ML18045A330
| ML18045A330 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Palisades  |
| Issue date: | 07/03/1980 |
| From: | Frost S CONSUMERS ENERGY CO. (FORMERLY CONSUMERS POWER CO.) |
| To: | Crutchfield D Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| Shared Package | |
| ML18045A334 | List: |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8007100199 | |
| Download: ML18045A330 (257) | |
Text
{{#Wiki_filter:,.* I consumers Power company General Offices: 212 West Michigan Avenue, Jackson, Michigan 49201 * (517) 788-0550 July 3, 1980 Directbr, Nuclear~Reactor Regulation Att Mr Dennis M Crutchfield, Chief Operating Projects Branch No 5 US Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 DOCKET 50-255 - LICENSE DPR PALISADES PLANT - PROPOSED TECHNICAL SPECIFICATIONS CHANGE -
- LIQUID EFFLUENTS AND ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING Transmitted herewith are three (3) original and thirty-seven (37) conformed copies of a reques"t for change to the Technical Specifications of Provisional Operating License DPR-20, Docket 50-255, issued to Consumers Power Company on October 16, 1972 for the Palisades Plant.
The proposed Technical Specifications chang~ is a result of the termination of the March 12, 1971 Settlement Agreement between Consumers Power Company and the Michigan Steelhead and Salmon Fishermen'. s Association*, et al. Section 17 of that Agreement states that ... "if not previously terminated, this Agreement and all rights and obligations of the parties hereunder shall automatically terminate thirty-six {36) calendar months aft~r initial successful operation of the modified condenser cooling system or the modified liquid radwaste system, whichever is later ... " Initial successful operation of the modified liquid radwaste system occurred on September. 5, 1973; and the modified condenser cooling system's initial successful operation occurred on October 1, 1974. Therefore, the Settlement Agreement automatically terminated in October 1977 being thirty-six (36) months af"ter the .latter of the two events. The Settlement Agreement resulted in the plant's Technical Specifications being modified in Section 3.9, "Liquid Effluents," and Section 4.11 "Environ-mental Monitoring Program," as well as "Special Technical Specifications Pursuan"t to Agreement" being added. This proposed change will remove the restrictions imposed by the Settlement Agree'ment.
- oc0680-0382a-43
\'. --- ....... /
2 The proposed change involves a single safety issue. Therefore, a check in the amount of $4,000 is attached pursuant to 10 CFR 170.22, Class III change.
~~v~~r Steven R Frost Licensing Engineer CC JGKeppler, USNRC NRG Resident Inspector-Palisades oc0680-0382a.:43
_.. ~
.- ~:(.
~1'""'
- _, ~ I" c;,.'!::i/8 / _.. ~-:::.
~- *. . .
. __.-"'H - * ** - --
r;.._H : ..c..;..,. ~ ~ I .
~
-_ .. ~ :_. 2;..,,., e,., ~ /,,28~x.S.OB.33 ~/~fie(,#_
. ~.7/C.S
/.e.N.:S/'-£ t..c'4 P 'e ~- .:
_ -Vv,te,)?+(/?.3~)e = 2~4e&~ .
~= ~7C,31-1c;.sz' -1t:J~: .s~4e>7ffl .
, ~
- 2~7~"' 6!31S~/<cZ8~ .,t/'?32~ *.:r~75o=t4 I
t * .
.. ' .. } ~ ~. : ~ .
I *
~ . * *t' I
' ' J ..... :~ *---* **-*-* - - ------* - - * - - - - - - - - - - - * - * * - - -
. ... ~* . -. ' *. .
* *t-*
r . ,-- - ._..,....".lo.,-- .- .-------- .
~---
'* * ,..l:O
*I
} r'
.. ReBistrutlon No.
State 030414 of: _ _~rr...:cc...w__:;Y:..:0:..:1..:.*k=---- ENGINEERING SPEC IFICATIO~r FOR A CONl'ROL ROD DRIVE MECHANISM FOR CONS IJifilRS POWER COMPANY PA"LI SADES PLANT CONTRACT.2966 Specification No. 70P-008 COMBUSTION ENG:'.:rIEERING, DIC. Nuclear Division Windsor, Connecticut ( RevL;ion 1, Septe:P.ber 14, 1967)
~
*rssued
(~~ ---/' 11 *'"i ; *' *. / by+L--~:__i. (.!.;, t .. ;./'
~
) ,* l,j/(!
Approved by_l~L( (i~£,jf_:Jj,"'-_ Approved
"/
Date Revision 2, c.O'
~l..;.. l*._' VJ Jti('.CJiani~,l;i ~i!l1J..l 0~~ \*'*') jL:U.r~;. 1 lll.!
1
**i..,1 ltlh. i'UtLJ prcdic Led life of those portions of the mechnn:i.sm \v:Lth less than forty years expected lifet:imc shall be listed as required :i.n Section 7 .o. of this spedfic'at.ion.
'I'he rncchun:i.cm shall be designed to operate without rnaintcnnnce for a minimum of one (1) year. It shall be a design objecti vc to limit maintenance to three year intervals.
4.1.4 The design of the pressure containing portions of the mechanism shall confc:--m to Reference 3.1.1. The pressure housing shall be considered as a Class A vessel per paragraph N-131 of Reference 3.1.1. The nil-ductility transition temperature of the pressure housing material shall be 10°F or less. A code stamp shall be applied. 4.1.5 The electrical portions of the meclmnism will conform to t.hc applicable requirements of Reference 3.1.4 and 3.1.5. 4.2 Control Rod Drive Mechanism Requirements 4.2.1 The drive mechanism shall be suitable for attachment to and support by the flanges provided on the reactor vessel head. When all mechanisms are installed, any rr..echanism shall bE; capable of being removed and replaced without significant dismantling of the adjacent mechanisms. Each mechanis;11 ;:;hall be identical and interchangeable with all others. Arrangement of the reactor head mechanism nozzles is shown on Figure 1. Details (2) of the nozzle a~e shown on Figure 2. The mecl:i~.ni.81,1 shall have a suitable flexible metal (ome~a type) seal for welding to the nozzle flange. Provision shall be made to insure proper orient-ation of the mechanism with respect to its nozzle on the reactor vessel head. This orienting provision shall be recomrnended by the supplier and subject to CEIID approval. 4.2.1.1 It shall be an objective to minimize locations of crud traps in primary fluid side of the mechanism. 4.2.2 Attachment points for horizontal supports (to be supplied by ot:-iers) shall be provided on the mechanism. The attachment points shall be designed and located to aid the mechanism to withstand the combined loads specified in 4.2.14. The overall ciesign between the a.ttacbment points an.d the horizonte.l support shall be mutually agreed upon *oy the supplier and CEim to implement the requirement of 4.2.3. 4.2.3 Field connections (electrical, cooling, drain, etc.) shall be made above the.horizontal support structure of the mechanism to facilitate ease of removal and replacement during refueling operations o.nd shall not require dismantling of the rr.echanism beyond those steps necessary to disconnect the mechnnism frrnn the control rod. It is c18sirable that no portion of the drive mechanism extend below the reactor vessel head mating surface when the drive is disconnected fro::n the control rod ar.d locked in the fully \vithdrmrn position. Spec. No. 70P-008 Rev. 2 Page 3 of 30 pagca
) . . . *.** *. ' (2) 4.?,.lJ Tho mechanism presnure housing shall not have a natural fre-quency in the 60 to 90 cycles per second range. 4.2. J.li* The mschanism shal1 withstand the fo11owin~ combined loads
. without exceeding the stress levels specified, and without causing or preventing rapid insertion or losing function
- 4.2.14.1 Normal loads are defined as those associated with normal operating pressures, temperatures, and transients (Section 4~J).
4.2.14.2 Accident loads are defined as blowdown forces acting on a control rod due to postulated main pipe ruptures. These loads shall be assumed to be applied axially in either the upward or dovmward direction at the coupling end of the mechanism drive shaft. The accident load shall be con.sidered as a suddo:mly applisd load of 2750 pounds with an associated impulse of 28 pound-seconds followed by a steady state load of 1,000 pounds. The mechanism need not function normally during the application of the accident loads but shall prevent ejection of the rod from the core and shall be capable of normal operation following the accident condition. (2) 4.2.14.3 Design seismic loads are defined as .975 g horizontal and 0.104 E vertical acceleration applied simultaneously at the center of gravity of the mechanism. (2) No-loss-of-function seismic loads are defin~d as 1.73 g horizontal and O. 21 g_ vertic.al acceleration applied simultaneously at the center of gravity of the mechanism. For both the design seismic load and the no-loss-of-function seismic load the horizontal com~onent is applied in the least resistant direction.
- a. Normal loads plus design seismic loads with membrane stresses limited to the applicable material specification allowable stresses at operating temperature.
- b. Normal loads plus accident loads plus design seismic loads with membrane stresses limi tsd to the applicable material specification yield stress at operating temperature.
- c. Normal lo.1ds plus accident loads plus no-loss-of-function seismic loads with membrane stresses limited to 11C% of the applicable material specification yield stress at operating temperature.
4.2.15 The ambj_ent conditions inside t11e contaimnont building folJ.cwi nG a postulated main gipe rupture may rapid1y increase to a *m.:1x:itiJUm of 55 psig and 283F1-rlth lOO;b relative hl;.rnidity. There may also be a spray cif bcric acid solut~on containirig 1720* prm boron at t.he saturA.ted te:r:perature of 283 F. The mechanism shall be capable of oper-1 ting and transm:l.ttin((, position indication with these conditions for at le2st on9 (1) honr .
- Spec. No. 70P-008 Rev. 2 Pa~e 6 of 10
~
D.~~_es
-SPECIFICATION FOR
---_FIELD ERECTED TANKS PALISADES PLANT CONSUMERS ~ C<JMPANY Consisting of:
- 1. Specific Co~ition' 2.
Specificatio~ 5935-~-soo, General Welding Requirer:.ents for Shop Fabricated1Equipment and Field Erected Tan.~s.
- \- . . - -
Form 79, Fabricators welding-Procedure Specification J. an4 Qualifica~on Record.
... Pom G-321-C, Drawings and Data Requirement*, .
~***
'*: ~,;,;," *:;
;* ..~: ~ . ~~ :~ .
~*-.
,~..
*.-,_~
Bechtel Company - . San Francisco, California , __ Pill.es ... - fLD. SUPT*._ _ _ __
\p_OB ~Na..*_---- *i
- ~: j>
*.£ SPECIFICATION FOR .
FIELD ERECTED TANKS l'ALISADES PLANT CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY SPECIFIC-CONDITIONS 1.0 SITE INFORMATION AND LOCATION Palisades Plant is a nuclear power plant.to be built_for Consumer& Power-Company of 3ackson, Michigan by Bechtel Corporation. Initial operation is scheduled for May, 1970. The site is located ori the east. shore of Lake *.Michigan ,r.: approximately five lliles south of the city of South Haven, Michigan and 17 miles north of Benton Harbor. A spur track, due for CDlllpletion in April, 1967, will run from the plant area to the existing Chesapeake and Ohio railroad line, which passes within 2 miles of the *ite*. *,,,
*~-
Interstate Highway l-196 and the Blue Star Highway (old u.s. Highway 31) pass alo119 the east boundary of the property .
*ite. _.
- _ \ .* *
- _ _
The plant acc"ess road, wi\:h a maximum grade of n, connects to the Blue Star Highway.! Within the plant site, additional *
- loop roads have IEen built '.with a fi\ maximum grade. During * .,-
the construction period the road subgrade will be completed but the road will not be paved. 1.1 Facilities furnished by Contractor: Potable water at existing outlets.
~*
"b) Electrical pow9r at uo ~olts, 3 phis.se~ -Subco~tractOr -*
shall provide load center and all extensions. c) Toilets at exl*ting locations._ dJ .Storage and vork area as designated by job superintendent (excluding means of protection
~gainst elements).
I e) IdentHication badges for Subcontractor's employees* **. and visitors.
., f) ~Designated parking facilities for employees
*private vehicles. No private vehicles will be allowed on the plant site, except as approved by the Contract.or.
.,_. 2.0 SCOPE OF' WOllK -..z
'* 2.1 work Included The *:subcontractor shall furnish all materials, labor, \
equipment, and facilities necessary to design, fabricate and erect the following storage tanks as specified herein, in accordance with this specification an4 attached drawings: *
.I
. 2.**1.l Item fl. One (1) Condensate Storage Tank 2 .1. 2 . Iteni f2. One (1:) Primary Supply Makeup Water Tanlt.
(No. 'l'-81) * !J** 2.1.J . Item 13. One (1) Safety Injection and P.efueling \ Water Storage 'l'ank (No. T-58) ** 2.1.4 Item f4. One (1) Domestic water Storage Tank (No. T-7) 2.2 Work Ngt Included The following items of work.are not included and will be furnished by the Contractor:
-,,.*. 2.2.l Concrete foundations, reinforcing steel~ sand pads, anchor bolts, and valve pit.
*~t' ,_ 2.2.2 Piping an4 valves external to the tanks as
*- ~*r ahQwn on the requirement clrawings.
2.2.3 Instruments, Btfitches, or control devices.
~*:. 2.2.4 Disinfection of tanks.
*O All interior coatings and the finish exterior 2.2.s coating for steel tanks will be done by the
*J ContractorJ there will be no coatings of aluminum tanks.
.:1
~ 3.0 *SCHEDULE REQUIRF.MEN'l'S In order to meet the construction sche4ule, field
- J.l erectlon (including testing and inspection) of the
*5
~anks shall conform to the fol101r."ing schedule:
-> Foundation Ready for Tank
.Item 11,
- 12, and U
. Tank Installation March l, 1968 Completion Date.
&eptember 15~ i968 r
,. Novemb.er 29, 1968 13 september 15, 196e 2 -
~** .i:-
3.2 Subcuntractor ahall coordinate hiu construction achedule with the Contractor's job aupcrintendent. Subcontractor has the option of *tarting work later than the da~e founda~ions are ready providing work is completed in accordance with above achedule. J.3 Each Bidder shall submit with his bid a detailed 4esign, fabrication, and erection schedule based upon the construction schedule listed above *
** o DRAWINGS
'l'he following attached drawings fora a part of this Drawing Number ruk
.:~*
5935-C-37 Fie14 Erected Tanks-Sheet'). l~.:.
*'* .. ' '~
5935-C-ll l'ield
, Erected Tanks-Sheet 2 .. _. *-
-~**
;~
5.0 CODES ARD STANMRDS
-~ ',
'!he codes and atandard* hereinafter referred to shall fora a part of this specification to the extent indicated by *'<-
reference hereto. Unles' olherwi*e noted, all references ~
*ball be to the latest re\rision of the code or standard. 'l'he abbreviations listed belaif, where used in this specification, shall have the following meaninga
- I { ~t A.!>>. I. -American PetroleUJI Institute A.S.A. -American Standards Association .
A.11.V.A. -American l'1ater works Association
- A.S.'f.'1. -American Society of Testing Material*
s.s.p.c -steel Structures Painting Council . SUBCON'l'RAC'l'OR' S DB'l'AIL DRAWINGS ARD DATA '} : . ;:. ? ";;..::*:. ~* Subcontractor shall *ubait detail drawings in Conformance *- with Form G-321-C attached hereto. Submittals shall include tank plate design calculations and all other information necessary for the Contractor to complete the design of foundations and to locate the anchor bolt settings. Drawings shall provide *ufficient detail *howing connections to the pipin; and equipmen't furnished by the Contractor. All drawin~s submitted by the Subcontractor must bear the following identification in or near the title blocks lft P&lisades Plant 0 Consumers Power Company Subcontract 5935-C-18 3 -
. -**.. ~. *\*
**~"
":), '1'hc Contractor will examine all drawin9s furnished and .
will return one print with comments or approval. Fabrication t~. :*_i . of the tanks* shall not commence until detail and erection 4rawinga have been approved by the Contractor. Such approval"
' ~~- -;~
- ~;.
*Will apply only to general arrangement and shall not relieve "the Subcontractor from responSibility for adherence to .
specifications or correctness of design, detail and dimensions~
- Pinal certified prints of all drawings, revised as required <:i by the Contractor, shall be furnished by the Subcontractor within the specified time after approval of preliminary drawings.
- l. 0.
- TANK SPECIFICATION 7.1 General
,~ The Subcontractor shall be completely responsible for
. the design, fabrication, and erection of the tanks.
7.2 Alternates
*Y .i*
- Bidders aay elect to aubmit proposals usin9 either welded ateel or alUminum materials for the Condensate Storage Tank (Item 11), Primary Supply Makeup Water * *
*storage Tank (Item 12), anc! the Safety Injection and Refuelinq t:ater Storage Tank (Item 13). No alternate will be accepted for the Domestic Water *Storage Tank (Item t*>. ,.
. 7.3 Design Standards and Codes
- 'l'he Subcontraetor shall be completely responsible
,. ~:~. : '.: for the design, fabrication and erection of the tanks
-'~ ;
S- ln accordance with the applicable standards and codes. SUbcontracto~ sha:).l submit his proposal in accordance vi th these standards and shall not interpret any section-~ ..
~f this specification as waiving in part or in whole ** **.
any require!llellt of the referencod standards and code*. other than the minimlllll required by the applicable . *. .
. atandards and codes. It ia the intent of this specifi- :;:.
*.cation to obtain welded vessels to be built in accordance**
-with the appropriate standards of API Standard 620, *
*ASA Standard B 96.l, and AWWA D 100, as listed below: '
,, . A ernate A A ternate *.. B
} .....
.,:F-------~------t w,..e'""l'""d'-"ed=-..::;;S~te=e..::;;l__,1-'A=lum=i:;;n;;;.:um=._.*--
- 1. Condensate Storage 'l'ank API Standard ASA Stand~
(Item 11) 620 B. 96. l i .. Primary Supply Hakeup Water API Standard ASA Standard Storage Tank (Item 12) 620 B 96.l
Aiurnate :..A. -f~t.~t~*a* Welded Steel I Alw::dm= .. J. Safety Injection and lltefuel API Standard l MA Standard 11\CJ Water Tank (Item fl) '.o
- 620 ' I .8 '9' 1 0
- t. Domestic Water Storage Tank AWA DlOO *IA (Item HJ *~
- . ~-.*
'*' DESIGN 7.C.l General
*-* -*~ '
-~.. ,- ~-
:0 t.t.2 'hnk Dimensions and capaciti**
. fte' Unk dimension* an4 capacit:iea *bown bel.Ow an4 on the drawing* are ainimwa. '1'he *torage . ~~
W>lmne mhall be . . .sured to ~ overflow Of the-_ respec:tiw tanks. 'lank height* *hall be btcreaftd to provide aiaimWI capacities i f requi,red for * ._.. clearance of roof aupports or truaHs. Dimensions aD4 capacities are u follows*
..... ,t*
Jt;p Ila 'Condensate Sto~age 'lank-21 '.;*feet diam.t.r~j~;
. i i feet lilgh. capacity 125,000 ~all~-*~,.:*,
~ " ... .
- . Jt,a 12 1 Jlri!lary fupply MAkeup StOraqe 'l'aDk~ -._
.** .. 22 feet dlmter iii427 feet high. *-'*
*' .... ... Capacity 75,000 gallou. \;
- _,_
~*1t
~<*:-
~- ,p_
- _,: - ., !tea llr *safety In;lection *...a RefueiincJ water :_.,* ~~~;.
...;,. ~ ,..,
. -~ - Storaqe Tank- 46 feet diameter ana .24 'feet llLJii. Capacity 285,000 gallons. .cc._, .\',
- ~- {*'
I t
- Uc Domestic water ltoraqe 'l'ank- U feet ,
. Cliaaeter and 14 feethigh. Capacity ' ~ .
15 ,ooo 9allou. . . -;. 'h N lJ') 7.t.3 lioadinq* ----*:._,.,,.*-:I ~o*;,_ *tile tank* *ball be dedqned to withstand noraal .-t forces (ilssumin9 the tank* to be fa.111, i
~,
operating
- ._ . ; combined with th* greater of the two loading*
., 11"84 below without exceeding allowable .code
*t:reuesa ,, .. _, __ -
'~~~.~::,~; '~
~- t
.,._ - 5
*f ~-..:
=--:;'
t:on * . -
~ - - ~* ..
. . 199_.- ::*? *<\~; ~t:'*'. ;_:_~:':;;~ .
- 1) Wind loadin91 ~o pet all tank( . -\ ...
.2) Seismic Loadinf Item 11 Items 12 and 14 Item 13 In addition, Itelll& 11 and U shall be designed t:o
- withstand normal operating forces (assmning the tank
.to be full) combined with cataatropbic aeiamic loads~
liated below without exceeding aaterial yield
- atreaseaz ..
- Seimnic Loadinn Item 11 .
Item 13
~ank roofs shall be l!esi911ec! to withatan4 a 8DOW J.C\&d. ;
7.5 Conditiona of Service .,. ;*:,*_:_.,.'
}
7.5.1 The site is at an elevation of 600 feet above '.isea
- i lexel. Ambient air temperature may vary from lidnus1:
-- let'£ to Plus. 95~~ DB. ~e tanJts wf outaoors- and &uu ect to so 1 ar--lieat ng.
11 be erected ..:.* *::: 7.5.2 The Condensate S oraqe Tank will receive or 41achaig conden11&te in accordance with the requirement*. of the condensate feedvater syatem. Condensate entering may have a temperature of 12001' and pJI
*will range between &.I and 1.5. _
'J.5.3 *'l'he Primary Supply Hake Up Water Storage ~ * :0~ .
will receive water frO!ll the deaineraliser unit, . -**., and may receive water at a temperature of 100 F *. ud vi th a pH will range between 6. I and 7 *I. .
- 7.5.4 The Safety Injection and RefuellngWater Storage .
Tank will handle a 1' solution of Boric AciQ &!3803l and may receive water at a temperature of 125 ~ *:~:. 7_.5.$ 'the Domeatic Water Storage Tank will r~iVe filtfir:.. e4 water at a maximum temperature of 100 F .fr011 a well pump1 pH will ranqe from 1.1 to 8.4 *. :.*, _2:.~':-:* 7.5.fi . All tanks will bave_ external tank bCtatJ.., *;~ ,(':*-. *,
*~' .
furnished by the Contractor
- 0
- Minblu:a c:'-sign °'\;'
water temperature will be *o 1. * . , ;. ;:_;.,....,.__ ~: >N - *.*
'...=**
- 7. 5. 7 All tank* ahall be Yented t:o atmosphere. * ; * *- ft -:'
Connections
. \ . ....~...-
,_*:;***1
- ~::
. ;* ~ i; *""'*"
'\.'- f .. 7;.6.1 The subcontract.or shall pmi4e connectiona' , ..
***.* in accorc!ance with attached Clrawinqs. Subcontrac-tor will have the option of field welding or* . 1,,
*ahop ve14ing the connections. 'l'he Bi4der *~all describe in the bid proposal the miethod he .. _
proposes to uae. :..
~;.;_ t.
6
~s*
~ .. *' ~-
_,;*, . .; '" ~~* ~-~
*~: .
If field welded, ~he tank floor penetrations J, shall be at least 3* larger t~an the outside diameter of the specified pipe. The floor penetrations shall be reinforced with a
":reinforcement ring on the un::lerside of the
_> tank floor. After the tank is in place, a
. ;;:,.** filler plate with the penetration the same _
*ize as the outside diameter of the respective plate will be .cut to fit the floor penetration' .
..* ~"* '.
and butt welded in place. In the case of flush * .--; * ~llOunted floor drains, the filler plate will - :;. .. . __
. have e sleeve welded to i t and then the plate */'.,' *,.~i~.i;'
will be cut and welded into its floor penetration. ( *
-- Details of field welded connections are shatm * * <',)-
,. on requirement drawings. ,. * ;.:;c;~
..... ..:. ,.t:.
'\ . .
- ,. . ~~*.**.
- 7.6.2~sCrewed connections shall be in accordan~ ~tb NPT standards. Weld-end preparations ehall be in acco~ance with Bechtel Standard drawings ~;
.which will be forwarded after aware! fo the *,. * ;.;;-
order. Flanqed ends shall ccnform to ASA Stanc!ard. B-16.5.
'7.6.3 Final orientation of connections will ~ approved
-.~
by ~e Contractor after p!acez:ent of the order * .,
.~- . 7.6.4 Co~ction aize* 111ay be d.anged (+ one standard .
> pipe sbe) due to chanqes in the en9ineeri09 :.'
design. If this happens before fabrication .-. drawings are approved by the Contractor the SUbcontractor *hall make the changes at no extra cost to.the Contractor.
-~*.'
. 7.7
- Material -* .; * ~- .... } . <'
\~'.;, '*'. 1. 1 .1 * *Al terna~~ ~elded I\ steel ~~oratje tanks in *. '*
'.*.;*':* .- * *, -* .,:: f* conformance With API Standard 620 (applies to ~- * ._
- * * * .**{~~'. *
- ltemS ll, U, aiid ill . :
. *:.h " Bottom, 8hell and roof "uterial shall be steel
-~~~:*~
... I
*in conformance vi th one of the following AS'l'H
***i::~~~ c .
A515, Grade 55 or 60 _.,.
* * ~442, Grade 55 or fiO _ *'. ' ._,, , 'I Bottom plates for safety injection and refueling"
.. tank (Item fl) ahall be 5/16* minimum in thickness.
- Bottom plates for other tanks shall be 1/4 * *
- minimum in t.hickncsa.
*, ,.t; ';- ~ ..
~:'
-, ~ .,.,~:
*~
.~... ....~j_' .~ ..
r,,'_r' --i
' .....-**~ :--~ j
.<>'.*.~ .:',,.*1-:~,:"
7.7.2 Alternate B, welded ln confor:n~nce with to lteir.s ll, 12 and ,_,~ ...;*i;,
~... ,;"
Bottom, shell, roof material, structural supports /~.*;~,i-.< :*;-'. :; if required, fittings and nozzles shall be ""'"- ; ;.:-z aluminw:a alloy Type 6061-'1'6 aluminum. Filler alloy specification to be used shall be sub- ~. >~;::'; :>~ ai tted for approval. MinimUll thicknesses of. plates shall be as follows: Bottoll Shell ~ Condensate Storaqe Tank (ltei::. 11) 1/4* 5/16. 5/16* Primary Supply Make-"Dp ;~ Storage 1'ank (Item 12) 1/4* 11** l/t* ., t::;* Safety Injection and 'it'* Refueling Storage TanJc " (ltea tl) 5/16* 7/16* Depends On
*Roof Design, Domestic Water Storage Tank (Item ff)
~\.r.
'7. 7.3 Bottom, shell and roof shall be steel, AST.i. *t*-
Specification A36 or A283 Grade C. Bott.c:n and ' ahell plates shall not be less than 1/4* t:.hickness; roof plates shall not be less than 3/16* thickness. 7.8 Tank Accessories ... Ladders, handrails, overflow pipes, vents, nozzles,~" lllllnholes, pipe connections, and other accessories t shall be furnished as shown on ~equiretnent drawings. External ladders shall be carbon steel construction, hot dipped galv~nized after fabrication ln accordance with ASTM A-123. Contractor reserves the right to , determine compliance with the *weight of coating* br aeans of a magnetic thickness CJa9e1
- for "the purpose of the test the thickness of a l oa. of a inc per square foot coating shall be taken as 0.0017 inch.
An insulatinc 111aterial ahall be used between dissinilar 11etals to prevent galvanic action. Contractor vill
*provide necessary insulating flanges to connect to external pipiDCJ.
1.0 CLF..AHING AND SURFACE PREl'l\RATION 1.1 ~ed Steel Tanks Upon completion cf tank crectjon and testing, the Subcontractor shall clean the interior eurfaces of
- 1.,,\
'\
all steel tanks for rcmo\.*at of grease, dirt, sand, , . scale and embedded foreic;n materials. Sandblasting and surface.preparations for interior eoatings will be done J;>y others. * , :.* . *
'l'he exterior surfaces shall be prepared in accordance with SSPC Specifications Ro. 1, SP-1*52T (Solvent Cleaning)J No. 2, SP-2-52T (Hand Tool Cleaning); and No. 3,_s~-3-52T (Power Tool Cleaning).
1.2 Aluminum tanks
'l'he SUbcontractor may employ wire brush or grinder .: '
for removal of imbedded materials from the interior surfaces but all particles or debris from cleaning* :~ operation shall be completely removed.
'Oil, qrease or surface dirt shall be removed with non-chloride bearing solvents, non-chloride bearing deterge~ts, or non-chloride bearing cleaning solutions, followed by a water rinse. The Contractor may inspect interior surfaces followin~ erection and cleaning, employing ultraviolet light for the detection of oil or grease and will make e visual examination for the presence of oth'1:ir contaminants. The tank shall,,
.*.; be free of any oil ~r grease detectable under ultra.;.*
'~ .. ""-
1 violet light and other observable contaminants *.
'~t 9.~ PRIMIRG AND PAINTING
' 9.i 'Welded Steel 'l'anks
. '.Itri.ming and paintinq of interior surfaces with eoatings will be done by others.
~~* ' .* .- :*
The tank ~terior aurfaces s!lall be primed with one J.
.... ~**..
coat 'of red lead primer conforming to Federal Specification; "1'-P-86, 'J'ype II. Surfaces vi thin 4 inches of edges .. * 'i: to be field welded shall not be painted until after :: ... erection is completed. * .....
*;); '9.2 Aluminum 'l'anka
~:,. 10 *.
- o. * :XNSPECTION No priming or paintfng is required for the alwninum
. *' tanks.
AND TES'l'ING
/,.
.1. . *.:
10.1* Inspection All tanks.sHall"be inspncted in accord~nce wJth I
*pplicable API, ASA~ or AWiiA Standards. Certified
*f
- 9 *-
*' 7 ., .
aill test reports for tank plate 111*,terial shall *-~ _:~ furnished. Inspection and testing of all openings in the bottom plates shall be performed before plates are placed on the grade. Inspection of shell butt velds shall.be performed by the spot radi09raphic inspection method, in conformance with applicable API, ASA or AWWA Standards. 10.2 Testing Following erection, the tanks shall ~-tested in "'_ . ... accordance with applicable API, AHlfl\, and ASA Standan!s. The Subcontractor shall submit details of proposed testing procedures to the Contractor's construction superintendent for approval. Subcontractor shall *:.*:.:
'provide all necessarr labor, equipment, and material~,
including temporary closures for tank openings, . . ;~ * ... to i!lccanplish the tank testing. * ,;! * ";:<°':;;;
-~~~-~ . :.., - j" ,..
;_*. , *...... * -J~~*- ~r.
11.0 PAYMENT ;.,- ~:: . -~.;*. ., --~ ~<:;*~~ - <
. :~, . . -. ' :~~i: -
Payment for the tanks will be made at the unit price ;~, . achedule included in the proposal. Such payment will tie full compensation for all labor, equipment, and materials to desiqn, fabricate, an~ erect the four tanks, complete;
\"
in accordance with these 'Jipecifications and c1rawings. *. .
*\
**.~ . . :-
.. ~ '
.l v*.,*'. 10 -
,* of_,._,-*
- .:. ,i. *--*
~~-
.PRICE DATA:
_,"', -'<Prices for the following equipment in accordance with
- ,specification 5935-C-18:
Welded Steel
~~
Item - p,,,_,-ri t ion Unit Tank
' fl cona -:*'.~'-lt"e Storage Tank "
*2 (No. j -2)
Primary Supply Makeup ffater L.S. i..s. Ir
~:';~
" Storage 'l'ank (No. T-81) $
f3 Safety Injection and Refuelin water Storage 'l'ank (No. '1'-SB)IL.S. $ $ Domestic Water Storage - Tank (No. T-7) L~S. $ II/A
'~, __ Note: Bidder may aubmit a proposal fos one or both materials.
TECHNICAL DA'fA1
- 1. ;~ penetration11 to be installed in ahop_ _ _or field _ __
.,_eave you included a design, fabrication, and erection schedule'I--,
Any exceptions -to the specifications must be specifically listed in the proposal on a separate page. _ _ Signature:
¥dress:
Date:
.: Ii
t
'!hS. ~- ol ~"1 < 4&ta ncj\li~nte b to k falf'l 'loeton ntderlnc rs-1 S.-leu.
i 8ff tiel.ov tor 4r&vipP nr,.utred &Di l.at .. a *ue, . . llur. er Yendor t.o -s-ly vS\b 4rawtnc Ml4 **"
~ulraen\9 *1 nnU la order *-llatlon ln tM r&H Di' fnltt&l lravii>gs, or ftll&l ~
,..trig w1Uihel.d 1* u. cu* er final *rsw1nca. llr-snc- are t.o 11e tonar4e4 to1
~tel Qirporatloa Pow<"r L Indm.lrlal, 14') Nt!w Mont1*~n PruttS.00 Calif
-"tfibldon or llliparG.nt. J (~eet MilnH} (P.Oiie'~
- I .lttK\.ien: D. J. Olvcr, Proj. ~nJiraMitlon, torvarC vfth ahf~nt, orw aet. or Ul7 *ra,,Jnp lle<<H&rJ', for l*l'baent, r. o.
fidd 1natallatfon. forvan!. coplea Of' &11 tr&no1dtta.l letter& t.o l'urehaalJ>t: lle-lox ))65, !Ian Franolaco ~. California ~119. Att.entlonr Expediter. R.. Gephart
...... °" _....
1~1-I a CROSS SECTION WITH PARTII LISTS. WITH PRICES r*--t--~-~~--'---~~~-ir------+---~~-~-~-~1~--+---1-~~ u C SHOP DitTIJL DRAWINGS 2 i D CERTll'1ED PUFOIUIANCE DATA WIRING DIAGRAMS
.. Weldin Procedures Yes 3
* "'ill Test Reoorts No M COOE C£RTIP'ICATD ORIGINAL I COP"1£5.
INSTRUCTIONS P'OR ERl!:CTION Oft MANUALS OP' EACH J INSTALLATION. Ol'ERATIOtC AND TT,.£ MAoNTENANCE UST Of' RECOMMENDED SP'ARI: PARTS FOR ONE YEAR'S OPERA. TIOfi. WITH PRICEli
!1---+-~~~~~~~~~~-+-~~~-t-~~~~~~-+-~~~-
~
COHPl-ETED BECHTEL CORPOftA. L TION DATA llHE&n; i .. Ialt.111.l llrav1np 11USt ahov all Jnto~ttoa aeeea......,. l'l>r l'llrcb&ser'a deatp or tound*t.Sona e.!Jd *~Y ocnnectlor.s to other equti-ent. C.'l
'O Ye~r'* dra11tn&11 vtll be ""fc:ved ud apprcrred onl:r as to &rl'L"ll""'eDt ... contor.ance to t.'* *1'<'"-
ltt.,.tl:>ns and related dn1tlngs 1 an4 &pproftl &Mll not 'be conaLnc4 to relfcw OT alt.t~tc th<" tlll '!\I
....0 Yendo.-'* "spona1b11U.y tor accurac1 or lldeqlBC)" and aultabtllt)' of *tcrlab Ulll/or equts--~ ...,._
preacnte! \hereon
- Final transparencies shall be 011 mylar,
.' II P'ln&l dravlnes llUst be ccrtlrfed and a\l!lt aboY 1 adjaeent to \St.le bloclt, Purchaecr'* equli=r:t title e.~.! mr.ibcr, afr'* aerle.l no. and purch**e o,-d.e,. n:.-'cr. ~::u:nmr->nimb:Jc~~~~
- 1 Hs~1:£,'l>;~"R~~d)>'.b'k'iMS1Clliffi"~""'l>"l~Vl'~c.:gt<.;\jl-~tM;i<:)..'tU!IU)'..ztu=. Inttlal transpar~:ick.t
- rt -y lie e.q or 1.hc toregolria or oulld yell\DS ..Se fr= trultlesa aes\en. Initial dN"tng:; n.-
quired vtthtn~d&J* or ~etpt or tlrm on!.cr. P'lnal crnJlnr;s required vft.htn ~dayi: or rec~!' 0 or &!'l'~o-.-ed initial dn.vifl£JI, or vtthta -=-d*ya or re-c~!pt or rtra 1111119! .u .. *~'-~~ 1!1t11lr~ a-. t request.r!. U - 1
- 1 ..J... -*
DRAWINGS AND DATA RCQU1RE1.*F.NTS
'J:>D t10. ~9'.'IS CONSUMF.RS POWER COMPA~~y ATTAC.HW.f".HT TO lllOUl&ITIOM NVM*<k PALISADES PLANT FIELD ERECTED TANKS 5935- C-1&
DESIGN SPECIFICATION FOR SODIUM HYDROXtDE TA!fltS FOR CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY PALISADES PLANT SOUTH HAVEN, MICHIGAN PRCPRIET ARY PREPARED BY: BECHTEL ASSOCIATES PROFESSIONAL CORP. ENGINEERS-CONSTRUCTORS SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA 94119
*CERTIFICATION: fu correct and complete al'ld ~
I, M. P. LaCJache, certify that this d~;'ign specificationl£overs the design requLrements with respect to (l) function, (2) mechanical and operational loadings including vibration and shock, (3) environ-mental conditions, including radiation, and (4) the classification of the component as determined by its function and operating conditions all* .as prescribed by~ection III, Nuclear Power Plant Components, of the ASME Codes. . ,. - ~ticle NA 32SO ~ -- 'I
~*- ..
- S;?ecif ication 5935-M-382 SPECIFIC CONDITIONS CONTEN'i'S SECTION l.O* SCOPE Of WORK 1.1 work Included 1.2 *Work Not Included 2.0 CONDITIONS OF SERVICE 2.1 General 2.2 Conditions of Service 3.0 DESIGN AHO CONSTRUCTION 3.1 'General 3.2 **Materials of Construction 3.3 Connections and Accessories 3.4 Structural Requirements 4.0 TESTS AND INSPECTIONS 4.1 General 4.2 Radi0graphy CRT) 4.3 Magnetic Particle (MT) Examination.
4.4 Hydrostatic Tests PAINTING, MARKING, AND PREPARATION FOR Sl!IPMENT 0 s.o 5.1 Painting 5.2 Marking 5.3 Preparation for Shipment 6.0 INFORMATION TO BE SUBMITTED 6.1 Re~iew and Approval of Procedures 6.2 Drawings and Data LL.
' ~ *EPOS'H :BHla=
- "*' spe~tfic~tion III ATTACHMENTS
- 1. *-specifications
- a. 59 35-G-lA, *,~fiV "?., General Project Requirements b, 59 35-M-500, .':.* . . ..* General Welding Requirements for Shop Fabricated Equipment and Field Erected Tanks.
- 2. Forms*
a .. G-321-C, :t?~\I. 1* ~rawings and Data Requirements
- 3. Drawings and Data Sheets
- a. 5935-SK-M-1053, ~ev. ~1 SOdium Hydroxide Tanks CD b. 5935-SK-M-1054, RSV* 1 Pressure Vessel Data Sheets
- c. 5935-M-382-SK-2,"AEv* t ASME Criteria Locator
- co d* 5935-M-382-SK-3,:fllt""* 1 ASME Section III Procedural
... Requirements v e, I 5935-M-663, Sht. 2, .. , Weld End Preparation, Tungsten-Inert Gas
- ~
r 0 " 0
~
0 0
\
Specification S9l5-M-!12 PREFACE This Design Specification consists of dt~ign information as pre-scribed by Section III of the ASME code and of design information that is not specifically related to the Code. Of necessity, the two categories are interspersed. For those primarily concerned with ASME criteria, such as enforce-ment authorities, reference should be made to drawinq number 5935-M-:T,li-sK-2, *ASME Criteria Locator*, which identifies that information prescribed by the Code.
Specification 5935-M-.JU SPECIFICATION FOR FOR CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY PALISADES PLANT SOUTH HAVEN, MICHIGAN SPECIFIC CONDITIONS 1.0 SCOPE PF WORIC 1.1 WOrk Included 1.1.1 This specification covers the design, fabrica-tion, testing, and delivery of pressure vessels* and accessories in accordance with the require-ments specified herein and on the attached data sheet. 1.2 Work Not Included 0 1.2.1 Foundations and Anchors 1.2.2 External Piping 1.2.3 Instrumentation and Controls 1.2.4 Labor for Installation of Equipment 2.0 CONDITIONS OF SERVICE 2.1 General 2.1.1 The work is subject to the General Project Requirements, Specification 5935-G-lA, as wel~ as these S?ecific Conditions, and the Seller c:; shall consider th~~ in detail for instructiol"Ot pertaining tc his work. It is not the intenQ
~
ca SpecificatiOn 5935-M-382 to specify herein all details Of desiqn and construction. It shall be the responsibility of the SellP.r to Supply equipment that has been - designed and fabricated in accordance with high standards of engineering and workmanship and suitable for the intended ser*1ice as described herein. 2.1. 2 All vessels shall be designed and constructed for the design temperature, pressure, and seismic class specified on the pressure vessel data sheet. 2.2 Conditions of Service 2.2.1 The vessels will be used in the Safety Injection System as iodine removal sodium hydroxide tanks. The tanks will store a 20% solution of NaOH with a sp. gr. of 1.22. 0- -3.0 DESIGN AND CONSTRUCTION 3.l General I 3.1.l Design, materials, manufacture, examination, and testing shall conform to applicable portions of the latest issue of the standards and codes as given on the respective tank data sheet and the supplementary code requirements of this specification for welding and non-destructive examination. Latest issue of such specifications, standards and codes means the issue (including latest published case rulings, interpretations and addenda) in force at date of purchase order. 0 Adoption of any subsequent issue or case rulings shall be subject to the Buyer's approval. 3.1.2 All welding used for fabrication and/or repair shall comply with Specification 5935-M-500,
*General Welding Requirements for Shop Fab1icated Specification *59JS-H-112 Equip~~nt", ~nd shall be perforr..~d using only welders qualified in accordance with the reauirP..ments of section IX of th~ ASHE Boiler and Pressure Vessel code.
The Seller shall be free to euggest alternative 3.1.3 materials during preparation of detailed drawings and shall bring such alternatives to the atten-tion of the Buyer, but shall not make sub-atitutions without prior approval of the Buyer. All materials to be used shall be* indicated on the Seller's detailed drawings and ehall be approved by the Buyer. 3.2 Materials of Construction Materials of construction' shall be as speclfied. 3.2.l on the tank data aheet for the respective ~ equip111ent. N I NO plastic or PVC parts ahall be used. J.2.2 0 connections and Accessories 3.3 0 3.3.l The vessels shall be furnished with all the 0
- appurtenances shown on the respective pressure vessel data sheet.
0 3.3.2 Ends shall be socket weld in accordance with 0 ANSI Bl6. ll and the ASM.E Boiler and Pressure
-~
Vessel Code-Section III, Nuclear Power Plant C0111ponents. Q Unless otherwise specified on the pressure J.3.3 vessel data sheet, all butt weld nozzlP.s shall 111ini!:!um length of six inches measured f.rot:! the tank surface. External piping will be designed with fle:l-:.ib1°lity 3.3.4 suc!1 that the expansion stresses at the nozzles do not e:-:ceed t)ne-half the allowable stress range given in the ASHE Boiler and Pressure vessel Cocle, Section III, for Class 3 piping.
Specification 5935-M-382 J.4 Structural Requirements The vessels and aupports shall be desiqned in accordance witt. requirements of the applicable code for t.he loads encountered during oper.ation with full tanka. The two pressure.vessels will be supported out-door* on th~ roof of the Auxiliary building. Both vessels shall be designed for 100-mile per hour winds. 3.4.3 Seismic Class I equipment shall be designed to the following criteria for load combinations and stresses. Natural frequency 6£ the equipment including supports shall not be less than 25 cycles per second. Load Stress
- a. Normal total equipment Code allowable*
loads acting in con-junction with a seismic acceleration of~ O*l16t" *Al
.-I horizontal and~ 0*076Q, ~
vertical. a ..
. b. Normal total equipment Minimum yield loads acting in con- stress plus 10\
junction with a seismic acceleration of ~ 0*'3 5'2-i ~ horizontal and .0. 0;99 O*IS-:L.4.. vertical. U L.!J 3.4.4 Seismic calculations shall be furnished by the 0 supplier for approval by the buyer. 4.0 TESiS AND INSPECTIONS 4.1 General ~
- ~
4.1.1 All test procedures to be used by the Seller
- shall be prepared in detail and submitted to the Buyer for his approval prior to any test work.
4.1. 2 The Seller &hall be fully responsible for all shop tests performed as required by this Specification and/or the applicable Codes and Standards. Test facilities shall be subject to inspection and approval a~ any time by the 0. Buyer. The Seller shall furnish a certificate ~ showing the results fo all such tests. ~ 0
- 4. l. 3 The Seller shall give the Buyer's representa- ~
tives at least five days prior notice of all
*~
-e-
Specification 59lS-M-312 tests, examinations, and other check' points in the manufacturing prograin, specifically requested by the Buyer. 4.1.4 Pressure boundary items and welds in nuclear vessels shall be nondestructively examined in acco~dance with the applicable requirements of Section III of the ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code. Buttweld nozzle ends shall be MT examined. Procedure and acceptance standards for examination ahall be per the Code. 4.1.S Welds in nuclear service vessels shall be non-O' destructively examined in accordance with the applicable requirements of the Code except that where random examinatjons are specified the ... 4.1.6 examination shall b~ 100\
- The internal pipe joints and support velds do N not constitute pressure boundary items and therefore do not have to comply with the non-0 destructive examination requirements of the Code.
0 Radiography 4.2 (RT) 0 Procedures and acceptance standards shall be in accordance 0 with the Code plus the following additional require~er.ts: 0 oi.2.f All radiography shall be p!!.rfon:ied with lead.
-, screens.
0 4.2.2 Film den~ity in the area subject to interpreta-tion shall be from 2.0 minimwn to 3.5 maxim:i.~ for single film viewir.g. Single film viewing only is p~rt:ti tted for \.;eld radiography.
*4.2.3 A radiographic techniq~e record complete with the info~ation stipulated in paragraph IX-3350 of the Cod~ plu5 the following additional infor-mation i:;h~ll be provid(;d ior each item radio-graphed.
- a. Expcsur~ time.
b, An in~crpretation of the results. 4.2.4 "The B:.i.::e~- re5erves the right tu reject the ql!ali ty of =he film and welds bascu on int1'!:'- prctatin~ br his rep=esentative.
Specification 5935-M-.382 . 4.3 Magnetic Particle (MT) Examination Magnetic particle procedures and acceptance standards shall be in accordance with the applicable codes plus the following adlitional requirements: All cast surfaces shall be examined by the dry particle method. 4.4 Hydrostatic Tests All vessels supplied under this Specfficatton shall be
- hydrostatically tested in accordance with the require-
~nts of Article ND-6000 of the Code.
S.O PAINTING, MARKING, AND PREPARATION FOR SHIPMENT Supports and exterior surfaces shall be prepared for painting i~ accordance with SSPC specification SP-10, sand blast to near white metal, profile l.S mils. Apply one primer coat of Carboline C-"%:-11, or equal, 3 mils minimum dry film thickness within 4 hours after sand blasting. Other acceptable coatings are Mobil Inorganic 17 by Mobil Protective Coating System.and Plasite 11000 by Wisconsin Protective Coating. Machined surfaces shall be protedted in accord-ance with Specification 5935-G-lA and 'the follow-ing:
- a. Machined surfaces shall not be painted.
They shall be protected with at least 4 mils (.004 inches) dry film thickness of MIL-C-l6173A, Grade I, 'preservative or equal , as approved by the Buyer.
- b. All machined surfaces shall be masked and fully protected before painting application.
5.l. 3 Seller's painting procedures shall be submitted
.to the Buyer for review and approval.
5.2 Marking 5.2.1 A corrosion resistant, metallic nameplate shali be attached to each tank stating: The manu- """ facturer's name and serial number, hydrostatic o* test pressure, the desiqn pressure and tempera- *~ ture, Buyer' e order number, equipment name and
~-
i 'j
~
Specification 5935-M-382 equipment nUlllber. The name plate shall be
- arranged ao that it will be readily visible after installation.
5.2.2 Each vessel shall be stamped in conformance with the appropriate code stamp requirements. The exact location of this stamping shall be indicated on the outline drawings for each vessel.
- 5.2.3 Any a*sembly, pipe, or part of accessory equip-ment shipped separately (if necessary) shall be marked for identification in accordance vith the Seller's assembly and layout drawings to facilitate a.;s<:mbly in the field. Shipping containers shall be cl~arly marked indicatin9 items enclosed therein.
5.2.4 Each nozzle or connection shall have
- label suitably attached stating the purpose or service of the nozzle or connection.
5.3_ 1 Preparation for Shipment
-5.l.l . Interior surfaces shall be thorouqhly cleaned and prepared for shipment in accordance with
*General Project Requirements*, 5935-G-lA.
Particular attention will be given by the Buyer's Inspector to internal cleanliness just prior to closing, before *hipping, and at its subsequent opening. 5.3.2 All interior surfaces of the equipment shall be cleaned of all rust, mill scale, cuttings, oil, 'q" weld spatter and other foreign matter by sand o blasUn9~ .pickling or othe.r..aaaDS .approved by'the Buyer. ,_.,
- 5.3.3 Cleaning processes shall be controlled to assure ~
effective cleaning without injuring the aurface finishes, material properties or metallurgical structure of the materials. 5,3,4 Subject to shipping restrictions and field hand-ling requirements, equipment shall be sub-assembled to the maximum extent possible at the Seller'a shops: complete assembly being pr~ferred. I I
Specification 5935-M-382 5.3.5 The equipment shall be protected aqainst weather, rust, and mechanical damaqe during shipment. Tanks shall be sealed and desecants added such as silica gel for corrosion pre-vention during outdoor storage prior to in-stallation. The number of bags shall be in accordance with manufacturers reconunendation. Baqs shall be attached to the seals which will be removed. Outside tags shall be provided to identify the nurrber of bags in the tank. 5.3.6 The above protective measures are only minimum requirements. It is the Seller's ultimate
- responsibility to protect the equipment against corrosion during manufacture, in transit-and during temporary storage prior to erection.
He shall take such additional measures as he deems necessary to protect the equipment during these periods.
- N 6.o*
5.3.7 Seller's cleaning and preservation procedures shall be submitted to the Buyer for review and approval. INFORMATION TO BE SUBMITTED 0 0 6.1 Review and Approval of Procedures 0 6.1.1 Procedures to be used in fabrication and examina-tion of equipment specified herein shall be sub- '::> mitted to the Buyer as soon as possible after award of order for review, and shall be approved 0 before the specific procedures are used. Copies ;.:. .., "J of these documents bearing the Buyer's approval will be re~urned to the Seller and kept on file 0 at the Seller's plant. 6.1.2 Seller shall submit within aix weeks of place* ment of purchase order a quality control check list detailing the manufacturing sequence and in-dicating those points where Seller's inspection will be performed. Buyer.will utilize this plan to determine Buyer's inspection program. 6.2 Drawings and Data 6 .2*.1 The documentation requirements including seismic calculations have been summarized on form G*321-C, "Drawing and Data Requirements". The addressee, type of distribution (prints, transparency, manual, etc.) and quantity required are shown on the above form for each item. All items marked with "No" under the "Approval Before Fab." column shall be "Final" before shipment. -... 0 O* N
~
*~
Specification 5935-M- 382 6.2.2 The fieller 's record:; sl.all be maintained in accord~nce with the applicable codes anj shall conform with the following addition~:. require-ments.
- a. Magnetic particle examination records.
The record shall show the assembly mark number, weld joint number, examination procedure, acceptance standards and other pertinent information. The record shall show the acceptance of examination results by the Buyer. b*
- ~
Radiographic Films Each radiographic film ahall be identified through the use of lead numbers and letters ~ to show the following as a part of the radiographic image. N
- 1. Bechtel Order Number 0 "
0 2. Equipment Number and Weld Identification~ 0 3. R for repair, R2, R3, etc., if more 0 than one repair.
- c. Mill Test Reports 0
., Mill test reports shall include results of chemical and physical properties tests as 0 required by the material specification. The reports on supplementarl' tests required shall also be included.
- d. Material and Weld Repair Records Approved repair procedures and detailed written reports of repairs with accept*nce of repair results by the Buyer's ~eprese~ta r**
tive. PROPOSU 0 W (Outline) drawing* r..
*o 2
-- l3-
.~
*~
Specification 5935-14-382 Swnmary of Proposal completely the 7 5 The Bidder , alternat signs of equipment if, such ernate designs will better vice requirements.
- - c
~ ~,~
*!\ Tbia *chedule of dnwing *nd clara req&&irrme11t* io to be fulfilled before rendering final inwoic.,1. Stt bcl-fat dniwin!i:* required aod elate* due. Failure of Veodot 10 c-rly with drawin~ and dara requitt11ten1* l!OaY I 1 \,
~sub in order cancellation io die case of initia! dnwin11, or fioa payment bei,.. withheld in chr ease of foyl
_ltr14-L dnwinp. Drawing* are to be forwardrd to: ._
' ! BECHTEL CORPORATION
- Powrr a lndusuial Diviainn
- P. 0. Bos J96~
- San Francisco. Calif. 94; IS'
;,. \. Anemioa: .Jlr.uc.e..-2.uahecir._ __ ------
I-'
,c DI ADDM"IOf!I, fOJtWAllD WITH IH1PWEIC'T. ONI: Sl:T Of ANY DRAWINGS !fKCl:SSAllY FOii Ptl'.LD llCITALLATION- f()Jl'WU~
- i. : ~
COP'f OP UTTER OP T*ANSMlTTAL TO: llFCHTEL CORPORATJON, P*OCURElilF.NT DEPARTMENT, P. O. BOX. Jl'IM SA!ll
! PRANCESCO, CALIFORNIA 04\U, ATT&fril'JO'!ll*. EXPEDlTOa NAMED ON PAOE I OF PURCWUIE o*DE*.
~.~c,_ TYPE OF D .. AWINGS APPROVAL.
B£FORE P'A9 KIND OF NUMBER REQUIRE:. AND __.._ __._4-- COPIES
- l OTHER f'IEOU1REME.NTS fYES NOi INITIAL j i~,.....-o_u_T_l._IN_lt_D_IM_lt_N_S_IO-N-.-.-N-D-----ot------+--T-.-A---_
. ..-'!__-"-~--C-!::::::::::::.1..::::::::::::.1..~:::::~
- I :;t--+~F~O~U~Nc::::::D~A~T~l~O~N:...;;R~E~Q~U~l~R~lt~M..;.;..E~N~T~*-----1f--....
v~.... c __-+--"'~*-*~T~*------t-----'1~---r--~1.___--t
--~~**~5* r, .._ac-+-C-R_oss_;__*~E-C~T-*O_N.;_W_IT_H_P_
l.llSTS WITH PRICltS .._"~T-*----~------r--T~*-A_*_*_*_ "MT* .._*_*_*_c_Y_ __,1-------+-------.
,../l&tlSP/l&*&MCY SHOP' DETAii. DRAWING*
0
- TWA ..SPA*K*CY 0
M MATERIAi. CltRTIP'ICATION* NO 0 MANUFACTURERS QUA.UTT I I l.111 z N CONTROL. INSPECTION AND TUT
~DR,.. m:,,.._ CHECJt
~1--+-~~~~~~~~""""T,....,....---+~~~-1::,--~~~~~-+~---.1r--~-+-~~----_....
0 Test Procedures "'J.,::a YES YES wlSTS "ranaparency
, 4 l~._-i--~';.z;ie*._.~~-iQ~~l.G'ta--4--.*~AJ-SJ-~e-..~~~~~-a-1~~*14-*~~H-~-i-J---4~;::.&..-~~.M.Jft'~9lll------~l-----'l!'-~~-+-~-~.....:.....;:;'-.q
~i c:! ~ r
.::;'I
- * -- - * -
- l'ransparency l
~O!w l-JP~~PAUiun11t~Ji'.D.lnni...;2J::at~di:IJ:JaB.~~~--l~v(Ee's._c~__;~,.i:j-~jn~-~ts..-~~~~~l-~__:1L,_~~.l-~__.:l..~~
.:'"'J-ri- 0 cl i d *p i rransparency l
."Clti:j ,, PrseRa~eF reparat on YES ~rin+a -1
~...,, ...... ,ui;a.,;t::urers \lua.1..1~y v;>n u:;S ransparency l l_J,g: ~ trol Insoectior. " "'""'t - i .. -~- t>-~ .. ~- I
~ 01 'M~O- 1 Veaclor'1 drawings will be mrinred andapprowtd only as to anangcment and conformance 10 the specifications and rcbtrd drawings. and appro..I ahaD not be c:ons1rwd 10 relicw or mirigare die Vendor'1 responsibility for accuracy or adcqUAC)'
and &Uitability of maceriala and/or equipment repreaented thereon. Faaal drawings must be umfied and must ah°"' adjuent to che dtle block. Purdwcr'* equipmrnt title and ,,...,,,~. 1 wl'tl I - j :Sj ~: manufaecurer'a ....W number and purcha1C order number. Initial tranapareneiea must be made from faultless masien. Final I~\ :1 iransparendea llhall be on reproduci-Additional drawing requhementa will be specilied ia the Tcchniul S~l.o.tion. hHJ Initial drawingl required ~fr.A'_}j__daya of receipt of fmn order. Final drawings requlttd within_.lO_:O.n of I l :> receipt of.initial drawings, or within-1Q.._.clay1 of receipt of 6.-m order if no initial duwings arc nquuted. Th< b.hzcJ
""!: o*t11 drawing Uaft511littal requirement elates will be specif..,d in che purchue ordet and will take precedence oon tlu *""""-
;a:
DRAW1NGS ANO OA.'T A REQUIREMENTS SODIUM llYDROXIDE TANKS Y* PALISADES PLANT ATTAC *WEllii.* T~ 1tEQU1'5~T'*'::'11to
.~ ....*11arro
*~
CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY
\
** *D*[I &.O ll&OuHll.IL DIYfltC*
S93s-N-3a2 I'
ASME CRITERIA LOCATOR DESIGN SPECIFICATION I. GENERAL 5935-M-382 (a) Functions of the components. s. c.* 2.2.1 (b) Mechanical and operational loadings including vibration and shock. s. c.* 3.4.2
*~ ,-. ' ....
(~) Code clasaification. Attach. 3.a ' 3.b (~) Procedure for the preparation, certif~cation, and filing of the Overpressure Protection Report. Attach. 3.4 Procedure for handling various Data Reports particularly with respect to transmittal to enforce-ment authorities. Attach. 3.c! (f) Certification of the Design Specification. Title Page II. RELATION OF COMPONEN'l'S '1'0 THEIR SYS'l'EM (a) For each boundary of Code applic~ bility ,~other than piping, (1) Forces and moments imposed at each boundary. S. C.* 3.3.4 c
*Specific Conditions l ICAL[ DlllGNlD ASME CRITERIA LOCATOR i SOf"UM HYDROXIDE TANKS
~ALISADES PLANT
- PawEf-: CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY
~~ ----~---
ASME SECTION III PROCEDURAL REOuIREMENTS I. Review and Certification of Stress Reports Two copies of the certified Stress Report required for Class 1 components by paragraph NA-3352 of Section III shall be submitted to the Buyer, for Class I components, and one copy shall be made available to the authorized inspector. II. overpressure Protection Report The overpressure Protection Report required by Article ND-7000 for the nuclear system in which the components will be installed will be prepared by the Buyer and filed with the enforcement authority at the jobsite. III. Data Report The manufacturer shall send one copy of the Data Report required by Article NA-3370 directly to his authorized inspector and two copies to the Buyer. One of the latter copies will be sent to the enforcement authority at the jobsite. f._
IMILL: llTL/1MIC:IUIHS+:;."-L!'-!:.JOt:2 Al'PLI C:Aa.1 CODE ----4Q~~~~!.::.::..-=<'.,..-..=~ lll:AD: llTL/'IMIC:SllUS-+==---'"~--'-.___._ ~IRAT 111~ PllUS (P'S IG)/ftw (Flt-==.*~"""'lf-fr_.,.'---'C:::-::':=-i lllTIJllU&.l(TIA'tl ITC*4-1=!.::!.=~------I DHIGll PRHS(HIG)/TIW(F) lllSUL CLIPI? ,,,......,,,,....,,;,.,,.._,,~...._~~~.::..:..;~~
.~
IUMJ'ACTUU*--~1---------~---~--------------~ K*IAL "°---+---------+-------~-----------t WllllT: *1/FLOOlllD (llDllO) (RIQ 0 ll NO. I_...,__ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ PICll0._ _ _ _~---------+-~,.....--~---~~~*~-~,__~-4-1 COST CODI PRESSURE VESSEL DATA SHEET COtJ~ERS FOWER CJ:W.-PA~Y No5435 Fr\U SAOCS PLAWT 5935-SK.-M- 054 IODlNE. REND'J AL fAA"/.E-UP ~a..01-1 TAtJK T-103
EARTHQUAKE. LOAD'$ THL TNJK rs "'TO &_ DESl6t-..ic.D FOR '" NATURAL f:REQ.lENC { l Z5 C..PS. THE LOAD5 ARC:
)>.::::, FOLLOW 5.
~ ~!)
- 1) t.lORMA L LO/t\D
+"SE.I~ C. l.D~
2.) tJDRlv\/\L l.Df>.l) t 2" SEJSIA \C LOAD No5~35-000
- 5'135- ~-M-10~;
'* _j"'"':' .,
l,;.*
.f
.. ~
**). .
- -~...~
* * * ~- J; !:
' *~
CCllBUS'?IO!I ENGDIEERIRG, Ill:.
- 1uctear Power Department
,. ~. **
~ ~,J*r~~rr:.:.¥-?~tiizf:l i:.'fi.~:.c~;~f?
q;:;{:f<' ;+~ :.~.**~-. :~ ......*. <:; to 1111bicnt external pressure or 63 p111g once* per )'ear *
'*:*Where. ~cltt~d on the Data Sheet, \..J.vea .baii'operatc
* * :... aatiafactori]7 vhcn. *ubjected to seiudc ecccleration
'-"- SD anr 4lrect1on horizontal~ anc1 vert!call.J 1n combine.t!nu
.,vlth nOrmal operatlne; loads. Seiamic loads for each valve .
- ve listed on the attached Data Sheets. . Streaae*a hem the I-~* *1* ::CQml>ined a1muitaneous aeismic. load* em Danial operatine;
,-. . ... io.da and thermal transient loada when specified ahall not
><:-:':i~*::,~~;:* *p :: , *Uceecl Code ~lonble' atre11 nluea. .;_._ ,
]~~,!tlti*~.J, , ~~:..-:e.=w~.:!h:::;-~.,~..
~:
~i ::~;:<i,.
r , *<: ~1.,, . t.":::i="~:i.::=.~..:..:-~.!':!'
., :. ~~ '\ ~ .. -. frca to 'PJ°F ~ five (5) aeconda. * *.
- .Jn&Pectiona _
-<f0
,.1.1 ~ valves abllll be inspected in accon!ance with the requirement* of Bererencea 3.1.1, 3.1.2, an4 3.1.3 u
{~- }:: QPJ.lc:.~le. .. '* . !**
..'5.1~! Vahea *ciassified aa BOOW.R are ao 4ealgnate4 w the *
~ "lilUcLEAR SERVICE" u noted on ~ Data Sbeeta.
,5.1.3 Valw*'* classified as JitX:IEAR ahall cOlllP1¥ vith all the
** l 1
.zequirements of References 3a.1, 3.1.2, and 3.1.3. *. All
*'.,: _~ ~
- other valns ahall comply with Reterencea 3.1.1 ud 3.1.2 *
~*5.1.I. '.
Jlefecta in pressure. retaini~ parts u defined b7 Reference 3.1.i. aball be repaired ill accordance vitb te B
* :~'.* ,.,; ,_.. ,._ reference. _ . . . :o
'*'
- 5.1., Refer 'to Reference 3.1 *.'4, paragraph 5.0, hir' .M1t1onai teat Pd inapectlon requirement&.
*:* ~-~ .; :_, :,_.2 *. !m!
- Water uaed tor hydrostatic testine and cleaning shall
*be clemlneralhed vitb a 11exill1W!I conductivity or 2.0 aicro-mho 1 an4 a llaXlmum chloride content of 1 ppm.
s.2.2 ) .. _ All YalYes &hall be h1drosbt1cally testM in accord::.nce
*. ,i with Reference 3.1.~ except that the test pressur.: sb.l~
be held tor a period of not less than one-half hour.
~ 5 or 8 Pacr.r.
Critical s~rvlro
' 'J I 1 su;*;>LY FAn.u:.t r rosmo:mt rosmo~
Fo;i lf!PUT Sl:OZ!Al Of OUli'UT 10 ll£
?EH AT As i i
._r:*
_I
,2 1Yf'£
'I II l.!ATEllllll 14 15
**1 12 r.1*. GAAYITY1 u VltCOSITY1
~ ltn 1
":.... '~
IS LIFT "* Per I
*upplier* recoin:nendat!:
*S* aub~ect to CERPJ> approve!
H UFJ Seismic Si11Gle 0.52g'Double 0.9lg . .:. ~
".;~.
I ~ a UFJ UFJ ll>-3015i Inlet-OUtlet, 12"~ Sch. 1i.o. K>-3016: Inlet, 12" Sch. 140, Outlet, 12" .250* Wall. i. H
.~~. ..
w
.., DESIGNER*
H DATE: DlTE: d
& LI;:! f'~ T 1' l!~"'!t.*1 i lr~~tlcn 11.M see "'~~!<
I n1,ici !,!::n~ UOUI~"?-: ti pAS[S J n~::1~:1 Trrl ~'c>t.<-r or-~1*11k<\. l'Jobo. l-LU~G-r1a~
- Br>.1!etl*ni t:r::."l=!'!J"*' f!.7 x 16!! ,p.______________.
~ .... 1;~,...o .. J f'r-:"'I"" 'i'r*nnlcnt. l'rr fr':c:tlnc li.5..._1_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _.
tlCCTRIC: a.se I ICl1b I W::';'LY FAILU::C: f'OOITIC:'f 1 ro3lllO:lER FO:t l!!?UT SIGl l.'11. Ol' OUT.'UT 10 llE ClOl:E AT O?W AT A!! 'a f'RZ$S. LlAX (} llllET II TEl.!P1 I.WC. 12 SI'. GMYITY1 EO- F II VISCOSITY: g 60' F 14 lift NDla: H 'lo 1?e furnished by su:;;,J '..
"* Per suppliers recol!::l:eno&t:
subject to CENPD approvb1 Seismic Single o.~Eig:Double o.~g
'l'hermal Transients per Sectic-:.
4.5.3. stem Position 'franmrJ.tter Required. Inlet 6* Sch. *o, Outlet 6" Sch. l20S.
-~ ...........
~-~
~***
l'IG' ,.._ 11\ICL *.At ~Vl:.IC'N
...,. I"'~.
W:-~'~1. C..>'.'r't:(ll,UT llElfONEftl ........ hOT**r* *l**':>C'"U':IO e., wscc 10 PV"'""SH * ._,. """0"'.,.*"*~ r~* ...... -.
., DA*~*-*~....... " .. 1.ac1** ..... , .. r * ***
.._. . . . . ** ..,.,.... ,.,,. wn~ *** co,.., .....
DATii l'ROJECT: COtflltACT Ne:
~Y ... '..~ .. k:-:.'. .. .!...:'......... DAn: **-/*)/.;.~..::_:. SU BJ ECT -~~:~.,.~ ....... l. .. !':.~.,.-..::.-.':-:'..;'.:,.;*: .... Ll.9'--~.:._z.N ..:::,._ SHEET NO ..... L. .......... OF ...Y.......... .. CHKD. BY .... T,V-/?
- t. .... !.-,..DATE ...... "'/17/t:
;;,... ><.u,, ~.... $.~:;:;;t-;;,_.r:1.~.1*. c... .........C.Q.N.~.F.Z:.:..:L°..!~.cJ ............. JOB NO ...................: ....................... - .
-0Ho0*---****-***-****H-H*Oh***-***-********Oo0HO_O
. . . ___ _ *-*******-********-*****-*:::?..t.....(;?._ . . ___1..............--::.-:-::**-=**;*-**-**************-.. .. *... :=-*****-***c..o_e.:_.-::...3......._________ _
i .
- ._... -* .. . . - **~-
OF THe.
"* - --~
J
fl Y .. l..!.~.. ;i.?.......... DI\ fE :"' ... /1 ...,-;.~* 0 SU fJJEC I ~.: .. ;.. :..'!.. S ......'....7.,.>-..-<.~,S?.. :'.'.. :,,....L.! ..9../....J*. U ..~->.:l ::iflEE I N0 *.. '.7.-::::-.......... 0F .-.....( ....... .1 . ' CHKD. BY .7)/!:..DATE .. ?-./J.z../$S _'$.~~.\ ..~*:.l.~..u:..........Co..N.NS.<..::r::.1.::..?.!::-L ........ _....- JOB NO...................: ..............*-***********
-*:*-***::*************************:-.-**-****.-************--**** -*****-****-*****--3..::.....C.?..!!...l... ---****-**-******--***-****--*-*****:.._. .....-.....**-.--:-*-****-**C.o...<3,.::__'f............ _............
STt::.E-L-,AS.:Mt:. SA-.3l2...JYPe347 (P1Ps) AT GS o.?f" Srn: I 8000 5 177 .- 2-7a oo
~,
/. 5 .. . .. **- -~ . . .*- -*. -
.3 5,7/-- .s 40~0 c-:_.:: 9, e.. 7 ,.r} 0-6. ll'// .,
//!'/* ~1=
p ~ \ b~$lG.t-..1 T;z.fV\p = G50° F
.DESIGN PR-=:SSURC-= 2-465 psi MAX- L"4TE"R.N;._'- -P~sss~~-c. ~ 3 \ ,-o* p.sJ
. MAX. ~XTE"~l"-A'-- PRt=::SSVR~-- &3. 2:..5 p~ J
. \
. . ~ ' .
; I r
I
.~ ..
C9.
..{"'"""
*t:fT _i .. :O**.~---*.-:-...........~ ..., j E.r.. -,* ... r..~.j-.--~1' l,,- SU ;:3J EC 1 .::":':-..":-:-:.l.X.i...?. ..... _L.J.:.:,...., ...."l._,! ..-..~.:... :~,-:.-::.... .'** ::-t::.-7..:*.:....:~.*~ ::>HI:.!.. I NU, .. :::::::.......... OF ...... * .......
- CH KO. B'( .rJL.toATE ~;l:. ?:./9J' . . . . . . s . ~.~...:...~.~..L.*..~:..*.JY.l...C?.-8..::::'..b. ~--******* JOB NO ....................*..............._........ .
' l
--*********--*****-*---**********-*********-*****--*--* --************-****-*:2.,f.............. L..._..........----***-*-*****---**--**-****
Co R- C\
- --*****************i.;_*********~---*-*****-*****-*-**
*- ' ~ ...,...
,.-_. c:-,,....'-*Y""
,:;=...s-_
i-:---3.5 '3.3 7 -- I
- 1. - ..7188
.--3.3531
/o.o
-~,
-4.0000
-~-~..,.:.
----+--{!;..-.
l ... b-L-.L..---.,.-.---l-
--:r .2$
.5 .75
.?SOO
.8J3C.
4 . o :::. 1 z__ ............L __ r t 1.0 .8750
-4.oe:.z4 - - - ...,..:;L_ .~375 4.o33~ ----i-*-' .:;,9:?>8 4-.10 5 2. ---+-..,jI /.0510 7.0*
3.~8~3--
..... .7812.
.29_ _
.-;!.$ ,.L_!_'!_
.. .. 1 .. -------***
~~
1.z...S .u..___~:... 3.., .7S
---**-*-- . -.A~--:fo
.ol 2.
II I
/Oo
t~ ....k-:'.-.-<........... BY......*. \)C~ D'T£?
,..,, '-/:/.:-*,.~-*~SU
.. : ...,.. . ..::..-" '--* 8J EC T- .~rr,,ir)-YR*=.*.r".v"*~ ~-v*~-,;..,--
.. o::-.***'l. ...r.............,,,,., ...;>.,J.......':'.............. ~ ......1... N. ... _.
t:;- OF ....*1......... SH EE T NO ...... "-........... . 1 CHKD. syJ:.l.1.RoATE ;.,./~./.~.P _s.~.L.S...~.\.i:.;:.............S:.o..r:':U::-LS.~T..!.<?..~---*******-***-* JOS NO ....................................: ........... .
--.:**-********--:***3........~~-l. ** J. ..........-:::***-***-.:-:*77:***:-*:**********:**,__ *.. .....,.....C..Q...=..~ ::::..::::>.....................
C N r::/ LoA.t;;i ,: LA~ C.L-'L.:-/~ ~__;_, ;*l'-/ - ... I
. I I
I
.r
UY r' ..... .'CJ .. . DATE .:-71z_1,.,,v
"' / .. SUBJECT ~L.. /S/'-// C .... lo/V/'/EC..7.'/.::J/:..(* SHEET NO. G. . OF .. 7
- ? ~//~'/~' II~ [*'.Ar.-~[ 11*: LI' ~"
CHKD. BY, ,;;;t.. DATE -/~~jvv JOB NO .
. I:-; p UT I):\ Ti\ ~:3.. ? ... I c.. 0 5-_s 2To10 II To 20 21 To :SO 31 32 To 40 41 To ~0 51 To GO 61 To 70 TITLE (On each ~\]:~e- ol output) 110.+0
~-------~--~~-~---*-1------1 COMMEtHS {On l11i;1 pat;f~ of output)* I. +O l(AO '+Q G v~ GRO Ro Zo 201.+o i
i Rb zb 20!.+0 I 1< 0 .+o Ho 30I.+ 0 If K0 l<a .+Q
.+o -Mb.+0 Ta (-H/2) a Ta(-H/4)
~)
T 0 (0) E~ Ta (H/4)
. II T0 (H/2 l sor.+o I Tb(-H/21 Tb (-H/4) Tb (0) 50J.+O I
Il Kb.+O p. 60!.+0
.. Kb .+Q WR I Pa Wz 70!. + 0 1 .+0 i K 0 xb .+o sor. + o 90!. + 0 1001.+0
- I*
I ~
--:ic.-1<: .... *.1c- //0.
I 4 n.r\'
- l. l. I. I. I. /O I.
3o-,/..87 2o.n Cr):.:; ,
~. ::Jr; B 7 /C~ Zo --1-------+-----f-------+-'2::::::....:0::__L-'-~.~-- - 1 A .. /~.7~ zos.
,,i 4. /9 . .5 Zof;,,.
~-. D 31 Z 1.9. 5- 2.07.-
~ -:*;
.._::-L!"~"~*- -
*' SHl':ET NO. 7 OF 7 JOEl NO.
I N P lfT l>A Ti\ ""
'- _-? .:: --... ~*
/t)" '":*. ?Z-.5.
_-!.. / -.
~* ZZ. r.. .*
2?.. 7 ..
-~~ /. /:).
-::.:. . ~c:.*
... I /:) c.?-':'.'?.
._ J 230.
'i '.
,//~ -~ - .... /;.
("-.
~
3o 1.
, ./..::)
- 3. 9. o.
- r. , - .. ,,,.
/o. /o. "':-.1.-1.:...*.....
//. //. o. o.
/?. /2.
/::.-:. / .3. 0. 0.
I!.-~* / 5-: --* I /""!
.._,_) ' :.../.
';::.;' I I
- I I a I :5. /-_:,_ a. G. -=-; \ 4 .
. ._..~:. (.J.
~ -..:* I
..... / . "'
~
. ...., . ,* ~
.,. I ) *
,,..~
**.I*
.,-.., ,....J' I"* j .-;
- I
~*!. *
.... I *"'
--*~
./'/.
..... ___ , -- 0 . ----
---? -;**
***~ :_,
_: . : ......~
._J - -* *
* ... t::*
......~
'(...
........ I I
*.JI
_.I .
. -
\.13 ~ H~RI Z:.ot~TA'-
, 2. \ a
. cl A -r\ . c ~!'-'
- ~
\ -
~ ;_ ~~ =
- - ;;;;> .._., ' Gi .Fz.~~,*~, r~"
.r
,i
u--:r- .* i ... 11.. > .... - ............ a;;1r, I ...... ,.. ... --;;.-;-;---*--------.;;;ir---.:..--_,~._-----.---,;."""";-n'";;~~-;.-~.-;-,.-;-;-;;o.&"o~.;-;-;-;.-~;OT.- * .---...........-."TY""o, ****** -............. - * * - *-I ....,., * - ~ * * * - 1 ...............h*-1 ...... _ .. . CHKD. ElY.1.i-1.goATE .;,.~l'l":.. c~.? ...... 5 . ~.1..5....~:\.l..C............~.9..N.N..~<.:r.l..QJ:L......... JOB' NO ..........................................~ .. .
--***:******::*..*********-:'.**-****..****.-********** ..***:*:--:*"' ...................................3...1.....C?..~ ...4:-....._..:*:..:*.:::-:-*:*.*:..**-**..****:*:::::. -* _*..*-:-: ...~.9..1::~.:..:2..........._........
No Los.s Q~ r*U\"l C. \ I ON
- Ss-1.s \V\ \ <:.. LoAD .s.
C::-~,~*
~ t:.; , .:., JV\
I .:__ *. LoADS. J: .A. -_CAN~\'-c~c?"
\-\A .s \.3 ~ E': N. A :s.s u /V\E'. !::> -
~ ~--"7.~ .,._,,,
5 /f'V\ PL1 S U
' p.' ,.1:'".J
. l
......__. ....... \ -- _...
MoDCL- C r-1 o ~ B e:: <--.t-"" t.J ..$ ~; .,.. s; c;;;
. v.Jo01..-D
- l M~
\-
s .= I Cl ,.___., .l .,,
.._,_.., *-*I'\ .._
AT** -1r-1~ Cc:=; N}F.:::}:< Or-= I Di--
\-1AS\ . \?.Jb~N - -- ._ I
\ G. f'.1 oR.~ D HAvG * *. L \ T-1 L-b ..J \ F A1'-lyJ E.Fi=--c- c:*r p 1~
11-t e: ST r~ ~:-.;.:: 5 r.:: .:*: l"-1 TH s PR. s 5 .s u ~ e-
\-\ o V -S 1 \'.,\ G .
(1-,
* \ '1 -~ ~ 1-. I) --i =
\ -- 2 -z'Cl
=:.I £' \7 \ I \ - :- '/\ ::
. ""2
..,_ 7 .::i =W *-.
- -- -~-
c,..* :, - f *..::J 1-( 'v CJ. - 1 ~I V'i
.0 -
-_:.i~
"" I *-;:;r
/
. 9
., C7 -
.- ~
I 7 :x ./_.
--....- ~;( '7=-X@
~? 7. /..
17_ ~. - - 4 ../l?'/
--. <<,1 v L_-
o=if /7= ><@
£
;;: ~- '7*~ ..r 0 =:_£/) <== ' =' n &
'**, <== 0-:.:
I
~ o=X(i)
A-" * * *-* ~-- --- *-'**** * * -- ** * ..
...,_- % (
~- CJ; -(@
/ ... E . ? .* . d/ z. - .. :* --
- -7 . 2 *,,a
.,..,~II'(). t-('7-Y)7)/ -t_-;r§/~lJ/--= /,'/;? V 1,(,)-+ q+ xw-; n /=f
- E: ~ .. ... - . --**** .... - *-*- --- . £ "Z - . ..
X ~ .tt"I- *=W
-z 7 1 7 &-
1 7 . '7 ...:- 0 I ** - - -*--****-- *** ****** . .** .. * * - * * * * --- * * * .. ... -- . * *
- --***-*******--***s*:::**g::-o-:;>--*.---- . *****--**:*****-*-*-******-*-**************::v***~-~-*-*:*£*******************-***-****- ****-*************-**************************-***-*****-****---
!**********************-***********-****-******"ON s or --**-********N*i.:n:i**~;:,.3--N:N**o*.::J--*****--::>>Tv'-!ST3'S'"-* 'i ~-~LT~-z***3i.va **-~f'ti"');."A s *a>l H:l [*--------****....Jn-----*--*., ........ ,.,"' , "'l":l 1-1c:: L-:~"1*v::" :-;rT**-.:-'.~:..:.*14*:=***~:--:'\"T .. ., .....rTr.T:.....,.""-". .1 '.J"=!ran.s .-**7;--:-".**:*~~-"3 1va***---:**~*:;,:;;,::"'-'..:T J.::1
EY ... l.~.. +<. .C?..............*. DA IE.':..[.:-:-. .. './ ...(.::;: SU UJEC I ....... :-w... L~ . .':'::......l. .. l.\.~-:.*.*~. ..;;.. :..:":J.:,.L:. .*.** u.l.J.~;::*.::: *.:::.:..1**'!u'.., SHEE I N0 ............'-! ..... 01- .... ::.-'.... . CHKD. BY./-*.:-/ ~J
-,.'*'. .L~.DATE ? - ,~*..........
........ {. - CP v .........S ..c.1.~ ..1.:t:l..~ ........¢..?.:.:.V.Al.r::.c;,,,:r.1.a.. N .................. JOB NO ...................................._ ........ .
***********-*--*******3....~ ...~.! **. 4:.........................................................*.. . . ..... ...:....C .. o ....B.:: er;____............... .
. Re-A c.. ,, 0 '" $
L,.::. 44.z.5
.'"3 rr. =
./
-~
'D .:= - 2- t:t~
I\ 2-- . . 2:- L1 . M= ~ IVJc. 1'1 c..
. : R-e. -:. z. \43 F. - /. s-..
T . . . l?. T :: -1. 14.3 ,::-*-+ I. 5 tv\ .c.. -. . FL-'- -~-. . . -- z:- 2.
i j
~ I \)
"';'.:*. .id'. """7
.;o
~I
(
!!: r~
0 z ! Cj Uj
,,., .. }: -
ifl 11.1 I- 0 w z V: w Cl - '
-J
~ . "'
ro.
*J
\iJ \fl *
~ ,0 ;*i . _J z
~'
t:\ . 7. le U) () i;J () r
~-I u.
()-..*
-f 8 . i-*
l.l) --t; D 0 *'<
.. I
- II i'-
N
<,. . ILJ
\.f)
L.
-~ '*
1~*
~
~ l~ 'll rn. .
/i
*I) J
,.'*J'...
,..~ ~t/
T' J _1
*6
~
D z 0. V"} 0i !
\.* Q
/) 0...
/.
I~ I z cr~i lii\~ ,_, i:Dl J)'
,~ ~ ~~'
I f\
~
1~*
}-
J
\)
..q- 0 If':
{l i OJ (() ll} DI
~
II Vi -z . v' Cl]
*' l h 1--
z " lJ)
~l ~ i v o.:"- -.,.._
. _. u: I~ L:7- 2 ~
5:l! _ J ii
' .f'l f'. J N
~ 0
- ) -:;1 '\"
,_ ()
I 1* a \j iI .
*-.J...
- .r_:*
II
'-.rl
,,i:: u II II w w I- I- -;* ~
-: ';J' j- bl.:" I~ I-
~(~I:::*.
\0 () ""/ 0
*;: 'L
\.)
*. ~ .. i..
[i ~
! L.~
I.~ l/'r
-l
~ ct
'l ~ !
- l]j
; ci ! Q
<:)
1 ~ ! 2
- ,..; ::t i.
OJ u i
-' 1) f-_y ? .... , ......
SUBJ ECT:_./.:.~.!t_~~~. . ?..J:.. ... '.f:~.C..;:.. ~!... ~:::.:...:.... .!.:i..Y.:'.{/;~.:::.:~~:~-- SH C:ET NO *. ~~ .....;.L __ QF _./E_... ElY h., .. .L .. --************DATE :'o:* .. .:...:/.:,.-,: CHKD. DY ................ DATE ....................
,,c::: c .
........ ,,.-?..E..1_;.. J:::;..!.C::: .............:: ..=::_.,_:_*,v..:::."'.7.. :::.:.t.D..,::~'. ........... JOB NO.************-*********************-*******-
-**********-***************;>.*~---*C:'.'..*.~-t..........................._...............---*-**** ~--s;..Q ..2'..:::-=::;:....-.. ********-*-**--*-*
7 ' I ' .-* C-r-- J' /1I. 0 ~ ! -r-A. .
--/--_,. )r,\..,.. , ... *-:. *.-1 ":'"
~. '"...;
.J_..J :,/ ;;. . . -* (.. *
- I - ,.,, ..,- I I I
/-;;i . .- .
1...n.1:"- t* , C::- V -
-*" c TC.. r I a;
1 z. Q, .o __o_o__ ( 8
*~}!] :
I -,,-- ( -- ~- ---1) c-4 8.7S - 7.1575 (;, 4 z_ 0, 7 f'.$ J Pr 2
. i 2..o.., ooo ( 8, ~~?:~\
U.->-- - - --------***--*-*-------- z.. . / ...
"3 C. 7 8. B f'~
-""(,.:;-(--:;* ~. -7.-1--8--7--.~~:'i) * ,1
~..,_-=7- . c. *'.:' c._5. . - - .' ,~
u; 1. 70 s-z. 8 p . 5 j
. -.._)
CI NC.. l::. *- 5-, I-;-,...., " ...
.. ~-
.~ -* C)---
.. r (f:"
I s r-,
?-,.
er~ 1 P:~ 2.
~Y ...\.:-;.,.,._1;::L.LL .... DATE*_.:/**?.:.;.:"'.~* .50 OJ EC i ... ~........\.. ,.~.15J.:::; .... .I .... ::*.... :~..T~.*-~ .....: ..:1.:::. ... ~.-~.:.? ..'?..-:.t.*..":'\.f;J1 ::>REE I NO *... 5*::?. ......... 01- ... :: ....... . CHKD. aYG.FD.DATEc.:::JU.:.:5 ........$.c.t.::?.t:l\L!:.......... Cr..N.!':J.:3:.~X.L9.JJ.. ..............- Joe No ............................................... ____............. --....~~-~.....CP......_~_1: ...................- ...............-................... - ~--:_-........<;;..o ..B..::...:::.-J. .................... I S 2* C'.) ( *, ) P, ~ ---=- . I 0 --r~ .s. I C. 5 Ls S. r.;,1 N; Lci..s !. . O;:- f vl'J c. 11 ;:> J'J p~: IJS~(. i1,;i) _., l B..S *.
-.,- .,.,,. *\i D*:;:._,I 2.10 ( IO"'r-J ) 22.Ls.~
I
~- ::
- /
l?J
\_' ..__ c/,..\J -
~ *... *.
-~r-378 Po11'\ T I.
-- =.--t: 187 F
7,.:-(--:---~=--=~ 8.7~- -7.157~- J
\. =
378 .
- -n*- I... ____-------- .._ - - ")
I '1 . p:, I
-.. ~ - ( 8, 7 S- - 7. IE 7~-
/87 77-( .--- ~ --*-*- l: '\ - /I 1~~.,
"l'
_s--
,9, {,-- ;:..... ~ - ..,. -7. /~"? ?~- .)
~*-;-:.'\ - :-
378
~ ,. 7.*-I ~- .. *- t. -* ---7"-----:-1) 2. I ;'?:;.I
.-* 2 .- ~ 7. I.:.:,* l.:.
-"- ( 8. ~--~
-'i
* -t-*:.. D 1; .-z_/ ~7.T;-
Ely ....\ ......... --*-***-*--- DA TE.:: ,r./.*;t'""" ... *
~-
- CE "'_D_--****_..,t*~~-
SU DJ --Cr ....... /..\.
.:.....--~~-=-- - ~ 1 --, ".,. , *;:-
.- .. *--*-***V*--*----**J.1.. ...... -J.L..... _,___
SHE ET NO *. _J~------OF _:, ____ _
-~
CH t~D. E1Y G FD. DATE *~.:-:.!.~-?.:::.G'.;'**- ---~~-1.S.IY:i.!.<. ...........C:::.r,,.U'. U.::: ...-.:. .. ~:1.L-;.L:J.. ...*_.______ JOB NO ....... *-***-***********--*-**----*--*---
. -_,. L'! -*-*-***-***-*******-**-***-****.. *-*-*-----*-*-******** -**-*******-* ------****-~-=---*c:;_, ______t_................ _. __:______________
- _______ c . o ..o--== -:::*~-----.
Si-1 s P.... R. c.-(1. I 4 3,._ 15 -"r ::;>, 3 y
- ~ (~~~~- ~~;~~-;-) -;
Z.. ( l. l ~ 3 ~ 2.. 7 4E-' '\
---------------*-- _..)__ = 3 2.. f psi"
-~ ( 8, 7 5 z:._ 7. i 8 7 .!>- ~ )
(/./43 .( 15 0, 3) 2.
--------*--** - \~8
;;-( 8, (,, c.s ~. 7-:J 8 7 5"2.)
- 2. (1. \4 3 -\ ""?_""! c':. ::?l__ =
3 52.. f'.::. I
-- lT ( ~ 1!..)
"-1r 8. l 2 s* - 7, I 8 7 5 Lor ~* E *-=-i::--1--.::. ..,.. *~ Dv e:*
--*---~-c:::.:l..'------::::'-l...---.,..._*_..i.....,..:.<.________________ ~c:.'
- k'c=.: ...-i... c. :~; o .-~* - -i--;,_
I r r.:
- P~-'.... .-., . ) t.:..-'- -..- .~\
--:** --~*
I .....
,: c. 1 \4 -z r-
.;_)
- .I .!:::>-
I Mc.
-c**
~---~
*A-..
....rr-- - ...
t- ) -l-) T""' El~ ....:,.. ,. .... D
.,. /; e.1, ,,
.......... DATE;.:.:.-;/*******'-') SUBJECTC.. Cl:lD ...Pr.;-.r:::,-:;;..~J..~.K'.r::.. /::J....1.!2!:.1.cl.-:=~-
y* SHEET NO *....C .. :********OF __':-;'.__
~*I j
rr\' CHKD. SY .-1...... ~ .... DATE ...~- -,1***/*/
.U .. :..~. ...... :'S":.c../..S.1\:'\.l..C. .........CQ.!.~l.~!.E.~.~..r:..J.9..1.':/........... - .. JOB NO.*********************-*****-*-*********-**;
--********-**-**:....... ,---~-~-----~:........4 ......*-*****-***-*****-*********-*********-* *-******--~.0.. b"?'....-:....=;:._________ :
t01t.-L 13c A -c: .s
- 1 ,. A 1::-_* t-...
-"-~
Be=: -,;,E I Sooo LE
?Lv s A 'P? r..;:o,lr\. 1 Mp, -r E'
*lS-ooo -t-Z(z..1.s-0)
---- =- 1048 .
0-= ps;
. ~ ( 8,=j-;i -t- - 7. r B 7 S"--=-)
.~ -* - ..... ;
U-= l;-78 .. p:5;
~t ~ ~ *-- -----:-I-;-:;!/~
. -rS;_.J--D.--*--Cf.-:..,*~.:.1* 0 c* Fl,...,v<r.'-.'r-.
~--------
HEETN 1 ~
- BY ...~-L...d*..I.--'********* DATE.~/./... /!?.;* SUBJECT ,,;,_, ...... i.. . ....... L.~:'.t;..;. ............r.,..""'.. -*******""******"'-***'*' .. w' S O *.. _. ****-*--OF'-'-..*-
CHKD. BY.... t7.. U.DATE ... G {' !"\ 7 /it'.,I'
- i. -A~!l.t
./. -...?.~..! .. ~.M..l:.~ ..........Co 1-J.1.':'A ..C:~,.r.1.o..N*.............. __ Jo a No ....................*--*---.. *-***--
- * * * * * - o O o e e e O e H o e e o - e * - * - * - *
- e e .. e*eeeeooe*eooooooeooOoooooeUOO* -*-*-*****-**..-*****2-~....~.~..:2........*-****--***--**--*-----*** :-------~.O...P_-:-3....___________ _
Se=c.T/ON 3 . G .. 5 S-f-Rc::'SS. '~T~N S.1TY Lttv\\TS
I\ DQ*.............. DATE <y.'JS- BY :::: ..0 .. v. 7
, SU ElJ E CT .C.~:.!\.!.D ..... J:).;'.~.S.. ~.!:-:'.("'.~.~ .. fl.P...V...~ ..1..!~J:.::l.:.._ . 5 HE ET N 0 ..... 2-... _._::QF--~*-*'**
-7..-:\~' -.......?..~1..;':.l.':l..~..~ .......~~}./.l'/...C~,..Ll.P..~.--..-...*-*******-*** JOB N0 .............*-*-***-*-***-***..**-
, .. CHKD. BY..r_r: D
"-Jt..l. ... DATc. ';',
..... \.- ..11
-***---******-*****.2.:.-..~..':...§:. .... --*-*****-----**:*-----**-* --.*--~QJ3-::..S..._.:_.. ____ _
- MA-r c~ 1A L- ANo D=-!71C.,N bAT,.,. *
- MA-rcRJAL-: Aus1GNtT1~ S-rAu~1-~...s.s 'S-r-i.:=::i:::-c....
ASM£ SA- 3'J2 l,. E: 25".15 J\ Io ps J /~T C,, 5 0 " 1=
. s,.,,:: 1 sooo .. .. ... "...
'I .
1.?.Sm:: 2. 7000 ** 3* sf\i : S-4 O(,) 0 II
. 5y.:- 2-0 000 ll
/, ' '5 y : ZC:.Ooo*
,, ti D6 5 I 61 r*{ TE.: JV\ p = ~50 c F
.,. Di:=s 1 c.1N. PRE-:: s i.J R~: "2- 4 s s- p .s 1 i
I I MAX t I N. T ~ r., NI~ ..... "P ~-.::-~; ~ v ~ ~ ::: 3' *JI D p .s ,.
,.. ~
** ~,
**,~
*....,~...........
~.- *.**-***-****-.-.U"'J\rr1-r=--i:;;.=:/77**z-*,,--****"'"*--c=.-sisurns~Jrr-crcr1.tL.<:1'..-:;-.,.r~ .. .Z.R..ES.~ .. k'..ii:.. ~.....C?:.9...'r!.. '-..!.l:i-<j.
..Y.'i.i,.T)..~ SHEET NO *......:.:.."!......... OF_C'..: ...~
CHKD. BY 11i1..e.. DA n: .:.~Ll:.~i' --*****-~§.. !..S./.'1.1 ..i::..........Co_v..u... ~.'."-T..f.O..#.'...................... JOB NO***************-****--***------**~
. -*-*-******Q c .....-:o...::.
-'""\ ...S!__,_____,
i 3 ..........
-*******-***-*****-**-*******l. c. ..!****S.-............._ ................--**-***--*-*
IT. CA~* SA-n:>r-1 ED 'f=o R.. lH ~ 5 e:1 SfV\,1 ~ Co N 1-..l E"t.:--r-10)..l.
- L:"!>>r..:-_
D~-. * ..... 4" 2.-
- l 4 9~ ~ . c..
S°/'\ ... ..$ f-1 ~ . -:.-.
~
SFld::O 1 NO ......... t ........ _or* ............ _.. . 1
*1 I '\. ~ D ~I~ ,- 5Ul3:JE\:.:T.S.. ..... ~.1..~.: . ..;._!., ... ,l,,,f;_.:-:',. ....:.1:',,.-'.,':"':~,;.;_,,,,l .. l.~.:.::.:-::!.J..1.-J'
~~-~-~~--~*zG.:~5.:o:T; liif?l~l* *-***;?~J..$.b~.\ ..Lc;...........Co..N.d.~:;;.T.!."?..d ........~.--
V J , r ( * * /"" .. JOB NO *..................*-********-*****--***-*
- c. CJ . .;:::.' - =-
*****************-****-*******************************-************* -**-******************?..:... c:....,.. _.:5........... _..............-..**-**-**-**-*-*--****- *-**--*****--***** .--~---***-....-r-~---**---*--
A.s CJr--1
/ / / £ * ~-...f'//-1'~...~ Loe..,,,\ l...- /v/C/-;3,.~*-~.:1¥..:::.. Srf?e::ss,:::3.s,
*ARG. Ex*TR ..,.:,.,.c::...*rci'-> *F'Rv/'"~ TH-:::: Co1'-1Pu7*c,~
Ou.rPvl 8 . /, s-c.** . , K ==...;::, Y-= o 2 7 00 G :.**s. *,'
- i
*.. ~
SAN\C" C0 ,,,,.., I
';~.
I I,.,* J "";"';t.--:,.
/~I .\<: S J 1'-l...S I ,";l E Si- JGl38
- 5..-I-/'>-, 3 / 10 (J . ..;. \ ? . .* . *,
.." . .-<tx* .=..
2..'l'Bs** , & } 3 (:;'5 ). = <- 0 Z.Ci'? D $I i ..
. ?5
- 2.. * ~-* ...._J <::::>.
~.: -....-t.1 c. ps 1
~-;~---..----::...---.- ~r;-**-----------......-- -~---~*~. -~*. ------~------;-.-.-; ~ ~ ~~*-* ~
CHKD. aYC\-:D.... DATE .;,i ibj.'..l~( -....S..t;.1.:5./~(...****c;,CC?.1A(.i:..!.C:.<:*.:r:-1.a..~l: ......_.............. JOB NO ...................- -.................._. ........................................................................ - ..........................~.............:...5:..........................-*--*-----*..*****- --*...:.....<..Q.B...:....::!............... _.
-4 12..
,'. s P."A N ~ e
.- . zo z.oo -.(-41 '2... )- : z.o ~ J *c.*. p.$/
f *
/. N- 4 L4. 4 . . . .. ..
~ b. . 2.S-)
r- .: :. * '3 48 . t:: .. *7188
.. Zo ~*
*k ( ter. Si;*~)
2.. ..
.S-.
i------~-----
. u CL.
\'2.C. lo ¥ ' . 0 z I\ .
. 0 .t>-
--~------1.---
~ "DB -- 0...,__</;, .~** SUBJECT ..C.t;;.. ND.....PRE~.s.~R~;
BY ..l.'.'. .......................... DATE ... ..1..,. .. .-~. . B.P..~. '!:./..~=;;__-- -SHEET NO *... G.____ QF _8_ .. ..: ... . f"',, r'°o ,. It; 1 CHKD. BY'.,.,,X'. .... DATE ....!:-'.~~r-[--:;.'! 1 I ,,. *
.............'S.c.1.S.M.! ..'-......-..c~.:*.&.~(..::::.~.. .r.1.!?..!:L............_. JQB NO.*******--*****-*****-**********-**********
-*********n*****-***-*--**-n-**-*****************************, -**-**--***-************.3..11.... G.J..: ..~-:--**:******--**********-***-**-**- * -**-----~-~--~"?... B.::_,,:::..........-..
s.:r. .
~b. S = I c.s 5:?5_ (-z_) - o =- .2..SJ eo. p:s, z.oq 4 /3 3 0 p.:s; LA"R, Cn c;;.~*T . S'Tf..>ES.$
1.5 *. 4 \ ~3 0 ps ,' ... .* PR s $ v R s- . c H ~\ ~ Vi ~ . . ; s .:SI I 0 p ... <,*.
*s. T.:: 3 llD
. "\
. ,.,, 3,2.S-l-9
= -~~o,oo.~
-.,. Sr~u*,~-
* ",..,,,. ., C:=
N- 414 ..~. *Is
. ' I -------- -------~ ----~-* - * - - .
CH KD. El -r(..~ 1.f DA TE. 2."":./.'J..~.?:_,~
... --*--*~£D::,/;;.1..C ..... <:.O.. ~",.-'./...(L.(.'. .. .7."°:L~L:J.-.:~............... JOB NO.********-*******************-*********---..-
-****************************--*--**************-***************** -***********-***-**:*~'--****~*'*****.;:2~---**********-**********-***************:***--*-**** . -*--'*-****C..0... J;:'_::....3..................
. ~ ---:;:> ,-:--- ~ .--
..__:::> ' J ' ' .__ - ._:..
_..q., 2.. l~r Cl. - ' i C*. 0~ ~E f:-; W1 '- . ,--G/ \._,..l
........... , .. - D
~.;; i*i c
- . ,1
' \
'":.?
_;>/ 2_,__,, c~- -~ lJ. A/o Lr--:...5 O,c F(.)1*.JCT"lor~ 5~1.St-?l~ ;;;:4?..08 -1'2/::.4Zl.37rt*
,,. "'~1- c.,: ":>' <..;..i.
V* Q. A~c \De~: r-~ - J I 4-£:7
,r- -**. :_ **
~ c 1-~ l-1 i ...:.
B3 oo p.51 ~ S;11. ;;:. J 8 oc ~) p.si* Ll.2. \ 4 Cl, .:_:,,..,I I ~. f'="' I ~ .f;J
"*po:-~ of ) .s
E'( .. R.D.J:i........ DAT£*~/1.. ?/,'..s 0
/'r.:,;1' 1-.'-.1-;-.:***~-*-
,/;.,,,
SUBJECT*'-* 1=. .J.,.J-./... **-****--**-'-~* '*-.*-******h*'-*"*****'.._...~ .. ..:..-;
.. '/.. ... ~ ...., ,,..
SH SET NO *.. ..;;; ........ _OF --..":? .*..*.... CHKD. BY ft.~\C.DATE .?..~.!]::~.~§ -.......£:.s-:..1..~.t-:!.l.. .<:.. ........c~ ;~1..,v~-:.~,.1:.1..!"?...M................- JOB NO ................................................
~.~ ***** ~*.1 *** s ........................................................ /'" --. t._-:; => .
oO*******o**00000000oo00o0*0000000000000000o00000000t00000000000HOOOOOO - * .......................... *-*-*-******--~.\..,,... ).. ::.... -.J. ................ s l..:: I .S !' *} I (.
-- //, 58 .0
..**/ .'
,, par.
~
1-, z.. I '-1 ls ,,,...A --! *,**s rc
..::>, I ~,-
c;;._~:--.
c.--,,........ SUEJJE:CL .... ;,.Lr..v. ... J~::E°.5'..:5..1..!.. :.:.;,._
/l- .
.. .:!..:!..J ..!.d..;,':... ' SHEET NO .... _./-...... OF .::::"-:. .....""-
... -.... 5£:J..:i./.'::1J...0:.............. ~.f.,t~A:!.~.. *::.:~.~ .. .Tl.<?..&!................... JOB NO.**************-*--************-**********---*
- ..........:.. .....................~. .1 .*...**.*t;;.:. ........l ......................................._____ ---*---~.Q.. 13.:::~)--**--*-*****-
~ ~
*S.-.
..*.*..*..*****... ,. *~ .:T ...* LJ" ..
"' ._t:. **********'-*****- __ ,,.,.~ -**1 CH KD. BY .. 1:.\ 1.e. DA TE .:....~.!.:. :":..~f:J ._..$ ..G.JS ..!~:ll.L .............(;;f?/:(/,!.C...~::T..!.4..~-:(................ JOB NO ..........-*-**-***********-*--*-*****
-*****-*************-**-**********-*********-**-*-************* --******-********--****::r_L_...C..'?...c ......~.--*-**---* ..-**-**-*****-*-----* c. (") ~ -..:.::)
--*---************-****-********-..L---*--<
~ De.s1~~1 TEMP*= &,so 0 1-=-
.. l)G-sic-.}.J. ?J?e5.SURE"-=- Z-4BS .P..s,/
- 2. I 1 pp. Lt Ar--lD S UsA c. E Ct) /./~i./ C <"- 7" I ;J,,,!,/ ,
BY .. .f,.L. /.t.! ...... -.. DATE :S/!.:~/Z...:' _ SUDJECT~:;..( ..::.~.P.....L.~.i_.~.. :/.{.v/!J:...... 0!?..~~-~-1.i~.'.5.. ___ SHEET NO ........ ::..?..-.. OF_....:S..____ _ CHKD. BY<;.r..Q ... DATE"J:-f.:-11~~*.f:' . -..S.. ..G...!5'.!.:::l..i:..~............ C?J.,.~:~':/...E.'-.T:.LtJ..d(._......- ......... JOB NO ............ *--******-***-****-*-***- ---******:******-***********-*********-*****-*********-**** :.______________ ,:?_~....~7.<.k......-.............-----*-**-------**- C (.~
*-----*****._ ..."': ... k 8-
--~---**---*---*-
S-ccT-10*~1 3. 6. S 11 S1Rcss "2 0 "--: fl:2_Ll- 8S p:S/. CAJ'l B-c a;..= 0 . '
-a:c-
-~
n BY .. . R. I?.f*~~~- DATE~~;:-{~ CHKD. BY 2.r.. ..: .... DATE .. .,.,i ....i......
. SU a;.;-~T,*S*'=:01/D. . .!.-::i;.:-;**f.!.!z;*'*.fl..Jl..:.~~-L~V..:'.1 ..~
- ..........?. .* ~ .. ..:i ..t.,.L .C:... ..........'>- .A./..l'... ..-:r. .. J. ** ... ..:V.-**-*----*
SHEET NO ....... :l:.... _OF_~5..:.. .. JOI? N0 ............ -----*------**-*---
-************--*******---------****-*--*******--***--***--* ---*****------.-*-**:3.*""-****G.......~--~--------*---*.:..*-*-----*- ----~..0. ..E...=. c'----*---*-***
-~
! ~....l-".S
, , ... ,, f.-,~7
~,,.,._,.-.;- ~ r-*-:.s ,;.;r:-' . fYz.~s~- s CY.::l...c.:;
I - - ...._ (_q,) .. I
.:a*.:
0 0 r. I :;;-:-..:J 0
°' 2..?
s-o ,, a z.. ?-JOO . 84.s -.J' ,.....,, J (_h) I Z..030. . 811 33 7{p. 7 /5"000. 2.. _z ~:so . 83 7 37073 I I. (_C)
, I '=>7() ,7=::>3 32.77~-
,/
II
... "2.. Z.33o .=:>38 ~87~8
~ (_t7/) I 2.0SS .B -z_7 34180 'I "2. ..
.. "2-2.. IS - B~ I 3 &8 z..~- . ..
~)i~f-r)-+ {)) I I 7 4-o ,7 Z893/ S>oo
-z_ 14-o , 8(p I 3558.;s-
"2 (f;) I 1750 ~ 70 4 z-:..~o?Jv 2...oo
- 2. Z7.so /, /07 ~S7SZ (i) I Zoo -08 33~~ -z..
(d) (.._ I Z-!Oo O*
' 187'.:s 0
34~2.4-C;> /0 "2 3110 ' /, 2..S z. 5t7-4S ,,
....., ( }f) I 0 0 -0 3.z.o
-'I'
'2... Z..485 /. 0 4/330 (2) I I '385' , 73::;; 3302..:S 3&.Sooc; "2 Zl8s I &73 2)t:, 3 z ::::;
(_(/)) I Pa ::: O* -* 0 4-o
'2..
~:.: ~ 3 - -1~2.S SI 745 - (-13z.s:-) _
~1-r* =
i ....
,..,.,~,-'( ....
rR01!..1 REF. 1J Fi c,, >.1- -41 s (-P) N= .7..r10 ~- c:_y~le4 17 ::- /0 c..yc.1~..s
----BY .. R.D..B........... DATE.?'.)..~:_;3 suoJEcT .. C.. .t;;°ND.....Th. *Z~.~v..z.~.....H!-?...r.t..;;..1.i':J. ...~.-* ~-
SHEET NO *.. :...*.*---OF __:-**-** " r(,. -~'::'...._
-* I *-r- \.,;; ~ ..
,-A I L.t..> R-C
I ..
- t -
Certif'ied BY l. L.\(~~.1/ Registration No. 0 'Z. '\ 7 'Z': ~ State Of hi 0U>:-Y~ ENGINEERING SPECIFICATION FOR. A PRESSURIZER ASSEMBLl_ . No.(~-001 Specification
-*--::--.:?:.*;:_~.
COMBUSTION ENGINEERING, INC. Nuclear Division Windsor Connecticut Prepared by_- \ . \,. \' ", * \(oj=t 094 J Date~ -Z) \9, (. (o Approved by~{;) ~~ nate l)/tn! <;) I qfp Co Approved by l<fKr
- Date /Irr ~ /766
-.~
November 7, 1966 Rev. 0
-v,**-;7,1,c-~_._,_ _ L:--~~:~;--1 1
RE_VIS::....:I::...:oO=N_ _ _ _ _..._/J
,__ _ _ ___,.R,_ev_.__1__
./-p? -;v Rev. 2
\
- Prepared by , l-/ V~
1 11
---i \ Mod. 1
.. *-r *
.l TABLE OF CONTENTS Section Page_ No .. *
- 1. 0 SCOPE 1 2.© ASSIGNMENT 0F RESP©NSIBILITY 1 2.3 Equipment and Services by CENCD 1 2.4 Equipment and Services by Others 1
3.0 REFERENCES
2 4 *. 0 DESIGN REQUIREMENTS 3 4.1 Equipment Requirement.s
- 3 4.2 Design Data 4-6 4.3 Water Chemistry 6-7 4 *. 4 Materials 7 4.5. Nozzles . 7-8 4.-6 Access Openings 8 5
- C9 BGCUMENTS. TO BE PR©VUlED BY CENCB . * §)-1© 6.© CLEANING, IDENTIFICATI©N AND SHIPPING 11 6 .1 Cleaning 11 6.2 Id.entif'ication 11 6.3 Shipping 11-0
- 7. © ;* INSPECTION ANB TESTS . 12LJ1 CJ.:)
7.1 Inspe~t1on 12LI-' 7 .-2 Tests. 12-......J c.o
. ., co
*.al*. . -*- ...
Spec. No. 70P-O©l Revisio.n 1 -i-
LIST OF FIGURES FIGURE NUMBER TITLE
- 1. . . Pressurizer Arrangement
- 2. ..... s~lsmic Loadings 3, . Piping Reactions
- 4. . Pressurizer Heatup
- 5. Pressurizer Cooldown 6.. Plant Loading at 5%/Min.
- 7. ... Plant Unloading at 5%/Min.
- 8. I e I I Plant Loading at 15%/Min.
- 9. Plant Unloading at 15%/Min.
- 10. ... Plant Step Increase of 10%
- 11. . ..
- Plant Step Decrease of 10%
- 12. ....... . Reactor Trip or Loss of load Or Loss of Primary Coolant Flow
- 13. Steam Line Rupture
- 14. ........ Safety Valve Operations N0'11ES:
~ Indicate~ changes in current revision.
(~) Indicates modifications to current revision. Spec. No. 70P-001 Revision 1 -ii-
RECORD OF MODIFICATIONS MODIFICATim PREPARED PROJECT APPROVED PAGES INVOLVED NO. DATE .. BY MA..'111AGER ,. BY ~* 1 5/1/69 Cover, iii, Figure 13
~.Q. Ht.., __
WAfti)) P./,~
*1-}/A., ~t~
~-1:.1.9 i/'1' 't9 I
I I . 1* I r 0 CJ'J
- w w
-. Q) c::>
0 Specification No. 7p~-~O~ Revision 1 iii
1.0 SCOPE This specifi~tion covers the design, fabrication, inspection, testing, cleaning and Cdeli very of .a pressurizer assembly to be used in the primary .. coolant system of a pressurized water nuclear power plant. 2.8 ASSIGNMENT OF :RESPONSIBILITY. 2 l 0 Com1:nustion Engineering Nuclear Components Division (CENCD} shaJ.Jl be responsible for.design, material procurement, fabcication, cleaning, shipping and AS.ME Code approval of one preSl'Eurizer vessel and *relate& equipment included in this specii.~ication.
- 2. 2 There shall be no deviation from thi.s specification wi thGut wri t:tten approval fr0m Combustion Engineering Nuclear Di vision
( CEif(C])).
- 2. 3 Equimment and Service by CENCD :.
(Add:ii~ional detail is given in subsequent sections*of this spec:ii:fication). 2.3.l One pressurizer assembly, including heaters. 2.3.~ One W:ssel shipping and upending structure with pr0v1s1on tG faci]itat~ unl~ading ,the pressurizer assembly from the shippi~g vehicle, moving it .to the erection site and.erecting it iDJ.to an upright position *. 2o3*3 Erecti0n spares:.
- a. TiWo (2) man~ay gaskets.
bo T'wo (2) each manway studs and.nuts. 2.3.4 Any special tools required for maintenance, includ~ng to0ls and fixtures to remove the spray nozzle and to cut heater vrelds. 2.4 Equipment.and Services by Others 2.4*.l The pressurizer assembly' support foundations and support_ components not integral with the pn~ssurizer vesseL o
'J?
2.4.2 Thermal insulation. c.tJ CJ.) 2o4,3 Rigging and equipment for unloading the- assembly from ttteo barge, m0ving_ it to the. job site, and-erecting it. into c::> po~ition. --- 2.4.4 Field erecti0n labor.
- Spec. No. 70P-001 Rev. 1 Page 1 of 12 Pages
3.0 REFERENCES
3.l T~e ~allowing references shall be used for pressurizer design, fB~-~cation and testing. Tb.e ~atest addenda or special. rulings in effect on the date of o::::-C.e:r shall apply: Later addenda and code cases.may be used i f lIIllltuaJ..ly agreed to by CEND and*CENCD. 3.1.l ASM!E B0iler and-Pressure Vessel* Code, Section III, Nuclear Vessels and applicable code cases. Winter 1966 addenda incJLmded. 3.l.2 ASA Code for Pressure Piping B31.l, .Section 6, Fabrication Det<:d.ls, Appendix *D. 3.1.3 ASME Boiler and .Pressure Vessel Code, Section II,_ Material. Specifications. 3.1. 4 ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code, Section IX, Welding Quali.fic_ations. 3.l. 5 ASTM Standards, 3.1. 6 NEMA Standard. No. HU-1-1963. Heating Units & Devices, Industrial. Spec. No. 70P-001 Rev. 1. Page 2 of 12 Pages
3~.0 REFERENCES 3.1 The following references shall be used for pressurizer design, fabrication and testing .. The latest addenda 0r special rulings in effect on the date of order shall apply: Later addenda and code cases.may be used if m~tually agreed to by CEND and*CENCD
- 3.1.l .AqME Boiler and-Pressure Vessel Code, Section III, Nuclear Vess.els* and applicable code cases. Winter 1966 addenda included.
- _ \
3.1.2 ASA Code for Pressure Piping B31.l, .Section 6, Fabrication Details, Appendix-D. 3.1.3 ASME Bo:iler and Pressure Vessel Code, Section II, Material Specificati0ns. 3.1. 4 ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code, Section IX,-Welding
- Quali:f:icati0ns.
3.1. 5 ASTM Standards, 3.1. 6 NEMA Standard No. HU-1-1963. Heating Units*& Devices, Industrial.
- Spec. No. 70P-001* Rev. 1 Page 2 of 12 Pages
4.0 DESIGN REQUIREMENTS 4.1 Equipment Requirements
- 4.1.1.
4.l.2 The pressurizer assembly shall be in general accordance with Figure 1, attached. The pressurizer assembly shall,be designed, constructed, and stamped in accordanc.e with the rules -for Class A vessels, Reference 3 .1.1. 4.1.3 A surge pipe shall.be installed through the bottom head. An intermediate heater support plate shall prevent passage of surge flow directly to the water surface. The_ internal surge pipe shall be designed to prevent large foreign objects from entering the connecting piping. Surge flow holes shall not be. greater than 1/2 inch diam. Holes shall be provided through the pipe and thermal-sleeve*to permit vessel draining. Provisions shall be made to prevent corrosion products er _other debris from settling into the surge pipe thermal sleeve annulus. 4.1.4 A.spray pipe shall be installed threugh the top head. It shall terminate near the vessel top with a nozzle designed to produce a full .cone shaped spray for the flow conditions given _in* paragraph 4.2~4 with minimum impingement on the vessel wall. The sp_ray.nozzle shall be replaceable through tb,e vessel* manway. 4.1.5 Electrical heaters shall be installed through the bottom head~ They sh~ll b~ individually replaceable. Heaters shall be welded to the heater.nozzles and shall be provided with mechanical backup to prevent heater blowout if the weld should fail. 4.1.6 Electric heaters shall be straight tubular sheath type for direct immersien, ungrounded, with a sealed connect0r at the electrical terminal~ The sheath shall be designed for an external pressure of 2500 psi a at 900~F in accordance with reference 3 .1.1. Th~ electrical c0nnec.tor shall be capable, if the sheath should rupture, of -retaining a vessel pressure of 2580 psia at 668°F without leakage to the atmosphere. The connector shall be provided with lugs for bolting type electric wire terminals. (JJ CJ.) CJ.) co C> Spec. No. 70P-001 Rev. 1 Page 3 of 12'-l?ages
4.1. 7 Heater Electrical Characteristics:
- a. Total capacity - 1500 Kw
- b. Voltage - 460 Volts
- c. Cycles - 60 Hz
- d. Phase - 1
- e. Watts density - CENCD to advise for CEND approval 4.1.8 Electrical heaters shall be completely X-ray inspected, tested at 1,000.:volts for 2,000 megohm minimum acceptable resistance, and tested for dielectric strength in accordance with NEMA Standard No. HU 1-1963.
4.1.9 Minimum Heater Warrantee Design Life at 480 Volts:
- a. 10,000 hours at full power with 5,000 on-off cycles.
- b. 20,000 hours at half-power with.10,000 proportionately controlled voltage cycles consisting of pius 50-percent and minus 40-percent from the half-power level.
CENCD shall state the expected unwarranted life of the heaters. 4.1.10 The pressurizer vessel shall be supported by a full diameter skirt generally in accor~ance with that shown on Figure 1. Four sh~ar J\ ~ lugs shall be provided on the shell 249" above the support skirt, ~ and spaced 90° apart. The shear lugs shall be designed for a horizontal shear load of 2:._ 96,000 pounds per lug applied tangentially at a location of 5 inches out from the surface of the vessel. 4.1.11 Clips to support thermal insulation shall-be attached to the pressurizer vessel. 4.1.12 All external carbon or low-alloy steel surfaces shall be covered with a paint which is resistant to heat and to a three-percent boric acid solution. c::> 4.1.13 The pressurizer assembly shall be hydrostatically tested MJitth the heaters in place. ~ 6 Design Data co c::> 4.2~1 Design Pressure -------------------------------.,----~--250tf"9psia D~sign Te~perature ----------------------------------- 700°F 3 Min free internal volume -----------------------------1500 ft 4.2.2 Normal operating pressure ----------------------------2100 psia Normal operating temperature -----.,-------------------- 643°F Normal operating water volume, Max. ------------------ 8©0. ft~ Normal operating water volume, Min. ---------------~-- 600 ft 4.2.3 Max. surge flow -------------------~------------------4000 GPM 4*.2. 4 Continuous spray rate ---------~----------------------1.5 gpm Max. spray rate -------------------------------------~375 gpm Available spray nozzle pressure drop at max. spray rate and 545°F -------------------------------------~-15 psi Spec. No. 70P-001 Rev. 1 Page 4 of 12 Pages
4.2.5 The pressurizer assembly shall be designed for a useful life of forty (40) years. 4.2.6 The pressurizer vessel, surge nozzle, and spray.nozzle shall be designed for the changes in plant conditions listed below. Plant Condition No. of Occurrences Figure. No.
- a. Heatup 500~------------------- 4
- b. Cooldown 500~-------------~-----*5
- c. Loading, 5%/min. 15,000---------------~---.:.. 6.
- d. Unloading, 5%/min. 15,000--~-------------.:.. ___ 7
- e. Loading, 15%/min. 15,000-------------------- 8
- f. Unloading, 15%/min. 15;000----------.:..---.:..------9
- g. Step increase, 10% 15,000-----------~--------10
- h. Step decrease, 10% 15,000---~-------.:..---.:..----11
- i. Reactor trip 500----------~---------12*
- j. Loss of primary-coolant flow 200-----.:..---~----------12
- k. Loss of load 200--------------------12 ..
- 1. Safety valve operations 200----.:..-----------.:..-.,...-14 ..
- m. No~mal pressure variance 365,000---~---.:..-----------.:.. -.
- n. St~am line rupture 2-----------~---~----13 4.2.7 The pressurizer assembly shall be designed for pressure transients caused by the tests listed below:
Type .of Test No. of Tests Pressure Temperature .
- a. Hy(irostatic 10 3125 psi a 18() to 4oo°F
- b. Leak 320 25©0 psi a *l©© to*4G©°F 4.2.8 The pressurizer assembly shall.be designed for a gross failure of a primary pipe or surge line so that no compc~ment. will yield sufficiently to impair its -function. Betails will be supplied later.
This condi ticm wi-11 not occur more than once in the life of* the plant.* 4.2.9 The primary* coolant system may experience vibrating exci ta ti on with a fundamental frequency of *.14 to 15 and 70 to 75 cycles per secc:md. The pressurizer vessel and internals shall be designed not to be* resonant with this frequency range. 4.2.10 The pressurizer assembly shall be designed to withstand-seismic loading equivalent to 0~2 g-in both horizontal and vertical-directions simultaneously, as given in Figure* 2. Formulas ~r combining loads are given below. C.O D c.o Q:) C:> C.J1 Spec. No. 70!'-001 Rev. 1 Page 5 of 12 Pages
Formulas for Combining Loads Loads Stresses (A) MOL + PTT + SL ASME Section III or ASA B 31.1 Allowable Stresses. (B) MOL + MTT + SL Minimum Yield Stress at Temperature. (C) MOL*+ MTT + 2 SL Minimum Yield Stress at Temperature Plus 10 percent. MOL - Maxi~um Normal Op~rating Load Including Design Pressure, Design Temperature Plus Piping and Support Reactions.
~ - Normal Planned Transients Associated with Expected Plant Normal Operating Transients Such as Start-Up, Shutdown, and Load Swings.
MTT - Maximum Transients. in the Systems *Functioning During Plant-Emergency Conditions Such as Full Power Reactor Trip, Turbine Generator. Trip, Loss of Auxiliary Power and the Maximum Hypothetical Accident. SL - Seismic Loads Due to the Design Earthquake. 2 SL- Seismic Loads Due to Twice the Design Earthquake *
- 4.2.11 4.2~12 Thepressurizer assembly shall-be designed to accept the piping rea~tions given in Figure 3.
The spray nozzle .shall be designed for the*following transient in additon to the changes in plant conditions given in paragraph 4.2;6.
~
I\
- a. 500 injections of 4o°F water with the pressurizer at 250 psig and steam temperature at 440°F. Maximum injection rate is 133 gpm.
4.3 Water.Chemistry U,). 4.3.l The pressurizer assembly shall be compatible with the pt::Bnary. coolant water chemistry given bel.ow: c::> O')
- a. Specific resistivity, prior to additives .... more tha.ri 0.5 megohm-cc
- b.
- Total solids, other than additives ......*... less than 2 ppm
- c. ph, normal operation, 573°F (avg)* ........*. 5.4 tq 9.5
- d. ph, at 700F *.......... *. *...* *... * ... * ... ;. *.* * .4.5 to 9.5
- e. Hydrogen ..................... ~.~-~ ...*...**.. Oto 50 cc (STP) per kg
- f. Halogens * .' .........**......... *..**....... ;_ *. less than 0. 25 *ppm
- g. Dissolved oxygen, normal operation, 573°F (avg) ..... *........ , ............................. less than 0.25 ppm, except during cold shutdown.
Spec. No. 70P-001 Rev. 1 Page 6 of 12 Pages
- h. Boric acid, plant cold .*.***..*..**.**.* less than 15,000 ppm
- i. Boric acid, plant hot ....*.***........** less than 12, 000 ppm
- j. Additives; LiOH, KOH, or NH .*.*.*.***.* less than 25 ppm 3
- The water used to hydrostatically test the pressurizer shall satisf'y the following criteria:
a. b. Total s0lids ...********..*.*.**..***.**** less than 10 ppm Halogens .*..*.*..*...**. * .****.......**.*.* less than 1. 0 ppm 4.4 Materials 4.4.1 CENCD shall select materials and* shall prepare any special material specific.atibns required for the pressurizer assembly. CENCD shall submit any special material specifications to CEND for approval prior to ordering materials. 4.4.2 Vessel surfaces or internals in contact with the primary coolant shall be of austenitic stainless steel or Inconel materials. Carbon content of austenitic stainless steel cladding shall not exceed 0.08 percent, measured at the surface. 4.4.3 All plates exceeding 3/8 11 thickness- shall be--ultrasoriically examined and all forgings shall be examined in the as-furnished I\ condition by ultrasonic and by magnetic particle or liquid ~ penetrant methods. 4.4.4 All nozzles shall terminate with materials suitable for we+ding to austenitic stainless ~teel piping .. 4.4,,5 Impact properties of all ferri tic steel materials which t:o.rm a part of the pressure boundary shall .meet the requirement5::) of Table N-332, reference 3.1.1, at a temperature not gre.BJter than 4o°F. Ul U) It shall be an objective tha~ the materials meet this CO requirement at a tempera.ture of 10°F. c:::> 4.4.6 CENCD shall advise CEND of the lowest temperature at which the pressurizer assembly may be hydrostatically tested an& satisf'y the criteria.of paragraph N-332, reference 3.1.2. 4.5 Nozzles 4.5.1 Nozzle Description Req. Location Size Preparation No. A. Man way Top Head 16 in I.D. Min. Flanged 1
~
B. Surge Bottom Head 12 in sch 140 Butt Weld 1
- c. Spray Top Head 4 in sch 120 Butt Weld 1 D. Safety Valve Top Head 3 in J.D. x 6 Flgd. (small 3 in. O.D. groove 2500#
Spec. No. 70P-001 Rev. 1
- Page 7 of 12 Pages
Req. Duty Location Size Preparation No. E. Relief Valvre Top Head 3 in. I.D. x 6- Butt Weld l 6 in. O.D. F. Level TGp Head l in. sch 80 Socket Weld 4 ~ G. Temperature Bottom Head l in. sch 80 Socket Weld 4 ZS Top Head l in. sch 80 Socket Weld l Shell l in. sch 80. Socket Weld l
- EL Heater Bottom Head l20 6 Nozzle butt weld ends shall be prepared in accordance with custome.r '*s specifications. 6 4*.5. 3 The surge .and spray nozzles shall be provided with thermal sleeves.
4.6. Access Openings 4.6.l A manway, per item A - paragraph 4.5.l, sha)_l be pr0vided. The manway ccwer shall be hing~d if located inside the vessel and. either hinged or provided with lifti.ng lugs if l0cated external tG the vessel. The_ manway cover gasket- shall be. spiral wound -c0nstruction of AISJ type 304 stainless steel ribbon and asbest0s filler. Spec. No. 70P-00l Rev. l Page 8 of l2 Pages
5.0 DOCUMENTS TO 33E PROVIDED BY CENCD 5.1 CENCD shall submit to CEND for review and approval five ( 5) prim:ts and one (1) reproducible of each revision of the fol.n.nwing drawings: "
- a. utline (within 38 days *of *order date)
- b. Langi tudinal Section
- c. CGeneral* Assembly
- d. ~upport Details
- e. ~hipping Arrangement (within .90 days *Of order date)
- 5. 2 CENCW shall submit to CEND for review and approval five. ( 5-)
copi..es of .calculations confirming the pressurizer vessel, nozz::les, and supports *as designed are sufficient to withstand* stresses caused by the following conditions:
- a. Pressure loadings.
bo IMechanical loadings including weights, pipe reactions, and* seismic effects.
- c. CC,yclic 0perations.
- d. (()perational thermal gradients at surge and spray nozzles.
5.3 CENCID shall provide CEND with the follqwing data as soon as* poss:ii.ble after the pressurizer has been.ordered:
- a. Wes_sel, free volume
- b. Water volume re~uired to cover the heaters c 0 Wes.sel weight:
{l) dry (2) under normal operating conditions ,. (3) flooded with water at 60)F do Vessel center of gravity location: (l) dry (2) under normal operating conditions (3) flooded with water at 60°F. 5.4 . CENCD shall provide CEND, fer information, five (5) copies-- of all specifications, procedures,. cutting lists, and c:::> drawings (other than those listed in paragraph 5.1) perta:&flng to material procurement and pressurizer fabrication.*. C...L') CJ.) These items shall_be supplied as they are completed.
. c..o .
CENCD shall provide CEND with five ( 5) copies o f ax+ engineering 5.5 schedule and a production schedule within two months a~er the pressurizer assembly has been ordered. Speco No. 70P-001 Rev. 1 Page 9 of 12 Pages
5.6 CENCD shall provld_e CEND with five (5) copies each of the current engineerjag and production schedules on or about the 20th of each mon~fi .
- 5.7 5.8 CENCD shall prov~de CEND with five (5) copies ~f the Integrated Manufacturing an~ Quality Plan prior to start :0f fabrication for .designation Gf hold. and "rd tness points. -
- CENCD shall provide CEND with Mill Test Data Reports *and CENCD Materials Certification Reports.for materials used to fabricate the pres.surizer.
Two * ( 2) copies of each report shall be . forwarded as they become available. Three (3) job folders, each including one (1) c0py of all such reports, shall also be forwarded when CENCD obtains the last report.
- 5.9 CENCD shall provide CEND with forty (4o}* copies of a technical manual including, but not limited to, th~ following information:
- a. Operational parameters
- b. Pertinent physical data such as dimensions, volumes and weights
- c. Materials de;s cription
- d. A list of nozzles, their size, and location
- e. Procedures for inspecting and replacing th_~ heaters* and *
. spray nozzles.
- f. . Sui table drawings
- 6
- g. Suitable photographs
- h. Ins_truction for .receipt, storage, handling, and insta1iati0n o~ the equipment to be furnished by CENCD~
Three* pr~limina)'.'y copies shall be subi:ni tted to CEND for approval five (?) months before the pressurizer is delivered
- 5.10 CENCD shall provide CEND with a list* of recommend.ed spare parts aft~r the. pressurizer has been ordered..
within. 6 *(6) months 5.11 . CENCD*shall *proyide CEND wi'th t.hree (3) reproducible (myiar or equiva;Lent) sets of as-built~"drawings. * *
- 5.12 CENCD shall provide CEND with five (5) prints of photographs taken duting signi.ficant stages of pressurizer fabricati0n.
CENCD shall provide a list of the fabrication stages the;'ln
. c::>
consider sign~ficant. * <..o
<..o Co Spec. No. 70P-001 Rev. 1 Page 10 of 12 Pages
6.0 CLEANING, IDENTIFICATION, AND SHIPPING 6.1 Cleaning The pressurizer shall be cleaned before shipment. CENCD shall submit to CEND. a cleaning procedure for approval.
- 6. 2 Id~ntification A:nameplate shall.be provided on the pressurizer in accordance with paragraph N-82J_, reference 3 .1.1.
- A bu~lder's nameplate may also be included.
6.3 Shipping Openings in the* pressurizer shall be. sealed for shipment. CENCD shall sµbmi t to. CEND t~eir proposed shipping procedures anq packaging methods for approval *
- Spec. No. 70P-001 Rev. 1 Page ll*of 12 Pages
7.0 INSPECTION ANF; T~STS 7.l Ins:r;ie.ction
- 7.i.2 Mat~rla.ls, welding, particular fabrication stages, and the compieted pressurizer shall be examined in accordance with the requirements for a Class A vessel, reference 3.l.l.
CEND and the customer's representatives will witness certain fabrication stages, tests, and examinations. The events to be witnessed will be defined after CEND and the cust§mer pave reviewed the Quality Plan prepared by .CENCD. Tests 7.2.l Tensile, guided bend, and impact tes~s of materials -and welding shall be made in accordance with the requirements for a Class A vessel, reference 3.1~1. 7,2.2 The pressurizer assembly sh_all be l].ydrostatically tested in the shop and-the code N-symbol stamped on the name plate at that time . l'o.) --
- Spec. No. 70P-00l Rev. 1 Page l2 of l2 Pages
.* CALCULATION No. _ _ _ __ COMBUSTION ENGINEERING, INC. NUCLEAR DIVISION DWG. NO. \== \ ~ i CONTRACT NO. _ _ __ SHEET OF--- SUBJECT Pres::. ss.u g_ \:Z. a<-. DATE 9 * \2 -(p(. ev"'I L\(
\:.:>A..'-' S A.;ps-- c p'-~NT CHECK DATE ev _ _
--- ---..J--~--l /
NO~MA.L W~\E.R. \£.YEL
\
/
.--"~PPRQ')(.. ~ FULL ,
I
'A EA-n:..rz.. (~.}J PP() tz..i Ii I-I
. ?'-~\"C:._~
CJ'1 (.!.)
~
co i f -+-+-- I I
\_.\EA.\~ ~ff'O\C\
0
~
II . ('
~~t:::> .:::iu~E:.. FL.Ou
--4 -i ...-1 ffJ UC.~LC:..L\ OR... \-=iA"TE.
*+-
2 uJ J. aJ ! u0
-r i
I 13Z1 Spec. #o /oP- 001 Rev .Vo I
SUPPORI _SK\Rl
- to_ S \-\ oc. K
( SEclrON 1\-t.. . ) LUyS (4)-.- -" h-5!,~.
-i.;;*
~-.
+Fx A
- -*----*------~--------*------*-*-
C0 r FORC.ES - ND l"T ICH--~ 1----r--'<-~--~---------l---~-----,------ F 'K V,\PS F7_ - MOlv'iEh1TS-F\-K I/~'( t,/*1 x tv~ i. 1
- ?_!+5 0 0 0 CJ CJ
* - -*-----4-------**- ***-*****-- . - -.----
~'{DR-:: S T1\TI C. 0 0 0 0 TE-ST 0
A -*. ... _. f-.'j D £ .s \ C1 :,\ +/- 92 (z) 0 +/- ...__'I,, .. __,
-"* 1 Lit* _, '"-, \ :J,-
.S E \ <;:, 1*.I', \ (,.
1-----------l----*----l-----------f------l--------- -*----
~'\ t*.' (.. -
~ p*..: 1---C_r,_s_s-~_1__~---==0-*==~-;~_'_90 I+ 8 91 O :__(_o_\:_.)___+_\~~ f~ _
\._Ru~r(~ '- '- ')_ij-:_c__J__-~ _c.._*-_1--._s_*.*:_- _7__,___o ____.:_+_2__,_o_-'---__o_ __,__-_I_1 _D--'-*-----'=----*J~~A- 5 °-_I l.o_*
C~S<'. 2. - >-"?U~'TUf~f. I\ " II II P.t\P/.\Ll.LL II (7.) HC:.'IRl-Z.(*1,n*,'\L SHE.AR FORC.~- IN /\!-l'r Plf-!E.CTIOt*~ (3) OV E RTUt?.tJltl i'.\ tv~OM S t*ff A E.OL!T t\NY \-IOI;, l,'ZO~-.ITI:.. \.. t' X l $. Spec. No. 70P-OOl *Revision 1 F\GURE 7.
j-Piping Reactions Shearine~-: Force at
.Axial-Force Safe End Bending l'orsior;.al Nozzle Dcaiznaticn Kin!3 Ft-!Ci:;2~
-------..----.l.,~---
--...--~-- Ft -Ifu. ~--
A. Sw:ryc c.> 310 210 73 130 B. Spray 60. 19. -~ (i-.5 - 7_.L
- c. S.:J.f cty and 290 65 19 27 Relief .Valve D. Level 6.4 1.1: .135 .2
- Figure 3
Temperature °F
.1:J:i.
10 X 10 TO THE CENTIMETER 1B X 2S CM. KEUFFEL &: ESSER CO. 46 1513
,.AOC IN U.S. A, Pressurizer Pressure - psia
+ --*~ _ ... 1. .1 * * * -~
--~. ~f--T"':"'"T" -
~4 rl-* ..*
.. ..;r j
.- . -::1 tt*'*,; ****I t..tL:! :.:_.._.._ . I:. 1,~:~
g;.f. +
-~=1~ ~ 3.;*- -~-
*i~"
.:::.~
L :I.;. - -..J 0 't llJ I 0 0 f-'
+
.. +~ .i... J
~-.
Ir T
*.~. .i,. -
*+~tiL-41 !lilJ:r~ ~~g
,._IT ff !ttt :ti j :tt i ,m fL
,f: -~*
*H I r
10 X 10 TO THE CENTIMETER lt:1 X 25 C'-1. KE:::UFFF.:L B: ESSER CO. Pressurizer Pressure - psia
~*:*:~-]=tit ~~~~~~d~~ ~
i
+ *:J -. *;z:+
. J tll >-:;.
-jL..r ~:;~.
' ~t :!" ._ ~
-~-*~;...: - .. ~i:-
+ *c-.' .
"-"" ::::~~:*:~:-~ ~ :~
-'-........-O!a:w,_ ...
.. ~.1.
- J~*~:;cr*~; -
'# ..+..J * : . ,. ~~
j:t I-
'b- u:
L.' C-
~~*tt +
.. D 1
+-§"-**c."""';., t l..i. !-' ..,.~ ~ 1 I:~ ~m i:r~l+/-.ti: :;:q ~ -~~ ,+ J
- - 1...:-o-
- -~
i.lti 1:1:r
- I~.
+
._;...I*'
~- -~
;.1 .
~ ***
t
.;. ~-~. :ii
~*
J*:g:*~ ' :t
*t-*
- +
+ **r
'++ ~. "j r*
10 X 10 TO THE CENTIMETER 46 1513 11"1 X 25 r.~L ... r.rn: 1N u. s. A. KEUFFEL & E::SSER CO. Tml~ L~ L j T
~ *.. :
I.,_.
~-
Li: ...Z1::t ,,/'.+ I+ *
""' Fl+: !--'-'
.,, -** .IJ:i:tt 'i-. ti'*'_:+/-t*-
*..:..::~
. h tr*:.~
t:U:.',:j:l~:J. r
; *1*
; Ti lj;j'.'.,.J
-~
- t;~t
*l
.'l '~"
-"'.':,~:- *,;-:-1-'
,,__~ *-" f.t:I:;:i _:::.,;
" ~ -*r
--~ t
;~I
_,_:*~ c*
~':" * .w
.~ ~t '
..,.~
.J-t _-
l:tj ~*
. !T ~*-
0 0\ EF:
. J....;'.H+
*h=: ::tlfl . ]It:;:-! i..!.: .*.
-~~ . . ,E:Jlri: *~
fl i:!:d. = :;-ttl* -+l:;. "'!J . --h-. . ...;::.
0 HJ A 1U IU IHt:. t,;t:.Nl lr\oiETER: 46 1 5 1 3 . 16 X 25 CM. llillllDt IN U.5./1. KEUf"F"F.L Bi ESSER co. Spray F1ow Surge Flow Pressurizer Coolant Tem)erature °F Tem)erature 0 F Temoeratures °F Pressure usia
.:-* ..j..,. **
- :t
*z. -I ... t
- j ra I
0 0 I-' i
.. fD ft~
* .1...2,
-u~*-1 r-!
I-
. I ;i i-'
C> +i-'
Spray .F1ow Temperature 0 F 10 X 10 T.0 THE CENTIMETER 16X25CM. KEUFFEL a. CSSER CO. 46 1513 li!ADL I" U, :;. A, Suige .F1ow Tem)erature, °F Pressurizer Coolant Tem)eratures °F Pressure psia
.j-_ *-~ .J. ,_
T
*..j. ~ **
-1:-__
--.1
~I ...:-:-** *.:: ..
-.-i-:
,f 0
0 I-'
*;r .;.~
-.J ui *;*
- 1.1 * ...1...
L.; *t. WJ_
+
.* 1
*J t* -*
'~
- j:~
r.
*'I -
-~..:.
- ..._;.... ,J
.::: .: : .J..
L~ -
. H*
**I g_ t..
*!'+/-.
\:q. t;*;:: . '
;J! 1.+/-ti:
~
~~
(1) I ()'.)
'"'. :lj
=11*
[>
+
Spray Flow 0 Temperature} F 10 X 10 TO THE CENTIMETER 18 X 2!!5 CM. KEUF"FEL 81 ESSER CO. 46 151. MADE Surge Temperature} F IH U.5.A Flow0 Pres sure C"'olant Temperatures °F Pressure sia
.~
-.:J 0
'""Cl I
0 0 I-'
10 x ,_o ;o THE CENTIMETER l'ilX:il.SC,*.,. 46 1513
- MADEl"IU,S,&.
Y.LUFFEL 0. ESSER CO, Spray Flow Surge Flow Pressurizer Goglant 0 Temperature, F Temperature, °F Temperatures, F Pressure, psia
+:1.+ l ff ill' +,
- !"..:* ::!i '
H,+i-1-~,._+++lf+H++'-ft.ti4Tl:j:h j_ *-* I
.+-i.!"1.-
~
- r. r --l *H:I: , ' :?,.t:::.+l
..-~
"". ~;
~. ;, !J_:l l
tf:i:f:t j :i* -..'.] 0 1-"d I ..: ~ ... 0 1_:- 0 I-' **'
*..r!
I '-r-!--
---i.
i:....:
+::~*! !:d
(])
'.-I
-~. ++ l.l.
+
. \iJ i*
~;.:t~: -+
, :*+/-rj.* - 4::!.ttt++
1,
'+.::! ' .11
~ $,+/-;
*J'.~
- ~_::\t~~ i_~. - ; '
J:fi 1:::.*:?:nUB: -:- I T j 1..-i:;" i::-.tt:.
.rn:::.: -.
.,.....:..:...1.
I !!'> l *r*I* *
- JT
.L. **1 *..
.. *i...;:..:-..:*=-.-:.:.
+i::F, *rt.F ::r.::
'* T-i.
.-+/- ~~'I T1
10 X 10 TO THE CENTIMETER 46 15.13 IAX25CM. ".ADE IN U. ~-A KEUFFEL Br ESSER CO. Spray :F1ow0 Surge,:I!'low Pressurizer C~olant Temperature, F Temperature;, Temperatures, °F Pressure, a LU..
+
- ~jt!* ,l~. :j_tl * 'EHt-' *'*
- 1. :\L_*~~:; .LS~**>:-l :.ilE * .~ ~iP ~
-11.i:;- ..... :-; - ~~i4 -............
!21 0
+. LJ.....LJ.
--.l 0 lij I 0 0 1J f-1 + H!:!.~- tt ;fr**
; ~J: 111 t
rt 1 [. . . tt
- LI C> I.
I
----*--4
11.n.~ 10 X 10 TO THE CENTIMETER 46 1513 : ';..: n..,...c: 18 X 2!15 CM, MADE IN U.S. A. KEUFFEL Bo ESSER CO, Spray F1ow Surgo F1ow Pressurizer Coolant 0 0 TeillJ?erature, F TeillJ?eriitiire; °F Temperatures F Pressure sia j~
- . **r ,
.f
~ 0
+.-~
*~
+
I -
*t* I
- 1-.:.
STEAM LINE RUPTURE POSITIVE INTO PRESSURIZER (SUBCOOLED ~!QUID) NEGATIVE OUT OF PRESSURIZER
- . (SA';['~TE;i!. STEAM)
(+)
~
- c 600
~
H ....:I 400 ti) I P-r
*0
....:I 200 J::LI rx..
~
ti) ti) ~P-r 0 ~ en P-r 200. 400 . ., (-) 40 80 120 16 0 TIME SECONDS TIME ..SECONDS 650 650 rx. 550 c..'J J::LI i::l
~500' SURGE FLOW SPRAY FL ow
~ 500
- =>
H ~ ~ J::LI J::LI ~ r:i:1 ~ H r:i:1 H 450 45 0 10 20 30 400~ TIME SECONDS 40 80. 120 16 TIME SECONDS Spec. No. 70P-001 Rev. 1 Figure 13
in . a:: Iii ti
- E 0
u j: : z Iii c*" u
- cIll .....
... t:
0 . :> 1-:J:" 0 u:.:
)( )(
2~ \
- Spec. No. 70P-001 :n~ure 14
i ,' ..0 ' . }f
. \.I , ,:. L ) '/ ' *,
" I ~. -.. /,'
l' J~ /
;USS S - J6J- -./'
- Instruction Manual PRESSURIZER PALISADES PLANT CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY
. . ~ .
- COMBUSTION ENGINEERING, INC.
* * .* * . Nuclear Components Department
. . Chattanooga, rennessee, U.S.A.
_ *.1-J~
- - --.-~ --1!
C. E. BOOK No. 296~C JULY, 1969 COMBUSTION ENGINEERING, INC. Nuclear Power Department. Windsor, Connecticut, U.S.A.
- I J
TABLE OF CONTENTS Page No. ge Noa ILLUSTRATIONS iv iv 5-1 5-2 v 5-3 5.. 5
- GENERAL DATA 5-8 5-14 1-1 Safety Notices 1-1 5~14.
1-2 Design Data 1-4 1-3 Manufacturer's Identification 1-4 later) CTION 2 - DETAILED DESCRIPTION 5-1 2-1 General 2-1 2-2 Nozzles 2-1 2-3 Surge Connection 2-3 7-1 2-4 External Appurtenances 2-3 7-3 c 2-5 Heaters 2-4 6 Spray Head and Connections 2-4 Manway Opening 2-4 Insulation 2-5 CTION 3 - INSTALLATION 3-1 Condition at Shipment 3-1 3-2 Handling and Storage 3-2 3-3 Receipt Inspection 3-3 3-4 Preparation for Installation 3-3 3-5 Installation of Vessel 3-6 3-6 Installation of Heater Terminals 3-9 3-7 Connections 3-9 3-8 Insulation 3-9 3-9 Installation of Keys 3-9 CTION 4 - OPERATING INSTRUCTIONS 4-1 Principles of Operation 4-1 4-2 Operating Precautions 4-3 4-3 Chemistry Requirements of Reactor Coolant Water 4-3 i
- 10500000 ii t ----:--*---*--- ....
l Palisades Presstlrizer
.CE Book 2966 C RECORD OF REVISIONS REVISION NUMBER DATE ENTERED
- ENTERED BY (SIGNATURE) 1
~
I iii a
. ( . .
I LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS
- Figure No.
5-1 5-2 Title Nut Tightening Sequence, Manway Removing Diaphragm Mfg. Dwg. No. Page No. 5-4 5-6 5-3 Welding Diaphragm 5-10 5-4 Detail Weld Procedure-Manway Diaphragm 5-13 Seal Plate* 5-5 Detail Weld Procedure-Heater to Sleeve 5-25 Replacement 7-1 Pressurizer Ou~line E-231-980 7-3 7-2 Vessel Assembly & Final Machining E-231-988 7-5 7-3 Replaceable Cartridge Type Heater Weigand AASK- 7-7 113092 7-4 Nozzle Details E-231-985 7-9 7-5 Nozzle Details E-231-986 7-11 7-6 Heater Arrangement & Detail E-231-987 7-13 7-7 Spray Nozzle Removal and Insulation* E-231-979 7-15 7-8 Insulation Attachments E-231-994 7-17 7;_9 Shipping Rig Assembly & Details E-231-978 7-19 7-10 Heater Seal Weld Cutter D-246-150 7-21 TABLES Table No. Title Page No. 1-1 General Data 1-2 10500003 Revised 2966-c
*10/70
.IW/ISION 1 OCT iv 1970
GLOSSARY A. Introduction The following list of terms and definitions is presented in order that there may exist a closer understanding between the manufacturer and customer as to the e~act meaning of terms used in conjunction with the manufacture, operation, and maintenance of the pressurizer. B. List of Terms and Definitions Class A Cleanliness - Class A cleanliness is intended to produce an item which is clean to the extent that no dirt or extran.eous material is visible with the unaided eyeo Cleanliness shall not be determined by an interpretation of the discoloration .or dirt obtained by wiping a surface with a wet or dry cloth. This t~chnique shall only be used to determine the cleanliness of surfaces which cannot be adequately inspected due to inaccessibility. In such cases, the cleanliness shall not be evaluated entirely on the basis of the discoloration observed, but on the type and quantity of extraneous mate~ial apart from any discolor-ation. Iridescent temper films resulting from thermal stress relieving or bright annealing and black tightly adherent oxide films resulting from welding need not be removed. v
; f
'I '
Clean Room - A clean room is an area in which all windows and doors are tight fitting. The air supply shall be clean and provide an atmosphere that is equivalent in cleanliness to what is normally expected in a business office or homeo Reactor Coolant - The reactor coolant is pressurized water that cools the reactor and flows through the primary side of the steam generator to supply heat for generation of steam in the secondary side of the steam generator. *The reactor coolant flows continuously through the reactor and primary side of the steam generator. i' 1*J5000D5 vi
\ I 1 I SECTION 1 GENERAL DATA SECTION 1 GENERAL DATA 1-1 SAFETY NOTICES RADIATION The pressurizer will become radioactive from* activity of the reactor coolant in the component. Observe extreme caution when approaching or contacting this equipment subsequent to critical oper.ation and make a radiation survey as required by the Health Physicist.
WELDING, GRINDING .AND OTHER No welding, burning, chipping, grinding or arc strikes shall be allowed on the pressurizer except as specifically permitted in this or other authorized manuals. ELECTRICAL The electric heaters are supplied with 480 Volt A.Co .! Power source. All circuits should be de-energized prior to maintenance or repair operations. WATER LEVEL Whenever the electric heaters are energized, the water level in the pressurizer should be high enough to completely immerse the heaters in order ~o prevent possible overheating and burnout of heaters.
*1osoooos 1-1
~ r J
- PRESSURE VESSEL Manufacturer *Combustion Engineering, Inc.
Nuclear Components Department Dimensions Figure 7-1 Weights~ Dry 201,967 lbs Normal Operating 230,869 lbs Flooded 295,716 lbs (60°F Water) Volumes: Free Volume 1507 Cubic Feet Volume required to cover heaters 350 Cubic Feet Center of Gravity Figure 7-1 Design Information Design Pressure 2500 psia Design Temperature 700°F Operating Pressure 2100 psia Operating Temperature 643°F Initial Hydrostatic Test Pressure 3125 psia Leak Test Pressure 2100 psia Minimum Pressurization Temperature Maximum Heatup/Cooldown Temperature Rate 200°F/hr Table 1-1 GENERAL DATA 1-2
- *1*3500007
\ f J I ELECTRIC HEATERS Manufacturer Edwin L. Wiegand Co. Number Installed 120 Part No. 1-113092 (includes Terminal Connector Assembly) Dimensions .875 inch O.D. See Figure 7-3 Weight 12.5 lbs. each Design Information Design Pressure 2500 psia (External) Design Temperature 900°F Rated Capacity 13,125 watts each~ 5% Power Density 88.3 watts per sq. in. Voltage 480V, 60 cycle single phase Total Capacity 1500 KW min. SPRAY NOZZLE Manufacturer Spray Engineering Co. Number Installed 1 Part No. "Sprayco" //:15 CF Dimensions Figure 7-5 Weight 20 lbs. Design Information Flow 375 gpm @ 15 psi Discharge Angle 30 degrees Table 1-1 GENERAL DATA 1-3 1.0500008
\ *r l 1
MINIMUM PRESSURIZATION TEMPERATURE A minimum vessel temperature of 70°F must be maintained 0 before any pressurization of the vessel. Between 70 F and l00°F the vessel pressure must not exceed 1000 psig. A vessel temperature of l00°F minimum must be maintained before increasing the vessel pressure above 1000 psig. NOTE: Other components in the system may have a higher minimum pressurization ~emperature. When the entire system is pressurized, the highest minimum pressurization temperature of any component will be the governing temperature.
- e 1-2 DESIGN DATA The pressurizer has been designed and fabricated in accordance with ASME Code Section III, for Class A Vessels. Refer to Table 1-1 for design information pertinent to the pressure vessel and components.
1-3 MANUFACTURER'S IDENTIFICATION Serial Number CE 66601 Combustion Engineering, Inc., Contract Number 2966C Reference to the above numbers in any communication pertaining to this equipment will assist the manufacturer in identifying the records. 1-4
. 10500009
- I I I SECTION 2 DETAILED DESCRIPTION SECTION 2 DETAILED DESCRIPTION 2-1 GENERAL The pressurizer is' a vertically mounted, A-533 Gr. B Cl 1 alloy steel vessel. The shell and top head are clad internally with Type 304 stainless steel, and the bottom head is clad with Ni-Cr-Fe alloy. The pressurizer assembly consists of a pressure vessel, replaceable electric heaters, spray nozzle, and other nozzles as shown on Figure 7-2.
The pressure vessel is 336 11/16 inches high from the bottom of the support skirt to the end of the spray nozzle and is 121 1/2 inches outside diameter. See Figures 7-1 and 7-2 for detailed dimensions. 2-2 NOZZLES (See Figures 7-4 and 7-5) The pressurizer is furnished with the following nozzles (See Par. 2-3 for surge nozzle). Details of nozzle ends are shown in Figure 7-2. 2-2-1 Eight (8) 1 inch level nozzles, four (4) upper and four lower, fabricated of ASTM-A-508-64 Cl 2 alloy steel forgings clad and fitted with SA~l82 Type F-316 alloy ends. The alloy end is to facilitate welding the 1osooo10 2-1
°i ' ' I SA-182 (F-316) stainless steel socket weld safe ends for connection of the water level instrumentation piping. 2-2-2 One (1) spray nozzle assembly-(See Fig. 7-5) fabricated of ASTM-A-508-64_Cl 2 forged alloy steel with Type 304 stainless steel cladding and fitted with an Ni-Cr-Fe alloy safe end. This nozzle provides the connection to the internal spray nozzle. 2-2-3 Two (2) 1 inch temperature nozzles, one in the upper head and the other in the lower shell in the heater area, fabricated of Ni-Cr~Fe alloy with SA-182 (F-316) stainless steel socket weld safe ends
- 2-2-4 One (1) 3 inch I.D. x 6" O.D. relief valve nozzle located in- the upper head, fabricated of ASTM-A-508-64 Cl 2 forged alloy steel with Type 304 stainless steel cladding and fitted with an Ni-Cr-Fe alloy 4" schedule 120 safe end.
2-2-5 Three (3) 3 inch I.D. x 6" O.D. valve nozzles, all in upper head, fabricated of ASTM-A-508-64 Cl 2 forged alloy steel with Type 304 stainless steel cladding and fitted with Ni-Cr-Fe alloy nozzle flanges to provide a 3 11 - 25001/: flange connection to the safety valves. See details on Figure 7-5. 10500011 2-2
~ ( t I 2-3 SURGE CONNECTION (See Figures 7-2 and 7-4) The pressurizer is provided with one (1) surge nozzle assembly, located in the bottom head of the vessel as shown on Figure 7-2. The surge nozzle is fabricated of ASTM-A-508-64 Cl 2 forged alloy steel with Type 304 stain-less steel cladding and fitted with a 12" schedule 140 Ni-Cr-Fe alloy safe end. The nozzle extends internally into a surge screen assembly which terminates at the heater support plate (See Figure 7-2). The support plate is provided with a removable cover for access to the surge screen and surge nozzle as shown on Figure 7-2. This removable cover is utilized for purging and remote inspection of the back side of weld during welding of the surge nozzle to the reactor coolant piping. 2-4 EXTERNAL APPURTENANCES 2-4-1
- Vessel Supports The .pressurizer is supported in a vertical position on a support skirt (See Figure 7-1) which is fastened to the pressurizer foundation. Alignment is provided by four (4) shock lugs on the upper shell of the vessel and four (4) keys and keyways on the support skirt flange.
2-4-2 Upending Lugs Two (2) upending lugs are provided on the upper head of the vessel for upending and lifting the vessel during 10500012 2-3
\ .
' .* installation. For details of upending and lifting refer to Section 3o 2-5 HEATERS One hundred twenty (120) single unit sheath type immersion heaters (See Table 1-1 and Figures 7-3 and 7-6) are installed in sleeve assemblies in the bottom head of the vessel as shown on Figure 7-6. The heaters are designed to be replaceable as described in Section 5 of this manual. The sleeve assemblies are welded to the internal cladding of the vessel lower head and the heaters are supported internally by a heater support plate. Table 1-1 and Figure 7-3 give detailed specifi-cations of the heaters. 2-6 SPRAY HEAD AND CONNECTIONS One (1) spray nozzle (See Par. 2-2-2) is located in the top head of the vessel. A spray head is installed on the internal end of the nozzle to spray subcooled water into the steam space. The assembly is designed so that the spray head may be removed for maintenance or replacement (See.Par. 5~6 and Figures 7-5 and 7-7). 2-7 MANWAY OPENING (See Figures 7-2 and 7-5) One (1) 16 inch nominal I.D. manway opening is located in the upper head to provide access to the spray nozzle and other internals as required. The manway is sealed with a
- Flexitallic gasket and backing plate, held in place by a cover plate and 20 - 1 1/2 inch studs and nuts assemblieso 10500013 2-4
I , The nuts are tightened to the torque values specified in Par. 5-4 to provide positive seal of the manway covero The manway opening is designed with a recessed seat to provide for substitution of a seal welded diaphragm plate
. for the gasket if required. Details of assembly of the cover plate, studs, nuts, gasket or diaphragm are given in Section 5 of this manual.
2-8 INSULATION Insulation of the vessel is provided by otherso Insulation support angles are field welded to the brackets on the vessel shell for attachment of the insulation (See Figure 7-8). Internally tapped studs, 1/4" - 20 UNC, are provided on the upper and lower heads for the field attachment of insulation retaining rods. 2-5
- 10500014
I ' SECTION 3 INSTALLATION SECTION 3 INSTALLATION 3-1 CONDITION AT SHIPMENT The pressurizer was internally protected with clean, dry nitrogen during shipment. Nozzles are sealed with expandable plugs and the manway sealed with a gasket and cover. See Figure 7-9 for nozzle plugs and seals. The heater area of the pressurizer is protected with iner~ gas (not pressurized), contained by an extension and cover (assembly 978-12) and inflatable o-ring (assembly 978-22) as shown on Figure 7-90 CAUTION: The nitrogen atmosphere is not life supporting and therefore the vessel must not be entered until a satisfactory working atmosphere is*obtained. See Paragraph 3-4 for method of obtaining a satisfactory working atmosphere. 3-1-1 Cleanliness at Shipment The pressurizer has been cleaned to Class A cleanliness requirements prior to shipment. The pressurizer must be maintained equally clean throughout installati~n. Pressurizer maintenance must be performed under clean room conditions. See Section 5 for Maintenance Instructions. 3-1
{ ' 3-2 HANDLING AND STORAGE 3-2-1 Storage The pressurizer should be st~red in a clean, dry area where it will not be subject to dam.age. During interim storage the nozzle plugs and manway cover are to be kept in place. The extension and cover assembly is to be kept in place to protect the heater area until the vessel is installed. The pressurizer is to be kept under an inert gas pressure of 2 to 3 psig. Periodic inspections should be made to insure that the pressurizer is not dam.aged or opened. If the vessel is found to be open, immediate steps should be taken to insure that Class A cleanliness has been maintained and the vessel resealed. The pressurizer should .be supported on the shipping skid or on equivalent saddles similar to the saddles on the shipping skid. 3-2-2 Handling The dry weight of the pressurizer is approximately 202,000 pounds (not including shipping skid which weighs approximately 50,000 pounds). The pressurizer should be handled by the upending lugs on the vessel head using a spreader beam. The lugs are designed to be used with the vessel in place on the upending 1J500016 3-2
11 ~ l I
- device. If the vessel must be removed from the upending device before installation, use padded slings to assure vessel is not damaged. It is recommended that the crane, craneways, slings and I I other lifting gear be adequate to handle the weight of the pressurezer and, prior to the lift, should be checked and properly certified.
CAUTION Do not lift or move the pressurizer when the metal temperature is below 0°F. 3-3 RECEIPT INSPECTION
-Visually inspect pressurizer, covers, and nozzle plugs for damage. Check gas pressure gage to assure that gas pressure is 2-3 psi. Report any damage or loss of gas pressure to CE Nuclear Components Department and obtain approval before attempt-ing repairs. Leave all covers, plugs, etc. in place until installation in accordance with Par. 3-2.
3-4 PREPARATION FOR INSTALLATION 3~4-1 Protection During Installation If grindi?g, welding or other poteptial debris producing operations must be performed, the pressurizer should be protected against contamination. Only the opening being connected to piping should be 3-3 13500017
I *
- exposed at one time. All other openings shouid remain sealed until their installation sequence. However, if the seals are removed from openings and cannot be reinstalled, the openings should be covered with plastic or rubber sheeting and sealed with tape until their connection sequence. The interior of the vessel should be protected from weld splatter and other debris when welding connecting piping to the nozzles. Prolonged exposure of the interior of the pressurizer to the atmosphere or to moisture should be. avoided. Inspect for damage or contamination as required and take necessary corrective action.
3-4-2 Movement Prior to Installation
- 1. The pressurizer may be transported on its shipping rig (assembly 978-01, Figure 7-9) by skidding the vessel and rig. Using spreader beam, attach moving equipment to the upending lugs on the head of the vessel, or to the lower I beam of the shipping rig (at quadrant section), depending on direction to be moved.
- 2. To lift the vessel and shipping rig from the rail car, or in any other movements when vessel is in horizontal position, use padded or belt type slings around the vessel shell to prevent damage.
3-4
Exercise care to avoid bumping nozzle, covers, or otherwise damaging the vessel. To release shipping rig from the rail car, break the four welds securing rig to car. Remove six (6) bolts (piece 978-21, Figure 7-9) securing gusset (assembly 977-28) to cover (extension cover, assembly 978-12). Pressurizer and shipping skid may now be moved together. 3-4-3 Preparing Pressurizer for Entry The pressurizer is protected with inert gas during shipment and storage. The inert gas must be purged from the pressurizer before any personnel may enter. This may be accomplished by disconnecting the inert gas supply to the pressurizer and opening the valves to permit the internal pressure to drop to zero gage pressure. Close the valves and connect an oxygen supply to the pressurizer and pressurize to approximately 4 psig. Allow the pressurizer to remain at this pressure for 45 minutes. Open the valves and allow the internal pressure to drop to zero gage pressure. The atmosphere in the pressurizer will now have an oxygen-nitrogen ratio approximating that* of normal air and may be opened for safe entry. The atmosphere within the pressurizer r.:.--
- 1J500019 3-5
------.-----~---*---------------------
should be checked with an oxygen detecting apparatus to verify a safe atmosphere prior to actual entry. 3-5 INSTALLATION OF VESSEL 3-5-1 Upending the Pressurizer
- 1. Upending the Pressurizer
- 1. The upending of the pressurizer involves lifting the upper head end (manway end) of the vessel with lifting equipment while allowing the pressurizer and shipping skid to rock up onto the circular quadrants of the shipping skid.
Lift by attaching proper shackles and clevices to the upending lugs. Use of spreader beam is mandatory. In order to maintai~ a vertical lift, the lifting crane should be moved horizontally or the shipping skid be allowed to move in order to maintain a vertical attitude of the lifting cables. Maintain alignment* of lifting equipment parallel to the centerline of the vessel to prevent sidewise loading.
- 2. When the pressurizer and shipping skid have been upended and moved a position above the pressurizer foundation, the shipping skid may be removed from the pressurize~ as follows:
3-6 13500020
j '
- 1) Lift the pressurizer (weight of vessel and shipping skid approximately 252,000 lbs) using the upending lugs, _until the weight is off the shipping skid.
- 2) Secure another lifting device to the shipping skid, attaching to the holes at the top of the skid. Take up slack to prevent falling of skid when released from the vessel.
- 3) Using adequate lifting facilities attached to hold down straps (assembly 978-02),
loosen turnbuckles on each end of straps. Remove four (4) bolts (978-11) from each strap to release strap halves. Slip pin (piece 398-31) out of clevis (piece 498-29) at each end of hold -down straps and remove strap half sections. Remove eight (8) bolts (piece 978-19) holding pressurizer skirt to extension and cover assembly.
- 4) Remove four (4) clamps (piece 977-36) and four (4) 1/2" hex nuts (piece 977-09) to release cover plate and pipe (piece 977-38) from extension and cover assembly. Turn 3-7 10500021
- pipe counter-clockwise with cover plate and retain assembly for reinstallation if desired.
NOTE Turn off inert gas supply before removing pipe. Release pipe from bottles at fast disconnect at end of hose from bottles.
- 5) Lift pressurizer clear of shipping rig and remove rig. If it is desired to maintain gas pressure in the vessel, instal~- a 1/ 4" pipe plug in the surge nozzle cover, or reinstall pipe and cover plate removed in step (4).
CAUTION Some heaters extend below the support skirt._ Exercise extreme caution to avoid bumping heaters or lowering weight on heaters. 3-5-2 Final Setting of Pressurizer Carefully lower vessel onto pressurizer foundation. Align and secure in accordance with Bechtel procedures. c 3-8 1J500022
- ' I
- 3-6 INSTALLATION OF HEATER TERMINALS 3-6-1 Procedure for Attaching Power Lead to Heater Terminals (See Fig. 7-3)
- 1. Slide boot back up over lead wire.
- 2. Attach cable leads to L-shaped terminal lug.
(piece 30) using pieces 32, 33, and 34. Finger tighten.
- 3. Tighten to a maximum.recommended torque of 65 pounds inches with the use of a suitable standard open-end wrench and a suitable torque wrench. Use 1/4" open-end wrench snap-on f/810 or equal; head thickness 5/32" standard. Use torque wrench snap-on f/TQ-6 or equal 1/4" drive standard.
- 4. Reinstall boot over connection.
- 3-7 CONNECTIONS Field weld nozzle connections in accordance with approved
. Becht.el erection procedures.
3-8 INSULATION Install insulation support angles in accordance with approved Bechtel procedures and Figure 7-8. Install insulation in accordance with Bechtel procedures. 3-9 INSTALLATION OF KEYS Install foundation keys in the support flange keyways and weld to the support steel in accordance with approved Bechtel c.- procedures. Fit up and install keyways to the shock lugs on the pressurizer shell in accordance with approved Bechtel procedureso \ 10500023 3-9
I
- SECTION 4 OPERATING INSTRUCTIONS SECTION 4 OPERATING INSTRUCTIONS 4-1 PRINCIPLES OF OPERATION The pressurizer maintains reactor coolant system operating pressure and compensates for changes in reactor coolant volume during load changes. During full power operation, slightly more than one half of the pressurizer is full of saturated water with the remainder of the vessel filled with saturated steam. The reactor coolant system pressure is controlled by maintaining the temperature of the pressurizer fluid at the saturation temperature corresponding to the desired system pressure. A small portion of. the pressurizer heaters are operated continuously to offset heat losses.
During load changes the pressur.izer limits pressure variations caused by expansion or contraction of the reactor coolant. A reduction in load results in the average reactor coolant temperature decreasing. The resulting contraction of the reactor coolant lowers t~e pressurizer water level causing the reactor coolant system pressure to fall. This loss of pressure will be partially off set by flashing of pressurizer 4-1 10500024
I
- water into steam. Automatic energization of all pressurizer heaters on low reactor coolant system pressure will form additional steam and_furt~er limit* the pressure decrease.
An increase in electrical load results in the average reactor coolant temperature increasing. The resulting expansion of reactor coolant causes a surge of water into the pressurizer, compressing the steam and raising the reactor coolant system pressure. If the pressure increase is large enough, the pressure spray valves open and spray relatively cold reactor coolant from the cold leg piping into the steam space. This spray condenses some of the steam in the pressurizer and limits the pressur~ increase. Small reactor coolant system pressure and volume compensations are made by providing steam volume to absorb flows into the pressurizer and water volume to match flows out of the pressurizer. See plant operating manual for complete details of operating conditions. 4-2 1)1500025
I' 4-2 OPERATING PRECAUTIONS Since the pressurizer is an integral part of the reactor coolant system, refer to the plant op~rating procedures for details of operation. Observe minimum pressurization temperature of l00°F and the heat-up, cool-down rates of 200°F/hr as specified in Table 1-1 of this manual. CAUTION The use of mercury and/or mercury containing instruments is prohibited during operation or test of the pressurizer. Deleterious.materials, as defined in Appendix I, 0 Reactor System'Components" must be excluded from the pressurizer to prevent damage. 4-3 CHEMISTRY REQUIREMENTS OF REACTOR COOLANT WATER The water chemistry conditions of the pressurizer are similar to those of the reactor coolant system. When water quality meets the requirements of reactor coolant, the resulting conditions are acceptable for pressurizer operation which is at saturation pressure and temperature. The range of coolant conditions expected are as follows: Normal operation at 573°F pH 5.5 - 7.5 Plant cold at 70°F pH 4.5 - 10.5 Hydrogen 15-50 cc per kg Halogens Chloride less than 0.15 ppm Fluoride less than 0.1 ppm 10500026 4-3
I
- Dissolve4 Oxygen Normal operation at 573°F less than 0.1 ppm Plant cold at 70°F
- not specified
*Hydrazine is added to the recirculating coolant at 1.5 times the dissolved oxygen concentration. The system cannot exceed 1S0°F until the oxygen specification is established.
Boric Acid Concentration Plant cold (77°F) 15,000 ppm maximum Plant hot (573°F) 12,000 ppm maximum Additives less than 25 ppm of Li 70H, KOH or NH40H 4-4 I I j
- 13500027
SECTION 5 MAINTENANCE SECTION 5 MAINTENANCE 5-1 GENERAL During maintenance, observe the following Safety Notices: RADIATION The pressurizer will become radioactive from activity of the reactor coolant in the component. Observe extreme caution when approaching or contact-this equipment subsequent to critical operation and make a radiation survey as required by the Health Physicist. WELDING. GRINDING AND OTIIER No welding, burning, chipping, grinding or arc strikes shall be allowed on the pressurizer except as specifically permitted in this or other authorized manuals. ELECTRICAL The electric heaters are supplied with 480 Volt A. c . power source. All circuits should be de-energized pr.ior to maintenance or repair operations. 10500028 S-1
WATER LEVEL Whenever the electric heaters are energized, the water level in the pressurizer should be high enough to completely immerse the heaters in order to prevent possible overheating and burnout of heaters. MINIMUM PRESSURIZATION TEMPERATURE 0 A minimum vessel temperature of 70 F must be main-tained before any pressurization of the vessel. 0 0 . Between 70 F and 100 F the vessel pressure must not
. 0 exceed 1000 psig. A vessel temperature of 100 F minimum must be maintained before increasing the vessel pressure above 1000 psig.
NOTE: Other components in the system may have a higher minimum pressurization temperature. When the entire system is pressurized, the highest minimum pressurization temperature of any component will be the governing temperature. 5-2 DRAINING Before any work is done inside the pressurizer, the vessel temperature and pressure must reach ambient conditions or as determined for safety of personnel. Draining is accomplish-ed through the surge nozzle. Approx. 3 1/2 inches are not drainable in the area around the surge nozzle. 5-2 iJ500029
.-~,~
PALISADES PLANT SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT between CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY and
.MICHIGAN STEEL'tEAD AND SALMON FISHERMEN'S ASSN. , et aJ..
- TABLE OF CO:NTENTS Page Section ~
l CONDENSER COOLING SYSTEM MODIFICATION
- 4 LIQ,UID RADWASTE SYSTEM MODIFICATION * * *. 8
- 3. GASEOUS RADWASTE SYSTEM * .* .. . *
- 14 4 *HOT FUNCTIONAL TEST * * ** 14 5 CONTROL ROD TESTS * * * .
- 15 6 MPSC AP.l?ROVA\:.;. WITHDRAWAL OF INTERVENTION * * * * * *
- 17 7 RESERVATIONS * * *
- 24 8 OTHER PROCEEDINGS * * . . . . . ** 25
- 26 9 INFORMATION AND REPORTS * *
- 10 LEGAL VALIDITY *: *
- 27 11 DISPUTES *** *
- 30 12 RATIFICATION AND APPROVAL * . .* .
- 31 13 BINDillG EFFECT ** 32 14 PUBLICITY * * * * ... *
- 34 15 SERVICE OF PROCESS * * * * * *
- 35 16 NOTICES * * * * * .....
17 TERMINATION * ..... 18 ENTIRE AGREEMENT
- 39 Awendixes I MODIFIED CONDENSER COOLING SYSTEM EXHIBIT A - PALISADES CLOSED CYCLE COOLING SYSTEM II l>K>DIFIED LIQ,UID RADWASTE SYSTEM EXHIBIT A - PALISADES CLEAN WASTE SYSTEM EXHIBIT B - PALISADES DmTY WASTE SYSTEM EXHIBIT C - PALISADES LAUNDRY. WASTE SYSTEM
~*.
1*
- . TABLE OF CONTENTS (Contd) 2 Ap~endices (Contd)
!II GASEOUS RADWASTE*SYSTEM SITE BOUNDARY DOSE (1% Failed FUel)
- ri STIPULATION BY AND BETWEEN ALL INTERVENORS AND APPLICANT IN SUPPORT OF FUEL LOADING AND LOW-POWER TESTING LICENSE EXHIBIT A - PROPOSED FINDINGS OF FACT, CONCLUSIONS OF LAW, AND FORM OF ORDER SUBMITTED JOINTLY BY APPLICANT.AND °INTERVENORS RESPECTING AUTHORIZATION OF A FUEL LOADING AND LOW-POWER TESTING LICENSE V STIPULATION BY AND BETWEEN ALL INTERVENORS AND APPLICANT IN SUPPORT OF FULL-POWER LICENSE EXHIBIT A - SPECIAL TECHNICAL SPECIFICATIONS PURSUANT TO AGREEMENT
/*
- AGREEMENT AGREEMENT, ma.de .this 12th day of Ma.+ch, 1971, by and between CONSUMERS POWER COMP.Ai.TI, 212 West Michigan Avenue, Jackson, Michigan, here-ina.i'ter called "Consumers Power," and MICHIGAN S'rEELHF.AD AND SALMON FISHER-MEN'S ASSOCIATION, 5619 Clato, .Ka.lama.zoo, Michigan, THERMAL ECOLOGY MUST BE PRESERVED (T.E.M.P.), 2312 Glenwood Drive, Kalamazoo, Mi~higan, CONCERNED PETITIONING CITIZENS,. 2312 Glenwood Drive, Ka.lama.zoo, Michigan, MICHIGAN LAKE AND STREAM ASSOCIATimrs' INC. ' 392 Fairbrook Court' Northville' Michigan, and sIEBBA CLUB, io50 Mills Tower, San Francisco, CaJ.ifornia (for itsel.f and for each and all of its chapters), hereinafter called, jointly and severa.lly, "Intervenors."
WHEREAS, pursuant to an application dated June 2, 1966 and assigned to AEC Docket No. 50-255, a per.mit to construct a. pressurized-water-reactor nuclear power plant known as the Palisades Plant in Covert Township, Van Buren County, Michigan, was duly issued to Consumers Power by the u. S. Atomic Energy Commission (in this Agreement called the "AF.C ") on March 14, 1967 after a. public hearing as required by law, without opposition by way of intervention, and pursuant to findings by the Atomic Safety and Licensing Boa.rd entered in favor of Consumers Power on all issues presented by the Notice of Hee.ring for construction permit; and. WHEREAS, by amendment to its application dated November l, 1968, Consumers Power requested issuance of a license to operate the Palisades
- Plant at steady-state power levels up to and including 2200 ther.ma.1 mega-watts (in this Agreement called the "full.-power license"); and
2 WHERF.A.8', on January 'Z7, l970, after. review a.nd proceedings required by law, the AEC's Advisory Committee on Reactor.Safeguards issued its Report on the Palisades Plant which concluded that .the Palisades Plant can be operated at power levels up to 2200 thermal. megawatts without undue. risk to the health and safety of, the public, if due regard is given to.the suggestions and comments contained in said ACR8*Report, subject to.the satisfactory c~letion of construction and preopera.tional testing; and WHEBEAS, on March 6, 1970, the AEC's DiVision of Reactor Licensing issued its Safety Evaluation.with respect to the Pa.1isades Plant which con-cluded, among other things, that there is reasonable assurance that the Palisades Plant can be operated a.s proposed without endangering the health and safety of the public; and WHEREAS, on March 10, 1970, there was published in the Federal Register a notice that the .AEC's Division of Reactor Licensing proposed to issue a. provisional operating license to Consumers Power to operate the Palisades Plant as requested, which notice granted an opportunity for public hearing on the issuance of such license; and WHEBEAS, certain persons later to become Intervenors had meetings and discussions with representatives of Consumers Power to discuss such persons' concerns relating to environmental effects of the Palisades Plant, but such discussions did not alleviate the concerns of such persons, later to become Intervenors; and WHEREAs, Intervenors requested a public hearing pursuant to .said
~ch 10, 1970 notice, upon the gr01Jl'.lds,* among others, that Intervenors were dissatiS:f'ied with the AEC's implementation of the National Environmental
- Policy Act and were dissatisfied with the design of the Palisades Plant
3 .
- insofar as radioactive and thermal effluents were concerned, and, accordingly, a public hearing (in this.Agreement ca.J.J.ed "the proceeding") commenced be-fore an AEC Atomic* Safety and Licensing Boa.rd (in this Agreement ca.J.J.ed "ASLB") on June 23, 1970, which proceeding has not been concluded; and rf1HEREA.S, during the course of the proceeding Consumers Power filed a motion for issuance of a license authorizing fuel lo.a.ding a.nd low-power testing at power levels not to exceed one (1) the:rma.1.'megawatt (in this Agreement called the "testing license") pending issuance of the full-
.Power license; and WHEREAS; the Intervenors have, since the proceeding began, vigor-ously contested the*issua.nce of the requested operating licenses to Cons:umers Power because of Intervenors' contention, among other.things, that the AEC, by such a hearing, is engaged in a continuing violation of the National Environmental Policy Act, the Federal Water Pollution Control Act, as amended, and the Atomic Energy Act of 1954, as amended; and WHEREAS, during the course of said proceeding, Intervenors ha.ve questioned whether the Palisades Plant bas been constructed in accordance with law and in accordance with Consumers Power's application, plans and specifications and if not so constructed, 'Whether it ma::; be operated safely; and WHEREAS, the parties have ma.de considerable expenditures of time and money in contesting the issuance of said operating licenses to date, *and costly and time-consuming appeals :f'ram. any decision of the ASLB in the proceeding are probable; and WHEREAS , Intervenors are wiJ J ing to forego in this proceeding final resolution of legal issues pursuant to the National :ji;nvironmental
4 Policy Act, the Federal Water Pol1ution Control Act, as amended, and the Atomic Energy.Act of 1954, as emended, provided that certain ~teps are taken by* Consumers Power, as provided in this Agreement, in order to resolve the contentions of Intervenors as regards radioactive and thermal. effects and nuclear safety of the Palisades Plant; and WHEREAS;. the parties hereto desire to min;i.mize further expendi-tures, to permit production ofelectricaI energy from* the Palisades Plant in accordance with the prov.j.sions of this Agreement, and to that end to resolve all controversies, differences and disputes between the parties hereto with respect to the. des.ign; construction, licensing and operation of the Palisades Plant, including but not limited to those which have heretofore arisen or might or could have arisen, or which may or could
- ~*
hereafter arise during the course of the proceeding* or otherwise in AEC Docket No. 50-255 and in appeals therefrom and in actions in connection therewith before the ASLB, the AEC Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Board, the AEC and all other governmental agencies and all federal, state a.r;d local courts, except controversies, differences and disputes arising because of alleged breach of, or.failure of performance pursuant to, this Agreement; NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of their mutual promises and
'lllldertakings herein, the parties hereto agree as follows:
. SECTION 1 - CONDENSER COOLING SYSTEM MODIFICATION
§l.l Consumers Power shall modii'y' the condenser cooling system now installed in the Palisades Plant to a condenser cooling system sub-sta.ntia.lly conforming to the conceptual design set forth in Appendix I hereto and in accordance with the principles set forth in this Section 1.
5 SECTION l, §1.1 (Contd) The condenser cooling system as so modified (and in this Agreement called the modified condenser cooling system") shall be so designed, constructed, operated and maintained as to form a closed cycle in which the. condenser cooling i'later is continua.ll:y recycled except for cooling system inake-up water from and blowdown to Lake Michigan. The modified condenser cooling system shaJ.l. include one or more wet-type cooling towers which may be of. either the natural or the mechanical draft type, at Consumers Power's sole option, provided, tha.t Consumers Power's obligation shall be to install either the natural or the mechanical draft type unless it is relieved from installing both types after exhausting all. rights .of
. - ~ . .hearing, appeal
. and requests for writs of certiorari to the highest state or feder~ court having jurisdiction, as provided in Section 10 of this Agreement. Design ,
and construction of the cooling tower or t0wers shall conform to the la.test applicable Cooling Tower Institute (CTI) codes and standards applicable at the time of detailed design, except to the extent the same llUcy' be contrary to any applicable law or rule, regulation or order of a.ny governmental body having jurisdiction.
§1.2 Upon execution of this Agreement, Consumers Power will pro-ceed immediately with all due diligence to arrange for the design, engineer-ing, procurement of equipment and materials, and construction required to install the modified condenser cooling system as provided for herein and to -make-application to obtain all licenses, permits, consents or other authorizations of public bodies or officials which are required in con-nection with the design, construction, operation a.nd maintenance of the
6
- SECTION 1, §1.2 (Contd) modified condenser cooling system. In making a.nd pursuing such applies.-
. tions, Consumers Power shall :pursue administrative remedies or court actions, or both, in the manner provided in* Section 10 of this Agreement, and the rights and obligations of the parties in connection with such remedies or actions shall be *governed a.nd determined by Section 10 of this Agreement.
The modified condenser cooling system shaJ.l be-instalJ.ed within .forty-two (42) calendar months folJ.owing the date of execution of this Agreement if Consumers Power installs a natural draft cooling tower or towers as part of the modified condenser cooling system, or within thirty-two (32) calendar months following the date of execution of this Agreement i£ Consumers Power installs a mechanical draft cooling tower or towers as :pa.rt of the modified
--* condenser cooling system. If, after Consumers Power has begun to arrange for the design, engineering, procurement of equi-p1nent and materials, and construction for a modified condenser cooling system utilizing e~ther the mechanical draft or the natural draft type of cooling tower or towers, Consumers Power is relieved from installing or continuing to install the type of cooling tower or towers it first selects, and it is necessary to change to the alternative type of cooling tower or towers, the time for installation of a. modified condenser cooling system utilizing the a.lterna.-
tive type of cooling tower or towers shalJ. commence from the date on which Consumers Power is relieved from installing or continuing to install the type of cooling-tower or towers first selected. The modified condenser cooling system shall be :placed in operation not later than the resumption of operation of the Palisades Plant after its first scheduled ref'ueling
*7 SECTION l., §l..2 (Contd).
fol.l.owing insta.l.lation of said system, provided,"that to the extent it can do so consistently with electrical. system load requirements, Pa.l.isades Pl.ant opera.t_ing requirements and applicable license and other legal l.imita-t ions, .Consumers Power shal.l. use its best efforts to scheduJ.e the f4"st refueling f ol.l.owing installation of the modified condenser qooling system so as to minimize the time between the completion of such insta.l.lation and the initia.l operation of the modified condenser cooling system. The foregoing provisions of this §l.2 are subject to the condition that in the event the insta.lla.tion or the initial operation of such mcidified condenser cooling system is delayed (i) by reason of flood, strike, insurrection, riot; embargo, a.ct of nature or the public enemy; or unavoidable dela.y in trans-portation or inability or unavoidable delay in procuring labor or materia.l..s; (ii) by reason of legal action by a:ny third party; local., state or federal. laWs; or the ruJ.es, reguJ.ations, orders, actions or fa.iJ.ure to a.ct of a:ny public body or official purporting to exercise authority or control with respect to installation or operation of the modified condenser cooling system; or (iii) by reason of any cause beyond the reasonable control. of Consumers Power, the time for performs.nee sha.ll be extended (subject to the provisions of Section 10 of this Agreement as respects [ii] above) for a time equa1 to the period of such delay. Moreover,. until. initial. successf'u.l. operation of the modified condenser cooling system, Consumers Power sbal1 notify' Intervenors quarterly of a.l.l. occurrences or conditions then known to any officer of Consumers Power, or to a.n empl.oyee of Consumers Power who reports directly a.nd regularly to any such officer, which Consumers
I. 8
- SECTION l, §1.2 (Contd)
Power ma:y claim forms a basis for a.n extension of time for the insta.ll.B.tion
- a.nd operation of the modified condenser cooling system, and shal1 notify Iritervenors on a c~ent basis of any occurrence or condition known to any officer of Consumers PoWer, or to a.n*employee of Consumers Power who reports directly a.nd regular:cy to any such officer, which CC?nsumers Power then claims will form a be.sis for such a.n extension of time.
§1.3 Pending insta.lla.tion a.nd operation of the modified condenser cooling system provided for in this Section l, Corisumers Power, insofar a.s
- tntervenors are concerned, * ~ operate the Palisades.* Plant at a.ny power levels authorized by any AEC operating license issued to Consumers Power, utilizing the existing once-through cooling system and releasing heated
- condenser cooling water to Lake* Michigan.
§1.4 As used in this Agreement the term "Palisades Plant" means and refers to a single-unit nuclear electric genera.ting plant and shall not ~e deemed to include any additional electric generating units that ma.y herea.:t'ter be installed at the Palisades Plant site.
SECTION 2 - LIQUID RA.IM.ASTE SYSTEM MODIFICATION
§2.l Consumers Power shall modify the liquid rad.waste system now installed in the Palisades Pl.ant to a liquid radwa.ste system substan-tia.l:cy conforming to the conceptual design set forth in Append.ix II hereto and in accordance with the principles set forth in this Section 2. The liquid radwaste system as so modified (and in this Agreement called the
modified liquid radwaste system") shall be so designed, constructed, operated and maintained that at all times under nonna.l. opera.ting conditions,
9 SECTION 2, §2.l (Contd) radioactive ma.teria.J.s in liquid discharges from the Pa.J.isades Plailt to Lake Michigan a.re reduced to essentia.l.ly zero; provided,
- however, that radioactive ma.teria.J.s in laundry waste system discharges which cannot. be treated in the dirty waste system of the modified liquid ra.dwaste system Without the p*ossibility of impairing the function of dirty ~ste_ .system equi:plllent may be released to. Lake Michigan at levels which* shall in no event exceed 25 picocuries per liter (2.5 X lo- 8 microcuries/cc) on an annual average basis; and provided.further, that "essentia.l.ly zero;" as used herein, shall not be construed to-preclude liquid discharges to Lake Michigan containing radioactive ma.terials at levels, as sampled at the recycle monitor tank before dilution, equivalent to or below th~n-current Lake Michigan background radioactivity levels, as monitored offshore from the Pa.l.isades Plant prior to such liquid discharges. As used in thi~ Agree-ment "normal ope:rat ing conditions" shall refer to operation of the Pa.J.isades Plant during or in connection with which there exist no abnormal. events or circumstances such as (but not limited to) steam generator tube leakages, fire, or pipe breakage; and "abnormal operating conditions" shall refer to operation of the Pa.J.isades Pla.nt during or in connection with which there exist any such abnormal events or circumstances. All radioactive .materials removed from liquid wastes by the modified liquid radwa.ste system will be accumul.a.ted a.nd :prepared for shipment in accordance with applicable rules, regtlla.tions and orders of governmental authorities having jurisdiction and turned over to a. carrier or carriers licensed by governmental authorities having ji.lrisdiction for shipment to an authorized disposal area or areas *
.10 SECTION 2, §2.i (Contd)
Consumers Power intends to be alert to, a.nd to utilize to the extent it is . practical to do so, means of minimizing the amount of laundry waste tha.t cannot be treated in the dirty waste.system *
.§2. 2 The parties recognize that under abnormal. opera.ting con-
. ditions it may be impossible or impractical to achieve essentia.lly zero release of radioactive materials in liquid discharges from.the Palisades Plant through operation of the modified liquid radwaste system. Cons1Jt!lerS Power shall so operate the modified liquid ra.dwaste system as to ensure that radioactive materials in liquid discharges to Lake Michigan resulting from abnormal operating conditions do not exceed, on a quarterly average basis and on an individual isotopic analysis basis, ten percent {l~) of appli-cable 10 CFR Part 20 l:imits in effact as of December 1, 1970, and are re-duced to essentia.lly zero no later than siXfy (60) consecutive days after the commencement of such releases resulting from abnormaJ. operating con-ditions. Notwithstanding the foregoing, however, dela.y beyond said sixty (60) day period in the reduction of radioactive materials in such liquid discharges to essentially zero sha.11 be excused (subject to the provisions of Section 10 of this Agreement as respects [ii] below) to the extent it is (i) due to inability to identi:f'y, locate or repair the abnoi-ma.l. operating condition; or due to flood; strike; insurrection; riot; embargo; a.ct of nature or the public enemy; or by reason of unavoidable delay in transpor-tation or inability or unavoidable delay in procuring labor or materials; (ii) due to legal action by a third party; local, state or federal laws; or the Tul.es, regulations, orders, actions or failure to a.ct of any public
ll SECTION 2, §2.2 (Contd) body or official. purporting to exercise authority or control with respect to such liquid discharges; or (iii) due to any cause beyond the reasonable control of Consumers Power; provided, however, that radioactive materials in liquid discharges to Lake Michigan from the modified liquid radwaste system during any such excused delay beyond said sixty (60) day period shal.J.. not exceed, on a quarterly average basis and on an individual. iso-topic analysis basis, one percent (1%) of applicable io CFR Part 20 limits in effect as of December 1, 1970; and provided further, however, that Consumers Power shall undertake promptly to correct abnormal operating con-ditions which result in releases of radioactive ma.teriaJ.s in liquid dis-charges to Lake Michigan from the modified liquid radwaste system at levels greater.than essentially zero.
§2.3 Upon execution of this Agreement, Consumers Power will proceed immediately with a.ll due diligence to arrange for the design, engineering, procurement of equipment and materiaJ.s, and construction required to install the modified liquid radwaste system as provided for herein and to make application to obtain all licenses, permits, consents or other authorizations of public bodies or officiaJ.s which are required in connection with the design, construction, operation and maintenance of the modified liquid rad.waste system. In making and pursuing such applica-tions Consumers Power shall pursue administrative remedies or court actions,*
_or both, in the manner provided in Section 10 of this Agreement, and the rights and obligations of the parties in connection with such remedies or actions shall be governed and determined by Section 10 of this Agreement
- 12 SECTION 2, §2.3 (Contd)
The design of said system shall be reviewed and approved by Combustion Engineering, Inc. in the manner described in subsection B.l.c *. and d. of Article I of the February 8, 1966 Nuclear Equipment Contract, as a.mended to December 1, 1970, between Consumers Power a.nd Combustion Engineering, Inc.
- The modified liquid ra.dwaste system shall be installed and placed in opera.-
tion no la.ter than.the resumption of operation of the Palisades Plant a.:f'ter its first scheduled ref'ueling (which is expected.to occur approx:i.ma.te~ seventeen (17] calendar months following the date of commencement of escala-tion to full power following issuance of the full-power license) or twenty-foilr (24) calendar months following the date of execution of this Agreement, whichever occurs first. The foregoing provisions of this §2.3 are subject to the condition that in the event the installa.tion or the initial operation of such modified liquid ra.dwaste system is delayed (i) by reason of fl.cod; strike; insurrection; riot; embargo; act of nature or the public enemy; or una.voida.ble delay in transportation or inability or unavoidable delay in procuring labor or materials; (ii) by reason of legal action by a third party; local, state or federal la.'Ws; or xhe rules, regulations, orders, actions or failure to a.ct of any public body or officia.l purporting to exercise authority or control with respect to insta.llation or operation of the modified liquid rad.waste system; or (iii) by reason of any ca.use beyond the reasonable control of Consumers Power, the time for perfonna.nce sha.11 be extended (subject to the provisions of Section 1.0 of this Agree-ment as respects [ii] above) for a time equal to the period of such delay. Moreover, until initial successful.operation of the modified liquid rad.waste
13 SECTION 2, §2.3 (Contd) system, Consumers Power shall notify Intervenors quarterly of al1. occurrences or conditions then known to a.ny officer of Consumers Power*, or to an employee reporting directly and regul.a.rly to a;ny such officer, "Which Consumers Power ma.y claim form a. basis for a.n extension of time for theinsta.llation and operation of the modified liquid ra.dwaste system,* a.nd sha.11*.notify *Inter-venors on a current basis of a.llY: occurrence or condition known to any officer of Consumers Power, or to an employe*e reporting directly and regularly to a.ny sucll officer, which Consumers Power then claims will form a basis for such an extension of time.
§2.4 Pending installation and operation. of the modified liquid ra.dwaste system pursUa.nt to the schedule provided iri §2.3 hereo~, Consumers Power,. insofar a.s Intervenors a.re concerned, may operate the Palisades Plant at a.ny power levels authorized by any AEC license issued to Consumers Power, utiJ.izing the existing liquid ra.dwaste.system; provided tha.t radioactive materials in liquid discharges to Lake Michigan shall be. at levels which are at all times a.s low as practicable and which do not exceed, on a quarterly average basis and on a.n individual isotopic analysis basis, a.nd based on the assumptions used in Section 11 of Consumers Power's Final Safety Analysis Report to the AEC for the Palisades Plant as amended to December l, 1970, (i) under normal or abnormal opera.ting. conditions as defined in §2.l hereof and assuming no failed fuel, two percent (23) of a:pplicable l.O CF_R PSJ:t 20_
l:i:inits in effect a.s of December l, 1970; and (ii) under normal or abnormal opera.ting conditions as defined in §2.l hereof and assuming some failed fuel, ten percent (10%) of applicable 10 CFR Pa.rt 20 limits in effect as of December 1, 1970.
14
- SECTION 3 - GASEOUS. RALWASTE SYSTEM
§3.1 No engineered feasible system is presently available to reduce the gaseous radioactivity release from a pressurized-water-reactor nuclear power plant to essentia.lly zero. Work is presently in progress by reactor vendors, na.tiona.l laboratories, and utility companies, including Consumers Power, on the development of systems o~ cauiponents of systems to reduce gaseous waste releases to essentia.lly zero. Consumers .Power wi11 reasonably support the developmental progress of this t-.roe of system and will retrofit such a system to the Palisades Plant when it is* available, proVided that regulato~J approvals for such retrofitting can be secured and provided thB.t; in.Consumers Power's reasonable judgment, (i) it is technically feasible to *retrofit such a. sys~em to the Pa.J.isades Plant at a reasonable cost, and (ii) the use of such. a system in the Palisades Plant would result in a.whole-body radiation dose at the Palisades Plant site bounda.rJ (assuming a. one percent [l%] failed fuel condition) signifi-cantly less than the whole-body radiation dose expected at the Palisades Plant site boundary (assuming a one percent [_1%] failed fuel condition) utilizing the existing gaseous radwaste system. . The latter whole-body radiation dose is described in Appendix III hereto *
.SECTION 4 - HOT FUNCTIONAL TEST
§4.1 On or a.bout February 5, 1971 Consumers Power commenced a hot functional test at the Palisades Plant covering the primary system and all nuclear auxiliary systems affected by the heatup of the primary system. The satisfactory performance a.nd completion of such test shall
15
- SECTION 4, §4,l (Contd) be recorded iri Palisades Plant records.
the AEC At Consumers Power's request,
- f'urnished ins:pectors to review the test procedUres, Witness sig-nificant :parts of the test .a.nd verify the test.results as recorded in Palisades Plant records. Consumers Power agrees to :per.?llit a representative of Intervenors to inspect, at a:ny reasonable time, the Palisades Plant*
records in which the testing contemplated by this §4.l is recorded. Consumers Power will request the ASLB or the AEC to have copies of AEC inspection reports covering said test made available to Intervenors. *
- SECTION 5 - CONTROL ROD TESTS
§5.1 Consumers Power agrees to test in the Palisades Plant reactor, within thirty (30) days after initia.l fuel loading, a.U full-length ..
control. rods which are to be initia.lly installed in the Palisades Plant reactor. The test shall be ma.de in accordance with the Consumers Power procedure entitled "Control Rod Performance Test," dated January 8, 1971, a. copy of' which ha.s been furnished to Intervenors, and sha.11 subject said control rods to normal opera.ting temperature, pressure, flmr, and rod movements, including drops from the f'ull-out and ha.l!'-out positions. The reactor shall be held subcritica.l by boron concentration throughout the test. The data obtained from the test will be evaluated by Combustion Engineering, Inc. to assure tha.t rod drop time requirements are met as provided in the "Control Rod Perf'ormance Test" procedure. If control rod drive motor current and drop time measurements ma.de during_ the test demonstrate that a;rry control rod exhibits a;rry abnormality that would impair
16 SECTION 5, §5.l (Contd) the ability of the rod to drop in an acceptable drop time, then Consumers Power shall either repair said rod or rep~ce*said rod with a. control*rod not exhibiting any such abnormality, prior to initial criticality~
*§5.2 At the conclusion of zero power physics t~sting and prior to escalation to power, Consumers Power shall repeat the test contemplated by §5.1 hereof to verify drop times on all installed fulJ.-length control .rods, and Combustion Engineering, Inc. shall eva.l:ua.te the data obtained from such repeat test to assure that rod drop time requirements are met as prorlded in the Control Rod Performance Test II procedure. If control.
rod drive motor current and drop til:ie measurements ma.de during the repeat test demonstrate that any control rod exhibits any abnormality Which woul.d impair the ability of the rod to drop in an acceptable drop time, then Consumers Power sha.ll. either repair said rod or replace said rod with a control rod not exhibiting any such a.bnonnality, prior to esca.lation to. power.
§5.3 Consumers Power shall require Combustion Engineering, Inc.
to submit to Consumers Power a written report of its eVa.lua.tions of the tests contemplated by this Section 5, and a copy of such report shall be filed as a part of the Palisades Plant records. Consumers Power agrees to permit a representative of Intervenors to inspect, at a:ny reasonable time, the Palisades Plant records covering the procedures, measurements and evaluations of tp.e tests contempla.ted by this Sect:i,on 5
- 17
- SECTION 6 - MPSC APPROVAL; WITHDRAWAL OF INTERVENTION
§6.1 Upon execution of this Agreement, Intervenors shall cooperate with and take all appropriate action to assist and support Consumers.Power in expeditiously obtaining the testing license, in-cluding but not limited to joining immediately with Consumers Power in presenting and f{ling in the proceeding the stipulatibn (a.copy of which is attached *hereto as Append.ix IV), which shall be executed by
*the :parties' attorneys of record in the :proceeding a.t the time of execu-tion of th~s-Agreement. Upon execution of this Agreement the parties' attorneys of record in the proceeding shall also execute, for later
. presentation and filing in the pro_ceeding as provided in §6. 6 hereof, the Stipulation (a copy of which_ is attached hereto a.s Appendix V) supporting issuance to Consumers Power of the full-power license con-taining the technical specifications in the form set forth in Exhibit A to said Append.ix V (said form of technical specifications being called in this Agreement the "special technical specifications") a.s pa.rt of the Technical Specifications for the Palisades Piant. By execution of this Agreement, the parties authorize their respective attorneys of record in this proceeding to execute_ and file said Stipulations in the pro-ceeding in accordance with this Agreement.
§6.2 Upon execution of this Agreement, Consumers Power shall, with a.ll due diligence, make a.pplica.tion to the Mi*chigan Public Servic*e Commission (in this Agreement called the "MPSC") for a.n order or other au-thorization (in this Agreement cal.led the "MPSC order") approving Consumers
18 SECTION 6, §6.2 (Contd) Power's execution and performance of this Agreement(and authorizing Consumers
*Power. for rate*ma.k.ing purposes to include in its rate base its total investment*in the design, engineering, equipment and construction of the modified condenser cooling system a.nd*the modified liquid radwaste system, less depreciation, and to include in its cost of service the expenses to be incurred in operating a,nd maintaining the modified condenser cooling system and the modified. liquid radwaste system.)
§6.3 Except as provided in (ii) of §6.4 hereof, this Agreement (a:.nd a.ll the rights and obligations of the parties hereunder) shall terminate and the Stipulation supporting the issuance to Consumers Power of the full-power license containing the special technical specifications shall be of no f'urther
- force or effect "(i) if .the .MPSC order is denied; or (ii) if the proceeding is .
- reconvened to consider the issuance of the full-power license or any operating license other tha.n the testing license prior to the granting or denial of the
.MPSC order; or (iii) if, a~er the MPSC order has been granted, the proceeding is reconvened to consider the issuance of.the ful.1.-power license or any oper-a.ting license other than the. testing license prior to the expiration of all t:ime permitted by law for rehearing, appeal or review of the MPSC order, or prior to the completion of any and all rehearing, appeal or review of the MPSC *C?!°d~~-- if rehearing, appeal or review thereof is. sought by any person.
§6.4* *No party hereto shall request that the proceeding be reconvened to consider the issuance of the full-power license or e:ny operating license other than the testing license (i) prior to the granting
- or the denial of the MPSC order, except that if the MPSC has neither granted nor denied the MPSC order within sixty (60) calendar days following the .
*-*--*-;*---*-----*--:--*--***---a-*---**-*
19 SECTION 6, §6.4 (Contd) date of filing of the application for the MPSC *order, *then Consumers Power shall have the right to request the reconvening of the proceeding to consider the issuance of the full-power license or any operating license other than the testing license; .or (ii) while there is pending any re-quest for rehearing, appeal or review of any granting of the MPSC order, or during the time in which any such rehearing, appeal or review of such granted MPSC order ma.y be spught under applicable law; provided, however, tha.t, while there is pending any such*request for rehearing, appeal or review of such granted MPSC order, or during the time in which any such rehearing,
- appeal or review of such granted MPSC order may be sought under applicable law, Consumers Pow:ers~ll have the right to request that the proceeding be reconvened to consider the issuance of the full-power license or any opera.ting license containing the special technical specifications, other than the testing license, and if Consumers Power does so request the pro-ceeding to be reconvened, as provided in this (ii), then Intervenors agree that they will join in such request, a.nd the parties agree that this Agree-ment shall not thereby terminate as provided in §6.3.hereof.
§6.5 Consumers Power shall promptly noti:t'y Intervenors of any request by a;n.y person for any rehearing, appeal or review of the granting of the MPSC order. Intervenors shall have the right, insofar as Consumers Power is concerned, -to participate in a:n.y such rehearing, a.~eal- or review and Consumers. Power shall pursue administrative remedies or court actions, or both, in connection with any such rehearing, appeal or review in the
- - manner provided for in Section 10 of this Agreement, in order to assert
20
- SECTION. 6, §6.5 (Contd).
the :validity of the granting of the MPSC order. If, after exhausting al1 such administrative remedies or court actions ?r both, it is finally determined that the MPSC order, or a:ny portion thereof, shouJ.d not have been gra:nted: I. and the MPSC ord.er or portion thereof is . required for the performance by Consumers Power of a.ny provision or provisions of this Agreement, then Consumers Power will be forever relieved of any obliga-tion to perform any provision or provisions of this Agreement (a.nd any and a.ll other provisions of this Agreement 'Which require _that said provision or pro-visions be performed) as to 'Which such invalidated MPSC order or portion thereof is required; II. a.nd the Ml?SC order or portion thereof is not required for the performance by Consumers Power of.any provision or provisions of this Agreement, then not-withstanding such final determination, Consumers Power will not thereby be relieved from performing any pro-vision or provisions of this Agreement.
§6 .6 In the event Consumers Power is granted the MPSC order prior to the time the procee~ing is reconvened to consid~r ~ss:uance of the full-power license or any opera.ting license other than the testing license, or if, pursuant to (ii) of §6.4 hereof, Consumers Power requests the reconvening of the proceeding while there is pending a.ny request for rehearing, appeal or review of such granted MPSC order, or during the time
.1 I
- SECTION 6 ,. §6. 6 (Contd) 21 in which any such rehearing, appeal. or review of such granted MPSC order may be sought under applicable law, Consumers Power shall promptly deliver to Inter-
. venors a notice to that effect. Intervenors shall there:uPon cooperate with and take a1.l appropriate action not *inconsistent with this Agreement to assist a.nd support Consumers Power in expeditiously obtaining the fuJ.l:-power license con-taining the special technical specifications, including but not limited to joining with Consumers Power in presenting and filing the Stipulation executed at the same time as. this Agreement* (a. copy of which is attached hereto as Appendix V).
From the time of the execution of this Agreement Intervenors shall not; unless requested by Consumers Power in order to support the issuance of the testing license and/or the full.-power license containing the special technical Speci-fications, or unless directed or requested by the ASLB, or unless permitted by this Agreement or the Stipulations (copies of which a.re attached hereto as Appendixes IV and V), take a.ny further action in the proceeding or file *I any documents therein (other tha.n the aforesaid Stipulations) or initiate or participate in any actions (including but not limited to administrative remedies or court actions) dehors the proceeding with respect to or in connection with the testing license, or the full-power license containing the special technical specifications,_or the issuance of' said licenses.
§6.7 When (i) the fuJ.l-power license has been issued to Consumers Power containing the spe~ial_ technic~l specifications and (ii) the initial or final decision in the proceeding bas become the final action of the A.EC without amendment of the said full.-power license so as to remove or change the special. technical. specifications, then Intervenors shall be deemed, without further action on their part, to have withdrawn from the proceeding
22 SECTION 6, §6. 7 (Contd.) with prejudice and without right thereafter (except as otherwise provided in §§6.9, 6.10 and 11.2 and Section 10 of this Agreement) to take a.ny further action in the proceeding or otherwise in AEC Docket No. 50-255;
- or t6 take any action in a.ny AEC proceeding to extend, renew or convert the full-power license from a provisional t_o a fina.1 operating license or to a.mend the full-power license to authorize operation of the.Palisades Plant at a.ny power level higher tha.n that authorized in the :f'u.ll-power license; or to appeal or to stay the effectiveness of a.ny or a.J.l. decisions, findings, orders or rulings theretofore or thereafter made or entered in the pro-ceeding or otherwise in AEC Docket No. 50-255 or in a.ny AEC proceeding to so extend, renew, convert or a.mend the full-power license; or ts initiate or participate in axry actions (including but not limited to administrative remedies or court actions) dehors the proceeding with respect to or in connection with the testing license or the :f'ull.-power license or the issu-ance of said licenses. Moreover, upon such issuance of the full-power license containing the special technical specifications and the initial or final decision in the proceeding having become the final action of the AEC, as aforesaid in (i) and (ii) of this §6.7, Intervenors sha.11 also thereby be deemed to ha.ve waived and forever relinquished any and all rights to take any legal action with respect to a.ny alleged noncompliance of the Palisades Plant, the proceeding or .a.flY decision in the proceeding, or the. testing license or the :f'ull-power license, with the National Environmental Policy Act, the Federal Wate.r Pollution Control Act as amended, the Atomic Energy Act of 1954 as amended, the Federal Rivers and Harbors Act of March 3, 1899 as a.mended, the*Federa.l Clean Air Act as amended, or with any other federal, state or local statutes or
. 23 SECTION 6, §6.7 (Contd) ordinances and a.nY, rules, orders and regulations of the AEC or any other public official or* agency* under a:ny of said* Acts, statutes or ordinanc.es.
§6.8* Consumers Power shall have the right to te~nate this Agreement by notice t.o Intervenors if ( i) the full-power ll.cense con-
- ta.ining the special technical specifications has not been issued by the *
- AEC Director of Regulation within one hundred fifty (150) calendar days after the dat~ of execution of this Agreement (:provided, that said 150.;.*
day period shal1 be eitended by one day for ea.ch day that the completion of low-power testing under the testing license is delayed beyond thirty~five [35].calenda.r days from and after the date of issuance of the testing li-cense), or (ii) there has ~een entered a court order or decree or an order of ~ public body or official having jurisdiction which, in the reasonable opinion of legal counsel for Consumers Power, renders improbable the issuance of such a full-power license within said 150-day period, as said 150-da.y period may be extended under (i) of this §6.8, or, if such court order or decree or order of a public body or official prevents the com-pletion of the low-power testing, as said 150-da.y period ms:y have been ~ tended under (i) of this §6.8 prior to the entry of such court order or decree or order of a public body or official. Upon delivery of such notice this Agreement (a.nd all the rights and obligations of the parties hereunder) shall terminate and the Stipulation (a co~y of which is attached hereto as Appendix.V) supporting the issuance to Consumers Power of such a :t'ull.-power license, if theretofore filed in the pro-ceeding, shall be withdrawn and shall be of no :f'urther force or effect.
24 SECTION 6 (Contd)
§6.9 Nothing* contained in this Section 6.sha.ll. preclude Intervenors from initiating any action.or.proceeding in AEC Docket No. 50-255 on account of Consumers Power's alleged breach of or failure*
of performance pursuant to this Agreement.
§6.10 Consumers Power shall give Intervenors advance notice of a:oy change.
in the technical snecifications of the fu.11-nower license respecting the construction, ins.ta.llation and operation of the modified radwaste and/or condenser coo~ing systems proposed by Consumers Power a.f'ter the issuance of said license. If Intervenors are of the
.opinion that a.n:y such proposed change is a breach of or failure of performance
. pursuant to this Agreement, they shall notify Consumers .
Po'Wer of such opinion within fifteen (15) business days following de-livery of sa.id notice by Consumers Power. If within ten (10) business days after delivery of such notice to Consumers Power, Intervenors re-quest .the AEC to hold a public hearing in connection with such proposed change, and if such request is reasonable, then Consumers Power will also request the AEC to hold a public hearing in connection with such proposed. change. Nothing herein shall preclude Intervenors *from ini-tiating a.n:y a.ctionor proceeding, in addition to such an AEC hearing, to contest a.n:y such proposed change on the ground tha.t it is a. breach of or failure of performance pursuant to this Agre~ent. SECTION 7 - RESERVATIONS
§7.l Nothing in this Agreement sha.ll prevent Consumers Power any from ta.king steps or measures in connection with the design, con-struction, modification or operation of the modified condenser cooling
-. --- =~-*---* -* 25 SECTION 7, §7.l (Contd) system and the modii'ied liquid radwaste system which contemplate modifica-tions, procedures or modes of operation equal. to or better, considering the protection of the environment, .than the modifications; procedures or modes of operation contemplated in this Agreement; provided, however, that the foregoing provisions shall not authorize Consumers Power to ta.ke a:ny steps or measures to install an.d operate a modified condenser cooling system having an open-cycle system utilizing La.ke Michigan water for* once-through cooling or to install and operate a modified liquid radwaste system which wou1d release radioactivity to the environment at levels above those contem-plated in Section 2 and Appendix.II of this Agreement under the conditions
*therein stated.
§7.2 The parties agree that Consumers Power's agreement to the modifications, procedures and modes of operation contemplated herein for the Palisades Plant and any action ta.ken by Consumers Power pursuant to this Agreement before or after the execution of this Agreement shall not
- be deemed, construed, interpreted or claimed to be an admission that*the same or a:n.y similar modifications, procedures or modes of operation are necessary or required at any other Consumers Power electric generating plant. The obligations of Consumers Power under this Agreement are limited to the Palisades Plant.
SECTION 8 - OTHER PROCEEDINGS
§8.l Intervenors sball. not initiate, or take part in directly or indirectly, or aid, advise or furnish infor.ma.tion to a.ny other person,
,.------------------~-- - ------ -
26 SECTION 8, §8.1 _(Contd) corporation or association in connection with, any suit, proceeding before any governmental agency, or other action, whether or not now pending (in-cluding but_ not lilllited to the pending proceeding in A.EC Docket Nos. 50-329 and 50-330 concerning issuance of construction.permits for Consumers Power's Midland Plant Units 1 and 2) to raise or contest issues with respect to (i) the design, construction, licensing or operation of.the.Palisades Plant, inclUding but not lilllited to the licensing or operation of the Palisades Plant at power levels above 2200 therma.1 megawatts {except as other-wise permitted by §§6.9, 6.10 and 11.2 and Section 10 of this Agreement); (ii) expenditures by Consumers Power to install and operate the modified liquid radwaste system or the modified condenser cooling system at the
,- Palisades Plant; (iii) expenditures by Consumers Power to obtain the testing and full-power licenses for the Palisades Plant or expenditures in connection therewith or resulting therefrom.
SECTION 9 - INFOBMATION AND REPORTS
§9.1 Not more frequently than quarterly, Consumers Power will answer reasonable requests for information respecting its performs.nee under Sections l, 2. a.nd 3 of this Agreement when made in writing by one
* (l) of the representatives designated in or in accordance with Section 16 hereof on behalf' of all of the Intervenors. Furth'ermore, Consumers Power shall, without request therefor, f'urnish to a representative of Intervenors, on behalf of all of the Intervenors, one (1) copy of all written reports Consumers Power is required to file with the AEC under the Plant Reporting Requirements of the Technical Specifications for the Pa.1isades Plant.
27 SECTION 9 (Contd)
§9.2 Upon execution of this Agreement, Consumers Power sha.11
- amend its proposed Technical Specifications for the Palisades Plant to add the following new item e. to subsection 6.6.l of Section 6.6, "PIANT REPORTING REQUIREMENTS II:
"e. When a control rod or a. pa.rt-length rod is misaligned as defined in 3.l0.4.a. of these Technical Specifications or when a.
control rod is inoperable a.s defined in
. 3.l0.4.b of these Technical Specifications. 11 SECTION 10 - LEGAL VALIDITY
§10.l If Consumers Power believes that the performance of a.ny provision or provisions of this Agreement (including any corresponding
- ~*
special techiiical specifications included in the full-power lic~nse, whether* or not specified in the notice) is contrary to or prevented by any local, state or federal law, or the rule, regulation, order, action or failure to a.ct of any public body or official purporting to exercise authority with re-spect thereto, or the order or decree of any* court, then Consumers Power shall prcmptJ.¥ notify Intervenors thereof by telegram., telephone or other meana and notify Interveriors thereof in writing within ten (10) business days thereafter, stating the basis for such belief. In the event Intervenors notify Consumers Power of their agreement with such belief within thirty (30) calendar days after delivery of the aforesaid written notice by Consumers Power (and from the time of the aforesaid telephonic, telegraphic; or other means of notice by* consumers Power and 1.Ultil the end of such thirty (30) day period whether or not such notification. is given to Consumers Power
28 SECTION.10, §10.1 (Contd) by Intervenors) Consumers Power shall be relieved of a;ny obligation to perform the provision or provisions in question and a:ny and all other provisions of this Agreement which require that said provision or pro-visions be performed. However, notwithstanding its release fl-om obliga-tion as provided in this. §10.1, Consumers Power shall have the right, in its sole dis.cretion, to perform or seek to perform said provision or provisions. In the event Intervenors do not so notify Consumers Power within sa.id thirty (30) da.y period, then Consumers Power shall in good faith and with due diligence pursue administrative remedies or court actions (in-cluding appeals or requests for wits of certiorari to the highest state or federal cOurt having jurisdiction), or both, to assert the ~idity of the performance of said provision or provisions and/or the invalidity or unla.wfuJ.ness .of the la.w, rule, regulation; order, decree, actio~ or failure to act that is the subject of the aforesaid witten notice by Consumers Power.
§10.2 In the event of an unfavorable ruling or the inability to have the validity of the performance of such provision or provisions (which a.re the subject of suit and/or proceeding as contemplated in §10.1 hereof) upheld a.f'ter exhausting all rights of hearing, appeal and requests for wits of certiorari to the highest state or federal court having juris-diction, then Consumers Power will forever be relieved of any obligation to perform the provision or provisions in question and a.ny and all other provisions of this Agreement which require that said provision or provisions be performed.
29
- SECTION 10 (Contd)
§10.3 In the event Interyenors.or one or more of them seek to participate in any courta.ction or administrative proceeding contemplated by §10.l hereof~ Consumers Power agrees not to oppose their particiIJa.tion and to stipul.a.te
. or take other. appropriate action to induce the . court or agency to permit Iµtervenors or one or more of them to participate.in the proceeding.
Whether or not Intervenors are permitted to participate, the parties sha.ll. cooperate by exchanging a.ll pertinent information, documents, plea.dings, or other papers filed or of record in such couxt or agency proceeding.
§l0.4 In the event Intervenors are not permitted to participate as a party in a:n:y such couxt or administrative proceeding, Consumers Power agrees to consider adopting a.nd submitting evidence a.nd arguments of Intervenors in support of Consumers Power's position before the court or agency except a.nd un1ess the same a.re, in Constmlers Power's judgment, defamatory, irrel.eva.nt, repetitious, ina.ccuxa.te or otherwise improper.
§10.5 The parties agree that while Consumers Power is pursuing the administrative remedies or couxt actions, or both, contemplated in
§10.l. hereof, Consumers Power.:may operate the Pa.l.isa.des Plant in s;rry manner pemitted by la.w; provided, however, Consumers Power agrees that while it is pursuing sa.id administrative remedies or court actions, or both, it sha.J.J. continue to perform all of the provisions of this Agreement except s;rry provision or provisions (and any and al.l. other provisions which require that said provision or provisions be performed) a.s to 'Which (i) it is pre-vented by a. court order or decree or is prevented by a.n order, notice or other action of any publ.ic body or official. having authority to enforce
30 SECTION io, §10.5 (C.ontd) such order, notice or other action without resort to a court for enforcement; or (ii) it is prevented by the la.ck of any permit, license, consent or other authorization of any public body or official which is required for continued performance; or (iii) to do so would~ in the reasonable opinion of legal counsel for Consumers Power, result in the violation of any criminal la.w or criiii:inal. ordinance or the imposition of a:ny criminal or civil fine, criminS.l. or civil penalty, or criminal or civil forfeiture; or (iv) there has been entered a court order or *.decree or a:n order, notice or other action of a public body or official which; while not preventing performance of this Agreement by Consumers P0wer, would require shutdown of the Palisades Plant or a reduction in the electrical output of the Palisades Plant if Consumers Power continued to perform.
§10.6 The special technical specifications to be iiicluded .
in the ful.1-power license sbs.ll. provide that Consumers Power sbs.ll. be relieved of any obligation to comply with said technical specifications to the extent and during the time tha.t Consumers Power is relieved from performing any corresponding provision or provisions of this Agreement pursuant to this Section 10. SECTION"ll - DISPUTES
§ll.l If any dispute arises b.etween Consumers Power and Inter-venors concerning the interpretation or performance of this Agreement, they will. first attempt' to resolve the same by good faith discussions directed toward settlement by t'ui"ther agreement.
-*. SECTION ll (Contd)
-31.
§ll.2 Any party hereto shall have the right, if' .not inconsistent with the terms of' this Agreement, to enforce a.n:y obligation of any other party hereto l.lllder this.Agreement in a.ny action, including administrative actions a.nd actions in AEC Doc..~et No *. 50-255; provided, however, the
. parties hereto a.gree that a breach of this. Agreement by a.n:y party cannot be adequately compensated or measured by money dmilages a.nd that the parties to this Agreement 'With resp.ect to enforcement thereof do not ha.ve an adequate
*remedy a.t la.w, except that a party hereto may enforce a.ny obligation of a:rr:r*
other party hereto a.nd seek money damages for breach of an obligation, if the*breach resulted from or was cased upon conduct which is either arbitrary, capricious or in be.d faith.
§ll.3 The parties agree that the obligations herein a.re not intended to create third party beneficiary rights and a.re not enforceable at the instance of any person who is not a. party hereto except a.s, a.nd to the extent that, the provisions hereof may be enforceable l.lllder appli-cable la.ws by any public body or official having authority to do so.
SECTION 12 - RATIFICATION AND APPROVAL
§12.1 Concurrently with the execution of this Agreement Consumers Power and each corporate Intervener shall deliver to each of the other parties verified evidence of the authority of the person executing the same to do so for and on beha.l:f of the corporation represented by such person.
Within thirty (30) days after the execution of this .Agreement, ea.ch Inter-venor which is* a voluntary association or other unincorporated organization
- shall deliver to each o:f' the other parties .a verified certificate by the
----*;*J..r .....
32. SECTION 12, §12.l (Contd) president or other authorized representative thereof.affirming tha.t the members of the association or organization have authorized or ratified and approved this Agreement a.nd the execution thereof on behalf of the associa-tion or other Unincorporated organization or that such members a.re not required to specifically authorize or ratify.and approve thf:s Agreement and the execution thereof, and that such members will be .jointly and severa..lly bound by.this*i\greement without their specific authorization or ratifies.- tion and approva.i thereof. SECTION 13 - BINDING EFFECT
§13.l The promises and undertakings herein shall be.binding upon the parties signatory to this Agreement and upon their heirs, representatives,
( successors and assigns; provided, however, tha.t a.ny transfer or assignment by an Intervenor of this Agreement to another party (whether or not the latter is a signatory hereof) or to a. successor, without the prior written consent of Consumers Power, sha.ll be null and void; and provided further, however, that Consumers Power shall consent to the transfer of this Agree-ment to a. *successor corporation of a. corporate Intervenor upon the merger or consolidation of such corporate Intervenor with, or the transfer of substa.ntia.lly a.ll of its assets to,.another corporation ha.ving in general the same purposes and objectives as the said corporate Intervenor a.nd i:f' said successor corporation is, by* applicable law or otherwise, bound and obligated under this Agreement to the same extent. and in the same manner as said corporate Intervenor was so bound a.nd obligated prior to such merger, consolidation or transfer of assets *
- (
33 SECTION 13 (Contd)
§13.2 Consumers Power agrees tha.t any unincorporated Intervenor may transfer and assign this Agreement to a. nonprofit corporation here-a.:f'ter organized under the laws of the State of Michigan by all. of the then .members (in this §13.2 ca.lied "incorporating members") of said Intervenor a.nd ha.ving in general the same purposes and objectives a.s said unincorpo-rated Intervenor, :provided (i) that said.corporation agrees in writing with Consumers Power to assume and be bound by all. of the obligations of Inter-venors under this Agreeme.>it; (ii) that a.11 living incorpora.ting members of .sa.id Intervenor, and all. living persons who were members in good standing of sa.id Intervenor on the date of its intervention in the proceeding or at a;r;ry time during the :proceeding(in this §13.2 called "intervening members"),
consent in writing to said transfer and assignment; (iii) tha.t all living incorporating members a.nd all. living intervening members of said Intervenor execute and deliver to Consumers Power a written release, in a form satis-factory to Consumers Power, forever releasing and discharging Consumers Power from any and a.ll obligations under this Agreement to ea.ch said incorporating or intervening member; (iv) that said Intervenor delivers to Consumers Power a complete list of its* incorporating and intervening members and the la.st-known address of ea.ch said member, verified by the representative of said Intervenor who executes this Agreement; and (v) tha.t compliance by said Intervenor and the incorporating e.nd intervening members thereof with the conditions of this §J.3.2 shall be a condition precedent to the effectiveness and va.J.idity of said transfer or assignment *
- SECTION J.4 - PUBLICITY
§J.4.1 Intervenors and Consumers Power.agree that ea.ch party may discl.ose to others such of the tel'.'lllS of this Agreement, a.s well a.s the reasons underlying such party's having entered into the same, a.s such party may detemine or a.s may be required to effectuate the terms hereof or* a.s may be required by.law or order of a:n.y governmenta.1 authority.
§14.2 Tl:le parties will issue a. joint news release announcing execution of this Agreement, . as follows:
"Spokesmen for Consumers Power Company and the groups which have intervened in AEC licensing pro-ceedings to contest the issuance of an opera.ting license for the Company's Palisades Nuclear Power Plant on Lake Michigan in Covert Township, Van. Buren County, Michigan, today announced that the parties ha.ve entered into a settlement agreement.
"The Company announced that it will proceed with a program, to insta.11 and operate, under .AEC license J.jJnitationa, cooling towers and an essentia.lly zero radioactive liquid release system at the Pa.1isades Plant.
The modli'ications will be a major undertaking and may take.severa.l years to complete.* It is contemplated tha.t the Plant will operate as presently constructed while the work is being done.
"Under the settlement agreement, insta.llation of the modifications is conditioned upon receipt of an order of the Michigan Public Service CCmmission approving the Company's execution and performance of the settlement agreement. *
"The settlement agreement a.1so provides that the Intervenors will agree to the immediate issuance of a.
license to pemit the Company to load fuel and begin low-power testing at the plant. 'When the Pu.bJ.ic Service Commission approval and a :f'tlll-power AEC license a.re obtained,
- the Intervenors will a.1so withdraw from the AEC proceeding and waive a.11 rights of appea1 on the issues .they have been* contesting.
"The proposed cooling towers will be of the mechanica.1 or natural draft type. Except for the cJ.eansing of lake
- SECTION 14, §14 .2 (Contd) 35 water residues.-frem the towers, they will form a.
closed circuit in which heated.condenser cooling water will be cooled a.nd recirculated for use in the Plant.
"The.modifications to the liquid radioactive waste system will essentially eliminate radioactive liquid discharges under normal conditions. The exist-ing system would release same radioactivity, although at levels 8ubstantia.lly below current AEC limits.*
A spokesman for the intervening groups urged approva.J. and installation of the modifications as soon as possible, describing the c*ampa.ny' s program as a major advance toward protection of the environ-ment through utilization of the la.test and best technology.
"The in:tervenors ' spokesman also sa.id: 'We hope and trust tha.t all state and federal agencies whose approval is required for these modifications will move qui~ to permit the parties to carry out their agree-ment, which we believe will assure the environmental protection we ha.ve been seeking and is thus in the public interest.'
"Spokesmen for both parties expect tha.t the AEC hes.ring Call be concluded in the near future and that issuance of a full-power operating licens.e will soon follow."
The foregoing news release is not in any way intended, a.nd shall not be deemed, to add to or subtract from or modify any of the rights Slld obliga-tions of the parties set forth in this .Agreement, and shall not in any way be uaed to interpret the provisions of this .Agreement. SiX:TION 15 - SERVICE OF PROCESS
§15.l For the purpose of bringing suit in connection with this .Agreement -in a.rry court in the State of Michigan, any party ma;:y (in addition to any other procedures authorized by applicable law or ru1es) obtain
36
- SECTION 1$, §15.1 (Contd) service of process upon any other party by leaving a copy of the Smmnons and Complaint with said other party's representative or representatives named in or pursuant to Section 16 of this Agreement, and by sending by registered ma.il*a Summons and a copy of the Complaint to said other party at its address stated in the first para.graph at page 1 of this Agreement (or, if such stated address is changed and said other party has notified all parties hereto of such change in -writing, at said changed address of said other party). Service of process ma.de in accordance with the fore-going provisions shall constitute valid service of process upon any party so served. This §15.1 shall not govern the method of service of process for any suit brought elsewhere than in the State of Michigan.
SECTION 16 - NOTICES
§16.1 Except as otherwise specifically provided in §10.l hereof, a.ny notice or other communication required by this Agreement shall be in writing and delivered either by messenger to the office of a representative of a party during regular business hours or by registered or certified mail, return receipt requested, postage prepaid to a. repre-senta.tive of a. party, as follows:
(a) If to Consumers Power: P *. A. PerrJ, Secreta.ry-Consumers Power Company 212 West Michigan Avenue Jackson, Michigan 49201 (b). If to Intervenors: For all Intervenors except Sierra Club:
- Eric V. Brown, Sr., Esq.
Brown, Colman & DeMent 125 W. Wa.J.nut Street . Kalamazoo, Michigan 49007 and
37 SECTION 16, §16.l (Contd). Myron M. Cherry, Esq. McDermott, Will & Emery lll West Monroe Street Chicago, Illinois 6o6o3 For Sierra Club: Lewis D. Drain, Esq. Mika, Meyers, Beckett & Jones 311 Waters Building Grand Rapids, Michigan 49502 Copies of all such notices and information shall.be delivered to: David Dinsmore Camey . Businessmen For The Public Interest, Inc. 109 North
Dearborn Street,
Suite 1001
- Chicago, Illinois 6o6o2 Any party may change its representative or representatives at any time, provided, however, that (i) the Sierra Club, and (ii) all Inter-venors except Sierra Club, sha.11 each have one representative who shall have and maintain a business address in the Lower Peninsu1a. of the State of Michigan, and all Intervenors except Sierra Club ms:y in addition have one representative who shall have and maintain a business address in Cook County in the State of Illinois; and provided further, that said party shall notify the others in writing of any change in the identity and/or address of its said representative or representatives. Notices and other communications required to be made in writing pursuant to this Agreement shall be deemed to be delivered on the day of actua1 delivery if by messenger or on the third ca.lenda.r day a.f'ter the day of mailing, as the case ms:y be.
38
- SECTION 17 - TERMINATION
§J.7~J. If not previously terminated, this Agreement and a.ll rights and obligations of the parties hereunder sbal.l automatically teriiina.te thirty-six. (36) calendar months after initial successful operation of the modified condenser cooling system or the modified liquid radwaste system, whichever is later, unJ.ess Cons'Limers Power is relieved of its obligation to instaJ.l or operate one or both of said sys-tems pursuant to Section 10 of this Agreement, in which event a.ll rights and obligations of the parties under this Agreement shall automaticaiJ..y terminate (i) thirty-Six (36) calendar months after initial successful operation of either the modified condenser cooling system or the modified liquid radwa.ste system, if Consumers Power is so relieved of it_s obliga-tion to install or operate the other system pursuant .to said Section 10; or (ii) twenty-four (24) calendar months after the date that Consumers Power is relieved of its obligation to install or operate the modified condenser cooling system or the modified liquid ra.dwaste system, which-ever date is la.ter, if Consumers Power is relieved of its obligations to install or operate both systems pursuant to said Section 10. . The foregoing provisions are subject to the specific condition that any breach of, or failure of performance pursuant to, this Agreement by any Intervenor or Consumers Power, and the res:Ponsibility or liability a.rising therefrom, which occurs prior to the termination of this Agreement as a.:foresaid, shall survive such termination. Consumers Power sha.ll notify Intervenors of the da.te of initial success:f'ul. operation of the modified condenser cooling system or the modified liquid radwaste system, or of
39 SECTION 17, §17~1 (Contd) the date that Consumers Power is relieved of its obligations to install.
. both of said systems, whichever is applicable under this §17 .1. C.onsumers Power. shall ma.k~ available to a representative of Intervenors such records as are necessary to support such notification.
SECT!ON 18 - ENTIRE AGREEMENT
§18.l This Agreement supersedes all prior representations, negotiations and understandings of the parties hereto, whether oral or written, and constitutes the entire Agreement of the parties with respect to the subject matter hereof. This Agreement. shall not be changed, supple-mented or superseded, except in writing, duly. executed on behalf of the parties hereto.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, th~ parties have executed this Agreement as of the day and year hereinabove first mentioned. CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY cm.TCEP.NED PETITIONING CITIZENS
~ / I,_
tf w.'
/1 . ./'"")
// .I ;;l ,/ )
By (,.'J*:*v {;k't.!(__J/ Senior ?/e Pre,dent ; MICHIGAN ST~ AND SAIMON MI LAKE AND STREAM FISHERMEN'S ASSOCIATION SOCIATIONS, INC
- THEEMAL ECOLOGY MUST BE SIERRA CLUB PEESERVED
~ .~~!~ By_/_'~-~---.r*----* J____
/47'*
)_,. t * "...._
CC>
.Agreement.dated in March, 1971 between APPENDIX I
*consumers Power Company and Michigan
- Steelhead and Salmon Fishermen's Association, et a.l *.
MODIFIED CONDENSER COOLING SYSTEM The modified condenser coolirig system_ will be designed in accord-ance With the principles set forth in Section l of this Agreement and_ will substantially conform to .the conceptual design described.in this. Appendix I. A sketch of the proposed modified condenser cooling system is shown in Exhibit A.hereto. To accommodate this closed circuit system, modifications will have to be made to the .plant. The existing cooling water intake structure will be modified so that .the present lake inlet will go only to the service wa.ter pump bay. Th~ existing service water pumps (not shown) will take suction from the cooling tower basin and from the lake, with the lake providing cooling tower makeup wa.ter. The existing circulating water pumps will be isolated from the lake inlet and instead will receive water from the cooling tower basin a.nd discharge to the condenser. New circu-lating water pumps will be installed to carry the. condenser discharge flow to the cooling tower inlet. The circulating water will pass through the*. tower into the basin below and then on to the modified intake structure where it will a.gain be pumped through the condenser using the existing circulating water pumps, or will flow through the condenser by gravity. Some water must be discharged from the cooling tower basin to the lake in order to control the concentration of salts or other impuri-ties which a.re contained in the lake makeup water. This discharge is termed* the tower "blowd.own." Dilution pumps will be installed to a.dd lake water to the blowd.own prior to discharge into the lake. The dilu-tion water flow will be such that the temperature of the mixed dilution water a.nd blowd.own wi.ll not exceed the ambient temperature of the
I-2.. receiving water at the shore.line by more than 5°F. The design heat rejec-tion to the Lake as a result of this discharge will be as low as practicable consistent with available equipment, Pa..lisades Plant and Consumers Power electrical system opera.ting requirements, design .optimization and other condenser cooling system design objectives, and will in no event exceed 500,000,000 BTU/hr. Design a.nd construction of the cooling tower or towers shall con-form to the latest applicable Cooling Tower ~titute (CTI) codes and standards applicable at the time of detailed design, except to the extent the same may be contrary to any applicable law or l"UJ.e, regulation or order.of any governmental body having jurisdiction.
I ..
** i.
EVAPORATIVE LOSS & DRIFT PUMPS COOLING TOWER PUMPS BLOW DOWN MAIN CONDENSER MA~E UP FROM LAKE DILUTION PALISADES PUllAPS . CLOSED CYCLE COOLING SYSTEM TO LAKE FROM EXHIBIT A LAKE
, *. Agreement dated in March, 1971 between Consumers Power Company and Michigan Steelhead and Salmon Fishermen's-Association~ et al. APPENDIX II MODIFIED LIQ.UID :AADWASTE SYSTEM The modified liquid radwaste system will be designed in accord-ance with_ the principles set forth iil Section 2. of this Agreement and will substantially conform to the conceptuai design described *in this Appen-dix II. The system will be designed to collect, store, process, monitor and dispose of all liquid radioactive wastes from the Palisades Pla.nt. The integrated system will be basically comprised of the following three subsystems :_ clean waste, dirty waste and laundry. The subsystems are shown on Exhibits A, B and C hereto, respectively. The cle~ waste system processes high-activity, high-purity (low solids) liquid wastes collected from four basic sources: the l~tdown from the primary coolant system, the pr_imarJ system. drain tank, the radioactive-_ chemical laboratory drain tank and the *equipment dra.in tank. The letdown from the primary coolant system is the largest source of both radioactivity a.nd liquid to the clean radwaste system.. The main sources of this liquid are thermal expansion of the primary coolant system and dilution of the primary coolant for boron concentration control. The primary system drain tank serves as a collection point in the containment bUilding for seven sources of liquid: chemical. and volume control syste.'ll heat exchanger drains, reactor shield cooling drains, safety injection tank drains, primary coolant pump seal. leakage, primary loop drains, quench tank drains, and reactor flange leaka.ge*dra.ins. The radioactive chemical-laboratory drain tank serves as a collec-tion point for the sample sink drains and the clean radioactive chemical.- laboratory drains.
II-2 The equipment drain tank serves as a collection point for the
*spent resin* shipPing cask drains, radioactive steam generator blowdown, spent f'uel pool heat exchanger drains, spent f'uel pool drain, spent resin storage tank drains, charging pumps relief line and drains, chemical a.nd volume control system ion exchangers and filter drains, volume control tank drains, and waste gas surge tank drain.
The liquids from the primary systein drain tank and the letdown pass through the vacuum degasifier where they a.re joined by the liquids from the radioactive chemical laboratory drain tank and the equipment drain tank. These liquids a.re then collected and held up for natural de-cay in the clean waste receiver tanks. A~er sufficient decay the liquids
- -* a.re P'.ll!Iped out of the clea.nwaste. receiver tanks, through the clean waste filter, the radwa.ste ion exchangers and the treated waste monitoring tanks to a.n evaporator. The evaporator will serve to further clean the demineral.;.
ized liquids and to separate out the boric acid. The distilJ.a,te from the evaporator will be stored in the primary coolant system makeup tank from which it will eventually be reused in the plant. The concentrate from the evaporator will be essentia.J.l.y pure boric acid and will be stored in the boric acid tank until f'urther use or sent to the solid waste drumming station for packaging and eventual off-site disposal. The dirty waste system collects low activity, high solids liquid from the engineered safeguards rooms, the volume c.ontrol ta.nk relief, access control aI'ea. sink, emergency shower, containment sump drains, vent stack drains, pump leak-off, decontamination pit drains, spent f'uel cask wa.shdown drains, contaminated lab drains, boric acid area. drains, component
--- ----,~- --------*--;-*-- --
II-3 cooling loop d.ra.ins, fioor drains, treated waste. monitor tan.it drains and the component cooling wa.ter surge tank. . The.se liquids are collected in the dirty waste drain tank from which they a.re passed through the dirty wa.ste filter to the filtered waste monitor tank. The filtered liquids will then be processed.through a.n evaporator to further clean. ~'P the liquids a.nd to separate out any boric a.cid or other solids. Like the clean waste distillate, the distillate from: the. dirty waste evaporator will be recycled for reuse in the plant. The concentrate will be reused a.s boric acid (if :pure enough) or sent to the solid waste drumming sta-tion for packaging and eventual off-site disposal. The laundry wastes consist of the used wash water from the* plant laundry facility. This liqµid ma.y have picked.up some solids from clothing and is therefore filtered to remove contaminates. The liquid will be processed through the dirty waste system unless it contains materials whic.h cannot be so processed without the possibility of im-pairing the function of dirty waste system equipment.
- PRIMARYCOOLANTt-------.....,f-------,-----------------------
PRI MARY COOLANT LETDOWN TO GAS SURGE I. I. TANK PRIMARY SYSTEM DRAIN TANK CLEAN WASTE RAO-CHEM STORAGE DRAIN 200,000 TANK GALLONS EQUIPMENT DRAIN TANK PALI SADES CLEAN WASTE SYSTEM TREATED EXHIBIT A WASTE MOllflTOR TANKS
- - - o F F SITE RESIN REMOVAL PRESENT SYSTEM lllllllllllllllllllllllllllll lllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll 1111111 II PROPOSED ADDITIONS RECYCLE MONITOR NORMALLY TO TANI< Cl OSE 0 GAS SURGE TO TANK ENVtRONt.AENT EVAP*
ORATOR PRIMARY COOLANT MAKEUP CHEMICAL TANK ANO VOLUME CONTROL SYSTEM BORIC ACID TANI<
..__ _ _ _ _ _ __.TO DR'-'MMING STATION FOR REMOVAL FROM SITE
\
- F'OTENilALLY.
CONTAMI NAiEO DRAINS DIRTY WASTE* DRAIN TANll:
*3aoo GALLONS PALI SADES DIRTY WASTE SYSTEM EXHIBIT 8 FILTERED ro W*STE CLEAN MONITOR WASTE TANK RECEIVER TANK PRESENT SYSTEM 1.lllllUJlllll 111 l l l l l l l l l l l l l l l l l l l l l l l l l l l l l l l l H l l l l l l l l l l l l l l l l l l l l llllll I II 11111111111111111111111111111111 11111111111111111 PROPOSED ADDlilONS NORMALLY RECYCLE CLOSE.O MONITOR 1-~--t--M~* TO TANK ENVIRON MEN EVAP*
ORATOR LOW REUSE TRITIATED JN ~AKE UP Pl.A Ni TANK BORIC CHEMICAL ACID ANO TANK VOLUME CONTROL SYSTEM iO DRUMM.I NG STATION FOR REMOVAL FROM SITE I l__ _
LAUN ORY WASTE LAUN ORY ORAIN TANK PALI SADES LAUNDRY WASTE SYSTEM EXHI SIT C FIL.TER 1---------ia TO DIRTY WASTE DRAIN TANK . TO !NVIRONM!NT
Agreement dated in Mar.ch, 1971 between APPENDIX IlI Consumers Power Company and Michigan Steelhead and Salmon Fishermen's Association, et al. GASEOUS RADWASTE SYSTEM SITE BOUNDARY DOSE (1% Failed Fuel) Assuming one percent (1%) failed fuel, 4,539 rt3 of gas dis-charged, ~fter a. thirty (30) day holdup time, and a X/G., of*l.33 X lo-5
- sec/m3, it is calculated that the whole-body radiation dose at the
.Palisades Plant site boundary from radioactive material released from the gaseous radwaste system presently installed in the Palisades Plant and as described in the Palisades Plant Final Safety Analysis Report*
to the AEC, as a.mended to December l, 1970, would be: Kr-85 0.06 mrem/yr Xe-133 1.62 mrem/yr Total 1.68 mrem/yr where ~D... = 0".2sEo-X* This formula is found on p. 339 of Meteorology & Atomic Energy (AEC 1968) . The value for E0 is ta.ken from pages 34 a.nd 72 of Table of Isotopes (AEC, Sixth Edition). The applicable 10 CFR Part 20 site boundary limit in effect as of December l, 1970 is 500 mrem/yr
- Agreement dated in March, 1971 between APPENDIX Dl Consumers Power Company and Michigan Steelhead and Salmon Fishermen's Association, et al.
.UNITED STATES OF AMERICA ATOV..IC ENERGY COMMISSION In the Matter.of
. CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY Docket No~ 50-255 (Palisades Plant) STIPULATION BY AND BEI'WEEN ALL INTERVENORS A.ND APPLICANT IN SUPPORT OF FUEL LOAiimG AND LOW-POWER TESTING.LICENSE Applicant and Intervenors, by their respective undersigned attorneys, and subject to the terms and provisions of an Agreement be-tween Applicant and*Intervenors ~ated the 12th day of March, 1971 (here-inafter called the "settlement agreement"), hereby stipulate and agree as follows:
- 1. That in accordance with the Notice of Hearing of May 18, 1970 in this proceeding, Applicant filed herein on July 21, 1970 a written motion for a license authorizing fuel loading and low-power testing of the Palisades Plant at power levels not to exceed one thermal
- megawatt (hereinafter called "the testing license"); that whereas Inter-venors have heretofore contested the granting of the testing license,
.Applicant and Intervenors entered into the settlement agreement and accordingly Intervenors no longer contest, but now support, prompt issu-ance to Applicant of the testing license; that, therefore, as regards fuel loading and low-power testing of the Palisade.s Plant at power levels not to exceed one thermal megawatt, there no longer is any "contested
2 activity to be authorized" within the meaning of the Notice of Hearing of Ma.y 18, 1970.
- 2. That, subject to paragraph 7 of this Stipula.tion, the Atomic*
Safety and Licensing Board (hereinafter called "the ASLB ") ms:y, but solely for purposes of the testing license, accept Applicant's evidence in this proceeding as*uncontroverted within the meaning of §VI(b) of Appendix A of the AEC's Rules of Practice and find that there is good.cause*for the issuance to Applicant of the testing license; and Applicant and Intervenors consent to the entry of the proposed findings of fa.ct, conclusions of law and.form of order contained in Exhibit A hereto, or to findings of fa.ct, conclusions of law and an order by the ASLB not inconsistent with said Exhibit A.
- 3. That the testing license should be issued pursuant to Appli-cant's request; and that the foitia.l. decision or order authorizing or directing the issuance of the testing license, a.nd the testing license as well, should become effective a.t the earliest time permitted by law and the rules a.nd regulations of the AEC.
- 4. That in support of the prompt issuance to Applicant of a testing lice~se in accordance with this Stipulation, Intervenors:
(i) will not engage in any further voir dire examination, cross-examination, or direct examination herein; (ii) will not make any further argument, objec.:. tions, offers of proof, motions or requests herein;
- (iii) will not submit or file or seek lea.ve*to submit or file any plea.ding, evidence, exhibit or other document herein; and
3 (iv) will not take a:n:y other action herein or initiate or participate in any actions (including but not limited to adminis-trative remedies or court actions) dehors this proceeding with respect to or in con-nection with the testing license, or the issuance of said license, unless requested by Applicant in order to support the issuance to Applicant of the testing lic_ense, or unless directed or requested by the ,A.SLB, or Wlless permitted by the settlement agreement or this Stipulation.
- 5. That Intervenors will not file any exceptions to any initial decision or order of the ASLB authorizing or directing the issuance of the testing license issued in accordance with this Stipulation.
- 6. That, subject to paragraph 7 of this Stipulation, Intervenors consent to the filing in this proceeding and service upon the parties and persons required to be served Wlder the rules of practice of the AEC, of written testimony, exhibits, pleadings and other documents* by Applicant and the AEC RegulatOI"'J Staff with respect to Applicant's application for
- a. license to operate the Palisades Plant at power levels in excess of one thermal mega.watt prior to the reconvening of this proceeding to consider the issuance to Applicant of such an opera.ting license.
- 7. That this Stipulation is entered into and submitted on con-dition that (unless Applicant and Intervenors shall otherwise stipulate),
in a:ny hearing or reconvening of this proceeding to consider the issuance to Applicant of a license to operate the Palisades Plant at any power
4
- levels in excess of one thermal megawatt, Intervenors reserve the right to contest all issues, substantive and procedural, with respect to Ap-plicant's request for a license to operate the Palisades Plant at such thermal power levels, including but not limited to any right to file mo-tions to _strike any filings made pursuant to par~graph 6 of this Stipula-tion, and any right of cross-examination, *direct examination, argument, introduction of evidence or motions and demands for documents; and in any such hearing or reconvening of this proceeding to.consider the issuance to Applicant of a license to operate the Palisades Plant at any power levels in. excess of one thermal megawatt, Intervenors shall not be bound by and.shall be free to challenge any findings of fact or conclusions of law proposed in Exhibit A hereto or ma.de by the ASLB in connection with or for the issuance of the testing_ license, and that solely for purposes of any such hearing or reconvening of this proceeding, Applicant shall not object to.Intervenors' treating, and Intervenors may treat, such pro-posed findings of fact and conclusions of law as if never proposed, ma.de or entered.
- 8. That Applicant and Intervenors will serve any notice, request or motion that this proceeding be reconvened to consider the issuance to Applicant of a license to operate the Palisades Plant at any thermal. power levels in excess of one megawatt at least five (5) days before the requested date of reconvening, unless they join in a notice, request or motion to reconvene this proceeding for such purpose upon the expiration of a shorter period of time.
- 9. Tha.t concurrently with the filing of this Stipulation, the
- parties will fiJ.e in this proceeding a true copy of the settlement agreement.
5
- 10. That Intervenors shall not under any circumstances oppose the issuance to Applicant of the testing license or challenge the validity of or seek to revoke or suspend the testing license after it has been issued by the Director of Regulation.
Judd L. Bacon, Esq. Attorney for Applicant Consumers Power Company Myron M. Cherry, Esq. Attorney for all Intervenors except Siel'l"a Club Lewis D. Drain, Esq. Attorney for Intervenor Sierra Club Dated: March 12, 1971
EXHIBIT A TO APPENDIX zy UNITED SllTES OF AMERICA ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION
/
I In the Matter of )
)
CONSUMERS .POWER *COMPANY ) Docket No. 50-255
)
(Palisades Plant) ). PROPOSED FINDINGS OF FACT, CONCLUSIONS OF IAW, AND FORN OF ORDER SUBMITTED JOINTLY BY APPLICANT AND INTERVENORS RESPECTING AUTHORIZATION OF A FUEL LOADING AND LOW-POWER TESTING.LICENSE
- 1. The findings and order of the Atomic Safety and Licensing
,. Board hereinafter set forth are concerned with a.nd limited to Applicant's request for the issuance of a provisional operating license authorizing fuel loading and low-power testing of the Palisades Plant at power levels not to exceed one megawatt.
- 2. On May 18, 1970* the Commission entered a Notice of Hearing on the application of Consumer.s Power Company for a. provisional operating license authorizing operation of the PaJ.isades Plant at steady-state power levels up to and including 2200 megawatts thermal. The Notice of Hearing contained the following provisions authorizing the Board to consider and act upon any request by Applicant for a provisional operating license for f'llel loading and low-power testing:
"While the matter of the f'llll power license is pending befo,re the atomic safety and licensing board, the boa.rd may:, upon motion in writing and upon good cause shown, consider and a.ct upon such request as the applicant ms.y make for a provisional opera.ting license authorizing f'llel loading and low power testing. Arry such action by the atomic safety and licensing boa.rd shall be ta.ken with due rega.rd to the rights of all parties to the proceeding, in-cluding the right o~ any party *to be heard to the
2 extent that his contentions a.re rel.eva.nt to the activity to be authorized. Prior to taking 8XJ.Y' such action, the atcmic safety and licensing board shall, with respect to any conteste4 actiVity to be authorized, make appropriate findings in the form of an initial. decision on the issues specified in this notice of hearing." 3* In accordance with the foregoing provision8 of the Notice of Hearing, Applicant fil.ed in this :proceeding on July 21, 1970 a. written motion requesting the Board to authorize the issuance to Applicant ot a. provisional operating license authorizing f'uel loading a.nd low-power testing at power levels not to exceed one mega.watt the~ (hereina:f'ter referred to as the 11 interim provisional operating license 11 ) . Pending the disposition of Applicant's motion, evidence was received in the proceeding relating to matters relevant to the issuance of the interim provisional. operating license.
- 4. Pursuant to a settlement agreement and stipulation between Applicant a.nd. a.11 Intervenors in this proceeding da.ted March 12, 1971, which agreement a.nd stipulation have been :t'iled with the Boa.rd, Intervenors no longer contest, but now support, prompt issuance to Applicant of the requested interim provisional operating license. Therefore, the f'uel loading and low-power testing to be authorized by- such license is no longer a "contested activity-" within the meaning of the above-quoted provisions of the Notice of Hearing.
- 5. Applicant bas submitted evidence with respect to each of' the numbered :t'indings hereinafter ma.de by- the Boa.rd in respect to the issuance of the interim provisional. operating license. Applicant's evidence includes, with respect to :t'indings numbered (l), (3) and (7),
3 those portions of the FSAR relevant to the activities to be conducted under the license [ApplicMt's Exhibits 51 through 58, received in evidence a.t Tr. i639], together with supplementary testimony describing the testing-program [Tr. 889-895; 992-994; 1853; Ap!llicant's Exhibits 59 through 62, received in evidence at Tr. 1855], the control of radio.- activity which might be generated during testing operations [Tr. 896-898; 994-1000]' the upper limi.ts of radiological effects associated with the most severe accidents which might occur during the testing period [Tr. 906-921; 1004-1022;
- 1031-1032], a.nd the power history
[Tr. 4642] and the fission product inventory [Tr. 4644-4645] during the testing period. With respect to finding numbered (2), the evidence includes the entire FSAR [Applicant's Exhibits 4 through li, *received in evidence at Tr. 1088], which describes both the design of the Palisades facility and the quality assurance a.nd testing program designed to assure conformance of the license application, as well as supporting testimony by Applicant's project engineer [Tr. 2110; 2J26-2J27; 2558; 26oo; 2634]. With respect to finding numbered (4), the evidence includes those portions of the Applicant's license application, including the FSAR, bes.ring on the technical and financial qualifications of the Applicant [Applicant's Exhibit 3, received in evidence at Tr. J2J.9; Applicant's Exhibit 50, received in evidence at Tr. 1842; Applicant's Exhibits 51, 55 a.nd 57; Applicant's Exhibit 63, received in evidence at Tr. 1796; and Applicant's Exhibit 64, received in evidence at Tr. 1800]. Additional evidence as to Applicant's financial qualifications
4 was supplled py Applicant's chief financial and a.cconnting officers . (Tr. 1386-1402;. 1791-18o2; 1812-1844]. With respect to finding numbered (5), th~ evidence includes the testimony of Applicant's Insurance Supervisor [Tr. 1271-1279j and Vice President for .Finance [Tr. 1845-1848] and related documentary evidence [Applicant's Exhibits 3, 45, 46~ 47, 48 and 66, received in evidence.at Tr. 1219, 1268, 1270, 1275, 1277 and 1848, respectively] showing that Appli-cant has met the financial protection requirements required by the Atomic Energy Act and AEC regulations. With respect to finding numbered (6), Applicant's witnesses testified that the Plant was ready for fuel loading ~nd low-power testing prior to the end of August, l.970 [Tr. 922-~3; 1893-1894; 1910; 1927; 2539; 2555*; 2870-2871].
- 6. Intervenors and Applicant have stipulated that the Board may, but solely for purposes of the interim provisional opera.ting license, accept Applicant's evidence as uncontroverted within the mea.~ing of §Vr(b) of Appendix A of the Commission's Rules of Practice and find that there is good cause for the issuance to Applicant of the interim provisional opera.ting license, and the Boa.rd so finds. The Board further finds that Intervenors' and Applicant's stipulation is subject to the condition that (unless Applicant a.nd Intervenors shall otherwise stipulate), in any hearing or reconvening of this proceeding to consider the issuance to Appli-cant of a. license to operate the Palisades Plant at any power levels in ex-cess of one thermal megawatt, Intervenors reserve the right to contest all issues, substantive and procedural, with respect to Applicant's request for a license to operate the Palisades Plant at such therma.J. power levels,
. 5 including but not limited to any right to file motions to strike evidence
- hereaf'ter filed in support of such request and any right of cross-.
examination, direct examination, argument, introduction of evidence or motions arid demands for documents; and in any such hearing or recon-vening of this proceeding to consider the issuance toApplica.nt .of a li-cense to operate the Palisades Pla.nt at any power levels in excess of one thermal mega.watt, Intervenors sha.ll not be bound by and shall be free to challenge any findings of fa.ct or conclusions. of law made herein in connec-tion with or for the issuance of the testing license, and that solely for purposes of a.ny such hearing or reconvening of this proceeding, Applicant shall not object to Intervenor.s' treating, and Intervenors may treat, such findings of fact and conclu.sions of l.a.w as if.~everproposed, made* or entered.
- 7. Based on the foregoing and the record of this proceeding, this Board concludes, with respect to the issuance of the interiµl. pro-visiona1 opera.ting license, tha.t there is good ca.use for the issua.Iice of said license to Applicant, and tha.t:
(1) Applicant ha.s submitted to the Commission all technical information required by Provisional Construction Permit No. CPPR-25, the Act, and the rules and regulations of the Commission to complete the application for the interim provisional operating license;
* (2) Construction of the facility has proceeded, and there is reasonable assurance that it wi:LJ. be completed, in conformity with Provisional Construction Permit No.
CPPR-25, the application, as amended, the provisions of the Act and the rules a.nd regula.tions of the Commission; I I
.1
. I 6
- (3)* There is reasonable assurance that (i) the activities authorized by the interim provisional operating license can be conducted without endangering the health and safety of.the public, and (ii) that such activities will be conducted in compliance with the rules and .
regulations of the Commission; (4) Applicant is technically and financially qualified to engage in the activities-authorized by the interim provisional operating license in accordance with the rules and regulations of the Commission; ( 5) Applicant has satisfied the applicable provisions of 10 CFR Part i4o, 'Financial Protection Req1:llrements and Indemnity Agreement~,' of the Commission's regulations; (6) There is reasonable assurance that the facility
*will be ready for initial loading with nuclear fuel within 90 days from the issuance of the interim provisional operating license; and *
(7) Issuance of the interim provisional operating license under the terms and conditions proposed will not be inimical to the common defense and security or to the health and safety of the public. The Board further finds a.nd concludes that there shall be-reserved to Intervenors the rights, as hereinabove stated in paragraph 6, that Applicant and Intervenors have stipulated should be reserved to Intervenors.
- 8. WHEREFORE, pursuant to the Act and the Commission's Regula-tions, IT IS ORDERED, that the Director of Regulation is authorized to issue to Consumers Power Company a provisional operating license au-thorizing fuel loading and low-power testing at a power level not to exceed one megawatt thermal, upon the following conditions:
(1) Such license shall be substantially in the form of the proposed provisional operating license filed herein by the AEC staff and distributed to the parties and con-sistent with this decision
- 7
- (2) Such license shall be issued upon verification by the Commission's Division of Compliance and a determination by the Director of Reactor Licensing that the Palisades Plant has been completed in conf'ormity with Provisional Construction Permit No. CPPR-25, the application, .the provisions of the Atomic Energy Act of 1954, as amended, and the Rules and Regulations of the Commission, and is ready for r"uel loading, and upon receipt by the Director of Reactor Licensing of proof that Applicant has provided financial protection. in the a.mount required by the Commission's Regulations.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED, in accordance with Section 2.764.of the Commission's Regulations, as amended effective January 19, 1971, that this Order shall become effective.immediate.ii upon its issuance subject to (i) the review thereof and further decision by the Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Board upon exceptions filed by any party and (ii) such order as the Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Board may enter upon such exceptions or upon its own motion within 45 days after the issuance of this Order
- Agreement dated in March, 1971 between APPENDIX V Consumers Power Company and Mj_chigan Steeipead and Salmon Fishermen's.
Association, et al.
.UNITED STATES OF AMERICA ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION In the Matter of .)
)
COHSUMERS POWER COMPANY ) Docket No. 50-255
)
(Palisades Plant) ) STIPUIATION BY AND BEI'WEEN ALL INTERVENORS AND
. APPLICANT IN SUPPORT OF FULL-POWER LICENSE Applicant* and* Intervenqrs., by* their respective undersigned attorneys, and subject to the terms and provisions of an Agreement be-tween Applicant and Intervenors dated the 12th day of March, 1971 (herei-nafter cal.led the "settlement agreement"), her.=_by stipulate and agree as follows:
- 1. That this Stipulation sha11 be subject to withdrawal by the Applicant or the Intervenors in the event the Regulatory Staff of the AEC fails, prior to the reconvening of this proceeding to consider the issuance to Applicant of the full-power license or a:ny operating license other than the testing license, to file in this proceeding a form of full-power license, proposed to be issued to Applicant, containing the special technical. specifications as part of the Technical. Specifications for the Palisades Plant. As used in this Stipulation: the "full-power license" means a license to operate the Palisades Plant at steady-state power levels up to ~d including 2200 thermal megawatts; the "testing license" means a license authorizing fuel loading and low-power testing
2
.of the Palisades Plant at power levels not to exceed one.thermal mega-watt; *and the "special technical specifications" means the technical specifications in the form set forth in Exhibit A hereto.
- 2. That Inte:!."'<renors have heretofore contested the issuance to Applicant of the ~<lll-9ow~r license; that in order to resolve their differences Applican.t and Intervenors have entered into the. settlement agreement, a true corrJ of which has heretofore been filed in this pro~
ceeding; and that in accord.a.nee with the settlement agreement and this Stipulation, Intervenors no longer oppose and now sup~ort the prompt issuance to Applicant of the full-power license containing the special technical specifications.
- 3. That Applicant requests that the special technicai specifi-cations be included in the full-power license as part of' the Technical Specifications for the Palisades Plant.
- 4. That in support of the prompt issuance to Applicant of the full-power license containing the special technical specifications, Intervenors:
(i) will not engage in any further voir dire examination, cross-examination, or direct examination herein; (ii) will not make any further argument, objec-tions, offers of proof, motions or requests herein;
3 (iii) will not submit or file: or seek leave to submit or file any pleading, evidence, ex-hibit or other document herein; and (iv) will not take.any other action herein or initiate or participate in any actions (including but not limited to ad.minis~
*. trative remedies or court actions) dehors
.this proceeding with respect to or in connection with the testing license, or the f'ull-power license containing the special technical specifications, or the issuance of said licenses, unless requested by Applicant in order to support the issuance to Appli-cant of the :f'ul.1-power license containing the special technical specifica-tions, or unless directed or requested by the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board (hereinafter.qa.lled the "ASLB"), or* unless permitted by the settle-ment agreement or this Stipulation.
- 5. Tha.t in support of the prompt issuance to Applicant of the f'ull-power license containing the special technical specifications,
- Intervenors:
(i) withdraw all requests, demands and motions heretofore made by them in this proceeding; (ii) agree that the ASLB may accept the evidence of the Applicant a.nd of the AEC Reguhtory
4 Staff and the conclusions of the Advisory Committee on Reactor Safeguards in this pro-
. ceeding as uncontroverted within the meaning of §VI(b) of Appendix A of the AEC' s RuJ.es of Practice; and
* (iii} consent to the entry of findings of fact and conclusions of law not inconsistent with the settlement agreement and this Stipula-tion, including but not limited to findings of fact and co~clusions of law in favor of Applicant on all issues specified in the Notice of Hearing of !vfa.y 18, 1970 in this proceeding on Applicant'*s application for a proVisional Operating license for the Palisades Plant as amended to include the modifications contemplated by the special technical specifications.
- 6. That Applicant shall file in this proceeding proposed findings of fact and conclusions of law and form of an initial decision not inconsistent with the terms and provisions of the settlement agree-ment and this Stipulation; a.nd that the same shall contain, inter alia, findings of fact and conclusions of law to the effect that:
( i) Applicant ha.s resolved to the satisfaction of the ASLB all evidentia.ry issues re-garding nuclear safety, radiological protec-
\
tion, quality control, safe operation of the Palisades Plant, a.nd all other factors material
to Applicant's application for the full-power license as amended to include the modifica-tions contemplated by the special technical specifications; (ii) Intervenors shall be deemed to have withdrawn from this proceeding when the full-power license containing the special technical. specifications has been issued to Applicant and the initial or final decison in this pro-ceeding has become the final action of the AEC without amendment of such license so as to remove or change the special technical
- specifications; and (iii) that the Intervenors will not lose or waive any rights reserved in the Stipulation heretofore filed herein by A:ppiicant and Intervenors in support of the issuance of the testing license unless and until Intervenors are deemed to have withdrawn from this proceeding as provided in
§6.7 of the settlement agreement and paragraph 8 of this Stipulation.
- 7. That the ASLB should authorize and order the issuance to Applicant of the full-power license conta.ining the special technical specifications in accord.a.nee with the findings of fa.ct and conclusions of law contemplated by paragraph 6 of this Stipulation; and that the
6 ASLB's initial decision directing the issuance of said full-power license, and. said . full power license as well, should became effective.at the earliest time permitte4 by law and the rules and regulations of the AEC.
- 8. That.when (i) the full-power license has been issued to Applicant containing the special technical specifications and (ii) the initial or .final decision in this proceeding has become the final action of the AEC without amendment of the Ml-power license so as to remove or change the special technical specifications, tpen Intervenors shall be-deemed:, without further action on their part,* to have withdrawn f'rom this proceeding with prejudice and without right thereaf'ter (except as other-wise provided.in the aforesaid settlement ~eement) to take an¥ further action in this proceeding or otherwise-in this Docket No. 50-255; or to take any action in any AEC proceeding to extend, renew or convert the full-power license*f'rom a provisional to a. finB.l. opera.ting license or to a.mend the full-power license to authorize operation of the Palisades Plant at any power level higher than that authorized in the full-power license; or to appeal or to stay the effectiveness of any or all decisions, findings, orders or rulings theretofore or thereaf'ter made or entered in this pro-ceeding or otherwise in this Docket No. 50~255 or in any AEC proceeding to so extend, renew, convert or a.mend the full-power license; or to initiate or participate in any actions (including but not limited to ad-ministrative remeQ,ies or court actions) dehors this proceeding with re-spect to or in connection with the testing license or the :f'ull.-power license or the issuance of said licenses. That, upon such issuance of
7 the full-power license containing the special technical specifications and the initial or final decision having become the final action of the AEC, as aforesaid in (i) and (ii) of this paragraph 8, Intervenors shall also thereby be deemed to have.waived and forever relinquished any and all rights to take any legal action with respect to any alleged noncom-pliance of *the Palisades Plant, this proceeding or any decision in this proceeding, or the testing license or the full-power license, with the National Environmental Policy Act, the Federal Water Pollution .control Act as amended, the Atomic Energy Act of 1954 as a.mended, the Federal Rivers and Harbors Act of March 3, 1899 as a.mended, the Federal Clean Air Act as amended, or with any other federal, state or local statutes or ordinances and any ru1es, orders and regulations of the AEC or any other public official or agency under any of said Acts, statutes or ordinances.
- 9. That if the aforesaid settlement agreement between Applicant and Intervenors sha.ll be terminated prior to the issuance of the full-power license containing the special technical specifications, this Stipulation sha.11 be withdrawn from this proceeding and sha.11 thereafter be of no further force or effect.
- 10. That when the Intervenors are deemed to ha.ve withdrawn from this pr~ceeding, as provided in §6.7 in the settlement agreement and paragraph 8 of this Stipulation, then Intervenors no longer sha.11 claim, assert or have the rights reserved by them pursuant to the
8 Stiptlla.tion heretofore filed herein by Applicant and Intervenors in sup-port of the issuance of the testing license and this*Stiptlla.tion. Judd L. Bacon, Esq. Attorney for.Applicant Consumers Power Company Myron M. Cherry, Esq *. Attorney for all Intervenors except Sierra Club Lewis D. Drain, Esq. Attorney for Intervenor Sierra Club Dated: March 12, 1971 /
EXHIBIT A TO APP.ENDIX V SPECIAL TECHNICAL SPECIFICATIONS PURSUANT TO AGREEMENT The licensee (in.these special technical.specifications some-times ca.lied "Consumers Power") has entered into a settlement agreement da-ced in Ma.rch,*1971~ with the parties who intervened in AEC Docket No. 50-255 prior to December 1, 1970.to contest the issuanc~ of an oper-ating license .(in these special technical specifications sometimes called "Intervenors"), pursuant to which agreement the licensee is to modify the condenser cooling system and the liquid radwaste system now installed in the Palisades Plant. The AEC is not a. *signatory to that agreement or to the stipulations entered into a.nd filed in sa.id Docket pursuant to that agreement, and is not bound in a.n:y way by the provisions of such documents. Pursuant to sa.id settlement agreement, the licensee has re-quested the inclusion of the following special technical specifications respecting the modified condenser cooling system, the :modified liquid ra.dwa.ste system, operation pending insta.lla.tion of modif'ied systems, and the licensee's reporting requirements. Consequently; the following special technical specifications shall, like other Palisades Plant technical specifi-ca.tiona, be subject to enforcement by the AEC; provided, however, that the inclusion of the following special technical specifications and their en-forcement by the AEC shall be without prejudice to any position which the AEC may ta.ke, in any forum or proceeding or otherwise, as to its jurisdic-tion with respect to the nonradiological effects of production and utiliza-
- tion facilities or of source, byproduct and special nuclear ma.teria.ls.
The following special technical specifications a.re additional requirements to a.ny other requirements of the Pa.lisa.des Pl.ant Technica.1
A-2 Specifications". No such other requirements of the Technical. Specifications shall be effective to permit the licensee to fail to comply with any require-ment of the following special. technical specifications. However, the li-censee shall not be required to comply with the following si>ecia.l technical. specifications during .the time and to the extent that the licensee is re-lieved of obligation to comply therewith in accord.a.nee with* their terms. As used in these special. technical. specifications the term ."Palisades Plant" means and refers to a. single-unit nuclear electric generating plant and shal.l not be deemed to include a;ny additional elec-tric genera.ting units that may herea.i'ter be installed at the Palisades
- Plant site. i I
SECTION S-1 CONDENSER COOLING SYSTEM MODIFICATION
§S-l.l Consumers Power shall modify the condenser cooling sys-tem now inst.alled in the Palisades Plant in the manner provided in these special. technica.l specifications. The condenser cooling system a.s so modified (and in these special technical specifications called the "modi-fied condenser cooling system") shall be so designed, constructed, operated and maintained as to form a closed cycle in which the condenser cooling wa.ter is continually recycled except for coo.ling system makeup wa.ter from and. blowd.own to Lake Michigan. The modified condenser coolin:g system shall include one or more wet-type cooling towers which ma.y be of either the natural or the mechanical drai't type, at Consumers Power's sole op-tion, provided, that Consumers Power's obligation shall be to install either the na.tura.l or the mechanical dra.i't type un1ess it is relieved from installing both types a.i'ter exhausting all rights of hearing, ap-pea.l and requests for writs of certiorari to the highest state or
A-3 federa.1. court having jurisdiction, as provided in.Section S-4 of these special. technical specifications. Design and construction of the cooling tower or towers shall conform to the latest applicable Cooling Tower Institute (CTI) codes and standards* applicable atthe time of.det~led
- design, except to the extent the same may be contrary to a:ny a.:pplicable law or rul.e, regu.la.tion or order of a:ny governmental body having juris-diction. The blowd.own shall be diluted with Lake water prior to discharge into the Lake so tha.t the temperature of*the mixed dilution water and blow-down will not* exceed the ambient temperature of the receiving water at the shore.line by more tha.n 5°F. The design hea.t rejection to La.k.e Michigan a.s a. result of this discharge shall be as low as practicable consistent with a.vaila.bJ.e equipment, opera.~ing requirements of the Pa.lisa.de*s Plant and Consumers Power's electrical system, design optimization, and other condenser cooling system design objectives, a:nd will in no event exceed 500,000,000 BTU/hr.
§S-1.2 The modified condenser cooling system sha.11 be insta.lJ.ed within .forty-two ( 42) ca.lendar months .following the da.te o.f the a..foresaid settlement agreement if Consumers Power installs a. na.tura.l draft cooling tower or towers as part of the modified condenser cooling system, or with-in thirty-two (32) *calendar months following the date of the a.foresa.id settlement agreement if Consumers Power installs a mechanical draft cooling tower or towers as pa.rt of the modified condenser cooling system.
If, a.:f'ter Consumers Power has begun to arrange .for the design, engineering, procurement of equipment a.nd ma.teria.ls, and construction for a. modified condenser cooling system utilizing either the mechanical draft or the
~
A-4 natural draft tYJ;>e of cooling tower or towers, Consumers Power is relieved from installing or continuing to install the type of cooling tower or towers it first selects, a.nd it is necessary to change to the alternative type of cooling tower or towers, the time for installation of a modified condenser cooling system utilizing the alternative type of cooling tower or :towers sha.ll. commence from the.a.B.te on which Consumers Power is relieved from in-stalling or continuing to install the type of cooling tower or towers. first
. selected. The modified condenser cooUng syst~ shall be placed in opera-tion not later than the resum:ption of operation of the Palisades Plant a.!'ter its first schedu1ed refueling following installation of sa.id system, pro-vided_, that to the extent it can do so consistently with electrical sys-tem load requirements, Pa.lisa.des Flint opera.ting requirements a.nd applicable license and other legal limitations, ConsUm.ers*Power shall use its best efforts to schedule the first refueling following installation of the modi-fied condense.r cooling system so a.s to minimize the time between the comple-tion of such installa.tion and the initial operation of the modified-con-denser cooling system. The foregoing provisions of this §S-l.2 are subject to the condition that in the event the installa.tion or the initial operation of such modified condenser cooling System is delayed (i} by reason of flood, strike, insurrection, riot, embargo, a.ct of nature or the public enemy; or tma.voida.ble delB.y in transportation or inability or una.voida.ble dela.y in procuring la.bar or materials; (ii) by reason of legal action by a.ny party other than Consumers Power or Intervenors; local, state or fedei-a.l.
la.ws; or the rules, regulations, orders, actions or failure to act of any
- . public body or official purporting to exercise authority or control. with
A-5 respect to insta.J.la.tion or operation of the mOdified condenser cooling system; or (iii) by reason of any ca.use beyond the reasonable control of ConsiJmers Power, th~ time for performance shall be extended (subject to the provisions of Section s-4 of these special technical specifications a.s respects [ii] above) for a time equal to the period-of such delay.
§S-1.3 Pending installation and operation of the*modified con-denser cooling system provided for in this Section S-1, Consumers Power may operate the Palisades Plant -at any power levels authorized by any AEC opera.ting license issued to Consumers* Power, utilizing the existing ~nee-through cooling system and releasing heated condenser cooling water to Lake Michigan *
. SECTION S LIQUID RADWASTE SYSTEM MODIFICATION
§S-2.1. Consumers *Power shall modify the liquid ra.d'W'a.ste system now insta.J.J..ed in the Palisades Plant in the manner provided in these special technical specifications. The liquid ra.dwaste system as so modi-fied (and in these special technical specifications called the "modified liquid ra.dwaste system") shall be so designed, constructed, operated a.nd
- ma.inta.ined tha.t at a.1.1. times under.normal opera.ting conditions, radio-active ma.teria.ls in liquid discharges from the Palisades Plant to La.ke Michigan a.re reduced to essentia.J.J.y zero; provided, however, tha.t radio-active materials in laundry waste system discharges which cannot be treated in the dirty waste system of the modified liquid ra.dwaste system without the possibility of impairing _the £'unction of dirty waste system equipment may be released. to Lake Michigan at levels which shall in no event exceed 25 picocuries per liter (2.5 X lo-8 microcuries/cc) on an
A-6 11 annual average basis; and.provided further, that essentia..lly zero," as us~d herein, shall. not be construed to preclude liquid discharges to Lake . Michigan containing radioactive materials at levels, a.s sampled at the re* cycle monitor ta.nk before dilution,' equivalent to or below then-current Lake Michigan background radioactivity levels, a.s ?llOnitored offshore from the Palisades Plant prior to such ii.quid discharges. As used in these S])ecial technical. spec~fications "normal. opera.ting conditions" sha1l refer
.to operation of the Palisades Plant during or in connection with which there exist no abnormal. events or circumstances such as (but not liniited to) steam generator tube leakages, fire, or pipe breakage; and "abnormal i.
opera.ting conditions" sha.11 refer to operation of the P.a1isa.des Pia,nt during or in connection with which there e:xist any such abnormal events or circumstances. Ail radioactive materials removed from liquid wastes by the modified liqilid ra.dwaste system will be accumu.la.ted and prepared for shipment i~ accordance with applicable rules, regulations a.nd orders of governmental authorities having jurisdiction and turned ~ver to a carrier or carriers licensed by governmental authorities having jurisdic-tion for shipment to an authorized disposal area or areas. Consumers Power intends to be alert to, and to utilize.to the extent it is pra.ctica.J. to do.so, means of minimizing the a.mount of laundry waste that cannot be treated in the dirty waste system.
§S-2.2 It is recognized that under abno:ma.J. operating condi-tions it may be impossible or impractical to achieve essentially zero re-lease of radioactive ma.teria..ls in liquid discbarges from the Palisades Plant through operation of the modified liquid ra.dwa.ste system. Consumers
A-7 Power shalJ. so operate the modified liquid radwaste system as to ensure tha.t radioactive ma.teria.ls in liquid discharges to Lake Michigan resul.ting from abnormal. opera.ting conditions do riot exceed,. on a quarterly average basis and on a.n individual. isotopic a.na.lysis basis, ten percent (10%) of. applicable 10 CFR Pa.rt 20 limits in effect a.s of December 1, 1970, and: are reduced to essentia.ll.y zero no la.ter than sixty (6o) consecutive da.ys a.I"'ter the c*ommencement of such releases resul.ting from abnormal opera.ting c onditi ans
- Not~ thst~ding the foregoing, however, delay b~yond sa.id sixty ( 6o) da.y period in the reduction of ra.dioa.ctive ma.teria.l.s in such liquid discharges to essentia.l.ly zero sha.11 be excused (subject to the provisions of Section S-4 of these special technical. specifications a.s respects [ii] bel.ow) to the extent it is (i) due to inabil.ity to identi:f'y, locate or re:pa.ir the abnormal opera.ting condition; or due to flood; strike; insurrection; riot; embargo; a.ct of nature or the public enemy; or by reason of una.voiaable delay in transportation or ina.bil.ity or una.voida.ble
\
delay in :procuring labor or materials; (ii) due to legal action by a party other than Consumers Power or_Intervenors; loca.J., state or federal laws; or the rules, regulations, orders, actions or fa.il.ure to a.ct of any public body or*officia.l purporting to exercise*a.uthority or control with respect to such liquid discharges; or (iii) due to a.ny ca.use beyond the reasonable . control of Consumers Power; provided, however, that ra.dioa.citive ma.teria.ls in liquid discharges to Lake Michigan from the modified liquid ra.dwaste system during *any such excused delay beyond sa.id sixty ( 6o) day period shall not exceed, on a. quarterly average basis a.nd on an individual iso-topic a.na.J.ysis basis, one percent (1$) of a.pplica.ble 10 CFR Pa.rt 20 limits
. A-8 in effect as of December 1, 1970; a.nd :provided further, however, tha.t Consumers Power shall undertake :promptly to correct abnormaJ. opera.ting conditions which* result in releases of radioactive materials in liquid discharges to Lake Michigan from the modified liquid ra.dwa.ste system a.t
.levels greater tha.n essentially zero.
§S-2. 3 The modified liquid .ra.d"Waste system shall be installed and :placed in operation*no later than the resumption of operation of the Palisades Pls.nt after its first scheduled refueling (which is expected to occur a.P];)rox:i.ma.tely seventeen [17] calendar months following the da.te of commencement of esca.J.a:tion to full power following issuance of the provi-sional operating license authorizing Consumers Power to operate the Palisades.Plant at steady-state :power levels tip to a.nd including 2200 thermal mega:watts) or twenty-four ( 24) calendar months following the date of the aforesaid settlement agreement, whichever occurs first. The foregoing provisions of this §s-2.3 a.re subject to the condition that in the event the installation or the initial operation of such modified liquid ra.dwaste system is delayed (i) by reason of nood; strike; insurrec-tion; riot; embargo; a.ct of' nature or the public enemy; or unavoidable delay in transportation or inability or unavoidable delay in procuring labor or ma.teria.ls; (ii) by reason of legal action by a. party other than Consumers Power or Intervenors; local, state or federal laws; or the ruJ.es, regulations, orders, actions or failure to act of any public body or offi-cial purporting to exercise authority or control with respect to installa-tion or operation of the modified liquid radwa.ste system; or. (iii) by reason of any ca.use beyond the reasonable control of Consumers Power, the
A-9 time for performance shall be extended (subject to the provisions of Sec-tion S-4 of these special technical specifications as respects [ii] above) for a *time equal 'to the period of such delay.
§S-2. 4 Pending installa.ti on a.nd operati on of the modif'ied liquid radWa.ste
- sysi;em pursuant . to the schedule prOvided in §S-2. 3 hereof, Consumers Power may opera.t.e the Palisades Plant .at a.rr:r power levels authorized by a.ny AEC license issued to Consumers Power, utilizing the existing liquid rad-*
waste system; provided that radioactive materials in liquid discharges to
.La.ke Michigan shall be at levels which are a.t all times as low as practicable and which do not exceed, on a quarterly average basis a.nd on an individual . isotopic a.na.lysis basis, and based on the ass-umptions used *in Section ll of Cons'll!l1ers Power' s Fina.1 Safety Analysi.s Rep9rt to the AEC for the Palisades
/ Plant as a.mended to December 1, i970, (i) under normal or abnormal. opera.- ting conditions as defined in §S-2~1 hereof and assuming no failed fuel, two percent (23) of applicable 10 CFR Pa.rt 20 limits in effect as of December 1, 1970; a.nd (ii) under no:rma.l or abnormal opera.ting conditions a.s defined in §S-2.1 hereof and assuming some failed fuel, ten percent (lo%) of applicable 10 CFR Pa.rt 20 limits in effect a.s of December l, 1970.
§S-2.5 In lin~ 8 of subsection 3.9.13 of Section 3.9, "EFFLUENT RELEASE" of the Technical Specifications, add the following af'ter "10 CFR 20":
"for gaseous releases, and within the liinits for liquid releases specified in the special technical specifications included herein at the request of the licensee pursuant to a settlement agreement dated in March, 1971."
A-10
- . SECTION S-~ - RESERVATIONS
§s-3.1 Nothing in these special technical specifications shall prevent ConsUm.ers Power from taking any steps or measures in connection wi~h the design, construction, modification or operation of the modified condenser cooli~g system and the modified. liquid ra.dwa.ste system which contemplate . . modifications,
. . procedures or. modes
. of operation equal*
. to or better, considering the protection of the environment, than.the modifies.-
tions, procedures or modes of operation contemplated in these
- special r
technical specifications; provided, however, that the foregoing provi-sions shall not authorize Consumers Power to take a:ny steps or measures to install a.nd operate* a. modified condenser cooling system having a.n open cycle system utilizing Lake Michigan water for once-through cooling or to install and opera.te a modified liquid ra.dwa.ste system which wouid release ra.dioa.ctivity to the environment a.t levels above those contemplated in Section s-2 of these special technical specifi.ca.tions under the condi-tions therein stated.
§S-3.2 The modifications, procedures a.nd modes of operation contemplated in these special technical specifications for the Palisades Plant and any action taken by Consumers Power pursuant to said special technical specifications or the aforesaid settlement agreement of March, 1971 before or after the execution of said agreement shall not be deemed, construed, interpreted or claimed to be a.n admission tha.t the same or a:ny similar modifications, procedures or modes of operation are necessari or -
required at SZJ.Y other Consumers Power electric genera.ting plant. The obli-ga.tions of Consumers Power under these special technical specifications a.nd said agreement are limited to the Palisades Plant.
A-ll SEcTimr s LEGAL VALIDITY
§S-4.1 *If Consumers Power believes that complianc~ with a.rr:r
- provision or provisions of these special technical specifications is con-trary to or :prevented by a.ny loca.J., sta.te or federal law, .or the rule, regulation, order, action or failure to a.ct of any public body or.official
- purporting to exercise authority with respect.thereto, or the order or decree of any court, then Consumers Power shall promptly notify Inter-venors thereof by telegram, telephone or other means and notify Inter-venors thereof in writing within ten (10) business-da.ys thereafter, stating the basis for such belief. In the event Intervenors notify Consumers PoW'er of their agreement with such belief within thirty (30) ca..;i.enda.r da.ys after delivery of the aforesaid written notice by*Consuiners Power (and from.the time of the aforesaid telephonic, telegraphic or other means of notice by Consumers Power and until the end of such thirty (30) day period whether or not such notification is given to Consumers Power by Intervenors) Coµsumers Power shall be relieved of any obligation to comply with_ the provision or :provisions in question and any a.nd all other :provisions of these special technical specif'i.cations Which require compliance with sa.id provision.or provisions. However, notwithstanding its release from obligation as :provided in this §S-4.l, Consumers Power shall have the right, in its sole discretion, to comply with or seek to comply with said :provision or :provisions. In the event Iritervenors do not so notify Consumers Power within said thirty ( 30) day period, then Consumers Power sha.11 in good faith and with due diligence pursue ad-ministrative remedies or court actions (including appea.la or requests for writs of certiorari to the highest state or federal court having
. A-l2 jurisdiction), or both, to assert the validity of compliance with said provision or provisions and/or the invalidity or.unlawfulness o:f the la.w, rule, regulation, order, decree, action or failure to act that is the subject of'the aforesaid written notice by Consumers Power.
* * *. §S-4.2 In* the event of an unfavorable ruling or the inability to have the validity of the compliance with such provision or provisions (which a.re the subject of suit and/or proceeding as contemplated in §S-4.1 hereof) upheld a~er exhausting all rights of hearing, appeal and requests for writs of certiorari to the highest state or federal court having' juris-diction, then Consumers Power will forever be relieved of any obligation to comply with the provision or provisions in question and any and a.1l other provisions of these specia~ technical specifications which require compliance with said provision or provisions.
§S-4.3 While Consumers Power is pursuing the administrative remedies or court actions, or both, contempla.ted in §S-4.1 hereof, Consumers Power ma.y operate the Palisades.Plant in arry manner permitted by la.w; provided, however, that while Consumers Power is pursuing said administrative remedies or court actions, or both, it shall continue to comply with a.1l of the provisions of these special technical specifica-tions except any provision or provisions (and any a.nd all other provi-sions which requi.re compliance with said provision or provisions) as to which (i) it is prevented from complying by a court order or decree or is prevented from complying by an ord.er, notice or other act ion of any public body or official having authority to enforce such order, notice or other action without re~ort to a court for* enforcement; or (ii) it is
A-13 prevented from complying by the lack of any permit, license, consent or other a.uthoriza.tion of a.riy public body or official which is required for continued compliance; or (iii) continued compliance would, in the reasonable opinion of lega.l counsel for Consumers Power, result in the violation of any criminal law or criminal ordinance or the imposition of any criminal or civil fine, criminal or civil penalty, or criminal or civil*forfeiture; or (iv) there ha.s been entered a court order or decree or an order, notice or other a.ction of a public body or official which, while not preventing compliance with these special technical specifications by Consumers Power, would require shutdown of the Palisades Pla.nt or a reduction in the electri.- cal output of the Palisades Plant if' Consumers Power continued to comply there"!.dth. SECTION *S REPORTING REQUIREMENTS
§S-5.l Add the following new item e. to subsection 6.6.l of Section 6.6, "PLANT REPORTING REQUIREMENTS" of the Technical Specifications:
"e. When a control rod or a. pa.rt-length rod is misaligned as defined in 3.10.4.a. of these Technical Specifications or when
- a. control rod is inoperable as defined in 3.10.4.b of these Technical Specifica-tions."
To *. PAPerry, Michigan Ave FROM JLBacon, Michigan*Ave DATE: April 9~ 1971 sus.ie:cT ATOMIC ENERGY
- PALISADES PLA.J.'lT
-. Operati'ng License: Settlement Agreement INTE:RNA~ CoRRE:SPONDE:Nce:
cc Attached for filing with the Company's executed copy of the Palisades settlement agreement is an executed duplicate original* of a certificate of resolutions:passed by the Sierra Club Board of. Directors authorizing the exe-cution of the settlement agreement and ratifying execution thereof by*Lewis D. Drain, together with a letter to me from Mr. Drain dated March 31, 1971, trans-mitting the certification.
\ . _,,..,
/, ( '->
I , {~-- _)
MIKA, MEYERS, BECKETT & .JON ES ATTORNEYS AT I.AW SUl*TE' 311 WATERS SUll_DING C::RNE:ST A. MIKA GRAND RAPIDS, MICHIGAN 4950.2 VE.RYL. N.ME:YE:RS
.JAMES a.BECKETT ..JOHN C * .JONES ARE:A CODE 616 .J, WARRE:N EAR OLEY TELEPHONE STE.VEN L.. DYKE.MA 451-2081 .JAMES R. BROWN LEWIS O. CRAIN LARRY .J.GARONER CLAUOE L.VANCf.:R PL.OEG March 31, l97l:
RONALD ..J,CL.ARK Mr. Judd Bacon Consumers PGWer Company 212 West Michigan Jackson, Michigan 49201
Dear Judd:
I am enclosing a duplicate original of a Certi-fication of Resolutions passed by the Sierra Club's Board of Directors authorizing the execution of the settlement agreement and ratifying my execution of same. This, together
- witl1 the copy o_f the telegram from the Sierra Club president, Philip s. Berry, which I sent you on March 16, 1971, provides you with the necessary documentation of the Sierra Club's approval of, and execution of, the settlement agreement.
Yours very truly, Lewis D. Drain LDD:pcp cc: Mr. Myron M. Cherry (w/enc.) Mr. David D. Corney (w/enc.) Enclosure RECEIVED APR 1 1971 C. P. Co. Legal
To PAPerry, Michigan Ave
- fROM DATE SUBJECT JLBacon, Michigan*Ave April.9, 1971 ATOMIC ENERGY - PALISADES PLAflT consumers Power Campany
- Operating License: Settlement Agreement INTERNAL CORRESPONDENCE cc Attached for filing with the Company's executed copy of'the Palisades settlement agreement is an executed duplicate original* of a certificate of resolutions passed by the Sierra Club Board of Directors authorizing the exe""'.
cution of the settlement agreement and ratifying execution thereof by Lewis D. Drain, together with a letter to me from Mr. Drain dated March 31, 1971, trans-mitting the certification.
\. . /)
, I::....,
. )
.* {,_,_- .
_)
- CERTIFICATION OF RESOLUTIONS I, Raymond Sherwin, ~ecrecary of the f.ierra Club, hereby certify that the following resolution was duly passed by the Board of Directors of the.Sierra.Club at its regular meeting of February 13-14, 1971, in Denver, Colorado:
Palisades Power Plant Lawsuit (Michigan)
*. MSC (Sill-Brooks) The Sierra Club Board of Directors re-solves that Phillip Berry, President of the Sierra Club, be and he hereby is authorized to execute an agreement on behalf of the Sierra Club with Consumers Power Company in the St.ate of Michigan and others resolving the dispute be-tween these parties -now pending before the United States Atomic Energy Commission concerning Consumers' Palisades nuc. lear power plant .
I further certify that the following resolution was duly passed by the Executive Committee of the Board of Directors of the Sierra Club at its meeting of March 23, 1971, in San Francisco,
- California:
Ratification of Settlement Agreement RESOLVED: that the execution by Lewis D. Drain on behalf of the Sierra Club of a document entitled Palisades Plant Settlement Agreement between Consumers Power Company and Michigan Steelhead and Salmon Fishermen's Assn., et al., on March 15, 1971, is hereby fully approved and ratified. Secretary
*-*--:-* - --~*-- ___.___ _.._ --- -------- ---~~-- ___:_ - ---*---*:--*---*---*----~ .-**------**-**--* --**-*-- *-***--*------*-*-- ---*
.-- ...~--- -
.SUPPLEMEN'J!AL AcmEEMEN'?, made this l 7¢ir d.a.y .0£ June, l.971. by a.nd between CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY, 2.J2 West Michigan Avenue, jack.son, Michigan, hereina£ter ca.lled "Consumers Power," and MIClD:GAN STEELHEAD AND SALMON FISEERMEN'S ASSOCIATION, 5619 CJ.a.to, JCaJa;rnazoo, Michigan, THEBMAL ECOLOGY MUST BE PRESERVED (T.E.M.P.), 23.J2 Glenwood Drive, Ka.J.ama.z~o, Michigan, CONCERNED PETITIONING cmZENS, 2312 Glenwood Drive, Kalama.zoo, Michigan, MICHIGAN !AKE AND STREAM ASSOCIATIONS, INC * , 392 Fa.irbrook .Court , Northville , .
Michigan, a.nd SIEREA CL~, 1050 Mills Tower, San Fra.llcisco, California (for itseli' and for each and a.ll of its chapters), hereinafter.ca.lied, jointly and severa.J.ly, "Intervenors,"
- WHEBFA.S, the pirties entered into a. Settlement Agreement d.a.ted Ma.rch 12, 1971 for the purpose of resolving all controversies, differences and disputes between Consumers Power and Intervenors with respect to the design, construction, licensing and operation of Consumers Power's Palisades Pla.nt in Covert Township, Van. Buren COllllty, Michigan; and
- WHERF.AS, Consumers Power filed an application with the Michigan Public Service Commission ("MPSC") on March 18, 1971 pursuant to §6.2 of the Settlement Agreement and* on J'lm.e 16, 1971 the Ml?SC issued an Opinion and Order in Case No. U-3884 with respect to said application; and WHEREAS, the parties mutua.J.ly desire to supplement the Settle-ment Agreement in certs.in respects; NOW THEREFORE, the parties hereto :further agree with respect to the Settlement Agreement a.s follows:
___,_ *- *-*** *-----,.-----*- ..... -- .....-----*--***--*----*-**- - --*-7--****.- - - .... -=...:.._. __ .* -- ***--*---*---~ :. *---~*-**=---;*----******: .... -~- - . **-* 2
- 1. The Opinion and Order of t:Q,e* Michigi:i,n Public Service Commis-sion issued June 16, 1971 in Case No. ri-3884 is neither a granting nor a denial of th~. "MPSC order" (as defined in §6.2 of the Settlement Agreement) contemphted by §§ 6.2, 6.3, 6.4 and 6.5 of the Settlement Agreement; the Settlement .Agreement sha.ll c.ontinue in f'ul.l force and effect a..nd. shall not te:rnlina.te by reason of the reconvening of th.e proceeding before the Atomic Safety and LicensingiBoard to consider issuance to Consumers Power of the :f'ul.J.-power license or any. other operating license for the Pa.lisades PlB.nt; and the parties agree that sa.id proceeding may be reconvened to con-sider the issua.nee to Consumers Power of the said :f'ul.J.-power or other operating license. *
- 2. The "MPSC order" (as defined in §6.2 of the Se:ttJ.em.~nt Agreement) is.not required for the performance by Consumers Power of any provision or provisions of the Sett1em.ent Agreement; the said Opinion and Order of the Michigan Public Service Commission issued June 16, 197J. in Case No~ U-3884 does not cause performance of any provision or provisions of the Settlement Agreement to be contrary to or to be prevented by a.ny local, state or federaJ. la.w~ or the rule, regulation, order, action or failure to act of any public body or official purporting to exercise a.u-
- t.hc..wit:.y with respect thereto, or the order or decree of any court ; a.nd the Settlement Agreement sha.ll not termina.te by reason of.the issuance of said Opinion and Order of June 16, 1971 or any further order or decision upon rehearing, appeal or review of said Opinion and Order.
- 3. The parties shall continue to be bound by and to observe and carey out all of their 'Undertakings in the Settlement Agreement in
~*-~ *- 3
- accordance with the terms thereo~;-,incJ.uding, but not 'limited to, filing in*the proceeding the f'ulJ.-power stipul.a.tion executed pursuant to §6.1 of the Settlement Agreement. *
- 4. Consumers Power agrees that it does not now, and will not la.ter, claim that it is or shall be relieved of any ob;Ligation under the Settlement Agreement bec~use of any order of the MPSC, now or in the future, disapproving or failing to authorize Consumers Power to include i
in its rate base for ratemaking purposes its investment in the modified condenser cooling system and modified liquid rad.waste system, made or to be made pursuant to the Settlement Agreement, or beca.i.ise of any such order of the MPSC, now or in the future, disapproving or failing to au-thorize Consumers Power to include in its cost of service for ra.tema.king
* *purposes*its expenses in opera.ting and maintaining the modified condenser cooling system and the modified liquid radwaste system, incurred or to be incurred pursuant to the Settlement Agreement.
CONCEBNED PE1'I_TIONING CITIZENS
. -/z . - *"'- .
.=:/ / .* ~>"':
..* ' / / *7'_-.ir -
,(*-/
".*" .* ./..* ..-'/ ,.** .-
MICHIGAN'.LAKE AND STBEAM ASSOCIATIONS, INC. I
\ /
- StJl'PLEMEN'LUi AGREEMENT. NO. 2
~ AGlm>IENT, made this 2 '-I (L day of September, 1971 by and bet-.reen CONSm.iERS POWER COMPANY, 212 West Michigan Avenue, . Jackson, Michigan, hereinafter *ca.ll.ed. "Consumers Fewer, " and MICHIGAN .STEELHEAD AND * . SAL'iQN F!SHE:RMEN'S ASSOCIATION, 5619 Clato, KaJamazoo, Michigan, THERMAL ECOLOGY MUST BE~ (T.E.M.P.), 2312 Glenwood Drive, Kalamazoo, Michigan, CONCERNED PETITIONING CITIZENS,.2312.Glenwood Drive, KaJame.zoo, Michigan, MICHIGAN LAKE AND STRF.AM ASSOCIATIONS,. ntC., 392 Fa.irbrook Court, Northville, Michigan, and SIERRA CLUB,.1050 Milla Tower, Se.n Francisco, California (for itself and for each and a.ll of its chapters), hereinafter*
Cal1ed J jointly Md Severally J 1'IDte1"V'tmorS J II WHEREAS, the parties entered into & Settlement Agreement dated March 12, 1971, as amended by a Supplemental Agreement dated June 17, 1971, for the purpose of resolving all controversies, differences and disputes between Consumers Power and Intervenorswith respect to the design, con-struction, licenaing*&nd operation of Ccmaumers Power's Palisades Plant in covert Townahip, Van Buren County, M1ch1gu; and WHERFAS, the parties desire to further amend and supplement the Settlement Agreement; NOW THEREFORE, the parties hereto f'llrther agree with- respect to the Settlement Agreement as follows:
- 1.
- The following new sentence is hereby inserted immediately be:f'ore the last sentence of' §6.l on page 17:
2
*"In .the event Consumers Power at any time :f'iles in the proceeding a. motion or other. request for issuance of a license,* other than the full-power license, to operate the Pa.l.isades Plant a.t any :maximum authorized power level. .
greater than one thermal mega.watt but less than 2200 thermal.*
* . mega.watts (in this Agreement cal.led a.n 'interim-power li-cense'), containing the specia1 technical. specifications,*
the parties' attorneys of record in the proceeding shal.l. also execute, present and file in the proceeding as pro-vided in §6. 6 hereof the Stipula.tion (a cow of which is attached hereto a.s Appendix VI) supporting issua.?ice to Consumers Power of interim-power licenses."
- 2. §§6.2 through 6.5 a.re hereby deleted.
- 3. Substitute the following for §6.6:
"§6.6* If' a.t any time or times hereaf'ter Consumers Power shall request that the proceeding be reconvened to consider the issuance of' any interim-power or :f'uJ..l:-power license containing the special technical. specifications, then Inter-venors agree that they will join in such request. Intervenors sha.l.l thereupon cooperate w:i:th and take a.11 appropriate action not inconsistent.with this Agreement to assist and support Consumers Power in expeditiously obtaining the licenses.
- Such assistance and support sba.ll include, but not be limited to, joining with Consumers Power in presenting a.rid filing in the proceeding the Stipulation, a. copy of 'Which is at-tached hereto as Appendix V, or in executing, presenting and*
filing in the proceeding the Stipulation, a copy of' which is attached hereto as Appendix VI, whichever is applicable. From the time of the execution of this Agreement Inter-venors sha.l.l not, unl.ess requested by Consumers Power in order to support the issuance of the testing license or any interim-power or full.~power license containing the special technical specifications, or unless directed or requested by the ASLB, or unless perm.j,tted by this Agree-ment or the Stipulations (copies of which a.re attached hereto as Appendixes IV, V a.nd VI), take any further ac-tion in the proceeding or file any documents therein (other than the aforesaid Stipulations) or initiate or participate in any actions (including but not limited to administrative remedies or court actions) dehors the proceeding with respect to or in coz:inection with the testing license or any interim-power license, or the :f'ul.1-power license containing the special technical specifica-tions, or the issuance of said licenses."
o I *'
- 4. In §6. 7, add after 11 proceeding 11 in line J on page 21 and line 17 on page 22 the:phrase "authorizing or dire.cting the issuance of the .full-power license".
- 5. . . In §6. 7 on page 22, '.3-dd after "testing license" on lines 11 14 and 21 the phrase , any interim-power license,"'.
- 6. Add the following new sentence at the _end of §6. 7 on page 23 :*
For purposes of this §6.7, the.term 'full-power license' sha.11 a.lso include a.rry license to operate the Palisades
- Pl.ant at a :maximum authorized power level th.at is less than 2200 thermal. megawatts, which license is issued pursuant to the.la.st initia.l decision in the proceeding rendered before termination of the ASLB's jurisdiction in the pro-ceeding, or pursuant to the final decision in the proceeding upon which the ASLB' s jurisdiction in the proceeding terminates." *
- 7. §6.8 is hereby deleted *
* .8.
9. In §6.10 on page 24, add a.f'ter "license11 in line 3 the phrase "or any interim-power license". In §8.1 on page 26, add af-ter 11 licenses 11 in line 13 the
*phrase "and any interim-power license or licenses 11 *
- 10. In §10.1 on page 27, add after "license" in line 3 the phrase 11 and any interim-power license".
ll. In-§10.6 on page 30, de.lete "to be incl.uded in the f'u.11.-power license" in lines l a.nd 2.
- 12. Append.ix V is amended and shall be in the form attached hereto.
Upon *execution of this Supplemental Agreement No. 2, the parties' attorneys of record in the proceeding sha.11 execute and file in the pro-ceeding the amended Stipulation (a copy of which is attached hereto), and shall withdraw the Stipulation heretofore filed in the proceeding supporting issuance to Consumers Power of the full-power license.
_!'", 4
- 13. In all other respects, the Settlement Agreement, as previously
. amended, shall remain in full
- force and e:ffect . .
I
*~
By: I ;./.?_, /..r <". 1
Agreement dated in March, *19n between APPENDIXV Consumers. Power Company and Michigan - (Amended) Steelhea.d a.nd Salmon Fishermen's
- Association, et. 8.1.
UNITED STA,Tg3 OF AMERICA ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION . In the Matter of )
)
CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY ) Docket No. 50-2 55
)
(Palisades Plant) ) STIPULATION BY AND. BmwEEN ALL INTERVENORS AND APPLICANT IN SUPPORT OF FULL-POWER LICENSE. Applicant and Intervenors, by their respective undersigned attorneys, and subject to the terms a.nd provisions of a.n Agreement be-tween Applicant and Intervenors dated. the 12th day of March, 1971-, as amended, (hereinat'ter called the "Settlement Agreement"), hereby stipu-late a.nd agree a.s follows: *
- l. That this Stipulation sball be subject to withdrawal by the Applicant or the Intel'Y9n0ra in the event the Regulatory Sta.ff of the AEC fails, prior ~o the closing of the record in this proceeding to con-sider the issuance to Applicant of the :f'u.ll-power license, to file in this proceeding a form of t'ull-power license, proposed to be issued to Applicant, containing the special technical specifications as part of the Technic8.J.
S?ecifications for the Palisades Plant. As used in this Stipulation the 11
- f'ul1-power license" means a license to operate the. Palisades Plant a.t steady-state power level.a up to and incl.uding 2200 thermal megawatts, pro-vided that, for purposes of paragraphs 6,
- 7 a.nd 8 hereof, the term ":t'ull-power license" sbs.ll. also include a license to operate at a lesser maximum
- authorized power level, E!oil as:~more particularly described in para.graph 8; "interim-power license n means any license, other than the f'ul.l.-power
2
- . license; to operate the Pa.l.isades Pla.Iit at a. maximum authorized steady-*
state power level.greater than one thermal. megawatt but less than 2200 thermal. mega.watts; the "testing license" means a license authorizing fuel loading and low-power testing of the Pa.l.isades Plant at power levels not to exceed one*the:rmal. megawatt; and the "special technical specifications" means
**the technical specifications in the form set forth in Exhibit A hereto.
- 2. That Intervenors have heretofore contested. the issuance .
- to Applicant of the. full-:power license; that in order to resolve their di.f:ferences Applicant a.nd Intervenora have entered into the Settlement Agreement, a. true cOF.f of which has been filed.in this proceeding; a.nd that in accorda.ncew:!.th. the Settl.ement Agreement and this Stipula.-
tion, Interve~ors no longer oppose and now support the prompt issu-ance to Applicant .of the :f'u.ll-power license containing the special technical. specifications.
- 3. That Applicant reque*t* that the special technical specifi-cations be included in the :f'Ul.J.-power license u part of the Technical Specifications for the Palisades Plant.
- 4. That in support of the prompt issuance to Applicant of the
- f'u.ll-power license conta.:1.ning the special technical. specifications, Intervenors:
(:L) w:!.ll not engage in any f'urther voir dire examination, cross-examination, or direct ex8mi.nation herein; * (ii) will not make any f'urther argument, objec-tiona, offers of proof, motions or requests herein;
3 (iii) will not submit or file or seek le.ave to submit or file a.n::r pleading, evidence, ex-hibit or other document herein; and (iv) will not take a.n::r other action herein or initiate or participate in any actions (including but not limited to. adminis-trative remedies or court actions) dehors this proceedi.i:ig with respect to or in con-nection with the full~power license con-taining the special technical specifications, or the issuance of said license, unless requested. by Applicant in order to support the issuance to Appli-cant of the full-power license containing the special technical* specifica-tions, or unless directed. or requested by the Atomic Sa:fety and Licensing Board (hereina.:fter called the "ASLB"), or unless permitted by the Settle-ment Agreement or this Stipulation.
- 5. That in support ot the prompt issuance to Applicant of the
- f'ull-power license containing the special technical specifications, Intervenors:
(i) withdraw all requests, demands and motions heretotore made by them in this proceeding; (ii) agree that any issues which the ASLB :::mst consider in this proceeding, and as to which there is no controversy between the Appl.icant
- and the AEC Regul.atory Staf':f', may be treated by
4 the ASLB as "matters not in controVersy" within the.meaning of §VI(b) ot Appendix A of' the AEC's Rules of Practice a.nd as *~ot being matters in controversy* among the parties" within the meaning ot §A.Ji of Appendix D to 10 CFR Pa.rt.50; and
*(iii) co~ent to the entry ot .f'inciings of fa.ct and
- conclusions ot law not inconsistent with the Settlement Agreement a.nd this Stipula.-
. t:i;on, including but not limited to .findings of fact and conclusions of' law in favor of Applicant on all issues specified in any Notice of Hearing issued in this pro-ceeding on Applicant's application for
- a. provisional operating license for the Palisades Plant a.s amended to include the modifications contemplated by the special technical specifications.
- 6.
- That Applicant shall file in this proceeding proposed findings of fact andconc1usions of law and fonn. of an initial decision not inconsistent with the terms and provisions of the Settlement Agree-ment and this Stipulation; and that the same shall contain, inter alia.,
findings of fact and conclusions ot law to the effect that: (1) Applicant has resolved to the satisfaction of the ASLB all evidentiary issues regarding nuclear safety, ra4iological and enViromnenta.l protec-tion, quality control, sa:f'e operation of the. Palisades Plant, and all other factors material
5 to Appllcant'sapplice.tion for the* full-power license as amended to include the modifica-. tions contemplated by the specia.l technical specifications; (ii) Int ervenors shall be deemed to have wi thdra.*,m
- from this proceeding when the full-power license containing the special technical specific~tions has been issued to Applic~t
.a:c.d the initial or. final decision in this pro-ceeding authorizing or.directing the issuance of said license has become the final action of the .AEC without amendment of said license so as to remove or change the s:pecial technical speci-fications, as provided in §6.7 of the Settlement Agreement and :paragraph 8 of this stipulation; and (iii) that the Intervenors will not lose or waive any rights reserved in the Stipulation heretofore filed herein by Applicant and Intervenors in support of the issuance of the testing license unless and until Intervenors are deemed to hn.ve wi thdra.wn from this proceeding as provided. in
§6. 7 of the Settlement AgI:"eement and paragraph 8 of' this Stipulation. *
- 7. Tha.t the ASLB should authorize and direct the issuance to Applicant of the fUJ.1-power license containing the special technic:iJ specifications in accordance with the findings of fact and conclusion~
or law contemplated by pa.ragra.ph 6 of this Stipula.tion; and that the
(,
- ASLB 's initial decision authorizing or directing the issuance of said full-power license, and said fu.lJ. power license as well, should becane effective at the earliest t~ permitted by law and the rules and.regulations of the AEC.
- 8. That when (i) the :fUll-power license has been is.sued to Appli-cant containing the special technical specifications and (ii) the initial or final decision in this proceeding authorizing or directing* .the issuance of the full-power license has beccme the :final action of the AEC Ylithout amendment of the fu11-power license so as to remove or change the special* technical specifications, then Interrenors shall be deemed, without further action on their pa.rt, to have withdraw. fran. this proceeding with prejudice and without right *thereafter (except as otherwise provided in the Settlement Agreement) to take any further action in this proceeding or otherwise in this Docket No. 50-255; or to take any action in any AEC proceeding to extend, renew or c.o:c.vert the full-power license :f'rom a provisional to a f'inal operating license or to amend :::-:
the .tUl.1-power license to authorize operation of the Palisades Plant at any power level higher than that authorized in the full-power licen_se; or to appeal or to stay the effectiveness of any or all deGisions, findings, orders or rulings theretofore or thereafter ma.de or entered in this pro-ceeding or otherwise in this Docket No. 50-255 or in any .P$£ proceeding to so extend, renew, convert or a.mend the fu11-p~wer license; or to initiate or participate in any actions (including but not limited to ~n ministra.tive remedies or court actions) dehors this proceeding with re- .. spect to or in connection with the testing license, any interim-power license or licenses, or the f'Ull-power license, or the issuance of said licenses *. That upon such issuance of the full-power license containing the special technical
7
** specifications and the initial or final decision authorizing or directing
*the issuance of said license having beccme the final action of .the AEC, as aforesaid in (i) a.nd (ii) of this paragraph 8, Intervenors shall a.lso thereby be deemed to have waived a.nd forever relinquished any ancl all rights to take a.ny legal
. action with respect to any alleged noncom-pliance of.the*Pa.lisades Plant, this proceeding or a:ny decision in this proceeding, or the testing license, a:ny inter:iln license or licenses, or the :f'ul.1-pover license, 'With the National EnviroDI!lental Policy Act, the Federal Water PolJ.ution Control Act as amended, the Atomic Energy Act of 1954.as amended, the Federal Rivers and Harbors Act of March 3, 1899 as amended, the Federal Clean Air Act as am.ended, or 'With &J.Y other federal, state or local statutes or ordiDa.nces &J.d any ruJ.es, orders and regulations of the AEC or a:ny other .public o:f'f'icial. or agency under a:a.y of said Acts statutes or ordinances. For purposes of' paragraphs 6, 7 and 8 hereof, the term "ful.J.-power license" shall a.lso include a:ny license to operate the Palisades Plant at a. maximum authorized power level that is less than 2200 thermal megawatts, which license is issued pursuant to the last initial decision in the proceeding rendered before termination of the ASLB's juris-diction in.the proceeding, or pursuant to the final decision in the pro-ceeding upon which .the ASLB's jurisdiction in the proceeding terminates.
- 9. That if the Settlement Agreement shal:l be termillateling system utilizing the al~ernative type of cooling tower or towers shall commence from the date on which Consumers Power is relieved from in~
stalling or continuing to install the type of cooling tower or towe.rs first selected. The *modified condenser *.cooling system shall be placed in opera.- tion not later tha...'l the resu'liption of operation of the Pal~sades Plant after its first scheduled rei'ueling following installation of said system, pro-vided, that to the extent it can do so consistently with electrical sys-tem. load requirements, Palisades Plant opera.ting requirements a.nd applicable license and other legal limitations*, Consumers P.ower shall use its best efforts to schedule the fi*rst refueling following insta.~ation of the modi-fied condenser cooling system so as to minimize the time between the comple-tion of such installation and the initial operation of the modified con-denser cooling system. The foregoing provisions of this §S-1.2 a.re subject tc the condition that in the event the installation or the initial operation of such modified cbndenser cooling system is delayed (i) by reason of flood, strike, insurrection, riot, embargo, a.ct of nature or the public enemy; or unavoidable delay in transportation or inability or unavoidable delay in :proc\lring labor or materials; (ii) by reason of legal action by any
- ps.rty other than Consumers Power or Intervenors; local, state or federal laws; or the rul.es, regula.tions, orders, actions or failure to a.ct of any pilblic body or official purporting to exercise a.uthorityqr control with
A-5 respect -to installat:j:ori or- opera-Cion of- tne- modified condenser cooling - - *system; or (iii) -by reason of M.y ca.use b~yond the reasonable control of
-Consumers Power, *the time for per~ormance shall be extended ( sub,ject to the provisions of Sec~ion S-4 of these special technical specifications as resuects [ii] above) for a time equal to the period of such delay.
§s-1.3 Pending instalJ.ation a.nd operation of the modified con-denser cooling system provided.for in this Section S-1, Consumers Power may operate the Palisades Plant a.t any power levels authorized by any AEC operating license issued to Gonsumers Power, utilizing the existing once-through cooling system and releasing _heated condenser cooling water to Lake Michigan.
SECTION S LIQUID RADWASTZ SY5TEM MODIFICATION
§S-2.l Consumers Power shall modify the liquid ra.dwaste system now installed in the Pal~sa.des Plant in the manner provided in these special technical specifications. _The liquid ra.dwaste system a.s so modi-fied ( a.nd in these special technical specifications called the "modified liquid radwaste system") shall be so designed, constructed, operated and maintained tha.t at a.11 times under normal operating conditions, radio-a.cti ve materials i, liquid dischA.rges from the Pa.lis~des Plant to Lake Michigan a.re reduced to essenti~_lly zero; provided, however, that radio-active materials in laundry waste system discharges which cannot be treated in the dirty waste system of' the modified liquid ra.dwaste system without the possibility of impairing the £Unction of dirty waste system equipment may be released to Lake Michigan a.t levels which shall in no 8
event exceed 25 picocuries per liter ( 2. 5 X 10- microcu.ries/ cc) on an
A-6 -* annual average oasis; and proVided further, that "essentially .zero," as ils1~d *herein, shall not be construed to preclude liquid discharges to La.ke Miehigan contai!ling radioactive materials at levels, as.sampled at the re-cycle monitor tank before dilution, equivalent to or below then-current Lake Michigan background radioactivity levels, as monitored offshore from the Palisades Plant prior to such liquid discharges. As used in these special technical specifications "normaJ. opera.ting conditions" shall *refer to operation of the Falisades Plant during or in connection with which there exist no abnormal events or circUm.stances such as (but not limited to) steam generator tube leakages, fire, or pipe brea.lt'..ige; and "abnormal op<:!ra.ting conditions" shall refer to operation of. the Palisades* Plant du~ing or in connection with which there exist any such abnormal events or circumstances. .All radioactive materials removed from liquid wastes by the modified liquid radwaste system will 11e accumulated and prepared for shi:pment in accordance with applicable rules, regulations and orders of governmental authorities having jurisdiction and turned over to a carrier or carriers licensed by governmental authorities having jurisdic-tion for shi:pment to an authorized disposal area or areas. Consumers I Power intends to be alert to, and to utilize to the extent it is practical to do so, means of minimizing th~ amount of laundry waste that cannot be treated in the dirty waste sys-:e..'!!.
§S-2.2 It is recogni=cd that under abnormal operating condi-tions it may be impossible or impractical to achieve essentially zero re-lease of radioactive materials in liquid discharges from the Palisades Plant through operation of the modified liquid radwaste system. Consumers
- Power shall so operate the modified liquid ra.dwaste system as to ensure that radioactive mate~iaJ.s in liquid discharges to Lake Michigan resulting
.from abnormal opera.ting conditions* do not exceed, on a quarterly average basis and on a.n individual isotopic analysis basis, ten percent (103) of applicable 10 C]'R Pa.rt 20 limits in effect a.s of December 1, 1970, and are. reduced to essentially zero no later tha.n sixty (6o)*consecutive days after the commencement of such releases resulting from abnormal operating conditions. Notwithstanding the foregoing, however, delay beyond said sixty (6o) da.y period in the reduction of radioactive materials in such liquid discharges to essentia.l.ly zero shall be excused ( su.bject to the provisions of Section S-4 of these special technical specifications as respects [ii] below) to the extent it is (i) due to *inability to identify, locate or repair the abnormal opera.ting condition; or due to flood; stri..lte; insurrection; riot; embargo; a.ct of nature or the public enemy; or by reason of unavoidable delay in transportation or inability or unavoia.B.ble delay in procuring labor or materials; (ii) due to legal action by a party other than Consumers Power or Intervenors; local, state or federal laws; or the rul.es, reguJ..a.tions, orders, actions or failure to act of any public I
body or official pulrporting to exercise authority or control with respect to such liquid discharges; or (iii) due to a.ny ca.use beyond the reasonable control of Consumers Power; provided, however, that radioactive materials in liquid discr..arges to Lake Michigan from the modified liquid radwaste system during 2ny such excused delay beyond said sixty (60) day period sr..all not exceed, on a quarterly average basis and on an indi vi.dual iso-topic analysis basis, one percent (1%) of applicable 10 CFR Pa.rt 20 limits
A.-3
- in effect as of December 1, 1970; and provided further, however, that Consumers Power shall undertake promptly to correct abnormal operating*
conditions which result in releases of radioactive materials in liquid discharges to Lake Michigan from the modified liquid radwaste system at levels greater than essentially zero.
§S-2.3 The modified liquid radwaste system shall be installed and placed in operation no later than the resumption of operation-of the Palisades Plant after its first scheduled refueling (which is ex:pected to occur approximately seventeen [17] calendar months following the date of col!lID.encement of escalation to :f\12.l power following issuance of the provi-sional operating license a.uthori~ing Consumers Power to operate the Palisades Plant at steady-state power levels up to and inc.luding 2200
- thermal megawatts) or twenty-four (24) calendar months following the date of the aforesaid settlement agreement, whichever occurs first.
foregoing provisions of this §S-2.3 a.re subject to the condition that in The the event the installation or th~ initial operation of such modified liquid radwaste system is delayed ( i) by reason of flood; strike; insurrec-tion; riot; embargo; a.ct of nature or the public enemy; or unavoidable delay in tra.ns:porta.tion or inability or unavoidable delay in procuri~ labor or ::nateri*ils; (ii) by rea.:::o:i of lega.l action by a. party other than Const.Uners Power or Intervenors; local, state or federal laws; or the rules, regul~tions, orders, actions or failure to act of any public body or offi-cial purporting to exercise authority or control with respect to installa-tion or cperation of the modified liquid radwa.ste system; or (iii) by reason of any cause beyond the reasonable control of Consumers Power, the
A-9
- time for perfonr.a.nce shall be extended ( subje~t to the provisions of Sec-tion S-4 of these special techriical specifications as respects .[ii] above) for a time equal to the period of such delay.
§S-~. 4 Pending installition e.nd operation of the modified liquid
- radwaste system pursuant to the schedule provided* in §s-2.3 hereof, Consumers
- Poi\*er may operate the Pa.lisa.des PJ.a.nt a.t 8.ny power levels authorized by any AEC license issued to. Consumers Power, utilizing the exi.sting liquid rad-waste system; provided that radioactive ma.teria.ls in liquid discharges to Lake Michigan shall be at le,rels which are at all times as low as practicable and which do not exceed, on n. quarterly aveJ-age basis and on an individual isotopic a.na.1.ysis basis, a.nd based on the assumptions used in Section 11 of Consumers Power's Final Safety Analysis Report to the AEG for the Palisades Plant as a.mended to December l, l970, (i) under normal or abnormal opera-
*ting conditions as defined in §S-2.l hereof and assuming no failed fuel, two percent (2%) of a.pplica.ble 10 CFR Part 20 limits in effect as of December l, 1970; and (ii) under ~orma.l or abnormal opera.ting conditions as defined in §S-2.l hereof and assuming some failed.fuel, ten percent (lo%) of applicable, 10 CFR Pa.rt 20 limits in effect as of December 1, 19'10.
§S-2. 5 In line 8 of subsection 3. 9 .13 of Section 3. 9, "EFFLUENT 11 I RELEASE" of the Technical Specifications, a.dd the following after 10 CFR i 20":
"for gaseous relea.~es, a.nd within the limits for I liquid releases specified in the special technical . !
specifications included herein at the request of the licensee pursuant to a settlement. agreement dated in March, 1971."
A-10 . SECTION S-~ - ~1ERVATIONS
§s-3.l Nothing in these special technical specifications shall prevent Consumers Power from ta.king any steps or* measures in connection
- with the. design, construction,. mod.i.fication or operation of the modified condenser cooling system and the modified liquid radwaste sy5tem which contemplate modifications, procedures or modes of operation equal to or better, considering the protection of the environment, than the modi fica-tions, proced"ll!"es or modes of operation contemplated in these special technical specifications; provided, however, that the foregoing provi-sions sh3.ll not authorize Consumers Power to take any steps or measures to install and operate a modified condenser cooling system having an open cycle system utilizing Lake Michigan water for once-through cooling or to install and operate a modified liquid radwaste system which would release radioactivity to the environment at levels above those contemp~ated in Section S-2 of these special technical specifications under the condi-tions therein stated.
§S-3.2 The modifications, procedures and modes of operation con-:emplated in these speda.J. technical specifications for the Palisades Plant and any action taken by Constimers Power pursuant to said specia:l:-
technical specifications or the aforesaid settlement agreement of March, 1971 before or a.~er the execution of said agreement shall not be deemed, construed, interpreted or cla.imed to be an admission that the same or any similar modificacions, procedures or modes of operation are necessary or required at any other Consumers Power electric generating plant. The obli-ga.tions of Consumers Power under ~hese special technical specifications and said agreement are limited to the Palisades Plant.
.A-11 SEC;L'ION S LE*JAL VALIDITY
§S-4.l If Consumers PO"Jer believes that compliance with any provision or provisions of these special technical specifications is con-trai:Y to or prevent~d by any local, state or federal law~ or the rule, revila.tion, order, action or failure to act* .of any .public body or or{~ic.i.al purporting to exercise author.ity with respect ther~to, or the order or decree of any court, then Consumers .Power shall promptly notify Inter-venors thereof by telegram; telepnorie or other means and notify Inter-venors thereof in writing within ten (10) business da.ys thereafter, stating the basis for such belief. In the event Intervenors notify Consumers Power of their a.g?'l!ement with such belief within thirty ( 30) calendar da.ys a..fter delivery of the.aforesaid written notice by Consumers Power (and from the time of the aforesaid telephonic, telegraphic or
- other means of notice by Consumers Power and until the end of such thirty (30) da.y period whether or not such notification is given to Consumers Power by Intervenors) Consumers Power shall be relieved of any obligation to comply with the provision or provisions in question a.nd any and all other provisions of these speci~.: ~echnical specifications which require compliance with said provision or provisions. F..owever, notwi thstandinr.;
it~ release from obligation as provl.ded in this §S-4.1, Consumers Power shall have the right, in its sole discretion, to comply with or seek to comply with said provision or provisions. In the event Intervenors do not so notify Consumers Power within. said thirty ( 30) da.~r period, then Consumers Power shall in good faith and with due diligence pursue ad-nti.nistra.tive remedies or court actions (including appeals or requests for writs of certiorari to the highest state or federal court having
A-12
- jurisdiction)? or both, to assert the validity of. compliance with said provision or provisions and/or the invalidity or unlawfulness of the law, rule, regulation, order, decree, action or failure to act that is the sub,ject of the aforesaid 'Wti. tten notice by Consumers Power.
§S-4.2 In the event of a.n unfavorable ruling or the inability to have the validity of the compliance with such provision or provisi'.ons (which a.re the subject of suit and/or proceeding as contemplated in §s-4.1*
hereof) upheld a.f'ter exhausting all rights of hearing, appeal and requests for writs of certiorari to the highest state or federal court having juris-diction, then Consumers Power will forever be relieved of any obligation to comply with the provision or provisions in question and a:ny and all other provisions of these special technical specifications which require compliance with said provision or provisions.
§S-4. 3 While Consumers Power is pursuing the administrative remedies or court actions, or both, contemplated in §s-4.1 hereof, Consumers Power may operate the ?alisades Plant in any r.ia.nner permitted by law; provided, however, that while Consumers Power is pursuing said administrative remedies or court actions, or both, it shall continue to comply with a.11 of the provisions of these special technical specifica-tions except any provision or provisions (and any and all other provi-sions which require compliance with said provision or provisions) as to which (i) it is prevented from complying by a court order or decree or is prevented from complying by an order, notice or other action of any public body or official having authority to enforce such order, notice or other action wi th<:>Ut resort to a court for enforcement; or (ii) it is
A-13 prevented from complying by the la.ck of any permit, license; qonsent or other authorization of any public body or offieial which is required f'or continued compliance; or (iii) continued compliance would, in the reasonable
- opinion of legal counsel for Consumers PoW-er, result in the violation of a.ny criminal law or crimina.J. ordinance or the imPosition of a.ny criminal or civil. fine, criminal or civil penalty, or crimiha.l. or civil forfeiture; or (iv) there has been entered. a court order or decree or an order, notice
- or other action of a. public .body or official which, while not. preventing
.compliance with these specitl technical specifications lJy Consumers Power, would require shutdown of the Palis.S.des Pla.nt or a. reduction in the electri-cal output of the Pa.lisa.des Plant if Consumers Power continued to comply therewith.
SECTION S REPORTING REQUIREMENTS
§S-5.l Add the foll.owing new item e. to subsection 6.6.1 of Section 6.6, "PLANT REPORTING REQUIREMENTS" of the Technical Specifications:
"e. When a control rod or a pa.rt-length rod is misaligned as defined in 3.10.4.a of these Technical Specifications or when a control rod is inoperable as defined i~ 3.10.4.b of these Technical Specifica-tions."
- Agreement dated in March, l97l. between Con.aumers*Power Comp~ and.~chigan.
staelllead am Sa..lmcn 11.ahemml' .a
- A:aacci&tion, et &l.
A:roMIC Elm\GY CO~SSION In the Matter ot )
)
CO!'ISUMERS FO~"'ER CC.\lPALTl ) Docket No. 50-255
)
(~sad.as Plant) ) STIPULATION BY AND BETWm'i ALL nrn:avmoBS ANP APPLI~"ft m. SUPPORT OF INTERIM-POWER LICENSES
. I Applicant and Intervenors, bY their.respective undersigned attorneys, and subject to the tema and proviaions o~ an agreement be-tween Applicant and Intervenora dated the l2th ~ of March, 1971, as a.mended (hereinarter caJ.J.ec1 the "SettlE!UDt Agreement"), bereby stii;Ju-late and ~ u :f'Ollon:
- 1. That in accordance with the Settlement Agreement a.nd the Stipulations filed in this proceeding, Intervenors continue to supPort the prompt issuance to Applicant of a license to operate the Palisades Plant at steady-state power levels up to and including 2200 thermal megawatts (hereina.f'ter called the "f'ull-power license"), containing the special technical specifications filed in this proceeding.
- 2. That in accordance with SupPlemental Agreement No. 2 to the Settlement Agreement, Intervenors al.so suwort the prompt issuance to Appli-cant of any license or licenses containing the special. technical specifica-tions, other than the :t'ull.-power license, to ope;r-ate the Palisades Plant at maximum authorized steady-state power levels greater than one thermal mega.watt but less than 2200 thermal megawatts (any such license being here-inafter called an "interim-power license").
2
- 3. That in support of the :Prompt issuance to Applicant of' any interim-power license, Intervenors:
(i) w:Lll not ~e in any further voir dire examination, cross-e:mml :cation or* direct e;mmina.tion herein; (ii) will not make aey further a.rgt:ment,- objec-tions, otters of :proof, ~tiona or requests herein; (iii) "4ill not ~t or tile or seek leave to submit or file MY pl~Jl evidence, exhibit or other cioculoont herein; Bild (iv) will not take any athu action herein or initiate or ~iciJ;a,te in a:rry actions (including but not lilaited. U> ruim:I niatn.tive remedies or court action.a) dehors this pro-cffdi~ With n~t to or in cozmacticn with the interim-power license, or the issuance of' said license, unless requested by Applicant in order to support the issuance to Applicant of any interim-power license, or unless directed or requested by the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board (hereinafter called the "ASLB"), or unless permitted by the Settlement Agreement or this Stipulation, or the Stipula-tion filed in this proceeding res-pecting the issuance to Applicant of the full-power license.
- 4. That in support of the prompt issuance to Applicant o-.t any interim-power license, InteI"V"enors:
3 - (i) agree that a.ny issues which the ASLB mu.st consider in this proceeding, a.nd a.s to which there is no con-troversy between the Applicant a.nd the AEC Regulatory Sta.:t':f, may be treated by the ASLB a.s matters not in controversy" within the meaning of §VI (b ) o:f Ap:pendix A
. of the AEC' s Rules of Practice and a.s not being*: matters in controversy among the parties" within the meaning of
§A.ll of' Appendix D to 10 CFR Pa.rt 50; (ii) agree that they do not a.nd will not oppose or make any contentions relevant to Applicant's motion or other request for the interim-power license; (iii) agree that the ASLB may accept the evidence of the.Applicant in this proceeding a.s sufficient to show tha.t operation under the interim-power license will not have a significant, adverse impact on the quality of the environment a.nd a.s sufficient to comply with the National Environmental Policy Act, the Atomic Energy Act of 1954, as amended, and the rules and regulations of the A.EX:; a.nd (iv) consent to the entry of findings of fa.ct arid con-clusions of law not inconsistent with the Settle-ment Agreement and this Stipulation, including but not limited to :findings of fa.ct and conclu-
- sions o:f law in favor of Applicant on all issues
-. specified in any Notice of' Hee.ring issued in this 4 proceeding, with respect*t~ Applicant's l!!Otion or other request for the interim-power license.
- 5. That Applica.nt.$ha.J.J.. file in this proceeding proposed.findings of fact and conclusions of la.wand form of an initial* decision, or a. proposed order, not inconsistent with the terms and.provisions of the .settlement Agree-ment and this* Stipulation; and tha.t the same sha.11 contain, inter a.lia, findings and conclusions, or orders, to the effect.that Intervenors will not lose or waive a.ny rights reserved in the Stipula.tions filed in this proceeding by Applicant and Intervenors in support of the issuance of the testing license and the full-power license unless and until Intervenors are deem.ed. to ha.ve withdrawn from this proceeding as provided in §6. 7 of the Settlement Agree-*
merit a.nd paragraph 8 of the Stipula.tion filed in the proceeding in support of the full-power license.
- 6. That Intervenors will. not file any exceptions to any initial decision or order of the ASLB authorizing or directing the issuance of any interim-power license, or seek to stay or suspend any such interim-power license.
.7. 'l'hat the ASLB should authorize and order the issuance to Appli-cant of any interim-power license requested by Applicant in accordance '1ith the findings of fact and conclusions of law, or order, contemplated by para-graph S of this Stipulation; and that any ASLB initial decision or order authorizing or directing the issuance of an interim-power license, and any interim-power license as well., should become effective at the earliest time permitted by law and the rules and reguJ..ations of the AEC.
5
- 8. That when Intervenors are deemed to have withdrawn from this proceeding, as provided in §6.7 of the Settlement Agreement and paragraph 8 of the Stipulation filed in this proceeding by Applicant and Intervenors in support of the full-power license, then Intervenors no longer shall claim, assert or have* the rights reserved by them pursuant to this Stipulation and the Stipulations filed herein by Applicant and Intervenors in support of tte issuance of .the testing license and the full-power license.
- 9. That concurrently with the filing of this Stipulation, .the partiP.s will file in the proceeding a true capy of Supplemental Agreement No. 2 to the Settlement Agreement.
Judd L. &.con, Eaq. Attorne-.1 for Applicant Corunm.ers Poirer Compal:l,y
~ M. Chei-ry, Eaq.
Attorney tor all Intervenors except Siarra Club Lewis D. Dn.:in, Eaq. Attorney.for Intervenor Sierrn. Club
- Dated: September ~' 1971}}