ML101050482
| ML101050482 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Watts Bar  |
| Issue date: | 04/15/2010 |
| From: | Curran D Harmon, Curran, Harmon, Curran, Spielberg & Eisenberg, LLP, Southern Alliance for Clean Energy |
| To: | Bessette P, Chandler C, Andrea Jones, Roth D, Sutton K, Vigluicci E, Williamson E Morgan, Morgan, Lewis & Bockius, LLP, NRC/OGC, Tennessee Valley Authority |
| SECY RAS | |
| References | |
| 50-391-OL, ASLBP 09-893-01-OL-BD01, RAS 17722 | |
| Download: ML101050482 (10) | |
Text
April 15, 2010 Paul M. Bessette, Esq. (pbessette@morganlewis.com)
Kathryn M. Sutton, Esq. (ksutton@morganlewis.com)
Morgan, Lewis & Bockius, L.L.P.
1111 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20004 David Roth, Esq. (david.roth@nrc.gov)
Edward Williamson, Esq. (elw2@nrc.gov)
Andrea Jones, Esq. (andrea.jones@nrc.gov)
Office of the General Counsel Mail Stop O-15D21 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555-0001 Edward J. Vigluicci, Esq. (ejvigluicci@tva.gov)
Christopher C. Chandler, Esq. (ccchandler0@tva.gov)
Office of the General Counsel Tennessee Valley Authority 400 West Summit Hill Drive, WT 6A-K Knoxville, TN 37902
Subject:
Third Supplemental Mandatory Disclosures Pursuant to 10 C.F.R. § 2.336
Dear Counsel:
Pursuant to 10 C.F.R. § 2.336 and the Agreement of the Parties Regarding Mandatory Discovery Disclosures that was sent to the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board on December 1, 2009, Southern Alliance for Clean Energy (SACE) hereby makes the following third supplement to its initial disclosures of January 15, 2010. These disclosures are based on information that is currently known to SACE, and will be updated as additional information becomes available, according to the schedule set forth in our Agreement.
- 1.
Witnesses SACE has no new information to add regarding its witnesses.
II.
Documents In accordance with 10 C.F.R. § 2.336(a)(2), documents, data compilations, and tangible things (e.g., books, publications, and treatises) in the possession, custody, or control of SACE that are relevant to SACEs two admitted contentions are identified in Attachment 1.
Washington, D.C. 20004 April 15, 2010 Page 2 of 2 Pursuant to our Agreement, however, Attachment 1 does not list documents already served on the parties to this proceeding, relevant news clippings, and drafts of documents. Attachment 1 also excludes documents for which SACE claims privileged status, for which we have agreed not to prepare a privilege log.
Please note that the production of documents to date should not be construed as a waiver of any privilege for documents that may be discovered or generated in the future.
Please identify any documents for which you request copies. In accordance with our Agreement, we will endeavor to produce scanned copies in pdf format; or if that is not possible, we will provide you with hard copies.
Finally, attached please find my declaration regarding the completeness of SACEs document production. My declaration covers all document production to date.
Please call me if you have any questions about these disclosures.
Sincerely, (Electronicaly signed by)
Diane Curran Encl.: As stated
ATTACHMENT 1: Watts Bar Unit 2 Operating License Proceeding Southern Alliance for Clean Energys Third Supplement to Initial Disclosure Log -- Page 1
- Harmon Curran Spielberg & Eisenberg, L.L.P. (HSCE) is located at 1726 M St. NW, Suite 600, Washington, DC 20036 NO.
DATE LOCATION*
CATEGORY CREATOR SUBJECT/DECRIPTION CONT. #
1 Undated HCSE Notes Unknown Outfall info from TN0026450 7
2 Undated HCSE Report TVA TN0020168 Enclosures 1 thru 4 for WBN Plant SCCW System 7
3 Undated HCSE Regulations EPA EPA regulation re cooling water intake structures 7
4 Undated HCSE Map Unknown Location of fish and benthic macroinvertebrate sampling near Watts Bar 7
5 11/09/72 HCSE EIS TVA Final EIS for Watts Bar, Pt. 1 7
6 11/09/72 HCSE EIS TVA Final EIS for Watts Bar, Pt. 2 7
7 11/09/72 HCSE EIS TVA Final EIS for Watts Bar 7
8 1975 HCSE Article
- Pflieger, W.L.
The fishes of Missouri 7
9 05/01/77 HCSE Guidance EPA EPA Draft Guidance for Section 316(b) 7 10 12/29/78 HCSE EIS NRC Final EIS for Watts Bar 7
11 1982 HCSE Article Bain, M.B.,
et. al Habitat suitability index models: coastal stocks of striped bass 7
12 1982 HCSE Article Stuber, R.J.,
et. al Habitat suitability index models: Largemouth bass 7
13 1983 HCSE Article Fay, C.W.,
et. al Species profiles: Life histories and environmental requirements of coastal fishes and invertebrates (Mid-Atlantic) - striped bass 7
14 1988 HCSE Article
- Starnes, L.B., et. al The mussels (Mollusca: Bivalvia: Unionidae) of Tennessee 7
15 02/26/91 HCSE Agreement TVA Interagency Agreement 1
16 03/01/91 HCSE Report TVA TN0020168 Mussel Bed Die-Off 7
17 1993 HCSE Article
- Etnier, D.A., et. al The Fishes of Tennessee 7
18 1994 HCSE Article
19 08/05/94 HCSE EIS TVA RAI Response re Final EIS for Watts Bar 7
20 11/01/94 HCSE EIS NRC Supp 1 to Draft EIS for Watts Bar 7
21 1995 HCSE Article Angermeir, P.L.
Ecological attributes of extinction-prone species: Loss of freshwater fishes of Virginia 7
22 04/01/95 HCSE EIS NRC Final EIS for Watts Bar 7
ATTACHMENT 1: Watts Bar Unit 2 Operating License Proceeding Southern Alliance for Clean Energys Third Supplement to Initial Disclosure Log -- Page 2
- Harmon Curran Spielberg & Eisenberg, L.L.P. (HSCE) is located at 1726 M St. NW, Suite 600, Washington, DC 20036 23 04/01/95 HCSE EIS NRC Supp 1 to Final EIS for Watts Bar, Pt. 1 7
24 04/01/95 HCSE EIS NRC Supp 1 to Final EIS for Watts Bar, Pt. 2 7
25 12/01/95 HCSE Report TVA Effects of Thermal Effluent From Sequoyah Nuclear Plant on Fish Populations in Chickamauga 7
26 04/01/96 HCSE Report TVA Monthly Operating Report to NRC, April 1996 7
27 06/17/96 HCSE Report TVA Monthly Operating Report to NRC, May 1996 7
28 1997 HCSE Article
- Vaughan, C.
Regional patterns of mussel species distributions in North American rivers 7
29 1998 HCSE Article
- Master, L.L., et. al Rivers of life: Critical watersheds for protecting freshwater biodiversity 7
30 1998 HCSE Article
- Parmalee, P.W., et. al The freshwater mussels of Tennessee 7
31 02/03/98 HCSE Report TVA TN0020168 Outfall 113 Mix Zone 7
32 06/01/98 HCSE Report TVA Aquatic Environmental Conditions in the Vicinity of Watts Bar Nuclear Plant During Two Years of Operation, 1996-1997 7
33 06/18/98 HCSE Memorandum S. Wang TN0020168 Cormix 3 Runs 7
34 06/19/98 HCSE Letter TVA TN0020168 SCCW Revised DEA 7
35 07/24/98 HCSE Agenda TDEC TN0021068 Interagency Meeting 1998 7
36 07/29/98 HCSE Report TDEC TN0020168 Cormix Validation Study 7
37 07/30/98 HCSE Report TVA TN0020168 Instream Temp Monitoring 7
38 08/01/98 HCSE EA NRC NRC EA for Watts Bar SCCW Project 7
39 08/04/98 HCSE Memorandum TDEC TN0020168 Revised Antideg Review of TN River 7
40 08/06/98 HCSE Report TDEC TN0020168 Conditional Site Approval Rationale 7
41 08/20/98 HCSE Letter TDEC TN0020168 Conditional Site Approval for SCCW 7
42 08/20/98 HCSE Letter TDEC TN0020168 Response to Site Approval Request from TVA 7
43 08/27/98 HCSE Memorandum TDEC TN0020168 Habitat Along TN River R.M. 529 7
44 10/28/98 HCSE Sampling Analysis TVA TN0020168 Addendum to 1998 Application for NPDES permit renewal 7
45 04/12/99 HCSE Report TVA TN0020168 SCCW Project 98-1092 Hydrostatic Test Water 7
46 04/15/99 HCSE RAI
Response
TDEC TN0020168 Response to SCCW Mussel Habitat 7
ATTACHMENT 1: Watts Bar Unit 2 Operating License Proceeding Southern Alliance for Clean Energys Third Supplement to Initial Disclosure Log -- Page 3
- Harmon Curran Spielberg & Eisenberg, L.L.P. (HSCE) is located at 1726 M St. NW, Suite 600, Washington, DC 20036 47 04/15/99 HCSE Table Unknown TN0020168 SCCW Revised Sketch Descriptions 7
48 05/17/99 HCSE Memorandum TDEC TN0020168 Draft Permit 1999 Review 7
49 10/01/99 HCSE ESRP NRC NUREG-1555, ESRP for Nuclear Power Plants 7
50 2000 HCSE Article
- Hampson, P.S., et. al Water Quality in the Upper Tennessee River Basin, Tennessee, North Carolina, Virginia, and Georgia 1994-98 7
51 01/18/00 HCSE Report TVA TN0020168 SCCW Mussel Habitat Enhancement 7
52 02/24/00 HCSE Letter TDEC TN0020168 Mussel Habitat Expansion Proposal Extension 7
53 04/14/00 HCSE RAI
Response
TVA TN0020168 Response to Mussel Habitat Enhancement Proposal 7
54 01/01/01 HCSE Report TVA SCCW Fish Monitoring at Watts Bar 7
55 09/18/01 HCSE Report TVA TN0020168 Hydrothermal Data for Outfall 113 7
56 03/08/02 HCSE Report TVA TN0020168 Mussel Habitat 7
57 12/18/02 HCSE Rule EPA Phase I regulations re cooling water intake structures 7
58 03/31/03 HCSE Notes TDEC TN0020168 Tritium in Onsite Monitoring Wells 7
59 05/20/03 HCSE Diagram TVA TN0020168 Enhancement to Flow Diagrams 7
60 04/07/04 HCSE Request TVA Request to NRC for increased raw water temperature 7
61 05/01/04 HCSE EIS TVA ROD re Reservoir Operations Study 7
62 06/04/04 HCSE Presentation TVA TN0020168 Hydrothermal Compliance Slides 7
63 07/09/04 HCSE Rule EPA Phase II regulations re cooling water intake structures 7
64 09/02/04 HCSE Report TVA TN0020168 Thermal Compliance Proposal 7
65 09/21/04 HCSE Report TVA TN0020168 Proposed Mods to Water Temps at Outfall 113 7
66 11/05/04 HCSE Permit TDEC NPDES Permit for Watts Bar 1, 7 67 2005 HCSE Article
- Marcy, B.C., et. al Fishes of the Middle Savannah River Basin 7
68 02/26/05 HCSE Report TVA TN0020168 SCCW Fish Monitoring Program Studies 7
69 03/22/05 HCSE Letter TVA WBN Unit 1 - Tritium Production Program - Unit 1 Cycle 6 Operating Experience 7
70 11/18/05 HCSE Report TVA TN0020168 Compliance Survey Outfall 113 Winter 2005 7
71 2006 HCSE Article
- Simon, T.P., et. al Reproductive biology and early life history of fishes in the Ohio River drainage 7
72 05/08/06 HCSE Request TVA Request to NRC for revision of ultimate heat sink temperature 7
73 02/06/07 HCSE Report TVA TN0020168 Compliance Survey Outfall 113 Summer and 7
ATTACHMENT 1: Watts Bar Unit 2 Operating License Proceeding Southern Alliance for Clean Energys Third Supplement to Initial Disclosure Log -- Page 4
- Harmon Curran Spielberg & Eisenberg, L.L.P. (HSCE) is located at 1726 M St. NW, Suite 600, Washington, DC 20036 Winter 2006 74 03/01/07 HCSE Notes TVA TN0020168 Blowdown Notes 7
75 12/20/07 HCSE Report TVA Impingement Monitoring at Watts Bar 2005-07 7
76 02/15/08 HCSE EIS TVA Final Supp EIS for Watts Bar 2 7
77 06/01/08 HCSE Regulations TDEC Tennessee Water Quality Criteria 1, 7 78 06/22/08 HCSE Report TVA TN0020168 Compliance Survey Outfall 113 Summer 2007 7
79 06/22/08 HCSE Report TVA TN0020168 Compliance Survey Outfall 113 Winter 2007 7
80 07/02/08 HCSE RAI
Response
TVA RAI Response re Final Supp EIS for Watts Bar 2 7
81 01/01/09 HCSE Notice TDEC Proposed changes to TN water quality criteria 1, 7 82 04/01/09 HCSE Permit TVA Application for Watts Bar NPDES permit 1, 7 83 06/12/09 HCSE Email E. Vigliuici (TVA)
Watts Bar Hearing Notice 1, 7 84 06/15/09 HCSE Email D. Curran (HCSE)
Watts Bar 2 Hearing Notice 1, 7 85 06/30/09 HCSE Letter EPA Letter to TDEC re NPDES permit application and thermal variance 1, 7 86 08/31/09 HCSE Permit TDEC Draft NPDES Permit for Watts Bar 1, 7 87 09/01/09 HCSE Report TVA Watts Bar RFAI Analysis 1993-2008 7
88 09/08/09 HCSE Email R. Jacobs (HCSE)
Request for Application 1, 7 89 09/08/09 HCSE Email R. Jacobs (HCSE)
Request for Application 1, 7 90 09/08/09 HCSE Email R. Jacobs (HCSE)
Request for Application 1, 7 91 09/17/09 HCSE Email M. Fraser (HCSE)
Watts Bar 316(b) Monitoring Program Submittal 7
92 09/17/09 HCSE Email S. Fathi (TDEC)
Watts Bar 316(b) Monitoring Program Submittal 7
93 09/17/09 HCSE Email S. Fathi (TDEC)
Watts Bar 316(b) Monitoring Program Submittal 7
ATTACHMENT 1: Watts Bar Unit 2 Operating License Proceeding Southern Alliance for Clean Energys Third Supplement to Initial Disclosure Log -- Page 5
- Harmon Curran Spielberg & Eisenberg, L.L.P. (HSCE) is located at 1726 M St. NW, Suite 600, Washington, DC 20036 94 09/18/09 HCSE Email S. Fathi (TDEC)
Watts Bar 7
95 09/22/09 HCSE Email S. Fathi (TDEC)
TVA-Watts Bar 7
96 09/24/09 HCSE Email S. Fathi (TDEC)
Clarification 7
97 09/24/09 HCSE Email S. Fathi (TDEC)
Advance copy of Watts Bar Comment letter 7
98 10/01/09 HCSE Report GAO Report on benefits of improving federal water use data 7
99 01/01/09 HCSE Email B. Paddock (S. Club)
Schedule for informal meeting and public hearing on Watt Bar Nuclear Plant draft NPDES 100 10/02/09 HCSE Email V. Janjic (TDEC)
Schedule for informal meeting and public hearing on WattBarNuclear plant draft NPDES 1, 7 101 10/06/09 HCSE Email V. Janjic (TDEC)
Schedule for informal meeting and public hearing on WattBarNuclear plant draft NPDES 1, 7 102 10/29/09 HCSE Email B. Paddock (S. Club)
TVA reports on Watts Bar & tritium 7
103 10/29/09 HCSE Email B. Paddock (S. Club)
Watts Bar draft NPDES - thermal 7
104 10/29/09 HCSE Email B. Paddock (S. Club)
Watts Bar draft NPDES 7
105 10/30/09 HCSE Email B. Paddock (S. Club)
Watts Bar file review 7
106 11/30/09 HCSE RAI NRC RAI re Watts Bar 2 SAMA analysis report 7
107 12/03/09 HCSE RAI NRC RAI re Environmental Review 7
108 12/07/09 HCSE Email B. Paddock (S. Club)
Watts Bar NPDES Public Hearing 1, 7 109 12/07/09 HCSE Email B. Paddock (S. Club)
Watts Bar NPDES Comment Deadline 1, 7 110 12/07/09 HCSE Email V. Janjic (TDEC)
Watts Bar NPDES Comment Deadline 1,7
ATTACHMENT 1: Watts Bar Unit 2 Operating License Proceeding Southern Alliance for Clean Energys Third Supplement to Initial Disclosure Log -- Page 6
- Harmon Curran Spielberg & Eisenberg, L.L.P. (HSCE) is located at 1726 M St. NW, Suite 600, Washington, DC 20036 111 12/17/09 HCSE Email V. Janjic (TDEC)
Watts Bar NPDES public hearing 7
112 12/21/09 HCSE Comments A. Harris (WTP)
Comments on NPDES permit renewal for Watts Bar Unit 1 1, 7 113 12/22/09 HCSE Email B.Paddock (S. Club)
WB2 RAI Environmental Rev.
1,7 114 12/23/09 HCSE RAI
Response
TVA RAI Response re Environmental Review 7
115 01/04/10 HCSE Curriculum Vitae S. Young (expert)
C.V. of Shawn P. Young, Ph.D.
1, 7 116 01/04/10 HCSE Email V. Janjic (TDEC)
Watts Bar NPDES 1,7 117 01/11/10 HCSE Comments SACE, et.
al Comments regarding draft NPDES permit for Watts Bar Unit 1 1, 7 118 01/11/10 HCSE Email V. Janjic (TDEC)
Comments on Draft NPDES Permit 7
119 01/11/10 HCSE Email A. Harris (WTP)
Amendment to comments submitted on 12/21-09 1,7 120 01/12/10 HCSE Email D. Curran Comments on Draft NPDES Permit 1,7 121 04/02/10 HCSE Letter William Adriance Letter to Dara F. Gray (Entergy Nuclear Operations, Inc.) re:
Notice of Denial of CWA § 401 Water Quality Certificate 7
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD
)
In the Matter of
)
)
Tennessee Valley Authority
)
Docket No. 50-391
)
(Watts Bar Unit 2)
)
____________________________________)
CERTIFICATION OF COUNSEL CONCERNING MANDATORY DISLOSURE REQUIREMENTS OF 10 C.F.R. § 2.336(a)
Under penalty of perjury, I, Diane Curran, declare as follows:
I am counsel to Southern Alliance for Clean Energy (SACE) in this proceeding.
I am responsible for assembling and producing discovery documents in SACEs possession, as required by 10 C.F.R. § 2.336(a). Pursuant to 10 C.F.R. § 2.336(c), I certify that all relevant documents required by 10 C.F.R. § 2.336(a) have been disclosed, and that the disclosures are accurate and complete as of this date.
(Electronically signed by)__________
Diane Curran April 15, 2010
1 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD
)
In the Matter of
)
)
Tennessee Valley Authority
)
Docket No. 50-391
)
(Watts Bar Unit 2)
)
____________________________________)
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I certify that on April 15, 2010, I posted on the NRCs Electronic Information Exchange System copies of the foregoing Letter from Diane Curran to Counsel Regarding Third Supplemental Mandatory Disclosures. It is my understanding that as a result, the following parties were served:
Lawrence G. McDade, Chair Paul B. Abramson Gary S. Arnold Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Mail Stop T-3F23 Lgm1@nrc.gov, pba@nrc.gov, wxb3@nrc.gov Kathryn M. Sutton, Esq.
Paul M. Bessette, Esq.
Morgan, Lewis & Bockius, L.L.P.
1111 Pennsylvania Avenue N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20004 ksutton@morganlewis.com pbessette@morganlewis.com NRC Office of the Secretary Rulemakings and Adjudications Staff U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Hearing.docket@nrc.gov NRC Office of Appellate Commission Adjudication U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 ocaamail@nrc.gov David E. Roth, Esq.
Edward Williamson, Esq.
Andrea Jones, Esq.
Jeremy M. Suttenberg, Esq.
Office of General Counsel U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 David.roth@nrc.gov, andrea.jones@nrc.gov, Jeremy.suttenberg@nrc.gov, elw2@nrc.gov Edward J. Vigluicci, Esq.
Christopher C. Chandler, Esq.
Office of the General Counsel Tennessee Valley Authority 400 West Summit Hill Drive, WT 6A-K Knoxville, TN 37902 ejvigluicci@tva.gov, ccchandler0@tva.gov (signed electronically by)
Diane Curran