ML17345A602
| ML17345A602 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Turkey Point  |
| Issue date: | 12/21/1988 |
| From: | Ernst M NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION II) |
| To: | Conway W FLORIDA POWER & LIGHT CO. |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8812290215 | |
| Download: ML17345A602 (9) | |
Text
Florida Power and Light Company ATTN:
Mr.
W.
F.
Conway Senior Vice President
- Nuclear P. 0.
Box 14000 Juno
- Beach, FL 33408-0420 Gentlemen:
SUBJECT:
MEETING
SUMMARY
- TURKEY POINT NUCLEAR PLANT DOCKET NOS.
50-250 AND 50-251 This letter refers to the meeting conducted at our request at the Turkey Point site on November 14, 1988.
The meeting was the eighth in a series of management meetings following issuance of Confirmatory Order 87-85 in October 1987.
The purpose of the meeting was to discuss overall plant status, equipment
- issues, FPL's 'Management-on-Shift
- Program, Technical Specifications, and maintenance programs.
In addition, an Enforcement Conference in the area of Security was conducted.
The results of the Enforcement Conference are described in separate correspondence.
It is our opinion that this meeting was beneficial and provided a better understanding of the issues.
In accordance with Section 2.790 of the NRC's "Rules of Practice,"
Part 2, Title 10, Code of Federal Regulations, a copy of this letter and its enclosures will be placed in the NRC Public Document Room.
Should you have any questions concerning this letter, please contact us.
Sincerely, Original signed by
Enclosures:
1.
List of Attendees 2.
Meeting Agenda 3.
Meeting Summary cc w/encls:
J.
S.
Odom, Vice President Turkey Point Nuclear Plant J.
E. Cross, Plant Manager Turkey Point Nuclear Plant L.
W. Bladow, Plant gA Superintendent J. Arias, Jr., Regulatory and Compliance Supervisor State of Florida Malcolm L. Ernst Acting Regional Administrator bcc w/encls:
(See page 2) 8812290215 881221 PDR ADOCK 05000250 P
PNU
OO Florida Power and Light Company QEC 8 I 19S8 bcc w/encls:
G.
E. Edison, Project Manager, Project Directorate II-2, Division of Reactor
e t r:ser 12/( /88 R I R rl njak 12(
/88 RI I ilson 12/ (q/88
.ch
(> <'l'
ENCLOSURE 1
LIST OF ATTENDEES NRC M.
C.
G.
B.
H.
G.
R.
G.
T.
D.
0.
FPL Ernst, Acting Regional Administrator, RII Hehl, Deputy Director, Reactor Projects Division, RII Lainas, Assistant Director for Region II Reactors, NRR Wilson, Branch Chief, Reactor Projects Division, RII Berkow, Project Director, Division I/II, NRR Edison, Licensing Project Manager, NRR Butcher, Senior Resident Inspector, Turkey Point L.
W.
C.
A.
N.
E.
C.
Schenebli, Resident Inspector, Turkey Point F. McElhinney, Resident Inspector, Turkey Point R. McGuire, Chief, Physical Security Section, RII M. Masnyk, Physical Security Specialist, RII C.
W.
H.
D.
C.
J.
J.
R.
H.
F.
D.
L.
J.
W.
J.
T.
S.
R.
G.
S.
H.
0.
F.
J.
A.
A.
S.
E.
J.
N.
H.
A.
W.
Arias, Regulation and Compliance Supervisor L.
W.
A.
T.
J.
M.
D.
T.
- Bladow, QA Superintendent
- Kappes, Maintenance Superintendent Finn, Training Department Superintendent Hale, Fngineering Project Supervisor
- Earl, QC Supervisor Smith, Services Manager - Nuclear Farrell, Licensing Engineer Young, Project Site Manager Woody, Executive Vice President Conway, Senior Vice President Dager, Vice President - Assistant to President
- Sager, Acting Vice President - Nuclear Operations Pell, Executive Assistant to VP - Nuclear Operations Odom, Site. Vice President - Turkey Point
- Cross, Plant Manager Acosta, Director, Quality Assurance
- Paduano, Manager, Nuclear Energy Services Southworth, Technical Department Supervisor Chancy, Director - Nuclear Licensing
- Pearce, Operations Superintendent
OO fi
ENCLOSURE 2
NRC/FPL MANAGEMENT MEETING AGENDA PTN NAB First Floor Conference Room 9:00 AM to 12:00 PM November 14 1988 TIME ITEM PRESENTER 9:00 AM Opening Remarks J.S.
Odom M. Ernst NRC 9:10 AM 9:20 AM 9:45 AM 10:00 AM 10:30 AM 10 45 AM 11:45 AM Plant Status Equipment Issues
-Equipment Malfunctions During Shutdown of Unit 3 Spent Fuel Pool Spill Drawing Update BREAK Maintenance
-Improvements
-Control Room Tags
-Maintenance Effectiveness (PM vs'M)
-Rework Closing Remarks J.E.
Cross J.E.
Cross F.H. Southworth L. Craig J.W.
Kappes J.S.
Odom M. Ernst-NRC 12 Noon LUNCH Note:
The afternoon agendas are provided separately.
ENCLOSURE 3
MEETING
SUMMARY
This was the eighth management meeting between the licensee and NRC since issuance of the Confirmatory Order in October 1987.
Although the previous meeting was in August 1988, the NRC SALP presentation of September 21, 1988 fulfilled the scheduler coranitments of meeting on a relatively frequent basis.
Mr. Arias provided a brief update on the status of the Tech.
Spec.
project.
FPL. developed 458 comments on the Proof and Review copy of which 220 comments were of a technical nature.
NRR's response to these comments is due on January 6, 1989.
Mr. Cross discussed the plant status.
Unit 3 was in day-45 of an outage that was originally caused by an RHR pump seal leak.
- However, many other problems developed; the most significant of which was insulation migration of the main generator rotor windings.
Unit 4 is in a refueling outage and is defueled.
The licensee plans to use the Unit 4 generator rotor in Unit 3 and send off the Unit 3 rotor for repair.
The equipment issues discussed by Mr. Southworth included; the RHR pump seal
- failure, PORV stroke
- time, pressurizer heater and insulation failure, pressurizer spray valves, snubber
- failures, degradation of LP turbine flow
- guides, accumulator level transmitters, and debris fretting of a Unit-4 fuel element.
Mr. Southworth also provided an update on the recent spent fuel pool spill and a summary of the report from the Event Response Team.
Mr. Lance Craig, Manager of Nuclear Engineering Support Services, described the recent problems and planned corrective actions with the facility drawings.
This issue was recently raised by the Resident Inspectors due to several operational incidents involving incor rect drawings and is further discussed in Inspection Report 88-30.
The licensee acknowledged that many Non-Conforming Reports (NRC's) that were generated by the Design Basis Reconstitution Program had not resulted in drawing updates.
The Enercon Report also notes a large backlog of required drawing changes.
Mr. Craig described the planned program to identify and correct the required discrepancies but stated that the program was not scheduled for completion until May 1989.
Mr. Cross stated that neither unit would be restarted until he was satisfied that the drawing discrepancy issue was fully understood and interim measures taken as necessary to ensure safe plant operation was not affected by critical drawing discrepancies.
Mr.
Kappes discussed the status of maintenance program enhancements.
These included a Conduct of Maintenance
- Document, a Critical Components
- Program, the Nuclear Job Planning
- System, and the results of an INPO Maintenance Assist Team visit.
The control room green tags had been reduced to 130 with a year
Enclosure 3
end goal of less than 100.
The Corrective Maintenance backlog was 905 with a year end goal of less than 700.
The Preventive Maintenance ratio was 20% in April, 40% presently and targeted goal is 60%.
In his closing remarks, Mr. Odom stated that major progress had been made this year in root cause determination, accountability and "fixing it right the first time."
Mr. Ernst stated that the NRC planned to continue these management meetings but would probably extend the frequency.
J