ML17053A765
| ML17053A765 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Nine Mile Point, FitzPatrick  |
| Issue date: | 05/04/1979 |
| From: | Harold Denton Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| To: | Fitzgibbons J OSWEGO, NY |
| Shared Package | |
| ML17053A767 | List: |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 7906290701 | |
| Download: ML17053A765 (26) | |
Text
DISTRIBUTION:
. ENTRAL FILE PSS READING P-.,433 MAY 4 ]979 EDO READING GERRTER (EDO-5650)
MGrcff HDenton LVGossick ECase
~~ 7~-~+~~
'r.
John E..Fitzgibbons VStello KCor/e11 tlayor of Oswego PCFine
- Oswego, NY 13126 DNCrutchfield DFBunch
Dear Nr. Fitzgibbons:
LPQQ
~ pic.
PQQ
.Your letter of March 15, 1979 to Chairman Hendrie has been referred to me for reply.
Shutdown of the FitzPatrick nuclear power plant in New York State was ordered by the NRC on Naech 13, 1979, because of, questions about the ability of the piping system to withstand earthquakes.
Our'objective is to review the situation in an expedited and dis-ciplined manner so that the FitzPatrick plant can be returned'to
" operatidn with assurance that this will not constitute a threat to the public health and safety.
We are mindful of the economic hardships that can occur as a
result of plant shutdowns and will work as hard as we can to avoid-any unnecessary delays in'ringing the plant back on line.
Sincerely, Qrlgtnat Signed BY Roger S. BoVd arold R. Denton, Director Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation q 9{j6'F98 ~
SEE PREVIOUS YELLOW COPY FOR CONCURRENCES NRR:PSS **
orr<as~
OUANANR~
OATC~
PCFine:sl 4/
/79 SEC PORbf 3lS g9-76)
&@LCD 0248
~
NRR:PSS:D **
NRR'PSS **
EDO NR:DD ~,.
J RR:
- EGC, H
e on
.DNCrutchfiel
~
~ ~
~ 0 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
5/
/79
~ I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
DFBunch 5/
/79
~ ~
\\
~ ~ ~
~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
5/ q/7,9
/79 5/'79 Q'U S 4OV4flNM'CNTrlllN7ltIOOrrlCR( 1ST ~
1I ~ ll1
~ 0 ~ ~
~
l 4
~
~\\
II P
P Y~ 4803~8 isnighQ bY~G.8 >ogoR
'"1q h
V I
t1r. John E. Fitzgibbons Mayor;of Oswego
- Oswego, NY 13126 o
Distribution Central files PSS r/f P-43 EDO r/f GErrter g 0-5650)
MGroff/
,CFine DMCrutchfiel d DFBunch
Dear Mr. Fitzgibbons:
Your letter of March 15, 1979 P Chairman Hendrie indicated that the.NRC had closed the Nine f1e Point nuclear power plant.
.The plant has been down for no al refueling, not because of any action by the NRC.
Shutdown of the:FitzP rick nuclear power plant in Hew York State was ordered by the HP on March 13, 1979, because of questions about the ability f the piping system to withstand earthquakes.
Our objective is o review the situation in an expedited and disciplined many r so that the FitzPatrick plant can be returned to operation wi'th assurance that this icillnot constitute a threat to the publi health and safety.
Sincerely, Harold R. Denton, Director=-
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
'RR:DD
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
'GCase NR
- SS:D
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ o
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
d DF u ch
""'4'j'-'79"
'RR:PSgpg N
PCFine:mmt
'D tchfi 4-""y"-"/9"""""'""'4'-"$-'79""'
~
o ~
~
~ ~
~
OPrPrlcd~
'VRNAMd&
OAVd~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ o4o ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
o 79o
~
o
~
~
RRC PORhf 318 (9-76)
NRQNC 0240 v.~. oovaooacaav pawaao oep icai i ~ p ~ - Roe - neo NRR:D EDO HRDenton
~ ~ ~ ~ o4o ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ o79 o ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~ o 4o
~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~7po
~
I
r IP 4
(
I sf lki I
4 ~
~I 4
~
sl I
r)
Ogyy4 UNITED ST S
NUCLEAR REGULATORYCOMMISSION WASHINGTON,D. C. 20555 A-A.
~c M8
~ic 2,.
c)&8~3 r
g ~78 72
t 4r
~
~j C
FROM:
'a~
mo Va SC@t5 C~I,5$Kkf'FOJCCtkiQ CCSFR NHk ACTION CONTROL COMPL DEADLINE ACKNOWLEDGMENT INTERIM REPLY FINALREPLY F ILE LOCATION DATES NTROL NO.
ha 07650 DATEOF DOCUMENT
'$9o)~ 79 PREPARE FOR SIGNATURE OF:
Q CHAIRMAN Q EXEC+TIVE DIRECTOR OTHER:
DESCRIPTION I3'LETTER Q MEMO Q REPORT Q OTHER
~="-~. copies ef rags. m "as 5A'l0."
CY@gf5g. tL" 1Q)Fa.~it% 4 ~Q580!JJ Fe e~tnge ee Mr.'-e N)c. 1 SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS OR REMARKS DOCUMENT/COPY NO.
NUMBER OF PAGES POSTAL REGISTRY hlO.
CLASSIFIED DATA CLASSIFICATION CATEGORY Q
NSI QRD Q FRD ASSIGNED TO:
DATE I
FO ATION ROUTING LEGALREVIEW Q
FINAL Q
COPY 7
NQ,".IQf'gP."L ASSIGNED TO:
DATE NO LEGALOBJECTIONS NOTIFY:
Q EDO ADMIN& CORRES BR EXT.
COMMENTS, NOT IFY:
EXT.
JCAE NOTIFICATION RECOMMENDED:
Q YES Q
NO NRC FORM 232 (1 1-75)
I EXECUTIVEDIRECTOR FOR OPERATIONS PRINCIPAL CORRESPONDENCE CONTROL DO NOT REIIIIOVETHIS COPY
I
FROM:
.TO;";a E. FfhagkY @~la eGJVV Qf ~5&~Qp fee
~ m ACTIONCONTROL COMPL DEADLINE ACKNOWLEDGMENT INTERIM REPLY DATES C'588 Q DATE OF DOCUMENT g
TO:
Ql@$ $~& p~$y~)~~
FINALREPt Y F I LE LOCATION
~lv /7 PREPARE FOR SIGNATURE OF:0 CHAIRMAN Q EXECUTIVEDIRECTOR DESCRIPTION Q I ETTER Q MEMO,Q REPORT Q OTHER SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS,OR EMARKS
' V~~ ~ l f.t >wgg Of gbL+ Q~%Pgw Q g Qf a$ ra Vale Riot DOCUMENT/COPY NO.
NUMBER OF PAGES POSTAL REGIS RY NO.
CLASSIFIED DATA CLASSIFICATION CATEGORY Q
NSI QRD Q FRD S."GY B<<Ã2 ASSIGN TO:
g~ "
DATE 3 2L-f9 INFORMATIONROUTING LEGALREVIEW DATE ASSIGNED TO:
Q F'INAL Q
COPY NO LEGAL OBJECTIONS NOTIFY:
Q EDO ADMINSc CORRES BR EXT.
COMMENTS, NOT IFY:
EXT.
JCAE NOTIFICATION RECOMMENDED:
Q YES Q NO NRC FORM 232 Ill-75)
EXECUTIVEDIRECTOR FOR OPERATIONS PRINCIPAL CORRESPONDENCE CONTROL DO /I/OT REA/OVE THIS COPY
I'I t
i II I
I t
/
Ill
'a
'I
'I I
FROM:
4C;,~p, C Ffg~ih~QZ,S f~~Wwh'f ~98pOg Icg Vi ACTION CONTROL COMPL DEADLINE ACKNOWLEDGMENT INTERIM REPLY
- DATES W,g CONTHP LlgO.0585Q DATE OF DOCUMENT TO CIZ8P~M PAAR't0 FINALREPLY I FILE LOCATION I
"'I PREPARE FOR SIGNATURE OF:
Q CHAIRMAN Q EXECUTIVEDIRECTOR OTHER:
DESCRIPTION Q,LETTER Q MFMO Q REPORT Q OTHER SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS OR REMARKS e zc'-pa~ Fk'f~kCC Qf i4"- 'S-""~~ 9 @~
4$ t " ')$h'I'6)PP DOCUMENT/COPY NO.
NUMBER OF PAGES POSTAL REGISTRY NO.
CLASSIFIED DATA CLASS IF ICATI0 N CATEGPRY Q
NSI QRD Q FRD S"Gi 7S t'SSIGN TO:
ears r'ATE INFORMATIONROUTING LEGALREVIEW Q
FINAL Q
COPY ATE ASSIGNED TO:
NO LEGAL OBJECTIONS NOTIFY:
Q EDO ADMIN8cCORRES BR EXT.
COMMENTS, NOTIFY:
EXT.
JCAE NOTIFICATION RECOMMENDED:
0 YES 9 NO NRC FORM 232 (1 1-75)
EXECUTIVEDIRECTOR FOR OPERATIONS DO NOT REIÃOI/E THIS COPY PRINCIPAL CORRESPONDENCE CONTROL
1 T
, r 1
1,
FROM:
r,Q~Qf'f 9$4e~p ~a e+
TO:
C.'f~k B@3I'F f@
ACTIONCONTROL COMPL DEADLINE ACKNOWLEDGMENT INTERIM REPLY FINALREPLY F ILE LOCATION DATES CONTROL NO.
ace DATE OF DOCUMENT PREPARE FOR SIGNATURE OF:0 CHAIRMAN Q EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR DESCRIPTION P LETTER Q MEMO Q REPORT P OTHER SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS OR REMARKS DOCUMENT/COPY NO.
NUMBER OF PAGES POSTAL REGISTRY NO.
CLASSIFIED DATA CLASSIF ICATI0 N CATEGORY Q N%
QRD QFRD
$ -6,V X~ A'"~
ASSIGNED TO:
~a<I 443 DATE ghat xg INFORMATIONROUTING NO LEGALOBJECTIONS NOTIFY" Q EDOADMINS CORRES BR EXT.
COMMENTS, NOTIFY:
EXT.
DATE ASSIGNED TO; LEGALREVIEW.-
Q FINAL Q
COPY JCAE NOTIFICATION RECOMMENDED:
Q YES Q
NO NRC FORM 232 (11-75)
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR FOR OPERATIONS PRINCIPAL CORRESPONDENCE CONTROL DO NOT REIÃOVE THIS COPY
ll
\\
Date ROUTING AND TRANSMllTALSUP TO: (Nome. office symbol, room number, building, Agency/Post)
P ik.
1.
E u
- concu Dato
)~/p Case concur De ion roval s Re vested ircuiate mment Coordination File For Clearance For Correction For Your Information Investigate Justl Note and Return Per Conversation Prepare Repl See Me Signature l.
All comments received on first draft have been picked up with the exception of D.
G. Eisenhut's concern regarding the necessity of the last paragraph on page 2.
Two organizations have expressed a preference for inclusion:
A.
I&E (with 'OELD concurrence) continues to feel that a "get off my turf" statement would reduce the potential of being requested to provide testimony in state
- hearings, and B.
The 'N. Y. State Dept of E'gergy is presently formulating policy on Post THI minimum safety requirements and has expressed an interest in the NRC's direction.
DO NOT use this form as a RECORD of approvals, concurrences, dlsposals, clearances, and similar actions FROM: (Name, org. symbol, Agency/Post)
P. Polk S041-102 Qu.s.oporrsrc-o-scr-C4riSSS4 Room No.Bldg.
338 Phone Np)B72 OPT10NAl FORM 41 (Rev. 7-76)
Prescribed bv OSA FPMR (41 CFA) 101-11.206
C
~
q l3 P
Cq
..'. 79-2882 NRC SECRETARIAT Logging DateM/2QZ9 TO: g Commissioner H Exec. Dir./Oper.
0 Cong. Liaison Q Public Affairs 0
Date 0
Gen. Counsel 0 Solicitor Q Secretary James Warden Fromm a e OnSumer rO eCt1 On Oar Ch11k 7
re c
s of re concern1n draw1n re
~ Prepare reply for signature of:
0 Chairman 0 Commissioner 0 EOO,.GC, CL, SOL, PA, SECY 0
Signature block omitted 0
Return original of incoming with response X%0 For direct reply' For, appropriate action 0
For information 0
For recommendation OCA to Ack, Remarks:
Suspense:
Nov 5 Bee'd Oft E)p.l
< /
T'm Cpy to: DSB' For the Commission; 1
le Hnc42 Send three (3) copies of reply to Secy Mail Facility ACTION SLIP
L
~
v
~ '>
V9-0492 Logging Date NRC SECRETARIAT Q Commissioner
'XI'(Exec. Dir./Oper.
0 Cong. Liaison Q Public Affairs Date 0.Gen. Counsel 0 Solicitor O Secretary Incoming;
~
h Fi bbO 'a Or I
From:
To;
Subject:
issues'ate XGk Prepare reply for signature of:
CJ Chairman 0 Commissioner XXG EDO, GC, CL, SOL, PA, SECY Q
Signature block omitted
,0 Return original,of incoming with response 0
For direct reply' For appropriate action Q
For, information Q
For recommendation Suspense:
-March 29 Remarks:
s:
RF
- y. <<-5 For the Commission:
'Send three I3) copies of reply to Secy Mail Facility NRC42 ACTION SLIP
~
H h
FROM:
,'hn$ q,i, ~Hs 8'.$ )8~')gi)faFk.
TO:
ACTIONCONTROL COMPL DEADLINE ACKNOWLEDGMENT INTERIM REPLY FINALREPL'It
~~
FILE LOCAT OIi,
~/,
DAj'ES CONTROL NO.O 5 2 7 DATE OF DOCUMENT q
PREPARE FOR SIGNATURE OF:
Q CHAIRMAN Q
EXECUTIVEDIRECTOR OTHER:
~~
DESCRIPTION Q LETTER Q MEMO Q REPORT Q OTHER 849, fBfO WI'fQPQQQQ 'JA94Q.lOOOA Of 8
)ale iGvc) N4)04cHvQ vhscQ fAc'fpklÃRFL
.8;:a ter; P@iAC a ir>qv$m@ $f he can@>i'~
- v. ) $Q'iC8B c'pp~gQSC't:R45MAC SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS OR REMARKS S
P~
CQS Qf l'CS(~W kQ SKI)C 49 4..8 JQ>zd'o'Qd Ar."8 'A7 4, FAQBAOP Ce)~Ken DOCUMENT/COPY NO.
CLASSIFIED DATA CLASSIFICATION NUMBER OF PAGES POSTAL REGISTRY NO.
ASSIGN 0;
%ljp I4 DATE-CATEGORY Q
NSI QRD Q FRD INFORMATIONROUTING
$bRage E
LR IEW DATE ASSIGNED TOr Q
FINAL Q
COPY NO LEGAL'OBJECTIONS NOTIFY:
0 EQO ADMIN8 CORRES BR EXT.
COMMENTS, NOTIFY:
EXT<
JCAE NOTIFICATIONRECOMMENDED: '
Q YES Q No
- NRC FORM 232 Ill-751 EXECUTIVE DIRE OR FOR OPERATIONS PRINCIPAL CORRESPONDENCE CONTROL DO NOT REAIOI/k THIS COPY
II 'I
FROM:
e".i,FV)es K~ t+~3$.
'iAa~l~3 p".ale, Pa.
TO:
y','IhC ACTION CONTROL COMPL DEADLINE ACKNOWLEDGMENT INTERIM REPLY FINALREPLY FILE LOCATION DATES
,/ >/
CONTROL NO.O 5 2 7 DATE OF DOCUMENT PREPARE FOR SIGNATURE OF:
P CHAIRMAN P
EXECUTIVEDIRECTOR OTHER:
~
DESCRIPTION P LETTER Q MEMO P REPORT P OTHER
"'1i" lAt F'Q yf5$4CQ 4Ni4Clf@jQA4
)~~ 'jest~'i gN.:fQ>"gva @"'"~w 5'"cSQRWARQP ~4 4f.,z j';))
Pe$ r4 4 4equ4rw ff >".. caw vsse" 4 4$ ~z$ 0LQ ~c.PP@k~~vQ faCOii~a~v94 SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS OR REMARKS RM cps Qf f~sgccA+ hQ ss~)C 49 pQ~@pgg QgQ pf $ QQ~Qp C,e'femf.
DOCUMENT/COPY NO.
NUMBER OF PAGES POSTAL REGISTRY NO.
CLASSIFIED DATA C LASS IFICATION CATEGORY P
NSI P RD P FRD ASS IG NFD".TO.'ATE INFORMATIONROUTING E AL R IEW P
FINAL P
COPY
~A 1% t<
Fa>phd ASSIGNED TO:
DATE NO LEGAL OBJECTIONS NOTIFY:
0 EOO ADMIN8 COR RES BR EXT.
COMMENTS, NOTIFY:
EXT.
NRC FORM 232 (11-751 JCAE NOTIFICATION RECOMMENDED; P YES Q NO DO NOT HEI//OI/E THIS COPY EXECUTIVEDIRECTOR FOR OPERATIONS PRINCIPAL CORRESPONDENCE CONTROL
79-0110 NRC SECRETARIAT Logging Datet~22 TO: 0 Commissioner XXKXExec. Dir./Oper.
0 Cong. Liaison Q Public Affairs Date 0
Gen. Counsel 0 Solicitor O Secretary Incoming:
From:
To:
Subject:
level radsoac
~ve waste 0
Prepare reply for sign'ature of:
0 Chairman 0 commissioner 0 EDO, Gc, CL, SOL, PA, SECY 0
Signature block omitted 0 Return original of incoming with response XX'ordirect reply'uSpenSe; Jan.
31 0
For appropriate action 0
For information 0
For recommendation emarks:
i-i/,>=- --
to Docket For the Commission:
'Send three (3) copies of reply to Secy Mail Facility NRC42 ACTION SLIP
1