ML110260290
| ML110260290 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Monticello  |
| Issue date: | 12/17/2010 |
| From: | Mcneil D Operations Branch III |
| To: | Northern States Power Co, Xcel Energy |
| References | |
| Download: ML110260290 (2) | |
Text
ES-401 Record of Rejected K/As Form ES-401-4 Tier /
Group Randomly Selected K/A Reason for Rejection 1/1 RO 295005 AK2.03 Rejected AK2.03 because there are no direct relationships between main turbine trip and the recirculation system. The only possibility of a question would be to relate it to the feed system which resulted in a double jeopardy situation for the 202002 topic selected in Tier 2/Group 2. Randomly reselected AK2.07.
1/1 RO 295016 AA1.09 Rejected AA1.09 as this is not applicable to Monticello.
Randomly reselected AA1.01 1/1 RO 600000 AK3.01 Rejected AK3.01 as its importance rating is <2.5. Randomly reselected AK3.04.
1/1 RO 295023 2.4.47 Rejected 2.4.47 because there are no references that could be used by the RO in the control room for a Refueling Accident. Randomly reselected 2.4.31.
1/2 RO 500000 EK3.05 Rejected EK3.05 and the entire EK3 K/As for this topic because none of these actions are performed at MNGP in response to high containment hydrogen. In order to maintain K3 balance in Tier 1 Group 2 a new topic and new K3 K/A was selected. Randomly reselected 295010 AK3.01.
2/1 RO 203000 K3.02 Rejected K3.02 as LPCI injection has little if any effect on Torus water level. Any question written on this topic would be operationally invalid. Randomly reselected K3.04.
2/1 RO 209001 K6.10 Rejected K6.10 as its importance rating is <2.5. Randomly reselected K6.02 2/1 RO 215005 2.1.30 Rejected 2.1.30 as all controls for APRMs/LPRMs are located in the control room. Additionally, any questions written on the APRM back panels will overlap with a selected JPM being used for the exam. Randomly reselected 2.2.37.
2/2 RO 201001 K5.05 Rejected K5.05 as this is a Plant Specific K/A that doesnt directly apply to Monticello. Randomly reselected K5.03.
2/2 RO 215001 A4.05 Rejected A4.05 as its importance rating is <2.5. Randomly reselected and rejected A4.02 as its importance rating is
<2.5. Randomly reselected A4.03.
2/2 RO 259001 K1.20 Rejected K1.20 as this is not applicable to Monticello.
Randomly reselected and rejected K1.15 as this is not applicable to Monticello. Randomly reselected K1.13 which is also plant specific and not applicable to Monticello.
Randomly reselected K1.11.
2/2 RO 271000 K2.01 Rejected K2.01 as its importance rating is <2.5. Since this was the only K2 for this topic a new topic was randomly reselected to maintain K2 balance in this Tier/Group.
Randomly reselected 268000 Radwaste. Rejected the Radwaste topic because it didnt have any K2 K/As.
Randomly reselected 272000 Radiation Monitoring K2.05.
2/2 RO 226001 A4.04 Rejected A4.04 as the keep fill parameters cannot be operated or monitored in the control room. Randomly reselected A4.07.
3/1 RO 2.1.37 Rejected 2.1.37 as this is an SRO responsibility and the K/A is being used on the SRO portion of the exam. Randomly reselected 2.1.18.
3/2 RO 2.2.7 Rejected 2.2.7 as to write an operationally valid question on this topic would require an SRO ONLY question. Randomly reselected 2.2.42.
3/2 RO 2.2.21 Rejected 2.2.21 as an operationally valid written question with plausible distracters would make it an SRO Only question.
Randomly reselected 2.2.2.
3/3 RO 2.3.6 Rejected 2.3.6 as its importance rating is <2.5. Randomly reselected 2.3.4.
1/1 SRO 600000 AA2.10 Rejected AA2.10 due to the inability to create an operationally valid SRO ONLY question. Randomly reselected AA2.15.
2/2 SRO 256000 A2.10 Topic 256000 Reactor Condensate rejected as no operationally valid SRO question could be developed from this topic. Randomly reselected new topic 201033 Control Rod and Drive Mechanism and maintained the A2.10 K/A.
3/1 SRO 2.1.23 Rejected 2.1.23 as performing system specific procedures is only an RO task and this K/A lends itself better to a JPM.
Randomly reselected 2.1.19.
3/1 SRO 2.1.27 Rejected 2.1.27 due to the inability to create an operationally valid SRO ONLY question. Randomly reselected 2.1.37.