Text

Comment (00685) of Ray Lutz on Behalf of Citizens Oversight, Inc. on PR-51, Waste Confidence - Continued Storage of Spent Nuclear Fuel
	ML13360A358
Person / Time
Site:	San Onofre
Issue date:	12/20/2013
From:	Lutz R; Citizens Oversight Projects (COPS)
To:	; NRC/SECY/RAS
	SECY RAS
References
	78FR56775 00685, NRC-2012-0246, PR-51
	Download: ML13360A358 (18)
	v • d • e

1 Rulemaking1CEm Resource From:

RulemakingComments Resource Sent:

Thursday, December 26, 2013 9:43 AM To:

Rulemaking1CEm Resource

Subject:

FW: Waste Confidence Comments from COPS Attachments:

COPS Comments On Waste Confidence DGEIS.pdf DOCKETED BY USNRCOFFICE OF THE SECRETARY SECY-067 PR#: PR-51 FRN#: 78FR56775 NRC DOCKET#: NRC-2012-0246 SECY DOCKET DATE: 12/20/13 TITLE: Waste ConfidenceContinued Storage of Spent Nuclear Fuel COMMENT#: 00685

Original Message-----

From: Ray Lutz [1]

Sent: Friday, December 20, 2013 4:44 PM To: RulemakingComments Resource Cc: shutsanonofre@citizensoversight.org; SCG-Team

Subject:

Waste Confidence Comments from COPS RE: Docket ID No. NRC-2012-0246 Please accept the attached PDF/A document.

THANKS!

Ray Lutz Citizens' Oversight CitizensOversight.org 619-820-5321

Hearing Identifier:

Secy_RuleMaking_comments_Public Email Number:

711 Mail Envelope Properties (377CB97DD54F0F4FAAC7E9FD88BCA6D0014433C4A0ED)

Subject:

FW: Waste Confidence Comments from COPS Sent Date:

12/26/2013 9:43:13 AM Received Date:

12/26/2013 9:43:15 AM From:

RulemakingComments Resource Created By:

RulemakingComments.Resource@nrc.gov Recipients:

"Rulemaking1CEm Resource" <Rulemaking1CEm.Resource@nrc.gov>

Tracking Status: None Post Office:

HQCLSTR01.nrc.gov Files Size Date & Time MESSAGE 677 12/26/2013 9:43:15 AM COPS Comments On Waste Confidence DGEIS.pdf 184512 Options Priority:

Standard Return Notification:

No Reply Requested:

No Sensitivity:

Normal Expiration Date:

Recipients Received:

!"#$

%&'()*

*

+*,##, #+

&-(.(

/(&0.(-.(.

%1(023(.3,

,

#+

/4(&&(5!(6(!5((!7(!

89(4!4:%(&26;<:%2;=8(023(.3,

,

#+.)&&6456(!(&(5!!.

>(4(!(!&(!(3,6((!

&!).

/:%2;(!(66(!!(&!(66(!./(&!

!6(!(8&&(&!.89?&

!66(!36(6((6(36(&.@(

(&(5(!56(&(6(6(

44(4!466(&((&5(6&6&5(

&!5(46(((&,64

5.@(4(6(6(&&(66(4(6&((

6(!755(&!(&&4&56(!

!!&&.!&(6(&!8:8%2;(

(5(&!(5(.94!6((!(6&(

(((&0(4(!6(((!?6&4!

4&(4;(43&:;(<;3:;=!!105

!&8A(&0)866(((&!(45(&!

A

B

+

#

B

+

$

B

+

?&6(&!4((7&.A)(066(.

2.<)&(0(5A('8A;8=B

<=

&5(6((5(44;(&4(.>((!!!&

!5((4;(43&:;(<;3:;=!(

.

A;(!6&(6((4&(&!

4!&((!54!!.A;!5&(&!(,,

(!(&6544(!!(&(5&(&&!(44&!

(!!6(4;(43&A(5A&&!

((4!((.)8(&((((;(48

<;=&6&4(A&C&((<AC=((

(;3:;<2. ,

=!3&(((/&A(!

<3/A,,). , ,

D

=5(&.A;&(4&!6((

&!7;3:;

.

1((?65((5350(57((4!

!&!(&(0(!66(6&.)&(5&

(?5&(6&545(4((!6(&

(.

/!(8)!6((6(4((!(

3.890(8(8(!5'((

((6488!5B

&(4&6&(((

((44&!(((((44&868(6(!.

/3;44!3&2!(!(?(6(.

95(&!64(!!(&(&!6&8(8!&(

8!87&45&&(((48685&&(((.4(4

((0((!.C8!8(6!((4(

A

B

+

#

B

+

$

B

+

!(((4(68(!(8

!((4&((!6((

44!&,,(6(&,,!'.90(55!

3;44!!(5(&!!!(&(064(

6&.

A&4(&&566(8!68(!

!(8(.8

9!!!(4!&(!(5!!&4(

(?!!(

.;5(((

!((&.

2(&(554(2!6!;61&;(2&&(<(&&

2;1;2=!;61&A((&<4=5&&66(6!6(&

(44(6(83&96(8<39=./5(!6(,

((6(&6&46(5(6(!.<2((A;

!;AC5&((&((5!(6((.=

. )!(6:%2;?39(&!72%3;%)>%3>%3/6(

(&&!!(&!((39?(4(

!46(!.2:%2;05(?6!&(!4

6(!./(6((66(6(

!!&(.

. /(((!(4((,645!44

6439.9?6?6&((45&&!((!!

(!&5,64./(((46&(((

!(((6&.)&&(4(&!

!&(4:%2;5&&0(5?&55&&&0&

!((&4(,64(.1(?6&( .B8/6((8(

6 , ,+8(&!(&6((5(0(4

A

B

+

#

B

+

$

B

+

&6(56&(!&!6!((&6(6&(!

&((!(4&(&((4((!&(66&(((4

(&((&6(((!(!&!44

(!&0.8@((((((&((!.9(

;(4

,&45((?&(((5.3(5

'(?6&5&0&88!(((6&&(

!:%2;66&!5,64%2;((6&.

1(!(((4&(6(!(6&5&&0(55

&&<(!(488=(&!!?6&&.

. A,#*E/6((&((&5&&6&4(!4

6(!(4(.((&?4((

./(

(5&&(4(!(46(5

&((0.2!((6&!4(?6(!

(4!(&!&!(!((6(!5!56

((5&&.

. 6??(&6(!(:%2;&!6(

8&!4:%2;!((&(!&(8./

(&!(6(!((.

. //4;</;=(&(6&&!3/

8(&(8./:%2;(!((&(.

. /(&!3/6(.%&)%()%3/!

((&(!&(.;!4:%2;(6(!((&!

&(5((!((&(.9(.

'6&5((6!&(.25(&!&05

!(

6.@(!(F!(4((5

!(.;((&!%%/%4(6((!6&!

((0(41)/.

B. 9!(04!(A(&0)<A)=.

1(0&&&&55&!(6(&(

5&&(./(0(55&!((&(7(4

A#

B

+

#

B

+

$

B

+

!.@(&6&(05&!,,7!(&&

!./(&6&(((4G

(G#

6%>

(4&!(65,!4&!(4(6(!4

.)!(4&&(6!&!(0&&!

(6(4(((.@(&((42;H;5

!!(&39?!?!!6(!(4(!(

(6(./(!(&6&!0(4!

(439(6(.@(&((((6%>

4?!&(4&4&&&(7

(?!3<!(&=

?.

+. /(4(7!(&!4(5&&./

6(&5!(F(5&&.@(&64&4!(&!(6(4

6(4!(.8!8!5(&(

4(!&5!(&&!(4(!(!!.2

!(((!(&5(6(&(54&!

(4(((455(&!(0(45!(F!!

.1(?6&;3:;(5&!4((&(6

(4&((.>((&((6&5(!!(7&.2&

(5&&6.;(5&0&((!

(5(IA(&

J.

. A6&!6!&(4(+*39 #

<A ,#&

=(6(&((5.)05

((&&5&&('0(&39&4./!

0(!&4&6((&3/!!0!

!(4&&!66(((4!6(&(6((.

/439&&(211%&&4(!6(&(6((

!&(((0(5&!!.@C

3%%/%;2%/K2;2;H)3211%%3/2)/%/K2;A/2392/K/K%

A%>)3%3/:%:2%A;2/@A/23.

$. 2((!6(5!445!6(&(6((!39

AB

B

+

#

B

+

$

B

+

(6(6(((!(I2(?66!4(

&0@>(!(6(6(!&0?6(!(&!

5((0I4(4(&((4:%2;4&5&&

(!(6((((6(&5&

5.@CC>%3/>C;/%L%)/K%;%)3:%;M

. @((8(7(&(8<?=!(

&(8/(&6(4((46&((.8/

&(7(&(!4((4(.55&&

&(((&(56&./K%%)%

%>)2323:2;;C%;)3/K%@>C;/%%;L%.

. 9!((&!2>A)/;(4)!(;((/(

&&;>).20(5(5((!4(((

2!(F0(5(5(&6./(!6(&(6((

6(6(!((!!./K2;>C;/%;A%%C/.

. @((A,B(&(!4

1B. !8/!4:%2;!((

((43&.8!(?6!;2:3212)3/@&

56(&!!4(0!!6(5(0(!

(&&!6(!./K2;K)3:%%;K)3:%/K%2%3;%;

/K)/%N2;/)3/K%%1%%)K>C;/%;C %/%/)2%3;%

)>%3>%3/A%;;5&!(66((!7

(46&.

. 9'((:%2;!7&!!!(464

(!4((

1B. (&!!(8

6(4(!(&&!!4:%2;!(!4!

&3%A)&4(4(!64&(4&&(

5(&!(!(6&(!(&6(4(!(.8,,3M

3%A)&&&(:%2;!!(&:%3%2(M

. A;66((&:%2;,(&&!739(?!

&6!((6(!(4+

4(6&&

9(4!4:%2;A,B A+

B

+

#

B

+

$

B

+

!6(4(4(.9%3/;CAA//K%3/23/K)//K%;%)%

)1%%3C: K1C;%)1/%/K%+

,%>>2;;2323:A%2M

#. A;!((66(8A(&,&8!!(!(4

,646&(!(&%2;

44(!&5,645(!<((&4((

!0(5&!?=.

B. 9!!((4(&!&((4?6&(

(&&./(&!23C%(6(.9&(&

6!!(&(6(56(&0(5&!!(4&

4(6(&(6((?!439

3/6(!6(&(6((&.3(5&(&!

&&(5!&!&6(&(4(5!!!(6&

&(&!?!!.

+. A,*(8&(6&&!4(4((

!4!?3(((!6&(4

!&....8/5!!5!

06&4(4!6(.5!!!(&&(5

50I93:./3!(((6&&&4

!!6&(46(!.2!((4&(!

.90!!&...3(5((&&6!(

!(45!(!(,(6!!(6(&

&(!((((!?!&9K%33

C/23%N2;/;/%)92/K/K%9);/%M

. A,*&*,

(((4&6(56&&!

(6(5(&!&4((4&4&./4(&

(&!(.@((6(&4(&4((4((6(.@((

&(48((&6&.8.9&4!(

6(&((4(.)&4((4?.2

&4(5B+J(46(57(4!(!(

6(&4(%((;3:;5(&!(444(

A

B

+

#

B

+

$

B

+

(&++,(6(!(4

56&5&!!(5./

!6&3/;/%11%/2L%!3/>A%/%92/K

/K%1>;1%3%:@!K)L%);%L%%%1%/23/K)//K%@AC%

L);/OC)3/2/2%;19);/%/K)/2;%N/%>%@)3:%C;13:%

/K)3%%K2;/@.

$. !A,* B, *(7!!(.

(!(6(4:%2;.4((&(.

%2;)35(&!45((&4!

!(./(&(((4!8(

(4(68&!&(./K%;%3%3;>C;/%)%;;%)3@C

)3F/;9%%A/K%>C3%/K%C:@;)@23:/K%@)%C/1;A%MM

/!445!6(&(6((!439...@C>C;/

2;;%/K%;%211%%3%;M

*. A,

?6!!4(44&4(4&6((&(2;1;2!!((!6&

5((6M;((&((!&!(6!((6.@(!!

((!6&((6(46('?6&&!!(

(!(6((!./4?6!!4&46('

);;C>%;4&5&&(&!(6&!!((!(&!

6(&&66!!&4(4&6((&./((4&4(6((&

((6&(!0((!(.K(5(

(6((&&4&4(4&6((&5&&(!(2;1;26((

6(!(44!4(3;)L23:;!(&((46('

(&!%L%;%..?6!!492;%AC%3/!;/%11%/2L%

!4(!(!(44!445!0

!4&6((&.24((4(!055(!(70&

6&((!4!4452;1;2!1C%A;I)5

((!(&((4?6!!4(5((.

. A,+,.2(!(43C%:,#$!

82%3;23:)/23;85(&!!!(((!(5

&.)!&((!!((!

A$

B

+

#

B

+

$

B

+

&!(5((!(4&!6(.

((.

. A,#B,83&&64&(!4(64&6((&

!6&!!0(2;1;2(&+

4!(4(P

&!&44((6(.8,,)(!((;%3&

(((/&A(!(4&4(A&C&((

%&(&&2;1;2(6&&(./

&5&&&&(6<&((4((6(=&2;1;2(6&&

!((!5&&./(&((4(4(.

. A,#,B82!2;1;2(444((&!&&64&

!5&&(!!&!&44((6(.83(&.)

(4((!2;1;2(6&&!84((6(8

&(&(&!.@(((8&!&44((6(!

!((<+

=8(5(6(&&(.A&5

!((!(IA&((F(55(!

6((((.

. A, , 8/((464&!&&!4((6((4

&((!!5,64%2;4(

1AB

(

1

AB &5.8206(&(45(!.A(&(!

&6((6(5(6(&64(6(+

!2(!;%&(&&2;1;2

!((!5&&.

#. A , ,

.@((&&5(0((!4!

!!(6(6((4&!64&6((&

!(6!!.(F(6&!.@(83(!

6((74(4((!(!!!5&!(

(!4!6!!((0!4(66((4&!4:%2;3

?&(45(0!.8

/(!&066(!&&(&((4((6(

!8(7(&(8<A?=:

A*

B

+

#

B

+

$

B

+

&0(?6&(47(&(&(&

6(43(!6!(6(4./7!

(&&(6(4!5(&!

6&4.3>%);;C>A/23;A%);%M

B. A ,+,$.@(3!(!(2;1;2&.!(

D0!!&5&!4(6&.(&(5

(!55!(6(!7I245(5

!((&6(4!(!(('(4&!((

64(6(4.9K%L2%9%/K2;I

+. A , ,B(" (.

. @(&(?(/4;</;=<( ..#A ,*=

&(&(66(!6((&5(0&.

@(F&((&(!((?&(6(M2!((&!7

5,4<4&6((&=!4<&&4

(4!F(=2;1;2.2!!4(2;1;2F(,

&(!?6&51&A((&&!?(((&4&6((&

&(6&54.//;(!(!&50!

(6(!!4&!!4(64(.

96654&&!!4((((6(5(

6&&!((4(0I945!(4&&&&

?6!?&(6(!(!(6(I9

664(&0!5!(4&6((&((6&0I

1(!0!(((!&56(&&05

!(&!((&&5&./K2;2;C3)%A/)%.

$. /!&!(5!(&5&&((/;50D

(!4(/;(&.246(&5((4

&0(!&&(0

4&6((&4(4&&!.

/4(&(!!(6&(&((?6&(4

A

B

+

#

B

+

$

B

+

87(&(8(&!((?.

((74&4((6&/;(

?6&(45&!,./6(&(55(066(!(4

5(0&&5(5(.9664/;4&I(!

(&!5&&&6((&(4!(I3(!!!.

*. A ,

, 8/!4:%2;(!(&6(4(

4/;(6(!(6&6(4(&6(4(!

(.89'(0M/(&3%A/C)!(4/;.3(?.2

!!(6(6(!8(6&68&

(6&/;45&(&0&((!(

!(&4(!(F&5(&0((!(

(?45&!&6.@(F4

!!((6.

. A , + E((!8448!&45&!(&(

0!(60((44&&!4&(!

./(4864&8?&6&!6&((4

&&0(5./(?6&(46087

(&(8...5&&!(F0(555&&66(4&&4

<(

=(4(2;1;2&(!(&(4

.

. A , $#,B(3/;8(7&85(&!!(

44&.987&8,,!((54&6((&(&!

!!/K%(6(&/;&&5(0I)!

5&!6!(<&&=4&6((&06

4/;5(0((.

. A , $ , #@(!(&65(44(./!6

&(0!((8!!4(4(8....(5

A

B

+

#

B

+

$

B

+

!((!(5(&(!(I3(&!6(&&6(&(

6&.

. ;( .

8)44!%(8(!(&445(5&&(

5!66!/K%@92K)AA%3M/&((

&564(10!&!&.3((5

&0&!;/292C!(;KC(!

44!(&&./K%%3/2%/@1/K2;;%/23>C;/%K)3:%

(!!(7(4!((6(5(6(&.3((

(!((,!(6((42;1;2MMMM24(!

!4((6(&.5!!5(

(444(()23;C1122%3/M 9((6((39 4(!6(&(6((.

@C3%%/%;2%/K)/211%%3%)3%K3%;/)C//K%2;H;M

#. ;( .#898(&(%NA%/%55(

5&&.9665(66((4?6(I3(!!!.

B. ;( (&(!((44&(!(!!!

(,,.1(?6&;( .B/6(((8(&!

(&6((5(0(4&6(56&

(!&!6!((&6(6&(!&((!(4&(&

((4((!&(66&(((4(&(

(&6(((!(!&!44(!

&0.8/&?6&(46544.

+. A . $;( .+8A&!6(&K&8(!&5?6(5

(5&&5!((4(?6!!.(4

(?6!66.

. ;(#.

,,@(6(!!(!((464&2;1;25/;!

((2;1;264(6(!(4!((4

5&&444&&(6&&!!!.

9%%2%L%@C)33/)%OC)/%@)%;;/K2;2;;C%/K2;1)23

A

B

+

#

B

+

$

B

+

)L)3%./K%%>C;/3/%):%3%)ACA;%8)AAL)812;1;2

84(8(&(!((?<&0/;=!(&6&(((5

!!(.20(5(5(66(!84(8(!((

>A%/%@2%;A3;2%M

9%%2%L%/K)/)//K2;/2>%/K%2;1;2>C;/3/%)AAL%1

23%/%>23)/%/2>%A%2;!(6(((543

(.

/2>AC%3/4(3(:%2;4(?!&+

455(&(64(!((6(!.((

(((((&!!55(070&(

&6!6,(&(6((5%;K)L%4!44

(445&&(((50.

$. C!&4(&6(56&6&

!((!!(!(&!(6&5+

(4!(4

(6(./!&8(856&56&5&&!.

3(53;(#2;1;2(6(4(.

9&93:4(3(!!&(56&.

*. A#,. #;(#.*. ?6&82!4;(8242;1;2(6&&

&!(4

/K%;A%3/1C%;KC%>L%/

)3/K%)/236&&((4,6(6&(!54(5

(!(&&!(64&&55&&(&&(5(

(50./4(233);%;KC)3@,)/%2;1;2

3/23C%/A%)/%1>%/K)3

@%);M2!!(&!

6(!((66(6!&(4(;KC%

>%A%L)%3/:%2;. !9(!&% %//K%

3/236!(./44()7(3

)2%3/;(.

. A#,

E((!5(!!6(&/;.@(!!

A

B

+

#

B

+

$

B

+

((!&!?6!&06&&!(5!!(

4&(4&!!(!,64&6&&6(&!!

(.)6(56&/>)3@C3H393;!

8(&!84(:%2;(66&(6(!&((&

!((6(!.)(4((&!4/;&&!!!

(!45((55&&4&&!..

6(&23)C/)3/K%B

@%);(6&(7

.

C&((64((66!3((4

!((&&(.

. A#,$((!8&((4(8((4&

(6&.9(/;4&!!(!I/5I/

(((!/;!((6&!.!&(.

/)3);1@D9%//)3;1%>C;/%2>AL%M

. A#,$?&(4&6((&...6((&(!!(&!

!(&((4((&4(!((./(>02(

&!((!&0(10./K%;%;/C/C%;)%

C3;)1%M@(&4(1&A((&5(&&44(5&&(!

5&&(5&&(&&?&5&&(6!(4(

4(!(5.)!5!(5&&&456(&..

/)3);11C%A;)1%/@23C23: K)%3%3/)23>%3/

>C;/%2>AL%M

. A#,$#8/(&64(4&(04(((&!

4!!&.8956(&((445

(!5!!(.K(5((((

6(&(&(55!(F(5((.245!

(!4(!&50(55(&!(!4!6

&&./!((!5(!4(&46(&

66A)!(((&&(562;1;2.

1. . A#,$BB,+8/3!!6(&(44&(

0(64&6((&&(&&!&&(5.8/F6(&

A#

B

+

#

B

+

$

B

+

5!(0(9(&!/!*'0.L&(56(&.

)!&(56(&(55(&!(6&&4&&((!.

66!5.;(5('((((0(56(&(&(5

5!!0.1(((&(6(&!(

&(5!4((7&./K2;2;/K%>;/;2:3212)3//K%)/A;%

@;2/23:+*39)C3/K%C3/@&+*4(((&

&5&&&!(&'&08!(8.23F/

/K23H/K%A%3/):3922H%/K2;2%)(&2(6&&(

6(6&5(&&&&05.

B. A#,$B #,

.6(!!!!6((

((.(4((75(!6(&(4&

&!4(3(H(((&!,&!&!!4&6((&4(5&&

(!6(46(56&..2!(&(5&

3!!((&(.

+. A#,$$*, .)!!5&5&&(!4!(50.

(50!9922!66.9!((5+*39(!

5&&6.4!&6(6&!5(.

. A#,$$ #, +(!&(8/3!!

!!((6&!5((4!0(0

6(&(44&(0&(&&!&&(5.8

&&IK(5!((4(.15!(3/0(5&0&((!(45((

0(

6(!.;(6&(65'(05&&(I/(&0

3&((06(./(&5(&&((0

6(&.)5(&!56(&&(5&&66.24((&

5395&&.

" # #$ $

$. ;(.#:%2;,&)&.A;66(3@(6(!(&4(

(,<!((=4(6&./:%2;(&!(!(&&(5

&!!62;1;2(6(M AB

B

+

#

B

+

$

B

+

94!9(4!:%(&26;(45

(4(!!(6((!(((4(.A;!((66(6(&,

66(55&&5(,645(!&&(539(

6(6.966((&(4:%2;,&&!566(

66(&(4(4(,&(!393@1/K%;K//%><+

,=

!((6(!.)6((&!6(!(44,(&(5,

(!!6(&(6(((46((&(5,0!&&(56&(4&&

!((!(&&(42;1;2!&(4!((

4!(6.

/(4/;5&&(6&!6&0(6(&&(5

39((((64(

(4!4!((?!

(0(!((55(04&.C&&&?6&64(5!>C;/

&!450(55&&5(0..54.2(5(!4&

6((&(&!6!(&!(!((!&&4(.

/(((4&0&(!((&!(,,.

/&!!.

/!(!60.../39(4!6(&(

6((!(((0(4((50./K2;2;;C%)33/%%1/

C/M)!4(((5&&!!(55((&56&

!?!&(4(&!6&6&&(5>0,2(54&

6((&(!!(0!6(&(&(!&&.

A&5!()3%K3%;/(0.A&!((56

!8((4(686.

64&&;!

DD

(!

A('<A;=.

A+

B

+

#

B

+

$

B

+

ML13360A358

Contents

Text

Subject:

Subject:

Subject:

Navigation menu

ML13360A358

Text

Subject:

Subject:

Subject:

Navigation menu

Search