ML17298A907

Forwards Operations Experience Base,Consisting of Experience Tables for Presently Licensed Personnel.Inadequate Number of Personnel Meet 6-wk Hot Participation Experience Requirement

ML17298A907
Person / Time
Site:	Palo Verde
Issue date:	03/23/1984
From:	Van Brunt E ARIZONA PUBLIC SERVICE CO. (FORMERLY ARIZONA NUCLEAR
To:	Harold Denton Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
NUDOCS 8403290236
Download: ML17298A907 (32)

Text

R ACCESSION NBR;840 FACIL:STN"50 528 STN 50 529 STN 50 530 AUTHeNAME VAN BRUNTiE,ED REC IP ~ NAtlE DENTONiH ~ Rq EGULATORY

• '<FORMATION'DISTRIBUTION SY EM (RIDS) 3290236 DOC BLOATED 84/03/23 NOTARIZED (ES D

Palo Verde Nuclear Station~ Unit ii Arizona Publi Palo Verde Nuclear Stationi Un)t 2g Arizona Publi 05000529 Palo Verdi Nuclear Stationr Unit 3i Arizona Pub'li 05000530 AUTHOR AFFILIATION Arizona Public Service Co ~

RECIPIENT AFFILIATION Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulationi Director

SUBJECT:

Forwards operations experience base<consisting of experience tables for presently licensed personnel'nadequate number of personnel meet 6

wk hot participation experience requirement.

DISTRIBUTION CODE:

M003S COPIES RECEIVEPgLTR ENCL SIZEe=

17 TITLE: Operator Requalification Program NOTFS: Stander di zed pl ant.

Standardized plant ~

Standardized plant.

05000528 05000529 05000530 RECIPIENT ID CODE/NAME NRR LB3 BC COPIES LTTR ENCL 1

1 RECIPIENT ID CODE/NAME LICITRAi E ~

COPIES LTTR ENCL 1

1 1

1 1

1 EXTERNAL: ACRS NRC PDR NTIS 08 10 10 02 1

1 1

INTERNAL:

N FS/LQB EG FI 04 LPDR NSIC 03 05 NRR/DHFS/OLB 01 RGN5 2

1 1

1 1

1 TOTAL NUMBER OF COPIES REQUIRED:

LTTR 21 ENCL 21

(v

~4 v

aV f

lI 'I n

II

~

I a

f

, Ilv a

)

M a>>

r

)MI'I M

v I M A

~

1 a

~

~

4

'I!)fItalian II af

)

'I a wf M

fM

il~MII a

M '() f t,f )4 a

II

'l II

)f) r pi I )

f f fMMMM 'i,

)ta M

')

a I"

~

tl a'lilt, "y)

~ )alt Jl r) fl r

I M

a

Arizona Public Service Company P.O. BOX 21666

~

PHOENIX, ARIZONA 65036 March 23, 1984 PVNGS-EEVB-L84-03 Mr. Harold Denton, Director Office of Inspection

& Enforcement U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.

C.

20555

Subject:

Palo Verde Nuclear Generating Station (PVNGS)

Units 1, 2 and 3

Docket Nos.

STN-50-528/529/530 File:

84-056-026; G.l.01.10

Dear Mr. Denton:

As requested by Mr.

Donald

Schnell, we are forwarding the Palo Verde Operations Experience base for the Commissioners and staff review.

The appropriate experience tables have been completed and are attached.

These tables are completed for all presently licensed personnel, as well as personnel expected to be licensed by the Unit I fuel load.

This experience data is current through February, 1984.

Concerning the nuclear plant experience portion of the proposed requirements, Palo Verde has a sufficient number of presently licensed personnel who meet or exceed these requirements to allow manning Unit I.

It is anticipated that some of those personnel who do not now meet this portion of the experience requirements will have spent sufficient time on-shift to allow them to meet this requirement by fuel load.

As far as the "hot participation" portion of the requirements is concerned, Palo Verde has individuals who were previously licensed on a

BWR facility and spent at least one year as an operator on shift.

Palo Verde feels that this experience satisfies the six month "hot participation" requirements, when coupled with the fact that these personnel will have been trained on a plant specific simulator, spent considerable time on-shift, and ultimately obtained an SRO license.

Palo Verde believes that these personnel are preferable to the use of on-shift advisors.

Additionally, there are an inadequate number of personnel who meet the six week "hot participation" experience requirements.

Palo Verde intends to correct this deficiency by sending the personnel to operating facilities to participate in hot plant operations.

This will be accomplished prior to fuel load.

PDR ADOCK 05000528 A

PDR Lj or<

I I

PVNGS-EEVB-L84-03 Mr. Harold Denton Page 2.

Pl It is noted tha t the

' ttached package change following a more thorough review Xs preliminary and is subject to of records and documentation.

Very truly yours, E. E.

Van Brunt, Jr.

APS Vice President, Nuclear ANPP Project Director EEVB/dh Attachment c:

Mr. Hugh Thompson Mr. Donald P. Schnell

0 0

It I

I

March 23, 1984 PVNGS-EEVB-L84-03 STATE OF ARIZONA

)

) ss.

COUNTY OF MARICOPA)

I, Edwin E.

Van Brunt, Jr.,

represent that I am Vice President, Nuclear, of Arizona Public Service

Company, that the foregoing document has been signed by me on behalf of Arizona Public Service Company with full authority to do so, that I have read such document and know its contents, and that to the best of my knowledge and belief, the statements made therein are true.

- E Edwin E.

Van Brunt, Jr.

Sworn'to before me thie oLJJf day of 1984.

I 4

My Commission Expires:

My Commission Expires April 6, 1987 Notary Public

0 I

DATE March 15, 1984 Palo Verde UTILITY 'rvice o L DATE

November, 1984 NUCLEAR POHER PLANT EXPERIENCE FOR OPERATING SHIFT POSITIONS (NOTE 1)

WEIGHTING MAXIHUH TYPE OF EXPERIBI'CE FACTO CREDIT OPERATING SIIIFT EXPERIEHCE Shift Supervisor SRO License (NOTE 2)

ENTER DATA'ONTIIS/HONTHS X WEIGHTING FACTOR P. Wiley

2. J. Dennis 3. R. Vali 1 4

e Niedermeyer SAHE TYPE COMMERCIAL SRO OTIIER COMHERCIAL SRO SAME TYPE COMMERCIAL Ro OTHER COMMERCIAI RO NAVY (HILITARY) NUCLEAR (Ro, EWSp EOOWg PPHS)

(OTHER)

SIMULATOR (REFERENCE PLANT)

(S IHILAR)

NUCLEAR PLANT EXPERIENCE (LESS TIIAN 1 1/2 YEARS (HORE TIIAN 1 1/2 YEARS LICENSED CLASSROOM TRAINI (OWH PLANT) i 1 ~ 00 NO LIMIT

.i

"--' 75 !;,."=. NO LIMIT

-i le 00 ".=.;=-', No LIMIT 0 75-NO LIMIT 36 MONTHS

. -.-::.'.'.50.',.'~"

, 0.25 12 HONTIIS

..':"- '-',5.00

=

(1,2 MONTIIS) 3 ~ 00.

(9 MONTHS)

ON SHIFT (OHN PLANT) 24 MONTHS PRIOR TO F Li) '--

0 ~ 75

(12 HONTIIS)

PRIOR TO F L.). ~... '. 0 ~ 50 (12 MONTHS)

NG AND EXAM

".. '+50

9. MONTHS 60/45 48/36 72/27 1 5 17/11.25 13.7 6.85 7/7 15/15 1 5 17/11.25 13.7 6.

20 20 9/6.75 72/19.25 18/12 36/27 72/33 14/8.25 PARTICIPATION AT OPERATING PLANT OTHER NUCLEAR PLANT EXPERIENCE.

CONDUCTING LICENSE TRAINING DEGREE (ENGINEERING, APPLIED SCIENCE EQUIVALENT)

(BACIIELORS DEGREE)

(ASSOCIATES DEGREE) 0.75

'2 0.25

=-'-

=. 12 i

~ ', 0.25';,

~

- 9 12 (12 (6

MONTHS MONTHS MONTHS MONTIIS MONTIIS)

MONTHS) 60/12 22/5.5 9/2.25 3/2.25 24/6 TOTAL NUCLEAR PLANT EXPERIENCEt 223.7/134.1 113.7/57.1 53.7/44.1 113.7/45.35 178.7/9

.6 TIME >

20 Ii PHR/8HR (HXS)

STARTUP

& SHUTDOWN (YES/NO)

MONTHS ON SHIFT HOT PARTICIPATION EXPERIENCE Previously Licensed-See above See Footnote

$/1 See Footnote I/3 See Footnote i/4 12(pwr) weeks 28 weeks es Yes

Previously See Footnote Licensed -

//2 See.above

~216 weeks See Footnote Yes

$/1 NOTE Is NOTE 2 Q

a.

Shift advisors must be used to satisfy the "hot participa-r~q~i~~m~~ts of th Q

b.

Shift advisors willprobably be required, at least for some shifts.

Q o.

Do not plan to use shift advisors unless some unforeseen circumstances arises.

INCLUDE ALL SIIIFT SUPERVISORS

~ (SS)

SHIFT SRO'S REACTOR OPERATORS (Ro)

AND SIIIFT TECHHICAl ADVISORS (STA)

SEE "I STRUMIONS FOR USE OF NUCLEAR POWER PIAHT EXPERIENCE FACTORS FOR CHECK ONE OF TIIE FOLLOWING OPERATIHG SHIFT POSITIONS (OL APPLIChNTS)" '

E4 I

DATF, March 15, 1984 Palo Verde UTZLITY OPERATItlG O.L.

DATE ervice

November, 1

em er.

984NvcLEAR PDNER P'ANT ExPERIENcE FOR OPERATIHG SHIFT POSITIONS

{NOTE 1)

~

SIIIFT EXPERIENCE Jos TZTLBs Shift Supervisor SRO License (NOTE 2)

MOH'/MONTHSX WEICHTZNC FACTOR WEIGHTING MAXIMUM FACTOR CREDIT TYPE OF EXPERIENCE SAME TYPE COMMERCIAL SRO OTHER COMMERCIAL SRO ShllE TYPE COMMERCZAL Ro OTHER COMMERCIAL RO LIMIT':,

LIMIT;.v~

LIMIT..'.

1 ~ 00 '-.. '.NO 1,00 i,', No 0 75 'o

~:..;- "36

.:-..-,,0.50.

0.25 12 5.00'l0 NAVY (MILITARY) NUCLEAR (Ro, CWsp BOONE PPWS)

(OTHER)

SIMULATOR

{REFERENCE PLANT)

(SIMILAR) 3+00..;

(9 NUCI,EAR PLANT EXPERIENCE OH SHIFT (OitH PLANT) '4 (LESS TIIAH 1 1/2 YEARS PRIOR To F.L )

. 0 75

{12

{MORE THAN 1 1/2 YEARS PRIOR TO F Lo).:.. 0.50 =-...(12 LICENSED CLhSSROOM TRAIHINC AND EXAM g

~ 50

=:

9 (OWN PLANT)

PARTICIPATION AT OPERATING l LANT,

".: 0.75 ' '2

....".';"-,-'.25 '""-12 i

'I

.':::i-i 0 ~ 25';,'

~ 9 DEGREE (BHCItlEERING, APPI IED SCIENCE OR

'~ "~=-."

EQUIVALENT) 12

{BACHELORS DEGRFE)

(12 (ASSOCIATES DECREE)

(6 OTIIER NUCLEAR PLANT EXPERIEHCE CotlDUCTINC LICENSE TRAIHIHC

~

~

LZIIZT MONTHS MONTHS MONTHS)

MONTHS)

MOHTHS MONTHS)

MONTHS)

MOHTHS tlOHTHS MONTHS MONTHS,"

MONTHS MONTHS)

MOHTHS) 1.M.

96/28.5 96/24 72/18 1/5 1/5 17/11.25 21/13.25 22/13.5 13.7/6.85 13.7/6.85 4/12 48/12 i ~

Halpin

2. S. Ryan

3. D. Ensi n 4

TOTAL NUCLEAR PLANT EXPERIENCEs 84 7/65 85 131.7/49.1

. 156.7/55.35 TIME +

20>

PWR/8'lR (WXS)

STARTUP S

SHUTDOWN (YES/tlo)

MOHTHS OH SHIFT HOT PARTICIPATION EXPERIENCE i *\\

ee footnote 5

yes NOTE ls NOTE 2s Shift advisors must be used to satisfy the "hot participa tion experience" requirements of the utility plan.

Shift advisors willprobably be required, at 1east for sow<

shifts.

Do not plan to use shift advisors unless some unforeseen circumstances arises.

ItlCLUDE ALL SHIFT SUPERVISORS (SS) g SHIFT SRO'S

~

REACTOR OPERATORS

{RO)

AHD SHIFT TECHNICAL ADVISORS (STA) ~

Q b.

Q o.

SEE INSTRVCTIOIIS FOR USE OF NUCLEAR POWER PLANT EXPERIENCE FACTORS FOR CIIECX ONB OF THB FOLLOWZNGs OPERATINC SHIFT POSITIONS (OL APPLICANTS)"

~ )

~

II ~-

~ I

~ '

~

~

~ ~

~ '

~ '

~

~

~

~

I

~

~

~

~

~

~ '

~

~

~ ~

~

~ t

~

~ ~

~

~

~

~

t

~

I

~

~ '

~

~

~

~

~

~ 1

~

~

~

0

~

~

~ '

~ '

~ ~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

l '

~

~

~

~

~

~

~ '

e

~

~~,

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

II

~

~

~

~ '

~ ~

~ '

~ '

~

~

~

~

~ '

~

~

~ ~

~

~ ~

~

~

~

I

~

~

~

~ '

~

~

I

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~ I e

~

I ~

~

~

~ ~

~

~

~ '

~ '

~ ~

~

~

~

~

~

~

r

~ I

~

~

~

~ I

~ ~

~

II ~

~

~

4

~

~

~

~

~

~ '

~

~

~

~ ~,

~

~

~

~

~

I ~

~

~

~

~

I

March 15, 1984 PLANT tIAHE Palo Verde Arizona Public Servic'e 4

NUCLEAR POWER P. AHT EXPERIENCE FOR OPERATIHG SHIFT POSITIONS (NOTE 1)

OPERATItlG SIIIFT EXPERIENCE JOB TITLEI NO IIIRO License (NOTE 2)

ENTER DATA>

HONTIIS/HONTHS X WEIGIITING FACTOR TYPE OF EXPERIENCE WEIGHTING HAXIHUM FACTOR CREDIT 1,D.

Coxon

2. D. Renn 3 S.

Zer1cel 4P. Murphy R. Betkke SAME TYPE COMMERCIAL SRO OTIIER COMHBRCIAL SRO SAIIE TYPE COMHERCIAL Ro OT)IER COMHERCIAL Ro NAVY (HILITARY) HUCLEAR

( Ro g BWS g EOOW i PPWS)

(OTIIBR)

SIMULATOR (REFEREHCE PLANT)

(SIMILAR) 0 ~75'O 36 0.50

. 0.25 P

,5.00 (12

'* '.00..'9 LItlIT MONTHS MONTHS HONTIIS)

HONTHS) i+00

=

NO LItlIT

' 75.-:.,',, HO LItlIT--

~

~

=

i+00

., HO.LIHIT.'-

72/28.25 1/5 112/43 72/19.5 1/5 108/40.5 1/5 96/27 LICEtISED CLASSROOM TRAIHING AND EXAH (OWN PLANT) 0,50 9

NUCLEAR PLANT EXPERIEHCB OH SIIIFT (OWN PLANT) 24 (LESS TIIAH I 1/2 YEARS PRIOR TO F.L,)

0,75

~ (12 (HORS TIIAN 1 1/2 YEARS PRIOR TO F.Lo):.

'a50 (12 MONTHS HOHTIIS)

~"

~

HOHTIIS)

MONTHS 17/11.25 8/4 17/11.25 8/4 17/11.25 8/4 18 12 8/4 17 11.25 8/4 PARTICIPATION AT OPERATING PLANT.

OTHER NUCLEAR PLANT EXPERIENCE CONDUCTING LICENSE TRAINIHG 0+75, 12 0.25 -'"

. 12 C

10.25;.

'.9 MONTHS HONTIIS MOHTHS 6/1.25 8/2 DEGREE (EHGIHEBRINGg APPLIED SCIENCE OR EQUIVALBIIT)

(BACIIELORS DEGREE)

(ASSOCIATES DEGREE)

TOTAL NUCLEAR PLANT EXPERIENCE<

J

~,'I 12 HOHTIIS (12 MOHTIIS)

(6 MONTIIS) 100/49

~ )

138/63.25 104/41 143/53.5 122/47 TIHE i 201 PWR/8'1R (WXS)

STARTUP S

SIIUTDO'HH (YES/tlo)

HOHTIIS OH SHIFT HOT PARTICIPATION EXPERIENCE NOTE ls NOTE 2:

/

SEE "IHSTRUCTIOHS FOR USE OF NUCLEAR POWER PLANT EXPERIEHCE FACTORS FOR OPERATING SIIIFT POSITIONS (OL APPLICANTS)"

ItlCLUDE ALL SIIIFT SUPERVISORS (SS)

~ SHIFT SRO'S REACTOR OPERATORS (RO) a, Shift advisors must be s

s must be used to satisfy the "hot partioipa AND SIIIFT TECIIHICAL ADVISORS (STA) ~

0 tion experiencen requirements of the utility plan Q

b.

Shift advisors willprobably be required, at least for so~i I

shifts.

Q o.

Do not plan to use shift advisors unless some unforeseen circumstances arises.

i 1

~

~

~ I

~

I

~

~

~ '

~

~

~ ~

~

~

~ ~

~ '

~ '

~

I

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~ '

~ I

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~:

~

I ~

~

~

~

~

0

~

I ~

~

~

~ '

~ ~

~ '

~ '

~

~

~

~ '

I ~

~

~

~

~

~ '

I

~

~

~

~ ~,

~

~

~

~

~

~ ~

~

~

DATEMarch i5 i984 PLANT NAME Palo Verde o ""'"

O.L.

DATE November l984 FOR 4

DPERATItlG Service NUCLEAR POWER P ANT EXPERIENCE OPERATING SHIFT POSITIOHS

{NOTE 1 SIIIFT EXPERIE;ICE Shift Supervisor 3-84 Exam (HOTE 2)

ENTER DATA>

MOHTIIS/MONTHS X WEIGHTING FACTOR TYPE OF EXPERIENCE WEIGIITIHG HAXIHUH FACTOR CREDIT 1.J. Scott 2.

3 ~

OTIIER COHHBRCIAL SRO OTHER COMMERCIAL RO TOTAL NUCLEAR PLANT EXPERIENCEI o

SAME TYPE COHHERCIAL SRO

. q'-'.. lo00.=...,'O LIMIT ';,

~ 75-','-..;.-'.. Ho LIHIT

-'AIIE TYPE COHHERCIAL RO

-" ':. 1400 '. ';," NO LIMIT.; ~

'o75 NO LIMIT NAVY (HILIThRY) NUCLEAR

-;;" "36 MONTHS (Ro,

CWS, BOONE PPWS)

-;~

..0.50

(OTHER),

..."; Oo25 SIMULATOR 12 HOHTIIS (REFERENCE PLANT) 5 ~ 00 ":>>, (12 HOHTIIS)

(S IHILhR) 3,00. '(9 MONTHS)

NUCLEAR PLANT EXPERIENCE Otl SHIFT

{OIAI PLANT) 24 MOHTIIS (LESS TIIAH 1 1/2 YEARS PRIOR TO F.Lo),

. 0 ~ 75

. ~

(12 HONTIIS)

(HORS THAN 1 1/2 YEARS PRIOR TO F.L ),:.

0,50 (12 MONTHS)

LICENSED CLhSSROOM TRAIHIHG AND EXAM

~: 'Oo50,.::

9 MONTHS

~.

(OWH PLANT)

~

~

PARTICIPATION AT OPERATING PLANT..:-"

0 75 12 HONTIIS OTHER NUCLEAR PLANT EXPERIENCE-

'..:~,';;'

~ 25

~e"

~

12 MONTIIS

~

CONDUCTING LICEHSE TRAINIHG 4 Oo 25'>>.

MOHTHS DEGREE (BHGINEERINGq APPLIED SCIENCE OR "4',o ':~'."

EQUIVALENT) 12 HONTIIS (BACIIBLORS DEGRFE)

~

(12 HOHTIIS)

(ASSOCIATES DBGREFo) 6 MONTHS) 72/l8 l/5 6/3.37'3.7/6.85 36'/9 l27/42.2

~ ~

TIME i 20%

PWR/B'IR (WXS)

~ SThRTUP a

SIIUTDOWH (YES/HO)

MONTHS ON SHIFT HOT Ph RTICIPATIOH EXPERIENCE See footnote 812 72 weeks.

yes 18 NOTE lt NOTE 2:

SEF "INSTRUCTIONS FOR USE OF NUCLEAR POWER PLANT EXPERIENCE FACTORS FOR OPERATING SIIIFT POSITIONS (OL APPLIChNTS)" "

INCLUOE ALL SIIIFT SUPERVISORS (SS),

SHIFT SRO'S, REACTOR OPERATORS

{RO)

AHD SIIIFT TECIIHICAL ADVISORS (STh)

~

4 4

CHECK ONE OF Tlls FOLLOWINGe Q

a.

Shift advisors must be used to satisfy the "hot partieipa tion experience" requirements of the utility plan, Q

b, Shift advisorswill probably be required, at least for son>>

shifts.

Qx o,

Do not plan to use shift advisors unless some unforeseen circumstances arises.

+l

OPERATING SIIIFT EXPERIENCE Shift Supervisor 7-84 Exam JOB TITLEs (NOTE 2)

ENTER DATAs MONTllS/MONTHS X WEIGHTIHG FACTOR DATE March 1

PLANT NAME Palo Verde UTII,ITY Arizona Public Service OrLe DATENovember 1

er, 1984 HucLEAR PDNER P'ANT EKPERIEHcE FOR OPERATING SHIFT POSITIONS (NOTE 1)

~

TYPE Of EXPERIENCE WEIGllTIHG MhXIMUM FACTOR.

CREDIT 1.R. Turner 2.Middleton 3.

ShtlE TYPE COMMERCIAL Ro TOTAL HUCLCAR PLANT EXPERIEHCEs II shME TYPE coMMERcIAL sRo

.'..'.00:-,,'.'o IIMIT':,

OrttER COMttERCIAL SRO

=..: =:",.75;-,.;.:.

~ NO LIMIT

~ " '

1,00, HO.LIMIT OTIIER COMMERCIAL Ro 0 75-',

Ho LIllIT NAVY (MILITARY) NUCLEAR

~

';.: -'6 MONTllS (ROe EWSg EOOWg PPWS)

", ~

. Oa50 (OTIIER)

- 0.25 SIMULATOR MONTllS (RCFEREHCE PLAtlT)

",5 ~ 00.'l0 MONTHS)

(SIMILAR) 3e00 -:'9 MONTHS)

NUCLEAR PLhNT EXPERIENCE ON SHIFT (OWH PLANT) 24 MOHTilS (LESS TllhH 1 I/2 YEARS PRIOR To F L )-, 0 ~75, '

(12 MONTlls)

(MORE TllhN 1 1/2 YEARS PRIOR To F Le),-:.

0 ~ 50;.,(12 tlOHTllS)

LICENSED CLASSROOM TRAINING AHD EXAM

...=,

0 ~50:

9 MOHTHS

~

.'OWN PLANT)

I

~

P PARTICIPATION AT OPERATING PLANT.

0,75; '2 flONTlls

~ P OTllER NUCLEAR PLAtlT EXPERIENCE

" '"..;.; 0,25 """. 12 MONTllS

~

COHDUCTING LICENSE TRAINING 0 ~ 25 i',

"9 MOHTHS DEGREE (EHGIHECRIHG, APPLIED SCIENCE OR EQUI VALEtlT)

. 12 MONTllS (DhCllELORS DECRFE)

(12 MOHTIIS)

(ASSOCIATES DEGREC)

(6 MOHTIIS) 42/42 1/5 5.5/2.875 13.7/6.85 36/9 132.2/102.225 48/36 12/9 60/15 1/5 10/7.5 13.7/6.85 3/2.25

.12/3

~/

156.7/85.6 TIME + 20l PWR/SWR (WKS)

STARTUP 6

SHUTDOWN (YES/No)

MOHTllS ON SllIFT HOT PARTICIPATION EXPERIENCE n

Previously Licensed See

.Above See footnote Ol s

Previously Licensed See Above ffl See footnote NOTE ls NOTE 2s Q

a.

Shift advisors must be used to satisfy the <<hot participa tion experience" requirements of the utility plan.

Q b,

Shift advisors willprobably bc required, at least for som<

shifts.

o.

Do not plan to use shift advisors unless some unforeseen circumstances arises.

INCLUDE ALL SIIIFT SUPERVISORS (SS)

SHIFT SRO'S

~

REACTOR OPERATORS (RO)

AND SllIFT TECHNICAL ADVISORS (STA) o SEC "INSTRUCTIONS FOR USE OF HUCLEhR POWER PLANT EXPERIENCE FACTORS FOR CHECK OHE OF THE FOLLOWIHG OPERATING SllIFT POSITIONS (OL APPLIChNTS)"

0

~ I

~

)

~

~

~ '

)

~

~

~

~ I

~ ~

~ '

~ '

~

~

~ )

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

I '

~

~

~

~

~

~ ~

~

~

~

I ~

e~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~ '

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~ ~,

~

~ ~

~

~

~,

~

h

0

~

II ~

~

~

~ '

~

~

I ~

~ '

~ '

~ ~

~ ~

~

~

~

~

~

I

~

~

I '

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~ ~

~

~

~

FOOTNOTES TO OPERATING SHIFT EXPERIENCE TABLES 1.

Previously licensed SRO with at least one year as a licensed RO.

2.

Previously licensed RO, includes time on shift at SONGS as Aux. Operator and as Reactor Operator.

3.

Represents time at Trojan as Aux. Operator.

4.

Represents only additional time at Prairie Island Nuclear Plant during observation training for PVNGS.

5.

Represents time at Prairie Island Nuclear Plant during observation, training for PVNGS.

6.

Represents time at SONGS as Aux. Operator/License trainee.

7.

Previously licensed RO, includes time on shift at FT. Calhoun Nuclear Plant as Aux. Operator and as Reactor Operator.

8.

Represents time at Cooper Nuclear Station as Aux. Operator 9.

Previously licensed RO, includes time on shift at Dresden Nuclear Plant as Aux. Operator and as Reactor Operator.

10.

Previously licensed RO, includes time on shift at Oyster Creek Nuclear Plant as Aux. Operator and as Reactor Operator.

ll.

Represents time at Arkansas Nuclear One Plant during Observation Train ing. for PVNGS.

12.

Represents time at Zion Nuclear Plant as Aux. Operator and includes license training for Zion Station.

13.

Total nuclear experience does not include 33.5 months as Aux. Operator at a fossil fueled power plant.

14.

Total nuclear experience does not include 36 months as Aux. Operator at a fossil fueled power plant.