ML13119A041

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Attachment 1, ANP-3186NP, Rev. 1, ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-189, Rev. 1 Comparison.
ML13119A041
Person / Time
Site: Oconee  Duke Energy icon.png
Issue date: 03/31/2013
From:
AREVA, AREVA NP
To:
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
ANP-3186NP, Rev 1
Download: ML13119A041 (91)
v • d • e


Text

ATTACHMENT 1 ONS LICENSE RENEWAL SCOPE AND MRP-189, REV. 1 COMPARISON (ANP-3186NP, R1)

[NON-PROPRIETARY]

Cn9()(;L~

oc nent A

AREVA ANP-3186NP ONS License Renewal Scope and Revision 1 MRP-189, Rev. 1 Comparison March 2013 AREVA NP Inc.

(c) 2013 AREVA NP Inc.

Controlled Document Copyright © 2013 AREVA NP Inc.

All Rights Reserved

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-1 89, Rev. 1 Comparison Page i Contents Pagqe 1.0 INT R O D UC T IO N ............................................................................................... 1-1 2.0 METHODOLOGY .............................................................................................. 2-1 3 .0 C O MP A R IS O N .................................................................................................. 3-1 3 .1 S co pe D efinitio n ...................................................................................... 3-1 3.1.1 Identification of ONS LR Scope for RV Internals .......................... 3-1 3.1.2 Component Items Contained in MRP -189, Rev. 1 ...................... 3-2 3.2 Component Item Comparison ............................................................... 3-17 3.3 Program Modifications .......................................................................... 3-19 3.3.1 Misc. Locking Device Parts (Original and Modified) ................... 3-19 3 .3 .2 [ ] ........................................................ 3 -4 7 4 .0 C O NC LU S IO NS ................................................................................................ 4-1 5 .0 R E F E R E NC E S .................................................................................................. 5-1

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-1 89, Rev. 1 Comparison Page ii List of Tables Table 3-1: Comparison of ONS LR Scope to MRP-189, Rev. 1 Component Items ..... 3-3 Table 3-2: Comparison of ONS LR Scope to MRP-1 89, Rev. 1 Welds ..................... 3-12 Table 3-3: Vent Valve Locking Device Materials of Construction of Interest ............. 3-21 Table 3-4: Vent Valve Locking Device Material Identification .................................... 3-27 Table 3-5: Vent Valve Locking Device Screening Parameters .................................. 3-29 Table 3-6: Vent Valve Locking Device Initial Screening Results .............................. 3-34 Table 3-7: Vent Valve Locking Device FMECA Results ............................................ 3-39 Table 3-8: Preliminary Categorization of Vent Valve Component Items .................... 3-42 Table 3-9: [] ........................... 3-51 Table 3-10: [ ]............................. 3-55 T able 3-11: [ ]........................................... 3-63 T able 3-12 : [ ]................................................ 3-70 Table 3-13: [ ...... 3-72

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-189, Rev. 1 Comparison Page iii List of Figures Figure 3-1: Original Vent Valve Locking Device Schematic ...................................... 3-23 Figure 3-2: Original Vent Valve Locking Device Schematic - Cross-Section View ... 3-24 Figure 3-3: Modified Vent Valve Locking Device Schematic ..................................... 3-25 Figure 3-4: [ ]3-26 Figure 3-5 MRP-189, Rev. 1 Screening Criteria ........................................................ 3-33 Figure 3-6 FMECA Risk Band (Safety or Economic) ................................................. 3-38 Figure 3-7: [

............................................................... . . 3 -4 9 Figure 3-8: [

] ............................................... 3-50

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-189, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 1-1

1.0 INTRODUCTION

In December 2008, Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI) issued Rev. 0 of the Materials Reliability Program (MRP) MRP-227 [i] Inspection and Evaluation (I&E)

Guidelines for managing long-term aging of pressurized water reactor (PWR) reactor vessel (RV) internals in the U.S. MRP-227-Rev. 0 was submitted to the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) for review and approval in January 2009. [ii] In June 2011, the safety evaluation report (SER) for MRP-227-Rev. 0 was issued by the NRC

[iii] and was revised to Rev. 1 in December 2011 [iv]; the revised Rev. 1 SER is included in the NRC-approved MRP-227-A report. [v] MRP-227-A provides generic augmented inspection requirements for the currently operating fleet of U.S. PWRs.

MRP-227-A Section 7.3 categorizes the implementation of the augmented inspections as "Needed" in accordance with Nuclear Energy Institute (NEI) 03-08 Guidelines. [vi]

Section 3.0 of Rev. 1 of the SER documents the staff's evaluation and findings pertaining to the adequacy of the MRP's Aging Management Program (AMP) recommendations. In particular, Section 3.0 documents staff concerns with MRP-227 and the basis for limitations and conditions being placed on the use of MRP-227 as well as licensee/applicant action items that shall be addressed by applicants/licensees who choose to implement the NRC-approved version of MRP-227.

Duke Energy plans to implement MRP-227-A for the Oconee Nuclear Station (ONS)

Units 1, 2, and 3 and in doing so, must perform the appropriate evaluation, analyses, and other required actions to fulfill the applicant/licensee action items specified in the SER. Applicant/licensee action item 2, from Section 4.2.2 of Rev. 1 of the SER, is as follows:

"As discussed in Section 3.2.5.2 of this SE, consistent with the requirements addressedin 10 CFR 54.4, each applicantilicenseeis responsiblefor identifying which RVI components are within the scope of LR for its facility.

Applicants/licenseesshall review the information in Tables 4-1 and 4-2 in MRP-189, Revision 1, and Tables 4-4 and 4-5 in MRP-191 and identify whether these

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-189, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 1-2 tables contain all of the RVI components that are within the scope of LR for their facilities in accordance with 10 CFR 54.4. If the tables do not identify all the RVI components that are within the scope of LR for its facility, the applicantor licensee shall identify the missing component(s) and propose any necessary modifications to the program defined in MRP-227, as modified by this SE, when submitting its plant-specific AMP. The AMP shall provide assurance that the effects of aging on the missing component(s) will be managed for the period of extended operation. This issue is Applicant/Licensee Action Item 2."

The purpose of this document is to perform a comparison between the ONS RV Internals license renewal (LR) scope and Tables 4-1 and 4-2 in MRP-189, Rev. 1 [vii]

(for B&W-designed RV Internals) to satisfy Applicant/Licensee Action Item 2 from Reference iv. This comparison will identify whether the MRP-1 89, Rev. 1 tables contain all of the RV Internals components that are within the scope of LR for the ONS units.

Information considered by AREVA to be proprietary is bracketed using the following brackets: [ ]

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-189, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 2-1 2.0 METHODOLOGY The methodology of the comparison described in Section 1.0 was to take the steps as follows:

1. Obtain definition of scope for license renewal (located within 10 CFR 54.4 [viii])

(Section 3.1 of this report)

2. Identify the scope of the license renewal for ONS RV Internals (contained in a Duke calculation) (Section 3.1.1 of this report)
3. List component items and welds contained in the scope (Section 3.1.1 of this report)
4. List component items and welds contained in MRP-1 89, Rev. 1 Tables 4-1 and 4-2 (Section 3.1.2 of this report)
5. Compare component items and identify whether the MRP-1 89, Rev. 1 tables contain all of the RV Internals component items and welds that are within the scope of LR for the ONS units (Section 3.1.2, Section 3.2, Table 3-1, and Table 3-2 of this report)
6. Once the component items that are in the LR scope (but are not in MRP-1 89, Rev. 1) are identified, propose any necessary modifications to the program defined in MRP-227, as modified by the SER (Section 3.3 of this report). This will be done by utilizing the same screening methodology as used to develop MRP-227-A. As described in MRP-227-A, the following sequence steps were used:
a. Identify PWR internals components, materials, and environments
b. Identify degradation screening criteria
c. Characterize components and screen for degradation (A, non-A)
d. FMECA review
e. Severity categorization (A, B, C)
f. Engineering evaluation and assessment
g. Categorize for inspection (primary, expansion, existing, no additional measures) and aging management strategy

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-1 89, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-1 3.0 COMPARISON The following sections execute the methodology described in Section 2.0 of this report.

3.1 Scope Definition The following definition of scope, for LR, is found in 10 CFR 54.4.

'(a) Plant systems, structures, and components within the scope ofthis part are--

(1) Safety-relatedsystems, structures, and components which are those relied upon to remain functional during andfollowing design-basis events (as defined in 10 CFR 50.49 (b) (1)) to ensure the followingfunctions--

(i) The integrity of the reactorcoolantpressure boundary, (ii) The capability to shut down the reactor and maintain it in a sqfe shutdown condition; or (iii) The capabilityto prevent or mitigate the consequences of accidents which could result in potential offsite exposures comparable to those referred to in § 50.34(a)(1), § 50.67(b) (2), or § 100.11 of this chapter, as applicable.

(2) All nonsafety-relatedsystems, structures,and components whose failure could prevent satisfactoty accomplishment of any of the functions identified in paragraphs(a)(1) (i), (i), or (iii) of this section.

(3) All systems, structures,and components relied on in safeot analyses or plant evaluations to perform a function that demonstrates compliance with the Commission's regulationsforfire protection (10 CFR 50.48), environmentalqualification(10 CFR 50.49), pressurizedthermal shock (10 CFR 50.61), anticipatedtransientswithout scram (10 CFR 50.62), and station blackout (10 CFR 50.63).

(b) The intendedfunctions that these systems, structures, and components must be shown tofufill in § 54.21 are thosefunctions that are the basesfor including them within the scope of license renewal as specified in paragraphs(a)(]) - (3) of this section. "

3.1.1 Identification of ONS LR Scope for RV Internals The aging management review (AMR) performed for LR is contained in a Duke calculation. The scope, or component items subject to an aging management review, is reviewed in Section 4.4.2 of this Duke calculation and reported to be the component items that support the five RV internals intended functions and associated materials as reported in BAW-2248A [ix], [

] and component items that support the intended function to provide gamma and neutron shielding including the thermal shield and the thermal shield upper restraint. These component items specific to the ONS units are listed in Table 3-1 (component items) and Table 3-2 (welds) of this report. Note that the welds for the ONS LR scope are not listed in the Duke calculation or BAW-2248A, but are rather in

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-189, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-2 the text and translated to a table format, specifically the following two sentences from Section 2.0 of BAW-2248A as well as details in Subsections 2.1-2.4:

The welds within the scope of the reactorvessel internals report include the major structuralwelds that form orjoin the major sub-assembly cylinders and flanges and minor structuralwelds joining parts such as lifting lugs, support pipes and tubes to the major sub-assemblies. There are no pressure-retainingor pressure boundary welds within the scope of this report.

3.1.2 Component Items Contained in MRP -189, Rev. 1 The component items contained in MRP-1 89, Rev. 1 Tables 4-1 and 4-2 that match those listed in the ONS LR scope for RV Internals are listed in Table 3-1 (component items) and Table 3-2 (welds). Component items contained in MRP-189, Rev. 1 Tables 4-1 and 4-2 that are additional beyond those contained in the ONS LR scope for RV Internals are not listed in Table 3-1 and Table 3-2 of this report. These component items are outside the scope of this document as well as the description of the applicable licensee/applicant action item (specific action item wording is given in Section 1.0).

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scone and MRP-189. Rev. 1 Comparison Paoe 3-3 ONS License Renewal Scone and MRP-189 Rev. 1 Cornnarison Pane 3-3 Table 3-1: Comparison of ONS LR Scope to MRP-189, Rev. I Component Items ONS LR Scope Item Component Item Reference Identifier MRP-189 Component Item Reference 1 Plenum Cover Weldment BAW-2248A, P.1.1 Plenum Cover Weldment MRP-189, Rev. 1, Ribs Table 2-1 [ix] Ribs Table 4-1 [vii]

2 Plenum Cover Weldment BAW-2248A, P.1.2 Plenum Cover Rib Pads MRP-189, Rev. 1, Rib Pads Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

3 Plenum Cover Bottom BAW-2248A, P.1.3 Plenum Cover Bottom MRP-189, Rev. 1, Flange Table 2-1 [ix] Flange Table 4-1 [vii]

4 Plenum Cover Support BAW-2248A, P.1.4 Plenum Cover Support MRP-189, Rev. 1, Flange Table 2-1 [ix] Flange Table 4-1 [vii]

5 Plenum Cover Support Ring BAW-2248A, P.1.5 Plenum Cover Support Ring MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

6 Plenum Cover Plate BAW-2248A, P.1.6 Plenum Cover Plate MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

7 Lifting Lugs (ONS-2, 3) BAW-2248A, P.1.7 Plenum Cover Lifting Lugs MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

8 Base Blocks (ONS-2, 3) BAW-2248A, P.1.8 Base Blocks for Lifting Lugs MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] (ONS-2, 3) Table 4-1 [vii]

9 Lifting Lug-to-Base Block BAW-2248A, P.1.9 Lifting Lug-to-Base Block MRP-189, Rev. 1, Bolts (ONS-2, 3) Table 2-1 [ix] Bolts (ONS-2, 3) Table 4-1 [vii]

10 Locking Cups (ONS-2, 3) BAW-2248A, P.1.10 Locking Cups (ONS-2, 3) MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

11 Integral Lifting Lug w/Base BAW-2248A, P.1.11 Integral Lifting Lugs with MRP-189, Rev. 1, Block (ONS-1) Table 2-1 [ix] Base Block (ONS-1) Table 4-1 [vii]

12 Plenum Cylinder BAW-2248A, P.2.1 Plenum Cylinder MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

13 Plenum Cylinder Top BAW-2248A, P.2.2 Plenum Cylinder Top MRP-189, Rev. 1, Flange Table 2-1 [ix] Flange Table 4-1 [vii]

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ON~ I ir~n~ RPnAw~I ~c.on~ ~nd MRP-1R~ R~v I mn~ari~r~n P~ncA '-4 ONS LR Scope Item Component Item Reference Identifier MRP-189 Component Item Reference 14 Plenum Cylinder Bottom BAW-2248A, P.2.3 Plenum Cylinder Bottom MRP-189, Rev. 1, Flange Table 2-1 [ix] Flange Table 4-1 [vii]

15 Plenum Cylinder BAW-2248A, P.2.4 Plenum Cylinder MRP-189, Rev. 1, Reinforcing Plates Table 2-1 [ix] Reinforcing Plates Table 4-1 [vii]

16 Plenum Cylinder Round BAW-2248A, P.2.5 Plenum Cylinder Round MRP-189, Rev. 1, Bars Table 2-1 [ix] Bars Table 4-1 [vii]

17 Plenum Cylinder Top BAW-2248A, P.2.6 Plenum Cylinder Top MRP-189, Rev. 1, Flange-to-Cover Bolts Table 2-1 [ix] Flange-to-Cover Bolts Table 4-1 [vii]

18 Plenum Cylinder Locking BAW-2248A, P.2.7 Plenum Cylinder Locking MRP-189, Rev. 1, Cups Table 2-1 [ix] Cups Table 4-1 [vii]

19 Plenum Cylinder Bottom BAW-2248A, P.2.8 Plenum Cylinder Bottom MRP-189, Rev. 1, Flange-to-Upper Grid Table 2-1 [ix] Flange-to-Upper Grid Bolts Table 4-1 [vii]

Screws 20 Plenum Cylinder Locking BAW-2248A, P.2.9 Plenum Cylinder Locking MRP-189, Rev. 1, Cups Table 2-1 [ix] Cups Table 4-1 [vii]

21 Upper Grid Rib Section BAW-2248A, P.3.1 Upper Grid Rib Section MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

22 Upper Grid Ring Forging BAW-2248A, P.3.2 Upper Grid Ring Forging MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

23 Rib-to-Ring Screws BAW-2248A, P.3.3 Rib-to-Ring Cap Screws MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

24 Lockpins BAW-2248A, P.3.4 Locking Pins MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

25 Fuel Assembly Support BAW-2248A, P.3.5 Fuel Assembly Support MRP-189, Rev. 1, Pads Table 2-1 [ix] Pads Table 4-1 [vii]

26 Dowels BAW-2248A, P.3.6 Dowels MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

27 Cap Screw BAW-2248A, P.3.7 Cap Screws MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

ControHed Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 (AN-q ircense Reea S(~Afl anrd MRPP-1 A Rev 1 Qrm nriernn D. "Ir ONS LR Scope Item Component Item, Reference Identifier MRP-189 Component Item Reference 28 Control Rod Guide Tube BAW-2248A, P.4.1 CRGT Pipe MRP-189, Rev. 1, (CRGT) Pipe Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

29 CRGT Flange BAW-2248A, P.4.2 CRGT Flange MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

30 Flange-to-Upper Grid BAW-2248A, P.4.3 Flange-to-Upper Grid Cap MRP-189, Rev. 1, Screws Table 2-1 [ix] Screws Table 4-1 [vii]

31 Dowels BAW-2248A, P.4.4 Flange Dowels MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

32 CRGT Spacer Castings BAW-2248A, P.4.5 Spacer Castings MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

33 Spacer Castings Screws BAW-2248A, P.4.6 Spacer Casting Cap MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Screws Table 4-1 [vii]

34 Spacer Castings Washer BAW-2248A, P.4.7 Spacer Casting Washers MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

35 CRGT Rod Guide Tubes BAW-2248A, P.4.8 Rod Guide Tubes MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

36 CRGT Rod Guide Sectors BAW-2248A, P.4.9 Rod Guide Sectors MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

37 Core Support Shield (CSS) BAW-2248A, S.1 CSS Assembly Cylinder MRP-189, Rev. 1, Assembly Cylinder Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

38 Top Flange BAW-2248A, S.2 Top Flange MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

39 Bottom Flange BAW-2248A, S.3 Bottom Flange MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

40 CSS-to-Core Barrel Bolts BAW-2248A, S.4a Original CSS-to-Core Barrel MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Bolts Table 4-1 [vii]

41 Locking clips (original BAW-2248A, S.5a Locking Clips MRP-189, Rev. 1, bolts) Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

Controled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 QN'5-q Ligon- Reea SvY-nn anr MRP-1 AQ Rev 1 ('.nm nrienn Dn~MIr ONS LR Scope Item Component Item Reference Identifier MRP-189 Component Item Reference 42 Outlet Nozzles BAW-2248A, S.6a, b Outlet Nozzles MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

43 Vent Valve Nozzles BAW-2248A, S.7 Vent Valve Nozzles MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

44 Vent Valve Guide Blocks BAW-2248A, S.8 Vent Valve Nozzle Guide MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Blocks Table 4-1 [vii]

45 Vent Valve Body BAW-2248A, S.9 Vent Valve Body MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

46 Retaining Rings BAW-2248A, S.10 Vent Valve Top and Bottom MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Retaining Rings Table 4-1 [vii]

47 Jack Screws BAW-2248A, S.11 Vent Valve Jack Screws MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

48 Misc Locking Device BAW-2248A, No corresponding Parts (original) Table 2-1 [ix] component item(s) included in MRP-189, Rev. 1 for ONS units 49 Misc Locking Device BAW-2248A, No corresponding Parts (modified) Table 2-1 [ix] component item(s) included in MRP-189, Rev. 1 for ONS units 50 Round Bars BAW-2248A, S.15 Round Bars MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

51 Flow Deflectors BAW-2248A, S.16 Flow Deflectors MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

52 Lifting Lugs BAW-2248A, S.17 Lifting Lugs MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

53 Core Barrel Assembly BAW-2248A, B.1 CBA Cylinder MRP-189, Rev. 1, (CBA) Cylinders Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scone and MRP-189. Rev. 1 Comparison Pane 3-7 ONS LR Scope Item Component Item Reference Identifier MRP-189 Component Item Reference 54 Top Flange BAW-2248A, B.2 CBA Top Flange MRP-1189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

55 Bottom Flange BAW-2248A, B.3 CBA Bottom Flange MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

56 Lower Internals Assembly- BAW-2248A, B.4a, b Original Lower Grid MRP-189, Rev. 1, to-Core Barrel Bolts Table 2-1 [ix] Assembly-to-Core Barrel Table 4-1 [vii]

Bolts 57 Locking Clips BAW-2248A, B.5a Locking Clips MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

58 Core Barrel-to-Thermal BAW-2248A, B.6a Thermal Shield-to-Core MRP-189, Rev. 1, Shield Bolts Table 2-1 [ix] Barrel Bolts Table 4-1 [vii]

59 Locking Clips BAW-2248A, B.7 Locking Clips MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

60 Baffle Plates BAW-2248A, B.17 Baffle Plates MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

61 Formers BAW-2248A, B.18 Former Plates MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

62 Barrel-to-Former Bolts BAW-2248A, B.19 Core Barrel-to-Former Plate MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Cap Screws Table 4-1 [vii]

63 Locking Pins BAW-2248A, B.20 Locking Pins MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

64 Dowels BAW-2248A, B.21 Core Barrel-to-Former MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Plate Dowels Table 4-1 [vii]

65 Baffle-to-Former Bolts BAW-2248A, B.22 Baffle-to-Former Hex Head MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Bolts (except F4) Table 4-1 [vii]

66 Locking Pins BAW-2248A, B.23 Locking Pins MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

67 Baffle-to-Former Bolts BAW-2248A, B.22 Button Head Socket Cap MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Screws Table 4-1 [vii]

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scone and MRP-1 89. Rev. 1 Comparison Paae 3-8 ONS LR Scope Item Component Item Reference Identifier MRP-189 Component Item Reference 68 Locking Pins BAW-2248A, B.23 Locking Wires MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

69 Baffle-to-Former Shoulder BAW-2248A, B.24 Baffle-to-Former Shoulder MRP-189, Rev. 1, Screws Table 2-1 [ix] Screws (F4) Table 4-1 [vii]

70 Locking Dowels BAW-2248A, B.25 Locking Dowels MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

71 Baffle-to-Baffle Bolts BAW-2248A, B.26 Baffle-to-Baffle 12 pt. MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Bolts/Internal and External Table 4-1 [vii]

Baffle-to-Baffle Socket Head Cap Screws 72 Locking Rings BAW-2248A, B.27 Locking MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Rings/Wires/Washers Table 4-1 [vii]

73 Lower Grid Rib Section BAW-2248A, L.1.1 Lower Grid Rib Section MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

74 Fuel Assembly Support BAW-2248A, L.1.2 Lower Grid Fuel Assembly MRP-189, Rev. 1, Pads Table 2-1 [ix] Support Pads Table 4-1 [vii]

75 Dowels BAW-2248A, L.1.3 Dowels MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

76 Cap Screws BAW-2248A, L.1.4 Cap Screws MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

77 Rib-to-Shell Forging BAW-2248A, L.1.5 Rib-to-Shell Forging Cap MRP-189, Rev. 1, Screw Table 2-1 [ix] Screws Table 4-1 [vii]

78 Locking Pin BAW-2248A, L.1.6 Locking Pins MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

79 Lower Grid Flow Distributor BAW-2248A, L.1.7 Lower Grid Flow Distributor MRP-189, Rev. 1, Plate Table 2-1 [ix] Plate Table 4-1 [vii]

80 Orifice Plugs BAW-2248A, L.1.8 Orifice Plugs MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 nKQI ,-anna P~fl=%Ain,2I = ~nnA KAPP_1OQ1 Q ~ m~i~ D 1_0 ONS LR Scope Item Component Item Reference Identifier MRP-189 Component Item Reference 81 Lower Grid Forging (ONS- BAW-2248A, L.1.9a Lower Grid Forging (ONS- MRP-189, Rev. 1, 2, 3) Table 2-1 [ix] 2, 3) Table 4-1 [vii]

82 Lower Grid Forging Ribs BAW-2248A, L.1.9b Lower Grid Weldment Ribs MRP-189, Rev. 1, (ONS-1) Table 2-1 [ix] (ONS-1) Table 4-1 [vii]

83 Lower Grid Shell Forging BAW-2248A, L.1.10 Lower Grid Shell Forging MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

84 Lower Internals Assembly- BAW-2248A, L.1.11 b Replacement Lower Grid MRP-1189, Rev. 1, to-Thermal Shield Bolts Table 2-1 [ix] Assembly-to-Thermal Table 4-1 [vii]

Shield Studs/Nuts 85 Locking Cups and Tie BAW-2248A, L.1.12 Locking Cups/Tie Plates MRP-189, Rev. 1, Plates (replacement bolts) Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

86 Guide Blocks BAW-2248A, L.1.13 Guide Blocks (mating with MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Guide Lugs on RV) Table 4-1 [vii]

87 Guide Block Bolts BAW-2248A, L.1.14a Bolts MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

88 Guide Block Washers BAW-2248A, L.1.14b Washers MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

89 Dowel BAW-2248A, L.1.15 Dowels MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

90 Shock Pads BAW-2248A, L.1.16a&b Shock Pads MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

91 Shock Pad Bolts BAW-2248A, L.1.17a Bolts MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

92 Support Post Pipes BAW-2248A, L.1.18 Support Post Pipes MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

93 Bolting Plugs BAW-2248A, L.1.19 Bolting Plugs MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

94 Support Post Cap Screws BAW-2248A, L.1.20 Cap Screws MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-1 89, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-10 ONS LR Scope Item Component Item Reference Identifier MRP-189 Component Item Reference 95 Locking Pin BAW-2248A, L.1.21 Locking Pins MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

96 Flow Distributor Head BAW-2248A, L.2.1 Flow Distributor Head MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

97 Flow Distributor Flange BAW-2248A, L.2.2 Flow Distributor Flange MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

98 Shell Forging-to-Flow BAW-2248A, L.2.3a Flow Distributor-to-Lower MRP-189, Rev. 1, Distributor Bolts Table 2-1 [ix] Grid Shell Forging Bolts Table 4-1 [vii]

99 Locking Clip BAW-2248A, L.2.4 Locking Clips MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

100 Incore Guide Support Plate BAW-2248A, L.2.5 IMI Guide Support Plate MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

101 Clamping Ring BAW-2248A, L.2.6 IMI Guide Support Plate MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Clamping Ring Table 4-1 [vii]

102 Dowels BAW-2248A, L.2.7 IMI Guide Support Plate MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Dowels Table 4-1 [vii]

103 Incore Guide Tubes BAW-2248A, L.3.1 IMI Guide Tubes MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

104 Gussets BAW-2248A, L.3.2 IMI Guide Tube Gussets MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

105 Guide Tube Nuts BAW-2248A, L.3.4 IMI Guide Tube Nuts MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

106 Guide Tube Washers BAW-2248A, L.3.3 IMI Guide Tube Washers MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

107 Locking Clips BAW-2248A, L.3.5 Locking Clips MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Table 4-1 [vii]

108 Spiders BAW-2248A, L.3.6 IMI Guide Tube Spider MRP-189, Rev. 1, Table 2-1 [ix] Castings Table 4-1 [vii]

Contro0ed Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 I ir~n~~ R~n~iA,~I ~ ~nrI MRP~1RQ P~i I CAmn~ri~An Do = '1 1 ONS LR Scope Item Component Item Reference Identifier MRP-189 Component Item Reference 109 Thermal Shield Duke B.10 Thermal Shield MRP-189, Rev. 1, Calculation Cylinder Table 4-1 [vii]

110 Thermal Shield Upper Duke B.11, B.12, B.13, Thermal Shield Upper MRP-189, Rev. 1, Restraint Calculation B.14, B.15, B.16 Restraint "A" and "B" Table 4-1 [vii]

Blocks, Shims, Hardfacing, Upper Plugs, Dowels, Cap Screws

ControlIed Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 I ir~n~ R~n~i~I 5~rc~n~ ~nr~ MRP-IRq Rc~u I C~Amn~ri~n Table 3-2: Comparison of ONS LR Scope to MRP-189, Rev. 1 Welds Item ONS LR Scope Weld Reference Weld ID MRP-189 Weld Reference 1 Top and bottom core barrel BAW-2248A, WC-1 1 Top and bottom core barrel MRP-189, Rev. 1, cylinders to top and bottom Section 2 [ix] cylinders to top and bottom core Table 4-2 [vii]

core barrel flanges barrel flanges circumferential seam circumferential seam weld weld 2 Top and bottom thermal Duke WC-12 Top and bottom thermal shield MRP-189, Rev. 1, shield cylinder vertical seam calculation cylinder vertical seam weld Table 4-2 [vii]

weld 3 Top thermal shield cylinder Duke WC-13 Top thermal shield cylinder to MRP-189, Rev. 1, to bottom thermal shield calculation bottom thermal shield cylinder Table 4-2 [vii]

cylinder circumferential circumferential seam weld seam weld 4 Core barrel top and bottom BAW-2248A, WC-20 Core barrel top and bottom cylinder MRP-189, Rev. 1, cylinder vertical seam weld Section 2 [ix] vertical seam weld Table 4-2 [vii]

5 Core barrel top cylinder to BAW-2248A, WC-21 Core barrel top cylinder to core MRP-189, Rev. 1, core barrel bottom cylinder Section 2 [ix] barrel bottom cylinder Table 4-2 [vii]

circumferential seam weld circumferential seam weld 6 Plug weld locking dowel BAW-2248A, WC-94 Plug weld locking dowel flush with MRP-189, Rev. 1, flush with special flat head Section 2 [ix] special flat head baffle-to-former Table 4-2 [vii]

baffle-to-former shoulder shoulder screw screw 7 Core support shield cylinder BAW-2248A, WC-43 Core support shield cylinder to top MRP-189, Rev. 1, to top and bottom flange Section 2 [ix] and bottom flange circumferential Table 4-2 [vii]

circumferential seam weld seam weld (WC-43) 8 Core support shield cylinder BAW-2248A, WC-44 Core support shield cylinder to vent MRP-189, Rev. 1, to vent nozzle weld Section 2 [ix] nozzle weld Table 4-2 [vii]

9 Core support shield cylinder BAW-2248A, WC-46 Core support shield cylinder to MRP-189, Rev. 1, to outlet nozzle weld Section 2 [ix] outlet nozzle weld Table 4-2 [vii]

10 Flow deflector (U-baffle) BAW-2248A, WC-48 Flow deflector (U-baffle) segments MRP-189, Rev. 1, segments weld Section 2 [ix] weld Table 4-2 [vii]

Controfled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-1 89. Rev. 1 ComDarison Paae 3-13 Item ONS LR Scope Weld Reference Weld ID MRP-189 Weld Reference 11 Core support shield lifting BAW-2248A, WC-49 Core support shield lifting lug to top MRP-189, Rev. 1, lug to top flange weld Section 2 [ix] flange weld Table 4-2 [vii]

12 Core support shield cylinder BAW-2248A, WC-51 Core support shield cylinder MRP-189, Rev. 1, vertical seam weld Section 2 [ix] vertical seam weld Table 4-2 [vii]

13 Round (LOCA) bars to core BAW-2248A, WC-52 Round (LOCA) bars to core support MRP-189, Rev. 1, support shield cylinder ID Section 2 [ix] shield cylinder ID surface weld Table 4-2 [vii]

surface weld 14 Flow deflector (U-baffle) to BAW-2248A, WC-53 Flow deflector (U-baffle) to core MRP-189, Rev. 1, core support shield cylinder Section 2 [ix] support shield cylinder weld Table 4-2 [vii]

weld 15 Guide block to core support BAW-2248A, WC-105 Guide block to core support shield MRP-189, Rev. 1, shield vent nozzle fillet weld Section 2 [ix] vent nozzle fillet weld Table 4-2 [vii]

16 CRGT flange to CRGT pipe BAW-2248A, WC-41 CRGT flange to CRGT pipe (all MRP-189, Rev. 1, (all around except at the 4 Section 2 [ix] around except at the 4 scallops) Table 4-2 [vii]

scallops) 17 CRGT pipe to plenum cover BAW-2248A, WC-65 CRGT pipe to plenum cover plate MRP-189, Rev. 1, plate weld Section 2 [ix] weld Table 4-2 [vii]

18 Flow distributor flange to BAW-2248A, WC-57 Flow distributor flange to flow MRP-189, Rev. 1, flow distributor head Section 2 [ix] distributor head circumferential Table 4-2 [vii]

circumferential seam weld seam weld 19 Incore instrument guide BAW-2248A, WC-158 Incore instrument guide tubes MRP-189, Rev. 1, tubes (center and Section 2 [ix] (center and peripheral) to flow Table 4-2 [vii]

peripheral) to flow distributor head weld distributor head weld 20 Incore instrument guide BAW-2248A, WC-159 Incore instrument guide tube MRP-189, Rev. 1, tube (center) to flow Section 2 [ix] (center) to flow distributor head and Table 4-2 [vii]

distributor head and gusset gusset weld weld 21 Spider to lower grid rib BAW-2248A, WC-160 Spider to lower grid rib section weld MRP-189, Rev. 1, section weld Section 2 [ix]

  • Table 4-2 [vii]

ControI~ed Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scone and MRP-189. Rev. 1 Comnarison Paae 3-14 Item ONS LR Scope Weld Reference Weld ID MRP-189 Weld Reference 22 Support post to lower grid BAW-2248A, WC-5 Support post to lower grid forging MRP-189, Rev. 1, forging weld Section 2 [ix] weld Table 4-2 [vii]

23 Lower grid forging (or BAW-2248A, WC-8 Lower grid forging (or weldment) to MRP-189, Rev. 1, weldment) to lower grid Section 2 [ix] lower grid shell forging weld Table 4-2 [vii]

shell forging weld 24 Bolting plug to support post BAW-2248A, WC-97 Bolting plug to support post weld MRP-189, Rev. 1, weld Section 2 [ix] Table 4-2 [vii]

25 Locking pin (for lower grid BAW-2248A, WC-99 Locking pin (for lower grid rib MRP-189, Rev. 1, rib section cap screw) to Section 2 [ix] section cap screw) to lower grid rib Table 4-2 [vii]

lower grid rib section weld section weld 26 Locking pin (for lower grid BAW-2248A, WC-100 Locking pin (for lower grid support MRP-189, Rev. 1, support post cap screw) to Section 2 [ix] post cap screw) to lower grid rib Table 4-2 [vii]

lower grid rib section weld section weld 27 Support post to flow BAW-2248A, WC-142 Support post to flow distributor MRP-189, Rev. 1, distributor plate weld Section 2 [ix] plate weld Table 4-2 [vii]

28 Flow distributor plate to BAW-2248A, WC-142 Flow distributor plate to lower grid MRP-189, Rev. 1, lower grid shell forging weld Section 2 [ix] shell forging weld Table 4-2 [vii]

29 Two plenum cover support BAW-2248A, WC-18 Two plenum cover support ring MRP-189, Rev. 1, ring segments to form a Section 2 [ix] segments to form a complete Table 4-2 [vii]

complete plenum cover plenum cover support ring weld support ring weld 30 Plenum cover support ring BAW-2248A, WC-19 Plenum cover support ring to MRP-189, Rev. 1, to plenum cover support Section 2 [ix] plenum cover support flange weld Table 4-2 [vii]

flange weld 31 Plenum cover weldment BAW-2248A, WC-28 Plenum cover weldment ribs to MRP-189, Rev. 1, ribs to each other weld Section 2 [ix] each other weld Table 4-2 [vii]

32 Plenum cover weldment BAW-2248A, WC-29 Plenum cover weldment ribs to MRP-189, Rev. 1, ribs to support ring and Section 2 [ix] support ring and support flange Table 4-2 [vii]

support flange weld I weld

Controfled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ON~ I ir~n~ R~n~w~I Se~rtnA ~nd MRP-lRq R~i I (~r~mn~ri~nn Item ONS LR Scope Weld Reference Weld ID MRP-189 Weld Reference 33 Plenum cover bottom flange BAW-2248A, WC-30 Plenum cover bottom flange to MRP-189, Rev. 1, to plenum cover weldment Section 2 [ix] plenum cover weldment ribs weld Table 4-2 [vii]

ribs weld 34 Plenum cover plate to BAW-2248A, WC-31 Plenum cover plate to plenum MRP-189, Rev. 1, plenum cover weldment ribs Section 2 [ix] cover weldment ribs weld Table 4-2 [vii]

weld 35 Plenum cover support BAW-2248A, WC-126 Plenum cover support flange to the MRP-189, Rev. 1, flange to the bottom of Section 2 [ix] bottom of plenum cover weldment Table 4-2 [vii]

plenum cover weldment ribs ribs weld weld 36 Plenum cover lifting lug BAW-2248A, WC-127 Plenum cover lifting lug base block MRP-189, Rev. 1, base block between 2 Section 2 [ix] between 2 plenum cover weldment Table 4-2 [vii]

plenum cover weldment ribs ribs weld weld 37 Plenum cover lifting lug BAW-2248A, WC-128 Plenum cover lifting lug base block MRP-189, Rev. 1, base block between 2 Section 2 [ix] between 2 plenum cover weldment Table 4-2 [vii]

plenum cover weldment ribs ribs weld weld 38 Plenum cover lifting lug BAW-2248A, WC-129 Plenum cover lifting lug base block MRP-189, Rev. 1, base block between 2 Section 2 [ix] between 2 plenum cover weldment Table 4-2 [vii]

plenum cover weldment ribs ribs weld weld 39 Plenum cover rib pads to BAW-2248A, WC-133 Plenum cover rib pads to plenum MRP-189, Rev. 1, plenum cover weldment rib Section 2 [ix] cover weldment rib weld Table 4-2 [vii]

weld 40 Plenum cover plate to the BAW-2248A, WC-142 Plenum cover plate to the top of MRP-189, Rev. 1, top of plenum cover Section 2 [ix] plenum cover weldment rib weld Table 4-2 [vii]

weldment rib weld 41 Plenum cover weldment rib BAW-2248A, WC-142 Plenum cover weldment rib to the MRP-189, Rev. 1, to the other weldment rib Section 2 [ix] other weldment rib weld Table 4-2 [vii]

weld

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scone and MRP-189. Rev. 1 Comnarison Pane 3-16 Item ONS LR Scope Weld Reference Weld ID MRP-189 Weld Reference 42 Plenum cylinder to top and BAW-2248A, WC-34 Plenum cylinder to top and bottom MRP-189, Rev. 1, bottom plenum cylinder Section 2 [ix] plenum cylinder flanges Table 4-2 [vii]

flanges circumferential circumferential seam weld seam weld 43 Plenum cylinder vertical BAW-2248A, WC-37 Plenum cylinder vertical seam weld MRP-189, Rev. 1, seam weld Section 2 [ix] Table 4-2 [vii]

44 X-750 dowel to upper grid BAW-2248A, WC-22 X-750 dowel to upper grid fuel MRP-189, Rev. 1, fuel assembly support pad Section 2 [ix] assembly support pad weld (except Table 4-2 [vii]

weld (except DB) DB) 45 Cap screw to upper grid fuel BAW-2248A, WC-23 Cap screw to upper grid fuel MRP-189, Rev. 1, assembly support pad weld Section 2 [ix] assembly support pad weld Table 4-2 [vii]

46 Locking pin (for cap screw BAW-2248A, WC-95 Locking pin (for cap screw to MRP-189, Rev. 1, to joining upper grid rib Section 2 [ix] joining upper grid rib section to Table 4-2 [vii]

section to upper grid ring upper grid ring forging) to upper forging) to upper grid rib grid rib section weld section weld Notes:

1. In BAW-2248A there are two brazements specifically discussed (CRGT assembly guide tubes and rod guide sectors brazed to the CRGT assembly spacer castings). These brazement configurations are specifically discussed in MRP-189, Rev. 1 Section 2.3.4; however no brazements are included in Table 4-2 of MRP-1 89, Rev. 1, only welds. As noted in MRP-1 57, Section 4.4.6, although these CRGT assemblies may be subject to age-related degradation, such degradation is not expected to have a significant effect on control rod drop times. In the case where a single control rod assembly is prevented from fully inserting, there is sufficient excess reactivity from the other control rod assemblies such that safe shutdown can be assured.

Therefore, these items do not warrant a discussion within this document.

2. There is no discussion of any of the welds associated with the vent valve misc. locking device parts or [

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-1 89, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-17 3.2 Component Item Comparison Table 3-1 and Table 3-2 of this report contain a comparison of the components items and welds contained in the LR scope for the ONS RV Internals and MRP-189, Rev. 1.

As shown in the tables, three component items are contained in the LR scope for the ONS RV Internals and are not identified in MRP-189, Rev. 1:

1. Vent Valve Misc. Locking Device Parts (original) (Table 3-1, item 48)
2. Vent Valve Misc. Locking Device Parts (modified) (Table 3-1, item 49)
3. [ ] (Table 3-1, item 111)

Any necessary program modifications regarding items 48, 49, and 111 from Table 3-1 of this report are discussed in Section 3.3 of this report.

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-189, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-18 Additionally, during a records search performed in 2009 and 2010, a feature unique to ONS-1 was identified for the plenum cover weldment rib pads. Each of the 32 plenum cover rib pads at ONS-1 is fastened to the plenum cover ribs with two Type 304 screws and one Alloy X-750 dowel. At the six other operating B&W units, the plenum cover rib pads are welded to the plenum cover weldment ribs. Since this unique feature was not known during the preparatory work leading up to MRP-227-A or the initial scope work performed for license renewal for the ONS units, the Alloy X-750 dowel and Type 304 screws and their locking welds at this location were not included in the ONS scope nor evaluated in the MRP screening documents.

AREVA previously performed a screening for the Alloy X-750 dowel, Alloy X-750 dowel locking weld, Type 304 screws, and Type 304 screw locking welds. The screening was performed using the same screening process and criteria that was used for other locations and documented in MRP-1 89, Rev. 1. The Alloy X-750 dowel and the Type 304 screws and their locking welds were screened as Category "A" items. The Alloy X-750 dowel locking welds were screened as Category "Not A" due to being potentially susceptible to primary water SCC (PWSCC). However, a functionality assessment of

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-189, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-19 the Alloy X-750 dowel locking weld categorized this component item as "No Additional Measures" per MRP-227-A. Therefore, no additional augmented inspection is required for this location.

3.3 Program Modifications This section discusses the background of the identified component items and any program modifications necessary based on the identification of these component items contained in the LR scope for the ONS RV Internals as discussed in Section 3.2 of this report.

3.3.1 Misc. Locking Device Parts (Original and Modified)

Section 3.2 of this report identifies component items contained in the LR scope for the ONS RV Internals that are not contained in MRP-189, Rev. 1. Two of these component items are the vent valve misc. locking device parts (both original and modified, see Figure 3-1, Figure 3-2, Figure 3-3, and Figure 3-4 of this report).

Vent Valve Lockinq Device Background

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-1 89, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-20

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-1 89, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-21 Materials of Construction The general materials of construction for the vent valve original misc. locking device parts are identified in Reference [ix] and are listed in Table 3-3 of this report.

Table 3-3: Vent Valve Locking Device Materials of Construction of Interest Component Item Material Specification Type or GradelClass Misc. Locking Device Stainless Steel A 240 Tp. 304 Parts (original) A 276 Tp. 304 A 276 Tp.431

--- A-286 Misc. Locking Device Stainless Steel A 240 Tp. 304 Parts (modified)

SA-479 or Tp. 304 SA-182 or F304 SA-193 Gr. B8 or B8M NiCrFe Alloy MIL-N-23228A Cond. A (Alloy 600) or SB-168 ---

MIL-N-23229A AM.2T1 Cond. A or SB-166 ---

NiCr Alloy AMS-5662C or ---

(Alloy 718) SA-637 Gr. 718

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-189, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-22 The original and modified vent valve locking device drawings as well as the parts to be replaced and the modified locking device parts are identified in the FCAs; these parts are listed in Table 3-4 of this report.

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-1 89, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-23 Figure 3-1: Original Vent Valve Locking Device Schematic

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-189, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-24 Figure 3-2: Original Vent Valve Locking Device Schematic - Cross-Section View

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-189, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-25 Figure 3-3: Modified Vent Valve Locking Device Schematic

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-189, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-26 Figure 3-4: [

I

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-189, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-27 Table 3-4: Vent Valve Locking Device Material Identification

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-189, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-28 3.3.1.1 Identification of Screening Parameters and Criteria The screening parameters for the component items listed in Table 3-4 are tabulated in Table 3-5. The environmental parameters for the component items listed in Table 3-4 of this report are the same as for the other vent valve items (see Table 3-2 of MRP-1 89, Rev. 1, identifiers S.7-S.14). The neutron fluence is less than 5E18 n/cm 2 (E > 1.0 MeV) and the temperature is 605'F. Operating stresses for the original and modified vent valve locking device parts were not located during the preparation of this task. The tack, plug, and fillet welds were not confirmed to be or not to be multi-pass welds, but due to their small size, they are likely not multi-pass welds. A cold work value of greater than or equal to 20% is expected for those component items in the modified vent valve locking devices that are [ I

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scone and MRP-1 89 Rev 1 Comparison Table 3-5: Vent Valve Locking Device Screening Parameters

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-1 89, Rev. 1Comparison Page 3-30

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scone and MRP-189 Rev 1 Comparison Note a - Operating stresses for the original and modified vent valve locking device parts were not located during the preparation of this task.

Note b - By examination of the applicable drawing, determination of a multi-pass weld is not possible. However due to the small size of this weld, it is unlikely that this is a multi-pass weld.

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-189, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-32 3.3.1.2 Characterize and Screen for Degradation The original and modified vent valve locking device items for the three ONS units identified in Table 3-4 of this report need to be screened using the screening process and criteria that has been used for other RV Internals component items and documented in MRP-1 89, Rev. 1, and Section 3. The screening criteria used are those detailed in Table 3-1 of MRP-1 89, Rev. 1. This table is repeated as Figure 3-5 of this report. Each age-related degradation mechanism is screened for each PWR internals component item by comparing the values in Table 3-5 against the screening criteria in Figure 3-5 and the results are contained in Table 3-6 of this report. An aging mechanism is screened in if the screening criteria are met or exceeded for that component item. Otherwise, the aging mechanism is screened out for the component item. If a value is unknown (e.g., operating stress), it is assumed to have exceeded the applicable screening criteria.

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-189, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-33 Figure 3-5 MRP-189, Rev. 1 Screening Criteria SOC IA C wear WF Fatigue Thermal Aging Embrlttlement Irradiation Embrlttlement Void Swelling Relax. and Stress Irradiation Creep Austanitdc stainless steel (stress > 30 ksaand (Types 3041304L. 3131t6L Cold-work CASS&

321,347.348, and Nitronlc 60) a 20%) ormultpass welds Ausonific Sithvess Austenitic Stainless steel welds ress>30 ksl ,ndferite Al alloys Setaf Weds (Types 308/308L and Relative Contlrlugal 316/3161) modon casting. >20% Aus tnIfc AuslenJtic Example fentte tafn/* .*te# ,stn*ss Martensltic stainless steel (Typos 403.,410.o431) Stress88ks! Alaloys control rod Al alloys Or >1.0E21 rVcmn. Steeland For - 2F21 guide lubas CUF>0.t Static E > 1.0 IOV Welds ThoimaiSRornly ivan' or (0 40-yrs) casing/SS 11.5 dal( Temperatur (seeNote 1)

Maitensitic PH stainless steoas r, > tM>V C ping C8>L Or welds with CASS S a e 6081F BotIed or spring (Typos I 5-SPH and I 7-4PH) p dpo], se5 fore Bolted or I0.50% Mo. Aust feic (320-C) locations raw'"lng SCC crida ExampW.: sMng >20% frent: S.lnloso Stool and fluence peload for Austonitlc PH stainless steals strw _> asuface 70 ksl*nd For higher ma" lodge Kems with > 0.50% Weds > 1.3E22 tunctionanty (A.oy A-286) cold-work orhot-headed Isaiice. betweeni ieie M0.

lferite>14%

or shot peened > 67E20 rdCm', E > Iffadiatdon-bolts Screen*ng internals and SRIIC Is Wltcm, > I MeV 1.0 MeV (20 enhanced SR/IC stress RV applicable Or 11 dpa) dpal _ 1.3E20 nf/rn',

CASS Stress> 35 ksl and forrite (MPa) 0r

o. Example: e 3.3E20 Warn. (Other alloys (Other > IMoV (0.2 dpa]

(Types CF-8 and CF-3M) (5% 15S.4 Bolted or baffle-IC- > IMeV exceeding alloys Apples to at WI(OW) Spring items former (0.5 ripe austetic exceeding bolted or sprtng Austanitic NI-basoe Alloys stress> 3 krJ +789.65 twere SR/IC bolts (It accoant for stak'ess Steel the criteria locations.

(Alloy 600) Is applicable potential criterion areao are to be Examnpe: syn-gt be er.aned in scoeenod I Austonltlc and 82)Welds (Alloys 182Ni-bas" strew 3S kr* baffle-to- effects) too.) too.)

former boi*s MAfrfns*lc and M.2flensic Austantlic PH NI-base Alloys stress > 100 ksl (X-750) or PH SMsnjss (Alloys 718 and X-750) 1130 ksi (718) Sleet ANlocations Co-base Alloys not susceptile in Intrnals (Sltto 16) locations

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scone and MRP-189. Rev. 1 ComDarison Paae 3-34 Table 3-6: Vent Valve Locking Device Initial Screening Results Original/ Drawing  ?, 0 a Modified Part o to 4)

Number 0 0) .2 "* 0 a.'- C. 0 25 - 0 "C :p~

.6~ E ~E 0o VM F- L..U W >  !

Original [ ] [ Austenitic A A Not A A A A A SS A Original [ ] [ ] Austenitic A A Not A A A A A SS A Original [ ] [ J Austenitic A A A A A A A ANotea PH SS Original [ ] [ ] Austenitic A A A A A A A A SS Original [ ] [ ] Martensitic Not A A A Not A A A A SS A Original [ ] [ ] Austenitic A A A A A A A ANotea SS Original [ ] [ Austenitic A A A A A A A ANotea SS Original Martensitic Not A A A Not A A A A SS A Original [ ] [ Austenitic A A A A A A A A

] ss

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scooe and MRP-1 89. Rev. 1 Comparison Paae 3-35 Original/ Drawing  ;,0.

Modified Part 0 a)

Number .0 .0E= &,i E .2 'E au.~ 0 cc LIo E c*ac .2~~

O.)U) 0LL . s 41 E L-w

~E W >o0 cci Modified [ ] [ I Austenitic Not A A A A A A A Ni-Base A Modified [ ] [ ] Austenitic Not A A A A A A A Ni-Base A Modified [1 [ ] Austenitic A A A A A A A A SS Modified [ Austenitic Not A A A A A A ANotea PH Ni-Base A Modified ] Austenitic Not A A A A A A ANotea PH Ni-Base A Modified [ ] [ ] Austenitic Not A A A A A A A Ni-Base A Modified [ ] [ ] Austenitic A A A A A A A A SS Modified [ 1 [ Austenitic Not A A A A A A A Ni-Base A Modified [ ] " ] Austenitic A A A A A A A A SS Modified Austenitic Not A A A A A A A I Ni-Base A

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-189, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-36 Note a - As depicted in Figure 3-5, thermal stress relaxation (SR) is applicable for bolted or spring locations requiring preload for functionality, while irradiation-enhanced SR/IC has a fluence requirement of >1.3E20 n/cm 2 (E > 1.0 MeV) for all bolted or spring locations. Therefore, only thermal SR is applicable to this component item. However, in Rev. 1 of MRP-189, thermal SR was not considered as a separate aging degradation mechanism in the absence of irradiation-enhanced stress relaxation and creep due to laboratory tests and operating experience. Therefore, this component item is initially screened as Category A because both thermal and irradiation-enhanced SR are not applicable.

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-189, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-37 3.3.1.3 Failure Modes and Effects Criticality Analysis (FMECA)

The objective of the failure modes and effects criteria analysis (FMECA) is to provide a systematic, qualitative review to identify components of RV internals component items and age-related degradation mechanisms that potentially results in degradation leading to significant risk. The FMECA is used to examine the susceptibility and safety and economic consequences of identified RV internals components item/age-related degradation mechanism combinations. The FMECA approach uses inductive reasoning to ensure that the potential failure of each component item is analyzed, to determine the results or effects thereof on the system, and to classify each potential failure mode according to its severity.

Each failure mode was judged on its importance to risk, based on the susceptibility and severity of consequences. Consequences were examined from two perspectives:

safety and economic. A risk matrix was developed to correlate the consequence severity of a particular age-related degradation mechanism with the susceptibility of that particular mechanism. Different risk banks were used within the matrix to categorize the level of risk of a particular component item/degradation mechanism pair, and provide guidance on the strategies that should be developed to reduce the corresponding risk and a basis for ranking and categorization.

The risk matrix established for the development of MRP-227-A is shown in Figure 3-6 of this report. The results of the FMECA are shown in Table 3-7.

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-189, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-38 Figure 3-6 FMECA Risk Band (Safety or Economic)

Increasing Suscepfibty from B to D

.hl B C D 1 il U

g 2 H III III 3 III IV IV I*0 ~

F 4 IV V V

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-189, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-39 Table 3-7: Vent Valve Locking Device FMECA Results SCC IASCC ISR &Crep Wear Fiu IE VS Original I a'

-- is-MoiidPart Description UF Original [ ] A A IA A A A C 1 21 BAA S]

86 AAAAiA a Original [ ] A A A A A A C 1*2 1 1 A A A A A AA A B5 Original [ ]AA AA AA AA Original [ ] A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A Original [ ]A A A A A A iA A A A A A A A , A A Original [ 3 B 1 21 A A A A A A A A A B i 2! A A A A A A Original [ ] A A A A A A A AA A A A A A A A A Original [ ] A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A Original [3 12 1 A A A A A A A A A B 12I1 A A A A AA Original [ B A AA 51 2 I AiAA A A A Modified [ ] l 2 ISA A A AA AA AA AA A A A a Modified [C Mdie ] CI I 2 1 TlBAA 5 AA AA A A A A A A A A A iA A B Modified [A A A A A A A A A AA AA A A A A Modified [ 1 2 1 A A A A A A A A AA AA A A A A Modified [ B 1 2 A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A Modified [ C I 2 I 1 B A A A Modified [ ] A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A Modified [ BI2[

AAAAA A A A A A A A A A A A Modified [ 2 AA A A A A A A A B 2 1 A A A A , A A

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 -

ONS License Renewal Scooe and MRP-189. Rev. 1 ComDarison Pare 3-40 SCC IASCC ISR&C Wear Fatigue TE IE VS Orgia Is 9 1: M t a, aaA A Par Decito U- -g U, 1 g C 1 Modified [.]

Moiie ] 21I A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-189, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-41 3.3.1.4 Categorization of Component Items The categorization of component items uses the initial screening results (Section 3.3.1.2) and the FMECA results (Section 3.3.1.3) to separate the component items into Category A, B, and C. Definitions of Categories A, B, and C and their respective criteria are listed in Section 5 of MRP-189, Rev. 1. The results are shown in Table 3-8.

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-189, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-42 Table 3-8: Preliminary Categorization of Vent Valve Component Items GE

  • E .2 E .0- - (D C Original/ Part Description CO Mu E ")

E * "0* o ,

Modified 1

-U ") E

=0,

-r"0 .

EL< -t

""

Iw wu > 0 0

Original [ ] A A B A A A A A B Original [ A A B A A A A A B Original [ " A A A A A A A A A Original [ ] A A A A A A A A A Original [ ] A A A A A A A A A Original [ 1 A A A A A A A A A Original [ " A A A A A A A A A Original [ 1 A A A A A A A A A Original A A A A A A A A A Modified [ ] B A A A A A A A B Modified B A A A A A A A B Modified A A A A A A A A A Modified [ A A A A A A A A A Modified [ A A A A A A A A A Modified " ] B A A A A A A A j B

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-189, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-43

o. 0) E C. *~ E .2 E Oiia/

Original/~

Part Description 0 E)

4) .2Wi 929r 4

Modified E I- mM.

-

LL -. 0 0O

4) C CLA0

~E ~E Z 4.0< E W W > C) 0 Modified A A A A A A A A A Modified[

Modified [ A A A A A A A A A Modified [ A A A A A A A A A

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-189, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-44 3.3.1.5 Engineering Evaluation and Assessment and Categorization for Inspection The component items screened as non-Category A component items in Table 3-8 are as follows:

° Original vent valve locking device: [ ] for wear

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-1 89, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-45 Additionally, the ONS units perform a visual inspection each refueling outage and a VT-3 inspection during the 10-year ASME B&PV Code inservice inspection (IS[) intervals of the vent valves. The accessible surfaces of the vent valves are visually inspected, including the locking devices. [x] [

] For these reasons, the original vent valve locking device [ ] are further categorized as "No Additional Measures" for the ONS units. [

Therefore, loss of material of the locking devices on the original vent valve assemblies due to wear is adequately managed by the ASME B&PV Code Section Xl programmatic controls along with the valve testing and inspection requirements each refueling outage.

  • Modified vent valve locking device: [

] for PWSCC The modified vent valve items that are fabricated from Alloy 600 and potentially susceptible to PWSCC are the [

I

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-189, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-46 Therefore, it is likely that the visual inspection performed during each refueling outage as well as the VT-3 visual inspection of the vent valve retaining rings performed on the 10-year ISI interval would detect the jackscrew turning, indicating potential cracking or damage to the [

1 For these reasons, the modified vent valve locking device [

J are further categorized as "No Additional Measures" for the ONS units.

Therefore, cracking of the Alloy 600 locking devices on the modified vent valve assemblies due to PWSCC is adequately managed by the ASME B&PV Code Section Xl programmatic controls along with the valve testing and inspection requirements each refueling outage.

However, it is noted that in MRP-227-A the existing program in place for vent valve locking device aging management at ONS is not identified as such in Table 4-7 (of

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-189, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-47 MRP-227-A). Duke is working with the MRP to establish interim guidance to account for this discrepancy and incorporate the appropriate information in the next revision of MRP-227. Therefore, in this document, ONS assumes that the visual inspections currently performed are equivalent to an Existing Program for MRP-227 implementation.

3.3.2 [ 1 Section 3.2 of this report identified that [ ] were omitted from MRP-1 89, Rev. 1 and were contained in the LR scope for the ONS RV internals. As such, these component items are subject to aging management review.

I

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-1 89, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-48 Materials of Construction

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-189, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-49 Figure 3-7: [

I

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-189, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-50 Figure 3-8: [

I

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-1 89, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-51 Table 3-9: [ I

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-1 89, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-52

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-189, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-53 Note a - All stainless steel welds assumed to be either Type 308 or 308L material, in accordance with standard industry practice at the time of fabrication.

Note b - The Ni-base alloy weld material is assumed to be Alloy 69, Alloy 82, or Alloy 182 material, in accordance with standard industry practice at the time of fabrication.

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-189, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-54 3.3.2.1 Identification of Screening Parameters and Criteria The screening parameters for the component items listed in Table 3-9 are tabulated in Table 3-10. The environmental parameters for the component items listed in Table 3-9 of this report are [

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-189, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-55 Table 3-10: [ I

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-189, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-56

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-1 89, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-57

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-189, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-58

Controllecd Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-189, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-59

Controi~ed Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-189, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-60

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-1 89, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-61

Contro0led Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-1 89, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-62 3.3.2.2 Characterize and Screen for Degradation The [ ] for the three ONS units identified in Table 3-9 of this report need to be screened using the screening process and criteria that has been used for other RV Internals component items and documented in MRP-1 89, Rev.

1. The screening criteria are provided in this report as Figure 3-4. Each age-related degradation mechanism is screened for each PWR internals component item by comparing the values in Table 3-10 against the screening criteria in Figure 3-4 and the results are contained in Table 3-11 of this report. An aging mechanism is screened in if the screening criteria are met or exceeded for that component item. Otherwise, the aging mechanism is screened out for the component item. If a value is unknown (e.g.,

operating stress), it is assumed to have exceeded the applicable screening criteria (unless otherwise noted).

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-189, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-63 Table 3-11: [

[ 1

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-189, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-64

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal ScoDe and MRP-189. Rev. 1 Comparison Paae 3-65 Page 3-65 P

I I

I I

I I

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-189, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-66

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-189, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-67

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-189, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-68 Note a - Although it is currently unknown whether this item is susceptible to thermal embrittlement and SCC (i.e., no records search for the actual heat treatment condition has been performed at this time), SCC is very unlikely because there are no stresses on this item once the surveillance specimen holder tubes were removed.

Note b - Although the stress is assumed to be < 30 ksi, it is not expected that any stress on this item will be beyond the screening criterion provided as Figure 3-4 of this document.

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-189, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-69 3.3.2.3 Failure Modes and Effects Criticality Analysis (FMECA)

The objective of the failure modes and effects criteria analysis (FMECA) is to provide a systematic, qualitative review to identify components of RV internals component items and age-related degradation mechanisms that potentially results in degradation leading to significant risk. The FMECA is used to examine the susceptibility and safety and economic consequences of identified RV internals components item/age-related degradation mechanism combinations. The FMECA approach uses inductive reasoning to ensure that the potential failure of each component item is analyzed, to determine the results or effects thereof on the system, and to classify each potential failure mode according to its severity.

Each failure mode was judged on its importance to risk, based on the susceptibility and severity of consequences. Consequences were examined from two perspectives:

safety and economic. A risk matrix was developed to correlate the consequence severity of a particular age-related degradation mechanism with the susceptibility of that particular mechanism. Different risk banks were used within the matrix to categorize the level of risk of a particular component item/degradation mechanism pair, and provide guidance on the strategies that should be developed to reduce the corresponding risk and a basis for ranking and categorization.

The risk matrix established for the development of MRP-227-A is shown in Figure 3 5 of this report. The results of the FMECA for the [ are shown in Table 3-12.

C;ontro(c 'JCC~men AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-189, Rev. 1 Comparison Paqe 3-70 Table 3-12: [ I A

A A

A N A A

A A

A A

dm J

.9 A

A M

A A

A A

A A

A A

A A

A A

q A

A A

A ii A

A A

A A

A

]

A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A

  • m A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A
  • m A A A A A A A A A A CI I I I A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A

A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A

A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A AIA AIA A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A C I I A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A B A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A C I I M C 1 2 1 M A C 2 1 MII A A A A A A B A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-189, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-71 3.3.2.4 Categorization of Component Items The categorization of component items uses the initial screening results (Section 3.3.2.2) and the FMECA results (Section 3.3.2.3) to separate the component items into Category A, B, and C. Definitions of Categories A, B, and C and their respective criteria are listed in Section 5 of MRP-189, Rev. 1. The results are shown in Table 3-13.

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-1 89, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-72 Table 3-13: [

A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A B A A B C I A AA A A A A A A A A A]

A A A A A A A A A A A

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-1189, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-73 A A A A A A A A A

]

A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A

A A A A A A A A A A

A A A A A A A A A

]

A A A A A A A A A I

[ C I

Controfled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-1 89, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-74 A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A r A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A

[ A A A A A A A A A

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-189, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-75 A A A A A A A A A A

A A A A A A A A A B A A A A A A A B A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A

[A ] A A A A A A A A

[A A A A A A A A A

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-1 89, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-76 A A B B B A A A B A A A A A A A A A

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-189, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-77 3.3.2.5 Engineering Evaluation and Assessment and Categorization for Inspection The component items screened as non-Category A component items in Table 3-13 are as follows:

Controlled DOCimnent AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-1 89, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 3-78 As described in the inspection plan for the ONS units RV Internals [x], the [

] are a part of the typical core support structures that will receive a VT-3 examination during the fourth and future 10-year inservice-inspection (ISI) internals at ONS.

As noted above, these items currently serve no function and should cracking initiate the worst scenario that could occur is that the item (or a piece of the item) could become a loose part. [

]

Therefore the [

I are categorized as "No Additional Measures" for the ONS units and no augmented examinations are required.

Controlled Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-189, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 4-1

4.0 CONCLUSION

S As required by applicant/licensee action item #2 for the MRP-227-A SER, a comparison was made between Table 4-1 and 4-2 in MRP-1 89, Rev. 1 and the component items designated in the scope of license renewal for the ONS units. Once this comparison was made, three component items were identified as being within the scope, but not in the applicable MRP-1 89, Rev. 1 tables. These components items are as follows:

1. Vent Valve Misc. Locking Device Parts (original)
2. Vent Valve Misc. Locking Device Parts (modified)
3. [ I A review of background information pertaining to the vent valve locking devices, both original and modified, and the [ I was made. The appropriate drawings and the items of interest were identified. The MRP-227-A sequence steps were used to propose any necessary modifications to the program defined in MRP-227, as modified by the SER. The material types as well as screening parameters such as temperature, fluence, neutron exposure, and operating stresses were identified. These parameters were then used to compare to the screening criteria from MRP-189, Rev. 1 to perform the initial screening of these items for degradation. A failure modes and effects criticality assessment (FMECA) was performed and a preliminary categorization, using the degradation screening results as well as the FMECA was performed. Finally, an engineering evaluation and assessment was used to categorize the component items for inspection.

The results are as follows:

1. Vent Valve Misc. Locking Device Parts (original) - Categorized as "Category A" or "No Additional Measures"
2. Vent Valve Misc. Locking Device Parts (modified) - Categorized as "Category A" or "No Additional Measures"
3. [ ] - Categorized as "No Additional Measures"

C~otro',Ied Docum[fent AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-189, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 4-2 Loss of material of the locking devices on the original vent valve assemblies due to wear and cracking of the Alloy 600 locking devices on the modified vent valve assemblies due to PWSCC are adequately managed by the ASME B&PV Code Section Xl programmatic controls along with the valve testing and inspection requirements each refueling outage.

However, it is noted that in MRP-227-A the existing program in place for vent valve locking device aging management at ONS is not identified as such in Table 4-7 (of MRP-227-A). Duke is working with the MRP to establish interim guidance to account for this discrepancy and incorporate the appropriate information into the next revision of MRP-227. In this document, ONS assumes that the visual inspections currently performed are equivalent to an Existing Program for MRP-227 implementation.

As described in the inspection plan for the ONS units RV Internals [x], the [

] are a part of the typical core support structures that will receive a VT-3 examination during the fourth and future 10-year inservice-inspection (ISI) internals at ONS.

These items currently serve no function and should cracking initiate the worst scenario that could occur is that the item (or a piece of the item) could become a loose part.

C]

Therefore the [

are categorized as "No Additional Measures" for the ONS units and no augmented examinations are required.

Additionally, during a previous records search, a feature unique to ONS-1 was identified for the plenum cover weldment rib pads. Each of the 32 plenum cover rib pads at

Controlle-d Document AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-189, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 4-3 ONS-1 is fastened to the plenum cover ribs with two Type 304 screws and one Alloy X-750 dowel; at the other B&W units, the plenum cover rib pads are welded to the plenum cover weldment ribs. Since these component items were unknown during the preparatory time of the ONS license renewal scope work and the preparatory work leading up to MRP-227-A, they were not included in either of these tasks. Using the MRP-227-A screening criteria and process, these component items are categorized as "No Additional Measures"; therefore no additional augmented inspection is required for this location.

Controlled Documient AREVA NP Inc. ANP-3186NP Revision 1 ONS License Renewal Scope and MRP-189, Rev. 1 Comparison Page 5-1

5.0 REFERENCES

i. Materials Reliability Program: Pressurized Water Reactor Internals Inspection and Evaluation Guidelines (MRP-227-Rev. 0). EPRI, Palo Alto, CA: 2008. 1016596.

ii. Letter (from Christian Larsen) Report Transmittal: Materials Reliability Program:

Pressurized Water Reactor Internals Inspection and Evaluation Guidelines (MRP-227-0),

EPRI Palo Alto, CA, 2008. 1016596 (NRC Accession No. ML090160204), January 2009.

iii. Final Safety Evaluation of EPRI Report, Materials Reliability Program Report 1016596 (MRP-227), Revision 0, "Pressurized Water Reactor (PWR) Internals Inspection and Evaluation Guidelines" (TAC No. ME0680), NRC Accession No. ML111600498, June 22, 2011.

iv. Revision 1 to the Final Safety Evaluation of Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI)

Report, Materials Reliability Program (MRP) Report 1016596 (MRP-227), Revision 0, "Pressurized Water Reactor (PWR) Internals Inspection and Evaluation Guidelines" (TAC No. ME0680), NRC Accession No. ML11308A770, December 16, 2011.

v. Materials Reliability Program: Pressurized Water Reactor Internals Inspection and Evaluation Guidelines (MRP-227-A). EPRI, Palo Alto, CA: 2011. 1022863.

vi. Nuclear Energy Institute, "Guidelines for the Management of Materials Issues," NEI 03-08, Rev. 2, January 2010. NRC Accession No. ML102880028.

vii. Materials Reliability Program: Screening, Categorization, and Ranking of B&W-Designed PWR Internals Component Items (MRP-189-Rev. 1). EPRI, Palo Alto, CA: 2009.

1018292.

viii. NRC Code of Federal Regulations, Title 10, Part 54, Section 4, "Scope," Last Approved in Federal Register, Volume 64, page 72002, December 23, 1999.

ix. AREVA document 43-2248A, "Demonstration of the Management of Aging Effects for the Reactor Vessel Internals," April 21, 2000. NRC Accession No. ML003708443.

x. "Oconee Units 1, 2, and 3 Proposed License Amendment Request for the Reactor Vessel Internals Inspection Plan, Licensee Amendment Request Number 2010 Supplement 1," June 28, 2012, NRC Accession No. ML12187A214.

xi. "Integrated Reactor Vessel Material Surveillance Program," BAW-1 543, Rev. 2, available from AREVA Inc., Lynchburg, VA, February 1984.

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML13119A041&oldid=2064578"