all installed TMI Action Plan equipment identified, a System Component Evaluation Worksheet (SCEW) (in accordance with 79-0lB format) is requested.
RESPONSE TO REQUEST Ald.
SCEW sheets for installed TMI Action Plan equipment are identified in Table
- 1.
Appendix A lists the SCEW sheets which have been sent to Franklin Research Center as an enclosure to this letter.
NRC REQUEST Ale.
The approximate installation date for the TMI Action Plan equipment items is requested so that the appropriate qualification criteria (NUREG-0588 or DOR Guidelines) can be used in the EEQ evaluation.
RESPONSE TO REQUEST Ale.
Approximate installation dates for the TMI Action Plan equipment items are given in Table 1.
N RC REQUEST A2
- The qualification documents, e.g., the actual test reports and associated correspondence cited as evidence of qualification listed on the SCEW sheets, for all identified TMI Action Plan equipment are requested.
RESPONSE TO REQUEST A2.
All qualification documents which are being sent to the Franklin Research Center are listed in Appendix B.
The enclosure to FRC includes both the qualification documents specifically requested in the NRC letter of February 23, 1982 and the qualification documents listed on the SCEW sheets which are being provided to FRC as an enclosure to this letter.
N RC REQUEST A3.
Where the Licensee has a standard Owners' Group position with respect to a NUREG-0737 technical area or has requested extensions of implementation dates, this information is requested in order to incorporate it into the review.
RESPONSE TO REQUEST A3.
Consumers Power Company has adopted the C-E Owners' Group position on item II.F.2.
NRC REQUEST Bl.
NRC requested 23 specific qualification documents on behalf of the Franklin Research Center.
RESPONSE TO REQUEST Bl.
Qualification ¢ocuments to be sent to the Franklin Research Center as an enclosure to this letter are listed in Appendix B.
TABLE I PALISADES PLANT REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION -
TMI ACTION PLAN TMI Action Plan Item No I. D.2 I I. B. 1
- 11. B.2 I I. B. 3 I I. D. 3 Description Plant Safety ¥arameter Display Con so I e' (C-E Critical Functions Monitoring System)
Reactor Coolant System Vents (Reactor Coolant Gas Vent System)
Plant Shielding Post-Accident Sampling Valve Position Indication st0382-0522a157-13 Fae i I i ty Change Number FC-487 FC-510-2 FC-494-2 FC-467 Safety-Related Equipment In Harsh Environment None Power & Control Cables Raychem Shrink Tubing Target Rock Solenoid Valves (PRV-1067, 1068, 1069, 1070, 1071, 1072)
Lim i torque Motor Operators Power & Control Cable Terminal Blocks Solenoid Valves Cable Terminal Blocks Junction Box B&W Acoustical Monitor Date Installed Dec 1981 Dec 1981 Dec 1981 Nov 1981 Nov 1981 Nov 1981 Dec 1981 Dec 1981 Dec 1981 Dec 1981 May 1980 Date To Be Installed EQR Page Number E-48 CABLE-23 E-48 MISC-11 E-48 SV-20 E-48 MOV-2 E-48 CABLE-20 E-48 MISC-8 E-48 SV-13 E-48 CABLE-18 E-48 MISC-7 See Note 1 See Note 3
2 TABLE I PALISADES PLANT REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION -
TM! ACTION PLAN TMI Action Fae i I i ty Safety-Related Equipment Date Date To Be EQR Plan Item No Descri1:1tion Change Number In Harsh Environment Installed Installed Page Number I I.E. 1. 2 Aux i I i a ry Feedwater System FC-492 Flow Transmitters Dec 1981 J-48 FT-2 Indication & Flow Electropneumatic Dec 1981 See Note 2 Converters Cable Dec 1981 E-48 CABLE-19 Termina I Blocks Dec 1981 E-48 MISC-7 Junction Boxes Dec 1981 See Note 1
- 11. E.4.2 Containment I so I at ion None Dependabi I ity I I. F. 1 Accident Monitoring 11.F.1(1)
Noble Gas Effluent Monitor FC-494-3 None 11.F.1(2)
Sampling and Analysis of FC-494-2 None Plant Effluents (Iodine Gas Sample Collection System) 11.F.1(3)
Containment High - Range FC-494-1 Victoreen Radiation Dec 1981 J-48 RE-2 Monitors Radiation Monitor Cable Dec 1981 E-48 CABLE-21 FC-514-1 Genera I Atomics 1983 (Later)
Radiaii~n Monitors Cable 1983 (Later) st0382-0522a157-13
TABLE I PALISADES PLANT REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION -
TMI ACTION PLAN TMI Action Plan Item No 11.F.1(4)
I I. F. 1 ( 5)
- 11. F. 1 ( 6)
- 11. F. 2 Description containment Pressure Monitor Containment Water Level Monitor Containment Hydrogen Monitor Instrument for Detection of Inadequate Core Cooling st0382-0522a157-48 Fae i Ii ty Change Number FC-490 FC-491 FC-494-4 SFC-8126 Safety-Related Equipment In Harsh Environment Pressure Transmitters Cable Level Element Level T ransm i tte r Cable Conax Connectors Junction Box Raychem Shrink Tubing Comsip Delphi 111 Target Rock Solenoid Valves Anaconda Power & Control Cable Raychem Shrink Tubing Pressure Transmitters Cable Hot & Cold Leg RTDs Reactor Vesse I Level Monitoring System Heated Junction Thermocouples Core Exit Temperature The rmocoup I es Date Installed Dec 1981 Dec 1981 Dec 1981 Dec 1981 Dec 1981 Dec 1981 Dec 1981 Dec 1981 May 1980 May 1980 Date To Be Installed May 1982 May 1982 May 1982 May 1982 TBD 1984 1984 EQR Page Number J-48 PT-8 E-48 CABLE"."18 J-48 LT-6 J-48 LT-6 E-48 CABLE-18 E-48 MISC-4 See Note 1 E-48 MISC-9 E-48 MISC-10 E-48 SV-16 E-48 CABLE-22 E-48 MISC-9 J-48 PT-6 E-48 CABLE-20 3
e
TMI Action PI an I tern No II. K. 1 Description lE Bui letins TABLE I PALISADES PLANT REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION -
TMI ACTION PLAN Fae i Ii ty Change Number Safety-Related Equipment In Harsh Environment None Date I nsta II ed Date To Be lnsta I led EQR Page Number NOTE 1:
Nema Type 4 junction boxes have been involved in several tests related to terminal blocks as described.in J-48 MISC-2, 6 and 7.
NOTE 2:
E/P 0736A and 0737A were replaced with Fisher controls Model E/P-546 and wi I I be moved to a new location.
NOTE 3:
The acoustical sensing system furnished by B&W is undergoing qua I ification testing as noted in the TMI Action Plan.
It is expected to be qua I ified for operation by January 1, 1983.
st0382-0522a157-13 4
APPENDIX A LIST OF ENCLOSED SCEW SHEETS E-48 Cable -
18 J-48 EP-4 E-48 Cable -
19 J-48 FT-2 E-48 Cable -
20 J-48 LT-6 E-48 Cable -
21 E-48 Cable -
22 E-48 Cable -
23 E-48 Misc 2
J-48 POS -
7 E-48 MISC 4
J-48 POS -
9 E-48 MISC -
5 J-48 POS -
10 E-48 Misc 6
J-48 POS -
20 E-48 MISC 7
J-48 PT 6
E-48 MISC 8
J-48 PT 7
E-48 MISC 9
J-48 PT 8
E-48 MISC 10 E-48 MISC 11 E-48 sv 13 J-48 RE 2
E-48 sv 16 E-48 sv 20 E-48 MOV 2
E-48 MOV 3
Doc ID 2318A
APPENDIX B LIST OF ENCLOSED REFERENCES A.
B.I.W. LOCA Test No 75A025 dated December 16, 1976 B.
Letter from G R Dietz of Isomedix to R Oppenheim of B.I.W. dated December 23, 1974 summarizing radiation test C.
Rockbestos Test Report "Qualification of Firewall III Class lE Electric Cables" irradiation cross-linked insulation with Factory Insulation Rework dated June 2, 1980.
SCEW E-48 Cable 18-2 D.
Rockbestos Test Report "Qualification of KXL-420 Insulation Rework with Chemically Cross-Linked Firewall III Insulation" dated July 10, 1980.
SCEW E-48 Cable 18-2 E.
Rockbestos "Addendum to 12447-039" dated September ~O, 1980 (comparison of Rockbestos tests to Palisades tests at Palisades requirements).
SCEW E-48 Cable 18-2 F.
Isomedix Test Report "Qualification Test of Electric Cables Under Two MSLB Simulations" dated June 1980.
SCEW E-48 Cable 19-2.
See Note 1 G.
[V/P 12447/039-E26H(Q)-2] method for determining 40-year equivalent aging.
SCEW E-48 Cable 19-2 H.
Letter from J R Merwin of Rockbestos to C A St Onge of Bechtel dated June 16, 1981 (with attachments).
(This certifie similarity to test specimens and qualities for hydrazine in chemical spray)
- SCEW E-48 Cable 20-2 I.
V/P 447-006/E20.0l(Q)-21-l (Letter from Celmark Engineering to C A St Onge, on Prototype Test report Analysis, Connectors, Consumers Powe~ Company, Palisades Plant, dated February 18, 1981).
SCEW E-48 Misc 4-2 J.
V/P-12447-025/E47(Q)-9 (Letter from Celmark Engineering to PK Smith on Certification Analysis to Extend Earlier Prototype Test Report for Class IE Connector Assemblies, dated September 18, 1981).
SCEW E-48 Misc 4-2 *
. See Note 2 K.
Conax Test Report IPS-353.10, Rev A, dated November 17, 1980, "Design Qualification Report for a 42/C #18 AWG Conax Low Voltage Service Classification Conductor Feedthrough Assembly."
SCEW E-48 Misc 5-1 L.
Letter dated April 28, 1981 from W C ~rederick of Conax Corp to
~ D Kinner of Bechtel Power Corporation.
SCEW E-48 Misc 5-1 Doc ID 2318A
M.
Report on "Environmental Qualification of States company Terminal Blocks for Alabama Powercompany Joseph M Farley Nuclear Plant."
SCEW E-48 Misc 7-1 N.
Wyle Laboratories Nuclear Environmental qualification Report No 44354-1 dated March 8, 1979.
SCEW E-48 Misc 7-1 O.
Raychem Report EDR-2001 dated August 10, 1978, "Heat Aging Study of WCSF Compound.;,
SCEW E-48 Misc 9-1 P.
Wyle Laboratories Test Report 58442-2 dated April 3, 1981, "Environmental Qualification Test Report of Raychem Nuclear Cable Breakout and End Sealing Kits."
SCEW E-48 Misc 9-1 Q.
Limitorque Test Report B0050, "Nuclear Power Station Qualification Type Test Report, Limitorque Valve Actuators for PWR Service."
SCEW E-48 MOV 3-1 R.
Miscroswitch letter to W Morsfield dated November 13, 1981 with microswitch interoffice correspondence from v Hocraffer to A Youmans dated November 10, 1981.
SCEW J-48 POS-7-1 S.
NAMCO Control letter of 10 October 1980 to C A St Onge from Robert Kantner with attached part number listing.
SCEW J-48 POS-9-1 T.
NAMCO Report No QTR105, 28 August 1980.
SCEW J-48 POS-10-1 U.
NAMCO Report No QTR107, November 3, 1981.
SCEW J-48 POS-20-1.
See Note 3
- v.
rosemount Test Report No 37821, Rev B, dated April 16, 1978 - Nuclear Steam Test Performance Evaluation, Model 1153 GA9.
SCEW J-48 PT 7-2
- w.
Letter from K E*stafford of Victoreen to J H Pressel of Commonwealth Associates dated August 18, 1981.
SCEW J-48 RE-2-1
- x.
BIW Qualification Report - for C E Inc, PO 9070989 - 09488 Supp 2 -
September 30, 1981.
BIW Report included inabove supplement 80F017, 81A026 & 761039.
SCEW E-48 Cable 23-1 Y.
Letter to:
R Marusich From:
C A.st Onge Da-ted:
October 3; 19-80 SCEW E-48*Cable 23-3 Z.
Raychem Report EDR 5011 SCEW E-48 Misc-11 AA.
Raychem Report EDR 5019 Palo Verde I Test Report SCEW E-48 Misc-11 AB.
Target rock Report 2375C SCEW E-48 SV-20-1 Doc ID 2318A
AC.
Letter to:
C R VanHorn From:
W D Meinert Dated:
February 12, 1982 SCEW E-48 SV-20-1 AD.
Limitorque Reports B00003 & B00058 SCEW E-48 MOV-2 AE.
ASCO Report AWS21678/TR Rev A SCEW E-48SV-13-l AF.
ASCO Certificate of compliance (2)
SCEW E-48 SV-13-1 AG.
Telcon between K Flint & W Maclehose, December 1, 1981 SCEW E-48 SV-13-1 AH.
Qualification of Firewall III Class lE Electric Cables Chemically Cross-linked Insulation w/factory Insulation Rework SCEW E-48 Cable 18-1 AI.
Letter to:
C A St Onge From:
F R Postma Dated:
September 12, 1980 SCEW E-48 Cable 18-1 AJ.
Rosemount Pressure Transmitters Model 1152 #117415 Rev B SCEW J-48 FT-2 AK.
Report:
AL.. Report:
AM.
Report:
AN.
Report:
AO.
Report:
AP.
Letter to:
From:
Dated:
SCEW E-48 AQ.
Report:
Wyle LABS Final Report on Consulting Services E/P-0736 &
E/P-0737 Isomedix dated June 1978 "Qualification Test of Electric Cables Under a Simulated LOCA/DBE" SCEW E-48 Cable 19-1 V/P 12447-.006/E.200l(Q)~l6 (Report No 548-8296 by approved Engineering Test Lab's)
SCEW E-48 Misc-4 Raychem WCSF-N Nuclear In-line Cable Splice Assemblies 5-15-80 SCEW E-48 Misc-9-2 l EEE 323-1974 Prototype Qua! for Hydrogen Analyzer Systems K-III & KIV dated September 1981 SCEW E-48 Misc-10-1 J Pressel CAI G T Budris Target Rock Corp August 8, 1981 SV-16-1 F-C4969-l FRC for Anaconda Co July 1979 SCEW E-48 Cable-22-3 Attachment AT-1 June 1981 to Firl Technical Report F-C 4969-1 Attachment AT-2 Fir! Technical Report F-C4836-2 &
F-C 4969-1 July 1980 SCEW E-48 Cable-22-4 AR.
Qualification of Firewall III Class lE Elec Cables (Chemically Cross-Linked Insulation) July 7, 1977 Rev November 26, 1979 Doc ID 2318A
AS.
Report:
AT.
Report:
AU.
Report:
AV.
Report:
AW.
Report:
AX.
Report:
Qualification Test of CoAxial-Type Cables in a simulated steam line break (SLB) & Loss-of-Coolant Accident (LOCA) Environment
- F-C5120-2 SCEW #-48 Cable 21 Qualification Type Test Data Report for class lE Victoreen High Range Containment Radiation Area Monitor System Wyle Test-Report #45050-1 SCEW J-48 RE-2 Qualification Type Test Data Report for class lE Victoreen High Range Containment Radiation Area Monitor System #950.301 SCEW J-48 RE-2 Report on Terminal Block/Junction Box Environmental Testing Northeast Utilities Ref l SCEW E-48 Misc-2 Test Report on effect of a LOCA on Electrical Performance of four terminal blocks Westinghouse Electric Corporation Ref 2 SCEW E-48 Misc-2 Westinghouse Terminal Blocks Ref 3 SCEW E-48 Misc-2 AY.
Letter To:
R Marusich, Consumers Power Company From:
C A St Onge, Bechtel Dated:
October 3, 1980 Ref 4 SCEW E-48 Misc-2 AZ.
Report:
Doc ID 2318A Qualification Test of Terminal and Fuse blocks for control products SCEW E-48 Misc-6
Note 1 Isomedix Test Report "Qualification Test of Electric Cables Under Two MSLB Simulations" dated June 1980 on SCEW E-48 Cable 19-2 should be dated January 1980 Note 2 V/P-12447-025/E47(Q)-9 (Letter from Celmark Engineering to P K Smith on Certification Analysis to Extend Earlier Prototype Test Report for Class IE Connector Assemblies dated September 18, 1981) on SCEW E-48 Misc 4-2 should be dated September 28, 1981 Note 3 NAMCO Report No QTR-107, November 3, 1981 on SCEW J-48 POS-20-1 should be dated 3/11/81 Note 4 Qualification Test of Terminal and Fuse Blocks FRC Final Report F-C5132 prepared for Control Products Division.
On SCEW E-48 Misc 6-1 should be Report #F-C5143 Doc ID 2318A