ML17156A796

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
2016 Monticello Nuclear Generating Plant Initial Licensed Examination Facility Post Examination Materials Transmittal Letter
ML17156A796
Person / Time
Site: Monticello Xcel Energy icon.png
Issue date: 12/02/2016
From: David Reeser
NRC/RGN-III/DRS/OLB
To:
Nuclear Management Co
Reeser, David
Shared Package
ML15274A427 List:
References
Download: ML17156A796 (13)
v • d • e


Text

{{#Wiki_filter:Facility Post Examination Materials Transmittal Letter (Applicant Q&A, Post Exam Analysis/Comments)

2807 West County Road 75 Monticello, MN 55362 (}, Xcel Energy* 800 .895.4999 RESPONSIBLE BY NATURE xcelenergy.com L-MT-16-065 December 1, 2016 10 CFR 55.40 Mr. David Reeser, Region Ill Addressee Only U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 2443 Warrenville Road Suite 210 Lisle, IL 60532-4352 Monticello Nuclear Generating Plant Docket 50-263 Renewed Facility Operating License No. DPR-22 Operator License Post-Examination Documentation Reference 1: NUREG-1021, Operator Licensing Examination Standards for Power Reactors, Revision 10 Pursuant to the requirements of Reference 1, Section ES-501 , "Initial Post-Examination Activities ," the Northern States Power Company, a Minnesota Corporation (NSPM), doing business as Xcel Energy, is providing the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) with the required post-examination documentation . The post-examination documentation was developed as a result of the completion of the NSPM grading and reviews of the Reactor Operator and Senior Reactor Operator License written examinations completed on November 18, 2016, at the Monticello Nuclear Generating Plant. The following information is being provided in this letter: Written Examination Performance Analysis , Written Examination Cover Sheets and Applicants Ungraded and Graded Answer Sheets, Questions and Answers Given During the Written Examination, and Completed NRC form ES-403-1. The examination grading and review was performed in accordance with Reference 1, Section ES-403, and "Grading Initial Site-Specific Written Examinations." Form ES-201-3 is not fully completed at this time. NSPM will submit the completed original form ES-201-3, "Examination Security Agreement," in accordance with Reference 1, Section ES-501 . RECEIVED DEC 0 2 2016

L-MT-16-065 Page 2 Summary of Commitments This letter makes no new commitments and no revisions to existing commitments. 

~~

Peter A. Gardner Site Vice President, Monticello Nuclear Generating Plant Northern States Power Company - Minnesota Enclosures (5) cc: Robert Orlikowski , USNRC , Region Ill (w/o enclosures) - Written Examination Performance Analysis - Written Examination Cover Sheets and Applicants Ungraded and Graded Answer Sheets - Questions and Answers Given During the Written Examination - Completed NRC Form ES-403-1 - Candidate Written Exam Feedback & Station Response RECEIVED DEC 0 2 2016

ENCLOSURE 1 WRITTEN EXAMINATION PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS 3 pages follow

Page 1 2016 NRC Stats.xis Question Average (D/I) 

                       .... Qi
                                   £

{! "' OJ

a. .E s:"'
                             ro 2

Question Key a: J: ~ Cl) 1 b b b b b b 1.000 2 c c a c c c 0.800 3 a a a a b b 0.600 4 d d d d d d 1.000 5 c c c c c c 1.000 6 b b b b b b 1.000 7 b b b b b b 1.000 8 b b b a b b 0.800 9 d d d d d d 1.000 10 c c c c c c 1.000 11 c c c c c a 0.800 12 c c c c c c 1.000 13 a a a d a a 0.800 14 d c d d d d 0.800 15 a a a a b a 0.800 16 a a a a a a 1.000 17 a a a d a a 0.800 18 b b b b c b 0.800 19 a a a a a a 1.000 20 c c c c c c 1.000 21 c c c c d c 0.800 22 b b b b b b 1.000 23 c c c c c c 1.000 24 c c c c c c 1.000 25 d d d d d d 1.000 26 c c c c c c 1.000 27 c c c c c c 1.000 28 c c c d c c 0.800 29 d d d d d d 1.000 30 c c a b a c 0.400 31 c c c d d c 0.600 32 c c c c c c 1.000 33 c c c c a c 0.800 34 b b b b b b 1.000 35 d d c c b d 0.400 36 c c c c c c 1.000 37 c c c c c c 1.000 38 b b b b b b 1.000 39 b b b c c c 0.400 40 c c c a c c 0.800 41 d d d d d d 1.000 42 b b b c b c 0.600 43 d d d d d d 1.000 44 c c c c c c 1.000 45 a a a a a a 1.000 46 d a d d d d 0.800 47 c d c d c c 0.600 48 a b a c a a 0.600 49 a a a a c a 0.800 11/29/2016 1 of 3

Page 2 2016 NRC Stats.xis Question Average (D/I) 

                       ....Q)     Qi
a. Ill Ill £ .....

Question Key Q) a: t:: Cl)

c
                                       ~
1E
                                            *e CJ)

Ill Q) 3: 50 c c c c c c 1.000 51 c a c b c d 0.400 52 b a b b b b 0.800 53 d d d d a b 0.600 54 c c c c c c 1.000 55 d d d d d a 0.800 56 b b b b b b 1.000 57 a a a a a a 1.000 58 b b b b b b 1.000 59 d d d d d c 0.800 60 a a a a a a 1.000 61 c c c c c c 1.000 62 b b b a b b 0.800 63 d d d d d d 1.000 64 c c c c c c 1.000 65 b b b b b b 1.000 66 c c b a a a 0.200 67 c a c b c a 0.400 68 b b b b b b 1.000 69 b b b b c b 0.800 70 b b b b b b 1.000 71 c c c c c c 1.000 72 c c c c c c 1.000 73 a c b b a a 0.400 74 a a a a a a 1.000 75 a a a a a a 1.000 76 d d d d d 1.000 77 b b b b b 1.000 78 c c c c c 1.000 79 b b b b b 1.000 80 d d d d d 1.000 81 c c c a a 0.500 82 a a a a d 0.750 83 d d d c d 0.750 84 b b b b c 0.750 85 b b b b b 1.000 86 b b b b b 1.000 87 b b b b b 1.000 88 d d d d d 1.000 89 b b b b b 1.000 90 b b b b b 1.000 91 d d d b b 0.500 92 a a a b a 0.750 93 c c a c a 0.500 94 a a a d a 0.750 95 b b b b b 1.000 96 d d d d d 1.000 97 a a c c a 0.500 11/29/2016 2 of 3

Page 3 2016 NRC Stats.xis Question Average (D/I) 

                                        ...Cl>     Qi I/)    I/)      £ 0.

Cl> t:: ca 

                                                          ~         .E       I/)

Cl> Question Key a: :r: ~ en ~ 'a'~~ ~ 98 lc.t¥ ~ a..Y ~y 1~......a- 1.000 ~i.13 99 c c c c c 1.000 100 a a a d a 0.750 l~'Z.q\l'- Total 92 93 76 82 65 0.859 Grand Total 100 100 100 100 75 0.860 Exam Average (%) 92.0% 93.0% 76.0% 82.0% 86.7% 0.859 RO 89.3% 93.3% 77.3% 82 .7% 86.7% 85 .9% I SRO 100.0% 92 .0% 72.0% 80.0% 86.0% 11/29/2016 3 of 3

ENCLOSURE 2 WRITTEN EXAMINATION COVER SHEETS AND APPLICANTS UNGRADED AND GRADED ANSWER SHEETS 15 pages follow

ENCLOSURE 3 QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS GIVEN DURING THE WRITTEN EXAMINATION 2 pages follow

c?f-F  ? 

                                                               /ft!. -{&:c/      /I /ltJrJJra/

5/anlly /111 t? ;,1(>  ;::ttYJ'I o.:L/1 a h/))tPL !111tJ( cct"i/r/s *; !~5 'di Yfhl1s Re_[ vesfiB  : -/./attl c! A~ ;;.vs 

                                                     ~ro

//J3 d3 ,;;, er* ) , (/{,,, h I uJ. fl 7 ,.1 

                                                              /~:1 1.
//J.q   33                E?..s  "'/) '      /)

i/ !1f(k, ' l/

//1-/ s I I I [ /d1 Ir l ,~, r 1. /J,,- ' 

                           /
                             ,.,,., n /

ry.1, t' II , .. I l

ENCLOSURE 4 COMPLETED NRC FORM ES-403-1 1 page follows

ENCLOSURE 5 CANDIDATE WRITTEN EXAM FEEDBACK & STATION RESPONSE Cf\clos0re \eJYVlOlX?~ ON'-~Co(\Us l >"IC o" yc>m.\-e c\ i.Jr..\o £ x<V>' * "' \d= 1?e Fr-+ c;_ 1 

     ~ '?os~ E ><CM'V' 1 \1\tt~tc)y-.. Co~ma>1.Js

[Ju.)~ 104 pages follow}}

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML17156A796&oldid=2438864"