ML17298A881

Forwards High Pressure Safety Injection Pump, Mechanical Environ Qualification Rept,Per Sser 5 (NUREG-0857)

ML17298A881
Person / Time
Site:	Palo Verde
Issue date:	02/29/1984
From:	Van Brunt E ARIZONA PUBLIC SERVICE CO. (FORMERLY ARIZONA NUCLEAR
To:	Knighton G Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
Shared Package
ML17298A882	List: ML17298A881 ML17298A883
References
RTR-NUREG-0857, RTR-NUREG-857 ANPP-28970-WFQ, NUDOCS 8403090012
Download: ML17298A881 (12)

Text

~t'EGULATORY NFORMATION DISTRIBUTION SY M (RIDS)

ACCESSION NBR;8403090012 DOC ~ DATE: 80/02/29 NOTARIZED: YES DOCKET FACILSSTN"50 528 Palo Verde Nuclear StationF Unit 1F Ar)zona Publi 05000528 STN 50 529 Palo Verde Nuclear Stations Unit 2< Arizona Publi 05000529

'STN"50-530 Palo Verde Nuclear Stations Unit 3F Arizona Publi 05000530 AUTH BYNAME AUTHOR AFFILIATION VAN BRUNTzE ~ E.

Arizona Public Service Co, RECIP ~ NAME RECIPIENT AFFILIATION KNIGHTONgG ~ W ~

Licensing Branch 3

SUBJECT:

Forwards "Nish Pt assure

.Safety Injection Pumpr" mechanical anvil on qua I ff fcati on reptp per SSER 5

(NUREG 0057) i~~ p DIsTRIBUTIDN coDE:

Acass coPIEs REOEIYED:LTR,J ENGL lk BIEE:

4-BC'ITLE:

OR/Licensing Submittal:

Equipment Qualification NOTES:Standardized plant ~

Standardized plant ~

Standardized plant ~

05000528 05000529 05000530 RECIPIENT ID CODE/NAME NRR LB3 BC 12 INTERNAL: ELD/HDS3 12 IE F ILE 09 NRR/DE/EQB 07 NRR RAB 06 F ILE 04 COPIES

'LTTR ENCL 1

0 1

1' 1 ~

20 1

1 ~

RECIPIENT ID CODE/NAME LICITRAFE ~

01 GC 13 NRR KARSCHrR NRR/DL DIR 1~

NRR/DSI/AEB RGN5 COPIES LTTR ENCL 1

1 ~

1 1 ~

1'm 1

1 ~

1 1 ~

EXTERNAL: ACRS NRC PDR NTIS 15 02.'1 8

1 1m 1

1'PDR NSIC 03 05 1

1

~

1 1,

TOTAL NUMBER OF COPIES REQUIRED; LTTR 25 ENCL 24

r C+

I>>

lrt'<<

' 'I C >I ~

+

r

~ 1

<)., IC

<<Itf I t',I C 'j f IC payer'>>

i I )~II I'jj I ICtr

'j 1~

'f

',I 3>>,

Ci'I ttty,I fir 1 I

h'ly "I<<

I, 1I Irjjvr C IIICI>> f I 'T'cjoy II I

fr'CIC,k I" f

>><<C r

1 >>r<< tl,'I g '<<>>

I oi e'I X

I

't j>>4 e Ic I jj,

)

c

~

'<<C<<'II I, [r r'I "pl,rcc,';y,'cI'j IIIII' I I,'IIc III;,.jest I

I I! gf,l ri II il j~tr t f <<lg I, <<j f IC C'

f"II I

II>>ll,itrgf Q>>br'IC f(t iljj jj~

f I'..'I Ij ij) I C

Ig>>I

>>rgij t

I lt I pug<<jr~ I ji lflrffijjr,gt j Pro tfr'll I

I y jlj J4 f ItIti I lr%fi~rr,ifBJf IjIIIII'I It I f II f I'$

l I ij g f I I tQ f >>C V j I I I

't I j I" f I q I

I 5 f l t'l C f >>QI" f >>I ij " 'I<>C ji ri tt.j j

>>I j II 9, I',i

Arizona Public Service Company P.O. SOX 21666

~

PHOENIX, ARIZONA 85036 February 29, 1984 ANPP-28970 - WPQ/TFQ Director of Nuclear Reactor Regulation Attention:

Mr. George Knighton, Chief Licensing Branch No.

3 Division of Licensing U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C.

20555

Subject:

Palo Verde Nuclear Generating Station (PVNGS)

Units 1, 2 and 3

Docket Nos. STN-50-528/529/530 Pile:

84-056-026; G.l.01.10

Reference:

NUREG-0857, Supplement No.

5, "Safety Evaluation Report

'related to the operation of Palo Verde Nuclear Generating

Station, Units 1, 2 and 3", dated

November, 1983.

Dear Mr. Knighton:

Appendix B,

Section 4.2(2) of the referenced document requested qualification documents for f'hree items of our mechanical equipment qualification program for audit'.

We are hereby submitting fifteen copies of the documents for your review.

If you have any comments or questions, please contact me.

Very truly yours, E. E.

Van Brunt, Jr.

APS Vice President Nuclear Projects Management ANPP Project Director EEVB/TFQ/sp Attachment cc:

E. A. Licitra (w/a)

A.

C.

Gehr H. Garg (NRC/EQB) 8403090012 840229

~':, PDR

• DOCK 05000528 "E

PDR

February 29, 1984 ANPP-2S970 UFO/TFQ STATE OF ARIZONA

)

)

as'OUNTY OF MARICOPA)

I, A. Carter Rogers, represent that I am Nuclear Engineering Manager of Arizona Public Service

Company, that the foregoing document has been signed by me for Edwin E.

Van Brunt, Jr.,

Vice President,

Nuclear, on behalf of Arizona Public Service Company with full authority so to do, that I have read such document and know its contents, and that to the best of my knowledge and belief, the statements made therein are true.

A. Carter Rog s

Sworn to before me this day of i 1984.

I p

My Commissi'on Expires:

MyCcmmf'"sfon P gfr:: ~>pry 6 gay Notary Public

h 4

4 t

o

,rl ll,,

, g)gl'7) ~

~ ~

,v 0

d

.<~>>pg,

LA p

61~ ~359 EST Fi.

15/1984

~i

~

ZCZC AN) l 3133)

PHOENIX AZc FEDFUAFY 15 1984 5182246418 TARGET RCCK CORPORATION 1966E EROADHOLLCW RDo EAST FARMINGDALE NY 11735 ATTN:

MR+

THCMAS De CRGWLEY BT AAPT-3133"JTB/MLR

SUBJECT:

ENVIRONMENTAL QUALIFICATICN OF TFC PRESSURE RELIEF VALVES F'I LE:

13-gi "691 REFERENCE<

TELEPHCNE CCNVERSATICN BETWEEN THCMAS CRO'kLEYi MARTIN RAINES AND ED GCUVIEF. CF FEEFUARY 15 1954 ~

GENTLEMEN:

THIS IS TO CCNFI FR THE REFERENCED CCNVERSATICN CCNCEFNING ENVIRONMENTAL QUALIFICATICN CF'RC SAFETY RELIEF VALVES~

APS EXPLAINED THAT AS PART OF'HE. EQUIPMENT QUALIFICATICN EFFGRT THE NUCLEAR REGULATCRY AGENCY HAD REQUESIED THAT WE SUEMIT THREE MECHANICAL ENVIRCNMENTAL REPCRTS FOR REVIEW CF WHICH TFC SAFETY RELIEF VALVES'URCHASED UNDER 13 JM 691m WERE SELECTED ~

APS STATED THAT AS PART OF THE FECRT SUPPLIEC EY TRC (FPT NO 35BCA)

WE HAD PEFFORMED AN ADDITICNAL ACING ANALYSIS TC SUPPLEMiENT

THE, TRC DATA-THE RESULTS INDICATED A QUALIFIED LIFE CF FORTY YEAFS MINIt'iUM AS OPPCSED TC THE FIVE, YEARS STATED IN SECTION 6+8'AGE 15 Cf 19'RC RPTo 3588A ~

THIS DISCREPCNCY PRCMPTED THE NRC TO REQUEST THAT APS OBTAIN CONCURRENCE fRCM TFC FCR THE

&PS C ALCULATI CN S ~

IT 4'AS FURTHER DISCUSSED THAT APS MAKES A DISTINCTION EETWEEN QUALIFIED LIFE AND DESIGN LIFE,~

FOR SITUATICNS WHERE THE RECCMMENDED REPLACEMENT INTERVAL:(DESIGN LIFE) IS LESS THAN THE QUALIFIED LlfEi APS MAKES EVERY EFFORT TC CCMPLY WITH SUPPLIER RECCMMENCATICNS.

HOWEVERS IF'ltiITATICNS CN AVAILABLE MANPOWER OR TIME CCNSTFAINTS PREVENTED REPLACEMENT WITHIN THE RECCMMENDED TIME FRAMERS THIS WOULD NOT RENDER THE EQUIPMENT UNQUALIFIEC AND CPEN APS TO A POTENTIAL NRC VIOLATICN OR FINDINGS IT WAS ALSO DISCUSSED THAT PERIODIC CPE.RAEILITY TESTING COUPLED kITH DETAILED SURVEILLANCE CF SELECTED "WORSE CASE" VALVES COULD ESTABLISH OPERABILITY CF THE REMAINING VALVES iHOSE AGE DEGRADABLE CCMPCNENTS REliAINED IN PLACE IN EXCESS CF THE DESI CN LIFE OFi REPLACEtiENT INTERVAL BUT LESS THE QUALIfI ED LIFE+

APS CCMMITTED TO TRANSMIT A COPY OF THE CALCULATICNS REVIEWED PY THE NRC VIA FEDERAL EXPRESS AND REQUESTED TARGET RCCK COFPCRATICN TC PROVIDE THEIR OPINIONS/RECCMMENDATICNS PRICR TO CUF REQUIRED

RESPONSE

DATE CF MARCH 4i 5984 TC THE NRC ~

NNNNEND TARGTROCK FDLE T

, IF YCU REQUIRE FUTHER INFORMATICN PLEASE CCNTACT MARTIN RAINES AT X682) 943-.7288'XTo 6854 ~

FOR YCUF CCNVENIENCE'UR TELEX NUMBER IS 668388-.AZ PUESVC PHX ~

VEFiY TRULY YOURS i H

E E

VPt4 BRUNT JR APS VICE PRESIDENT NUCLEAR Q

ANPP PROJECT DIRECTCR

~c EEVBJR/MLR/DH

$ o CC s Ao C ~

ROGE RS Jo Te BARROW Eo J ~

GCUVIER To Fo QUAN py V ~ i.

KEDiiili gyg$gQ g Q ]+

'8~>>

.'".P>> 23 QLJ>>

liftf t

I t

'H TT

+

PZ PUFSVC PHX't l

t H.

,I,I U INFCt' STEr-.'-887787I Cb4 82/23/Sh T4X"'Tf-t>>('-TRCCK FE LL ZCZC P34/',F~r>>t"INH.PLE, N.Y.'LF. '23 TLX 66-BOS'N PZ.'PUESVC PHX

,ATTtv:.,

t",'Ro ', f'if;,rtTIN '-Ri-',IN Eb'

~ r'T

. SUEd:'NVII>>Ct>>>>t>>>>ENIPL GU/klFICPTICN CF Trc PFE.ssUF E, rE.LILF vF Lvks I LF.:

13-dYH-691 FrF ~:

(C )

TELEPHCAk CCMVE rS<TI CN E'ETL;-I Etd T.

CFct LEY t'", ~

i'-ter E r'-cUVIk F CF FE E' IS~

1994 rflNES

, 'F )

PPS TAX 0'NPT "3133->>.'TE/Yik 8 t

TzrckT FccK=Hps rEvlLtzc YCLtp cpppc,ecH Tc EsTerLIsHINc-r-FLExIE-LE t;uNTENeNCL bCHkrULF. ~Nr: Cct CUPS rs LcN(

ns THE t cTE,C INSPECTI(;Ns FNL/GF rHVl-LUATICNS-rRE 'CGNLUCTE.L Prl cr

'1 C EXTENSI CN'F t;Pit'TENDANCE.

INTkrvrL~

E>>LYct't;, Ter<ET rccK's rLcct;tiLNr<TIcNs.

IF YGU HFVE. FUFTHLF QUESTICNh.

PLEPSt, CCNTrCT THE UNLkrSICNEr;.

t

~ I

,THCY'0S t).

CRCt LE,Y CCNTFFCT~ NF'NPCLri

.PChkt:

PFCDUCTG

'r Dc/N c.

, CC:

D ~ K ~

Vi';TE.t>>

V ~

k I PNTCNI C H

g

-TU T IYHE.:

11: CS l-'.t:.

NNblN 1132 E.ST

+

l'Z PUESVC PHX

pgAWlvbs pv8 Si<<op rnevezy c4 F

I

t 1g

'4 lf f