ML13053A296
| ML13053A296 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Ginna  |
| Issue date: | 02/20/2013 |
| From: | Constellation Energy Nuclear Group, EDF Group, Ginna |
| To: | Division of Operating Reactor Licensing |
| Thadani M | |
| References | |
| Download: ML13053A296 (23) | |
Text
R.E.GinnaNuclearPowerPlant NFPA805 LicenseAmendmentRequest PreApplicationMeetingwithNRCStaff February20,2013
Introductions
CENGRepresentatives ll l k l
l ElliottFlick CENGGenl Manager-FleetEngineering TomMogren GinnaEngineeringManager MichaelLilley GinnaProjectManager,NFPA805 JarredJackson GinnaSupervisor,Licensing JeffStone CENGSupervisor,PRA Sean Gillen Ginna Supervisor Electrical Design SeanGillen GinnaSupervisor,ElectricalDesign RobCavedo CENGPRAPrincipleEngineer ProjectConsultants
- PaulAmico Sr.RiskConsultant,KGRS
- SuzanneLoyd RiskAnalyst,KGRS 2
Agenda OverviewofGinnaDesignFeatures CurrentFireProtectionLicensingBasis NFPA 805TransitionProjectOverview CompliancewithNFPA 805 ProbabilisticRiskAssessmentDevelopment/Results p
/
Implementation Overview Summary Summary 3
OverviewofGinnaDesignFeatures Single unit PWR 1775 MWt SingleunitPWR,1775MWt Westinghouse2loopNSSS Ultimate heat sink is Lake Ontario UltimateheatsinkisLakeOntario InitialOperatingLicenseissuedin1969 Renewed Operating License issued expires in 2029 RenewedOperatingLicenseissued-expiresin2029 4
GinnaCurrentFireProtectionLicensingBasis FireProtectionProgramStandardLicenseCondition 10CFR50.48(a)and(b) 10CFR50,AppendixA,GeneralDesignCriterion3 10CFR50,AppendixR BranchTechnicalPositionAPCSB9.51AppendixA pp CurrentExemptions OperatorActions-ExistingwithNRCapproval p
g pp 5
NFPA805TransitionProjectOverview License Amendment Request (LAR) committed LicenseAmendmentRequest(LAR)committed submittaldate-March29,2013 UsingtheNuclearEnergyInstitute(NEI)LARtemplate g
gy
(
)
p Preparationandinternalreviewactivitiesarein progress p
g WebportalhasbeenestablishedtosupportNRC review 6
NFPA805TransitionProjectOverview Fi P
t ti P
T iti FireProtectionProgramTransition
- LicenseConditionbeingrevised
- Technical Specifications being revised
- TechnicalSpecificationsbeingrevised
- Reviewedexistingexemptions
- WillnotbetransitioninganyexemptionstoNFPA805 7
CompliancewithNFPA805 NFPA805Chapter3Compliance
- ReviewperformedusingNEI0402,Revision2guidanceas supplementedbyFAQ070036 R
i d
t d i B 1 T bl (Att h
t A f LAR)
- ReviewdocumentedinB1Table(AttachmentAofLAR)
- Results
- One Modification -code compliance adding 2 sprinkler heads OneModification codecomplianceadding2sprinklerheads
- 108of120Sections/Subsectionscomplyorcomplywithevaluation
- 4Complywithclarifications 3 C l
ith P i NRC A l
- 3ComplywithPriorNRCApproval
- 5SubmitforNRCApproval 8
CompliancewithNFPA805 N
P O
ti NonPowerOperations
- ReviewperformedusingNEI 0402,Revision2guidanceas supplemented by FAQ 070040 supplementedbyFAQ07 0040
- ResultsofReview
- Allsuccesspathsidentified
- CompletecomponentlistbyKeySafetyFunction
- HighRiskEvolutions
- PinchPointsidentified
- RecommendationstomanageFireRisk 9
CompliancewithNFPA805 Radioactive Release RadioactiveRelease
- ReviewperformedusingNEI 0402,Revision2guidanceas supplementedbyFAQ090056 pp y
- PlantevaluatedonaFireZonebasis
- Creditengineeringcontrolsforgaseousandliquideffluents
- RevisedPreFirePlansandTrainingmaterialtoclarify monitoringandcontrolrequirements Procedure changes and training program revisions are
- Procedurechangesandtrainingprogramrevisionsare complete 10
CompliancewithNFPA 805 NuclearSafetyCapabilityAssessment
- Review performed using NEI 0402, Revision 2 guidance as ReviewperformedusingNEI 04 02,Revision2guidanceas supplementedbyFAQ080054
- FireAreaReview C
E l
- CommonEnclosures
- SuppressionInitiationEffects
- ExtensiveBreakerCoordinationAnalysisperformed M l i l S i
O i
i
- MultipleSpuriousOperationsreview
- Results:
- NoFireAreastobetransitioneddeterministically
- All16FireAreastobetransitionedusingRiskInformed(RI)
PerformanceBased(PB)method 11
CompliancewithNFPA805 SafeandStable(STS):
- Originally defined as Cold Shutdown OriginallydefinedasColdShutdown
- WhilecompletingNSCA,changedtoHotShutdown NFPA805guidancepointstoHotStandbyforPWRs
- STSdefinesHotStandbyas:
- Mode 3
- RxMwt N/A
- RCSTemp>350°F Gi H
Sh d
ll f h STS d fi i i GinnaHotShutdownmeetsalloftheSTSdefinition TitlesofModes3and4arereversedatGinna.
12
CompliancewithNFPA805 Recovery Actions RecoveryActions
- ReviewperformedusingNEI 0402,Revision2guidanceas supplementedbyFAQ070030
- PrimaryControlStation
- 3AppendixRAlternateShutdownLocations 7 U i R
ti
- 7UniqueRecoveryactions 13
CompliancewithNFPA 805 MonitoringProgram F ll i
FAQ 10 0059 R i i 5
id
- FollowingFAQ100059,Revision5guidance
- NSEL andFPRA Components
- IncludeanynewfunctionsinexistingMaintenanceRuleProgram y
g g
- NPOComponents,Rad ReleaseSystems,FPProgram Components I
l d i l S d P H
l h M i
i
- IncludeinnormalSystemandProgramHealthMonitoring
- FPSystemsandFeatures
- LowSafetySignificant-NormalSystem/ProgramHealthMonitoring y
g y
/
g g
- HighSafetySignificant-NFPA805SpecificMonitoringProgramthat usestheMaintenanceRuleProgramsoftware 14
PRADevelopment/Results FirePRAbuiltonahighqualityInternalEventsmodel
- FullpeerreviewtoRG1.200,Revision1in2009
- FocusedscopepeerreviewtoRG1.200,Revision2in2011 Fi PRA i
d b PWROG i J 2012 FirePRApeerreviewedbyPWROGinJune2012
- Totalof44Facts&Observations(F&Os)
- 19 Findings
- 19Findings
- 22Suggestions
- 3 BestPractices
- AllF&Os subsequentlyaddressed
- Nounreviewed methodsused 15
PRADevelopment/Results Overall Plant Risk PostTransition OverallPlantRiskPostTransition
- TotalFireCDF=3.35E5/yrandLERF=1.27E6/yr
- Total CDF = 5 05E5/yr and LERF = 3 25E6/yr
- TotalCDF=5.05E5/yrandLERF=3.25E6/yr
- Sufficientmargintoaccountfornonquantified hazards TheresultsoftheRIPBevaluationmeetthe requirementsofNFPA805andRG1.174 16
PRADevelopment/Results Deltariskincludesinternaleventsriskreduction from NFPA 805 modifications fromNFPA805modifications Metric FireDelta IE Delta NetDelta CDF 1.53E5/yr 6.05E6 9.22E6/yr Fi d lt P
t t iti C
li t ( ith 805 M d )
LERF 9.25E7/yr 3.30E7 5.95E7/yr
- Firedelta=Posttransition Compliant(with805Mods)
- IEdelta=Current Posttransition 17
ImplementationOverview ModificationsPlanned 17 Total Modifications Credited in FPRA
- 17TotalModificationsCreditedinFPRA
- 1PreviouslymentionedforNFPACodecompliance
- 2modificationscreditedwerealreadyinprogress Process/ProcedureChanges Training
- Training
- OperatorResponseforRecoveryActions
- FireBrigadeResponse g
p
- DesignChangeProcess 18
MajorModificationsCredited PowerfortheStandbyAuxiliaryFeedWater(AFW) pumps will be able to be supplied by a dedicated Diesel pumpswillbeabletobesuppliedbyadedicatedDiesel Generator(DG)intheStandbyAFWpumproomwith availableconnectionsforasecondportableDG InstallshutdownsealsonbothReactorCoolantPumps tominimizesealleakageduringafireinducedlossof sealinjection 19 19
MajorModificationsCredited InstallastandbyhighheadpumpintheSBAFWbuilding to be free from the effects of a fire outside the charging tobefreefromtheeffectsofafireoutsidethecharging pumproom InstalldisconnectsintheControlRoomforPORVs,,
Letdownorificevalves,LetdownIsolation,andExcess letdownisolation.
Installadditionalprotectedindicationinthecontrol roomforPressurizerpressureandsteamgeneratorlevel 20 20
MajorModificationsCredited Installovercurrent protectionforbothDGsthatisnot impacted by a fire outside the DG Rooms impactedbyafireoutsidetheDGRooms Provide a diverse Reactor trip from protected Pressurizer ProvideadiverseReactortripfromprotectedPressurizer highpressuresignaltoopenRodDriveMGsupplyAC.
UpgradedesignofHEMYCforspecifiedcircuitsin BatteryRoomB.
y 21 21
MajorModificationsCredited ProvideautoisolationofspecifiedContainment Isolation/Containment Ventilation Isolation valves on Isolation/ContainmentVentilationIsolationvalveson lowPressurizerpressuresignal.
ProvideanautoclosureofPORVsonPressurizerlow pressuresignal.
ProvideautomaticclosureoftheMSIVson2of2lowSG waterlevelprotectedchannels.
22 22
Summary CompleteLARtobesubmittedonorbeforeMarch 29, 2013 29,2013 NoalternativeFirePRAmethods Significant Modifications planned SignificantModificationsplanned TransitionSchedule
- Implement procedure/process changes 6 months after SER Implementprocedure/processchanges6monthsafterSER
- Completionofmodificationsby1st RefuelingOutagemore than12monthsafterSER 23