ML17191B192
| ML17191B192 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Dresden  |
| Issue date: | 01/07/1999 |
| From: | Grant G NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION III) |
| To: | Kingsley O COMMONWEALTH EDISON CO. |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 9901130091 | |
| Download: ML17191B192 (44) | |
Text
UNITED STATES
- NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
- *. REGION Ill
- *' 801 WARRENVILLE ROAD:* * **.
LISLE, IWNOIS 60532-4351 January 7. 19.99 Mr. Oliver D. Kingsley President, Nuclear Generation Group Commonwealth Edison Company ATTN: Regulatory Services Executive Towers West Ill 1400 Opus Place, Suite 500 Downers Grove, IL 60515
SUBJECT:
DRESDEN MANAGEMENT MEETING
SUMMARY
Dear Mr. Kingsley:
The NRC staff met with Commonwealth Edison and Dresden Nuclear Power Station management on December 15, 1998. This management meeting was held at the Dresden Station and was open to public observation. Enclosure 1 contains the associated meeting summary. Enclosure 2 contains the handout provided by Commonwealth Edison during the meeting.
In accordance with Section 2.790 of the NRC's "Rules of Practice,* Part 2, Title 10, Code of Federal Regulations, a copy of this letter and its enclosures will be placed in the NRC's Public Document Room.
Docket Nos.: 50-237; 50-249 License Nos.: DPR-19; DPR-25
Enclosures:
- 1.
. 2.
Meeting Summary Meeting Handout See Attached Distnbution
~~1130091 990107
~
p ADOCK 05000237 PDR Sincerely,
~~f~~
~11reJ J~ Gra0. o;~J,,
Division of Reactor Projects I I;
January 7, 1999 Mr. Oliver D. Kingsley President, Nuclear Generation Group Commonwealth Edison Company ATTN: Regulatory Services Executive Towers West Ill 1400 Opus Place, Suite 500 Downers Grove, IL 60515
SUBJECT:
DRESDEN MANAGEMENT MEETING
SUMMARY
Dear Mr. Kingsley:
The NRC staff met with Commonwealth Edison and Dresden Nuclear Power Station management on December 15, 1998. This management meeting was held at the Dresden Station and was open to public observation. Enclosure 1 contains the ~ssociated meeting summary. Enclosure 2 contains the handout provided by Commonwealth Edison during the meeting.
In accordance with Section 2.790 of the NRC's "Rules of Practice," Part 2, Title 10, Code of Federal Regulations, a copy of this letter and its enclosures will be placed in the NRC's Public Document Room.
Docket Nos.: 50-237; 50-249 License Nos.: DPR-19; DPR-25
Enclosures:
- 1.
- 2.
Meeting Summary Meeting Handout See Attached* Distribution Sincerely, Isl Geoffrey E. Grant Geoffrey E. Grant, Director Division of Reactor Projects DOCUMENT NAME: G:\\DRES\\DRE12158.SUM To receive a copy of this document, indicate in the box "C" =Copy w/o attach/encl "E" =
Co w/attach/encl "N" = No co NAME Lerch/
DATE 01/b /98 OFFICIAL RECORD COPY
- 0. Kingsley cc w/encls:
D. Helwig, Senior Vice President H. Stanley, PWR Vice President C. Crane, BWR Vice President R. Krich, Vice President, Regulatory Services DCD - Licensing M. Heffley, Site Vice President P. Swafford, Station Manager F. Spangenberg, Regulatory Assurance Manager R. Hubbard M. Aguilar, AssistantAttorney General State Liaison Officer Chairman, Illinois Commerce Commission Distribution:
SAR (E-Mail)
RPC (E-Mail)
Project Mgr., NRR w/encls J. Caldwell, Riii w/encls C. Pederson, Riii w/encls B. Clayton, Riii w/encls SRI Dresden w/encls DRP w/encls TSS w/encls DRS (2) w/encls Riii PRR~/ ncls PUBLIC 01 w/encls Docket F e w/encls GREENS IEO (E-Mail)
DOCDESK (E-Mail)
- Jf
Public Meeting Summary Management Meeting for Dresden Nuclear Power Station December 15 Management Meeting Summary:
This management meeting was conducted as a part of continuing, periodic oversight of the performance of the Dresden Station. The most recent past public management meeting on Dresden was conducted on October 1, 1998, at the Region Ill regional office and was largely focused on operator cognizance of Technical Specification requirements and maintenance department issues.. This December 15, 1998, meeting was primarily centered on plant performance, material condition, and functional area review in operations, maintenance, engineering and plant support. The licensee discussed how the capacity factors for the units were very good compared to past performance. The licensee noted that the power history curves showed better material condition to be better during the last part of 1998 when compared to the first part of 1998~ Similar performance with respect to automatic scrams was noted. Other performance indicators, such as unplanned capability loss factor and unplanned entries into limiting conditions for operations, also showed positive trends. The licensee presented information regarding non-outage corrective maintenance, system health, and maintenance rule status to show that material condition was improved. Within the functional areas of operations, maintenance, engineering, and plant support, the licensee presented information to show that performance was generally good and improving. Within the specific area of engineering, the licensee presented some candid discussions regarding areas that required improvement, and admitted the difficulty in establishing goals and standards to show improvement. The licensee concluded by stating that it considered its performance in operations and in nuclear oversight to be good and to show that its programs and processes were well established.
The licensee presented information contained in the applicable handout in Enclosure 2 during the meeting.
1
Partial List of Attendees:
J. Dyer, Regional Administrator, Region Ill G. Grant, Director, Division of Reactor Projects S. Reynolds, Deputy Division Director, DRS K. Riemer, Senior Resident Inspector, Dresden M. Ring, Chief, Branch 1, DRP, Riii D. Roth, Resident Inspector, Dresden Commonwealth Edison L. Aldrich, Radiation Protection Manager J. Almon, Training Manager S. Barrett, Operations Manager W. Beck, Quad Cities Regulatory Affairs S. Butterfield, NRC Coordinator P. Chabot, Site Engineering Manager C. Crane, Vice President BWR T. Eason, Operations Training R. Freeman, Engineering Manager R. Fisher, Maintenance Manager M. Heffley, Site Vice President K. Ihnen, Nuclear Oversight R. Johnson, Risk Management Engineer R. Kelly, NRC Coordinator
- 0. Kingsley, President Nuclear Generation Group K. Kociuba, Executive Assistant R. Krich, Vice President, R~gulatory Services K. Langdon, Executive Assistant W. Lipscomb, Jr., Site Vice President Executive Assistant R. Osgood, Site Commission Coordinator M. Pacilio, Outage and Work Control Manager R. Quick, Assistant Security Administrator R. Rybak, Licensing Administrator R. Spangenberg, Regulatory Assurance Manager P. Swafford, Dresden Station Manager J. Tietz, Outage Director G. Waldrep, NGG Nuclear Oversight D. Winchester, Nuclear Oversight Manager R. Schulz, Section Chief 2
Com Ed Management Meeting Handout
I*
- I.
~-
ComEd Dresden Nuclear Power Station
. NRC Management Meeting December 15, 1998
Meeting Agenda D Plant Performance Review D Material Condition D Functional Area Review
- Operations
- Maintenance
- Engineering
. *:*Plant Support D Closing Remarks P. Swafford P. Chabot S. Barrett R. Fisher P. Chabot L. Aldrich M. Heffley
I.
Plant Per/ ormance Review
. Preston Swqfford Station Manager
Station Capacity Factor 90o/o 80%.69.8 ******-
70°/o 60°/o 50°/o 40°/o 30%,
20°/o 10%
0%
1997 JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC I* Dual Unit
- Unit 2 *Unit 3 I
0 Dec-97 Jan Feb RBC(
l\\t1ar-98 Apr-98 l\\t1ay-98 D2!='~,
Jun 021 Jul Aug-98 o~
Sep Oct Nov-98 Generator Output (MWe) w 8
~
0 0 (J) 8 l).cl'lii~ ~ :>flic I -~
.~
I -
~--- - _..
1,,.,..,, 1
- l">--
~ <*-* --
\\II L..c~ k * !:.lr!I ll.'ell£ri *ry o: ~R1 5
~ **Tr-.1 ~fc Nl'I' r P.ebu 3~ -E HG Pr~ !:;::it.ire f~'-G cri.c:r~~~ ~cro~ rid RRP I\\ IGbr~ 'h1~pl 181Cerrr::1rt
~
- s.
.::: =-
L..I.....
t f
'ill~
....-i-t J
I co 0 0 c
- o en N
Dec-97 Jan-98 Feb-98 Mar-98 Apr-98 May-98 Jun-98 Jul-98 Aug-98 Sep-98 Oct-98 Nov-98 Generator Output (MWe)
~
~
W
~
~ m
~
~
~
I 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
~
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
~
I::;( 1htior. :-ond~ n.;c:*T c ~tinq
-~
-[i
- ii **..
II -*
RI ~P*MG Bru:Sh
~irrs1,
l.:OO? ot:::i.
~*Jr -*~ilklri. c-:::, ~[:) ~ !c\\*cl ::imtch ~ P.f! ?-Pu~i:: ~Yl::ll!) ~
D3f.2~ -PCI uroui P.chv
- ~
D3P ~2- * *rr Q:'1:::~0:1 ncr R~1 )h11c~rrr M 03f.2"(' '.r::11111::: orr:ic: Co :>lir. ; Con~ ol
~I 26C.ol R~ ll::11l*1c
.J t -,
Cc<.p1 ::it.::iil!o* 'f'rod*:: W'lp'!X~ ~rbir.c ld:ff ~re 1tir,! ex )::llf'l~O C'V/J:' r.ip ~i:: /dbc!'t Q:q ~*\\"::II *1c
,J l
I
Dresden Station Automatic Scrams per 7000 Critical Hours
- 2.5 -
i 1.5 1997 JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC
...._____.! 1997 Industry Top Quartile Year End Pro*ection Unit 3 Unit 2
- * * *
- Unit 3 Industry Median Year End Projection Unit 2
==--- Dresden Station Un pl a n~ed Entries In.to LCOs ~7 Days 1997 JAN FEB MAR APR IVIAY JUN JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC
--* 1997 Rolling 12 Month LCO's
2.0 -
1.8 1.6 s 1.4 0 I-
.c 1.2 c
0
- !E 1.0 N
Q.5 0.8 0
0::
0.6 0.4 0.2 0.0 Dresden Station Sa/ ety System Actuations 0
m 1997 JAN FEB MA APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC c:::::::J 1 9 9 7
~Site Goal
--.- 12 Month Rolling Actuations
_._ Ind u st rv Ave r a a e
Dresden *Station Unplanned Capability Loss Factor 25 J
0 1997 JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC 1997 Unit 2
- -.. - - Un it 3 Industry Top Quartile Perfo rmance Year End Pro *ection Goal
Material Condition Peter Chabot Site Engineering Manager
Material Condition Template LONG TERM PLANS B u1ine11 Plan J - Year Pla n J - Y ear Plan e
OUTCOMES SUPPORTING INDICATORS 1ti;i:) :iht~cN.> <
- .. Sy ii*~,,;
- A<:~i~l(j(ii)i:I\\::.
~<i~1h.ill~<>iri tfo\\:
- ..::::::::.::: ;.::::: ~:~~#~Cia~~*~=i:f((
r;.;;.,,.;;'""""'~;L-,,--,----..,.~
Syslem Window Perform a nee
- ~~:;.~~~,~~ *.}/
Non-Outage Corrective Maintenance Backlog 1400................................. *******................................................................. *****-* *..........
1200
...... _................... _... _... _..... _..... __.. __.. _... _... _. _. _... _. _. _... __. ________. _... -D-__... __..
Good 1000 800 600 400 200 1997 JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC CJ 1997
-Actual
--Goal I
SHIP 20..
15..
Projection 10..
5..
0 May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr I RED System Overall D YELLOW System Overall
30 r'-l 25 e
. ~
r'-l
~ 20 r'-l
~
15
~
0 a..
10
~
~ e =
5 z
0 Jan Maintenance Rule Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug
- Site (a)(l) Systems in Monitor Status
- Site (a)(l) Systems in Action Required Sep Oct Nov Dec December projection
v
=-----*Material Condition Issues D Scram I Derates t:J Feedwater Control
- D Control Rod Drives
- MCIP oRWCU
- D Main Power Transformer
- Logic Mods *
- !* Half Scrams o HPCI Point-to-Point
- !* System Walkdowns
- !* Review all LERs since-1/95 o 250 VDC a(l) Plan D Recirc MG Set
- D Off Gas
- .:.Indicates D3R15 Act_ivity
I
- i.
Functional Area Review Operations
- Maintenance Engineering Plant Support S. Barrea R. Fisher P. Chabot LAldrich
l Operations Steve Barrett Operations Manager
I
\\.**
- Operations*
o Current Performance
- Senior Operations Management Involvement
- 117 Days Without a Missed LCO
- NLO Performance
Operations DFocus Areas:
- Main Control Room Distractions
- Mentor Operating Personnel to be More Self~Critical
- Equipment Attendant to Equipment Operator Upgrade Training
- IL T and NLO Class.
/
I.
Maintenance Robert Fisher Dresden Maintenance Manager
i
--- Maintenance D Current Performanc*e
- Corrective Maintenance Backlog Reduction
- Performance Centered Maintenance (PCM)
- Implemented
- Strong Work Control Process Established
I -.
j I
Percent Schedule Adherence Completions Within 8 Hours 100-----~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
90....... ___________________________
80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 o~-.----r~.-----.------r~.--.----.~-r----.--r-~,.---r-----~..--~--'--o-~~
~-~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
- ~#~##~~#~~~~~~~~~~
~$~~~~#~~~~~~~~~~#~
v v
~
~
~
~
~
~
~
~
~
~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~
~
-GOAL.
->-ACTUAL% I
I I
--*Maintenance*
D Focus Areas
- Outage to Online Transition
- PM I Surveillance Completion
- Rework Data Analysis. *
- Independent Verification
I.
j Engineering Peter Chabot Site Engineering Manager
r '
Engineering o Current Performance.
- Decrease in Number of Maintenance Rule a(l) Systems
- Decrease in Engineering Request Backlog
- Improved Support to Operations D Focus Areas*
- Engineering Product Quality (Calculations)
- Updating Analyses to Current Ind~stry Standards (FPFI)
- Resolution of Long-Standing Material Condition Issues
- . (HPCI, Off Gas)
I.
Plant Support Lary Aldrich RadiaBon Protection Manager
Plant Support
- Radiation Exposure is INPO 2nd Quartile
- Implementation of Security Defense.Strategy is Effective (Some Industry Best Practices)
- Station Personnel Safety Record (ISAR)
D Focus Areas
- Chemistry - Improve Department Adherence to
~ Standards and Program Ownership - Procedure Adherence
- Radiation Protection - Improve Station Adherence to RP Procedures
- t:=
500 450 400 c
350 CD 300 Q. e CD 250
- 0::: c 200 0
If)
- 150.
Q. -
CD 100
- J
~
50
- a.
)(
w 0
Dresden Exposure History Dresden Station Yearly Exposure Peformance (Per Unit) 1998 Goal 220 Rem/Unit
-1998 Stretch 200 Rem/Unit 1998 Projection -
198 Rem/Unit Year
Closing Remarks Mike Heffley Dresden Station Site Vice President
Dresden Nuclear Power Station Ma*terial Condition Supporting Indicators
Dresden Station Control Room Lit Annunciators a
7 6
5
";::l -.. --
-c 4
- 3
~ = -* 3 z
2 1
0
- DRES2/3 Cl GOAL
250 200 1 5 0 1 0 0 50 0
Dresden Station Main Control Room Distractions JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JU L AUG
- rem pAlts **
C o n tr o 11 e rs 1
Dresden Station PM Status 5
4 0 *c Cl)
Q.
Cl)
CJ e 3
(!)
Cl)
.s::. --
Cl) ca Q.
2 Cl)
- IE Q.
0
- a:
0 JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC
- Past Grace Period Goal
1 0 0 c
CD 90 80 I:! 7 0 CD
- n.
60 50 40 Dresden Station PM/CM Ratio JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC
--PM 1C M 1998 G 0 AL 3000 2750 2500 2250 2 0 0 0 ~
u 1750-g I'll II) 150 0 ~ -
0...
1250_8 E
- I 100 0 z 750 500 250 0
Dresden Station Operator Work Arounds 45 40 35 in
'C c
30
- II e i!:
25 0
3:...
0 -
f!
20 G> c.
0 c
G>
1 5
- c.
0 1 0 5
0 1997 JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC C::::=:l'1 9 9 7
~Work Arounds
---Site Goal
60
.5 (j Cl) 40 0
- iE I I-...
0 30 Cl>
.c E
- s z 20 1 0 0
Dresden *station Temporary M odijications z
<(
CD w LL a::
<(
~
a::
a..
<(
<(
~
z
- J
.....J
- J a..
w Cf)
I-()
0 0 z
-TotalT-Mods ---Goal _.,_Unit3
_._Unit2
()
w 0
~-
Material Condition
~---
Supporting Indicators o Indicators to be Developed *
- !*RED & YELLOW System Action Plans
- !* System Window Performance
- !*Equipment Failures
- !* Leaks and Leak Repairs
- !* Repeat Maintenance
.. e