ML113340418
| ML113340418 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Crystal River  |
| Issue date: | 11/28/2011 |
| From: | NRC/RGN-II/DRS/OLB |
| To: | Progress Energy Florida |
| References | |
| 50-302/11-301 | |
| Download: ML113340418 (55) | |
Text
CRYSTAL RIVER UNIT 3 JPM COVER SHEET ADMIN JPM #CO1 NRC 2011 RO / SRO PERFORM AN RCS BORON CHANGE CALCULATION PREPARED/REVIEWED BY:
Jim Gregitis Date: 07/10/11 VALIDATED BY:
B. Wooten / B. Webster / R. Virgin Date: 07/10/11 APPROVAL BY:
Mark VanSicklen Date: 07/27/11 (Nuclear Training Supervisor)
CONCURRED BY:
Mike Kelly Date: 07/28/11 (Operations Representative)
Validation is not required for minor enhancements, procedure revisions that do not affect the JPM or individual step changes that do not affect the flow of the JPM.
Operations concurrence is required for new JPMs and changes that affect the flow, critical steps or time critical steps of the JPM. Operations concurrence is not required for changes that are required due to a procedure revision.
ADMINISTRATIVE JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE 7/26/2011 Page 2 of 12 Admin CO1 (NRC 2011)
JPM #: Admin CO2 - NRC 2011 Task: Determine a reactor coolant boron change calculation.
Alternate Path:
YES NO PRA Top Critical Action:
YES NO Safety Function: NA K/A Rating/Importance:
G2.1.37 RO 4.3 SRO 4.6 Task Number:
0020102029 - RO Position:
SRO ONLY RO/SRO NLO/RO/SRO Task Standard: Perform a reactor coolant boron change calculation using OP-304.
Preferred Evaluation Location:
Preferred Evaluation Method:
SIM PLANT ADMIN PERFORM SIMULATE
References:
OP-304, Rev 33 OP-103C, Rev 31 Validation Time: 30 minutes Time Critical:
YES NO
=========================================================
Candidate: ______________________________
Time Start:
Printed Name Time Finish:
Performance Rating:
SAT UNSAT Performance Time:
Examiner: ___________________________________ _____________________________/_______
Printed Name Signature Date Comment: _________________________________________________________________________
ADMINISTRATIVE JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE 7/26/2011 Page 3 of 12 Admin CO1 (NRC 2011)
SIMULATOR OPERATOR SETUP INSTRUCTIONS
- 1.
None SIMULATOR OPERATOR INSTRUCTIONS
- 1.
None TOOLS/EQUIPMENT/PROCEDURES NEEDED
- 1.
Consumable copies of OP-304, Rev 33
- 2.
Consumable copies of OP-103C, Rev 31
- 3.
Calculators
ADMINISTRATIVE JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE 7/26/2011 Page 4 of 12 Admin CO1 (NRC 2011)
READ TO THE OPERATOR INITIAL CONDITIONS You are the Reactor Operator.
The following plant conditions exist:
Rx power:
80%
Initial rod index:
280%
EFPD:
300 INITIATING CUES The CRS has directed you to perform the boron change required to achieve the following final plant conditions:
Rx power:
100%
Final rod index:
280%
Do NOT consider the effects of Xenon.
SWQL B OP304.XLS is NOT available.
Document your answer below.
ANSWER RCS boron concentration must be raised / lowered by __________ ppm (B).
(circle one)
ADMINISTRATIVE JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE 7/26/2011 Page 5 of 12 Admin CO1 (NRC 2011)
EXAMINERS NOTE: FOR STEPS DENOTED AS CRITICAL STEP, WHICH HAVE MULTIPLE ACTIONS, THE INDIVIDUAL REQUIRED ACTION WILL BE DENOTED CS. IF NO INDIVIDUAL ACTIONS ARE DENOTED AS SUCH THEN ALL ACTIONS WITHIN THE STEP ARE DEEMED CRITICAL.
TIME START STEP 1:
Obtain copy of appropriate procedure.
STANDARD:
Candidate obtains a copy of OP-304.
EXAMINER NOTE:
Provide candidate with a copy of OP-304. When candidate asks for OP-103C, provide him/her a copy at that time.
COMMENTS:
SAT UNSAT STEP 2:
(OP-304 Enclosure 4 Step 1)
Record initial plant data.
STANDARD:
Candidate accurately transfers data to Enclosure 4.
Rx Power 80%
Rod Index 280%
EFPD 300 COMMENTS:
SAT UNSAT
ADMINISTRATIVE JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE 7/26/2011 Page 6 of 12 Admin CO1 (NRC 2011)
STEP 3:
(OP-304 Enclosure 4 Step 2)
Record final plant data.
STANDARD:
Candidate accurately transfers data to Enclosure 4.
Rx Power 100%
Rod Index 280%
COMMENTS:
SAT UNSAT STEP 4:
(OP-304 Enclosure 4 Step 3)
Determine Reactivity for reactor power R1RP (Initial) and R2RP (Final).
STANDARD:
Using OP-103C curve 15, candidate determines R1RP to be 0.2056% k/k and R2RP to be 0% k/k. Candidate accurately transfers data to.
EXAMINER NOTE:
Acceptable ranges for R1RP is 0.19% k/k to 0.21% k/k due to readability of curve 15.
COMMENTS:
Critical Step Basis:
Reactivity Management SAT UNSAT
ADMINISTRATIVE JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE 7/26/2011 Page 7 of 12 Admin CO1 (NRC 2011)
STEP 5:
(OP-304 Enclosure 4 Step 4)
Determine Reactivity for rod index R1RI (Initial) and R2RI (Final).
STANDARD:
Using OP-103C curve 14, candidate determines R1RI and R2RI to be
-0.1349% k/k. Candidate accurately transfers data to Enclosure 4.
EXAMINER NOTE:
Step is not critical due to no change in rod height.
COMMENTS:
SAT UNSAT STEP 6:
(OP-304 Enclosure 4 Step 5)
Determine total reactivity R1T (Initial) and R2T (Final).
STANDARD:
Candidate accurately calculates R1T (Initial) and R2T (Final) and transfers to Enclosure 4.
R1T = R1RP + R1RI = 0.2056% k/k - 0.1349% k/k = 0.0707% k/k R2T = R2RP + R2RI = 0% k/k - 0.1349% k/k = -0.1349% k/k COMMENTS:
SAT UNSAT
ADMINISTRATIVE JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE 7/26/2011 Page 8 of 12 Admin CO1 (NRC 2011)
STEP 7:
(OP-304 Enclosure 4 Step 6)
Determine R (Change in reactivity).
STANDARD:
Candidate accurately calculates R and transfers to Enclosure 4.
R = R2T - R1T = -0.1349% k/k - (0.0707% k/k) = - 0.2056% k/k COMMENTS:
SAT UNSAT STEP 8:
(OP-304 Enclosure 4 Step 7)
Determine IB (Inverse Boron worth).
STANDARD:
Using OP-103C curve 4, candidate determines IB to be 157.2 ppm/%k/k.
Candidate accurately transfers data to Enclosure 4.
EXAMINER NOTE:
Acceptable range for IB is 156.2 ppm/%k/k to 158.2 ppm/%k/k due to readability of curve 4.
COMMENTS:
Critical Step Basis:
Reactivity Management SAT UNSAT
ADMINISTRATIVE JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE 7/26/2011 Page 9 of 12 Admin CO1 (NRC 2011)
STEP 9:
(OP-304 Enclosure 4 Step 8)
Determine B (Change in RCS boron). Raise boron if positive, lower boron if negative.
STANDARD:
Candidate accurately calculates B and transfers to Enclosure 4.
B = (R)(IB) = (-0.2056% k/k)(157.2 ppm/%k/k) = -32.32 ppm Candidate determines boron must be lowered by 32.32 ppm.
EXAMINER NOTE:
Acceptable range for B is -29 ppm to -34 ppm due to previous acceptability ranges (Lower boron by 29 ppm to 34 ppm).
COMMENTS:
Critical Step Basis:
Reactivity Management SAT UNSAT TERMINATION CUE: OP-304 Enclosure 4 complete.
END OF TASK TIME STOP
ADMINISTRATIVE JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE 7/26/2011 Page 10 of 12 Admin CO1 (NRC 2011)
ENCLOSURE 4 (Page 1 of 2)
ON-LINE REACTIVITY MANAGEMENT
- 1.
Record initial plant data.
Rx POWER 80 %
ROD INDEX 280 %
R1XE Saxon N/A %k/k EFPD Saxon 300
- 2.
Record final plant data.
Rx POWER 100 %
ROD INDEX 280 %
USE CAUTION TO ENSURE PROPER SIGNS ARE MAINTAINED DURING ALL CALCULATIONS.
R2XE Saxon N/A %k/k
- 3.
Determine Reactivity for reactor power R1RP (Initial) and R2RP (Final)
Use OP-103C curve 15 R1RP 0.2056 %k/k R2RP 0 %k/k
- 4.
Determine Reactivity for rod index R1RI (Initial) and R2RI (Final)
Use OP-103C curve 14 R1RI
-0.1349 %k/k R2RI
-0.1349 %k/k
- 5.
Determine total reactivity R1T (Initial) and R2T (Final) 1 R
+
1 R
+
1 R
=
1 R
XE RI RP T
k k
+
k k
+
k k
=
1 R
T
2 R
+
2 R
+
2 R
=
2 R
XE RI RP T
k k
+
k k
+
k k
=
2 R
T
R1T 0.0707 %k/k R2T
-0.1349 %k/k
- 6.
Determine R (Change in reactivity) 1 R
2 R
=
R T
T
k k
k k
=
R
R
-0.2056 %k/k Continue calculation on next page ANSWER KEY
ADMINISTRATIVE JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE 7/26/2011 Page 11 of 12 Admin CO1 (NRC 2011)
ENCLOSURE 4 (Page 2 of 2)
ON-LINE REACTIVITY MANAGEMENT
- 7.
Determine IB (Inverse Boron worth)
Use OP-103C curve 4 for current EFPD If reactor power is >18%, use HFP values.
IB 157.2000 ppm / %k/k
- 8.
Determine B (Change in RCS boron).
Raise boron if positive, lower boron if negative.
)
IB
( )
R
(
=
B
)
k k
ppm
)(
k k
( =
B
B
-32.32 ppm PERFORMED BY DATE VERIFIED BY DATE ANSWER KEY
ADMINISTRATIVE JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE CANDIDATE CUE SHEET (TO BE RETURNED TO EXAMINER UPON COMPLETION OF TASK)
INITIAL CONDITIONS You are the Reactor Operator.
The following plant conditions exist:
Rx power:
80%
Initial rod index:
280%
EFPD:
300 INITIATING CUES The CRS has directed you to perform the boron change required to achieve the following final plant conditions:
Rx power:
100%
Final rod index:
280%
Do NOT consider the effects of Xenon.
SWQL B OP304.XLS is NOT available.
Document your answer below.
ANSWER RCS boron concentration must be raised / lowered by __________ ppm (B).
(circle one)
CRYSTAL RIVER UNIT 3 JPM COVER SHEET ADMIN JPM #CO2 NRC 2011 RO / SRO CALCULATE SDM WITH A MISALIGNED CONTROL ROD PREPARED/REVIEWED BY:
Jim Gregitis Date: 05/24/11 VALIDATED BY:
B. Wooten / B. Webster / R. Virgin Date: 07/10/11 APPROVAL BY:
Mark VanSicklen Date: 07/27/11 (Nuclear Training Supervisor)
CONCURRED BY:
Mike Kelly Date: 07/28/11 (Operations Representative)
Validation is not required for minor enhancements, procedure revisions that do not affect the JPM or individual step changes that do not affect the flow of the JPM.
Operations concurrence is required for new JPMs and changes that affect the flow, critical steps or time critical steps of the JPM. Operations concurrence is not required for changes that are required due to a procedure revision.
ADMINISTRATIVE JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE 7/26/2011 Page 2 of 14 Admin CO2 (NRC 2011)
JPM #: Admin CO2 - NRC 2011 Task: Determine Shutdown Margin (SDM).
Alternate Path:
YES NO PRA Top Critical Action:
YES NO Safety Function: NA K/A Rating/Importance:
G2.1.7 RO 3.7 SRO 4.4 G2.2.40 SRO 4.7 Task Number:
1150202005 - RO 1190201006 - SRO Position:
SRO ONLY RO/SRO NLO/RO/SRO Task Standard: Determine SDM using SP-421, Reactivity Balance Calculations.
Preferred Evaluation Location:
Preferred Evaluation Method:
SIM PLANT ADMIN PERFORM SIMULATE
References:
OP-103C, Rev 31 SP-421, Rev 61 TS 3.1.4 Validation Time: 15 minutes Time Critical:
YES NO
=========================================================
Candidate: ______________________________
Time Start:
Printed Name Time Finish:
Performance Rating:
SAT UNSAT Performance Time:
Examiner: ___________________________________ _____________________________/_______
Printed Name Signature Date Comment: _________________________________________________________________________
ADMINISTRATIVE JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE 7/26/2011 Page 3 of 14 Admin CO2 (NRC 2011)
SIMULATOR OPERATOR SETUP INSTRUCTIONS
- 1.
None SIMULATOR OPERATOR INSTRUCTIONS
- 1.
None TOOLS/EQUIPMENT/PROCEDURES NEEDED
- 1.
Consumable copies of OP-103C, Rev 31
- 2.
Consumable copies of SP-421, Rev 61
- 3.
Copies of ITS
- 4.
Calculators
ADMINISTRATIVE JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE 7/26/2011 Page 4 of 14 Admin CO2 (NRC 2011)
READ TO THE OPERATOR INITIAL CONDITIONS You are the Balance of Plant Operator.
With the plant initially at 100% power, control rod 6-6 dropped from its group average height of 80% to the 60% withdrawn position and has been determined to be untrippable.
The plant is now stable at 60% power.
210 EFPD Xenon value from current Saxon is -2.13% k/k. (This value must be used for calculation.)
Boron-10 atom percent is 19.8.
RCS temperature is 579° F.
INITIATING CUES The Control Room Supervisor has directed you to verify if adequate SDM exists using SP-421, Reactivity Balance Calculations. Enter SDM below and document additional actions, if any, you would perform.
SROs only: After calculating SDM, determine if any TS actions are required.
Include applicable time requirements. Document your answer below.
ADMINISTRATIVE JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE 7/26/2011 Page 5 of 14 Admin CO2 (NRC 2011)
EXAMINERS NOTE: FOR STEPS DENOTED AS CRITICAL STEP, WHICH HAVE MULTIPLE ACTIONS, THE INDIVIDUAL REQUIRED ACTION WILL BE DENOTED CS. IF NO INDIVIDUAL ACTIONS ARE DENOTED AS SUCH THEN ALL ACTIONS WITHIN THE STEP ARE DEEMED CRITICAL.
TIME START STEP 1:
Locate procedures.
STANDARD:
Candidate obtains a copy of SP-421 and OP-103C.
EXAMINER NOTE:
Provide candidate with a copy of SP-421. When the candidate asks for OP-103C, provide it to him/her at that time.
COMMENTS:
SAT UNSAT
ADMINISTRATIVE JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE 7/26/2011 Page 6 of 14 Admin CO2 (NRC 2011)
STEP 2:
Determine correct enclosure to use.
STANDARD:
Candidate determines that Enclosure 1B, One Hour Misaligned Rod Shutdown Margin Calculation, is the enclosure to be used.
EXAMINER NOTE:
If candidate determines that Enclosure 1, Shutdown Margin -
Normal Conditions, is to be used, allow the candidate to complete the JPM since both enclosures will result at the same endpoint.
Make a note of this and during the final exam review point out to the candidate that Enclosure 1B was created just for this type of plant condition.
COMMENTS:
SAT UNSAT
ADMINISTRATIVE JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE 7/26/2011 Page 7 of 14 Admin CO2 (NRC 2011)
STEP 3:
(SP-421 Enclosure 1B Step 1)
Enter core burnup.
STANDARD:
Candidate accurately transfers data from Cue Sheet to enclosure.
COMMENTS:
SAT UNSAT
ADMINISTRATIVE JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE 7/26/2011 Page 8 of 14 Admin CO2 (NRC 2011)
STEP 4:
(SP-421 Enclosure 1B Step 2)
Determine Boron Reactivity.
- 1.
Enter RCS Boron Concentration. (Cue Sheet)
- 2.
Enter B-10 atom percent. (Cue Sheet)
- 3.
Calculate B-10 adjusted value.
- 4.
Enter RCS temperature. (Cue Sheet)
- 5.
Use Curve 19 to determine boron concentration required for Shutdown Margin. (CS)
- 6.
Use Curve 3 to determine differential boron worth. (CS)
- 7.
Perform calculation to determine boron reactivity. (CS)
STANDARD:
Candidate accurately transfers data from Cue Sheet, determines correct curves to use and accurately calculates the value for boron reactivity.
EXAMINER NOTE:
Values must be within limits on attached key.
COMMENTS:
Critical Step Basis:
Accurate curve selection and calculation required to determine adequate SDM.
SAT UNSAT
ADMINISTRATIVE JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE 7/26/2011 Page 9 of 14 Admin CO2 (NRC 2011)
STEP 5:
(SP-421 Enclosure 1B Step 3)
Determine Control Rod Group Reactivity.
STANDARD:
Candidate notes that no credit will be taken for APSR position in shutdown margin calculations.
COMMENTS:
SAT UNSAT STEP 6:
(SP-421 Enclosure 1B Step 4)
Determine Xenon Reactivity.
STANDARD:
Candidate accurately transfers data from Cue Sheet to enclosure.
COMMENTS:
SAT UNSAT
ADMINISTRATIVE JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE 7/26/2011 Page 10 of 14 Admin CO2 (NRC 2011)
STEP 7:
(SP-421 Enclosure 1B Step 5)
Determine SDM.
- 1.
Calculate SDM.
- 2.
If SDM is determined to be less negative than -1.0% k/k then SDM is unacceptable. Immediately notify the CRS and refer to TS 3.1.1.
- 3.
If SDM is determined to be equal to or more negative than -1.0%
k/k then SDM is acceptable.
STANDARD:
Candidate determines that SDM is unacceptable and notifies the CRS.
EXAMINER NOTE:
Value must be within limits on attached key.
COMMENTS:
Critical Step Basis:
Accurate calculation and immediate notification of the CRS is required to comply with TS.
SAT UNSAT TERMINATION CUE: SDM calculation complete and unacceptability determined.
RO - END OF TASK
ADMINISTRATIVE JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE 7/26/2011 Page 11 of 14 Admin CO2 (NRC 2011)
STEP 8:
(SRO Only)
Refer to TS 3.1.4, Control Rod Group Alignment Limits, and determine required actions.
STANDARD:
Candidate determines that the following actions are required (TS 3.1.4 Condition D):
- 1.
Initiate boration to restore SDM within 1 hour1.157407e-5 days <br />2.777778e-4 hours <br />1.653439e-6 weeks <br />3.805e-7 months <br />.
- 2.
Be in Mode 3 within 6 hours6.944444e-5 days <br />0.00167 hours <br />9.920635e-6 weeks <br />2.283e-6 months <br />.
EXAMINERS NOTE:
TS 3.1.1, Shutdown Margin (SDM), is only applicable in Modes 3, 4, and 5. Per the Cue Sheet, the plant is in Mode 1.
COMMENTS:
Critical Step Basis:
TS required actions SAT UNSAT TERMINATION CUE: TS required actions determined.
SRO - END OF TASK TIME STOP
ADMINISTRATIVE JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE 7/26/2011 Page 12 of 14 Admin CO2 (NRC 2011)
ENCLOSURE 1B (Page 1 of 3)
ONE HOUR MISALIGNED ROD SHUTDOWN MARGIN CALCULATION NOTES For this enclosure the following applies:
(1)
It is permissible to round EFPD, boron, %wd, and ºF to the nearest Integer.
(2)
For RCS > 532 degrees F, 532 degrees F data may be used.
(3)
Two decimal place accuracy is required for reactivity terms in calculations.
- 1.
Core Burnup Core Burnup = EFPD (from SAXON)
= 210 EFPD
- 2.
Boron Reactivity
- a.
Measured RCS Boron Concentration
= 1109 ppmB NOTE The reference Boron-10 (B-10) atom percent (a/o) is 19.8 for all calculations used in deriving the reactivity curves in OP-103C.
- b.
B-10 atom percent of RCS Boron
= 19.8 a/o supplied by an approved Reactor Engineering Operational Communication (ROC).
- c.
B-10 adjusted Boron Concentration is Step 2(a)
- Step 2(b) / 19.8
= 1109 ppmB
- d.
RCS temperature
= 579 ° F.
- e.
Using RCS temperature from 2(d) and core burnup from Step 1, determine the Boron concentration required for shutdown from appropriate Curve 18 or Curve 19 of OP-103C.
=
1602 ppmB (LIMIT 1590 to 1610)
- f.
Differential boron worth from Curve 3 of OP-103C, Reactivity Worth Curves.
= 0.6984 % k/k /100 ppm (LIMIT 0.69 to 0.71)
- g.
Reactivity During Modes 1,2,3,4, and 5 Reactivity = [(e-c) x f/100] - 1.0
= [( 1602
- 1109 ) x 0.6984
/ 100] - 1.0 = + / - + 2.44
% k/k (LIMIT + 2.32 to + 2.51)
ADMINISTRATIVE JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE 7/26/2011 Page 13 of 14 Admin CO2 (NRC 2011)
ENCLOSURE 1B (Page 2 of 3)
ONE HOUR MISALIGNED ROD SHUTDOWN MARGIN CALCULATION (Cont'd)
- 3.
Control Rod Group 8 Reactivity No credit will be taken for APSR position in shutdown margin calculations.
NOTE (1)
For the one hour misaligned rod calculation ONLY, the value for xenon calculated prior to the misaligned rod for this hour may still be used provided that:
the existing SAXON printout accurately reflects the core conditions prior to the misaligned rod, and the maximum post-misaligned rod power level is less than, or equal to, the power level used on the existing SAXON printout for calculating this hour's xenon.
(2)
Using a xenon value of 0.0% k/k is conservative and may be used at any time.
- 4.
Xenon Reactivity
- a.
Obtain Xenon reactivity from Saxon code (submit printout).
- b.
IF the Saxon code is unavailable, THEN use 0.0% k/k or contact Reactor Engineering for a value (0.0% k/k is conservative and therefore preferred). - 2.13 % k/k
- 5.
Shutdown Margin Determine the shutdown margin by adding Items 2 and 4 above, and round to the nearest hundredth
+ 2.44
+ - 2.13
= + / - + 0.31
% k/k (LIMIT + 0.19 to + 0.38)
Item 2 Item 4
- a.
IF the shutdown margin determined in Step 5, rounded to tenths, is less negative than -1.0%
k/k (i.e., zero, positive or between 0.0 and -1.0).
THEN the shutdown margin is unacceptable. IMMEDIATELY inform the Control Room Supervisor and refer to ITS 3.1.1.
- b.
IF the shutdown margin determined in Step 5, rounded to tenths, is equal to or more negative than -1.0% k/k, THEN the shutdown margin is acceptable.
Calculated By:
Date/Time:
Checked By:
Date/Time;
ADMINISTRATIVE JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE CANDIDATE CUE SHEET (TO BE RETURNED TO EXAMINER UPON COMPLETION OF TASK)
INITIAL CONDITIONS You are the Balance of Plant Operator.
With the plant initially at 100% power, control rod 6-6 dropped from its group average height of 80% to the 60% withdrawn position and has been determined to be untrippable.
The plant is now stable at 60% power.
210 EFPD Xenon value from current Saxon is -2.13% k/k. (This value must be used for calculation.)
Boron-10 atom percent is 19.8.
RCS temperature is 579° F.
INITIATING CUES The Control Room Supervisor has directed you to verify if adequate SDM exists using SP-421, Reactivity Balance Calculations. Enter SDM below and document additional actions, if any, you would perform.
SROs only: After calculating SDM, determine if any TS actions are required.
Include applicable time requirements. Document your answer below.
CRYSTAL RIVER UNIT 3 JPM COVER SHEET ADMIN JPM #EC1 NRC 2011 RO / SRO PERFORM A QPTR CALCULATION PREPARED/REVIEWED BY:
Jim Gregitis Date: 05/25/11 VALIDATED BY:
B. Wooten / B. Webster / R. Virgin Date: 07/07/11 APPROVAL BY:
Mark VanSicklen Date: 07/27/11 (Nuclear Training Supervisor)
CONCURRED BY:
Mike Kelly Date: 07/28/11 (Operations Representative)
Validation is not required for minor enhancements, procedure revisions that do not affect the JPM or individual step changes that do not affect the flow of the JPM.
Operations concurrence is required for new JPMs and changes that affect the flow, critical steps or time critical steps of the JPM. Operations concurrence is not required for changes that are required due to a procedure revision.
ADMINISTRATIVE JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE 7/26/2011 Page 2 of 13 Admin EC1 (NRC 2011)
JPM #: Admin EC1 - NRC 2011 Task: Perform a QPTR calculation.
Alternate Path:
YES NO PRA Top Critical Action:
YES NO Safety Function: NA K/A Rating/Importance:
G2.2.12 RO 3.7 SRO 4.1 G2.2.40 SRO 4.7 Task Number:
0150202001 - RO 1190201006 - SRO Position:
SRO ONLY RO/SRO NLO/RO/SRO Task Standard: Perform a QPTR calculation using SP-303, Tilt Monitoring with an Unavailable Incore System.
Preferred Evaluation Location:
Preferred Evaluation Method:
SIM PLANT ADMIN PERFORM SIMULATE
References:
COLR (Cycle 17)
SP-303, Rev 6 TS 3.2.4 Validation Time: 20 minutes Time Critical:
YES NO
=========================================================
Candidate: ______________________________
Time Start:
Printed Name Time Finish:
Performance Rating:
SAT UNSAT Performance Time:
Examiner: ___________________________________ _____________________________/_______
Printed Name Signature Date Comment: _________________________________________________________________________
ADMINISTRATIVE JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE 7/26/2011 Page 3 of 13 Admin EC1 (NRC 2011)
SIMULATOR OPERATOR SETUP INSTRUCTIONS
- 1.
None SIMULATOR OPERATOR INSTRUCTIONS
- 1.
None TOOLS/EQUIPMENT/PROCEDURES NEEDED
- 1.
Consumable copies of SP-303, Rev 6
- 2.
Copies of COLR (Cycle 17)
- 3.
Copies of ITS
- 4.
Calculators
ADMINISTRATIVE JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE 7/26/2011 Page 4 of 13 Admin EC1 (NRC 2011)
READ TO THE OPERATOR INITIAL CONDITIONS You are the Balance of Plant Operator.
The plant has been stable at this power level for the previous 3 hours3.472222e-5 days <br />8.333333e-4 hours <br />4.960317e-6 weeks <br />1.1415e-6 months <br />.
The Symmetrical Incore Detector System is inoperable.
Current NI values from the control console are:
NI-5 = 62%
NI-6 = 63%
NI-7 = 63%
NI-8 = 68%
Tc = 0.3° F Rod Index is 245%.
INITIATING CUES The Control Room Supervisor has directed you to calculate current out-of-core QPT using SP-303, Tilt Monitoring with an Unavailable Symmetric Incore System. Enter AOT (adjusted out-of-core tilt) values below and document additional actions, if any, you would perform.
SP-303, Enclosure 1, Table 1 is attached.
NI-5 AOT =
NI-6 AOT =
NI-7 AOT =
NI-8 AOT =
SROs only: After calculating AOT, determine if any TS actions are required.
Document your answer below.
ADMINISTRATIVE JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE 7/26/2011 Page 5 of 13 Admin EC1 (NRC 2011)
EXAMINERS NOTE: FOR STEPS DENOTED AS CRITICAL STEP, WHICH HAVE MULTIPLE ACTIONS, THE INDIVIDUAL REQUIRED ACTION WILL BE DENOTED CS. IF NO INDIVIDUAL ACTIONS ARE DENOTED AS SUCH THEN ALL ACTIONS WITHIN THE STEP ARE DEEMED CRITICAL.
TIME START STEP 1:
Locate procedure.
STANDARD:
Candidate obtains a copy of SP-303.
EXAMINER NOTE:
Provide candidate with a copy of SP-303.
COMMENTS:
SAT UNSAT STEP 2:
(SP-303 Enclosure 3 Step 1)
Record time, current NI power levels, Tc and Reg Rod Index in Table 3.
STANDARD:
Candidate accurately transfers data from Cue Sheet to Table 3.
COMMENTS:
SAT UNSAT
ADMINISTRATIVE JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE 7/26/2011 Page 6 of 13 Admin EC1 (NRC 2011)
STEP 3:
(SP-303 Enclosure 3 Step 2)
Obtain the appropriate normalization constants (N) for each quadrant from Section 4.1 and record in Table 3.
STANDARD:
Candidate accurately transfers data from Table 1 (provided) to Table 3.
COMMENTS:
SAT UNSAT
ADMINISTRATIVE JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE 7/26/2011 Page 7 of 13 Admin EC1 (NRC 2011)
STEP 4:
(SP-303 Enclosure 3 Step 3a)
Calculate the current average NI power.
STANDARD:
Candidate accurately calculates an average NI power of 64%.
COMMENTS:
SAT UNSAT STEP 5:
(SP-303 Enclosure 3 Step 3b)
Calculate the current out-of-core tilt (OCD) in each quadrant.
STANDARD:
Candidate accurately calculates OCD tilt for each quadrant.
COMMENTS:
SAT UNSAT STEP 6:
(SP-303 Enclosure 3 Step 4)
Record the current OCD for each Quadrant in Table 3.
STANDARD:
Candidate accurately transfers data to Table 3.
COMMENTS:
SAT UNSAT
ADMINISTRATIVE JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE 7/26/2011 Page 8 of 13 Admin EC1 (NRC 2011)
STEP 7:
(SP-303 Enclosure 3 Step 5)
Calculate adjusted out-of-core tilt (AOT) for each quadrant.
STANDARD:
Candidate accurately calculates AOT for each quadrant.
EXAMINER NOTE:
Values must be + 0.1 of values listed on attached key.
COMMENTS:
Critical Step Basis:
Accurate calculation of AOT for each quadrant SAT UNSAT STEP 8:
(SP-303 Enclosure 3 Step 6)
Record AOT values for each Quadrant in Table 3.
STANDARD:
Candidate accurately transfers data to Table 3.
COMMENTS:
SAT UNSAT
ADMINISTRATIVE JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE 7/26/2011 Page 9 of 13 Admin EC1 (NRC 2011)
STEP 9:
(SP-303 Step 4.2.2)
Compare the current AOT for each quadrant to the Power Range Channels QPT limit in the COLR.
STANDARD:
Candidate determines that Quadrant ZW AOT exceeds a COLR Power Range Channel QPT limit (above the Transient Limit and below the Maximum Limit) and notifies the CRS to take appropriate actions of Technical Specification 3.2.4.
COMMENTS:
Critical Step Basis:
Accurate comparison to the COLR and notification of the CRS is required to comply with TS.
SAT UNSAT TERMINATION CUE: Quadrant AOT calculations and comparison to COLR limits complete.
RO - END OF TASK STEP 10:
(SRO Only)
Refer to TS 3.2.4, Quadrant Power Tilt, and determine required actions.
STANDARD:
Candidate determines that the following actions are required (Condition D):
- 1.
Reduce THERMAL POWER to < 60% of the ALLOWABLE THERMAL POWER within 2 hours2.314815e-5 days <br />5.555556e-4 hours <br />3.306878e-6 weeks <br />7.61e-7 months <br />.
- 2.
Reduce nuclear overpower trip setpoint to < 65.5% of the ALLOWABLE THERMAL POWER within 10 hours1.157407e-4 days <br />0.00278 hours <br />1.653439e-5 weeks <br />3.805e-6 months <br />.
COMMENTS:
Critical Step Basis:
TS required actions SAT UNSAT
ADMINISTRATIVE JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE 7/26/2011 Page 10 of 13 Admin EC1 (NRC 2011)
TERMINATION CUE: TS required actions determined.
SRO - END OF TASK TIME STOP
ADMINISTRATIVE JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE 5/25/2011 Page 11 of 13 Admin EC1 (NRC 2011)
ENCLOSURE 3 (Page 2 of 2)
TABLE 3 Date _____________
Current Out-Of-Core QPT Calculations Time Step 1
2 4
6 1
2 4
6 1
2 4
6 Quadrant
/ NI NI Pwr N
OCD AOT NI Pwr N
OCD AOT NI Pwr N
OCD AOT WX
/ NI-5 62
+0.10
-3.13
-3.03 YZ
/ NI-6 63
-1.57
-1.56
-3.13 XY
/ NI-7 63
+0.10
-1.56
-1.46 ZW
/ NI-8 68
+1.37
+6.25
+7.62 Tc 0.3 °F
°F
°F Reg Rod Index 245 %wd
%wd
%wd Performed by:
Initial Initial Initial Verified by:
Initial Initial Initial Where:
NI Pwr = Out-of-Core Nuclear Inst Power (%)
N = Normalization Factor (%)
OCD = Out-of-Core Detector Tilt (%)
AOT = Adjusted Out-of-Core Detector Tilt (%)
ADMINISTRATIVE JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE CANDIDATE CUE SHEET (TO BE RETURNED TO EXAMINER UPON COMPLETION OF TASK)
INITIAL CONDITIONS You are the Balance of Plant Operator.
The plant has been stable at this power level for the previous 3 hours3.472222e-5 days <br />8.333333e-4 hours <br />4.960317e-6 weeks <br />1.1415e-6 months <br />.
The Symmetrical Incore Detector System is inoperable.
Current NI values from the control console are:
NI-5 = 62%
NI-6 = 63%
NI-7 = 63%
NI-8 = 68%
Tc = 0.3° F Rod Index is 245%.
INITIATING CUES The Control Room Supervisor has directed you to calculate current out-of-core QPT using SP-303, Tilt Monitoring with an Unavailable Symmetric Incore System. Enter AOT (adjusted out-of-core tilt) values below and document additional actions, if any, you would perform.
SP-303, Enclosure 1, Table 1 is attached.
NI-5 AOT =
NI-6 AOT =
NI-7 AOT =
NI-8 AOT =
SROs only: After calculating AOT, determine if any TS actions are required.
Document your answer below.
ADMINISTRATIVE JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE ENCLOSURE 1 (Page 3 of 3)
Calculation of Normalization Constants TABLE 1 Normalization Constants Step 2 Step 2 Step 4 Step 6 (IT - OCD)
Quadrant/NI NI Power Incore Tilt (IT)
Out-of-Core Tilt (OCD)
Normalization Constant (N)
WX / NI-5 55
+0.10 0
+0.10 YZ / NI-6 56
+0.25
+1.82
-1.57 XY / NI-7 55
+0.10 0
+0.10 ZW / NI-8 54
-0.45
-1.82
+1.37 Step 7:
Normalization calculations from:
Control Console
/
Yesterday Source
/ Date Tc at the time of the source data: 0
°F Regulating Rod index at the time of the source data:
240
%wd :
Performed by:
AK
/
Yesterday
/
0100 Initial
/
Date
/
Time Verified by:
GQ
/
Yesterday
/
0130 Initial /
Date
/
Time
CRYSTAL RIVER UNIT 3 JPM COVER SHEET ADMIN JPM #RC1 NRC 2011 RO / SRO DETERMINE STAY TIMES USING SURVEY MAPS PREPARED/REVIEWED BY:
Jim Gregitis Date: 05/24/11 VALIDATED BY:
B. Wooten / B. Webster / R. Virgin Date: 07/07/11 APPROVAL BY:
Mark VanSicklen Date: 07/27/11 (Nuclear Training Supervisor)
CONCURRED BY:
Mike Kelly Date: 07/28/11 (Operations Representative)
Validation is not required for minor enhancements, procedure revisions that do not affect the JPM or individual step changes that do not affect the flow of the JPM.
Operations concurrence is required for new JPMs and changes that affect the flow, critical steps or time critical steps of the JPM. Operations concurrence is not required for changes that are required due to a procedure revision.
ADMINISTRATIVE JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE 7/26/2011 Page 2 of 7 Admin RC1 (NRC 2011)
JPM #: Admin RC1 - NRC 2011 Task: Determine stay times using survey maps.
Alternate Path:
YES NO PRA Top Critical Action:
YES NO Safety Function: NA K/A Rating/Importance:
G2.3.4 RO 3.2 SRO 3.7 Task Number:
1190102008 - RO Position:
SRO ONLY RO/SRO NLO/RO/SRO Task Standard: Determine stay times using survey maps.
Preferred Evaluation Location:
Preferred Evaluation Method:
SIM PLANT ADMIN PERFORM SIMULATE
References:
DOS-NGGC-0004, Rev 12 Validation Time: 15 minutes Time Critical:
YES NO
=========================================================
Candidate: ______________________________
Time Start:
Printed Name Time Finish:
Performance Rating:
SAT UNSAT Performance Time:
Examiner: ___________________________________ _____________________________/_______
Printed Name Signature Date Comment: _________________________________________________________________________
ADMINISTRATIVE JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE 7/26/2011 Page 3 of 7 Admin RC1 (NRC 2011)
SIMULATOR OPERATOR SETUP INSTRUCTIONS
- 1.
None SIMULATOR OPERATOR INSTRUCTIONS
- 1.
None TOOLS/EQUIPMENT/PROCEDURES NEEDED
- 1.
Consumable copies of DOS-NGGC-0004, Rev 12
- 2.
Calculators
ADMINISTRATIVE JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE 7/26/2011 Page 4 of 7 Admin RC1 (NRC 2011)
READ TO THE OPERATOR INITIAL CONDITIONS You are the Primary Plant Operator.
The plant is at full power.
INITIATING CUES Using the supplied survey map, determine the individual stay times for yourself and another PPO without exceeding the annual administrative dose limit. (Do not consider dose received during transit).
You have an accumulated annual Whole Body dose of 1790 mR (Progress Energy). The other PPO has an accumulated annual Whole Body dose of 1800 mR (Progress Energy). No additional dose has been received at any other site.
A hot spot has developed on MUP-1C (C Make-up Pump). You will be flushing the pump through a drain valve on the north side of MUP-1C.
Calculations should be based on Progress Energy Administrative Dose Limits. Do not consider ALARA Task requirements. No dose extensions have been approved by the Site Vice President.
ADMINISTRATIVE JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE 7/26/2011 Page 5 of 7 Admin RC1 (NRC 2011)
EXAMINERS NOTE: FOR STEPS DENOTED AS CRITICAL STEP, WHICH HAVE MULTIPLE ACTIONS, THE INDIVIDUAL REQUIRED ACTION WILL BE DENOTED CS. IF NO INDIVIDUAL ACTIONS ARE DENOTED AS SUCH THEN ALL ACTIONS WITHIN THE STEP ARE DEEMED CRITICAL.
TIME START STEP 1:
Candidate uses survey map to determine stay times.
STANDARD:
Candidate determines the stay time for him/her is 3.5 hours5.787037e-5 days <br />0.00139 hours <br />8.267196e-6 weeks <br />1.9025e-6 months <br /> and that the stay time for the other PPO is 3.33 hours3.819444e-4 days <br />0.00917 hours <br />5.456349e-5 weeks <br />1.25565e-5 months <br />.
This is based on working in an area with a 60 mR field and a dose limit of 2 Rem.
EXAMINER NOTE:
If requested, provide candidate a copy of DOS-NGGC-0004.
Calculations must be within + 0.2 hours2.314815e-5 days <br />5.555556e-4 hours <br />3.306878e-6 weeks <br />7.61e-7 months <br /> to pass the JPM.
COMMENTS:
Critical Step Basis:
Correct calculation required so dose limit will not be exeeeded.
SAT UNSAT TERMINATION CUE: Individual stay times calculated.
END OF TASK TIME STOP
ADMINISTRATIVE JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE CANDIDATE CUE SHEET (TO BE RETURNED TO EXAMINER UPON COMPLETION OF TASK)
INITIAL CONDITIONS You are the Primary Plant Operator.
The plant is at full power.
INITIATING CUES Using the supplied survey map, determine the individual stay times for yourself and another PPO without exceeding the annual administrative dose limit. (Do not consider dose received during transit).
You have an accumulated annual Whole Body dose of 1790 mR (Progress Energy). The other PPO has an accumulated annual Whole Body dose of 1800 mR (Progress Energy). No additional dose has been received at any other site.
A hot spot has developed on MUP-1C (C Make-up Pump). You will be flushing the pump through a drain valve on the north side of MUP-1C.
Calculations should be based on Progress Energy Administrative Dose Limits. Do not consider ALARA Task requirements. No dose extensions have been approved by the Site Vice President.
- 90
< 1
< 1
< 1 03-08-22 70 60 N
< 1 20 45 32 5
7 6
2
< 1
< 1
< 1
< 1 Make Up Valve Alley A
B C
CRYSTAL RIVER UNIT 3 JPM COVER SHEET ADMIN JPM #EP1 NRC 2011 SRO ONLY DETERMINE EMERGENCY ACTION LEVEL AND PROTECTIVE ACTION RECOMMENDATIONS Performed in Classroom PREPARED/REVIEWED BY:
Jim Gregitis Date: 05/24/11 VALIDATED BY:
B. Wooten / R. Virgin Date: 07/07/11 APPROVAL BY:
Mark VanSicklen Date: 07/27/11 (Nuclear Training Supervisor)
CONCURRED BY:
Mike Kelly Date: 07/28/11 (Operations Representative)
Validation is not required for minor enhancements, procedure revisions that do not affect the JPM or individual step changes that do not affect the flow of the JPM.
Operations concurrence is required for new JPMs and changes that affect the flow, critical steps or time critical steps of the JPM. Operations concurrence is not required for changes that are required due to a procedure revision.
ADMINISTRATIVE JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE 7/26/2011 Page 2 of 9 Admin EP1 (NRC 2011)
JPM #: Admin EP1 - NRC 2011 Task: Determine Emergency Actions Level and Protective Action Recommendations.
Alternate Path:
YES NO PRA Top Critical Action:
YES NO Safety Function: NA K/A Rating/Importance:
G2.4.41 RO 2.9 SRO 4.6 G2.4.44 RO 2.4 SRO 4.4 Task Number:
1150101001 - SRO Position:
SRO ONLY RO/SRO NLO/RO/SRO Task Standard: Determine Emergency Action Level and Protective Action Recommendations to protect the public.
Preferred Evaluation Location:
Preferred Evaluation Method:
SIM PLANT ADMIN PERFORM SIMULATE
References:
EM-202, Rev 94 EOP-03 Figure 2, Rev 16 EOP-07 Figure 1, Rev 16 Validation Time: 10 minutes Time Critical:
YES NO
=========================================================
Candidate: ______________________________
Time Start:
Printed Name Time Finish:
Performance Rating:
SAT UNSAT Performance Time:
Examiner: ___________________________________ _____________________________/_______
Printed Name Signature Date Comment: _________________________________________________________________________
ADMINISTRATIVE JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE 7/26/2011 Page 3 of 9 Admin EP1 (NRC 2011)
SIMULATOR OPERATOR SETUP INSTRUCTIONS
- 1.
None SIMULATOR OPERATOR INSTRUCTIONS
- 1.
None TOOLS/EQUIPMENT/PROCEDURES NEEDED
- 1.
Consumable copies of EM-202, Rev 94
- 2.
Consumable copies of EOP-03 Figure 2, Rev 16
- 3.
Consumable copies of EOP-07 Figure 1, Rev 16
ADMINISTRATIVE JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE 7/26/2011 Page 4 of 9 Admin EP1 (NRC 2011)
READ TO THE OPERATOR INITIAL CONDITIONS You are the Shift Manager.
See attached plant data sheet.
INITIATING CUES Determine the highest Emergency Action Level for the time line provided. Also determine the Protective Action Recommendations (PARs) required, if any. Document your answers below.
THIS JPM IS TIME CRITICAL
ADMINISTRATIVE JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE 7/26/2011 Page 5 of 9 Admin EP1 (NRC 2011)
EXAMINERS NOTE: FOR STEPS DENOTED AS CRITICAL STEP, WHICH HAVE MULTIPLE ACTIONS, THE INDIVIDUAL REQUIRED ACTION WILL BE DENOTED CS. IF NO INDIVIDUAL ACTIONS ARE DENOTED AS SUCH THEN ALL ACTIONS WITHIN THE STEP ARE DEEMED CRITICAL.
TIME START STEP 1:
Obtain a copy of the correct procedure.
STANDARD:
Candidate obtains a copy of EM-202.
EXAMINER NOTE:
Provide candidate with copies of EM-202 and EOP figures.
COMMENTS:
SAT UNSAT
ADMINISTRATIVE JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE 7/26/2011 Page 6 of 9 Admin EP1 (NRC 2011)
STEP 2:
Determine classification for the data provided.
STANDARD:
Candidate determines the classification using the Fission Product Barrier Matrix:
LOSS OF RCS
+4 (RM-G29 or 30 > 10 R/hr for 15 minutes or longer)
POTENTIAL LOSS OF CONTAINMENT (RB pressure > 30 psig with no Building Spray available)
+1.5 TOTAL
+5.5 SITE AREA EMERGENCY COMMENTS:
Critical Step Basis:
Protection of the public SAT UNSAT
ADMINISTRATIVE JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE 7/26/2011 Page 7 of 9 Admin EP1 (NRC 2011)
STEP 3:
Determine Protective Action Recommendations.
STANDARD:
The standard for this JPM is that NO Protective Actions Recommendations for the general public are required based on a Site Area Emergency.
EXAMINER NOTE:
Candidate may refer to Enclosure 3 of EM-202. Protective Action Recommendations are applicable to General Emergencies only.
Candidate may refer to Section 9.3 of EM-202, Emergency Coordinators Guide for Site Area Emergency, Step 9.3.4 and determine using Enclosure 2 that protective actions required for the Energy Complex are to perform assembly and accountability and instruct the fossil control rooms to report results to nuclear security.
COMMENTS:
SAT UNSAT TERMINATION CUE: Emergency Action Level determined and conclusion that NO Protective Action Recommendations for the general public are required.
END OF TASK TIME STOP
ADMINISTRATIVE JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE CANDIDATE CUE SHEET (TO BE RETURNED TO EXAMINER UPON COMPLETION OF TASK)
INITIAL CONDITIONS You are the Shift Manager.
See attached plant data sheet.
INITIATING CUES Determine the highest Emergency Action Level for the time line provided. Also determine the Protective Action Recommendations (PARs) required, if any. Document your answers below.
THIS JPM IS TIME CRITICAL
ADMINISTRATIVE JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE PLANT DATA SHEET At 1330 today, the plant was as 100% power. The plant experiences a transient and the following time line of indications occur:
TIME 1345 RCS PRESSURE 110 PSIG PRESSURIZER LEVEL 0"
INCORES 370° F RX BLDG SPRAY FLOW 0 GPM/TRAIN RX BLDG PRESSURE 48 PSIG RM - G29 & 30 15 R/HR TIME 1400 RCS PRESSURE 110 PSIG PRESSURIZER LEVEL 0"
INCORES 360° F RX BLDG SPRAY FLOW 0 GPM/TRAIN RX BLDG PRESSURE 47.3 PSIG RM - G29 & 30 18 R/HR The containment is intact and no release is in progress.
Based on the above information, identify the appropriate EAL and PARs, if required.
FOR THIS EXERCISE DO NOT USE ANY EC DISCRETION!