ML17347B433
| ML17347B433 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Turkey Point  |
| Issue date: | 11/22/1989 |
| From: | Varga S Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| To: | Goldberg J FLORIDA POWER & LIGHT CO. |
| Shared Package | |
| ML17347B434 | List: |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8912010220 | |
| Download: ML17347B433 (12) | |
See also: IR 05000250/1989203
Text
~8 Rfgy
lO
n
UNITEDSTATES
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
WASHINGTON, D. C. 20555
+y*~+
Docket Nos.
50-250
and 50-251
NOV 32
1989
Mr. V.H. Goldberg
Executive Vice President
Florida Power and Light Company
P.O.
Box 14000
Juno
Beach, Florida
33408-0420
Dear Mr. Goldberg:
SUBJECT:
TURKEY POINT DESIGN VALIDATION INSPECTION (50-250
AND 50-251/89-203)
This letter
conveys the results
and conclusions of the Design Validation
Inspection
(DVI) of the Turkey Point Nuclear
Power Plant, Units 3 and 4.
The inspection
was performed at both the Turkey Point site
and the Nuclear
Engineering offices at Juno
Beach during the periods of September
11-15,
September
25-29,
and October 12-13,
1989.
The inspection report is enclosed.
t
The purpose of the inspection
was to assess
the effectiveness
of the actions
that Florida
Power
and Light Company
has
implemented
as part of the
Turkey Point Performance
Enhancement
Program
(PEP) Project
4 on configuration
control.
The inspection
team performed
a Safety System Functional Inspection
(SSFI)
on three
systems
to review the implementation of the
PEP actions.
The inspection
team concluded that the faci lity exhibited
a weakness
by confin-
ing its Design Basis Documentation
(DBD) verification effort to the system
level aspects
only.
Numerous errors were identified by the inspection
team
with respect to the component
level information.
The team
had additional
concerns with the multiple instances
in which seismic
and anchorage
analyses
were not available to substantiate
the adequacy
of major
components
in the component cooling water system.
The team also found errors
in the electrical
and piping calculations
which indicate the need to implement
the planned essential
calculations
program and to perform more thorough techni-
cal verification of the output calculations.
Some operating
procedures
were
found in er ror with respect to valve lineup configuration.
Based
on the
identified design output document
and design interface control problems,
the
team concluded that greater technical oversight is needed
on the part of
Florida Power and Light with respect to contractor work products.
On
a positive note,
the team found that maintenance initiatives,
such
as the
analysis-based
preventive maintenance
program, yielded beneficial results
and
the system level
DBDs were
deemed well prepared.
Bql20 ~ 0ZZ
5000250
811ZZ
pDOCK 0
G
/
E
t
0
II
d
1
~
~
~
I
Hr. J.H. Goldberg
?
-2-
blOV ~8
1989
? l
Regiop','II will determine if any of the identified issues
require enforcement
'ction,and will notify you under separate
correspondence.
In accordance'ith
a copy of this letter and the enclosure will be placed in the
Public Document
Room.
You're requested
to respond to this office within 60 days to inform us of the
actions -taken related to the designated
items identified in this report and the
date
by which these actions will be available for followup inspection".
,Should
you have
any questions
concerning this inspection,
please
contact
me or
'Hr. Robert
Gramm (301-492-0991).
Sincerely,
+i'fggaf signed
t)J
Enclosures:
1.
NRC Inspection
Report 50-250
and 50-251/89-203
cc:
See next page
Distribution:
See
page
4
Steven
A. Varga, Director
Division of Reactor Projects I/II
Office of Nuclear Reactor
Regulation
Document
Name:
TURKEY REPORT
- See previous
concurrence
C
NAtf
- RAGramm"
1/16/89
- EVImbro"
- 11/16/89
WDLanning*
W
11/19/89
BKGrimes*
ll/21/89
- Il ~
89
L
Q f
0
Hl 'l
II
IH
V
I
H
II
P
I
kl
'
N
pf
p
II
I
II
I
II
if~(
~ 'I
g
N
g
I
u
il
tl
I
~
~
~
I
Nr. J.H. Goldberg
Region II will determine if any of the identified issues
require enforcement
action
and will notify you under separate
correspondence.
In accordance
with
a copy of this letter and the enclosure will be placed in the
Public Document
Room.
E
7ou are requested
to respond to this office within 60 days to inform us of the
date
by which actions related to the designated
items identified in this report
will be available for followup inspection.
Should you have
any questions
concerning this inspection,
please
contact
me or tir. Robert
Gramm
(301-492-0991).
Sincerely,
Enclosures:
1.
NRC Inspection
Report
50-250
~
~
~
and 50-251/89-203
cc:
See next page
Distribution:
See
page
4
Steven
A. Varga, Director
Division of Reactor
Projects I/II
Office of Nuclear Reactor
Regulation
Document
Name:
TURKEY REPORT
- See previous
concurrence
RAGramm"
1/16/89
- EVImbro*
- 11/16/89
- WDLanning*
imes
- SAVarga
~
W
- 11/19/89:11/
~(/89
11/
/89
(>
<<I
0
I
Nr. J.H. Goldberg
-2-
'You are requested
to respond to this office within 60 days to inform us of the
date
by which actions related to all the items identified in this report will
be 'available for followup inspection.
Should you have
any questions
concerning
" this inspection,
please
contact
me or Nr. Robert
Gramm (301-492-0991).
Sincerely,
Enclosures:
1.
NRC Inspection
Report 50-250
and 50-251/89-203
cc:
See next page
Distribution:
See
page
4
Steven
A. Varga, Director
Division of Reactor Projects I/II
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
Document
Name:
TURKEY REPORT
0
RS
R
W
NQ1:RAGr
m
1/) (y/89
- NR
- R I :DRIS:NRR
R I
- D
- NRR
D'D IS:NR
~
CKw
- EVImbro
- WDLanning
- BKGrimes
- 11//$/89:11//'f/89:11/
/89
- DI:U P:N
- SAVarga
- 11/
/89
0
&
W
4
~
g
4
I
t
lI
I
h[
'
~
I
~
I
e
I
. ~
Mr. J.H. Goldberg
-3-
NOV P2
1989
cc w/enclosures:
Harold. F. Reis,
Esquire
Newman
and Holtzinger, P.C.
1615
L Street,
N.W.
20036
Mr. Jack Shreve
Office of the Public Counsel
Room 4, Holland Building
Tallahassee,
32304
John T. Butler, Esquire
Steel,
Hector and Davis
4000 Southeast
Financial Center
Miami, Florida
33131-2398
Mr. K.N. Harris, Vice President
Tut key Point Nuclear Plant
Florida Power and Light Company
P.0.
Box 029100
Miami, Florida
33128
Senior
Resident
Inspector
Turkey Point Nuclear Generating Station
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory
Commission
P.O.
Box 57-1185
Miami, Florida
33257-1185
Mr. Jacob
Nash
Office of Radiation Control
Department of Health and
Rehabilitation Services
1317
Winewood Blvd.
Tallahassee,
32399-0700
Intergovernmental
Coordination
and Review
Office of Planning
and Budget
Executive Office of the Governor
The Capital Building
Tallahassee,
32301
Institute of Nuclear
Power Operations
1100 Circle 75 Parkway
Atlanta, Georgia
30339
Administrator
Department of Environmental
Regulation
Power Plant Siting Section
State of Florida
2600 Blair Stone
Road
Tallahassee,
32301
Regional Administrator,
Region II
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory
Commission
101 Marietta Street,
N.W.
Suite 2900
Atlanta, Georgia
30323
Attorney General
Department of Legal Affairs
The Capitol
Tallahassee,
32304
Plant Manager
Turkey Point Nuclear
Plant
Florida Power and Light Company
P.O.
Box 029100
Miami, Florida
33102
L.W. Bladow
Plant
gA Superintendent
Turkey Point Nuclear Plant
P.O.
Box 029100
Miami, Florida
33102
E. Lyons
Acting Regulatory
and Compliance
~
Supervisor
Turkey Point Nuclear Plant
P.O.
Box 029100
Miami, Florida
33102
~Joaquin Avino
County Manager of Metropolitan
Dade County
111
NW 1st Street,
29th Floor
Miami, Florida
33128
)f
gt
0
e1
~
~
~
0
Hr. J.H. Goldberg
-4-
NV S2
19Sq
.Distribution:
50=250
0 50.251
DRIS R/F
RSIB R/F
SAVargy,
BKGrimes,
MDLanning,
EVImbro,
RAGramm,
TEMurley,
JHSniezek,
GEEdison,
HNBerkow,
RLSpessard,
RMBorchardt
EBO
.
RVCrlenjak
RII)
FJape (RII)
hVSinkule (RII)
Inspection
Team
ACRS (3)
OGC (3)
Regional Administrators
Regional Division Directors
LPDR
1S Distribution
I
I j
1